MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Israel Insider

Israel Insider with Ashley Perry

Watch Israel Insider with Ashley Perry on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

Prime Minister Netanyahu showed in his speech to the UN that Iran remains the number-one threat to Israel. How much does this issue dominate Israel's diplomatic policies?

Transcript Automatic captions

Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 11, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.

0:00 hello and welcome to the middle east forums webinar series israel insider with ashley perry i'm stacy roman and i will be moderating this discussion today we're pleased to have mr ashley perry advisor to the middle east forum's israel office join us here each wednesday at 3 pm eastern to update us on all the events going on in israel mr perry will be giving us a briefing on current israeli affairs for 15 minutes then open it up for questions should you wish to ask a question please use the q a box located at the bottom of your screen to type your and now with no further ado i'll turn the discussion over to mr ashley perry thank you very much stacey and good evening everybody from israel tonight we're going to sort of leave the of coronavirus the economy to one side we will deal with it i'm sure certainly the questions as well but i'd like to sort of take a look at what is always an anticipated event in israel around the world and that is

1:01 prime minister netanyahu's annual speech the united nations general assembly as everyone knows every year all the leaders of the world or designated leaders doesn't necessarily have to be head of state or head of government um gives to speech to the united nations general assembly um did allow in the past victor liga when he was foreign minister uh to give one speech but since that time i think that was i should know because i was on the staff at the time i think it was 2009 at 10 i think anyway since that time basically netanyahu has given that speech and it's always been a great show it's he's usually come with uh with tools with graphs with pictures with uh and he certainly doesn't didn't disappoint this year for the first time uh the leaders obviously didn't come to new york uh they all did this by video conferencing they all had nice backdrops netanyahu showed jerusalem the old city of jerusalem the two big israeli flags

2:04 and again you know he had a nice sort of um uh let's say tactic uh to basically reveal uh israeli intelligence uh assets on what's going on in beirut specifically uh hezbollah's stockpile of ammunitions and he knew they were what he was doing to try and gain attention to what hezbollah is doing in lebanon also to send a message to the lebanese people this is what your so-called savior your popular party because it is it remains a very popular party very popular organization this is what it's doing certainly after the explosion in the port of beirut which killed many people and many many more people injured and homeless uh to sort of bring attention to the stockpiles of his flowers was a very strategy but behind all of this was something that netanyahu has gone back to again and again and that is the threat of iran

3:07 now we've talked uh in the past about how many leaders and prime minister netanyahu certainly one of those who's used a bit of distraction deflection uh to try and uh you know move attention away from other failures what's going on with the cronovirus which you know part of it's certainly not within his grasp or any but it's clear that iran is it's not a distraction it's not a deflection it's something very deeply rooted within it you know it's something he believes more passionately i would argue than almost anything else that he does believe that iran is nexus a existential threat to uh to israel and he's worked very very hard or credited for many many years to draw attention to this uh for many years it has been on the uh you know there's certainly a debate to be had to what level of success or failure obviously the jcpoa signed under the previous american administration uh was uh a big blow to israel's messaging they shouldn't allow iran to have a

4:11 nuclear weapons capability because all this did was kicked the car down the table it didn't rule out uh in iran iranian nuclear weapons capability all it did was say that it has to be for a certain period of time uh not uh and it would allow certain uh movement on uh parts of their nuclear capabilities in exchange for release i should say on sanctions etc etc this was a big blow to israel's diplomacy uh when president trump came in and you know arguably ripped up the jcpoa the iran nuclear deal this was uh certainly cheered in jerusalem by all left and right and the question is now obviously what's going to happen with sanctions but again it was very very telling uh that netanyahu chose once again to make it iran the centerpiece uh obviously he talked about the uh the recent normalization agreements with the united arab emirates and bahrain and even held out an olive branch of the

5:13 palestinians saying you know that he's still willing and able to meet with them and begin or carry on some sort of peace what's interesting is that uh it was mentioned to me earlier i had a conversation maybe an hour or two ago uh where suddenly i thought to myself you know mahmoud abbas makes a lot of noise when it's his time to speak and don't forget the the state of palestine is is recognized by the u.n uh general it is a recognized state mahmoud is the president of that state again there is no such state in actuality but this is something that's been recognized even so mahmoud abbas has given a platform the same as netanyahu as president trump and as all the other world leaders and it's interesting usually it makes a lot of noise makes a lot of headlines in israel and around the world and what was interesting is i suddenly that i hadn't heard anything about this feature i actually googled it to see and he actually gave it last friday and the interesting thing is it made

