Webinar or Talk
The Middle East and South Asia Come Together with Seth Oldmixon
Watch on YouTube
Description
The Middle East and South Asia and are very distinct regions. But new connections, such as between Israel and India, Turkey and Pakistan, and among Islamist groups, are increasingly affecting them both. What is the current situation, what are the trends, and what are the implications?
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 6, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:00 okay good afternoon and welcome to the Middle East forums podcast series featuring talks from Middle East forums projects um I am Cliff Smith of the Middle East forums Washington project and I'll be moderating this discussion today uh the format of this webinar and podcast will be a 15minute interview followed by 15 minutes of question and answer from the audience if you want to ask a question please use a Q&A box located at the bottom of your screen to type a question um and now I am for I am pleased to introduce Our Guest Seth old Mixon Seth is a former Peace Corp volunteer in Bangladesh and the found founder of Liberty South Asia um he is an expert on the region and he is here to discuss the middle east and south Asia come together as the name suggests the Middle East Forum um we at the Middle East for are predominantly concerned with the Middle East however um the world is increasingly interconnected and in a world where relationships between countries far outside the Middle East have a large impact on what happens within the Middle East and with those
1:02 that are interacting with the Middle East um this has always been the case but it is increasingly so and it is even more true today now than it was even very recently and the connections and um relationships with State actors non-state actors many others are growing daily and the importance of them are growing daily uh moreover the problems in the Middle East um such as the ideological contagion of radical Islam knows no bounds um what what is in the Middle East does not stay in the Middle East and what is in South Asia does not stay in South Asia and vice versa um I'll get started by asking a few questions um just as I said and then go to the audience question so just can start tying in whenever you'd like in the meantime Seth let's start with a big issue the collaboration between India and Israel is increasingly public um for just a few examples um Prime Minister Modi became the first Indian Prime Minister to visit Israel um the islamist foes of Israel um and India are increasingly openly working together and they are increasingly large um trade
2:04 Partners as well um so basically big picture question how have we gotten here what is the future of this relationship what are potential pitfalls that we might want to look at thanks cliff and uh thanks for having me today um you know as you mentioned uh you know things don't stay um within when the borders or regions um as we would like them to and I think that the relationship between between India and Israel is um one that really demonstrates that um look Israel is a middle eastern democracy um and it has you know been threatened by violent extremist groups in the region uh islamist groups in particular uh for a long time India uh is um not only you know the largest democracy in South Asia um it is you know really the largest democracy in the world and India too has also suffered from attacks by uh violent extremist
3:09 islamist groups um in the region and quite often these groups do um collaborate um there have been instances um of collaboration information Personnel sharing between uh radical extremist groups like uh jamat dawa uh also known as flash great taiba that has been responsible for some really uh horrible terrorist attacks in India uh collaborating with uh radical islamist groups um in in uh Palestine so you know we see these radical groups don't recognize borders um and you know India and Israel um both as uh democracies um you know have a shared interest in uh protecting um themselves but also in defeating this um violent extremist ideology that that sees no borders you mentioned trade they have
4:11 been large trade Partners um India has um also been a um you know they have a major um trade in in uh security and in arms um between I believe 2015 to 2019 um India um made up something like 45% of um Israeli military hardware um procurement so um and that's you know that's the sort of the public side of things there's also certainly um intelligence sharing and intelligence cooperation working against these shared groups now pitfalls um you know one of the I think real challenges here is that they feed um you know this this cooperation as important as it is can feed the uh radical uh propaganda the conspiracy theories so one of the things we hear in South Asia um among the extremist um talking points is a reference to uh Hindu zionists um and
5:17 you know really trying to play up this this um India Israeli Nexus from a from the perspective of a a a radical um uh you know extremist ideological conspiracy um and in fact um you know this has um impacts outside of of India um as well we saw earlier this year where uh Bangladesh um another uh South Asian democracy one that has um was um founded as a secular State and uh has you know since founding in 1971 really struggled against um attempts to uh turn it into a Theocratic State um we saw the current government earlier this year removed um the uh reference in the Bangladeshi passport to um not allowing travel to Israel and there was there was
