Webinar or Talk
"Israel's National Unity Government: What's Next?" with Ashley Perry
Watch on YouTube
Description
Finally, Israel has a government, led by Benjamin Netanyahu and Benny Gantz. Can they work together and govern effectively? Which parties make up the coalition? What are the main areas of consensus and of contention?
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 13, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:00 right it's three o'clock hello and welcome to the Middle East forum speaker webinar series Israel insider with mr. Ashley Perry I'm Stacey McKenna and I will be moderating today's discussion we're pleased I have mr. Ashley Perry adviser to the Middle East forums Israel office join us here each week to update us on all things Israeli mr. Perry will be giving us a briefing on current Israeli affairs from our play 10 to 15 minutes that open it up for questions should you wish to ask a question please use the Q&A box located at the bottom of your screen we will do our best to get to all questions but we have many participants on this webinar so I apologize in advance if we do not get yours today and now with no further ado I will turn the discussion over to mr. Ashley Perry thank you very much Stacey good to be here again it's been two weeks since we last had this webinar and two you know they say 24 hours is a long day a long time in Israeli politics or two weeks is a very long time I've been saying since
1:02 the beginning of this webinar series that there will be a national unity government that it was just posturing you know between the sides whether they would you know sort of play this game of chicken who could get what house that negotiations you know even up until the last minute there was talk that there wouldn't be a national unity government there was even talk that Prime Minister Netanyahu was negotiating at the last minute while negotiating with many guns he was also negotiating with I mean parrots of the labor party to bring in two members of the Labor Party just two that he would be able to reach that magic number of 61 that we've talked about for the last few weeks be able to form a government without any guards and there was talk of him offering the two member labor party five ministries including a rotation of prime minister at the end of the third year I think this was all talk I don't believe that that was a serious proposition it was again probably just to put pressure but
2:05 in the end it worked both sides came to the table and earlier in the week they signed an agreement now as opposed to what everybody else is saying there is no government yet there are still many steps to take before we reach a government first of all because it's the Knesset that's in charge of finding a candidate to be the next prime minister any candidate which now will be a Netanyahu has to receive 61 signatures of other or 60 other signatures of members of Knesset before them they go back to the president who then will but there were various other stages first of all there are people have gone to the Supreme Court and try to invalidate Prime Minister Netanyahu as the next prime minister on the basis of the fact that he standing trial he's indicted and it's going to be standing trial within weeks for three very serious cases as a breach of trust or fraud etc etc now up until now when anyone has gone to the Supreme Court to
3:09 ask them to disbar Netanyahu the Supreme Court said we're not ruling on a theoretical position because he's known he is not at the stage where he's ready to form a government but now we're in different territory now he is almost ready to form a government what that will mean who knows one of the things that Netanyahu they could did try and do during the negotiations was try to put something in the agreement with blue and white that if the supreme court Despard netanyahu and they've just go it would basically they were trying to overall it now that wasn't but the language wasn't put in there in the agreement in the end if they do dis Barnett in you know in theory then we will go to those fourth I don't really have a sense of where the Supreme Court will go on that it's unclear there's we don't have a constitution as many of you know but sadly we don't have a written constitution so the law is not clear on exactly this particular point but even
4:14 so Nitin yo still has to negotiate at the moment he's bought in the moment we're talking about I think it's 36 he could he now has 15 blue and white or at least the belly GAD cider might because Yale appeared and the telling party or his part of the telling party it gets very confusing as with many in the opposition so here is 36 plus 15 with Bennigan's that's 51 now he has two members of teller and he has only Levy who broke off from the Labour Party and two members of the Labour Party the only other party is actually signed with so far is United tour Judaism the Ashkenazi ultra-orthodox party which apparently negotiations last seven minutes and as we've seen with every other coalition negotiations through Netanyahu the easiest negotiations always with the imagine so Judaism the shafts the Sephardic or to Orthodox party will join very very shortly the big question mark remains opium you know the right-wing National Religious party
5:16 even have tiny bayonet there's a lot of bad blood this is not going to be easy negotiations they have for let's say heavy hitters at the top of the party each of which have been a minister in the past each of which want to be a minister in the next government but they only have six seeds so to give four ministries to a party of six seats it's obviously quite a high price but we will have 36 eventually 36 ministers in the next government that's what was agreed and I believe 16 something like that deputy ministers that's an absolute record it's three times the amount of many other countries like Austria who have 11 I think Swit some has 12 ministers much larger countries we will have 36 ministry ministers and so the debate is now whether you mean it can be brought in you mean interestingly is not focusing on the issue of annexation because that is in the agreement that your might and they know that that's
