Israel Insider
Israel Insider with Ashley Perry
Watch on YouTube
Description
President Trump's continued pressure on Prime Minister Netanyahu to continue implementation of the hostage deal could cost Netanyahu his government. Yet Trump is also talking about depopulating Gaza and releasing previously suspended munitions to Israel. Where may all this be heading? What are the implications for Israel’s coalition and for Netanyahu’s political future?
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 20, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:08 hello good afternoon and welcome to the Middle East forum's weekly podcast series Israel Insider my name is anaf Kalam and I will be moderating today's discussion we are pleased to be joined by Ashley Perry who is an adviser to the Middle East forum's Israel office joining us each week to give us a brief overview of the top events currently going on in Israel Mr Perry will speak for 15 minutes followed by 15 minutes of Q&A from the audience if you'd like to ask a question you can do so by using the Q&A box located at the bottom of your screen to type your question and with that I will turn the discussion over to Mr Ashley Perry thank you very much AK and good evening from Israel um really there's only one place to start tonight and that is with the uh invitation by newly inaugurated uh president Donald Trump to Israel's prime minister Benjamin netan first of all it's a historic invitation because it is the first time ever that
1:14 the first foreign dignitary to visit the White House at the beginning of a presidential term will be an Israeli Prime Minister usually uh those who follow American diplomacy know that it's that position is usually reserved for one of the more traditional us allies whether it's the UK whether it's Canada sometimes Mexico perhaps Japan I think in the past uh maybe some other Western European countries but um to have Israel as you know represented as the first foreign leader is really a very symbolic and important gesture if we can go back to the beginning of the Bison Administration there were many domestically in Israel and internationally who were counting the days until netan even received uh you know received a a phone call um or had some sort of time with President Biden I think it was something like 28 days and it was months and months and months
2:16 something like eight or nine months until there was actually a face to-face meeting and that was on the side of the UN it wasn't uh a traditional White House sitdown um and if we look at what that represented symbolically it showed allies and adversaries alike that there was Daylight between Israel and the US clearly President Biden was unhappy about some of the things prime minister netan was doing judicial reform Etc um but it really sent a very strong message so if that sent a strong message then this would also send a very strong message that there is no daylight between the US and Israel uh us and Israel relationship is really at the uh front end of the priorities of this um administration's uh foreign policy uh decision making um and it's a real show of support for Israel as it winds down a very long uh bloody
3:20 expensive uh you know emotional roller coaster of 15 months um and uh we'll have to wait and see what is going to be on the agenda and what exactly is expected of netan it's clear that the hostage deal will be on the agenda Iran uh what sort of tact to take diplomacy first military second are military options on the table is this an opportunity with the US help uh not help stand aside Etc Saudi normalization is something that many people have been talking about um you know we we we haven't heard for a while the Saudi demand that a a a strong path towards a Palestinian State um be uh you know sort of in action before any sort of normalization but we'll have to wait and domestically uh Neto is in a bit of a bind and there's one commentator said this week and it's basically to a certain extent true BB in the next few weeks um especially towards the end of
4:24 the phase one of this hostage deal we have to make a simple choice not so simple but really let's break it down it's between smotrich and the future of his government and Donald Trump what I mean by that is that it's clear that this uh Trump Administration from Donald Trump himself down witkoff the Middle East Envoy and others they want this hostage deal uh done to the end All Phases um all the hostages out an end of the war at least for now um humanitarian Aid etc etc on the other hand Talos smri has said that that um he will remain in the government for phase one because he has been promised uh by Netanyahu that there will be a return to fighting after phase one and an accomplishment of all the main goals set out at the beginning of the war and as we know those goals include not just the return of all hostages but uh a victory for Israel the end of hamas's uh military and governing Rule
