Webinar or Talk
Limiting the Problems Created by Turkish President Erdogan
Watch on YouTube
Description
Is Turkey Redeemable? The debate is over. President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan is no friend of the United States, Israel, or the West. Have two decades of incitement and bureaucratic reform made Turkey’s Islamist transformation permanent? Policy analysts will discuss what U.S. policy towards Turkey should be: Co-option, containment, or coercion? Should the United States designate Turkey as a state sponsor of terrorism? Is it possible to expel Turkey from NATO, and if not, what other options exist? Can Turkey be a force for stability in the region, or will it always be a spoiler? As many in Washington, Europe, and NATO continue to calibrate Turkey policy to wishful thinking rather than reality, what more can be done?
Sam Brownback served as Ambassador at Large for International Religious Freedom from February 2018 to January 2021. He served as governor of Kansas from 2011 to 2018. Prior to that he represented his home state in the United States Senate and the House of Representatives. While a member of the Senate, he worked actively on the issue of religious freedom in multiple countries and was a key sponsor of the International Religious Freedom Act of 1998. Ambassador Brownback currently serves as co-chair of the International Religious Freedom Summit and is a senior fellow at Global Christian Relief. He is also chairman of the National Committee for Religious Freedom
Sinan Ciddi is a non-resident senior fellow at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies (FDD) and an expert on Turkish domestic politics and foreign policy. He is also an associate professor of National Security Studies at Marine Corps University (MCU). Prior to joining MCU, Sinan was the executive director of the Institute of Turkish Studies, based at Georgetown University (2011-2020). He continues to author scholarly articles, opinion pieces, and book chapters on contemporary Turkish politics and foreign policy and appears regularly on various media outlets.
Michael Rubin is the MEF Director of Policy Analysis at as well as senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, where he specializes in Middle Eastern countries, particularly Iran and Turkey. His career includes time as a Pentagon official, with field experiences in Iran, Yemen, and Iraq, as well as engagements with the Taliban prior to 9/11. Mr. Rubin has also contributed to military education, teaching U.S. Navy and Marine units about regional conflicts and terrorism. His scholarly work includes several key publications, such as Dancing with the Devil and Eternal Iran. Rubin earned his Ph.D. and M.A. in history and a B.S. in biology from Yale University.
Presented on May 14, 2024 in Washington, D.C.
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 22, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:02 our next panel will be chaired by the Middle East forum's director of policy analysis Michael Rubin the topic limiting the problems created by Turkish president erdogan is turkey redeemable the debate is over president RP T erdogan is no friend of the United States Israel or the West have two decades of incitement and bureaucratic reform made turkey's islamist transformation permanent policy analysts will discuss what US policy towards turkey should be co-option containment or coercion should the United States designate turkey as a state sponsor of terrorism is it possible to expel turkey from NATO and if not what other options exist as many in Washington Europe and NATO continue to calibrate turkey policy to wishful thinking rather than reality what more can be done Michael will introduce our panelists have a very interesting discussion on this topic Michael thank you so much um one of our
1:06 panelists had a little bit of a transportation hiccup but I'm thrilled that we have two other panelists here today I'm not going to spend much time with introductions and instead of doing a traditional panel we're going to have a conversation and then at some point we will turn over to questions not statements questions from the audience and um you will see that I am not normally a polite person and I am even less polite when someone asks a statement from the c um tries to deliver a statement from the crowd now what I'd like to do uh again my name is Michael Rubin I'm thrilled to be here as um part of the Middle East forum for the first time although I will just add when Daniel was saying it was all getting started 30 years ago I was an intern at the time uh as that happened and then had a 30-year detour that said I want to introduce our panelists today I'm thrilled to have them both with me um
2:08 with me to the far left is Ambassador Sam Brownback who used to be the ambassador for international religious freedom at the state department I believe he was the inaugural one and many of you also know Sam Brownback from his distinguished career in both the US Senate and as governor of Kansas but is much more elaborate biography is is in the booklet and then sonan Judi is the director of the turkey program at the foundation for the defense of democracies which is um another Washington DC Think Tank and also teaches at the Marine Corps University and has some of the most incisive writing out there when it comes to the INT in intricacies of Turkish politics but um let me just start out by talking about how much turkey has changed and one of these one of my old mentors Bernard Lewis uh who I met when I was working on my PhD dissertation
3:13 ago told me that I should always pay attention to political humor in the various countries which I studied and for those of you that didn't know Professor Lewis he was a repository of jokes some of them going centuries but U quite literally centuries but I've heard one about turkey recently about one of these academics who had a tweet and said something by Twitter he should not have said and soon found himself with a 20-year prison sentence and when he went prison after he was processed he went to the prison library with a long list of books because he has 20 years to spend and he goes to the prison librarian and offers him the the the list and the prison librarian goes over the list of books and says I'm so sorry we don't have any of these books we only have the authors the the point is turkey has
4:17 fundamentally changed and let me start by asking Ambassador Brownback how much has turkey changed and what should we do about it that was a great joke uh I I appreciated that and I I can't start without thanking Middle East Forum 30 years ago I was a freshman Congressman in the Revolution and the gri Revolution coming in from Kansas and Daniel pipes was somebody that I got to know while I was in Congress and I just very much appreciated his insightfulness and his willingness to go against the trend uh and speak truth even if it's not well received or lauded uh at the time if he stands there long enough than people come around and Daniel thank you for for being there and in that role for a long period of time and doing a great job uh erdogan has changed turkey or turkey maybe was always there and erdogan has just uh really followed the populist instincts I don't know which would be accurate it was a gentleman maybe his
