MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Israel Insider

Israel Insider with Ashley Perry

Watch Israel Insider with Ashley Perry on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

Tensions are high in Israel at the start of Ramadan. What is Israel’s government doing to prevent the situation from escalating? Will it succeed?

Transcript Automatic captions

Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 4, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.

0:00 good afternoon welcome to the middle east forum's webinar and podcast series israel insider each week with ashley perry i'm stacy roman and i will be moderating this discussion today we are pleased to have ashley perry advisor to the middle east forum's israel office join us here each wednesday 30 pm to update us on all the events going on in mr perry will be giving us a briefing on korean israeli affairs for 15 minutes then open it up for questions should you wish to ask a question please use the q a box located at the bottom of your screen to type your question and now with no further ado i'll turn the discussion over to mr ashley perry thank you very much stacy good evening from israel obviously again you know we've talked about this uh quite a bit when i'm asked to write the description of the event it's usually a few days in you know and a few days ago everyone was talking about last week's terror attacks which claimed the lives of 11 people so it was very important to talk about those but obviously today we're talking

1:02 about something else completely um let's start at the end at 6 one in for four most common political commentators i mean sequel released uh to the news that um silman who is actually the coalition uh had resigned from the coalition now this caught everybody by surprise as we know the coalition has 61 uh votes 61 seats to the opposition's 59 so what this does essentially is it evens up the number it makes it into a tie uh 60 each 60 each which leaves us in a bit of a so what is what is this why did this come about first of all uh since this government was formed who are considered right-wing religious

2:04 members were essentially targeted by the opposition which has seen itself as a right-wing religious opposition and they try to identify certain quote unquote weaker links uh that it could maybe persuade or harass er might be was considered one of those weaker links she was harassed they had outside uh demonstrations uh her husband to work apparently was uh harassed her children in the uh the youth organization that they belong to arrest she was harassed in her synagogue she was harassed at weddings that she went to and family events she was harassed on the street according to her she was even physically assaulted at a a gas station petrol station at one point it was a lot of pressure put on her not just on her but she was definitely identified as one of the weak links throughout these these 10 months

3:08 she has pretty much sat relatively quietly in the coalition she's done her work as the coalition whip made some mistakes but that's to be expected from a relatively rookie uh politician especially in such a pressure job as the coalition with with uh such narrow margins between the opposition and the coalition lately she's definitely come out on certain issues which she understands is closer to her base as a right-wing religious uh woman ostensibly uh the issue which um you know was the straw that broke the camel's back was this idea that in during pesach uh for those uh uh you know observing jews amongst us uh know that you're not allowed to eat eleven what's called chametz and uh for a number of years uh hospitals um were basically the the guards at hospitals around the country were telling people uh not to bring in any food that has it has any leavened bread

4:12 or anything like that uh but then in 2020 um a secular movement took that to court and basically the supreme court decided that there's no legal basis for that and guards cannot ask anyone entering hospitals during a passover festival to bring you know not to bring in lebanon bread comments whatever it is this happened under netanyahu and last year for example uh the supreme court ruling was upheld during the you know the right-wing religious uh government uh led by netanyahu this year the minister of health uh nissan horowitz from the merits party which is electric secular party sent out a letter to hospital administrators or managers or director general saying that to uphold that supreme court ruling apparently that incensed idiot someone who is the head of the health committee in the knesset and she

5:16 said this is a disgrace a person like that has no right to be a minister in a a government of a jewish state and she really uh lambasted um the health minister on it most people thought okay she wants to have her say she wants to look tough she wants to look like she's standing by her principles but it will die down by mr bennett said pretty much the same thing this is not a major issue don't worry about it we'll fix it everyone just has to calm down a little bit amazingly as i said when the country woke up at 6 46 to this announcement uh amazingly prime minister bennett apparently heard about it the same as the rest of us he was completely taken by surprise according to people around him it wasn't something that he foresaw but what had happened is that again because of the pressure um because perhaps she saw the writing on the wall as we know yamina

