MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Israel Insider

Israel Insider

Watch Israel Insider on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

If no budget is passed within two weeks, Israel’s government is automatically dissolved and another round of elections takes place. Is this government doomed or can the coalition partners muddle through?

Transcript Automatic captions

Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 12, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.

0:02 hello and welcome to the middle east forums webinar series israel insider with mr ashley perry i'm stacy roman and i will be moderating this discussion today we're pleased to add mr ashley perry adviser to the middle east forum's israel office join us here each wednesday at 3 pm eastern to update us on all the events going on in israel mr prairie will be giving us a briefing on korean israeli affairs for 10 to 15 then open it up for questions should you wish to ask a question please use the q a box located at the bottom of your screen we will do our best to get to all questions but we have many participants on this webinar so i apologize in advance if we do not get to yours today and now with no further ado i will turn the discussion over to mr ashley ferry hi thank you good evening from israel it's been a few weeks since we last did this so there's a lot to catch up on and rather than focusing one issue tonight i thought i'd just go through a few different issues facing israel challenges over the last few weeks especially in

1:04 the last few days and then open it up to your questions to wherever you want to focus on so let's start on our northern border in i think it was eight days ago now that really captured the international the explosion in lebanon in beirut that had a massive obviously effect in lebanon but it also had an effect in israel up until that moment there was a lot of tension on the northern border israel and hezbollah there was a small uh hezbollah unit across the border which was repelled by the israeli army it was ostensibly to retaliate for the army one of hezbollah accused the israeli army of taking out one of their senior militants in syria and hassan nasrallah the leader of hezbollah had long said that we will retaliate um it's a big question mark whether that was the retaliation they've they've said it they even claimed that the event did not happen uh or at least not in the way that the israelis were saying that

2:05 uh no lebanese person across the board and the israelis just opened fire and some people the other side of the fence um but there was a subsequent to that the israeli mobile the israeli army mobilized on the northern border brought in a lot of troops because they really did expect uh in the days after that especially leading up to the muslim holiday they they did expect some sort of response and then the beirut blast happened and hezbollah basically um obviously their attention was elsewhere and the country's attention is elsewhere i believe tomorrow or friday is going to give a big speech on the anniversary of the last lebanon uh war lebanon ii uh so i'm sure we'll hear a lot more from him then but basically hezbollah that there are two schools of thought about it probably the most likely is hezbollah cannot launch an attack against this right now at least not a concerted attack because you know they're facing a lot of internal

3:08 tensions a lot of people in lebanon uh them for the blast blame them for what was even happening before they were demonstrations because of the economic uh in lebanon and hezbollah as one of the powers in the government along with the christian allies were certainly uh blamed for a lot of the problems there were regular demonstrations bullies would come in and even beat up some of the demonstrators so already the popularity was low and perhaps one of the reasons why they were looking to start a fight with israel usually when there's tension against hezbollah and lebanon sometimes they look to relieve that by you know sort of trying to face off against this or to show this is why we're around this is why you need us um there is that school of thought that perhaps because it's weakened it's going to again use that excuse but probably now there's too much focus for them really to use that um you know there's all talks of some sort of under underground network and whether it was materials that were being used in the

4:14 future attack on israel that was actually exploded in the bay report so there's a lot of certainly a lot of fizzbile are under a lot of pressure to answer these questions so i think at this point in time probably they're going to be more internally faced not to say that they will ignore israel and perhaps if there is an opportunity they will use it but at the moment they're probably too internally focused uh to really launch a concerted effort against israel although they still retain at least uh verbally uh that right to what they claim retaliate for the for the killing of their um higher up uh in syria on the southern border with gaza things have also been heating up basically over the last few days dozens every single day dozens of incendiary devices attached to balloons usually balloons that look like things that kids would want to get with pictures of mickey mouse or cartoon characters what they do is they blow up uh helium balloons and then attach an incentury device to it and float it across the border in the hope