6:22 quickly a a large um outcry particularly among um you know farri and r islamist groups suggesting that you know this was some sort of conspiracy that this was some sort of um you know the the government of Bangladesh um being controlled by Western powers or something like that it's all utterly ridiculous but you see how this can feed into these extremist narratives that they use for recruitment yeah I I you you make a good point and beyond that one thing that's interesting is I've noticed actually some of these same radical islamist actors that you're talking about are actually also specifically in public going after both India and Israel for the arms trade that you mentioned and trying to make this into some Grand conspiracy of course of course which is just interesting I mean there's been quite a few articles written in um qari propaganda Turkish propaganda P Pakistani propaganda um and that actually leads me to my next question which is another big issue is the increasingly close relationship between turkey and Pakistan um of course
7:26 these countries have a historic relationship it's not new but erdogan I would say has increasingly been looking to non-muslim majority non-arab Muslim majority countries that is as the Arab world has drifted away from his Direction and his way of looking at things to sort of set him up as a world leader and they are increasingly thus um along Pakistan and turkey are increasingly collaborating on economics and even in Conflict areas with non-arab Muslim majority countries Pakistan Chief among them just recently turkey and Pakistan side protocol to improve interparliamentary ties and conflict areas such as Cyprus Kashmir and the Israel palestin people were specifically mentioned as areas where they may collaborate um where do you think this is going um and what do you think each of these countries are trying to get out of their relationship with each other sure well I you know so I think that turkey and Pakistan are very interesting to talk to talk about um uh especially together you know um here you
8:32 have two countries um that sort of come from this these sort of parallel Traditions that were um nominally secular you have um you know ataturk's secular approach to um Society in turkey and uh the founding father of Pakistan Muhammad Ali Jenna um you know despite Pakistan being established as um a a a Muslim country um it's sort of complicated with the two Nation Theory um but but Muhammad Ali Jenna in his early um speeches was was explicitly secular um in his thinking um and what you've seen um in both countries especially um recently but you know certainly in Pakistan quite quickly is was a a reversion to this idea of uh a society and a state that is um based in a a religious identity and one that tends to become um you know more extreme so you know where you have uh these two leaders in
9:34 both countries IM ranan in Pakistan and erdogan and turkey they both have a vision of their societies and of the future that is largely defined by um a a very Theocratic um a very um religiously defined um radically religiously defined um social and political identity and there's something that you know there there are um in in Pakistan especially among radical uh islamist extremist groups violent extremist groups there is uh something that you know folks may have have heard some talk about but this uh prophecy known as gazay Hind and it's the idea that the uh islamist groups are going to um rise up and Conquer All of of India um really all of South Asia um and you know there's behind this idea is this again transnational trans Regional
10:38 idea of um the rise of an Islamic halate an Islamic theocracy um that is is transnational um and I think that you know in Turkey um especially um you know you can see there's there's a book that I want to recommend um if you haven't read it it's by um tamim anari and the TI of the book is Destiny disrupted and what it looks at is the the decline of um of the Ottoman Empire and the the last calefate and this idea um that is prevalent among some that um that was an anomaly in history and that the calefate is going to rise again um and you know I think that there are um parallels in that sort of prophetic um future of a an isamic Global calefate that can be found in the political thinking um between Pakistan and turkey and so they have you know that in common yeah um on the topic of um of
11:44 um we are witnessing before our eyes the complete withdrawal of the US forces from Afghanistan and there's a lot of people wondering what's going to come next um this is true both for Afghanistan but also what the US Retreat will mean for The Wider region and it doesn't take genius to figure out that what happens in Afghanistan matters to the Middle East one only needs to think about Osama Bin Laden in 911 to make that painfully obvious so how do you think that'll affect um both South Asia and the Middle East um and how do you think that will affect those who subscribed sort of a radical ideology be that you know political islamist jihadist groups some combination of the two so on and so forth well I think that we're already seeing some of that we're already seeing um a lot of these uh IAL islamist groups um pointing to this um as they have been for years as a um a proof of this this prophetic vision of the return of this sort of global Islamic halate um it's been very encouraging uh to you know