6:17 is a party that won seven seats of the last elections immediately one of those left well i didn't believe uh you mean officially but he decided not to go into the government and basically acted as a singular vote uh in the opposition on behalf of yamina so basically prime minister bennett who has who had who has well now he has five uh seats but before that he had six seats uh just didn't seem to be able to get his people in line a lot of people attributing this to you know the demands of the job as prime minister he's involved in diplomatic issues security issues you know many many national issues every minute of the day what he didn't do enough of uh people are saying including a member of his own party is pay attention to what's going on in on the ground politically uh it does seem that uh almost all of the polls that have come out have not seen them uh move up at all in the polls they haven't

7:19 gained anything according to really pretty much 95 99 of the polls uh and they even people have dissected the polls say that all of the form none of the votes that they would receive today are their base which is again that might be religious uh then it perhaps was trying to attract a more centrist perhaps more traditionally minded or even secular minded centrist or center-right so he doing things that perhaps his base wouldn't uh approve of one of his members of knesset today apparently in a meeting when he called the other remaining members of the party to a meeting they accused him of uh not taking enough care politically not uh not caring enough about his base uh natalie bennett himself used the term west bank to refer to the area over the green line now while most of the world uses the term west bank in israel especially on the right whether the term west bank is never used

8:21 it's judea and samaria and especially as a former chairman of the yeshua council which is the council representing israeli citizens that live over the green line uh judea and sumeria it was very surprisingly shocking to hear him use those terms some say that again when secretary us secretary of state lincoln uh accused um settlers of violence he didn't stand up to him and there's there's various other things they didn't build enough uh in the settlements there's a lot of accusations that certain members of the party have on him so where does that leave us today uh it basically leads us in a bit of well not a bit in paralysis a few different scenarios going forward and how this can play out the one way which is uh what the coalition lead is you know from the beginning of this coalition i have spoken about the fact that the court if it was left up to coal mission leaders this government would probably uh realize it's full term uh they they know how to work together despite some disagreements they understand the

9:23 necessity to work together the necessity to compromise on certain issues and that's the way it's mostly been but there are obviously other members uh within each of their but the leaders met today after this shock announcement and basically said that they would like to carry on uh the government for as long as possible what it does mean though is in the knessets as far as votes are concerned they don't have a majority for everybody turns up and everybody votes you know according to the coalition opposition lines no laws will be passed from from this moment on certainly no basic laws which are sort of quasi-constitutional which which are above uh regular laws which you need a 61 votes to pass the other thing that is now uncertain not to pass is the budget which they have to pass by march next year now uh in recent weeks we've been hearing a lot especially from finance minister avigdor liebman that he wanted to push the budget issue off the table for the

10:26 two years subsequent because there is a budget for this year uh by dealing with that in the next couple of months now there is no way that that will pass because you need a 61. so this government at most unless the really unthinkable happens and someone comes across from the opposition which i think is exceedingly unlikely and the least likely scenario here so basically this government at the best case scenario has until march 2023 now the opposition has a couple of options here uh the most likely is that they will try and get one more vote to get that 61 to pass a law to disperse the kinesthetic a lot of dispersive connection means basically the connect center is this kind of set is over and we have 90 days or 100 days i've got how until the next elections um that is the most likely scenario because all they need now is one more vote and there is talk that uh probably another you mean a person may go at the moment um no one is coming forward but that

11:29 could all change uh pretty soon apparently abhi akara was part of this meeting with uh silman who had with uh also with hashikli the renegade the original renegade winner and they were going to form a faction because this is also important as things stand if there are elections it is silman who has been promised for her defection um to basically be number to be number 10 on the decode list and be the next minister of health now according to knesset rules as things stand she will not be able to run in the next uh elections because she left her party and once you leave your party in a knesset you can't run with an established list in the next elections so as things stand she cannot run but if another member of eurena leaves and they join with shikley and he did zillman they can form a breakaway party because you need over a third of a party to join a breakway party then you can have full funding and you can run in the next elections etc etc