5:18 raised in Turkey could say more but it's different he's an islamist uh he's not our friend he's not I don't believe on our team uh and I think we've got to just be more clear-minded about this and start pushing back in very credible and in and clear ways and doing things in our best interest like degrading our positions that we have in turkey as a as a country I think we've got to start moving out assets uh over time it'd be the same as any of you that own a company or work in a company and you look at a place that's really just not performing very well for you you just kind of let it degrade over time uh and move move and put your investments in other places sck out a threat of what you said and then we can get back to that and um for for either of you is the problem turkey or is the problem erdogan was it always the case is it possible to go back to the status quo empty I if if I could really quickly yes that's the
6:20 problem both and but the issue is erdogan you know when he had the the military was going to come in and take over which they had done 10 times before this was the atat Turk model uh you know when things get out of control the military steps in and puts things back on the regular course well he figured that one out flipped it uh and so what you've got really is probably a more natural turkey with Eran letting them follow the instincts rather than the military correct in the course you agree I mean yes I think there's a lot to be said there I mean you could look at it from this many ways one of the ways I've always looked at this is sometimes after 2010 folks started saying what happened to erdogan he's changed he was this sort of pragmatist this sort of you know um you know following the the accession process for the European Union being quite sort of collaborative over a range of foreign policy issues with the United States they wanted to turn a you know a page after the Bush Administration with the with the US following Iraq and there was a bit of fence mending and suddenly with the onset of the Arab uprisings
7:24 what you started to increasingly see is a very Divergent Aran so what I always say about this is I don't I always say that Aran hasn't changed what what what has changed is essentially he has stopped pulling uh wool over people's eyes and basically allowed his character and his ideological and foreign policy perspectives to really play out um and nothing has changed that well let me ask you this has the demography in Turkey changed to the point where does erdogan have a support that if we go back to the tooo era the the the leader back in uh throughout much of the 80s and early 90s where is it a fundamentally turkey different turkey just in terms of population oh yeah I mean absolutely I mean I would say look you know he's been in office for the for the longest amount of time in turkey's history as a republic right since he's been in office since 2003 more than atat Turk more than atat tur um a new an entire New Generation has grown up under his rule that does not know another political leader other than ardogan and and that's profound because he's had the ability to not only influence that generation but
8:26 he's also Consolidated sort of bureaucratic and State power over these 20 years you know es and flows what you've seen is the complete overhaul of major institutions with people that think like him or sort of espouse his views and project them and Implement that policy but he's also deinstitutionalized the country you know especially since the coup attempt of 2016 where he's basically centralized power he doesn't want to listen to anybody except very few advisers and basically determine how he looks at the world and that is not a good picture for us to essentially sort of you know follow through let let me actually ask about religion for a second um I'm an Iran Watcher by training and in Iran they often talk about dinim my personal religion which is a way of differentiating themselves from the state imposed religion as we talk about this generation and perhaps more than 30 million people have gone through the Turkish Education System since erogan came to power is there actually has he succeeded um in terms of political Islam in terms
9:31 of the Brotherhood Outlook um Society or has he created a backlash uh among the youth and I'd also ask this to Ambassador Brownback how has the problem of um religious intolerance grown in turkey and what as someone who worked on this in the state department how do you fix that what's the I mean it's one thing to complain what's the policy prescription so let me ask you about how younger generation is in terms of religion but then I'd like to ask you Governor Ambassador um about the policy prescription what can the United States do about something like that it depends I mean you know you're he's on record for saying shortly after the 2018 elections basically saying we've succeeded in basically capturing the hearts and minds of a vast amount of the population in the services oriented government of the AKP as in like we AKP is the political party oh his party so convinced people say he's happy that basically people buy into the services
10:33 he's delivered as a as a government but he said we fail to basically conquer the cultural realm I would say at least 50 to 60% of the country still is vehemently you know uh he's very polarizing figure and reject that sort of authoritarian islamist Outlook that he wants people and kids to gr up with now they've introduced that into the curriculums of primary schools education and second they've they they've removed things like Evolution Theory now and now they've introduced m religion classes which in My opat Religion classes but religion it's called world religion but in my interpretation it's code for hate everybody except people who think like them so I mean but what I'm asking is if you're Christian if you're Jewish if you're a levie which is sort of like a a Shia offshoot sect do you have to go to the Sunni instruction you have to take the world religion class and uh and and and if you're subjected to that in most cases in state schools my understanding is those classes um you know have a lot to say about a particular view of Islam and not a lot of nice things to say about other religions or other sects so
11:35 what do you do about it as a US policy maker I think we start treating them the way we did Saudi Arabia about 20 years ago when they were exporting radical Islam to the rest of the world uh we you know and and Daniel you were involved in a lot of this uh we started pointing out what's in the textbooks we started pointing out what's coming out from the imams that come from turkey or from Turkish uh educational institutions are ones that they sponsor because religion to spread this ideology um just to interrupt many of you know about the stabbing that occurred in Israel recently in Jerusalem the person the perpetrator who was then killed was actually a Turkish Imam trained by the Turkish State organization and he took it upon himself went to Jerusalem as a tourist and tried to stab someone anyway I'm sorry to interrupt he was in an official tour okay that I didn't realize on the I'm sorry to interrupt Ambassador turkey is using the same play that Saudi Arabia did 20 25 years ago when they were
