Israel Insider
Israel Insider with Alex Selsky
Watch on YouTube
Description
As Netanyahu's allies pound him with demands, negotiations to form Israel’s next government have reached an impasse. What are his choices?
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 30, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:00 good afternoon and welcome to the Middle East forums webinar and podcast series Israel Insider this week with Alex selsky I'm Stacy Roman and I will be hosting this discussion today we're pleased to have Alex telski a senior advisor to the Middle East forum's Israel Victory project join us this week to update us on all the events going on in Israel Mr Celsius will be giving us a briefing on current Israeli Affairs for 15 minutes and open it up for questions should you wish to ask a question please use the Q a box located at the bottom of your screen to type your question and with that I will turn the discussion over to Mr Alex selski good evening from Jerusalem for everyone as you definitely might see who we have today a very uh Sunday because in the morning the first news that we saw is a very very tragic terror attack in Jerusalem next to its religious neighborhood remote
1:05 and uh 19 people were injured and one 16 year old boy was eventually dead and let his memory be blessed hashemi come down and we understand that this terror attack was uh you know of the kind that we remember from 90s um a bomb that was put and operated from from far so it's a very you know very bad picture for us and it came into the intense negotiations for forming the which until yesterday was very hard and very intense but somehow you know it it went on and everybody blamed each other but today after this terror attack that heard the
2:07 hearts of every Israeli the negotiations accelerated and everybody started to speak that we must form a government now because we see that the challenges the security challenges are so big um and Vietnam virus he always does came to the place of the terror attack and spoke about the need of fighting the terror in a new way in more aggressive way meaning as he calls it a to uh the terror has to pay the price meaning that to stop you know the the good conditions of the terrorists and Israeli prisons and meaning that we have to go back to assassinations of the leadership that we have to punish the Palestinian Authority which uh continues with the incitement and incentive Within it's a
3:14 educational system so definitely the issue of security you raised up and we all saw today that everybody is speaking about the very very fast need to form the government but yet again what we saw today primarily uh blame trade between we could and the uh the Zionist a religious party headed by smotrich and the blame trade only strengthened and liquid said that Smothers thinks only about the you know the positions are not about the essence and definitely smart which said exactly the same about liquid but we do see that you know slowly but surely things come into place we see already that apparently Shas and Arya Dairy got uh they're somehow you know final position and what we see from the Publications even though we cannot
4:16 believe I think definitely majority of all the Publications that we see about the negotiations because we never know what is true and what is leverage and what is pressure Within These negotiations but we do see that he apparently is back from his demand to take the Finance Minister and goes back to his a Ministry that he headed for many years the internal affairs but he will be given also the minister of religion which he really wants and now again we see all the time you know small small demands that that don't come to resolution but again I think that every moment every moment we can hear that the government is is for because we must understand at the end of the day no one of them nobody of the players within the this
5:20 Netanyahu and his partner's Coalition doesn't have another Choice it's either this Coalition or going to new elections because even though Netanyahu in all his previous definitely before 19 2019 used to to take into his Coalition somebody from the center left uh it was guns in on the last year um and before that it was I remind you that in 15 he had before 15 he had living and lapid and before that he had Abu dying Barak within his uh Coalition of 2009 so he he definitely can't do that but I I don't see and I think that nobody can see in this upcoming Coalition this opportunity because this time he really spoke about
6:23 going with his only right-wing block and he has enough to form the government and you know on one hand we see that all of them support Netanyahu and support his demands and support his goals but on the other hand you know it's it's sometimes even more difficult to form a government and to govern with the closest allies because even though you you have a consensus on the you know on the policies a maybe not full consensus but you know you definitely close on the palace policies with with your right wing and Ultra Orthodox Partners than the right left but on the other hand remember that they compete on the same voters on the same target audience so they must Within These governments all the time to prove that each one has to prove that it's his
7:29 success in order to next time take the um take the votes now for Netanyahu I don't think that again we don't know but many speak about the fact that this is maybe his last term of the Prime Minister if this Coalition will serve you know Will Will Survive three or four years so he may be for him it's like the last time so he has to reach all his goals but for all the others definitely for smart region for Benford this is the opportunity to take maximum they can they were in opposition for almost two years they came to maybe the peak okay and many say that they came to the peak to their maximum power because of the frustration and the disappointment from the previous government so they must take maximum power and they must deliver this time so and they will not do it without Netanyahu and I don't
8:31 think and I think they understand that going to another elections they will they will not take the same result because they will be definitely blamed so everybody understand that that's that's the Coalition they might close and they go into into the closure so I think we we will soon see the government now what are the and this is the very important question what are the prices and what we can expect from this government at at this moment what we see and I think that this week can teach us a few things first of I think it shows that even though this Coalition is so uh uh you know has he's homogeneous and has a consensus but we see that the fights are very big and the fight's not only personal but fights on the essence on the policy so even though we we think today that 64 seats in coalition
9:33 is white Coalition but no first of all it's it's it's not so wide and I want to remind you that in the end of four 2014 Netanyahu fired his Justice minister simply living in his Finance Minister Yale lapid because he claimed that he cannot govern when they have such a pressure from each side and she had on the sixth then and lapid had 19 and for Netanyahu it was a big partner that that was pressing him and that Coalition was then 68.