5:28 and the ability of Gaza to uh threaten Israel uh again what we've seen over the last few days is that Hamas are very much still there they're still the governing power power uh to what extent they are able to re-equip uh rearm uh reman uh their forces is subject to debate clearly they're not where they were uh on October 7th of of last year but it's clear also that Hamas are still running things uh in Gaza uh and especially with the return of civilians to the north of Gaza um there is more of a focus on what was not achieved alongside what is being achieved and that's chiefly from the Israeli side at least uh the return uh of hostages we're going to see another uh three hostages uh released tomorrow and another three Saturday um the question of what would happen if they move from Phase 1 to phase two and let's not forget over the
6:31 next few days there has to be the beginning of discussions on what phase two will look like and how they'll move from phase one to phase two in fact those discussions are already started taking place in Cairo Qatar and elsewhere as I said Steve witkoff is very much in the region who um Midwife the first uh deal and is very intent on making sure that this goes further at the behest of Donald Trump if smich does it leaves netan as a minority government now he has been offered a safety net by many members of the opposition whether it's y leid or Benny Gant but that is only for the hostage deal um as I've said many times a very key date is the end of March because the end of March this government has to pass a budget uh if it does not pass a budget by the last day of March uh we automatically go to elections regardless of anything else so if smartr does leave the government there is not a majority to pass a budget and let's not forget that bmrc is the
7:35 Finance Minister in charge of working on the budget and he is working on the budget and tonight he said don't worry the budget will get passed I'm even going to be working on the budget for 2026 this government is not going to fall um which is a little bit different from the language uh he has used uh recently um and another issue let's not forget that while smartr is a major threat to the existence of this government there is another threat on the horizon and it's very much not even on the horizon it's very much uh in the here and now and is the longstanding issue of the ultra Orthodox enlistment um the ultra Orthodox parties are really uh running out of patience uh this is something that Net's dragged on um Julie edstein who's the head of the nesset defense and Foreign Affairs Comm which any law is supposed to go through and they're supposed to be the ones debating it it's not moving at the moment there's a lot of discussions there's very little
8:38 compromise on the ultra Orthodox side um at the moment defense minister Catz is looking at something very minimal uh juli Adin uh and many others are looking for something far more substantial the IDF came out again and said by this time next year or at least by 2026 by the end of 20 2026 if they are given the um demand from the political level they will be able to absorb as many Ultra Orthodox um people into the IDF as necessary in fact all of uh the 18y olds who are meet the criteria um of going to the IDF so really that's going to be major struggle we did hear arader of the Shas party very important usually quite quiet and likes to uh do some of his neg Neti ating behind the scenes came out and said if um we do not have a satisfactory end to this issue where um uh uh our our boys can remain in the
9:41 study hall in the Yeshiva Hall then we will fail this government there will not be a budget passed again just like smartr only a few hours later basically said this was not an ultimatum um I'm not making any demands etc etc usually what happens with is they are making the demands very much so and then they got a call from netan explains to them why this is not helpful probably the fact that it's on the eve of this historic trip to the White House probably calmed uh voices there let's not forget that arader is the more moderate and closer to Biby out of the ultra Orthodox and B smri of the far right uh uh National Religious parties uh is the more moderate of the two we already know that Ben G already left the government so but the fact remains is the ultra Orthodox issue has to be resolved to the satisfaction of the ultra Orthodox or they themselves will also leave the government and that is the end of the government simply so Netanyahu really has two major
10:44 challenges uh that he has to deal with in the next few weeks as well as dealing with u the security issues uh trying to negotiate uh the relationship with Donald Trump trying to get whatever uh he can possibly uh out of this relationship or both sides as well it's not forget it's not a one-way uh relationship one other interesting uh tidbit that came out this week was uh when President Trump talked about the um the possibility of some Palestinians in Gaza perhaps as much as one and a half million uh being relocated temporarily or otherwise Trump said it didn't bother him either way two other areas he originally talked about Egypt and Jordan how they'll both take that's clearly never going to happen especially with Jordan with a 70% Palestinian uh demographics they're not going to be able to take even 10 more thousand let alone hundreds of thousands so that was a non-starter and clearly they came out against it um but other countries that were floated were