5:17 that some child will grab it or fall into a playground but what it's most like what it's been doing over the last few days is basically causing massive fires in the south of israel um we we are going through a particularly arid uh part of the parts of the calendar it's very hot so anytime something like this lands it can set off a fire which really does cause massive massive fires yesterday there were 70 fires that uh that the authorities had to put out to today there was only 24 but they say because we've got a little bit better about shooting some down and for some other reasons but certainly this is a big worry uh for israel because you know it could it can certainly heat things up people can die you know there's a lot of money which is lost there's a lot of produce which has lost animals etc etc israel has responded uh by taking out uh hamas installations nothing too uh it did just uh limit guards and fishermen that's what usually they do is

6:20 girls and fishermen have a certain limit which they can go out into the waters to fish etc and they need to send a message they usually limit them so they've done that but there's a lot of focus what's going on in the south at the moment there is this idea that hamas certainly are in a bit of financial trouble and again we hear about qatar with their suitcases of money being brought in some in israel call it protection money the fact that we allow qatar to give hamas and gaza which is basically run by hamas millions and millions of dollars for and usually when they're causing troubles is usually just to make sure that israel allowed they said and then reports yesterday that again mossad had uh held meetings with qataris or maybe interlocutors through the qataris to basically give the green light but this protection money for this money to come into uh to gaza for hamas in exchange for a quieting down of the situation

7:22 there have been a few shootings across the border even the rocket attacks a couple of weeks back so that board is something that uh always has to be look looked after speaking which our defense minister overnight went through an operation uh for what's believed to be a slip disc uh so he was out of commission for a day but apparently in the last hour or so he has informed the cabinet secretary that he is able to fulfill his duties even from his uh hospital bed where he's recovering at the moment um so that's that's that situation the political situation is the one that everybody's kind of keeping their eye on uh because you know the big question is are we going to elections i would say we certainly are whether we're going to elections in november december or early next year you know that just has to be worked out at the the two major parties liquid and blue and white it's just mutual recriminations one between the other that there isn't a day which goes past one accuses this of that or whatever but basically we have now 13 days

8:27 to either pass a budget in which if the budget is not passed the the national annual budget if it's not passed immediately we go towards elections now there is a a way to uh to sort of stop that and that is there's a small sort of satellite party of blue and white benny against his party called daryl harris which is speaker hausa and us hendell who basically put up a law which uh puts off having to pass the budget by a hundred days this was put up before the knesset for the first reading today it passed and so people were sort of breathing in a little bit a sigh of relief but the fact remains that they could have said that we will not allow it to pass the second or third readings unless uh we get something from blue and white in return the big argument ostensibly above the sort of uh you know openly is about the budget we've talked about this in the past blue and white want to maintain what was agreed in the coalition agreement to have a two-year budget or i should

9:30 say one year in three months because any budget that's passed now is just till the end of the year they could just want to have a budget now now there is there are economic arguments for both probably most economists would uh side with blue and white and they do but what's going on far beyond that is the liquid is not just seeking or flexing his muscles about the budget it's probably that's largely an excuse what they want is to ensure that under any deal and remarkably the coalition agreement is being opened up months after it was signed sealed and delivered um and basically they could want more assurances that when uh prime minister netanyahu uh prime minister netanyahu hands over his office to betty ganz who's the ultimate prime minister next year if the supreme court uh supreme court disallows netanyahu to hold the position of alternate prime minister and maybe another minister because someone according to israeli law someone who is under such serious

10:33 indictments cannot serve as minister prime minister there was a ruling which says he's allowed to but the moment that he no longer becomes the prime minister there is a worry that the supreme court will disbar him from holding any other office so they want to open that back up and they want to open another few but basically mostly to do with netanyahu's legal woes but trying to frame it as a as an economic issue as something to do with the coronavirus and there's a need to push forward with these things but the fact is for a government that was supposed to focus just on coronavirus and its attendant economic issues they've been certainly focused on so many other different and the coronavirus certainly came back to israel in the second wave although things have stabilized a little bit and are starting to go down but the big question is is what's going to happen in the next couple of weeks tomorrow there is a or there was a discussion today and will carry on tomorrow about whether israelis will now be able to travel for the first time abroad and

