MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Webinar or Talk

MEF Presents: "Qatar: US Ally or Global Menace?": A Global Media Empire

Watch MEF Presents: "Qatar: US Ally or Global Menace?": A Global Media Empire on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

MEF Website: https://www.meforum.org/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Middle.East....
Follow us on Twitter: @meforum
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Middle East Forum is hosting a conference, "Qatar: U.S. Ally or Global Menace?" in Washington, D.C. where Qatar's lobbying and disinformation campaigns, its funding of Islamic extremism and more is discussed. Panelists include Daniel Pipes, Samantha Mandeles, Mohamed Fahmy and Alberto Fernandez.

Transcript Automatic captions

Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 16, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.

0:00 thank you Greg and good afternoon ladies and gentlemen you heard several times about El jazer you probably have encountered it yourself you've heard about how the katar government uses Al jazer founded in 1996 remember I mentioned earlier their Ambitions go back over 20 years uh to spread their message to whitewash their Outlook at the same time my favorite fact about Al jazer is that over there on Capitol Hill the New York Times only has some 40 plus correspondents accredited to Capital Hill and El jazer has 170 plus has four times more than the New York Times you wonder what's all this about well we have three distinguished speakers Muhammad FMI at the end is a journalist of Egyptian Origins who has worked for CNN the BBC and the Los Angeles times in September 2013 he became the international bureau

1:05 chief for Al jazer English he was located in Cairo at the time two months later December 2013 he was arrested he had along with two of his colleagues he spent the next two most of the next two years either in jail or on baale until he was poned by President CeCe he moved to Vancouver where he now teaches at the the University of British Columbia and he founded the FI Foundation whose name you see there her beler Fernandez had a distinguished 30-year career in the state department where he focused on public diplomacy and if you spend any time in the state diplom in the state department you know that public diplomacy is not its strongest suit correct uh he in other words he was talking to the general public rather than to fellow diplomats he was in particular important uh in articulating US Government positions in

2:08 Arabic to Arabic audiences he's currently president of the Middle East broadcasting network which includes elor television and Samantha mandelis has worked for a range of American organizations dealing with the Middle East including camera the scholars for peace in the Middle East Americans for peace in Tom an she currently serves as the coordinator of mef's islamist Watch Project this is our effort to look at lawful islamism lawful islamism as opposed to unlawful islamism we believe that blowing up and shooting is less important in the end than working through the institutions political legal educational media and the like and that's what islamist watch focuses on including of course El jazer we argue that violent Jihad gets the headlines but stealth Jihad gets the results so each of them will provide a perspective personal or investigative on

3:11 El jazer and at the end I'll ask them each to address a policy issue about whether El jazer should be required to register as a foreign agent under the new provisions of the National Defense authorization Act of 2019 so [ __ ] could we start with you certainly U glad to be here it's a real honor to be uh with all of you and with this distinguished panel first of all I want to make the usual uh uh declaimer that uh the comments I'm making are not those of the government of the United States or that of the Middle East broadcasting Network's Inc but my own you know um it's interesting to have to talk about Al jazer I'm happy to do so uh of course when I say Al jaer I'm talking about Al jazer Arabic um I appeared on the station dozens of times maybe hundreds of times uh from 2005 to 2017 I did all kinds of programs first as a diplomat of course uh and then after I retired as a a a as a pundit as a diplomat I actually twice worked to

4:16 get Al jazer journalists out of prison once in Jordan a local guy who later became head of Al jazer by the way um but more importantly I was uh when I was the head of the US m in Sudan I worked on getting one of the great cause celebras of Al jazer their cameraman Samu Al Hajj released from Guantanamo something the state department and the defense department worked to do and I was there when he arrived at cartoom International Airport I remember the military escort cutting his plastic cuffs and handing them to me as he was taken away to a Big Al jazer press conference I think when you look at Al jazer often there's a mistake made um that we make and that is the major problem with Al jazer is not that it has false information it often does have false information and it's not that it's deeply anti-American it's very against this Administration but it's generally

