Webinar or Talk
The Abraham Accords: A View from the UAE with Najat Al Saied
Watch on YouTube
Description
How do Emiratis view the treaty with Israel? What has the UAE gained and what dangers does this step involve? how does this treaty differ from those of Jordan and Egypt with Israel?
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 10, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:00 all right hello and welcome to the middle east forum speaker webinar series i'm stacy roman and i will be moderating this discussion today we are pleased to have naja assayed independent researcher columnist and author join us to discuss the abraham accords a view from the uae dr acaid will speak for 15 minutes and open it up for questions should you wish to ask a question please use the q a box located at the bottom of your screen to type out your question and with that i'll turn the discussion over to ninja sae thank you so much uh stacey for this uh today i'm gonna be uh actually talking about uh three main points the first um the point how do imaratis view the treaty with israel and in general um um and the other and uh in general to answer this question how do emiratis view the treaty with israel in general they view uh the the treaty in a very positive way in general and this is due to uh to several reasons
1:01 one a lot of emiratis are proud that their country is a symbol and role model of peace and tolerance in the region a lot want to maintain this image to their country and they think that this peace treaty is a big proof for that so um emiratis think that their country they're so proud of their country and they want to maintain this this model and this image that their country is a model of peace and tolerance so they think by by by signing this peace treaty they are they are proving that their country is uh as a true model of peace and this is a number one reason number two reason the fact that this peace treaty was accomplished under the condition of stopping the annexation that also convinced a lot of emiratis so that means that their country is still working for the palestinian codes and this peace treaty is one of the main steps of the two-state solution so here they think their country is that that's why they are convinced their country is promoting the two-state
2:04 and uh there are a lot of things that happen but didn't reach up to a solution so why we don't try the peace also the third reason a lot of citizens think that the time has come to deal differently with the palestinian issue they think that the world has changed and they couldn't solve a complicated issue with the same way for decades tension and conflicts didn't solve anything so it is about time to try peace so the new generation now um is thinking out of the box they're saying our older generation was using the hard power and it didn't work out they cut the diplomatic relation they they even though they weren't involved in and direct war uh milita in a military uh in a military action but they were supporting it but all of these actions didn't work out so why wouldn't try them the soft power and one of the means of power is uh is diplomacy so uh so that's why they think that we have to think out of the park
3:06 after out of the box let us think of something peaceful and let us stay away from tension and conflict also um a lot of emiratis are also proud of their country's successful diplomacy and through the abraham uh and through the abraham accord this diplomacy succeeded in shedding light on the palestinian issue and proved that the emirati diplomacy is effective regionally and so a lot of a lot of immigrations are so proud of their countries of of their country and think that is really playing at their the country's diplomacy is really playing a vital role uh in in this piece of treaty so whether because they want to try another initiative because as i mentioned the hard power didn't work out so let us try now the diplomacy and they're proud that the emirati diplomacy started a new and this is not only a peace treaty this is a war and peace treaty and i will explain that later how this is a pos a p a warm piece
4:12 not only a cockpit peace like the others um the the fifth reason other immigrants think this peace treaty as it will bring peace uh harmony tolerance and co-existence it will bring economic development that will benefit everybody including the palestinian courts um so here we will have a valid uh outcome which is the economic and i will go through this economic development later on thirdly the the people are convinced one of the main reasons that that one of the main reasons that people are convinced about this peace treaty uh uae and most of arab gulf countries um mean in general they look up to their the the relationship is more like a kinship rather than a ruler citizen this is what this this is what distinguishes people of the arab gulf from the other arab countries so once the leaders agree upon certain decision most of the people agree because they trust the opinion of the leadership this is something even a lot of arabs couldn't understand they think that people in the gulf are
5:16 are like in harmony with their leaders because of fear it is not because of fear because of trust and loyalty and there's blood between them which means kinship and marriage between them so there's a huge trust um so here all of that didn't in fact in this kind of tolerance and peace that people see in the uae didn't come as a coincidence the marathi leadership recognizes in order to make the people open to peace and tolerance is one of the main reasons to make people open to to peace and tolerance is through education so emirati students are told peace and tolerance at school and this is different to in uh compared to many students in other arab countries you didn't see hostility you didn't see hatred in the in the in the textbooks and and educational curriculum uh which is quite different than many arab countries so the aim of sheikh mohammed bin zayed is to take back control of the educational ministry from the islamists who originally wrote the country's