11:45 Indonesia and Albania Albania's prime minister came out again and said he was not consulted on this and he would not be necessarily in favor um but as we saw with the Colombia episode uh Donald Trump likes to get his way and he has a lot of levers he has a lot of carrots and a lot of sticks which he can shake in uh various directions so perhaps this episode is not uh over yet but it would be quite a mammoth task to uh facilitate uh the removal not forced voluntary or otherwise I'm I'm assuming it would be voluntary of uh hundreds of thousands of Palestinians interestingly enough there has been quite a lot of media attention to those uh Palestinians who have moved uh back to their um uh towns and cities in the north of the Gaza Strip uh who said there's simply nothing left for them and they're quite happy to leave tomorrow um those voices are growing louder the question is whether the
12:47 International Community will assist uh in these efforts or not uh there's always been a special exception for the Palestinians um while in every other conflict in modern history the international communities helped those who want to seek to leave the theaters of War to do so except for the um the fact that uh that there's a lot of uh so so with this issue there are those who suspect in Israel that uh that this was a bone thrown by Trump at the beest of Neto towards smotrich because this is something that smrc has been very much in favor of voluntary uh immig immigration of the Palestinians I don't think it's uh that sophisticated I don't think it's um something that was organized I don't think it's something that's going to happen in the next couple of weeks um so I'm not quite sure as we've seen Donald Trump has a lot of ideas and likes to talk about them openly even if at first they they do seem uh
13:50 unlikely um going back I should say uh about the whole Ultra Orthodox enlistment issue there were those uh who said that the fact that the strongest proponents of the hostage deal in the government are in fact the ultra Orthodox parties and there were some on the right including smotrich or including certain members of Smart's party who suspect this is what they've openly said that um they are uh supporting the hostage deal as a quidd pro quow for the uh opposition support in some way for the uh IDF non- Enlistment laws they would prefer it again I think that's probably unlikely first of all because the opposition really can't do much it can't really enter into a uh a law at this point it's very difficult for them to do so government you know usually has the Reigns on those types of things uh and also if we look historically the ultra Orthodox has been a lot more doish on these issues they have uh put uh these types of issues first let's don't forget
14:53 Shas allowed the passing of Oslo Shas were a big supporter of the Shalit deal so I don't believe that that's particular reason but that's certainly something that's put out by uh balos smrc and the supporters and some of the other right-wing uh members of the government uh finally we are seeing uh more hostage releases and in Israel it's a very emotive issue everyone it's glued to their screens uh when they're getting released how they're getting released but also what we're starting to see is people understanding the cost of the deal we're seeing tremendous celebrations in East Jerusalem and other and around Judea and Samaria as these terrorists are being released we're understanding who they are we're understanding who they murdered um and we're also starting to hear from some of the Israeli residents in the Gaza envelope in stot and some of the kibot Sim they were invaded on October 7th who are starting to witness activity in
15:56 areas close to them that they simply have not seen for over years a year uh since October 7th or at least since Israel uh started its ground invasion they are starting to get worried don't forget some of these communities are me hundreds of meters apart and you know these communities were told that they will be safe they will be secure and they will not allow October the government will not allow October 7th to happen again but there is worry there is concern um and it starts to filter through um as I I suggested a few weeks ago uh Israel will take as many hostages as possible all the hostages uh but when that is over the um the reaction and the the the feedings of the people for the price will start coming to the for and that's when we'll see a bit of push back uh against um the hostage deal even though at this point in time it still receives majority
16:59 support so with that I'm happy to answer questions all right thank you Ashley for that update um I'll uh begin with something you kind of mentioned uh regarding the hostage agreement now president Trump has played a large role in negotiating the agreement perhaps out of a need as he said to end the conflict by the time he takes office but as you point out uh Israel has signaled that it is committed again to the stated goals from the beginning of the war so how strongly do you think the Trump Administration would support Israel's goal of a total victory over Hamas I think at this point very much the line that the Trump Administration is taking and it's very much enunciated by uh the envoy witkoff who's in Israel currently is that they want to see this hostage deal the hostage agreement be fulfilled all stages um what happens after that is anyone's guess I'm sure there if Hamas were able to rebuild were
