Webinar or Talk
The Decline of ISNA: On-the-Scene at an Islamist Convention with Susannah Johnston
Watch on YouTube
Description
The Islamic Society of North America (ISNA) once flourished as a prominent Islamist organization. Now its membership has plummeted, its leadership is rudderless, and even the U.S. State Department has distanced itself. Middle East Forum investigative reporter Susannah Johnston “crashed” the latest ISNA convention to learn first-hand about its moral and political collapse. Is this a good development? What is its future? What does it tell us about the wider Islamist movement in the U.S.?
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 2, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:01 good afternoon and welcome to the Middle East forums webinar and podcast series featuring talks from the Middle East forums projects my name is Dexter van zyl and I'm editor of focus on Western islamism and I will be moderating this discussion today Our Guest is uh Susannah Johnston who attended the Islamic Society of North America's annual convention that took place outside of Chicago over Labor Day this Susanna is an Intrepid investigative reporter and she has written a number of articles for FYI about her findings at the conference and before we begin I would like to remind our listeners that they can submit questions at the bottom of the screen by posting them in the Q a so let's begin Susanna what was it like at the conference give us a description of the attendees and vendors at the event and the overall Vibe can you tell us about the vibe sure uh first thanks for having me um I got there you know early Friday afternoon so they were still setting up
1:05 when I arrived the vendors were still setting up most people hadn't arrived um but overall I would say I mean people by Friday night things were pretty full and it was really friendly people young people a lot of young families I'd say probably half of the attendees were um under under 40 at least maybe under 30. I lots of strollers small children um sweet people though yeah obviously enough I mean people were very kind here right yeah yeah definitely definitely uh and uh very real well I mean somewhat to be expected the vendors were very uh were very engaging but really I mean everyone everyone was friendly I didn't encounter anyone that was not okay so what was attendance like I think that was a concern or that was an issue that people spoke about um so prior to the convention there was impressed saying that uh they uh leadership is still leadership came out and said hey we're expecting you know 50
2:07 000 attendees they definitely did not have 50 000 attendees I don't know what attendance exactly was it's pretty hard to estimate attendance um but I would say a few thousand is all it seems a lot more like it and if you uh look at their uh it's not has not put out anything since the convention to say uh hey we had a fantastic attendance they've said they had thousands um but I put it in the low thousands uh and this was this was a point that was actually brought up at their General Assembly uh one of their sessions at the convention was their general assembly and they had a few things that they voted on um but about 50 people attended that general assembly and a number of those people had a lot of complaints about uh what's going on with membership with Esna and why is it uh why is this organization dwindling uh and attendance here is terrible and how are we how are we going to get to the the Next Generation how are we not not going to lose them now one of the things that uh that popped into my head right now is that
3:10 that still didn't stop the fact that there wasn't an awful lot of attendance uh or attendees didn't stop uh people from the Biden Administration and other public officials to show show up at this event uh can you talk a little bit about that and what do you think is going on sure well historically uh Isa has been a really one of the leading islamist organizations in the U.S they've had they have had huge attendance in the past and so I think I mean they they still have that name uh and so I the presidential administration's Clinton uh at least as far back as Clinton uh have have shown some involvement with this and then it's no leadership and so I think there's probably some holdover from that okay now do you now what do you think what talk to us about their political messaging what do you think is going going on what is their message and and how did that job with some of the uh lifestyle messaging that they offered at the event
4:11 sure uh I think it was a bit incongruous uh so first off let me talk about a little bit about the the social so-called social issues messaging uh they were very vague on that uh they seem to be presenting you know both Progressive and islamist positions vaguely at the same time so if you were attending it was like well what what am I supposed to think about that so an example of that was that the abortion issue came up um lgbtq issues came up and in both of those issues the speakers panelists who were being asked these questions hardly ever had anything to say I mean it was like oh what so one speaker when asked said oh well we need we need to be investing in schools and scholarships so that people have answers for these tough questions and I would think that if you're in attending you'd just be like well okay so what am I supposed to think about this issue am I supposed to be for or against or and it was just it was very vague now contrasting with that to a certain extent they were a lot Bolder with their political uh their political perhaps enthusiasm uh you had several elected