11:36 maybe even some uh foreigners allowed into israel because up until this point only israelis have been allowed into israel with certain exceptions but tomorrow they're going to release a list of countries green countries which you'll be able to to and from without having to isolate for 14 days when you return um there's also you know in in three weeks we'll our kids will be back in school whether that's going to happen or not uh that's a big question uh question mark because the numbers are still pretty high there is talk of lockdown another lockdown but at the moment the coronavirus coordinator the corona uh ronnie gamsu is someone who's very much against uh lockdowns is trying to prevent it there's a lot of pressure on for when then the government to call for a lockdown at the moment he is resisting it he said this is the last tool that we should use and they're trying to do all sorts of things to try and prevent another lockdown his claim is that if there's another lockdown another half a million israelis will become unemployed and obviously that is

12:40 a massive problem for the economy to try and get people back into work rather put more people out of work so it's certainly something that we'll be watching over the coming with that i'm happy to open up the all right well first off welcome back our viewers certainly missed you um so the first one is are the demonstrations and outrage and bearish spreading to the rest of lebanon and how is tesla weathering the storm i know you talked about the popularity going down but aside from that well i mean my personal belief again i'm not a security expert i'm not an expert in lebanon but i think hezbollah will weather it just because they do have you know the way lebanese politics works is there's four different communities and they each have the shiite community has which is largely not totally largely uh loyal to hezbollah and some of its satellite organizations um so there's a there's a very strong power base there

13:43 and iran is obviously playing a role here and hezbollah as many terrorist organizations do these days they certainly have a social welfare part to what they do as well as a political and a military arm they have a social welfare and there are many many lebanese people who are dependent on hezbollah they have their own hospitals they have their own sort of social welfare system etc etc so i think it's a little bit too um ground in uh for it to really be threatened certainly there is a lot of anger and it probably has to take a step backwards and talk the right language at this point but it's still the power broker uh in lebanon things could change but again it's a country which is very split ethnically religiously um and hezbollah is you know it it sees to a population which is just growing the shiite population whereas other communities that the christian community and the jews community is largely shrinking so i don't see hezbollah as being

14:46 completely threatened but there's certainly a lot more anger on the streets around lebanon you can see that with the demonstrations even before the blast of the where hezbollah was certainly a target for the demonstrators now it's been heightened we did see an of hassan nasrallah with the noose around his neck and effigy um just shows this sort of uh the the but again they still have a very very strong base and i don't think they're about to lose that anytime soon thank you so for the balloons coming in one is um where is the helium coming the uh the border is sealed pretty well all this stuff is getting checked and um is there any sort of technical or military solution well he i don't know exactly how they're getting the helium i don't know how you create helium maybe there's a way you can create it locally um there was a lot of there's been a lot of

15:48 discussions over the uh years about dual items uh perhaps helium is one of them perhaps it can be used for many other different things maybe medical and which israel will not stop i i just don't know about enough about the compound itself to speculate on that as far as our israel's there is a new system uh a laser system which can shoot it down but you can imagine first of all it's quite a long border with uh with gaza so it'd be very very difficult to have this laser system all the way through and again a system to take down a few basic balloons with some incendiary device again it's it's something which israel has to deal with but you can imagine the cost and the of the system uh to deal with something relatively basic and the question is if we stop the balloons what's the next thing you know the hamas are pretty innovative they come up with new responses and they play on the fact that we are you know very a very high-tech nation we

16:50 come up with innovations and inventions but these are cost of millions tens of millions hundreds of millions of dollars maybe even billions in the in the case of uh iron dome and hamas it's rockets it's balloons etc etc cost i mean how much does it cost for a couple of balloons a bit of helium and a century device probably a few tens of so it's a very very difficult uh threat to face it's not the most lethal threat i don't think there's been anyone anyone who has died from these balloons or i think there have been some children were injured earlier on now today most in the border area whether it's steroids or other towns and keyboards in there have been taught not to touch balloons in fact you know even even in other parts of the country because they do if the wind is right they can actually float quite far kids around the country now know if you see balloons in the air you don't uh you don't touch them um so it is a threat and it's something