5:19 anti-American or even that it's anti-israel or anti-semitic it has all of those elements in its daily makeup but but those are not the heart of the matter nor is it the fact that it is a slavish and faithful tool of Cuttery foreign policy something you can see for example if you watch Al jazer which makes a big effort about how they are for a free press and free media and yet when it comes to examp the world's largest Jailer of journalists turkey erdogan's turkey they are silent because of this cozy relationship that exists between the Turkish government and Qatar uh but it gives this impression of kind of being you know being a kind of Patron of of press Freedom none of those things are actually the heart of the matter all of those things are important they're significant the fact that they're that there's anti-Semitism anti-semitic material on aler is significant the fact that it has a daily

6:21 diet of anti-American material is significant all of those things are significant but the greatest problem with alir is how for a generation it has mainstreamed and normalized an islamist grievance narrative which is served as kind of the mother's milk for all sorts of islamist movements you know sometimes we think we've heard of Hamas for example but but basically what what Al jazer did for decades was to serve as kind of the foer or of of of jihadism and islamism or the the entree point for jihadism and islamism even groups that didn't necessarily agree with each other so at different times in Al jaz's history it's been a partisan for example of Hamas continues to be of course but Hezbollah not so much now but there was a time 2006 2007 when it was very much Pro hisbah and very much Pro hisbah

7:24 narrative alqaeda and Isis these are all groups of course that fight each other they're all along the spectrum of islamism and jihadism but what Al jazer did is it set the mood music for the kind of political violent revolutionary appeal that these groups were going to make so in a sense it prepared the ground the kind of ideological psychological political ground for them if you look at the media in the Arab world the media in the Arab in many ways is the media of regimes right it's the discourse of authoritarianism the discourse of dictators well Qatar is an authoritarian regime but its media is different than that of the others it seeks to be the media of Revolution whatever that Revolution is so if you watch it at times it sounds left-wing other times it sounds islamist

8:29 other times it sounds very much in sync with something you might hear coming out of Moscow or tan uh it's not just you know islamism and jihadism I even though Qatar is an authoritarian regime like its neighbors its media is the media of Revolution mostly Islamic revolution but not just Islamic revolution and so what it's done in its politics is to amplify the appeal that these groups have um this I think is the most important thing how they basically tried to ride the populous wave of contending islamism and jihadism for their own purposes so they would promote this kind of unabashed grievance narrative which is tailored for islamist and jihadist solutions so they paint the world in a certain way this is the way the world is this is the reality of the the people responsible for your

9:32 miserable condition are The Usual Suspects and then from the masses rise the great champions of you know reification of of the Arab masses whether the MB or Hamas or hasbalah or Isis or alqaeda so it's so in a way it's it's brilliant because um aler is not alqaeda television or Isis television or any of these but it basically prepares the ground for the The Narrative and the discourse that they're going to push out the region is polarized the region is unstable but this kind of revolutionary Doctrine Amplified in their media makes it even worse and I think a fair person would say yes Alberto but Al jazer are not the only ones to do this that's true there are actually more poisonous networks out there there are worse things out there the problem is Al jazer is the worst one that has a large audience there are

10:39 stations throughout the a world that put out you know 100% racist or 100% bigoted stuff without any disguise but they tend to have small audiences they're significant they they poison the waters they encourage extremism but they don't have the very large footprint that Al jazer has so Al jazer is you could say the most extreme or the most dangerous of those networks or stations or Outlets that tend to put out this type of poison um you know you can say in their defense and I think it's worth exploring is are they the chicken or the egg did Al jazer cause people to become extreme or cause this you know kind of ferment or is it basically reflecting and amplifying kind of you know extreme polarized conspiracy ridden xenophobic narrative that exists in the Arab world as well that's that's certainly something that we can say uh I think that when we look at this

11:44 problem and I think it is a problem um we do have to look at ourselves a little bit it's not hidden what Al jazer in the service of Cuttery foreign policy is doing um and I think three American administrations have not done a great job of monitoring Al jazer content and making the issue a bilateral one of real importance between the United States and Qatar in a way they've they've been able to get away with it because we haven't been as prepared as we should be there was in the Bush Administration there was briefly an inter agency Al jazir working group I was one member of that group that was to monitor its content and see how it could be improved but that initiative was not sustained over time or through administrations the problem then becomes when Administration officials of different administrations would engage with the cutteries they didn't have the information necessary to basically say