12:48 let's just be honest it's been very encouraging to Violent extremist groups because they see this as um you know a demonstration of of this sort of rag tag band of um Islamic Jihadi Fighters being able to defeat um you know not just the worlds but you know arguably you know um history's um most powerful um uh Force and and they see that as as proof of of their mission and proof that that they will succeed so I think it's going to continue to be encouraging um I'll you know recommend a recent article in foreign affairs by um Pakistan's former Ambassador Hussein hakani who is now at the Hudson Institute where he talks about um with Pakistan in particular but I think it you know the the lessons are can be extrapolated far beyond of the um the consequences the blowback um for
13:51 the region uh that is is very likely to come from this uh this rapid withdraw um you know I'm I'm one who I'll tell you Cliff um I I think that there may be a slight overstatement of um the uh us withdrawal from the region certainly ground forces are being withdrawn um I I would think I would certainly hope that uh the United States is not completely you know just walking away from the area I think that yeah no I I I I intended to say withdrawal from Afghanistan the troops I should have said Afghanistan at the region that was well sure no that but but you know to that point um you know I think that um you know Pakistan certainly has um you know facilitated the Taliban in Afghanistan um you know that's demonstrated by the leadership living there um you know sort of passing rather freely over the Border um the um you know once once the Taliban you know uh
14:56 if they are successful in um taking again you know you're already seeing groups uh in Pakistan violent extremist groups like tariki Taliban Pakistan the Pakistani Taliban that has been violently against the Pakistani State and the Pakistani military um looking at this as as a victory for them as well so I think we're going to see this um uh this lesson taken throughout the region uh we've already kind of covered this but another thing I wanted to ask about was sort of a little bit more specific of the same basic topic I mean last year I wrote an article called we are all Hamas which talked about the very open and somewhat direct collaboration between groups like jamaati islami in Pakistan and The Wider South Asian region and Hamas they were openly touting each other's causes sending each other money things like that um there's a lot more of this s of common cause between radical groups terrorist groups in both middle east and south Asia um particularly as the wings have shifted
15:59 in South Asia um how do you think this will matter in terms of what they in other words look what I'm trying to say Saudi Arabia for example is cracking down the Brotherhood so is Egypt they are not nearly as some of these islamist groups not well accepted in South Asia particularly like Pakistan it's much different how do you think that will affect things going forward absolutely so you know in in Pakistan um there is this idea of Afghanistan the need to have a a um Pakistani puppet or a very friendly Pakistani regime in Afghanistan um in order to provide what is known as strategic depth in their sort of this this ongoing forever war against India that they um feel that they're fighting and uh you know the Strategic depth comes from the fact that that um Pakistan is is not not very large geographically and so it gives uh
17:02 Afghanistan having you know at least a proxy control over Afghanistan gives Pakistan the ability to strategically Retreat regroup um uh it gives them you know access to um Logistics and hardware and things through other channels that they can then use um you know should they need to in their forever war against India um similar L we've seen in the past where you mentioned Osama Bin Laden earlier Osama Bin Laden's not South Asian um he's certainly he was not Afghan but he had set up uh his Camp Al-Qaeda the base in Afghanistan and the reason why is that it provided a friendly um environment where they could carry out their training and Logistics um activities they're planning uh if not with with explicit support certainly without any hindrance um and as we see um you know countries in the
18:04 Middle East cracking down on violent extremist groups and Afghanistan um under Taliban control is very likely to revert to that it's very likely to revert to a place where radical violent extremist islamist groups um throughout the Middle East are able to uh regroup and come together um you know to prepare for the next phase we have to you know always remember these groups are not fighting a war that's been going on for 20 years that're are fighting a war that you know to them has been going on for over a thousand uh we're running a little bit behind here but let me ask one last question before we get to to uh the audience questions um but audience you can start please start typing in questions um another thing mdle East Forum pays attention to is islamist groups in the west um there are unquestionably quite open proxies of South Asian radicals the Islamic circle of North am America is a open obvious and admitted um proxy for jamaati islami they are also increasingly making um um common cause with Muslim Brotherhood