6:18 textbook textbooks so in the beginning the country was based uh and the islamists wrote the educational textbooks and merely the curriculum so now it is shifting from from the islamist control in the educational system to more liberal and educational officials so the current curriculum is road map for the young emiratis towards moderation respect for the other uh peacemaking and tolerance so that's why when the peace treaty came you don't see a lot of people back but firing or against it because they're told peace and tolerance and co-existent and as cool since early this is the first curriculum in the region to separate moral education from religious education so mostly morals are taught in in most of the arab countries through through religion and through religious curriculum but in the here in the uee you have a different version that you have moral education which is
7:21 separate from the religious education the curriculum that's moral education is has a curriculum and this curriculum contains four units uh character and morality the individual and community cultural studies and civic studies so the main reason for promoting peace tolerance and that that even happened before many many years before before the peace treaty that took place recently because the uae population is actually 9.2 million of which 1. 1.4 million uh our emirati are local emiratis the rest are expats so in order for the locals to live peacefully and in harmony with the expats who are coming from different races from different religions the you ha they the the locals and the minorities have to have to be taught a lot a lot of principles about tolerance peace and co-existence so no conflicts will happen
8:21 so that was the initial idea about teaching peace and tolerance in the educational system adding to that with all this curriculum of peace and um there are new textbooks being taught just two weeks after the peace agreement um the peace agreement so after the peace agreement has been announced there are even textbooks that are taught to uh to the students uh for example uee 2020 islamic studies uh praises peace initiative with israel the bolsters the initiative by stating corporation and peace are fundamental islamic values and uae national characteristics a uh social studies textbook mentions judaism as belonging in the arab region so adding to what have been told before there are more uh textbooks that are taught now to the students to accept this piece of treaty so all of that hard work is actually and that would distinguish it from other
9:23 peace treaty that happened that's why we see it more people to people peace rather only government to government peace so but you see this excitement about this peace treaty among honestly among the younger generation even much more than the older generation based on all of these uh factors mainly the educational curriculum and um and the percentage of the young population especially the ones under 25 in uae four percent cent the big age majority in the uae is from 25 to 54 which is 65.9 percent so mainly you can see you can say that the population is uh more composed of younger of younger generation more than the older generation so most of the population is young actually so this is uh this is the fir the first uh the first uh um thing that i'm gonna be this that i discussed how do imaratis view the the treaty with israelis so this is just giving giving you a general view about how the israeli
10:25 um viewing the the peace uh the second question was what what has the uae gained and what dangers does this tip uh involve um um honestly i i see um i see that the uae um has gained the through this piece of treaty and i don't see any danger that is coming out of this peace treaty i see it as win-win situation everybody is winning through this piece of treaty so the uae has gained and also the israel israel has gained also but the main uh the main thing that uae has gained from is uh is mainly strategic and economic so there are many strategic objectives have been gained through this piece of treaty first of all as i mentioned before the agreement represents abu dhabi's willingness to take a leading regional role and build on its existence and on
11:27 on its existing international prestige as a country of tolerance and moderation and seeking to establish itself as a model for the arab world the uae has taken on a more assertive role that further enhances its regional position as a progressive actor so we here we the uae wants to represent itself as a role model for peace and and also as a progressive actor it's actually not promoting something that doesn't exist when you come and visit the uae you actually see the tolerance you see the peace among the different races the different religions and also after the collapse of the arab and mainly the ideologies of the arab traditional powers which is mainly arab nationalism arab gulf countries and on the top of it and then on the top of them as the uae wouldn't um want to promote something different to the region
12:28 okay you you you as arab traditional powers gave you know uh promoted this um these arab ideologies and mainly arab but it guided to nothing on the contrary it guided to uh chaos and to and to uh even it didn't help the palestinians at so um and and um and those representative of the of the of the arab nationalism which are merely egypt syria and iraq actually didn't gain from it so now the turn comes to those younger countries which are represented by the arab gulf countries and mainly uae so now we want to promote to the arab region something different which is political pragmatism okay we don't go for ideologies we don't go by slogans and and uh trying to uh to uh to accumulate the arab world with anger with hostility we want to give action and actually something that that is done um