6:19 either going to be dealt with the remote and have Tony Bennett has put out press releases saying that they are pushing for more liberal type economy especially with a coronavirus hitting Israeli economy as it's hitting economies across the world very very hard so that's the kind of line he's taking perhaps it's in preparation of sitting outside so they can be a robust liberal with a small L opposition to what are going to be very uncomfortable and difficult economic times ahead there's a big debate some people think that they will stay out some people think that they'll go in my feeling is that they will go in there trying to hard bargain but I don't believe in have Tony Bennett fought for a year over a year to get back to where he has just to sit in the opposition set alongside parties which he vehemently disagrees with whether it's merits or the our parties he will find common themes with ABI talib men of the Israel mitaina party which is also said it's going to sit out and it would be relatively
7:23 uncomfortable and it will make them even less relevant than they have been in the last few elections because as we seen the numbers have gotten lower and lower and lower so I believe that they will enter the government but Netanyahu doesn't need them to form government so they're they're Handy's very weak and that's exactly how Netanyahu likes it so these are the things that still have to be worked out we all still have a good few weeks in Israel until we have officially a government next week we commemorate Yeomans a Quran which is the day our moral day for Israel's fallen fallen soldiers and victims of terror followed by your Matt's mode which is issues Independence Day the government's aside you put out guidelines that you're not allowed to leave your homes or your communities usually these are very big days for Israel the day you're missing Quran is a day where people go to visit their loved ones that they lost in wars and terror attacks and basically the government is not going to allow it
8:26 obviously because of fear of the spreading of coronavirus and the massive parties that will happen on you - murder will be cancelled every town every city every neighborhood has big big parties firework displays at night barbecues in parks up and down the country they will obviously all be abandoned this year Ramadan is starting in a couple of days and there's also been similar stipulations placed on the Muslim community that they are not allowed to celebrate outside of the nuclear family outside of the family lives in a particular home in other words the usual family and clan celebrations you know village wide or town or city wide celebrations have all been canceled but Israel has started relieving some of a harsh sort of sanctions some special education programs are being allowed to return in a school setting we're now allowed beyond a hundred metres from our home to five hundred metres for exercise more people are going back to work so we
9:30 starting to see the positive trends in that as far as infection rates they've actually started going up a little bit but I it can't be because of these are the release of restrictions because that was only a couple of days ago but like everywhere else they're trying to manage it suppress it keep it as low as possible and that's kind of where we are at the moment I think with that I'll open up to questions if there are any Stacy thank you so much we ever quite a few questions coming in after the establishment of a unity government who are the winners who are the losers I think Netanyahu is the number one winner I think he gets a lot more with a national unity government and that's why I felt that he would always go with the national unity government he gets stability for at least a year and a half because Benny Gant's will not want to break apart the government and ruin his chances to be Prime Minister if that will happen the majority of Israelis do not believe that Netanyahu
10:32 will pass over the reins in a year and a half I think something like only 30 percent believe that he will but he gets stability for you and a half especially in an extremely complex and difficult economic period and social period ahead so he definitely gave that and that we know one party that will be able to bring down the government if you look at the numbers in the end it would be something like 76 and the largest party outside of Italy could within that government will be blue and white which I believe is 15 so there'll be no one party that will be able to bring down the government which happens quite a lot you know the threats are there and as long as they need the numbers of those in a particular party than they're you know susceptible to these threats so it gives him a lot of stability which is something that he wants Benny Ganz gets a lot of ministries he gets a potential opportunity to sit in ministers office he will be Defense Minister for at least the next year and a half and the position of basically there it's gonna be unprecedented when
11:39 the Prime Minister is sworn in there'll be two prime minister sworn in so that's a way that Benny Gans put in the language so it would be an automatic process in your heart rather than having to go back and swear in and that would be problematic step if there was a challenge so he gets to be sort of a substitute Prime Minister for lips year-and-a-half and defense minister and he gets a foreign ministry for his good friend Gabi Ashkenazi and various other ministers so he has got the potential to do something make some noise but my feeling is at the end of this he will look back and it won't be particularly profitable time for him politically Yale appeared of the netted part of the other side of blue and white one could argue that he's lost out a veto Lieberman was also lost out because they believed that Benny Ganz would join them in trying to topple Netanyahu which they didn't the ultra-orthodox parties are pretty much