5:16 officials who spoke um as you mentioned a couple of people from the Homeland Security Administration representative U.S house representative Andre Carson was there uh Indiana state senator Fati guadora was there and then you had a handful of other people too and um and I believe uh the governor also um the governor of Illinois I did a zoom or something for them I I was not present for that but it isn't social media on that but they they didn't have much that they were celebrating that was a very curious thing they you know say they were it was it was a lot of kind of a lot of hot air and really what they were saying is hey uh Muslims are a minority in the U.S and look at us we've made it to the highest places in the land isn't that great let's keep that up but they didn't have anything more substantive that they were now there was some unhappiness at the event about there was a a booth from the Customs and Border Patrol at the event uh and did you talk to us about that sure uh Customs and Border Patrol was
6:21 there uh they had a booth I didn't see I mean there were there were a lot of booths so it was hard and there were people Milling around in there so hard to know how much attention was paid to that booth at the convention uh there were a number of complaints online about that and there's certainly uh certainly at least some critics think that is selling out to homelands to Customs and Border Patrol protection uh by having them there saying hey these are the people that have gone after uh immigrants uh why are you selling why are you having them here at our convention okay now what was the the party breakdown of the uh of the politicians and public officials that attended the convention because that was one of the questions that was put into the Q a just now what do you I mean can you make a uh most mostly Democrat and but at the same time one of the things that we have spoken about amongst ourselves is that an awful lot of their
7:24 social uh agenda would be essentially supported more by by the Democrats uh excuse me by the conservatives the conservative Republicans is there some sort of dichotomy going on here uh that essentially on one hand they they side with Democrats because it it helps them essentially achieve influence in American society but at the same time it may not necessarily align with their yeah I think absolutely um in fact uh Senator fatty wadura made an interesting point and he was bragging about actually getting he's a Democrat but he was bragging about getting crossover votes because they because Republicans resonated with his message and uh but he made a big point to say and I think that this is probably a more widely held position than it is that is openly acknowledged but he said it's really important that we basically you know as Muslims um recognize that political parties are Vehicles don't get don't get caught up in being one party or the other
8:29 okay now you've worked on Capitol Hill and how would politicians base what type of calculus would they actually start thinking about when it comes time to decide whether or not or how to interact with an organization like isna well I'm getting votes so you might want to show up at a conference to attract a specific voting okay now do you think that they're going to be able to recruit or is is going to be able to recruit the next generation of supporters uh given some of the difficulties that that you were able to document what do you think you know what what's the the uh what's the the the value that's being ventured by Isner to its supporters you know what's its value proposition do you uh I think they're I think they're internally split right now uh and I think that what what we're seeing at the convention and the commentary online is that they don't have a clear a Clear Vision for the future and I think if you don't have that Clear Vision it's going
9:32 to be hard to attract uh the Next Generation now I think some of this is leadership is well aware that that's a problem uh the president's office um was pretty defensive about the voting membership of isma which is apparently somewhere around five thousand I think their membership in general is private but they they did leak that number um but uh while he was defensive and trying I think kind of trying to say hey we're not looking as bad as you say we're looking uh the vice president of the organization is actually stepping down from her position so that she can recruit but I don't think if they don't have a clear message of what they're offering and what's hey what's the goal for the future they're going to have a lot of trouble recruiting even if she's working really hard on it okay now one of the things was there any sort of ideological split do you think between the younger members and the older members uh who attended uh you know what do you think's going on there and what do you think that the younger attendees are looking for from an organization like yes
10:36 um you know so a lot of the questions that were asked pieces of paper so it wasn't like you had individuals from the crowd standing up and asking their questions so it's a little bit hard to tell you know younger versus older but based off a dress um it was most of the women at this convention were wearing hijabs um I did not wear a hijab or any kind of head covering but there were a handful of women there who did not wear hijab so I didn't really stand out um but pretty much all the young women were hijabs um they I I suppose some some didn't um but the women who were wearing the cobs there were a number of nakabs and those were almost all young women so I think that I mean it certainly seemed like it's the the younger generation at this convention that is in interested in more uh islamist leaning uh vision for the future and they want to know I I would assume they want to know how to rear their families okay now one of the things that you
11:39 mentioned in one of the Articles was uh you you heard one speaker essentially say that American evangelicals had essentially misinterpreted or or inaccurately conveyed how uh the founding of the United States about that I I just found that so very interesting and was there a certain surreal aspect to having to listen to uh it was certainly surprising to hear that uh so I yeah sure the speaker um and I apologize I'll I'll pull it off um his name um it's in the article that I wrote um but yeah he said that hey uh the enlightenment wouldn't have happened without uh Muslim influence and then he he also went from there to say that uh there was islamist influence at the very founding of the US and he said that hey uh the founders were influenced by mohabbatan Christians so it's evangelicals who rewrote U.S history when they at the fountain you know from