12:31 but as i said i think the most likely scenario is someone will be convinced by you know because now they see the writing on the wall and this is a government which will be almost completely paralyzed obviously can pass governmental decisions executive but as far as the knesset goes it's going to be almost complete paralysis that's the most likely another scenario is a vote of no confidence basically needs not just a vote of 61 but you need to form a government with seats and what the problem is here even though the opposition is now up to 60 six of those are with the joint arab list which will not sit in any netanyahu led to so basically they have 54 at this point so they would need at least seven to be able to form a government because you have to lay out that government who's going to lead it who's going to be ministers who who are the people who would sign on to such a thing uh the only party available with those sort of numbers is blue and white and we

13:34 get back to the point of defence minister benny so we know benny garcia sat with a former prime minister that you know in the past and was promised to be prime minister and obviously we know that that promise was relent on uh so there's a lot of distrust between the two but if benny gaunts was promised uh rotation to be prime minister immediately and maybe the game will change the other thing that is important to note is if there was a law to disperse the commencement according to coalition agreement the moment after foreign party would immediately become prime minister now why is that important first of all it gives uh naftali bennett a sort of threat to some of the members of his right-wing policy that if you go to the other side and we do pass a dispersal of knesset law yield appeared this left wing uh as they were they would probably frame him or lift the center um

14:36 leader would then become prime minister and as we know from every single poll that has been undertaken for the last three years neither block has a majority which could mean we could have not just one election coming but maybe another one on top of that and who knows maybe another one on top of that that could mean that yeah it appeared his prime minister of israel for months if not a year now that is obviously a threat and that also may play into benny gatz's decision-making because benny gats and lepid are not just political rivals they also have major personal differences between them so these are all the factors on the other side netanyahu certainly prefers the option of going to elections he believes that he will only strengthen in the polls uh and he has certainly strengthened the polls but again there has not been a single poll which has shown his block receiving the necessary 61. so either they would need someone to come across from the other side or we would go for another set of elections uh some of his partners want different things as we know arya derry took a plea bargain the leader of davido

15:39 a a couple of months ago which meant that he has to step down from the knesset but he can run in the next generation which means shas would want new elections because they would want their leader back in the knesset the ashkenazi ultra-orthodox party united torah judaism does not want new elections they would like to form an alternative government within this knesset and in fact one of the leaders of the party masha gaffney interestingly said this morning that it's time that the opposition also did a bit of soul searching and perhaps it is time for someone else to lead uh you know the opposition would be government with someone who has more likelihood of forming the government which was a direct attack to a certain extent on netanyahu now subsequently he retracted his comments and said he was misunderstood even though everyone heard the words very clearly and they're on record but it does show that there is an openness there to consider someone else uh other than letting go to be the government that's unlikely to happen just because uh

16:42 netanyahu will not and will not allow it uh but perhaps that sort of flexibility is what some someone like benny gans is looking that people benny dance as we know has pretty good relations with the ultra orthodox parties i'm sure that they will be reaching out to him day and night to try and see what he needs and offer him the world uh whether netanyahu signs on or not it's a whole nother thing the day is i i believe that the next few days uh there is a momentum towards the opposition towards the right-wing religious opposition they held a a big demonstration in the government court outside their prime minister's uh office uh this evening it was a bit of a show of strength netanyahu spoke you know it was all smiles all cheers all applause singing and dancing so they definitely feel that they have the momentum they feel it's only a matter of a short amount of time until this government falls uh as i said this government does now have a ticking clock uh maximum it could survive is march and there's something unthinkable happens

17:44 which i i don't see at this point um so those are sort of uh the scenarios to play out like my particular view is that someone else me i mean there's a very strong likelihood that they will leave because then they'll see the writing on the wall they'll look at their just as it is look at our personal uh you know future and say well this government is done anyway i may as well not go down with this uh sinking ship uh you mean it is polling minimally this government has already got a shelf life on it so why should i go down with it there'll be a lot of pressure if it can survive at least the next few weeks until the commercial returns in may perhaps there will be the moment the momentum of the uh opposition will be halted a little bit and perhaps we'll get back into some sort of uh status quo again where there will be uh political parliamentary paralysis perhaps but at the government level that it's possible that they'll still be able to