12:42 as strong as they were every issue which they care about they pretty much been given in the coalition negotiations but I just don't think you can walk away with anything Netanyahu is still the most powerful person in the country by far within his party no one is able to challenge him even though there's been a lot of anger in the way that he has run the response to coronavirus he's basically put out regulations and only had the cabinet voting on them afterwards which you know in the u.s. you have a presidential system here we have a government or a parliamentary system and the executive is the cabinet Prime Minister is just one of many votes but Metis knows basically got whatever he wanted on these programs and the way to run the economy run the restrictions against the coronavirus and that will certainly continue because I think he's shown himself to be the leader of the country and as I said we've been moving towards a presidency away from the parliamentary
13:45 system without actually enacting any laws or constitutional reform that would create such a system so Netanyahu is basically I would argue even one touch more that he was a few months ago thank you what are the ramifications of the charges against mr. Netanyahu now I mean they're very serious and there's even talk of more cases coming obviously you know like in any in any democracy he's innocent until proven guilty but there are very serious charges and the court cases are supposed to start in a few weeks but they were gone for many many Netanyahu has no interest in speaking this process up he'll use as he has done up to this point his lawyers to push back as much as possible and this process will go on for many many years so it's it's very it won't have a short-term effect or a medium-term of it because now he has this stability I
14:48 talked about before it has the security of a year and a half so we will probably see the Prime Minister going in and out of court in a Bey uncomfortable situation to have the leader of a country sitting in Criminal Court but it would affect him probably politically for that thank you what is the long-term strategy for the survival of Israel considering coronaviruses damaging the economy and according to a recent Middle East's Forum article Iran is planning more well the long-term survival of Israel I mean you know it's it's like any other country that I don't think the coronavirus will affect the long-term legitimacy or survival of Israel it's going to be a difficult period as it will be globally but I think Israel will get through it Israel has done pretty well up until now in stemming the flow of the virus so I don't think there'll be a necessarily problem there it will
15:52 be very trouble and challenging times ahead economically and socially but it will be everywhere else in the world Iran is certainly using this time as an opportunity to you know rattle the Sabres they say we heard about the satellite launch we heard about its harassment of American ships in the Gulf so they obviously are using this time to try and put pressure but Iran is offering Iran is suffering socially politically and above all economically so there are opportunities if the international community wants to place more pressure on Iran especially at this time and something that Israel has called for in the last 24 hours is greater sanctions on Iran because of its aggressive behavior thank you will the unity government have an effect on relations with the United States I think it would just have positive effect we saw when President Trump rolled out the
16:56 peace plan he invited not just Prime Minister Netanyahu but also at that point the main opposition leader Benny Ganz to discuss the roll out in in DC with him we heard Mike Pompeo come out and speak very positively about the fact that there is a government it's a national unity government if there is going to be movement on the issue of annexation and sovereignty it slightly is better for the US and it's certainly better for Israel if main to parties the center-left on the center-right are standing together in agreement on the major issues of the day so I think it's it will be seeing very favorably the fact that Israel has a government is something which is certainly disturbed you know relations with many countries in the u.s. is no exception so the fact that there is now a government moving forward is seen favorably in DC and it will certainly meet a lot of plans that they have together whether it is annexation or where there is they're moving forward with a peace plan or something to be
17:59 much easier I was really youth conscious of Israel's security concerns or they attracted towards the peace camps pension for unilateral lateral ISM at the expense of focusing on defense issues well don't forget Israel's I mean it depends we core Israel's youth but don't forget in Israel when you're 18 you go to the army again it's an exceptions with the Arab and ultra-orthodox community so when you're 16 17 already starting to think about what you're going to do in the army you're starting to go for testing you'll start to go for meetings so you have a conscious that you know going you know there are people who go straight to University especially if it's something that contribute to the army whether it's a medical or legal or whatever but most Israeli youth are going to the army interestingly enough as opposed to places like the US and Europe the youth of Israel tend to move to the right and if you look at the numbers and they could especially or parties on the right
19:02 have a relatively in percentage terms high number of youth who are supporting them in fact you know a big past time during Israel elections is they go to high schools and they have a whole panel there every one or the different parties represented and afterwards they take a poll and even in the pockets of you know what a scene there's more left-wing liberal support the right wing does very very well even better probably than in the national elections so it's very different to other places in the West where the youth don't forget who have grown up never seeing a Palestinian leader an Israeli leader in the same room negotiating shaking hands they you know they if you're more than 27 years old you never experience Oslo you never experienced you know let's say the hey there heady days of a peace process what you have experienced are conflicts with Hamas terrorist attacks threats from Hamas Hezbollah Islamic Jihad Iran this