12:43 the founding so uh fantastic Pie in the Sky now one of the things you know I've attended a number of religious events over the course of my career and generally there may not be reporters there all the time okay but there is some sort of uh coverage of it and and if they pass resolutions and the thing is it won't be just type like a preview but they'll actually write about what happened at this convention afterwards uh but at the same time I haven't seen an awful lot of coverage is it was fwi one of the only sources of information about this event and and you know after the fact and and and what do you think's going aside from maybe Muslim Publications here in the United States and aside from that what what do you think if there isn't any or what explains the level of coverage that you've seen
13:45 that's an interesting question um I certainly didn't see any other press um there was definitely a press there beforehand because they did you know some preview stuff that as you mentioned um some local Chicago coverage and I I did see like a couple articles I before and after but uh as you said not not really widespread I don't know I don't know why um there wouldn't be more and it may may have to do with the internal split and perhaps not wanting to weigh too heavily into that that split that seems to be going okay now where do you think this story is headed and it looks as it from the impression that I get from the articles that we've published uh it seems as if this is an institution in Decline okay or is you know is that a good thing or a bad thing from the people who are interested in counter islamism what do you think oh interesting um so I I think perhaps I should just mention this a little bit of this split
14:47 uh a little more so it seems that I in the past turkey's been a little bit more involved with isna and in recent years uh one of their presidents Syed Saeed was apparently kicked out for being basically uh anti-churkey I may be oversimplifying this for the sake of discussion but uh there seemed to be a Turkish boycott going on uh that is the convention this year we certainly didn't see a prominent Turkish Presence at the um and Care apparently boycotted uh Zara Balu wrote about it on her Facebook um and uh the vice president of isna she said hey this issue this issue is taken care of basically insinuating hey we're not anti-turkey anymore um but still nonetheless turkey didn't really seem to be present at this convention what's going on there we're not exactly sure but it seems like there is a split between uh you know Muslim
15:50 Brotherhood turkey influence and the Old Guard isna in the U.S and we're not sure where what that what that means for the where does this know where does this night end up coming down okay now I'm going to change the subject a little bit and I don't mean to Ambush it but you've written an awful lot about Oberlin College and mahaladi and uh I think last week essentially there was a congressional letter that was sent to Oberlin largely as a consequence of your reporting can you talk a little bit about what what what you that story and I don't want to rehash it entirely but and where do you think that story is headed oh uh well we can talk about regime influence foreign regime influence in the U.S and is that a problem is foreign funding uh a problem to schools is that well enough tracked no um I think it's fantastic that Congress is interested in this issue um this is just one of many people in
16:52 the U.S that need to be looked into really for foreign regime influence and what does that mean not just for foreign regimes and uh support going back and forth but where where do young people who are being taught by these professors where do they end up and I apologize for the audience um the man that I wrote about was Maha is professor mahaladi at Oberlin College in case we uh miss that missed that name there okay yeah all right now tell me why is he a problem oh why is he a problem um well he he certainly appears to have a lot of uh at present that he has not clearly um he's also in the past uh in the 1980s Massacre uh in in Iran of um there was a terrible Massacre and thousands of political prisoners were executed by Iran Iran got away with it and uh mahaladi was then U.N Ambassador for Iran and uh he pretty much for sure
17:58 knew what was going on um but regardless of whether he did or didn't he then cover he then tried to cover up that it happened uh when it became very public that it happened I tried tried to blame it on Iran's enemies but he's never come clean about that uh so it certainly looks like he was pretty directly involved he's been criticized by the previous I think the previous uh Iranian Ambassador um to the U.N uh for for not distancing himself further so he's never come clean about that so there's a there's the massacre that happened in the past to what degree was he involved in that and then in the present I possible regime relationship right now and and the man lives in the U.S and teaches in the U.S at a U.S college right now is there a sense that and I has anyone at Oberlin decided to essentially like uh accelerate the uh the campaign against him or they basically just at this point uh just
19:01 kind of waiting to see the Congressional letter play itself out you mean Oberlin leadership yeah I haven't I had a response remote with one um my guess is that they're they're probably trying to stall for time okay I just find that astonishing if they haven't responded publicly to that letter is that am I am I just being naive yeah you worked on Capitol Hill you know I mean how do people respond to those letters when they get them usually I don't want to be cynical but I I think that it's it would it's not surprising it's not surprising at all okay all right so is there anything else that we think that you need to cover or or inform people about the Isner conference and where do you think that organization is headed in the future I guess and what choices does it have to sure uh well for one thing um I'm guessing I'm betting that some of the people who are listening have already read our articles on fwi but if you haven't we've got several