12:39 really pushing the radical uh clerics around the world that radicalized much of Islam much of Islam in many places around the world was not radical and then the turkey I mean the Saudis started exporting all these radical imams or bringing imams into Saudi Arabia which is an easier draw because you got Mecca and Medina there to to educate to radicalizing well then you had these countries start pulling back saying whoa whoa whoa whoa whoa we're going to start educating our own IM moms so Indonesia now does this usbekistan now does this of of other uh more moderate trying to move more moderate Islam and I think we have to play take that same Playbook only Turkish has turkey has been more subtle about it I mean there's has been more funding related theirs has been I presume more seminar related we've just we've got to get in and stop this r radicalization that they're funding and pushing out from turkey and that's also happening in turkey and when nobody's doing that that I know of maybe somebody is but not that I know of I mean you may have an easier time actually accomplishing that with a
13:41 lighter touch in the sense that I think you know to go back to your earlier question is it ardan is is he fundamentally Chang the country I think my prediction for the future is when ardogan dies um some people will remember him um and he'll have an official sort of graves up whatever but they will not have a MOS he will not have a mosum I mean he has attracted the IR and hatred of at least half the country if not more um and if if he had been successful in islamization that would sort of voluntarily still pronounce the name atat Turk and would want it on all like all his iconography on walls his portraits of in official buildings he wants that gone he's wanted that gone for a long time but he cannot erase it he would like to um and I think he's very sort of muddled and sort of jealous about that and I think once he dies you know Aron's memory is a dis you know he will he will wither I think in much the way what some other sort of iconic leaders did he would like to displace that sort of the the kemalist uh secular image of turkey I don't think he's going to succeed and that's not just brute
14:43 optimism I think even his constituencies even his most loyal supporters yes by show and practice they go to to Masque and they go to sort of projecting the sort of Pious lifestyle which I think is most in most cases is a veneer they don't want a a to sort of raise the next um devout Sharia based family what they want is they want the next apartment they want to send their kids to prestigious schools they want to establish businesses they want to make money they want to they want to spend that money in Monaco and and and New York um you know they're not looking for a return to a Theocratic lifestyle and for now ardogan has been a vehicle to sort of achieve those goals I think he will fail in the cultural realm um I would just point out and I'm going to go back to um Ambassador you in a second with regard to the conversion of some of the um um churches to to mosques um but I I do want to just point out and correct me if I'm wrong look at the best of times oftentimes Turkish politics can be sort of like an elementary school little
15:46 league soccer game where you just have a big scrum but every now and then there is a consolidation of power um you had it in the 1950s under um Adam mandas uh where the Democracy party Consolidated power you had it in the 1980s under toret ozal with the motherland party and those parties didn't actually survive for long the death of those charismatic leaders so the exception of course being aot Turk with the Republican people's party which is oftentimes abbreviated CHP from the Turkish um from the Turkish um but so what you're basically saying is it makes sense that the AKP isn't going to lasts long past erdogan's death although perhaps some other um some other parties will emerge from the alumni of the AKP yeah I mean the AKP I would say is just a vehicle for to enable kleptocracy Okay that's all it is and once he dies he doesn't even care about the future of the party I mean it's just a front at this point and when ardan dies the
16:48 party's gone too is Anchor 2024 Teran 1978 good question um hard to say I don't think we've gotten there yet but I think this is the most interesting aspect of why we probably have a panel on Turkey because where he's maneuvered the country strategically policy-wise in the last I would say at least most worryingly since 2016 um 2017 um should ring alarm Bells okay in terms of what he's doing Michael I want to jump in with another policy idea building on one has been very successful uh the abrahamic Accords uh I in a normal situ Donald Trump would get the Nobel Peace Prize for the abrahamic Accords uh this is phenomenal that this took place and we were this close to the Saudis joining it until the Iranians come after Israel through Hamas and don't ever let the Iranians off the hook on this the Middle East is going to stay stirred up as long as that Iranian
17:50 leadership is in power they'll find somebody else but we should build on the abrahamic Accords we should build an abrahamic Faith initiative and work with uh Daniel was saying I think islamization peaked in the Middle East you said a decade ago I agree and I've been meeting and talking with some of the leaders in these other Islamic countries in the Middle East many of them are tired of this they want to move on to something and be more open and they're seeing the end of these Petro dollars fueling everything that they have and they want to have a more open Society where you're not killed if you're uh if you have to be a Sunni Muslim or else you're thrown in jail and killed they they're saying we've got to have a more open Society here so they want to open this up and I think if we came in and backed building on that an abrahamic Faith initiative we got uh religious leaders from all the the three abrahamic faiths that would unite around an idea that our faith does not support
18:53 the killing of innocent people under our theology just because we dis agree with them just have a very very basic agreement but start to build uh this with other more moderate Muslim countries and push back against this Turkish initiative and narrative to radicalize and continue to radicalize albe it smaller populations but it doesn't take many radicals to really make a place blow up or go bad uh you just need a few I think we need to build on I think we can win with that strategy yesterday if if those of you who may not know um erdan was talking with the prime minister of Greece and the prime minister of Greece referred to Hamas as a terrorist group Eran said no no no it's not a terrorist group they're insurgents we support them not only do we support them we actually have offered them uh we have a thousand Hamas members who we are giving Medical Care to in
19:56 Turkey right now what was the reaction into that and when the Turks were called out on that oh it was it's astounding we're still sort of trying and work through the details um everyone was kind of shocked and they thought did the president misspeak um and I went back and listened to actual Turkish uh broadcast and he doesn't missp speak he's very clear he literally says we' treating a thousand Hamas uh uh Fighters which by you know us standards is is D there are multiple layers of sanctionable actions there that you can the biggest question that we have is how do they get them out how do if if Turkey is treating thousand Hamas Fighters inside of turkey if that's not a misspeaking on his part how do they get there um and I've been pinging people since last night trying to sort of get a knowhow and the most plausible sort of scenario seems to sort of focus on well they're smuggled out of tunnels to Egypt because there's a racket going on in in across the RAF where Egyptians are essentially taking bribes and and and and turkey's on record for essentially deling the most amount of Aid to to to uh uh uh to to to Gaza so if Turkish planes are flying into Egypt presumably