6:16 almost no noise if we think back to years previous mahmud abbas is every word would be delivered by media publications around the world it'd be responded to by israel maybe other you know be poured over et cetera et cetera the fact remains that it it barely got any attention but i did find some excerpts of it and what was most telling i think is his you know what what could only be described as an exhaustion or even an understanding that the palestinians are no longer front and center i think especially the normalization agreements with our countries and it's clear that some other muslim or our countries are going to join and some other steps like saudi arabia to allow israeli planes to fly over their territory and various other things that have happened recently it shows that the palestinians have lost a major hand a major hand of theirs was the threat or you could say price that they would not be accepted in the region until they

7:18 made peace according to the dictates in terms of the palestinians that has now been you know sort of at least pushed aside and the palestinian leadership is obviously extremely angry about that and extremely uh wary of the fact that they are losing this battle they are getting side like their issues are no longer front and center their major card that they had as a veto israel's place in the region is now being disrupted uh so i think you know if we look if we look at these two speeches we see on the one hand muhammad abbas basically giving a speech where he's almost i wouldn't say giving up he's certainly not giving up you know he did call for an international peace uh conference and she obviously criticized israel and his usual sort of uh you know rambling about israel's uh so-called illegal occupation etc etc but on the whole vaphew took this seriously took notice of him which i think is is fairly unprecedented uh and netanyahu you know made a speech that again was

8:22 designed partly for a local domestic consumption but again the the vast majority of it was sent as a warning to the international community iran is still the major threat not just to israel but a threat to peace and stability in the region if we look around the region we see these normalization agreements and we see even within the sunni arab and others we see we see a great interest to try and lower the flames to more stability less instability that is basically being created by iran and at the root of these uh normalization agreements yes israel gains a lot from it and even united some bahrain and others will gain from it but at the root of it is this shared distrust uh dislike of iran and what it's doing in the region so i think uh netanyahu very cleverly and as usually very eloquently uh basically try to place iran front and center because the sanctions uh issue is coming up again uh certainly

9:25 president trump wants to bring it up um and it remains to be seen where the international community is going to bite at the moment the europeans are pretty uh standing firm on this they they want to revive the jcpoa or keep it going as as long as possible but it's it's clearly a moribund agreement the iranians have openly defied it again and and the americans have finally caught their bluff on it so it remains to be seen what the europeans will do because there's a lot that can be done here because uh snapping the uh the the sanctions back would obviously be a major major blow to the previous administration's policy uh and it will certainly send a very strong message to iran it's something that the iranians certainly do not want so it means to be seen where the europeans are so prime minister uh is basically you know from his meetings from his understandings from the cables that he's receiving from our consulates and embassies around the world he understands where the international community is vis-a-vis so it's clear that uh this is a very

10:29 timely message and the fact that he again with everything going on with coronavirus with the normalization agreements with economic situation the fact that iran was front and center i think is very telling what's going on behind the scenes uh and you know almost almost every meeting anybody comes into israel regardless of what the meeting's about bilateral agreements etc etc prime minister netanyahu makes a point of always talking about iran what are israel's expectations for countries in europe and around the world to do anyone what it can do anyone what it should be doing on iran and certainly israel is sharing a lot of their intelligence what they're seeing what's going on iran especially its nuclear weapons uh but also what it's doing uh in the region with its destabilization destabilization efforts uh chiefly in lebanon and the fact that netanyahu went so public on israel's intelligence to show what they're doing uh with a hundred thousand plus rockets aimed at israel as we speak uh shows exactly where netanyahu would

11:33 like the international focus to be at this point um i'm happy to talk about coronavirus happy to talk about all the other situation uh in israel but i thought it would be it's it's important to sort of show that whatever else is going on in israel netanyahu hasn't lost sight of this very very important issue to himself which is he sees as really probably his life goal and his life goal if he could ask him if he could do one thing i'm sure it would be uh to stop uh iran uh acquiring nuclear weapons uh and so much of his work day and night is dedicated to preventing that so i'm happy to answer questions on this or anything else all right thank you so much uh can you were talking about lebanon earlier can you update us on the civil unrest and spread of corona in lebanon and has the unrest spread beyond beirut to the rest of the country and has their reactions to israel's disclosure disclosure of hezbollah's