20:03 um honest at a piece on Hindu anti-hindu hate being imported at the conference um Martha Lee did a piece this re this week that's really good on the internal divisions that'll give you some more background there and Sam westrup I did a piece on uh on the really on the Turkish the Turkish background there so it certainly looks like they are in Decline based off the message at the convention they didn't have uh they didn't have a Clear Vision they don't have a Clear Vision for the future so unless they get that cleaned up then I I would I would imagine they'll continue to dwindle okay now and I guess how do you think that the islamist community here in the U.S would respond to that what do you do you think they'll be happy or sad with its disappearance well I mean and not that it's going to disappear but suppose you know it's continued decline so the point where it you know essentially like a a dormant or less effective Institution well I think the biggest thing is that
21:05 they're at a crossroads right now and at least some of isna's leadership understands that um and the question is can they recover uh they might they might recover um I wouldn't I would not count that out as an option um the other thing is there are a lot of other islamist groups so and people move so I it just I think it just makes things more complicated yeah no no go ahead is there any possibility that and you know this is be being maybe naive but that at some point the institution or isna could become a Force for reform or an updating of how Islam is practiced in in the United States some people probably want that but um we'll see that's that's nice and helpful all right did you didn't did you see any evidence of that and what and was there anybody that expressed that from the floor from the questions or were they just looking to essentially sustain
22:08 their sense of order and nomos it really seemed like based off the questions people were interested in more Hardline answers and frustrated that they weren't getting Hardline answers right so it didn't seem like and there and combating that there wasn't much of there wasn't any kind of reformist message it was just a non-message okay now now suppose what would recovery look like for isna and what would your recommendations be and you know as a non-muslim you know what would your recommendations be for reform for the organization or um that's a that's a great question well they've got to have clearer messaging on what they mean uh from from the ground up on their moral messaging their social issues messaging they've got to figure out what in the world they believe in things uh and then their politics is going to be Downstream for that from that uh and I think that a lot of you were asking earlier you know
23:10 why why were people there uh what did they want um I I think they want to know how to live their lives and there it was just it was very vague so they need they would need to clean that up yeah now you spoke a little bit about the leadership being divided can you elaborate on that and what do you think of the prospects that they would actually like try to like maybe even abandon or disavow their islamist Roots isn't as it's it's islamist groups and say yes this is part of our past do you think that is there anybody in the leadership that might be interested in doing that I don't know okay I think I think that's I think that's a great question um that's I mean that's really what we'd like to see yeah because I've been thinking a lot about what would reform look like from these organizations and one of the things is I would sure like to see no you know them to stop offering references to Hassan albana on their websites in a laudatory manner
24:13 you know that would be wonderful and also essentially say yeah we had our roots in the Muslim Brotherhood but we're here in the United States we're not interested in promoting that type of agenda anymore and we're looking to help people practice Islam as a as a private Faith just the same way that the other faiths are and yeah we want to play a role in politics but we're not looking to dominate the way things are so and you know let me just clarify I I don't think I don't see that right now from us now um and if you they're actually holding an event this evening um celebrating kardawi that's not that's not reform right there so you could you know you could start you know coming out and saying hey you know these islamists that we've looked to in the past we've realized they were wrong uh we're headed in a New Direction this is what the New Direction looks like uh that's not that does not seem to be happening so how worried it seems like you you mentioned that there was a lot of young people at this event how worried should
25:16 we be that younger Generations seem to be leaning towards islamism here in the U.S uh it's a concern uh I don't we shouldn't be worried about taking it seriously yes okay all right I think that is actually uh that's more of a CS Lewis worldview I think that you're offering us right now isn't it so um I think I just want to thank Susanna I think that's pretty much the end of the questions uh we've come to the end of our webinar and I want to thank you again Susanna and I want people to be on the lookout for next week's webinar offerings which will be emailed to you over the weekend uh just briefly uh uh Cliff Perry will be speaking on Wednesday uh excuse me Ashley Perry will be speaking on Wednesday a part of uh Middle East forums Insider Israel Insider series and then next Friday Cliff Smith director of our Washington project will be speaking with Mindy
26:19 belts uh former senior editor of World magazine about the Kurdish fight for rights to the Middle East and how it relates to American values and interests in the region and with that I want to thank everyone for attending and wish everyone a good weekend thanks so much