Israel Insider
, Israel Insider with Alex Selsky
Watch on YouTube
Description
Israel has a budget. Now, judicial reform returns and will likely dominate the public agenda, along with the cost of living and taxpayer subsidies to the Haredim. How will the government navigate these issues?
Alex Selsky is a senior adviser to MEF's Israel Victory Project, and lecturer at Hadassah Academic College. Formerly, he served as advisor to Prime Minister Netanyahu and as CEO of the International Israel Beytenu Movement. He holds a BA in Business and Executive MA in Public Policy from Hebrew University.
#MEFWebinars
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 29, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:07 and welcome to the Middle East forums webinar and podcast Israel Insider this week with Alex selski I'm Stacy Roman and I will be moderating this discussion today we're pleased to have Alex selsky senior advisor to the Middle East forum's Israel Victory project and lecture at Hadassah academic College join us this week to update us on all the events going on in Israel Mr selsky will be giving us a briefing on current Israeli Affairs for 15 minutes and open it up for questions should you wish to ask a question please use the Q a box located at the bottom of your screen to type your question and with that I will turn the discussion over to Mr Alex selski Stacy thank you very much and good evening from Jerusalem Israeli evening and afternoon at your time well Stacey as you said I will update about all the happening in Israel but it's impossible to update about it everything that happens in Israel definitely not in 15 minutes as you know in Israel we have so many news and so many things happening all the so we'll try to give you you know the
1:12 major things and there are definitely things that we have to update about so let me give you the previous chapters because we really need to you know to go a little about a month ago in order to understand what's happening this week so as you remember in April we all spoke about the fact that judicial reform is on hold and that at the moment that the knesset will be back they will put aside the reform and they were all concentrated in passing the budget and budget must be passed until the end of May otherwise government may just fall and the other thing that we all spoke about in April that Stephen Curry with all the things happening with the all the demonstrations and all the split within the Israeli society and all the attempts of our enemies around you know
2:17 around the area around the region to try us again thinking that they might and use this opportunity that something will happen so both things happened um we had the operation shield and arrow and the budget passed exactly last Wednesday so at the moment that both things happened what everybody accepted that would happen now the reform will be but surprise you know I live next to a knesset where all the demonstrations usually um come by through and I was expecting that this week you know from all the sides we'll have demonstrations those who want the reform back and those who want to postpone the reform but there is quiet so what's happening first of all there are many things that
3:23 bother Israelis after the budget and after the operations after the operation and the major thing that I think that every house and every family bills and speaks and manages itself to prepare to is the cost of living the rise of cost of living the and the price is just you know go up in every field except maybe here and there we see that because of the again the the Central Bank raised the interest rate so we see um that the prices of the housing are not going um higher because of that but we just said see the mortgages go up now the situation is very similar to what's happening in Europe and what's happening
4:25 in the states even a bit lower but I think that now these months and during the next months we'll see the inflation in Israel trying to catch up the inflation in the United States and in Europe because we hear almost from every industry from every Market that the prices will go and the government doesn't succeed to uh you know to lower this wave and this there is a very high and very big criticism on this budget that just passed that it's not really providing that it doesn't provide really the the expected tools uh to fight differentiate inflation to fight the prices and uh you know government tries to explain that it does but we just don't see it the interest rate now is in Israel and stands now on the 4.75 it's very close to the
5:30 interest rates of the Federal Reserve in the United States of 5.25 so uh a regular average mortgage raised in 1 000 shekels for average family which is a lot which is about 300 dollars this is a lot and people don't and houses of the prices of the housing again as I said you know a bit in stagnation but all the rest is going high and that's what definitely bothers people and other two things that happened this week that I think definitely worth because these are two two big things some of them might look not so big but I think that we will see their effects on Israeli society and Israeli politics and is really economy and differently on international
6:33 relations for a long period ahead the first thing is that the leader of the one of the biggest Community within the ultra Orthodox community the the Lithuanian Community lead [ __ ] as they call themselves died at age of 100 years old Gerson Edelstein who was born in the Soviet Union 100 years ago in Middle yard Caesar when he was a age of uh and 10 I think or 11.