13:32 so far that this conflict has lasted for more than 72 years and nothing has been done now we want to actually do action and do things and that this is one of the main strategic objectives promoting to the region something different that has that has been given uh for you know since uh since the the 60s until now secondly there are geopolitical priorities for those arab gulf states that signed the abraham israel is aligned with these priorities in terms of their opposition to the iranian regime and political islam in general and the muslim brotherhood in particular they have these enemies in common more than they have opposition in relation to their views on police on palestinian aspirations so after the collapse of the uh arab nationalism in the arab world there's something called the islamism in the in the in the region that expanded uh from the early from the late 60s until until the more through the iranian revolution
14:37 because uh when he came here he wants to the the islamic shiatsu revolution to the whole region and then accordingly another another ideology came from the arab peninsula which is called the the dawah movement to counterpart or to combat this movement in iran so this so accordingly extremism has expanded in the region and spreading the region and moved from modernization that was in the that was in the under the uh the constitutional monarchies in the early 40s and 50s until they shifted gradually until they became like that until extremism spread in the whole region so now they want the the the region was exploded with political islam which is basically different than islam which is because it is uh taking islam as an ideology so here both the arab gulf countries and israel are aligned with the with the same with the same concept to
15:38 to confront the these kind of radical islamists and the third and thirdly what exploded this whole expansion of islamism it's what is called the arab spring so a lot of arab countries were controlled and were dominated by uh by by those muslim brotherhood and and uh and also and other states turned to be failed the states unfortunately and uh and the two and what added to that even well more the 2000 fl the 2017 diplomatic crypt that isolated qatar sea partners do its support for the muslim brotherhood and other extremist groups and lately its alliance with the iranian regime and erdogan turkey this uh all of these factors have contributed to a growing perception of israel as a strategic ally in the in a wider region so this this is kind of another strategic objective for the uae uh to make this piece of treaty and
16:40 also for israel fourthly the the need for the arab gov states to have israel as an ally has never been uh greater due to to both parts peace in the us and the u.s calling for from the middle east this shift of u.s away from the region has prompted the uae to step into peace process rather than waiting until the us leaves the region or reduces its presence so a lot of members from both parties the democrats and the republicans are calling to shift away from the middle east region so so here i'm not saying a complete shift it might not be a complete shift from the middle east uh due to a lot of interest but maybe it won't be the first priority maybe the middle east will be the third priority after china and russia so here the arab gulf photo that they need that they need an ally in the region to fill this uh after the u.s withdrawal or it reduces its presence in the region
17:42 fifthly the uae the uae approach and this presence treaty has been uh to expose those in the region who want to manipulate the israel-palestinian dispute to to benefit their own agendas for turkey and specifically its ambitious populist leader erdogan has so to exploit palestinian grievance to expand their hegemony and influence in the region so there are a lot of uh a lot of things are you know um um this this this uh everlasting conflict in the region the palestinian israeli conflict a lot a lot in the region especially those uh islamist opportunities and even some arab nationalists took advantage of it so everyone wants to increase his hegemony and dominance in the region uh he are trying to call the and to be a hero and to liberate palestine so here by doing this peace treaty the uae wants to cut this dispute like as if it's saying enough is enough enough take trading off with this issue enough those who want to to
18:44 rip off the region under the name of palestine who want to expand and and to dominate the region under the name of palestine we want to do a true peace we don't want to take advantage of this issue we want to solve this issue so this is one of the strategic objectives to put an end to those who are taking advantage of this of this conflict this is this this is a summary of the objectives i'm gonna highlight quickly the economic objective the abraham accord list 16 areas of israeli uae collaboration including health science technology cyber security environment agriculture and water and food security as well as more strictly commercial areas as such as civil aviation tourism and energy economic impact at the ministry of economy estimates that the normalization ties between israel and the uae could lead to as much as 500 million dollars in bilateral trade and
19:49 some might say this these kind of business deals have been done before uh with other peace treaties anyways it didn't go to that far extents uh number one number two the main thing is not only the value business but also the value of attitude and basic principles in which countries and business people uh promote their economies so for example these these attitudes that i'm talking about is like uh respect politeness honesty and openness and not only among the government the governments but also among the people something that i see here in the uae that i didn't see and the other peace treaties this kind of politeness openness warmth even in dealing with business so here we're not talking about uh only materialistic business deals but the type of attitude and dealing with that with the business deals um the third uh the third question that i'm gonna be talking about also uh how does this treaty differ from