12:50 why are you doing this why are you not doing that why are you putting this thing out because it's not as I said it's not that they were put out fake news sometimes it was fake but it was more they putting out skewed biased uh selective news that led to kind of the pushing of a certain world view for that you need someone who really knows what they're talking about right who can who can kind of address that whole thing address that whole reality and unfortunately what's happened in the United States with the American administrations is there never was one stakeholder holder in official Washington who had this portfolio some would say for example that um America I think and I think this is true I think you would probably agree does not do a great job when it comes to tracking propaganda and ideology and when we talk about the threat of of islamism and jihadism much of the threat a large part of the threat as you said is ideological

13:55 it's in the mind the easy thing is when something gets blown up or somebody gets killed but kind of the ideological ferment the kind of incitement that Al jazer and others will do will do is is a harder thing to put your finger on in an Ideal World State Department's under secretary for public diplomacy and public affairs could be the office to kind of do that monitoring and do that engagement but it hasn't turned out that way um you could say the near East Bureau of the state department could do that it hasn't actually happened that way and of course um DOD or the intelligence Community or even the state department when they deal with Qatar there's only a certain amount of bandwidth if you go in and you have 10 issues and Al jazer is number nine your your interlocutors your Cuttery interlocutors are going to understand that well that's important to you but it's not that important you know number one two and three this thing related to Bases or this thing related to funding or this thing related to

14:58 whatever qu operation they're going to realize well we can give we can give on those issues and still continue to do the things that we've been doing unless if it's raised as a priority issue in a bilateral context it will never be fixed it will kind of continue yeah yeah yeah they they you know we hear you we understand you but not really making the changes that are required we need to prepare ourselves to have a kind of much more substance substantive understanding of what they're doing um to be able to address it the steady constant drip drip of poison on Al jazer not a big awful thing but lots of small lethal things every week is something which is hard to put your finger on with Precision if you know if you're a senior official who gets a uh briefing checklist with 20 things on it that you need to be able to talk about and you're you're you're your Cuttery counterpart on those issues is

16:02 going to be able to kind of finesse it and kind of push you off and move on to the next item which maybe is more concrete because when you're talking about something related to propaganda when something talking about related to a narrative and ideology it's a lot harder to put your finger on so I think that there's plenty of of of U of of blame for for for the reality we face H I think the cutteries in many ways have been allowed to do that because they haven't they haven't had a really strong response from us uh as I said it comes and goes we would chastise them about things which were actually not the most important thing you know getting a story wrong the problem isn't getting a story wrong the problem is is how you skew and spin stories throughout the day the things you highlight the things that you don't highlight and that's a much more

17:05 complicated thing I I know earlier today people talked about Cutter's influence operations in the United States uh well Al jazer is in a way is an influence operation uh in the Arab world and it what what it has done it has been able to move the discourse to move the discussion to move the political ferment in ways which have given Aid and Comfort to enemies of the United States they've been able to have their cake and eat it too it didn't need to be that way I don't think it's too late for us to actually challenge them on these things and demand real change rather than the lip service we've gotten in years past thank you very much and I'm happy to answer questions later on I've got one question for you now we've heard before how katar has used its soft power because it doesn't have hard hard power yeah used its money for football for schools how do you reconcile that with your interpretation of el jazer as a

18:10 revolutionary Channel How would it would seem to be contradictory well it's the the idea of the uh you know the guy that keeps throwing people to the tiger hoping that they'll be the last one to be eaten right um they're going to ride that tiger for all its worth and they think that it's it's useful for them and by the way one of the interesting things in the in the Cuttery media space is the cutteries have learned from Al jazer Al jazer is an islamist television network that's its identity uh and in recent years what they've tried to do is diversify and so now you have for example you have pan Arab nationalist media Outlets which are not islamist that are all Al controlled by the cutteries and stuff that azmi bishara is doing for for example this is not islamist but is also friendly or kind of complimentary to Cuttery foreign policy so they they are expanding

19:12 putting their eggs more than in one basket but but but ideally they see themselves as as um you know a an authoritarian regime a traditional regime like its neighbors but one that has bet on that the the the disa dissatisfaction and ferment of the region that already exists and which they work with you know amplify manipulate is of is of use to them a dangerous game no yes dangerous game thank you Muhammad thank you please allow me to share a story with you um I entered the the prison in Egypt accused of uh fabricating news and belonging to the Muslim Brotherhood and um you know fabricating news to fit agenda I just want you to imagine walking sitting in a prison for a crime you didn't commit but then suddenly you