12:36 arms ports and beirut bin so i'll deal with the last part uh first basically so hezbollah took an opportunity to try and get some pr out of this and they did try and organize a press invite the media to the location of israel and netanyahu claimed uh is an arms depot and you know they tried to make a whole thing about this there was chanting there were slogans against israel for hezbollah et cetera et cetera but some of the let's say you know sort of not singing from the same score sheet media basically uh demonstrated that hezbollah did not allow the media actually to go where they wanted to apparently they were allowed to see a very small square footage of where netanyahu pointed uh to the army po they weren't allowed beyond that point so it's clear that hezbollah has something to hide they try to demonstrate because they obviously feel the pressure they

13:38 understood that this message of netanyahu is one way or another would seep into lebanon in this era of globalization there's no way to prevent it so they wanted to try this was this was more for the internal consumption than anything else they understand that there's still a lot of bank a lot of resentment uh to what they're doing you know the the explosion at the port hasn't been you know i say firmly credited to hezbollah but there are a lot of and even if that particular explosion was not down to visible light it's clear that they have a lot of other commodities assets around the country that could end in a similar way so netanyahu very cleverly wanted to try and bring attention to that um and it's clear that there's there's still this uh anchor and resentment and hizballah feeling it yes it is uh sweeping across the country um but again hezbollah is not you know we on the outside world we see it as a terrorist organization as a as even a as an armed organization but we've got

14:40 to remember in lebanon and it's also a uh organization it's a political organization with a very strong hand in the parliament and even in the government so it goes far far beyond what we see as a as a militant as a terrorist so it has its supporters it has a very strong base of supporters but those on the other side of the aisle are certainly feeling a lot more anger to it and are allowing themselves to vent that anger in a more open fashion than for for many years um i don't know about their coronavirus uh what's going on coronavirus at this point so i can't really answer that part of the question all right thank you at what point will israel decide it must attack hezbollah's precision guided missile sites in lebanon that's a very good question um basically it's policy let's just say it's sort of active policy over the last few years has been quite a simple one to ensure you know

15:42 a few months ago israel hasn't officially claimed it but assassinated a senior hezbollah official in syria uh one that hezbollah has said that they will respond to they will retaliate for them we saw a couple of attempts at retaliation over the last couple of months but thankfully they were all failures but uh hezbollah still claimed that they retained that right to retaliate but the question that needs to be asked is what hezbollah senior hezbollah doing in syria and what they were doing is they were passing very important armaments missile capability etc from syria uh to lebanon and what israel has done is whenever it's seen a containment that it considers extremely worrying it is usually trying to break up that uh again not taking responsibility on most occasions every now and again there's a by a senior israeli leader exactly what they are doing but basically that's their main active step that they've taken over the last

16:43 few years is to stop as much as they can because it is a very porous border between lebanon and syria and especially for an organization that hezbollah that knows the area very well has obviously very strong allies on both sides of the border uh they're trying daily if not weekly to get uh to really beef up their uh military abilities to to to get the latest technologies etc etc i don't think israel is going to do a preemptive strike i don't think we're certainly not there at this point um i don't think either side i really want something like that so i don't see that happening in the near future so in the event that ever does become a do you think anyone israel arabs the u.s is actually prepared to carry out a full-blown military attack to prevent iranian nuclear weapons that's the big question um you know a few years back there was this big sort of talk and leak that netanyahu was preparing to launch some sort of military strike against

17:46 iranian facilities to do with a nuclear weapons uh program and there were other figures like at the time defense minister barak who basically warned him of it and then they didn't do it and what the americans allah allotted i mean this was under president obama but the americans alerted uh they obviously would have been against it at that point um there was that window that window has been shot for the moment uh israel certainly retains that ability like and can assure you without intimate knowledge of it that israel is preparing for every scenario uh the americans have stated on many many and even president obama said this let alone president trump that all options remain on the table iran is not at that point of nuclear weapons capability when they are it's a whole different ball game it changes the region it changes everything it changes the balance of power it changes the ability of other countries to attack it as you can imagine i don't see it happening at this point