21:00 they can be loaded up and flown back with uh uh Hamas fighters to Tok that's that's the most plausible thing that comes to my mind um but then there was a sort of lukewarm uh non non- denial denial yeah um reuter is reported about an hour after adan's speech suggesting that um an anonymous Turkish official said to Reuters that the president misspoke what he meant to say was that they're essentially only um only injured gazans were being flown back to Turkey the only reason why I'm suspicious of it and I haven't ruled it out is because there actually is an existing Cooperative agreement between turkey Egypt and Israel yeah sick acutely sick people injured gazin but also people receiving Cancer Care and all these sorts of cares are being flown to turkey that is that actually is happening but if you really wanted to set the record straight you wouldn't do this unofficial sort of you know anonymous to Reuters you would want his press and comms director to to to
22:02 schedule a press conference and say hey just to set the straight record straight the president misspoke what he meant to say was they could they would do a cleanup an official cleanup and I haven't seen anything since I mean there's this old joke some of you may know about two psychiatrists who are in practice together one goes in in the morning and said you know I made the biggest Tran slip to my wife this morning over breakfast and another one said what did you say said well I meant to say honey please pass more waffles but somehow it came out you really ruined my life life I mean it's one of those um the the correction just isn't convincing but if I may crystalize if I may crystallize you're talking about um and you you could I I know from FDD work from foundation for defense of democracy work you can really go down into how erdogan has been throwing fuel on the fire um and really vocal in terms of support for Hamas the current foreign minister of turkey hakan fid was for 13 years the intelligence chief he is responsible for allowing Hamas to really set up its Financial its diplomatic its
23:07 technical infrastructure inside turkey just shortly before the October 7th program the terrorist attack Israel had actually intercepted tons of uh explosive precursors that were destined being smuggled into Hamas so turkey has its hand dirdy but at the same time Ambassador you're talking about how we really need to build up on this abrahamic face initiative and what's clear is that turkey wouldn't turkey under erdogan wouldn't want to be part of that so the question is given that turkey is part of NATO given that turkey institutionally um what it is today how do we address this fact is it possible to address the problem that turkey essentially has a veto power over NATO we saw how they engaged in extortion with regard to Sweden and finland's um NATO membership we see what's going on in Syria with the ethnic cleansing a of afine and other districts how do we address this problem of turkey from a security standpoint and if I may we're on the verge of giving Turkey
24:10 f-16s um how do we address these issues I'll just open this to both of you yeah I I think we've got to we've got to stop doing that as I started with I can think we got to start degrading our asset base in turkey and with turkey I think we've got to go to other places I think we you got to look for other places and turkey has a lot of natural features really hard for our defense U assets and not give things like f-16s to somebody who doesn't support us this this guy is not on our team and he's now increasingly gotten a country that's Bolder against us uh well now how do you get him out of NATO this is going to be a difficult thing but what you can do is you can certainly degrade that position over a period of time and I think we clearly need to do that and I want to throw another policy idea out here we need to have an ambassador to the Orthodox World similar to what we have an ambassador to the Vatican and it needs to be that person needs to be stationed in State Department not in uh
25:15 Istanbul that would really throw the Turks off and they would really go at the head the the the patriarch uh the Greek patriarch there that's the first among equals and the Orthodox but we're talking about the Orthodox region of the world where much of this problem is taking place and you need a voice inside of State Department saying hey wait we need to be doing this for these other Orthodox countries that are under attack like Armenia is right now primarily an orthodox country under attack by aaban and turkey Armenia has been a bone in the throat of turkey for centuries they've been there for thousands of years it's the oldest Christian Nation on Earth and Azan wants to wipe them out with turkey's backing and unfortunately our military assets and Israeli military assets that have been going to aeran let me just for a point of clarification I'm going to you as a turkey expert and as the head of the turkey program at foundation for defense democracy why is it so difficult to kick turkey out of NATO it's just it's it's just legal ease
26:21 I mean it's import there is no mechanism built into NATO's actual founding treaty that expels a member um NATO was conceived after 1945 obviously as a bullwark against the Soviet Union right it it never had thought from a perspective of design that it would have to deal with Insider threats and the other issue is consensus and consensus and for membership everybody actually has to essentially agree there's no op if all members do not agree on who becomes a member then that person doesn't become a member and consequently there is actually no mechanism for saying even if there's a consensus on we don't want you it doesn't work it doesn't doesn't exist inside of the organization but it's not just membership it's major policies with it's major policies so they're a church and horse it would appear so right at this point I mean it's it's deeply problematic because both Hungary and turkey have figured out that they can hold the alliance hostage for policy gains should they choose to do so and the Finland and Sweden acceptance into into you know it took over nearly two years to essentially get them accepted into NATO and that's a deep problem um and and you can look at this you know
27:25 you know what can be done not just NATO but like in terms of policy options I don't think there are any good ones um you know for example sanctions is the ones that we that we always continue to apply to adversaries but we've also sort of imple implemented several of them on Turkey they don't seem to be deterring turkey after turkey acquired Russian missile defenses um back in 2019 which is completely against sort of uh uh NATO operations and NATO policy for an for an Allied country to adopt Russian Hardware um that was precisely the reason why turkey was kicked out of the F35 program um and as and as a result those sanctions haven't really deterred turkey from doing any other things that are deemed to be detrimental to the interests of of of the alliance um but we have problems independent of sanctions we have a sort of divided line of effort within the US government of how to work with turkey right we have the treasury Department uh which has been very Vigilant uh especially since October 7th uh attacks on Israel in identifying entities and persons who are breaching us stions or us sort of um uh