18:45 do some of the reforms that they uh set out at the beginning the knesset in in their uh wide and holistic agenda and with that i'm happy to answer any questions on this or any other issues relating to israel all right thank you so much so the first question is uh if the coalition with the thai are is unable to pass any laws why would it want to stay power until march 2023 well first of all because the alternative is not to be in power at all you know don't forget there's many many ministers there who still have ministries to run and as i said that there's still a lot they can do at the ministerial level the government level they can pass executive decisions at the ministerial level just not laws the difference between laws and what are called government decisions our government decisions can be easily just um replaced in a subsequent government a law has to be then uh relitigated and go through

19:49 the whole process with the committees and all the three votes and et cetera so it's always preferable on an important issue for something to go through the kinesis but there's still a lot that can be done between now and then you know every uh minister minister in their ministry has a plan has something that they'd like to do and don't forget to go into elections tomorrow as opposed to after six months and perhaps the economy is looking a bit better perhaps some of the ministers have got a few more achievements behind them is a very different thank you for clarifying that uh and a follow-up to that how does the israeli public feel about the current situation well the there was that was paul tonight immediately and you know there's always going to be a sort of reflex feeling about this and sometimes it's best to let the dust settle but that's not what they play posters for um and the numbers were sort of almost a third a third a third a third want to carry on with this government a bit less than that i would like to

20:53 see an alternative government in other words the right-wing religious government and around 20 so it's not really the third the final part but 20 would like to go to elections so it shows that uh the majority would like this to be worked out at the political level without having to go back to the public because there is a weariness about uh you know elections and again because of the polls that we saw even tonight all of the major uh tv stations did polls and again it it meant a deadlock if those uh results came out after elections so the uh the people uh four fifths of the people at least um just would not like to go to elections so there are those scenarios where we don't go to elections uh my feeling is that that eventually is what will happen whether it's days weeks or months eventually we will just go to another elections and perhaps even in other elections beyond that thank you eric asks did the likud break the law by offering someone a spot will

21:57 she now vote with the opposition i guess since she resigned now but well the second uh the second question yes uh she will now sit with the opposition uh as far as breaking the law there is a law that you're not allowed to offer uh someone a future position that all goes back to uh the days of yet sakura beer no it's shimon peres the so-called sticky maneuver at the end of the eighties where positions were offered to try and break up the government and then they legislated uh that you can no longer do that but it's it's a relatively vague law and it's done pretty much been done in the last few years um i think the ngo movement for uh quality of government or government quality whatever it's called uh has already petitioned the supreme court about this um but i you know again i don't think anything's been signed anywhere or anything's official so i think it'll be very hard overrule it but again as i said as things stand if we went to elections

23:00 tomorrow he did someone would not be able to stand on the liquid slate but she could still be a minister without being a member of knesset because we many of those uh currently so uh i think that's that's where those uh issues start at the moment thank you length gets us in between all these coalition issues who's watching the progress on the iran deal it's a very good question uh you know if you ask some who are critical of the fact that prime minister bennett is not focusing enough on on the ground politics uh he's very much involved in the uh iran issue in fact you know it seems so long ago but it was only a few days ago it came out that uh another way that they were going to ensure that the turnover between bennett and the pit would actually take place which was supposed to take place in the latter part of 2023 was uh that uh naftali bennett whatever position he took after would still be in charge of

24:03 the iran dossier um so uh you know i'm not particularly worried that there are a lot of diplomats involved in security officials involved in this certainly the prime minister will have been distracted today and will certainly be distracted in the days to come or perhaps need to uh care and pay more attention to what's going on uh uh you know domestically politically um but i i wouldn't worry it's not as if this was going to stop functioning in the days and weeks ahead israel had managed to function for two years without a a you know without a stable government um so i'm not overly wide i'm not you know like everyone in israel we're worried about the the way things are moving and the agreement and iran's move towards nuclear weapons capability but i'm not particularly worried about you know leadership attention spent on this issue because it is so important thank you and another question on current affairs uh ken miller asks if