20:53 those uh of jordan and egypt with israel i already these uh these matters but i'm gonna be focusing more here the uae and its the relation with israel is completely different from other arab cases as egypt and jordan not only because the immigration did not engage in a direct military conflict with but beca but also mainly the emirati case relates to its particular traits of the uae which are mainly distinguished in its experience and its development and modernization model the uae has ambitious development plans and global competitive aspiration embodied by the uae vision and the uae uh italian skill strategy 2071 which are promising that have specific precise goals and existing and executive action programs that ensure that the achievement of these goals in a timely manner its expertise and progress and various
21:55 fields and here israel cannot be excluded from this equation especially in light of the israeli super superiority in certain industrial and technical fields and sectors so it seemed difficult to access and on this technology with without cooperating with israeli experts and and companies so here the uae is a country with a vision and it has a direct vision which is division of 2021 and it has a strategic vision which is the 2071. so it's a strong relationship with all the progressive countries and you couldn't exclude israel out of these progressive this is one one main factor and that will distinguish it from other arab countries there and actually they're not forced to this to do this treaty but because it is part of the uh this is number one number two therefore the path of normalization between the uae and israel takes an exaggerated practical nature and here i'm gonna highlight the word
22:57 practical nature since the first days of the signing of the agreement is established in relation between the two sides which were linked to different officials official cooperation through agreements between the uae companies and sectors of their israeli counterpart which did not happen in other arab cases because the uae has goals the uae has clear strategic interests and this and therefore it is not in its interest to keep the agreement on paper or to leave it in a box of cold peace so that what what derive actually jordan and ed and egypt for the peace is basically political matters and especially there were conflicts between israel and these here what is deriving the the the uae is basically vice versa it's not political it's economic for peace through economy it's not the other way around it's not because um is we can go we can make peace
23:58 through in a true economy and through uh and through and and uh and the and the benefit of this economy can reach to everybody including the so that's what makes a difference so it is not for them it's it's so that's why it's not for the interests to keep this this piece of treaty called they because they want it to be successful and they want it to be warm and they want to distinguish it from other peace that's why it is more people to people and these kind of businesses is not like the egyptians and the jordanians only among governments even the individuals and individual companies and the government is open about it but if for example can an egyptian businessman do a bit of and invest in israel that can never happen but it can happen in the uae and it will happen even soon if it if without the covet 19 uh it could have happened as soon as they signed the peace treaty adding think
24:59 adding to that the openness and acceptance that i i explained before of the imminent society to others and the rooted culture of co-existence among the immigration people who have inhabited this culture since the establishment of the the the union state and the participants of hundreds of thousands of expat workers where emirati citizens deal daily with more foreigners than even locals all of these help with to make this piece 381 the population of the uae belongs to more than 200 nationalities east and and of different races and religions and this also explains this great positive responses to the relation with israel so here we see people uh we have hundreds of millions of people who are coming from different races from different religions we have uh we have churches we have even now uh uh now even uh the abrahamic house is open in 2022 and that will include include church synagogue and mosque all
26:02 so people can see people and there are even temples of hindus in the in the in the country so people are exposed to different religions are exposed to different races so this is truly what wasn't truly a shock that shock because because that the people are are are used to these things one of and one of the main points also i um explained before but i'm going to highlight it here there's absolute absolute popular confidence in the political leaders and their decision emiratis look up to their leaders due to their accumulation of expertise people see their country's tremendous prosperity and development in all areas in all areas of life which places the uae and ranks of the most countries in various development indicators so here the people trust their leaders they say if they if they keep up the country and you know that they develop the country to that extent of development of prosperity and and and we are living in harmony and people are