17:52 that israel has to deal with but as you can imagine it's a very very difficult uh challenge to deal with because of its low-tech nature thank you for that um so biden recently uh said his choice for vice president and what is the reaction from israel on well she's she's relatively well known in israel and i think from an israeli point of view again i'm not going to talk about domestic politics or get it weighed into the whole elections in america but from an israel point of view she is a known quantity she is someone who's seen as a centrist uh on the democratic side someone who you know come out against bds someone who sees the israel u.s relationship importantly again not to say everything is perfect and not to say that you know nothing that she's ever done is something to be concerned about but when we look at the possible pics and some of those on the

18:53 far left of the democratic party who are fans of bds or at least won't condemn it and have even called for aids to israel to be sort of contingent on israel's behavior certainly uh kamala harris is someone that let's just say we you know it is is relatively good pick from our point of view that's good to know thank you um along those lines i know that we've already talked about this for but for our viewers just joining in uh should biden win in november and netanyahu remain in power what type of relationship can be expected between the two leaders well they know each other biden has been and has been coming to israel being involved in issues whether it's in the senate or whatever for many many years there's nothing unknown there um i think there's an expectation it won't be a return to the obama era distance between the countries but it certainly won't be as close as it has

19:54 been under president trump um i'm not sure there'll be any great bold moves will they return the embassy to tel aviv i think it's unlikely now that it's in jerusalem would he have moved it to a potential president biden no but once it's there i think it may well be a fatal complete uh there certainly won't be that friendliness uh that closeness that has the trump administration of the netanyahu administration um but it certainly won't be a something like a bernie sanders or or something like that um so i think you we'll sort of there'll be a certain reset but it certainly will be the the the dah won't be moved back to the obama era or something further than um and netanyahu and biden know each and you know there were certainly rocky moments in the relationship when he was vice president to president obama um but i i think they know each other well enough and uh you know joe biden it's a i believe he is a friend of

20:56 israel again is he as friendly as as we may like that's certainly a question but i think he's a friend of israel and i don't think that you know it will be an unknown sort of force for us here in israel thank you so with the coronavirus how many israeli jobs have disappeared do you think it will take long to reintegrate these workers well no jobs are ever gone forever uh but there was a report put out recently that said it could well be into 2022 before we get back to our single-digit unemployment um or at least maybe not single even to a pre-corona virus level i think uh if i'm not much mistaken uh unemployment was around four percent before coronavirus uh then it's up to 20 so to get back to four percent we're talking about it could be a year and a half two years and that may be true by the way of other countries um but it all depends how many more waves there are how many how much lockdown restrictions etc there are that's all

21:59 depend obviously they say you know i read various reports which uh talked about the constriction of our gdp and again everything is dependent on how many more waves there are when a vaccine or something that will constrict the chronovirus will be ready but the worst case scenario is that unemployment will just grow as i said before the new coronavirus coordinate national coordinator ronnie gamsu said if there's another lockdown it could lead to at least another half a million israelis and at a time where there's already 800 plus israelis maybe close to a million or an unpaid leave another half a million to the uh the ranks of the unemployed will be a massive massive blow to the israeli economy and the livelihood of so many israelis who are on these people for jobs and pay and etc speaking of a lot of it comes from tourists um can you expand a little more you were talking about how they're

23:01 voting on whether or not to let other countries in and israelis to travel abroad well israel certainly um you know makes a lot of money from tourism as you can imagine and we've been breaking figures every single year for many many years you know more tourists are coming in our hotels generally full throughout the year obviously coronavirus basically stopped that completely there have been no tourists whatsoever external tourists since march when they closed the borders to non-israeli citizens now for the first time they are talking about having some countries the problem is even if we call a country green they may not uh reciprocate so someone who comes let's say from greece uh when they go back to greece maybe they'll have to isolate for 14 days so it has to be a sort of reciprocal process you know even if israel doesn't make someone who's coming in isolate for 14 days which is currently the case many countries will look at israel's