18:02 able to threaten were even uh to attack Israel I'm sure there would be a strong hand uh or at least a you know a a large uh and determined uh uh uh support from the Trump Administration but I think at this point uh the Trump trump Administration officials are very much pushing not to return toward this point which will mean that the goals will not have been met you know what however you want to sugarcoat it Hamas will still remain in power now could there be a technocratic government as Hamas have suggested perhaps but that will be window dressing and also you need to bring in the PLO which Israel is against the PLO themselves are against Muhammad Abbas and the pa um and at the end of the day we've seen that Hamas would still remain the power behind the scene and the military power on the ground would still be Hamas so it's clear that if the deal is uh you know is is run to the end the goals will not have been met
19:05 Hamas will still be in power they will not be defeated they will still be governing they will still be uh the military power and at some point in the future they will be able to threaten Israel once again um so that's basically at the moment that's that's what the reality is that if we want the hostage deal we want all the hostages out it's clear that the other two goals as annunciated by netan in the government will not be met right thank you now Eric sov would like to ask it was announced that 8 of the 33 hostages are dead if most of the remaining hostages are dead how does that affect the deal well not most eight out of 33 uh which is a minority so Israel pretty much knew uh they were given uh numbers they weren't given names uh this week but they were given a list of how many were alive and how many were dead in the first phase I should say um and they pretty much uh aligned with what Israel already knew let's not forget Israel has very good intelligence I'm not going to
20:07 go into too many details exactly how it knows and what it knows but it knows very much the vast majority of those who are alive it even knows where many of them are it is even has had some level of contact uh with them um so none of none of this is a surprise and they went into this with their eyes open but the majority of the hostages all of them uh not just in Phase One those those to be releas in Phase One are still alive and and Israel knew almost let's just say 95% certainty uh who was alive and who's not all right thank you now uh step Miller would like to ask is there any new information in uh on where in Gaza the hostages are hidden uh um I I'm certainly not privy to that I do know that as I said uh in the answer before that Israel has a very good idea of where they are um some of
21:10 them has a very accurate idea but there was a decision made after the murder of I think was four hostages including hsh Gobo Poland that uh Israel would not try any more rescue operations because I think all or at least most hostages are kept uh deep underground at this point where a rescue operation is almost impossible um so that that's the reason why there hasn't been really any rescue operations recently and that's largely why the why that the fact remains almost certainly the only way to get the hostages out at this point is through a deal um some of them are held by Islamic Jihad uh one or two of the people who are going to be released over the weekend are how by is Jihad and some have even suggested even by more extreme groups associated with Isis um and that's why there was a certain amount of concern over some of those hostages who are going to be released over the next few days um but again I I should stress
22:14 that to the best of my knowledge there's very little hope of um any sort of rescue operations at this point and that's why the government amongst many other reasons decided to go for the hostage deal at this point right thank you now I'll go to a question from Adam Perry who asks is BB now calculating his easiest route to avoid imprisonment will the relationship with Trump play well enough to gain public sympathy rather than going against Trump while trying to save his government by siding with the far right well that's the typ rote that netan is really going to have to tread over the next few weeks you know I I say this quite frequently but I'm going to say it again you never get it you never bet against BB um this would confound I would say 95 to 99% of politicians around the world um but Biby has got himself out of I'm not sure more difficult situations but certainly
