MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Israel Insider

Israel Insider

Watch Israel Insider on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

July 1st marks Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu's date set to start annexing parts of the West Bank. But will this happen? Either way, what will be the domestic, regional and international reactions?

Transcript Automatic captions

Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 12, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.

0:00 hello and welcome to the middle east forum speaker webinar series israel insider with mr ashley perry i'm stacy roman and i will be moderating this discussion today we are pleased to have mr ashley perry advisor to the middle east forum's israel office join us here each wednesday at 3 p.m eastern to update us on all things mr perry will be giving us a briefing on the current affairs for 10 to 15 minutes and open it up for questions should you wish to ask a question please use the q a box located at the bottom of your screen we'll do our best to get to all questions but we have many participants on this webinar so i apologize in advance if we do not get to yours today and now with no further ado i'll turn the discussion over to mr ashley perry thank you very much stacy um and good evening from israel uh today's the day we've been talking about it now for weeks if not months uh today was the day that uh the coalition deal signed between uh benjamin netanyahu's like and benny access blue and white allowed the beginning of a process to apply uh

1:05 israeli sovereignty to uh portions up to i think about 30 percent 29 of judea and sumeria in the west bank uh everyone was looking at this day for a while it was considered to be a very crucial day a day where something at least however symbolic could happen but basically today has come and gone anything uh at most uh prime minister netanyahu put out um a communique uh during the day basically saying that discussions are still taking place um and they will be ongoing over the next few days offering who is a minister and he could minister in the government uh basically said that uh he believes that something will happen this month uh there's still consultations with the americans and that seems to be where uh the momentum has stopped for the moment at least uh it seems you know avi berkowitz who is the us envoy uh to uh on the peace plan he uh took over

2:08 from jason greenblatt he was in israel today he's gone back to debrief jared kushner adviser to the president and obviously son-in-law about where things stand and then apparently that will then be taken up to the president himself and it's suggested by some people in the know that a decision will be made by the president or at least some senior people around him exactly what's going to happen now over the last few days what's suddenly put a bit of a spanner in the works is there's been this uh seeming and reported demand that uh israel provide a quid pro quo for america allowing or giving the green to israel to apply its sovereignty over parts of judea and samaria um there's been all sorts of talk of however much percent israel applies its sovereignty to israel should then allow the palestinians to move certain territory from area c to area b those who are not familiar with what these areas are

3:10 in the 1993 oslo peace plan the west bank judea and samaria was split up into three areas area a which was full palestinian control which is where 98 of palestinians live area b which was under palestinian civilian control but israel's security control on area c which was around 60 um of the territory which was under full israel control and obviously that's where all the settlements the israeli communities uh reside uh at this point in time or at in recent months or even years there's been a great push uh by the palestinians to try and uh push certain areas from area c to area b so they can get some sort of control and in those areas it's been quite a controversial issue as you can imagine so the raising of that by the americans is certainly going to be something which will cause a certain amount of outcry liquids right wing amongst the more

4:13 settler leadership who are already very skeptical on this whole application of sovereignty move because they don't feel it goes far enough and it could lead to what they that particular uh part of the british i believe is a worrying possibility of a palestinian state that for them is uh shouldn't be on the cards that's their particular belief um so some sort of quid pro quo some sort of compromise and concession to the is probably where we're at at the moment there has to be some gesture it can't be all uh at this point uh on israel uh that is probably where we're at at the moment um there's been a lot of back and forth you know uh avi as i said avi berkowitz david freeman the ambassador who met with not just netanyahu and his people but also benny gatz and foreign minister ashkenazi who are pretty reticent on this issue in fact uh what caused a bit of a stir this week is when bunny benny goes

5:15 was asked about annexation and his response is there are more important things to deal with uh the economy fighting coronavirus et cetera et cetera and uh prime minister netanyahu reacted to that uh when he met with the iranian the the u.s point person on iran who was in the region went to uae went to saudi arabia a few other places and he came to israel and netanyahu basically said on the iran issue but with a sort of also a wink in a nod to the sovereignty issue he said there were certain things that could not wait until after corona um moving on to the sort of tension you know i've talked about the tension between the parties a couple of people in the knesset this week said to me they don't believe this government is going to last a few months uh we have a major major hurdle uh which is the budget that's uh there's a bit of a fight over the budget at the as we said uh i think in a previous uh uh there's an israeli law that says a new government has to pass a budget by