27:06 living lavishly so why i don't trust them and this peace treaty and uh and this is also another big difference um there's there's you don't see this trust between the people and the leaders here in the country and even in other other countries compared to the other countries they're always kind of suspicious relationship if you compare them to the arab gulf this established relationship between the leadership and the people is in the fact that there is a strong bond and solid loyalty therefore the emirati the emergency strong please support normalization with israel as a strategic choice for the state there are many actually already that that distinguish it from other other countries and distinguish it as a warm piece first of all after after the sign of the suspicious treaty we saw the israeli ashen plate and the khalifa tower this is something that has never been done in any other arab countries that signed the peace the peace treaty uh you see even
28:09 catering is now available in many and airlines in the uae the celebration of the jewish new year and many immigration newspapers you see headlines with shana tova celebrator hashanah and even sheikh abdullah bin zayed tweeted about the jewish new year also emirati's artists were playing their israeli national anthem this is also something that we have never seen in egypt or jordan on the country of all the egyptian movies and drama that spread hateful messages against israel even after signing the camp david accords back in after the abraham accord and agreement has been announced between abu dhabi film commission and israel confront to promote tolerance peace and culture understanding between the imaratis and israelis this is also something that we haven't seen in the other arab countries on the country we saw a peace treaty signed and we saw hateful messages through the drama through the until this moment we are seeing egyptian
29:11 movies that are promoting hostility and hatred against israel and here since the signature of this abraham they are even merging together in this industry together at uae and israel together to promote peace and cultural understanding so this is another important thing that distinguishes the uae israel business council was also established immediately after the peace treaty has um a lot of businessmen and public sectors leaders from the uae and israel helped to foster shared opportunities economic cooperation and partnership between emiratis and israelis i'm here not talking about i'm talking about the public uh business uh the individual business man uh collaborating with israeli businessmen together it had more and this and the website of the israeli business council has more than 2 000 members sign up for the uae israeli business since since uh less than 40 45 days from its
30:14 uh form its launch so there were more than 2 000 members and the portal of uh and less 45 days from its lounge the uae also uh israeli the israeli policy forum was also established to bring researcher researchers academic and scholars from both countries together this is something that we so even we there are even whatsapp groups uh implemented together and the design together to bring researchers israeli researchers with the uae researchers and even with other arab gulf countries researchers also there's something important that has been established with which is the gulf israel women form so that was established last the jerusalem deputy deputy deputy with the jewish women's business network has started the gulf wellness forum that unite both uh imarati women business businesswoman with israeli businesswoman um also a top israeli singer joining
31:17 jews in dubai to celebrate the simsa torah holiday this is something also something new that we haven't seen um i will honestly want to wrap it uh quickly stacy i can see you that i you want me to wrap it up i will just highlight something very important at the end um you know i'm really optimistic about this peace treaty i don't see any negative between it because i ca because i know both israelis and and emiratis and i can see the warmth between them the only thing that i'm really worried about i'm so worried about is the media the leftists and liberal media in the us and the other western countries because they were they were undermining this peace treaty and they were about it i don't know why maybe one of the reasons because it was done under trump administration and uh maybe because also and i see that also from the lift yes israeli media okay okay maybe because they are also under netanyahu some of them are against the peace treaty not because they are against peace with
32:18 arabs but because they are against netanyahu so here comes this is the here comes the political interests of each party more than the uh expanding the peace uh and just ability in the region this is so dangerous why it is dangerous because even though i told you about all those positive positive points but we are still in the in the beginning since we are in the beginning stage we want to build the trust between the two nations you couldn't shake the nation by by these kind of uh of negative media by either like undermining the peace or attacking the uae government because that will shaken the imarati people because here we need to build the trust the other thing you are giving a gift to an a silver plate to the radical islamists because they are against this peace and when they see this media as against this treaty they will say we told you we told you we are against especially there's arab media supporting the islamists mainly al-jazeera arabic
33:20 so here we are giving them a good weapon to uh to fight us we are the p we want we are pro-peace so this is the main thing that i'm really worried about because it can pay really play a negative role and that's what i'm worried about thank you thank you so much all right thank you so much najet we learned so unfortunately we didn't get to the questions from our viewers but i think you covered quite a few of the topics that were asked um thank you again so much for taking time to speak with us today for our viewers please be on the lookout for our weekly webinar offerings email coming out over the weekend thank you all for joining us and i hope you have a wonderful day thanks again have a go thanks are there questions or not uh unfortunately it's only a half hour format so we've ran out of time okay okay thanks thanks thank you okay