28:31 actors that are aiding and abetting Hamas and other terrorist entities and we've sanctioned those individuals and we've we've done it quite harsh um but the problem is on the other hand we've got the state department which is essentially trying to sort of you know one word could be coddle turkey or the other word could be work with turkey because from their perspective State Department is in a is in a it's trying to figure out a way to work with an ally no matter how troubled it is because if you look at it from their perspective they would say well in 20 years time if we take this decision now to really cut you know hold turkey accountable 20 years from now what if we need turkey and I was the we were the administration responsible for driving turkey off the cliff and basically making them a parah state because we cut ties and they become a country like Iran right there's this pathological fear of losing turkey okay right but weakness invites probing when you're we weak or when you act weak and everybody knows the United States is not weak we got the biggest gun in the world they just question
29:36 whether we'll use it or not but when you act weak uh it invites probing and it invites probing not just by Russia not just by China it invites probing by turkey looking at us and saying okay they'll cuddle you you know you you we'll okay let's go let's kick all let's kick 120,000 Christians out of Nar arach and let's see what the West does which was nothing oh well maybe we can go a little further here with this and let's just that's the the you cannot do that in this world today you you you can't be you can be unpredictable that's Donald Trump I think measured in that uh you know which is a helpful thing if the other guy doesn't know he knows you got a big gun and he actually knows you're crazy enough to use it maybe I'm raised in the West too long and watch too gunm smoke but it was Matt Dylan didn't go out on on Dodge City's Main Street carrying a water pistol he had a gun and they knew he knew how to
30:39 use it and that's what you have to do I I've got two final questions and then I'm going to turn it over to the floor um the first question would be what is Turkey's vision for the Middle East today I mean Beyond simply Hamas and the second question so that I'm not you're not accused of being tur the first country inside of NATO to shoot down a Russian fighter jet since 1952 um it raised alarm bells in the Atlantic Council the NATO Council was called under Article 4 for deliberations everybody was scared because if the Russians retaliated and struck turkey
31:41 back for shooting down one of their Fighters what would we do would we go to war with Russians right um and everybody was worried but Putin basically looked at this and thought I'm not going to provoke a fight I I can really squeeze more juice out of this by being clever about it and basically he cut off um tourism with turkey which is a vital sort of economic thing for Turks because about 2 million Russians vacation in Turkey every summer um he cut off the Imports of Turkish agricultural produce that turkey Den depends upon to the tune of about $8 to 10 billion dollar a year cut business visas and and tourist visas it it contracted the Turkish economy by about 0.5% of its GDP and basically resulted in Aran writing a letter of apology and offering compensation but then also starting to work with Putin because that was one the conditions under which Putin would say let's normalize ties again but all this is to say that there is a way that you can be consistent and forceful that we've never employed with with with with anchor um because erogan basically understands if if treasury says and does one thing and state does and says another thing hey
32:44 you can play one off of the other got it um so that that's by that turkey's vision for the future AR Middle East for the Middle East well it's in line with his others I think um world which is the world is bigger than five he's basically says the world is more diverse and uh you know different than it was in 1945 with five major powers that make up the UN Security Council and we want a voice in that and we want a deliberate voice in how the Middle East is shaped independent of us in positions as as he would see it sometime offline I want to find out how Lindsay Lohan became such an acolyte of Reb T erdogan quoting his slogan the world is bigger than five that's that's a good I I think it's a Neo Ottoman Empire okay I think he's you know clearly mentally that's the mentality and it it's an Islamic caliphate and modern terminology and modern operation and ways so it doesn't look like the old uh uh one but mentally I think that's the I've traveled and worked a lot in Central Asia and you can really see all the Turkish uh fingerprints and
33:47 Footprints all over the place do we still get any benefit from Turkey before we turn over to the floor and start thinking about your questions not the statements well in terms of benefit what we get right now it's hard to quantify not much okay right I mean we're not really getting that much but again I think the worry from you know sources like you know even the Pentagon or even at State they would say well we could be doing a hell of a lot worse if we push them over the edge as in if we are more forceful with them erogan may just cross that line I mean he's they're already an observer on the Shanghai cooperation organization they have increased ties with Russia I mean they have very sophisticated ties with Russia right and uh you know he's hedging between both the Western camp that is a member of of Alliance wise and institutionally but he also has one foot that he's dangling in the other saying if you know um if I if I don't get what I want uh to us and our Western allies then I may just cross that threshold so he keeps that level of unpredictability which makes it difficult for us to guess which is so is there anything we good out of it not really but you know he's dangling what
34:49 you say Ambassador I want to just in know before we go to question with this point the the word of our era right now acceleration everything's moving faster these changes and these Alliance realignments are moving faster than they've ever done before we're used to kind of a okay this will take several years for this to develop happening in months Russia flipping from Armenia to aeran Turkey trying to line somewhere else up uh to to really I mean they're I don't think they want to align with the Chinese I think they want to align with turkey I think they want they want a bigger Turkish in a multi-polar world uh but they want it islamized and that they think they can put uh put a lot into that and I think we have to then move acceleration I was watching the NBA playoffs last night for a little bit and I thought man how fast these guys move and how big and if you watch the same game game 20 years ago the guys aren't
35:53 quite as big and they don't move the the the speed of the game has gone up the speed of the foreign policy and defense game has gone up and we've got to move faster with it and we've got to be more Nimble and move with it acceleration is the word of the day actually one final question a little bit on this track um we've talked offline Ambassador when we travel to Armenia together about how religious freedom is often times the canary in the coal mine diplomats can say that reform is working and so forth but if you don't have religious freedom doesn't matter whether it's China with the weager I mean it really does show where cont regime is heading it does okay the question I have should the Jews and turkey stay or go and it's sad that we even have to ask this question and I don't know is a perfectly fine answer yeah how many have already left yeah a lot that'd be I would think that'd be if if I were them and it was my family I would be leaving