6:18 a certain amount of time i believe it's three months or something like that and if not then we go to automatic uh according to the coalition agreement there's there's supposed to be a budget for every two years this is an innovation which the israeli government has tried over a certain amount of years there's a lot of economists who say it gives more stability to the markets to more stability to the israeli government understanding in advance what's going to be the budgets now prime minister netanyahu has called for a one-year budget his claim is and he's backed up by certain people within the financial system by the finance minister and others that we need to do this one by one uh one year by one year because there's so many unknowns with covid with the economic depression which is sweeping the world so it'd be a little bit difficult to broadcast or forecast i should say what should be the budget for next year so they're very much in favor of moving it to a one-year budget and in fact interestingly enough

7:21 yes charles katz the finance minister met with yay lapid who has become benny guns uh arch nemesis after being his partner and uh yay lapid put out an interesting tweet where he says he fully backs the on the one year uh process as opposed to two at the moment any council's giving in and israel cat said if this is not sorted out by the end of august simply we will go to new elections um which again according to my song my sources in the political world is certainly not uh unlikely uh there's a lot of tension a lot of mistrust almost every day there's sniping between ministers even uh prime minister netanyahu's son yay got involved with this telling a minister in coalition run by his own father to shut up on twitter um so you can imagine you know the the relationships uh are certainly not great interestingly enough uh this week we had the first poll in quite a while which showed netanyahu's favorability uh decrease for the first time it showed

8:24 that his liquid party while they will still be by far the largest party and the right-wing religious bloc will still a majority uh liquid would move a few seats down um from the the previous poll um his favorability rating or at least uh his rating by the public and how he dealing with the coronavirus uh went from the mid 70s and now is just over 50 again that's pretty good numbers those are pretty good numbers but it shows that his numbers are sinking it's something which i said a while ago and i i believe that they will continue to sink as the situation worsens in israel the situation as far as the number of infections every day is at an all-time high we almost reached 1000 infections in one day which i don't think we saw even at the worst peak uh in the first wave health minister edostein has said that israel is on the cusp of the second wave and while the numbers of infections are

9:27 up the numbers which are most crucial for israel and any government dealing with us you know to ensure that we don't overload the health system are still low the amount of deaths is still very very low uh the amount of people on uh ventilating machines which is a crucial metric uh i believe there's still 29 and israel has about two or three thousand uh ventilators and other serious cases is again below so those numbers are certainly not rising but the numbers of infected israelis are but the overwhelming vast majority i think is something like 99 of uh people have been infected in the couple of weeks are showing mild or no so while it's a worrying trend it's not impacting on you know the idea that we could be facing uh another lockdown uh what's going to happen has only started happening is they're going to be red zones where certain neighborhoods

10:29 certain towns perhaps even cities will be on lockdown to try and uh stem the the spread they've already limited um weddings from 250 to 100 and religious meetings also have gone down to about i believe it's 50 in a closed room um so there are steps we are moving back towards some sort of more restrictive measures the palestinians are actually moving far they they had about 280 cases in the last day and that's pretty high for them and as a friday they will pretty much be a complete lockdown again so their numbers are not looking so good and it's it's something that both both populations are seem to be on a second wave and uh both leaders are trying to stem uh this rise but neither seem to be successful at the moment so those are some of the things as i said the iranian the the u.s point man uh on iran was in

11:33 the region interestingly enough when asked a question uh during during a media outing he uh said that again all options are on the table dealing with iran there's a great worry about iran in the region especially with the iaea latest reports which basically disbarred any sort of visitors and on the iranian nuclear programme and there's a very strong amount of worry between you know the sunni gulf countries the uh saudi arabia and also israel so while a lot of the uh world is focusing on uh sovereignty it's interesting that almost in every single speech or interview that prime minister europe gave this week iran was number one was the top of the bill for him as it has remained for for quite a while and sovereignty has been sort of a little bit hushed perhaps that's because there's no