19:09 organizations that have the roots in the Middle East in the west um I wonder if you want to comment the nature of some of these groups and if there are any such groups that are being overlooked in terms of how they are affecting um uh America's politics and the world yeah absolutely the um you know the two that a as we've been saying this whole time you know you see these these ideologies and these groups are able to easily you know uh Traverse um State boundaries Regional boundaries the West the United States uh the United Kingdom the EU you know none of us are have impenetrable barriers to this um and in fact in recent years certainly we've seen um this come to fruition um both in terms of you know islamist attacks um in Western countries carried out by people um who have you know had relationships um sometimes gone traveled to the Middle East or South Asia for
20:11 training um and indoctrination and then coming back and carrying out attacks um and and you know some of these are are very well known you know we all know about um we've heard about um individuals having ties with Al-Qaeda and having individuals having ties with with um Isis but there are you know like as you mentioned other organizations jamaati islami is often uh talked about as um an on-ramp for these organizations there are two in particular that are often overlooked that I want to point out one being uh the kotne nuat um which is a a very violent um radical islamist uh movement um largely in South Asia largely out of Pakistan um that targets um AMD Muslims um and and murders them um and then there's another one known as hisb tier um hisb tier um operates uh kind of ironically hisb terer has actually been banned in a lot
21:15 of Middle Eastern and South Asian countries as a violent um extremist terrorist organization but they still continue to operate rather freely in the United States and the United Kingdom and so you will see them carrying out um you know demonstrations with you know big uh black flags and you know demands to you know um uh behead um people and establish a global calefate again this is all part of this this shared prophetic vision of um of a global calefate but cman nuat are are they import people um uh evangelizers uh for these ideologies K nuat brings them in from Pakistan and holds um uh meetings and conventions here in the United States um and in the United Kingdom and they have th those have resulted in violence serious thing to think about uh to the audience questions um um Dennis was wondering how
22:19 um Pakistan and turkey's Alliance um or I not perhaps Alliance C door but relationship with Iran um what what that is and then how will China who is increasingly close to Pakistan sort of navigate um those relationships they have with each other those are two great questions so Iran is um Iran is an interesting one because Iran is um kind of the odd man out uh in the region um because Iran is Shia um and while um you know there are certainly um overlaps between um you know the a shared vision of um you know spreading theocracy um you know there are there are some disagreements in the details and some pretty big ones about what that theocracy is going to look like and I think that you know with Pakistan and Iran there are particularly interesting um uh things to watch where they have a a hot and cold relationship
23:24 um in fact the um while they have you know some you know very important uh shared um goals and aims um there has been an ongoing um uh series of skirmishes especially along the border um between uh radical groups um out of Pakistan that go into um Iran um to carry out attacks and then um you know Border guard retaliation um inside Pakistan and it's important to remember Pakistan in particular has really been rocked um in recent decades uh by sectarian violence so you know there is not a sort of uniformity of you know when we talk about um uh you know radical Islam there are many different forms of radical Islam and um one of these in Pakistan in particular um though certainly not unique to that is anti-shia um uh a strain um and then the uh I'm sorry the oh China um you know
24:31 China again is another sort of wild card um and I say that because China has um China tends to operate um behind the scenes a lot more um which Pakistan and other countries U like Pakistan like because they don't get embarrassed on the world stage um but and and and China is also uninterested in human rights in the way that the United States and and the United Kingdom the EU are um so China will Overlook a lot of things um as long as they're getting their um Economic Development programs in um you know they're willing to really kind of look the other way about a lot of Human Rights stuff now where the Wild Card bit comes in is that China does not have a lot of patience with radical violent extremism when it comes to China um and you know we have seen uh a few times um recently in fact um within the past couple of weeks there was a rare occurrence of Chinese um