7:16 and he was actually the last a leader that adds I think the influence that could Unite all the little community and everybody speaks about the fact that from now on it will be a new era of leadership and this community which is one of the again one of the two biggest communities uh within the ultra Orthodox communities that it will not be led in the united form and three rubbish will be leading uh the Retro community and it means that it will be much more concentrated much more competition we will see much more and I think it will affect the politics of the Orthodox community and definitely the you know the the way it will into the general con society and I think
8:21 it will cause more integration not less now the the lead Rock Community are those who are represented by movement which is one of the two parties that are united in the ultra order ducks Ashkenazi a list called the Judaism of the Torah the Judaism of the Torah are two parties as I said Israel and a and those who represent the the litva community and the Israel are those who represent the Hasidic primarily the Bells and I think it also might it will it affect this cooperation so let's see in the next elections how it will affects you know
9:26 the fact that there is much less concentrated leadership within regulator I think it's a major event a social and political event in Israel another event that I think also a very worth mentioning is that for the first time um the since Israel left Gaza and Northern shumran since the Israel approved formula approved that the Shiva in homish homish is a settlement between you know within the triangle of Janine Shem and turkai more closer to Shem in Northern not the most northern chumran but not in chumran and Samara Samara and
10:30 Hamish is one of the three settlers that were removed during the disengagement and now it's uh Yeshiva that was active in this settlement and homish is back but it moved from private Palestinian land to the state land with the approval of the army and with the approval of the defense minister we have the International Community definitely the Europeans and the White States in against it claiming that it's illegal that it's um against the law but first of all Israel passed the law that cancels the disengagement in the northern Samaria just a few months ago so in terms of the law within Israel it's all legal
11:35 okay it's an unstate land it's by a formal approval of the army that's I remind you that the Army the IDF is the body that controls Judea and Samaria and manages the life of Judah and so Mary the Palestinian and the Jewish as well and it's done by this law which cancels the disengagement but it the White House and the state departments claim that Israeli governments promised not to do that not revive these settlements in Northern Samaria so it's definitely by their claim is against these promises it doesn't help the sofa not so easy relationship between the current prime minister and the current White House we see that Netanyahu haven't been yet invited to the White House and we see that it's it's not on the horizon
12:39 even though we we heard that you know the White House said that if the judicial reform will be fully canceled then we definitely would see you know a warmer cooperation and invitation of the Prime Minister to come to Israel we don't see it so far so now that's the time to come back to where I started from and to speak about the judicial which first of all everybody is expecting to come back it doesn't come back and everybody asks okay what's what's the faith of the reform definitely from the angle of the relationship with the United States as I stated before definitely understanding that that's the next big crisis
13:41 political crisis understanding that it was put on hold for the budget and for everything else that the government had to pass in order to survive so what's not and here I think we must put pay attention to two things first is that a Netanyahu had a pull by which he definitely saw that the Israeli public prefers wide agreements on the judicial reform and if he now brings it back as by the way after exactly after the passing of the budget he was asked by a journalist so now everybody everybody is waiting for the reforms where is the reform will it be back and he said definitely will be you know fully back so apparently we see that Netanyahu really
14:45 keeps the track of the negotiations with the open with the opposition with the and the Presidents by the supervision of the president it's Herzog um let's see and and and and the sign of it is also the cooperation between the sides in a nomination of the knesset representative to the committee that that chooses the judges um and the second thing that we definitely must pay attention to is yesterday's speech yesterday's today's event speech of speaking about the reform and it was very hard speech a very emotional and you know the leading Israeli journalist the Amit
15:49 Seger called it a speech of frustration frustration speech and he said listen that's not a speech he said you just you know watch it on mute and if you see the body language it's definitely not the body language of someone who is you know in a controlling role in the government it's a body language of someone who is losing of an opposition later so it definitely looks like a speech of and today Amit Segal spoke in the news Apparently after briefing Javier within himself or people close to him that you're even within during the next couple of weeks we'll see what the faith of the reform and see what's his next step and if the reform will be not
16:53 will resign so it definitely will be the next Crisis I don't know if it will be the next Crisis within the Coalition but it definitely will be a big crisis within Lee could and maybe for Coalition definitely as well because we all understand that the reform was not only interest of Europe Levin or Netanyahu it was interest of all the partners of the Coalition definitely of the ultra Orthodox and of the religion zionists so we will definitely speak about the reform again in a couple of weeks um 16 minutes after 10 and I think we approach the questions very wonderful thank you so much so the first question we have is from Don Sable asking do you think many of the protesters against judicial reform do not know many of the details besides the issue of the knusts override of the
17:55 Supreme Court and little about the issues of standing judiciability reasonableness warriors uh yeah so do you think that they understand like the the full facts or is uh if that's the case are the protests about more than just judicial reform very good question you know some will claim that people overall don't understand usually things happening that they criticize you know I'm sure that we're all confined researchers about you know the level of understanding of an average quarter about I don't know economy when he goes to vote in the elections or you know what is the process of legislation in the certain country or whatever country it is in I'm not sure we will find a very deep knowledge of all the processes so overall I think that really
19:00 you know the level of deep knowledge of average citizen not even Israel every citizen within any we will find it much lower than than than higher let's be and and and again and everybody from its side you know within a democracy and you know sector that he lives in be it's left or right be it you know some sector of the ethnicola national people you know people don't a they they they don't search for information in you know sources of information outside sector of of connection of a different
