Webinar or Talk
Pakistan’s Anti-India Cabal in USA Exposed | Clifford Smith on NewsX India, March 31, 2023
Watch on YouTube
Description
Clifford Smith, director of the Middle East Forum's Washington Project, joins NewsX in India for an exclusive interview in which he discusses Pakistan's anti-India cabal in the United States.
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 28, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:00 joining us on the broadcast is Cliff Smith the Washington director for the Middle East Forum through the course of the interview Cliff will shed light on two American organizations the hhrd and its mother organizations the Islamic circle of North America the hhrd and icna routinely spread misinformation about India and run strong anti-india campaigns in the United States the icna has even put up Holdings alleging genocide in Kashmir in the U.S we take a deep dive into these organizations with Cliff Cliff appreciate you speaking with us and thank you for taking out the time and taking our questions as well the first question you worked extensively on on helping and a helping hand for the relief and development organizations what have you found out about these helping hand for leaf and development is a jamati islami charity in America and it is very clear that they are Islamic charity and they have been involved with
1:05 various extremists and radicals for some time a number of years ago I believe it was 2017 they held a conference in Pakistan with multiple branches of lashkaritaba which they promoted which they apparently funded one of their fundraisers in the New England area of the United States in Connecticut was actually convicted of lying to the FBI as part of a tariff Finance investigation it's quite clear when you look at the court documents for example that his brother was involved in funding they also quite openly work with a group called the al-kidmat foundation a jamaat charity in Pakistan and they've funded hundreds of projects with them and for um el-kidma itself has openly worked with Hezbollah team has had speeches given by senior leaders and Terror groups has sent money even to terrorist groups in other parts of the world they're on their website they once mentioned that they sent money to Hamas in the Gaza Strip for example so this is just sort of a sampling of what they
2:07 have been up to it's not to say that the money went directly to terrorism per se always but sometimes it did and they clearly are sympathetic to the radicals that um support right and Cliff who are the people who are running the hhrd what has been found out about the connections and their linkages abroad so hhrd is just a sister organization of the Islamic circle of North America these long circle of North America is quite explicitly the jamati islami branch in America Uma Duty the founder of jamati islami visited their opening public event a year two before he died and they have been active in creating other branches and networks for a long time the current head of Islamic circle of North America Dr Ansari Mosin Ansari was formerly the president of Helping Hands relief and development he talks about as president of as long circle of North America the great things they can do with their hhrd
3:09 branch which he always paints as innocuous and and safe I have a different thought on that how did the hhrd receive its first grant of three crore Pakistani Rupees from usaid in 2021 was it ever a call for action against this uh so yes they did receive for the first time ever that I'm aware funds from um I think there's multiple issues going on here I think that some not all but some in the bite Administration are sympathetic or minimum blind to sort of islamist radicalization in South Asia also I think there's sort of a cultural problem at usaid that they simply if something is tear designated they think okay we can't do that anything else it's open season they don't look at it closely and I think sadly there was just a complete lack of due diligence Congress had raised this issue before they had been concerned about some of the facts about hhrd that I had mentioned and previously members of
4:12 Congress had brought this up I think hhrd was most likely trying to build a you know sort of counter the concerns about them by getting money for major usaid and I think usaid simply fell for their fell for their game luckily Congressman Michael McCall the chairman of the house Foreign Affairs committee recently did send a letter demanding answers about why this organization was chosen and uh for a grant for the first time especially after Congress complained about it I'm hopeful that that will start to change direction on things we'll have to wait and see Cliff uh what more can you tell us about the Islamic circle of North America who are the people that are running the icna uh well like I mentioned uh um Dr motion Ansari is currently the president of the long circle of North America he has been involved in jamati islami and Pakistan previously he's a Pakistani immigrant he's quite open about his affection for various jumati
5:16 islami projects abroad and one thing to know about them is much like their branches in Kashmir in in Pakistan in um they're open about their hostility to India and they have done a lot to what I would call extremist narratives about what's going on in India for example they've put up Billboards in America that said things like free cashmere from fascism oppression and genocide now I just came from Srinagar yesterday I spent several days there and you know there may be some criticisms that are valid of the Indian government and the way they've handled the issue but there's quite clearly no genocide going on by any reasonable definition of the term it's pure propaganda and they've been a big right Cliff also talk about what sort of anti-india propaganda is run by the icna and it's a subsidiaries in America I think there is a cottage industry that
6:19 wants to exaggerate any disagreement with the Indian government wants to spread just you know way over the top problems and sort of delegitimize anything the Indian government does and I think that has been increasingly the case of islamist groups in America not just ones of South Asian origin ones that are you know West Asian middle eastern origin for example the Council on Islamic American Islamic relations or care their executive director was in front of the Indian Embassy a couple years ago protesting along with all the South Asian groups this has become a big cause for them of pushing for a more islamist point of view in Kashmir in against India that's been the entire islamist network the islamist way of thinking that exists in the United States has been aimed at India in recent years and I think it's important to note it's fine to have disagreements with the Indian government and even discreance the Indian government over how they handle issues regarding Muslims many of them protested over the so-called hijab Row for example what it's worth I
7:23 thought they were right I thought the government handled that poorly I thought they should have been able to wear their hijabs if they so chose however that doesn't the same thing as saying there's genocide going on in cashmere it's not the same thing as wildly exaggerating any perceived you know um or real problem they have and just to delegitimize the country and also frankly to you know go after Hindus as a group as well and that's the kind of thing they do with increasing frequency right and you know since there are such wild allegations of genocide uh what did you see in Kashmir as a third party well there's no doubt that it's a difficult situation there's a lot of security forces all over the region um and there's no doubt that the changes the product on 370 are going to cause some amount of political turmoil and uncertainty and I think I got that from talking to the locals at the same time I saw a lot of investment from the government from foreign countries from companies within India that were