23:15 equally difficult situations where he really has to try and appease competing interests um how he does that we'll only know in the weeks ahead at the moment you can say he can't have everything he can't have this relationship with Trump H you know good relationship with Trump where he basically aderes to what the Trump Administration wants and uh his government uh at least not at this point there's no one who's going to bail him out from across the aisle unless there's something I don't know Idan r one Defector from the istid party could perhaps come across to the government U but that's one uh if smotrich goes I think the number is like 57 if I'm not much mist M Aken I'm not sure he'll be able to get the four necessary to pass a budget um but again it could be he'll make another deal with smart Rich to hang on a little bit longer pass the budget and then see what happens from there it's very possible all these things could happen it could be that he'll make some deal with Trump where
24:18 he'll give him something but not everything it's a difficult situation it's you know it's not an enviable situation uh for those who support uh netan this is certainly going to be a major challenge but you don't bet against BBY um as far as imprisonment his court case is going on interestingly uh he's made the case in the last week that he's not sufficiently regained his health after recent operation to be able to sit in court and give evidence uh for full day um but he is able to go off to the US for a 4-day visit um so that's something which a lot of people have talked about as far is prison or anything like that we're we're years away from from anything like that so that doesn't really play into the calculation no one's talking about plea bargain there's too much else going on uh the court case is going on but it will go on for a while and then either way there'll probably be an appeal and this that and the other so uh imprisonment isn't something in in the near or even medium-term Futures that's probably not a major calculation
25:21 although it's always there I'm sure for netan and his and his advisers uh but at the moment he simply has to get through the next few weeks to try and stop smotrich from leaving uh over the the the possibility of moving from phase one to phase du of the hostage deal he has to try and come up with some resolution to the ultra Orthodox enlistment law while passing the budget which is also there are elements which are unpopular within his own government if he doesn't then we go to elections so it's very challenging times ahead for Israel's minister and thank you now we have an announce attendee who would like to ask what are the general opinions on witkoff is he generally favored by Israelis well again the majority of Israelis at this point favor the hostage deal and witkoff is seen as instrumental in that he seen this especially by Israeli commentators and reporters is the one who sort of pushed netan into it he he flew over on a Saturday demanded
26:23 to meet netan on the Sabbath which some more right-wing uh religious elements have criticized but the fact remains that he was able to Midwife the uh the um the hostage deal um you know it's something that Trump basically told him go and get done and he simply did it so at the moment he's a popular figure I would say on the center and on the left and to a certain extent on the center right but the more rightwing you go the less popular he is um he has become a little bit of a a lightning rod for the far right right they obviously don't want to criticize president Trump so they're looking at witkoff they're looking at his background and some of the um path that he has and his relationships with Qatar and and criticizing that um so he has become a lightning rod for those who don't want to criticize Trump openly on on the right uh in Israel but I would say at the moment he's uh you know the the fact that he was the man who was able to get this deal done which is still a popular
27:26 deal makes him a popular f right thank you now uh we have another question from Eric sov who asks amid Israel Hamas hostage talks speculation grows over freeing Palestinian leader Marwan baruti praised as a unifier his potential releas faces backlash over his past deadly attacks do you think he will released um at the moment no um he Israel has demanded a veto over some of the releases there are some equally um uh you know bad Palestinian terrorists with a lot of Israeli uh blood on their hands but Maan bouti has a special place and I say that in a in a negative way uh for Israelis because of not just what he did but also who he is he is an immensely popular figure amongst the intransigent and rejectionist elements within Palestinian Society um Israel
28:29 knows if he would be released he would immediately become the most popular figure and that is obviously a very problematic thing for Israel an arch terrorist becomes the leader probably of the Palestinian Authority one way or another especially with an aging and ailing Mahmud abas and that's not something that Israel wants to countenance at this point so at the moment Israel's put a veto uh on his release um but uh I guess it is possible it could happen in the future but at the moment Israel has said a firm no uh to even discussing his release okay thank you now I'm afraid we are just about out of time here for this week's podcast I want to thank you again Ashley for taking the time to update us this week absolutely thank you of course and now for our viewers and listeners please be on the lookout in your email inboxes for the Middle East forum's upcoming podcasts for next week as always I hope you all have a wonderful day and I thank you again for joining us