20:04 identification so I definitely think that you know on both sides uh again of every split you know the left or or the protesters they read what they want uh to prove their opinion so I definitely think that if we just let people know search research and know much deeper the claims the history the data they will always reveal that it's it's much less than they want that they think because it's always you know it's always it's always stereotypes of knowledge I know yeah I'm I'm I'm sure that if you just go to some secular I don't know what Tel Aviv and ask people about take care about Orthodox you know now the
21:06 budget passed okay so many budgets were given to ultra Orthodox now the right the Coalition claims that it's all you know affirmative action that provides a budgets that were taken uh from the wood toward the Ducks and the second will say no they you know they take it and they use us and and think now I I I'm sure that you know after all the the truth is somewhere in the middle uh that if we go deeper we find that you know that that we all use some information that you know that built stereotypes so the secular don't really know uh you know they they say that which word is they don't work and they don't serve that's not right many work in many serve and the opposite you know those say ah the secular not Jewish they forgot how to be Jewish you know I'm quoting you know Netanyahu is very
22:11 a popular quote it I'm sure that if you just go you know and learn about the second so-called secular we find that much of them many of them are observers and and and and from not maybe religious but from definitely traditional families I hope I answered thank you so in the past we've talked about how the judicial reform most of the issues were coming from how quickly it was being pushed through uh do you think that now it's getting the the proper discussion which is leading to the less protests uh and and can come to some sort of cooperation on this I think that just everybody is now you know waiting what what what's happening what the negotiations will bring and everybody you know on low starts you know with all his equipment you know and people just waiting for attacking the other side if they don't
23:13 get what they want so those who are in favor just wait okay if they you know if when I'll see that the deal is bad for us we will attack and and under the other side the same so I think that just everybody now sits and waits and all the sides tell their supporters to certain weights for the negotiation for agreed format of the reform that would come out yeah the the the the these talks what it will be how it will be when it will be please don't ask me I don't want to commit to something that nobody knows but definitely we will see in couple of weeks that we will come to some culmination of these uh pressure on every side and these expectations will be either satisfied or it will be a huge
24:19 you know huge blow thank you and you you talked about an impending divide in the ultra-orthodox uh party uh so we're seeing a lot of power and strength I guess uh right now with policies being passed uh how will this expected to divide uh going forward affect politics now and in the future uh we'll be more will more laws be pushed through while they're still United excuse me the question is about the split within the Orthodox Community or general correct with the uh passing of the uh the Lithuanian leader and the question is again sorry so right now we're seeing the ultra-orthodox kind of in a position of power do you see that divide affectingness going forward well definitely I think that the very fact of you know decentralization of the power
25:24 will will not strengthen them and because you know it will be more competition it will be more splits so definitely I think it it might and it's expected to uh to reduce their um how will it I don't know I remind you that you know the previous leader which was much Rabbi kanevsky passed out only one year ago in March 2022 and also before that when the bigger rabbi of litworks when he died everybody spoke that you know okay now you know he's the last we don't know how it will be everything we'll just you know a fall but but but things happened and didn't
26:28 really I think we didn't see really big changes but again I think that these changes are first of all we don't really see them yeah on you know on the surface and also I think that these processes these things happen slow but now yes we hear I think more than previously more than after passed out and more than after ilyasov passed out we hear that that was the you know era of one United leadership and one Rabbi and everybody speaks about three so yes I think that this situation is new now even if it's you know if the change will not be you know this but it takes us another step lower another step lower another step lower another step lower we are in some a crave going down how it will go what pace to what results it will cost I don't
27:32 know but we do see a change that will affect the politics and affect the economy and affect the integration because I think less people will feel so the so so so so so more people will feel freeware so you know not to obey because the you know the leadership status of three apparently will be lower than the leadership status of one so uh that's I think it's it's it's logic and it that's what definitely would happen instead thank you uh Eric asks in recent polls does Benny Gantz blue and white still have a higher popularity than yes yes it's lower the gap is lower though than it was before the operation shield and arrow because I think that much of the fall of
28:37 likuden Netanyahu before the operation was because he was blamed by a weak reaction to uh the rockets that we saw from Lebanon and Rockets that we had from Gaza so he was definitely blamed on being weak and you know while seeing all the sorry all the our enemies you know that you know we saw a Syrian participating in Arab League conference and we see a that Hezbollah it feels much stronger to to you know to let a fire Rockets programs so every I think that this fall was because of that and after the operation Netanyahu you know he closed the Gap he didn't close it fully so now it's like 27 versus 28 but it's one now is definitely less than
29:44 it was but again you know pulls when there are no elections don't mean much you know elections it's an event that happened at a very at very certain time and very certain events very certain agenda and you may relate to that as this so now I think it's it's it's very amateur to think that these polls are correct but but the polls show the polls show tendency and the tendency definitely shows that the agreement of the the over the reform is something that people want because that's the position of guns and that's how he goes up and we definitely see that people security which they didn't feel that
30:47 Netanyahu provides and uh and I hope it means that they want Unity within Israel and they don't want to see the split they don't want to see people in the Army who say that they will not come they want a strong and they want Us and they want us to defeat our enemies and to be a strong again let's say before all the splits that and that took place a few last months I hope that's what it means I'm sure we all hope that well thank you so much we've come to the close of our webinar and podcast Alex thank you for taking time to update us this week thank you of course for our viewers and listeners please join us Friday at 1pm Eastern for a webinar with Oren Kessler discussing Palestine 1936 the great
31:51 you're full of the roots of the Middle East conflict and the roots of the Middle East conflict thank you all for joining us and I hope you have a wonderful day thank you