25:36 State backed uh voices threatening Pakistan and saying look if you can't clean up the violent extremist situation on our border we're going to come in there and do it ourselves um so I think that those conversations um are being had again they're being had behind the scenes China is not interested in a global cbate um so I think that that that is um something to pay attention to this kind of feeds into another question that David the audience was asking he was saying that the ethnic differences between Sunni and Shia and other um sort of ethnic and National differences um make pan Islamic thinking difficult um obviously when it when the rubber meets the road um how do you see that playing out in South Asia and in um in the Middle East in general I mean you sort of touched on that you talked about Iran and Pakistan but is there a sort of a wider issue of how this breaks down in the world and in South Asia um I you know I think in the The Wider World um we tend to see what um what are
26:43 highlevel cooperations um and that's because there are you know basically you have the enemy of my enemy is a is my friend type type thinking and so it's look you know we're all together against the West right um but once once that sort of breaks away then you see where things start to break down and become more schismatic you know the in the Islamic extremist narrative um there's a lot of talk they reference the Uma which is the the the global community of Muslims um and it's an interesting idea um you know it's it's rather like talking about Christendom right right and we can talk about Christendom as like this sort of global community of Christians um but we also recognize that you know there's not there's certainly unlikely to be anytime in in the future um a workable you know uh sort of global Christian theocracy it
27:47 did just like it hasn't worked in the past in the 14th century there were two popes for for a period um and you know as things as things um break into sex we see that more so and Pakistan is is I think a particularly good um uh opportunity to look at what that looks like um you mentioned jamaati islami earlier jamaati islami is a a transnational it's a global um radical islamist organization whose goal is to establish an Islamic theocracy um of their imagining right um but the way that they operate in different countries is um tells you a little bit about what the political situations in those countries are because in um India um they are much more moderate in their actions um but they don't have a lot of room to to move so they they operate with as much space as they're given in Bangladesh they have a little bit more um space um although the the aam league
28:52 government that's currently in power um has really made a priority of breaking up that breaking up their pow jamaat Islam's power and influence in that country in Pakistan they really have free reign um there are really no restraints on their ability to evangelize to organize um and as I mentioned before to operate as an on-ramp to bring people in to identify where they could be useful in this sort of broader um uh radical movement and then shift them over into these organizations um so you know I the idea of a a single you know Islamic Global calefate is you know theoretically unworkable um there's just not enough um you know coherence in ideology but as long as there is a sort of enemy of my enemy is my friend we can set aside our differences as long as we're you know operating against the United States or or you know Europe um we're going to see those cooperations and then as they gain power in these regions you know or in
29:56 these you know more localized are areas um you're going to see more of these violent skirmishes break out that are intering Warfare we're running out of time but just you can answer in one minute um you mentioned that Hindu Zionism or these word used was being demonized by islamists and I think you're talking about sort of the Hindus and the zionists working together um is sort of their sort of this you know bigger ideology but can you expound a little bit on what you mean by that sure well so this is a phrase that's sort of bandied about usually by um radical um conspiracy theorists um and and and it's this idea that you know first of all there are um uh there is a a broad sort of belief in a global Jewish conspiracy right um and um in the effort to demonize India in particular um and to um spread that demonization beyond the uh kind of localized Pakistan India
31:05 fight um they really latch on to any way to sort of tie India make a connection between India and Israel to sort of loop India into this this supposed you know uh Global Jewish conspiracy um in order to make their fight against India relevant to um you know radical islamists outside of South Asia in the Middle East in particular yeah I I'll just add to that that you can certainly see that in the United States with the various islamist franchises from both middle east and south Asia they're increasingly n only working together but they're demonizing both Israel and India in the same language AB anyhow uh wish we had more time this has been great um I appreciate you coming on to talk to with us and I think we're going to see a lot more interesting things happening in the region and maybe sometime we'll talk about him again but thank you again very much for coming on thank you audience for joining us here and uh have a good day have a good absolutely thank you so much cliff