20:17 are approached by scores of 20-year-old students Muslim Brotherhood students or sympathizers with the Muslim Brotherhood and all they're telling you and you're the bureau chief who just took the job few months ago that they've received cameras from Al jazer they have sent footage mostly to Al jazer Arabic that they have received $200 to $300 for videos that they sent to the network now to me here I am trying to prove my innocence I'm shocked and I'm angry at the same time because I come from a an idealistic background the journalist that walked into Iraq on the first day of the war with the LA times as a cub reporter in 2003 and worked with CNN for three years and alhur for a while and what I realized is that Al jazer had spread this network of

21:23 students and Muslim Brotherhood sympathizers all across Egypt and these kids were telling me that they would receive these $200 they would keep a 100 bucks save save it to get married and they would invite their friends they would organize a protest film it send the footage to Al jazer and they would buy sandwich sandwiches to the protesters and produce posters at that point I was angry because if I was told this was happening and I had agreed to it then I would be accountable but this was happening behind my back as a bureau chief of the AL jazer English office so I decided to get the actual confessions of these young students from the prosecutor and I sat in my cell reading their confessions and a lot of it um was corroborated the stories are telling me so often we Judge Al jazer by what you see on the screen but a lot of

22:29 it that angers a lot of these security officials in Egypt and other countries and people who criticize the network is what happens in the news Gathering process which Al jazer has applied in Syria Libya Iraq and many countries where non-journalists we all want to be the first to get the story and the exclusive we all compete to be the best journalists and the first on the on the front line but what they did defied everything that that is related to journalism and I took it even further and I sued the network for their contribution to my incarceration which made my situation even worse in front of the Egyptian government and I am against the incarceration of any journalist and I have an organization that Advocates press freedom but this is not about press Freedom this is about a Network that has resulted in the death of people a lot of these young students were radicalized or were poisoned by the ideas that this network puts on the

23:34 screen and what they they they stand for I mean if you look at some of the content and I've done a documentary film and I've done extensive research that I included in my lawsuit against this Qatari arm that they call a News Network and I am a very angry man when it comes to Al jazer and they're watching now and they know that I'm after them and I will not stop because this is not just a personal issue some of my friends in Al jazer journalists are going to die and some of them have been incarcerated and killed because they have been unknowingly working for a network that recruits terrorists and Muslim Brotherhood um uh agents if you want to call it across the Middle East so you see al-qaradawi one of the The Scholar that was that ran away from Egypt and was given the the citizenship in Qatar uh and he he's a cleric that educates the Amir of Qatar and his father about Islam and everything this guy sits on TV saying the the anchor asks him do you

24:40 agree with suicide bombings in Syria the guy goes no you should not act alone you should never blow up yourself unless it is endorsed by the Brotherhood this is a man who is being watched by millions of people this is a network that res results in the death of soldiers this is the same guy that sat there saying yes kill Egyptian soldiers in Sinai yes it's okay for Al jazer to say that Those Who Kill Israeli civilians are Martyrs 2008 Kar the Hezbollah guy that the the the they call him the resistance he's a terrorist he was in prison he comes out of prison he's killed four Israelis and a young girl they celebr celebrated his release in Al jaz's office in Beirut and aired it on TV is this a News Network and I'm telling this network that I am after you and tonight everything that's been said in this room

25:44 about Qatar is true this is a country that has crossed the line and this is a network that has 80 officers across the world and more and their journalist some of some of them are great journalists but they if they were in my situation and they saw what I saw in prison non-stop stories by Brotherhood Youth and some of these Brotherhood youth it's not even their fault they're fighting for a cause and this network is allowing them to work illegally in Egypt they're allowing them to fabricate news they're allowing them to forward their agenda by putting this content on TV when I worked for CNN covering the revolution in Egypt maybe three or four times I took footage from people who actually filmed an explosion that we didn't get on camera we weren't there but before I put it on air I put the name of the person on the video I made him sign a document I corroborated that this guy is not you know member of a specific group that's what a network does that is citizen

26:46 journalism not what Al jazer does where they give cameras and resources and um uh devices and money all over Egypt in poor areas so here I was sitting in my cell dealing with my incarceration as a journalist and my lawyers were like you need to just you know figure it out are you going to go out with all this I'm like yes I will go out with all this because I'm not going to stand in front of the judge all day saying I'm not a Muslim Brotherhood terrorist I'm going after the network as well because what I saw inside was unbelievable and um a lot of these youth these Muslim Brotherhood youth were telling me how they watched Al jazer and how they believed in it so you know it's not it's a network that calls for revolution but you never see them calling for um calling out the non-democratic state of Qatar that has no labor unions no fresh Freedom no elections it's only the other