36:57 okay just and and it doesn't because it doesn't take a lot we had I was governor of Kansas and we had an attack on the synagogue in Kansas and I condemmed it and we put extra police officers in there but and it was a it was a guy he he was a Christian guy and he ended up shooting uh uh some Christians he didn't shoot uh Jewish people but my point of it doesn't take very many just takes a couple that are crazy uh and that want to kill somebody and then you're and you're Off to the Races any final word yeah I mean I would I would say you know even if you're a Muslim in Turkey the majority of which the country is I I I would argue you don't have religious freedom yeah in Turkey recently relatively famous uh um uh artist died um and in his will basically he said he he didn't want a Muslim burying that he wanted to be crated he was buried with a full Imam um sort of funeral service I mean you're not there's no cremation service for Muslims you cannot designate how you get
37:59 you know die and get buried you have to have the official thing in terms of the Jews if they I mean look that was the largest remaining um uh minority population in in Turkey which has existed inside of turkey since basically the 1490s right um from originally from Spain and Portugal and you know Turkish Jews are amongst the most fiercely proud of being Turkish um they have very deep ties and you know before the Israel was founded there was a at least close to a couple of hundred thousand of them if I'm not mistaken that figure today is down to about 15,000 and most of you know it was it was over 25 I would say about 10 years ago that Exodus of about 10,000 in the last few years is because they're extremely worried about what ardan's doing but it's hard for them to transition out of turkey go to countries like the us or back to Portugal and Spain less so to Israel because for them it's all these are foreign countries right um they they don't know what to do with themselves and the older they are the more traumatic it is for them to leave their country okay um during I'm during the question and answers because
39:02 I forgot to ask the question if you can't think of a really poignant question ask about the conversion of um churches to mosques I won't ask it but if one of you wants to do it it will be fine uh the other thing I want to do is just close look my my father-in-law is a Russian refus Nick a Soviet refus Nick and he tells a Russian joke about the difference between a Russian Optimist and a Russian pessimist the Russian pessimist is the one who says you know things have never been so bad War famine economy Health they couldn't possibly get worse and the Russian Optimist is the one who says no no no they can always get worse so perhaps this is an optimistic panel about turkey but with that really and we're also going to play Jeopardy rules and by that I mean you can ask as many questions as you want but I'm only going to direct the first one to be answered okay so let's try to get as many questions in as possible yes sir Turkish rivalry you
40:08 know yes turkey turkey is a is a Sunni state that is rivaling the Shia Iranian influence okay do one of you want to take this I'm you are both you guys take it somebody here I mean turkey has been promising um or promised I should say uh the safety of Ukrainian tatars since the invasion of Ukraine in 2014 by Little Green Men um and it really hasn't followed through with it but also turkey is essentially been promising sort of you know the sanctity and and safety of wegers in in China which it really hasn't followed through with because again it's China and right now basically it's not interested in following up by you know offering its support you know significant or substantive support to protecting Ukrainian Muslims that are remnants of the Ottoman Empire I should say mainly because it you know he's looking down staring down Mr Putin and he has no interest ardan has no interest in shaking that boat um you know it's just
41:11 it's just it's just too problematic for him and he's just not going to move on that okay okay since you're offering us the chance to ask as many questions no seriously just one okay I two but okay every now and then uh we see that local elections go against erdogan and his parties does that mean that still under erdogan today there are free elections question I this is my estimation of it I think as a politician I think he is crested and he's coming down and so you're what you're starting to see is the undergrowth growing up underneath it and you you'll see that expressed in more liberalized areas uh and you'll start seeing them winning local elections before they're able to push through at the top would be my uh my view my interpretation of that I can answer your question with a question which is to say um do elections in Turkey still matter and the answer would seem to be yes I mean you look at the two different elections both in Russia
42:13 and Turkey right aroan got you know clobbered just a month ago right he is not in charge of local governance in turkey and that may not matter much to some but local governance is the key to governing turkey they want local governments because that's where the corruption happens that's where the money is Right zoning permits construction all of that they don't have access to most of that which means they cannot essentially Finance their political machine and and you you have less reason as a construction tycoon or a person with significant assets and capital to offer your support to Eran because you're looking well who's going to give me permits and you're looking to well the other the opposition guy who won it who's going to be the mayor of this town right and that governance so unlike Russia turkey still uh a country where elections matter and aran's deeply worried about this and so we may see sort of moves to change once again the electoral system or even the mode of governance uh such that he's CU he's looking already forward to the next election so it can be like Putin medev Putin sort of thing well no they're
43:15 thinking of reinstituting the Prime Minister as once again which is there you go uh Daniel and then um Daniel then we're going to go to Leah Jacobson in the front row and then we're going to go to this side Mr Ambassador thank you for the kind words Mr jidy I have two questions and then you'll pick which one you want um one is to suggest you you you mentioned that there was a transition uh by erdogan around 2010 I thought it's the July 20111 meeting with the heads of the military where he took over the military that until that point he was fearful of the military and after that point he's not before that he behaved after that he didn't tell me if you agree or not and secondly could you say something about deism the emergence of deism as an alternative to Islam oh excellent questions um yeah you could I would say you could take your pick um in terms of what the fundamental turning point that people started to say Eran has changed right I look at it as 2010 basically when you know there was there