20:08 is you know you probably spent a certain amount of time and safe rooms as a result of rocket attacks you've you know people have gone off to war it's a very different effect because you we feel it here and the youth of growing up on that so that's probably a reason for why Israeli youth tend to be more to the right well they're not in Yahoo's approval ratings in the country as a whole now I mean the last ones he's been pretty consistently good they have gone down in recent weeks on his handling of coronavirus I think if you split his handling into managing the spread he's done pretty well you know if you look at statistically Israel's done better than many many other countries around the world let alone you know just even in the OECD whether is anger is on the economic and social front Israel's unemployment is up to a million and a quarter I believe which is massive for a country of nine
21:11 million people and very few system or eight packages have actually been released there's numbers today in the Finance Committee in the Knesset I heard their chairman gave a whole speech where basically said hundreds of thousands of asked for unemployment payments and only a few thousand be given out you know tens of thousands of people have asked for these loans which have been talked about as part of aid and assistant packages and only a few hundred have actually been given out so the government has been pretty slow to react on that there's a lot of discomfort and unease about the fact that the economy hasn't even started to go back considering the numbers and considering the relatively low level infections and especially when they're grouped in clusters people want to see far more restrictions relieved even this week some some schools are supposed to be going back to some programs and they basically put such ridiculous criteria
22:15 that they simply were not able to and obviously if the schools are not working a lot of people cannot go to work there's been major major disagreements about the education system the head of the teachers union basically came on TV and said I'm not pathetic about one day of my summer vacation teacher summer vacation to make up for this which she became the most hated person in Israel as a result so Netanyahu's handing of the crisis is definitely weakened but the signing of the agreement with burro and Wyatt n'they you know they're putting together off a national unity government is certainly popular last time I saw 62 percent approval rating in Israel with 22 percent against but I've said from the beginning as the weeks and months carry on there'll be certain amount of resentment and anger at the leadership as will happen probably in every country usually happens with these crises first of all solidarity and then
23:19 there'll be more and more resentment regardless of the steps that the leadership takes so this is the trend that we're already seeing and we see that many other places around the world yeah what does the annexation plan look like in the coalition agreement is it the entire West Bank or is it just the Jewish villages and towns in Area C what is the Palestinian reaction to this plan well there's no details in the in the agreement the idea is to the idea spoke especially before coronavirus reached us was that the Israelis and the Americans were put together a team committee that would look over the whole of the territory and see what areas can be annexed when what portion and and all this sort of things obviously with coronavirus and the attention elsewhere that hasn't happened according to the the director-general Prime Minister's Office although it hasn't happen in great level they still be it's still on
24:22 a low burner so these discussions have taken place in the agreement itself it just said that after July 1st they'll be able to move forward on this I don't believe that Netanyahu move forward without the approval of the Trump administration and I'm sure there'll be lots of context between now and them but it's unclear exactly what's going to happen the Trump plan did have a map but obviously that was just recommendation suggested Malcolm and that will obviously be poured over to see what can at what point maybe there'll be different stages Palestinian reaction has been obviously quite showing a certain amount of displeasure they basically said that prepares reaction today which was and it's up to each also decide what it will are an excellent how and when and Palestine is basically threatened as they have many many other times over the years that they're prepared to rip up the Oslo Accords and agreements which they threatened probably every couple of
25:24 months since 1993 so we don't put too much emphasis and that but obviously it's it's not good for them they're unhappy about it and but I think they like everyone else is just waiting to see what will happen after July first so the lock dome has had a decimating effect on tour it on the tourism industry is there any discussions yet about when the borders might be reopened for visitors to Israel and will the government bail bail out ll I think regarding the last part I think they have to bail out alarm as every national carrier will probably be bailed out by their their government because simply to rebuild a national carrier cost far more than to bail out so I think LR will emerge from this as the national carrier in a better position than all the other private carriers and that would be true I think of many national carriers around the world as far as the timetable for opening the borders as someone far more