27:50 countries that need to have elections you know and in my lawsuit I'm having so much fun with my lawsuit because allows me to discover more and more and if you're watching you know what I got you know these guys not only do they um you know there was there was the hacking thing you know Al jazer does it really cool you know they and and the AL the qari intelligence they hack the people anyone that criticizes them and that's what happened to me as well and they send the New York Times Reporter uh the flash drive he calls me and others and says yeah you know what I got all these documents and stuff you know and I'm going to write a story like go ahead write the story al jaaz already has their guests ready because the story is coming out tomorrow and they're sourcing the New York Times but it's all been orchestrated by the qari intelligence that has full control of the network it's not even debatable what this network is about when people say I am all for press freedom I have been

28:53 calling every government out there since my started my career about respecting journalism and it stands for but when you have a network that uses its qari and you know they spread their money as we all said here today to these great organizations like cpj and amnesty and others when when they get all cornered about you know signing up for Farah and saying oh this is against press Freedom it ain't about press Freedom this is a network that promotes terrorism it it promotes the incitement and results in death and radicalization of people there's no question about it so what what thank you so much could you tell us the nature of your lawsuit what is your yeah so my lawsuit is based on uh the fact that they were working without proper documentation that's one uh the second fact is that they were without telling us journalists that they were dealing with uh people who are considered as terrorists and giving them equipment

29:56 like I said and giving them money and defying all the um the ethics of Journalism while their professional journalists were trying to do their job ethically so they were basically supporting these terrorist groups working illegally in Egypt without telling us and of course I submitted all these emails that corroborate me asking them are you working legal legally in Egypt they say no no no don't worry about it you take care of your um editorial stance and we got it under control okay and yeah so basically that is what the website the is about in effect you were hired under false pretenses exactly it seemed like you were this but you in fact that that is correct and where is the lawsuit the lawsuit is in Vancouver Canada I am Canadian Egyptian so I filed it in the British Columbia Court and I've submitted hundreds of documents including affidavits from you know K the former qari uh Minister Justice Minister and when they hacked my inbox they got a they got they saw all my cards before I

31:01 even submitted the the the documents to the lawsuit so they started taking it more serious and they started preparing themselves and they banned the Justice Minister from leaving Qatar and amnesty the whole thing about it I mean you know these guys operate you know in such an evil manner I mean when I say I'm after you and when I send them this message I'm after you with my pen with my camera and in court you're taking it out of Court that's another thing play ball thank you thank Samantha um first I want to say that it's a real honor to be here thank you to Dr pipes and my colleagues at the Middle East forum for working so hard to organize this event and of course to my esteemed co-panelists um it's really a pleasure um so we just marked the 17 th anniversary of the murder of journalist Pearl in an interview with the Wall

32:05 Street Journal a few years after his death his father Professor Judea Pearl um called Al jazer one of the most dangerous organizations in the world today we are talking here about an organization which is committed to weakening the west and they are doing it under the cloak of ordinary journalism Professor Pearl's observation shows why it is crucial I argue that the US Department of Justice and the Federal Communications Commission require Al jazer to register as a foreign agent it is time our government helps to strip this harmful network of this veneer of legitimacy aside from its seemingly Limitless qari funding alzer's major strength as an anti-western propaganda out Outlet is its methodological flexibility its adaptable dawa if you will alzer's core ideology is islamist Islamic supersessionism and Supremacy

33:12 and a belief in the fundamental evil of Jews Christians and the West in general that's constant it doesn't change but in service of these ideals deception and incitement to hatred and violence are key tools used from platform to platform language to language and the network shifts its messaging to entice and seduce its unique audiences and ultimately increase worldwide support for its causes and values for the Arab and Muslim world where anti-jewish anti-American conspiracy theories are common and part of the normal discourse you might say Al jazer engages in islamist accusations of Jewish control um American government or American Media subservience to Jewish actors and of course predictions of Islam's conquest of the United