44:16 was this referendum in Turkey over the Constitution 26 articles of the Constitution were put before the public to be changed and a lot of those uh basically focused on making the military uh more accountable before civilian law and and make them accessible to civilian oversight in terms of jurus prudence right but it also allowed the first instance of the politicization of the Judiciary whereby the government initiated penetration into appointing judges and prosecutors for the first time before it with that it was a cast system right they basically appointed judges and prosecutors were appointed and at that point I saw that was a for me that was a fundamental turning point because he felt empowered um you know they tried to shut his party down and remove him from Office back in 2007 and so but what you're alluding to is absolutely right I mean you know that's another by 2011 he really did take on the military and they ended up quitting uh the force commanders ended up committing uh quitting he didn't care uh before we talk about the dism though as we go into this one thing I don't see
45:18 the US government doing which is um relevant to Daniel's question is why aren't we using what a did to dismantle the checks and balances as a case study in terms of how um dictators or would be dictators islamists who talk the language of democracy slowly dismantle the system are we actually learning the lessons from what occurred but with that rhetorical question let me ask both of you about the deism uh before we go on the next question and then we're do rapid fire questions on this side of the room you know I I love the question there and it's something I've been observing in other Muslim majority countries is this you newer generation coming up going I don't know if I agree with my uh this interpretation of Islam is being forced here on us and starting to search and look and I think here we have to thank Iran and the mulas that have been run ruling that country for 40
46:22 plus years it was supposed to be paradise on earth right finally when Islam ran everything and and we're in control and we've got it all this is supposed to be perfect right this is what we've been Islam is the way and so this should be and it's not and people there are not happy with it and so I think then the newer generation's coming up going I I want to look somewhere else I I would just say that when ayatollahi died on june3rd 1989 there's a heat wve in tran and the the rumor or the quip on the streets of Teran at that point was that the old man was so scile he forgot to close the door on the way down uh I mean the the fact of the matter is people had already started to turn against someone who had been a charismatic religious leader at least inside Iran but um do you have anything to add or should we go to I'll just say something briefly but this is the one of the only panel I've been on where you have really good jokes lined up I I don't mean that I really do mean that I mean I hope they don't if we keep going they're going to get more and more off
47:25 color so so don't press me but can I just say something to theism absolutely I mean one of the things the backlashes against ardan sort of use of Islam to I call use of Islam to make the country more authoritarian because I think that's his ultimate goal right um uh is to sort of vulgarize Islam and its traditions and practices in the in in in in the face of the people just you know um in in various ways we could talk more offline about this that has caused such a backlash and disillusionment with like you know corporate religion in turkey or Islam in turkey that there is a big switch off this like if you look at like across the school you know the the the school system kids are like you know impose a world religions class on kids with no opt outs I mean kids are as cynical as an next guy right and after a while people just start switching off and so there is this sort of backlash people Define themselves as deis or bah or you know I believe in a big mover but I don't believe in Allah or God or whatever so yeah it's an interesting thing to watch sorry will uan make good
48:30 on its threat to Israel made after 107 to eliminate trade no so turkey basically terminated like and Turkish islamists Al ardogan right I mean they talk the big talk about how they're essentially Pro you know pro anti-israel pro Hamas and you know the oppressed people we we know we want to save the Palestinians at the end of the day it's all a racket they don't care and so be after October 7 people that we're watching essentially the trade volumes in Turkey between in Israel and Turkey and in 2023 it hit a all-time high of about7 billion dollar a year and it's quite lucrative and some of the contract contractors who making the most money out of that trade volume on the turkey side are government officials and erdogan's family including his son that are shipping all sorts of things to to Israel such as explosives sheet metal aluminum you know to Israel gets used to to get 65 to 70% of its concrete from Turkey right um the interesting thing is there was so much
49:32 public pressure people saying well hang on a minute so you you want you know Israel to be held accountable for you know killing Palestinians quote unquote right but you're selling stuff to them so why and they try to brush that off initially and say well that's trade and it's existing contracts and people really double down and say well no hang on a minute you can't have it both ways I mean that's just duplicity this is why I call it a racket because they're iner um all they care about is making money right it's not you know they're just using the name of God and religion right and Islam to basically continue whatever they're doing and then things came to AE after the local elections where Aran got hammered maybe in part because of this sort of duplicit stance on trade with Israel now they've completely cut off trade ties they issued a proclamation the government rulle saying all trade with Israel has to stop again if you look at what's going on behind the scenes sort of Turkish exporters are now having shipping that stuff to places like for example Slovenia and then from Slovenia it gets sort of whitewashed and uh you know exports it to Israel as Slovenian goods
50:34 and then they buy that you know it's still going on I don't know to what exent how large it is but you know money is money and that's all they care about yes Sonam thank you so I would like to ask as there is no clear policy till now to Turkey what's going what's is doing the califate of Islam erogan in in Syria supporting the the military groups who are occupying afin and committing a lot of violation there what do you think is the policy should should be uh to stop that and just following questions no no that let's pick that question first Sonam but before we put the mic down so that people can talk to you offline as well could you just briefly introduce yourself and who you're representing yes I'm s Muhammad the US Representative of Syrian Democratic Council I am a Kurdish woman from afin whom my family has been displaced running out because
51:39 of these military groups islamist got it and the Syrian Democratic Council basically runs the northeast of Syria not the Bashar Assad portion but the portion which is allied with the United States and which the US military is operating in so I'm going to direct you guys to answer the question with regard to um the Turkish support for various groups in Syria especially um jihadist groups and if I may to Ambassador brambach look you've been to uh Armenia and so forth and you've heard all these reports include there there's been captured people of how the Turks had brought uh Al-Qaeda Affiliated groups that um members that they had sponsored in Syria and Libya and they had them fight to to ethnically cleanse the Christians in neoral carach so I turn the floor back over to you guys I I think we've got to become much more direct clear confrontational uh and I think we should use economic sanctions and I want to give you just one quick example of that