10:11 so then he thought that 68 is hard to govern control so what about the 64 when everybody pushes on you now everybody also understands the part the the Coalition Partners understand that Netanyahu needs them and they again and they pressure at maximum and they know that he can be pressed and ultra-orthodox who are very hungry and they were in you know as we say in Hebrew you know the opposition this desert they came back very very angry and very hungry and they want to take it all back what was taken from them by liberman and the people so the pressure is very big and the hunger is very big and Netanyahu will give them because he understands that the stability that he needs so much depends on them and not on his body so he apparently will hurt much of the hunger
11:14 within likud which will create internal opposition within likud and we already hear every hour or two we hear briefings from within liku that people are so disappointed by him that he gives out everything to the partners and leaves nothing to likud members and more than that I want to remind you that in the beginning of the Netanyahu spoke about giving the Foreign Affairs Ministry to Ron Derma who you definitely know well now it shows two things that I think about what uh Netanyahu plants first I think it can teach us the the policy is not less important for him at this term than the politics because he takes someone whom he really in policy toward the United States even though he understands that this
12:18 will hurt really hurt the the could ministers because they will feel that he you know doesn't count them and even though and and now if he will not give it to Ron Derma so he will I think hurt twice you know he didn't achieve what he wanted and he hurt the people uh by by the very consideration of this nomination but I think again the the even thinking about Ron dermer shows how important United States will be for him how important Iran will be for him how he will concentrate on maybe a even helping the next Republicans who will run on behalf of Republican party definitely to Trump even though I'm not sure what other relations today and how for him this will be a very major uh front
13:26 what else I think is also important is what we can see about the agenda and about what we can expect we see the majority of the fight majority of of the briefings and the fights between the members on the finance ministry now everybody understands maybe until this morning that the major thing that hurts Israel is today is the economy the inflation the prices Tel Aviv is the you know the most expensive city on Earth at the moment to a large extent because of of a very stable status of the shekel but anyway Israelis pay more and more every day and the economy is what hurts definitely you know security is here to stay and sometimes we think that security we don't feel it but this terror attack definitely reminded us that security is here to stay in the Palestinians are here to stay in that the Palestinian
14:30 will not disappear and that Israel must defeat the Palestinians and we definitely see people within this Coalition and government that understands that the policy should be and we really hope that Netanyahu as he to every hope that he had in the last 10 years bogey I alone and then liberman and then Bennett and he neutralized he not realized each one of them so I think we we we will definitely see pressure from the right from Ben burins Modric on but I don't know if Netanyahu will be able to really change policies and we know that because we saw the previous times of uh you know of people who who pressed him from the rights but were not realized very easily by him um I think that I'm close to 15 minutes Stacy tell me if I have more time or we
15:33 will just pass the questions please you have more to add we can certainly take take a few more minutes towards well maybe another very important and very major point that we must see on on the political map today and and we see that different from the negotiations is how Central is the issue of religion and and we see how big is the fight for example on the ministry of religious Affairs between Shas and a smartrich now this is a very important issue and it becomes more and more important issue in in the Israeli Society I think I'll try to really make it brief I think that the new divider the new division the major division between right and left is not the
16:35 security issue I think that security issue overall has reached some broad consensus I think majority of Israelis today and definitely political leaders even in the center and Center left even agree on overall that we must fire Iran that we must you know not promote the Palestinian State and fight the terror definitely people will will argue on how to do that but the major division Within the a the society is the Jewish character of the state the Jewish identity of the state the issues and one of the major uh you know yesterday topics that were in in the news from the negotiations something I think just just a few years ago it was it was so minor but
17:41 smartridge wanted to demand demanded that the the division between the the gender division in religious um uh events will not be considered as because today in many places when religious let's say a single religious singer or or a group of religious Orthodox women wants to have a separated a municipality may say that it's not illegal and they must open it even though they this is a small group and nobody will come to this event except those women so what he wanted is that this kind of event will not be considered as illegal all the discourse not all but definitely majority of the discords yesterday in the middle was that you know Iran is here and Israel becomes Iran and and we all are now under
18:50 and you know secular people will not be able to live in Israel now this is not definitely the intention another situation but the issue between the secular and the religious and definitely the ultra Orthodox is so uh you know it's so hot so dividing so it hurts people on the both sides so much and the demographics are you know demographics go with the Orthodox and we see in every field of life in culture in TV that people are more and more and more and more traditional and more and more religious and we see you know more and more left-wing very liberal singers who start uh wearing Keepers and sing to religious crowds and go to the Judean Samaria and to ultra Orthodox crowds and they say you know like we've given who is a symbol of you know liberal Tel Aviv and
19:53 Thai IDF anti territories it's anti right-wing and he few months ago had a concert with with ultra-orthodox star singer avram freed in religious uh one of the major religious settlements in judeen samarabeth next to Ramada with a keeper on his head saying I am sorry I it was my mistake many years ago to to to to to to hurt your feelings I have so these issues are very very Central today and we will see a huge fight over these issues I think much more than the Palestinians even but the security will not leave us and Security will remind as we saw just this morning every time and everybody who thinks that you know we live our life and Palestinians don't exist anymore and he will be very very painfully