12:35 movement on it at this point uh they're as as i said they probably will be at some point uh this month but there seems need to be a little bit more clarity and a bit more coordination with the there's been major pushback by a lot of uh other western countries in europe etc we had two op-eds uh in the last 24 hours one by the eu high representative for foreign policy which is de facto the foreign minister of the eu and one by uh the british prime minister boris johnson both of them basically saying as friends of israel we recommend highly not to go forward uh annexation it will harm israel's the eu representative went a little bit further and said it could harm uh eu relations the joint list which is predominantly arab parties that she wrote to the high representative eu representative and actually called for sanctions against israel including uh the freezing of the uh eu israel association agreement which is

13:40 basically the agreement which governs and relations between the eu and israel so there's a lot of pressure a lot of outside pressure a lot of internal pressure um to try and stem or stop uh or even reverse uh the idea that israel should or will apply uh its sovereignty over the green line and with that um i'm happy to uh answer any questions all right thank you so much so you're discussing the coded situation um what is the status of allowing tourists to come to israel and could you comment on ll's situation so first of all um as far as uh tourists there are no tourists um at least until august um because basically israel has a currently that no non-citizens uh can enter israel there are some exceptions if you're a long-term resident if you're learning in

14:42 a particular if you're learning in the seminary but only for marriage uh couples and not for singles uh but just a very few exceptions but basically non-israelis are not not allowed in tuition at this point and i don't see that changing the foreseeable future and even if they were able to they would have to then undergo uh two weeks isolation so very few tourists are going to want to come to israel uh having to stay in a room for two weeks uh ll has been flying very intimately but basically they've grounded all planes and that's largely an internal um over the last few months have basically just been doing a few flights here and there to rescue quote unquote israeli stranded in countries around the world in australia and latin america i think in in other places but at the moment uh ll is not flying uh they still have a very large amount uh its work their workers on furlough and they're waiting for you know what they would see as a

15:44 as a bailout from the government because it's part owned by the government it's the national carrier of israel so there's ongoing negotiations there the israeli government did make them an offer a few weeks back and it was rejected so that's the current situation and uh the original date august 1st for allowing at least certain countries to be allowed to come into seems to now be pushed off i mean israel didn't even make the eu list of countries which could uh which could travel into the into europe i mean there was only a few countries which were put on the red list the us russia israel and just a few so the situation here as far as international travel is actually getting worse in recent weeks and i don't think uh i don't think that the the summer will bring too many tourists to israel thank you can you update us as to the status of developing relations with the gulf states particularly particularly the uae well the relations the the move towards

16:49 what's what's called normalization uh between israel and the pragmatics sony gulf nations uae saudi arabia others has been moving progressively uh over the last few years uh even the last few months the big question which a lot of people are asking is will annexation the application of sovereignty affect those uh we spoke about it in the previous way but now how uh ua ambassador to washington said that you can't have both you can't have normalization and annexation but then a couple of days later the foreign minister of the uae basically said that we can have these uh disputes and disagreements but we can still move forward to stronger relations so a bit of a mixed message there i've always said that i don't believe that relations will necessarily be affected because the relations are based on far more what both sides will see as more important issues i.e iran which is absolutely essential which is seen as an existential uh challenge to both israel and the gulf

17:51 nations whereas the palestinian issue is not seen anywhere near that uh there's also uh close relations or or sort of close on even the fight against coronavirus which certainly has seen is more uh high-tech innovation sharing uh you research and development these are all issues which these nations value far more than their relations with the palestinians which quite simply a lot of them are fed up with uh how muhammad abbas has run uh things recently and they've been showing that uh more more openly so i don't personally think um if there is any application or sovereignty and the jury is still out on that as i said you know the length and breadth of that relations uh will be necessarily affected too deeply uh between israel and the gulf nations thank you along those lines you were talking about the eu um you know discussing sanctions against israel if it were to move forward