8:27 bringing people jobs I talked to a waiter at the hotel I was staying at that talked about how things are very difficult after 370 but later on things were much better and he saw the he liked the fact that there was more investment his friends were getting jobs I saw you know just um life going on more or less as normal for most people I visited the Muslim shrines in the region I attended one of the afternoon prayers there was no oppression going on there were some plea people praying and so it's a it's a difficult situation it's not a perfect situation there's no doubt that the increased security and changes in governance will create tensions but that at the end of the day you know these are kinds of things that can be dealt with and can be dealt with reasonably and rationally provided we're not giving in this kind of propaganda that is saying that you know there's dead bodies everywhere which is just not true right Cliff what is the role played by icno to Rally international support for Pakistan's so-called Kashmir cause I think that
9:33 um you know Islamic Circle North America and jamaat um organizations and others that are in their support and they they clearly are engaged in a campaign to go after India on you know more or less Pakistan's behalf I think that they believe in Islamic rule that's what makes them islamist organizations um I'm not against Muslims I'm not against Islam I am against people imposing their religious beliefs on others as part of the government and that is what at the end of the day shabbati islami wants that's what the Muslim Brotherhood wants and so it's no shock that their branches in the U.S go around doing that same thing so to the degree they can push for more Muslim rule for you know Muslim totalitarianism in Kashmir anywhere else they're going to continue to do it and that is what they're doing all right Cliff Pakistan is bankrupt and really under Financial stress is it a possibility that organizations such as the icna are fronts that are funding debted organizations in Pakistan could they be sending money back to Pakistan
10:37 it's hard to know for sure exactly how their funding works and I think it's there should be more looking into that what I can say for example however is that a Islamic spoke of North America hhrd fundraiser as I mentioned the New England area was convicted of lying to the FBI and it was quite clear if you look through the court documents that there was a terror Finance scheme going on where he was sending money to his brother who was quite openly Alaska supporter and this guy made roughly thirty five thousand forty thousand dollar American dollars a year and two hundred thousand dollars had passed through his bank account in a couple of years clearly this was not a you know there was something going on that was not quite right there and my guess is there's more of that going on I'm not saying these groups are Terror Finance fronts per se they may be but I have no proof of that what I am saying is there are many of people that are involved with them that are doing things that would certainly incur urge the ideology of terrorism and they
11:39 are far too willing to work with terrorists whenever they seem it in their best interest and some other members are quite overtly involved right and similar to the hhrd and icna the Middle East Forum has also exposed the Indian American Muslim Council what have you found out about the iamc uh just that their Founders have a long history of being involved with uh different radical organizations jamati islami Simi others and that they continue to push you know even just bigoted anti-hindu cartoons for example one of their one of their top people was shared a cartoon accusing Hindus of drinking cow urine for example I mean just you know just face disgusting smears and that they are involved in creating the same kind of narratives that you might expect from a group that is working in the same direction as jamati islami and other Islamic extremist organizations right and why is there a lack of action
12:43 against Sterling to organizations such as icna and of course the hhrd there's a cultural um thing inside American politics that certain parts for understandable reasons for good reasons you know want to be friendly and Champion Muslim Americans and be concerned of their interest and that's not bad what is bad is there are groups such as Islamic circle of North America that claim to represent you know all or most American Muslims or a very large contingency in reality they represent very few they represent basically you know their their handful of members that are you know usually jamati islami leaders in other countries or have you know connections to them and they claim to represent All American Muslims and I think there's a hesitancy among some in the American political system to challenge them because they believe that that is true but it's not and as far as like hhrd funding goes I think that usaid is very program very not concerned about anything that is not
13:48 on the terror designated list and there's a cultural understanding that you know we are rewarded if we move money to do good things without thinking too much about if those things really are good and without looking too deeply into the ideology of such groups I think that's a real problem that needs to change right I see any and the likes uh run extremely vociferous anti-india campaigns both online and offline how much these lies be counted according to you the true thing is we told um both about what these groups are saying and about what's really going on I think that um it is important to Simply give the real facts about what's going on on the ground you know don't um you don't need to sugarcoat it you don't need to say it at all um criticisms of the government or of Hindus are wrong but you do need to say that look we need to talk about reality here if you want to talk about how we're best going to handle cashmere in a post 370 time let's talk about that let's not talk about genocide because that's crazy
14:51 talk it's only done with the with the purpose of trying to help Pakistan and radical groups narratives it's not has anything to do with reality so talking about reality and you know engaging in those issues honestly is in the end of the day is your only real way of countering it right and do you think that the people funding icna and the hhrd also could be funding the sudden emergence of the kalistani movement in the United States and elsewhere of one of my colleagues have done very deep work on this issue and um he might be a better one to talk to on some level but there is no doubt that there has been some partnership between some of these um you know islamist radicals and some of the Palestinian movement and I expect that you know much as um you know guys that are working for the greater good or working for the greater bad tend to tend to coalesce together so I would not be shocked if that became even more of a thing that it already is in the future all right Cliff I appreciate you taking out the time and speaking with us and giving us those uh
15:54 you know detailed notes and perspectives about this particular threat to our country and of course the world as well dipping into a short break be right back thank you for more such videos subscribe to the news X YouTube channel hit the Bell icon