21:00 reminded about the uh about the reality unfortunately as today all right thank you so much so on that point Eric asked when a remote control bomb goes off how can Israel stop the bombs or capture the terrorists who exploded the bombs uh will there be any sort of military operations uh in response to this it's a very very good question first of all Israel launched few small operations already in Judea and Samaria I just remind you that a few months ago we had a new terror group within Nablus Shem very aggressive with the kind of tactics of Islamic Jihad 10 years ago in Israel with few very very precise operations just killed two of the leaders and then one of them
22:02 was uh you know was captured by Israel is so just demolished the whole unit within within a few weeks we see Israel operations very precise in Janine but people do ask as exactly as as you if there is no you know time for a new big operation like defense of Shield which we remember that Sharon launched in we by the way Israel Victory project had a whole conference in May marking 20 years to defensive children asking ourselves if this is not time for another defensive Shield to in what was then in the defensive Shield operation that had this victory over Terror for almost a generation but now there is another generation that doesn't remember already the defensive Shield you know those guys who are today 19 and 20 and they're already leaders of the of these militants they don't remember that so definitely I think that the operation
23:05 will be on the table definitely with Ben veeren's motrich coming into the government I'm sure but again I don't know you know we saw so many hawks coming with so much energy into the governments and and you know many words within the election campaigns don't necessarily mean much after and we already saw that so unfortunately I'm more cautious and and and not pessimistic but definitely uh we have to see because Netanyahu again knows how to how to neutralize those hooks so let's see let's see definitely I think it will be on the thank you Robert Slater asked how strained do you think the Netanyahu Biden relation will be especially regarding Iran and the Abraham Accords you know I personally believe that personal relations are not so
24:10 Central in international relations and in a relations between countries I think that after all you know leaders know how to play friendship when they need it and how to play rivalry when they need it after all it's all about interests primarily internal interests um I think that we definitely can see you know as we speak Israeli chief of staff is now visiting Washington and apparently planning or coordinating um attempts plans I don't know about Iran uh otherwise why Israeli Chief of Staff while being in Washington's space that we reach the critical point of Iran to be ready to develop the nuclear bomb so I think that after all you know we all speak about you know bad relationships and and Democrats you know that not liking
25:16 Netanyahu I think that after all if the interest will be really so close they will definitely work together um the um the midterm elections are over a Biden forgotten for bad has now stable situation for at least a year this year will be very very crucial so I think they will work by the interests you know and again I think that that but again I'm sure that Netanyahu sees you know looking forward for the elections for the presidency already and yes waiting and he doesn't hide this waiting for Republicans again I'm not so sure if he is waiting so much for Trump um you know Haley and DeSantis are very very close friends of of Israel DeSantis was I want to remind you a co-chair of
26:20 the Israel Victory Congressional caucus the first ones we we Israel Victory project and Middle East Forum definitely know how the scientist is good and close about Haley I don't think that and I have to bring any proofs so they will work when it's about interest and they will fight when it's about interests and you know I also believe that much of the political fights uh theatrical and for you know for for the very fights and you know I saw many times within Israeli politics while being advisor of Netanyahu how he was fighting you know in front of the cameras somebody and shouting on him and then sitting and sipping some you know Coffee and Wine in the cafeteria and thickness are just 10 minutes after and it was it was without words coordinated fight because it served each one of them absolutely thank you an anonymous
27:24 attendee asked does the quality and knowledge of individuals influence the choice of their selection for a ministerial posts or is the Coalition building done strictly by political consideration oh that's so good question ah I would like to tell you that uh you know the personal ability is the one that leads but unfortunately I think that in this um structure in this regime of parliamental democracy after all uh you know Netanyahu needs his partner to be stable and to be loyal so if the leader is providing the stability but will be a minister so Netanyahu catches you know reaches two uh two objectives he also gets the loyalty and he also it hurts the Rival political rival
28:28 because I remind you that at the elections the the hardest rival is the closest partner because after all you know you cannot bring you cannot take if you're right wing from somebody who is very very different from you from left you can take a voter from somebody who is very close to you so the closest Partners in the ideological the closest ideological partner he is the biggest political rival so yes if you know if and you know they say that you know I want to remind you that Arya Dairy sat in the jail for what for corruption and now we speak about nominating him to Minister of Finance he will not be apparently also because of the opinion of the legal adviser to the government who said that it's not possible I think they can fight it but apparently they don't go for it but I think that for Netanyahu to give him the
29:32 Finance Minister there's a perfect trick you know he Derry will be satisfied and loyal and everybody will shot on dairies the next time he will go down that's nothing else all right well thank you so much we've come to the close of our webinar and podcast Alex thank you so much for taking time to update us this week thank you and let's hope that tomorrow will have a stable government that will bring policies and bring Israel victory absolutely thank you for of course for our viewers and listeners we will not be having a webinar on Friday for those of you in the states I wish you a very Happy Thanksgiving thank you all for joining us and I hope you have a wonderful day