52:42 when it was an American Pastor Andrew Brunson was being held in a Turkish prison uh and became a cause celeb this thing was kind of bouncing around and in the bureaucracy people were coming up with a little bitty answers to it it bounces up to Trump and uh he says uh you know look I'm just going to I'm going to sanction the steel and aluminum exports into the United States from uh from Turkey I'm going to put a 75% U tariff on them uh and Brunson becomes the most expensive political prisoner in world uh immediately and within 6 months he's out of jail um it was it tanked their stock market uh temporarily it had the impact there I think we need to start using those sorts of clear tools uh and tie them very clearly uh to and these are things that we we can and we should do and and if we never actually do anything towards ER toan you're just going to
53:46 keep pushing it it's just going to keep happening only it'll become more aggressive and worse you actually have to not only growl you have to bite um do you have any yeah I mean she son makes a raises very interesting points from particular you know both her people's security but also vital us interests right which is well we've kind of forgotten about Isis right it's kind of gone and dead and that's the reason why we initially partnered with Syrian uh forces and Kurdish forces right to undermine it because they're on the ground they're motivated they have a clear interest in eliminating Isis and they're also very capable uh and worked and work very effectively with the US military to undermine degrade and at some level eliminate Isis but we were just talking before this it appears that we should all be on the watch saying Isis is not gone right right now if you look inside of North you know Northern Syria where um you know uh SDF forces exist alongside with uh US forces what you have are Isis prisons right with thousands of captured and detained and
54:49 imprisoned Isis Fighters right and the Turks the Turkish military has been striking uh militarily striking with howis with plane bombings very drones whatever right nonstop and increasingly so since the October 7 attacks because nobody's paying attention tur turkeyy is hitting Kurdish forces because turkey identifies them as terrorists and that they have to be taken out um the United States is basically saying hang on a minute no no no but it's not being forceful per the ambassador's sort of suggestion here and I've been on record saying look we need to read them the riot act right in terms of stop targeting our c British Partners One Stop endangering US forces in the region which are essentially uh working with them because the biggest problem is is if the Turks and the Syrian Kurds have to fight each other who's going to man and protect the Isis prisons right those that's not you know that's not a done deal if those prisons break out right I don't think those guys are essentially going to go and take a holiday in the Bahamas they're
55:51 essentially going to get armed and equipped and we're going to see a replay of what we saw in the early 2010s and we'll have to do it all over again a as we prepare to take the next question just to summarize this sometimes in the news you will see discussion about whether the Turks are about to launch an operation into Syria the prison where most of the Islamic State prisoners are now is called allh H and the fear is I mean basically that if Turkey strikes at the people who are the prison guards then suddenly you have thousands of people are even more indoctrinated than the initial Islamic State because they've been raised in this prison they can't I mean the French won't take them back the Germans won't take them back and so forth if they scatter where are they scattering to Chances Are they're not going to be scattering to Iraq which would not have no compunction about killing them instead they're probably going to make their way through turkey to Europe and if you have thousands of
56:53 Islamic State um people some of whom speak speak native French native German and so forth what will happen that's the policy implication that we're watching behind the scenes but sir your question about um consist being consistent and forceful in terms of containing turkey is there a way we could develop a global strategy or Alliance around that in the way that you have India and France defending the Christians in Armenia against Turkish you know forces and Military in aeran can we use these countries to develop some sort of an alliance in a more contained strategy and before we answer that question I just want to single you out because uh you're from kmir right um there is a growing tendency we hear about turkey in terms of the west but turkey has Prov been providing drones and drone technology to some of the Pakistani uh terrorist groups operating in Kashmir and these are the same groups that were responsible for example for
57:56 the 2008 Mumbai attacks and so forth and I'm I actually I'll answer this question I'm happy to say that the Middle East forum is working um behind the scenes but in ways which we can talk about not only I mean with people that have many of the same interests because the whole is greater than the sum of the parts and so when we're working uh not only with Iranians and people in Israel and so islamists people who truly believe in religious tolerance but we're also working in the Eastern Mediterranean with the Greeks with the Armenians if if Amtrak hadn't gotten in the way uh our third panelist today was the son of azan's leading dissident um and we're working of course um Coop finding ways to cooperate with the Hindu American foundation so I do want to give a shout out beyond the scenes there's a lot going on uh which your support helps um
59:00 allow and with that I'm just looking at the clock we have time for one more quick question right over there relationship to I don't know how the stands feel about got it one minute to answer and then we'll close the panel um I the the St this is my estimation to the stands and I've worked with these guys for quite a bit period of time they're interested in themselves they're former Soviets uh they're secularist uh they want to keep Islam out uh they want to keep Russia out and they want to run this place because it's mine and so they'll work with any of them they'll they want their investment but they don't want them running the place they don't want Turkish trained uh
1:00:03 clerics coming in they don't want Russian military running the place now the kazaks brought them in for a little bit to clean up uh a problem they had and then shipped them back out uh my sense of it is is that they're just trying to play everybody in the region to maintain their own control that they have of the place but they'll they'll have Turkish money coming in they have no problem with that just I don't want the radicalize cleric s on 20 20 seconds on the ottomanism oh yeah they tried that and nobody wants it okay and I I'll just conclude by saying one of the problems we faced is that turkey has a much fond remembrance of the Ottoman Empire than many of its subject peoples do you have to end with a joke I'll I'll tell we'll go out for drinks later and then there will be some more not for not not while the cameras on with that I want to turn the floor back over to the director of the Middle East Forum Greg Roman thank you very much thank you br on Michael Ruben