24:03 morbidity rate and think you know these are not people that we want coming straight in and then mingling with our population um and we're i don't think we're on anyone's green list there was talk the other day in the knesset where the head of the coronavirus committee said there's only four countries at the moment that will allow israelis in i think that was uh overstating a little bit but certainly very few countries are letting israelis in so there's a lot of work being done as we speak uh the foreign ministry is reaching out to all sorts of countries especially in the eu greece the greek foreign minister is expected tomorrow and we're trying to put a lot of pressure and lobby a lot of different nations to try and them to let israelis in for them to come to visit israel so hopefully they're talking about four o'clock tomorrow they're going to release this list of which countries are considered green from israel but again that doesn't necessarily mean that uh bengali airport is gonna be open you know for thousands of people again uh that will take quite a while uh to get back to those pre-korean virus

25:08 understand so with israel being shut down and not allowing people in do you foresee a rise in aliyah and if so how do how does the country plan to have the infrastructure to absorb them well there is massive uh there's there's general talk about uh an uptick in a surge in ali especially earlier on there were talked of five to six seven times the amount of inquiries for aliyah why do we see still even during corona virus there is still aliyah i i know actually people who are making early on the first thing they do is 14 days of isolation but people are still prepared to do it i believe that there will be a peak in aliyah in the next couple of years they're talking about even potentially hundreds of thousands of jews coming uh coming to to israel to make aliyah so there's a lot of talk in the khmer said there are certain budgets being distributed to try and entice this and also to allow for greater absorption because israel gives a a very generous

26:14 to immigrants to israel to absorb them to allow them to have a future so secure future etc etc it's something which has been discussed at the moment and um the uh alia uh the immigrant the immigrant absorption minister certainly fighting for uh greater budgets and she's the new one is pretty well liked and uh the jewish agency together with her are really preparing for a great surgeon ali over the next couple of years thank you how is gaza done so far with the regard to the covid is there relative isolation yes largely there there hasn't been that many cases largely because there aren't so many places guardians can go egypt tony just reopened their border and obviously the border with israel is only open for exceptional circumstances and very few people travel

27:17 through it some journalists some aid workers etc etc so as you can imagine there are very very few cases uh in gaza and the west bank there's a lot more and the palestinian authorities certainly also taken relatively draconian steps to try and stem that flow by shutting down whole villages and at times to try and stem that flow um but again we're not talking about massive massive amounts um but according to the percentage of the population they certainly still see a worry in it and because the israeli and the west bank popular west bank palestinian populations are relatively um there is still that threat from either community to spread it to the so with the elections do you think that netanyahu will be making those concessions to get the budget extension passed well it's actually the concessions are from the other side uh netanyahu's asking for the concessions i believe he'll get some of them

28:20 one of them is that in the according to coalition agreement there'll be a professional body that will choose future supreme court justices or not supreme court but high level uh picks in the judicial moving it away from a politically oriented uh netanyahu and the liquid are seeking to return to that i think that's going to be a sticking point some of the things i think they may well compromise on but blue and white ran on having a more professional a separation between the judiciary judiciary and the political level so to suddenly go back on that i think that'll be probably one of the most difficult things for them to do it just depends how much liquids are willing to give up on their side there are a lot of commentators uh probably most of the commentators in israel who said that netanyahu has already decided to go to elections one way or another and it's just a matter of trying to put blue and white into a corner so that they don't look like they're taking the blame at the moment the uh in a large majority blame netanyahu

29:24 if there will be uh elections i think by two to one over gantz at this point um so it's certainly something that netanyahu should keep in mind that he you know again according to these commentators that he does want to go to but he doesn't want to be seen as the person going to elections so that's the kind of uh the fight at the moment all right well unfortunately we've come to the close of our webinar thank you again for taking the time to update us this week on friday at 5 1 pm eastern we'll have sam westrock here discussing more trouble for islamic relief please be sure to join us for that and thank you all again for joining us and i hope you have a wonderful day thank you glad you're back