26:27 knowledgeable on this said it's the only time table I think it was even a comment though it was the only timetable that matters is the coronavirus timetable was not for anyone else to decide is there going to be a second way but it can be a third way when is it going to come I don't believe that borders will be fully opened a for at the end of the song you know they're talking about September at the you know even to start thinking about it and I think there will be true of most places so I you know if anyone's think you're taking a holiday in Israel we welcome you we hope you come but I'm not sure now is the best time to start planning your summer vacation in Israel I know quite a few people have what it counts old it's it's decimating the tourism industry hotel industry etc as it is again Israel's not unique to that even though we do have quite a large tourism industry but hopefully at some point you know when we can manage the
27:32 coronavirus might even necessary get rid of it I'm sure we'll come back stronger than ever thank you do you think that president Romania of Rivlin has acted unwisely during building of the coalition only forcing the kiddin and blue and wait to promise compromise after the third election why did the agreement between Netanyahu against not take plate please after the first election well I think at the end of the end you can argue that President Rivlin steps that he took to sort of basically in essence threaten them say you have 21 days to to deal with this to get this over the line and it worked because you know the proof is that the agreement was signed so you can say that that was quite prudent rather than wasting more time you know if perhaps he would have given the mandate to Netanyahu Netanyahu would have had such a strong hand that he wouldn't have needed many gas and then would maybe would be back to this game
28:36 of chicken where's one it's it's a much better situation the other why did we get here before I think simply coronavirus gave a lot of people when ladders to come down from very high trees I think that's that's simply where was Benny Gann said he would not sit with a prime minister under indictment Prime Minister Netanyahu called dance for a year week unli - if like someone you know unfit for office you know you have Amir Peretz of the Labour Party who's going to the coalition who shaved his moustache and said just so you could read my lips I will not sit with Netanyahu and here he is on the eve of City with Netanyahu so I think that everyone can basically blame the coronavirus for saying you know during a crisis we all need to do things that we wouldn't do in other normal times I think that was it gave basically a lot of people are not an excuse to arrive at this point and that's where we are the numbers also who
29:41 worked out better during early elections dance had higher numbers had more of a chance of securing perhaps a majority but I think at the end of the day it's the coronavirus crisis that basically allowed everyone to calm down thank you and for closing do you have any last thoughts or remarks to share with our audience before we end this briefing I mean you know we've been talking about this national unity government we were talking about a government now for I don't know how many weeks since we started this and my prediction was regardless of the talk regardless of the threats it would come and I believe that would still happen even though we're not quite there yet there'll be a lot of stability moving forward and I think Israel needs that above all Israel needs stability whether you're in favor of Netanyahu or Gantz or whatever it is I think a lot of people will say at least we have a government and during this time you know there's global pandemic I
30:45 think to go into another elections would have been highly irresponsible and I hope that there will be structural changes to the Israel political system after these 14 months of instability I don't see it happening because there are too many people are invested in this current system but I think there needs to be and that's what I would really hope that the next government as well as dealing with the corona virus itself the economic and the social for lands I believe that we have to after many many years we have to start dealing and reforming the system because we've already started moving toward political paralysis and we cannot to wait another generation we're just this will happen in greater numbers and will not be able to move forward you know during times of crises like we see now so we have one more question before we go can you give us a quick update on the Middle East forums Israel activities yes I mean you know West we're still working we're waiting for
31:48 the government because we have very good relations we had good relations with the last functioning government you know all levels from the prime minister president ministers MKS from across the political spectrum so you know we're we're well-placed to regain those relations we'll start up our court because that was so one of the biggest and most successful caucuses in the last Knesset and our relations with decision makers and opinion shapers NGOs across the the wide political diplomatic and security spectrum we've started a security officials forum called generals for neutral victory of very impressive format IDF generals which are giving their viewpoints on the issues of the day whether it's regarding Hamas Iran Hezbollah all the other security challenges that Israel faces so the the Middle East forum Israel offices has not stopped working even in coronavirus
32:53 obviously with the winners challenges where we're meeting every day Izu and we're discussing next steps but we're pretty confident that we're going to be giving back in the Knesset like we were last time with with with support from parties from across the spectrum like we had during the last functioning Knesset wonderful we've come to the close of our webinar thank you again mr. Perry for joining us today on Friday and we obey with Winfield Meyers and cleverest myths begin how Congress can start reforming Middle East Studies thank you again for joining us have a great day