34:16 States for instance in August Arab News reported that since the 2016 presidential election Al jazer has the administration and Donald Trump in more than 1,800 disparaging news and opinion pieces often describing him in crudely anti-semitic terms calling him the conductor of the orchestra of Satan and insisting that he is either Jewish or controlled by Jewish forces the Network's equal contempt for America and its president were communicated for just days after the 2016 presidential election ction in a published open letter to the president-elect titled message to Donald Trump after declaring Trump devoid of culture and a stupid person the author explained that he actually hoped Trump would win the election so the world could see America's ugly face meanwhile

35:23 Al jazer Arabic political cartoons on Trump His Image is caricatured as a worm a serpent or with a bag of cash stuffed into his mouth and indeed Trump's victory has been kind of a windfall for islamists the world over including Al jazer in the west where serious citations of the protocols of the Elders of Zion are less acceptable Trump policies such as the much protested Muslim uh travel restrictions which is termed the Muslim ban by American islamist groups have inspired an explosion of nonprofit islamist networks um substituting motifs of Jewish control and those with those of Zionist influence it is just as Alberto talked about this nonprofit islamist network has exploded a narrative in English the work attacks

36:28 American society and president Trump under the guise of anti-racism and advocacy for oppressed populations Al jaaz english's website uses language crafted to attract Western progressives It's About Us section claims that its vision is to be the voice for the voiceless and its values deceptively include speaking truth to power in our journalism as well as amongst ourselves this language mirrors language used by the larger American islamist scene in the last decade or so American islamist organizations and alzer's Western geared programming have increasingly inspired and mimicked one another for example the islamist organization American Muslims for or honors hosts and employs speakers who use Arabic to spout anti-jewish and

37:32 anti-American conspiracy theories at 's annual conference in November it hosted a turkey-based professor called Abdullah Maru whose Arabic tweets espouse vicious anti-semitic motifs and stereotypes but 's English website features a quote from the group's co-founder the notorious islamist professor hatm bazan exhorting others to listen to the voice of the voiceless meanwhile in this March am's annual fundraising banquet will feature Mark Lamont Hill delivering a keynote lecture on the theme of you guessed it speaking truth to power the AL jaaz conglomerate has harnessed left leaning audiences even Beyond those in groups like amp with as Brooke talked about AJ plus an online news platform featuring short easily sharable video clips it broadcasts in

38:35 several languages and is integrated very closely with social media platforms so is attractive to Millennials like myself aj+ even more than aler English targets Young left-leaning Americans by focusing on areas of progressive interest such as the patriarchy or lgbtq rights though promoting intersectionality feminism and same-sex marriage appears at odds with islamist ideology Al jazer allows aj+ to cover such topics favorably so that a Sinister accompanying ideological message is afforded legitimacy AJ Plus's branding allows Doha to Pedal anti-Semitism and anti-americanism to a younger audience under the guise of minority rights casting Israelis and Israel in general as racist or oppressive is crucial to Al jazer and Western islamists at large broader agenda to manipulate the

39:37 thinking of their audiences the AJ plus Branch thus dedicates considerable airtime to covering aspects of uh islamist groups like uh AJ plus uh excuse me um aspects of the Israeli Arab conflict to portray Israel as the aggressor like American islamist groups AJ plus and alaz English then insulate themselves from charges of anti-Semitism by condemning overt acts of anti-jewish terrorism in the United States such as the Pittsburgh shooting AJ plus spreads anti-americanism with a similar anti-racist slant one AJ plus video features short clips of young adults in American flag plastered clothing not to brag but we have the most incarcerated people in the world God bless the prison industrial complex Americans consume 80% of the world's painkillers makes sense though right I mean racism in this country is a big pain in the ass the size and influence of alzer's

40:41 network and with it clutter's ability to influence public opinion has truly ballooned with more than 65 bureaus worldwide and broadcasts in multiple languages Al jazer has succeeded in branding itself as a hard hard hitting example of in Hillary Clinton's notorious words real news instead alera is just another Cog in a vast islamist machine that has managed to cultivate its strongest allies among those who should know better and oppose it most forcefully liberals for these reasons it is crucial that the networks anti-jewish and anti-American propaganda and duplicity in every language be identified and thank you thank you I have a lot of questions for you but I'm told that we're out of time so you are spared thank you all thank you fansa Ambassador Mohammed fi thank you thank

41:43 you for this very incisive thank you