18:53 uh would this be in the best interest for israel to go forward with these plans despite this well there's no real sanctions on the most uh senior politicians in europe whether it's the eu itself or individual countries i mean we saw germany the german parliament is going to pass a resolution calling on israel not to annex et cetera et cetera but there are no sanctions involved in this resolution the same with boris johnson's letter in the israeli media he basically the uk prime minister he uh also didn't talk about any sort of knock-on effect he just said that this is not what israel is he tried to make the moral argument without really using any sort of stick um the eu high representative the foreign minister the eu did hint at some sort of uh harming of relations but again without putting in too many details there are certainly some extreme left elements in europe that

19:55 have called for sanctions there was a letter i think it was 18 mps members of parliament from the british parliament all of them labor i believe all of them for the far left of the labour party who did specifically call for sanctions uh against israel should it do so and there's been some from holland and a few others so there will certainly be individuals within europe who will be calling for sanctions but we don't really see it openly we don't see it at the highest level um they certainly will behind closed doors be hinting at some sort of stick you know to sort of beat israel to sort of show that there are consequences to it um but it's it's not something which israelis the israeli public i think that these individuals these senior figures who are writing articles in the israeli it's not something that will affect uh israeli public opinion no matter how many of these articles are israel doesn't have the strongest affinity to europe at the political level at least

20:58 um they believe that europe you know is against them anyway uh so they won't make uh pay too much attention to this um even though they're not really paying too much attention let's say to the whole issue anyway it's not considered one of the priorities for most israelis um but you know it looks it looks it looks good from the european uh point of view that they are at least warning israel but at the moment there are no sanctions on the if there are i think they'll be largely things that could hurt israel certainly the horizon 2020 program that israel is a part of there's threats to not allow israel to continue on that program which again wouldn't be the biggest deal in the world but it's certainly something which israel enjoys and certainly europe enjoys as well uh so even something like that could be harmful but not to the level of the eu uh israel association agreement thank you so you were discussing the do you think they would accept anything

22:01 or is this just a political move well the palestinians are not interested uh in coming to the table although they did i say that they did come out with a plan of their own which they uh sent to the quartet who even remembers there is a quartet you know that was something that was created a number of years ago you know tony blair was the head of it a number a number of years ago and you know they haven't really done much since the quartet for those who don't know is the the u.s russia the eu and the u.n and they were supposed to be the four partners to try and help move the peace process forward so the palestinians did apparently send some sort of a plan which is interesting in itself because the palestinians have had no interest not even on a symbolic level to do anything on the peace process for many many years so the fact that they did that obviously shows they feel that they're in a certain amount of corner but it was nothing unpredictable in there basically it said uh we called to restart negotiations on the basis of the 2008 understandings and if we remember

23:04 that that was erdogan's very generous offer of 100 of the territory there's some minor land swaps half of jerusalem the holy site some refugees i mean basically everything the palestinians wanted so to start negotiations from there they know it's non-starter you know they're the ones who rejected it the israeli offer was there it was serious it was on the table the palestinians rejected it so you know anyone who's involved in negotiations knows that you can't keep on saying no and then just saying okay let's start again from that point so it's a non-starter but it's it shows that there is some pressure on the palestinians to be seen to be acting uh which is an interesting development in itself thank you so on another topic are there any insights on the explosion east of tehran earlier this i mean not not that much that i can give any more insight to what's uh you know read in the paper you know i'm sure that there are some very senior intelligence people in israel who will have far greater insight so i i'm i'm certainly not going to uh

24:05 give any my opinion on that because uh you know i i just know what i've read in in the newspapers there all right thank you for the try um so what is the level of the coronavirus impact on syria and lebanon can you comment on the deep economic crises in both syria you know syria is basically de facto barely estate fairly functioning as a state today you know its leadership is basically run from moscow or tehran we see and and to a lesser extent uh so the economic impact on a state which whose economy is anyway massively impacted by the civil war um it's you know we don't know what the numbers coming out of syria i think as far as the official figures they have no coronavirus but we all know that's you know not true uh lebanon is a different story lebanon has coronavirus their economy is uh proceeding it's it's it's they're in big trouble and we've seen a lot of