25:05 the government or sorry uh carrie hillibrand asked uh will alia from the ukraine be impacted no again because aliyah is not there's no real laws that need to be passed um you know government decisions can be taken whether it's in the ministry of aliyah and absorption whether it's the finance ministry if they need to find money as i said the the ministers have worked very well on this issue and most issues um throughout this government so um most of issues that do not need a law to be passed in the connection will continue um and when it comes to earlier there's pretty much cross-bench consensus on the need to help anyone who needs to make earlier especially at the moment from uh the ukraine thank you now to ken miller's question uh if the government issues executive orders uh since there's no constitution in israel how does this the israeli

26:09 supreme court base their decisions as being illegal on a government decision well first of all as i said there are quasi-constitutional laws which are uh what is of course the the basic laws but there will be no more new ones of those but we do have quite an activist supreme court in israel which sometimes take on issues that they were not even asked to necessarily so they can take on an issue that they believe is against the character of the state you know again some of the basic laws on you know the nature of the state whether it's uh the jewish nature of the state basic rights and all those sort of things you know the supreme court will look at those and will judge whether uh any of the executive decisions again i i use the term executive decision just because it's the most familiar to our american viewers uh we don't have a presidential system so there is no one person who has executive power the executive power is invested in the government uh but each ministry has uh the uh the um the opportunity to do

27:14 what's called a sort of a government decision so if it decides uh like for example the agricultural reform if the agricultural ministry wants to continue with the reform even though it will have zero chance of passing the knesset it can still continue to do it at the ministerial level thank you so much and uh i don't believe the coalition was able to get around to passing any uh term limits or anything like that but len levin asked could netanyahu be eligible as prime minister again so soon he's eligible yesterday today and tomorrow there's nothing to prevent him the court cases are going on and there's been quite some fascinating events taking place there with some of the uh state witnesses giving uh some uh very open uh and from the netanyahu camps and worrying statements about what netanyahu uh you know and these cases of breach of trust and ford and some of these other serious allegations but until

28:17 uh if and when he's convicted uh he can continue to uh try to be prime minister and even serve as prime minister uh there is excuse me another question that's come up in israel is does this make a plea bargain more likely or less likely some say makes it more likely because he has a stronger hand with the state prosecution office i believe it makes it less likely because now there's a good likelihood at some point in the future that he may return to office and maybe be able to pass one of those laws that ensures the court case either he's put off until after he's prime minister perhaps is taken away completely or allows him to run even if he is convicted these are all laws that have been approached in the past by members of the good that you know keeps them claiming that nothing to do with me i didn't even know about them but you know it's clear that that's not strictly true so now that the chance has certainly increased that he could return to being prime minister uh and possibly passing these laws i think there'll be less of

29:20 an impetus for him to take any uh potential plea bargain so in my mind it certainly lowers those chances thank you and you did say that if if netanyahu lists government is unlikely is there truth to that statement that you mentioned earlier about it being easier to form a right-wing government without him that's been true since the beginning if netanyahu would have allowed someone else and that he couldn't form a government this government would never have happened a new hope of gideon yamina of um of naftali bennett maybe even uh yeshua beiteina would have joined such a government israel but 10 also have a problem being in the government of the ultra orthodox parties but certainly those other two parties wouldn't have a problem maybe even blue and white maybe even yesterday who knows could have formed a government very very easily uh and that's what uh marcia gaffney was referring to the fact that uh perhaps it's time to look at those other options but as things stand i i think the chances of anyone else leading a block

30:23 like that uh is extremely unlikely thank you so much we've come to the close of our webinar and podcast actually thank you again for taking time to update us this week for our viewers and listeners please join us at friday at 1 pm eastern for a webinar with ella zeiser discussing israeli universities after american academics opted for bds thank you all for joining us and i hope you have a wonderful day