25:07 demonstrations recently interestingly from an israeli angle what usually happens is when hezbollah who make up a strong part of the government control to a large extent of the government whenever they need a bit of a release and a diversion and then they start saber-rattling against israel we saw a video come out recently which shows that that they have a new level of precision missiles which they claim can reach any single point in israel wherever it may be and we know that that's a threat with a certain amount of truth to it um because hezbollah are certainly feeling the heat uh in lebanon there's a lot of demonstrations and fizmalov sent in their uh you know bullies let's say uh to beat up protesters and they they got a lot of uh you know bad press uh recently and even the american ambassador waded into the debate there and she got a bit of uh talking to let's say from the uh from the lebanese government and there

26:08 was a meeting and there was a big show of it how you know they wanted to show her about the dysplasia so things are certainly heating up there internally and as we've seen in the past when things heat up internally hezbollah sometimes use us as a bit of a escape valve and that's also better for worry thank you how would annexation affect the relationship between israel and the diaspora of jews um well it depends who you ask i mean there are those who say it's a positive thing obviously those who are in favor of it and those you know there's been many letters or many uh you know by organizations or individuals or small groups but again it pretty much splits as to your ideology obviously if you're more right you'll be more accepting more welcoming left you'll be more against and opposed it's certainly not going to win us too many friends because the majority let's say of dice were jews are more to the left than israelis

27:12 partly because of the reality that israel finds itself partly because that's just the demographic makeup most jews in america for example vote democrat and democrats are far less likely according to all polls and according to the politicians themselves far less likely to support annexation in any way whereas the republican party has been far more supportive especially when this is part of the trump land which is obviously a republican president um so the jury is still out again i think as i've said before a lot will depend on the length of breadth a lot will depend how it plays out how manages to communicate its policy um but we've seen you know we've seen greater ruptures between us from the diaspora in the past and we've got over it and i think that as long as we're able to communicate this policy in a sensible incredible way i don't think there'll be any lasting what is the status of the east

28:14 mediterranean plant pipeline and the threat of turkish interference well the threat is always there we've seen a lot of talks between israel and greece israel and cyprus in recent days you know they've come across even with uh the problematic status with corona virus etc and while tourism will certainly be on an issue as we've seen uh that particular plan is you know front and center is the most important thing for these nations turkey is livid with what's going on and they will certainly try as much as possible to with the process but at the moment it's going on without them the relationship between israel and turkey is pretty low uh but then has been pretty low for for a number of years and there's certainly no interest on the turkish side to raise those relations or things down because again like i said about hezbollah erdogan basically he has an interest in distracting deflecting his public by

29:18 blaming israel for all sorts of things so they will try certainly and disrupt it because it's you know not just for on a geopolitical but on an economic basis it certainly harms their interests but that remains to be seen exactly how or if they will be able to do anything consequential all right thank you so much and this is the last question of the evening for you afternoon for us uh why are the people in the jordan valley many of whom are farmers against annexation when israel is a major in controlling influence is against it oh i believe the question is the people in the jordan valley i mean there's israelis in this palestinians the palestinians will be against it uh the israelis to the best of my knowledge uh are mostly for it um i haven't heard too objection um i mean we're talking about areas the jordan valley especially which are largely uh unpopulated or relatively unpopulated

30:23 but at the end of the day israel's argument about the jordan valley as opposed to more populated settlements is on a more plane and that's something which successive governments have talked about that's something which i think even the left of center in israel are very much in favor of any guarantee and appear to have talked about uh annexation of the georgian valley even before it became the official policy of the israeli government because of that uh vital security uh strategic interest so i i think i'm sure there will be some israelis will be against it who live in the jordan valley most of them are not ideological settlers uh they're there because of the land because of as you said their farms the uh area and it's very very good agricultural land so there'll be certainly those who will be against it on a geological basis but it won't be significant enough uh rejection there for that to be put off that to put off the israeli government all right well thank you so much i think

31:27 personally i'm looking forward to see what happens with the budget uh whether there will be another election uh we have come to the close of our webinar though mr prairie thank you again for taking time to update your next week uh please be sure to tune in next week to see what will unfold on friday we will not be having a webinar as we are off for the 4th of please be on the lookout for our weekly web webinar offerings coming out over the weekend thank you all again for joining us and i hope you have a wonderful day