18:51 in time but what is happening with these these these closer ties between israel and the gulf countries and not just the one who's officially normalized relations with but the others like the saudis uh from oman and others um this is you know always the the number one point of any discussion what is going on iran what can we do to stop it how can we cooperate how can we coordinate share intelligence etc etc so this as i said in my opening remarks this is really at the root of all cooperation that's happening now between israel and the pragmatic sunni nations especially in the gulf um so it remains to be seen exactly what level of action will be taken but at the moment there's assuredly a lot of below the radar events and activities that are happening anything that can even push back at this point rather than stop the nuclear weapons capability do you think that the israelis should

19:55 support democratic regime change in iran they would love to everybody would love to everyone would love to see a regime change the the debate is how you go about it you any recent sort of uh demonstrations have been largely stifled you know they they haven't had the momentum that they did a number of years ago i think it was called the green revolution if i uh remember correctly and there was a lot of criticism maybe the american administration and president obama should have done more uh to help that because that was probably the greatest threat to the itolas uh probably before and since um the big question is how do you even go about regime change in a country like iran you know many many countries have tried it in lesser countries and not been able to succeed so it's you know it's it would certainly be the dream of many countries i'm sure at the top saudi arabia america and even the europeans wouldn't be adverse to it

20:57 i'm sure um but i don't think it's necessarily something that can be actually actively pursued from the outside it has to be driven from the uh grassroots and if some outside actors can assist then something else it's it's not a i don't see necessarily a program that could be enacted uh from the outside understood do you see any indication that the europeans are going to wake up to reality about the iran but or will they continue to keep their hudson sands the interesting thing i always remember when i was in the foreign ministry and you know we used to meet with our european counterparts and again iran was number one the number two item on the agenda um i remember the the europeans being even stronger more hawkish on iran than the americans at the time and especially the british uh very very they pretty much towed the same line as uh as israel and then and then basically i think the lost faith in the process of you know uh

22:02 of trying to you know take other i my my assessment is um that when they saw the americans moving uh some type of negotiations they moved with it they understood that this was the game in town and they became addicted to it and they kind of dropped to a certain extent i don't this statement may sound a little bit more harsh than this but kind of dropped israel in it a little bit and isolated israel on this issue because i do remember some being in some conversations with some extremely hawkish foreign leaders who talked about iran in very similar terms to how israel saw it but then that kind of when uh what then became the jcpoa uh when they when they started to uh begin and crystallize i think the europeans decided to move from from this hawkish to this more dubbish stance and join the american administration in these negotiations with iran and can you comment on the apparent

23:09 increasing closeness between netanyahu and naftali bennett and what that means if there's another election in the foreseeable future i don't know who asked that question but i'm not sure what they're getting the information from because there's certainly no growing closeness that i can see or i've heard of if anything the opposite is true uh naftali bennett is more and more a threat to netanyahu every day we talked a little bit about this last week usually there's a poll as i said last week usually polls come out on wednesday there hasn't been a poll this week um but if there was i'm sure the numbers wouldn't be any different to maybe even further away from netanyahu uh netanyahu and bennett there's no love lost uh we talked also about the fact that um there's no love lost not just between benjamin netanyahu but also sarah netanyahu and other members of the uh netanyahu family uh you know natalie bennett served as uh netanyahu's chief of staff when he was leader of the uh and then he and ellen chiquette who was also on the staff quit and eventually they formed various

24:13 parties and today it's called yamina uh but they are the biggest threat i think that if anything uh netanyahu may even want to hold on to benny gans a little bit longer just to stay the threat that nathalie bennett brings we have to wait and see if and when elections are called and we have to see if naftali better because he's pulled they won the past but for the first time to turn polling numbers into actual knesset seats because we've seen sometimes uh the actual votes for bennett halved from what the polls were saying so you know everyone shouldn't be getting uh too ahead of these numbers but i as i predicted quite a few months ago netanyahu's numbers are decreasing uh naftali bennett is seen as the only opposition today the leader of the opposition yay left is at this point not able in any way to form a government and his numbers are not really growing too much but naftali bennett is seen as a serious and so he's causing netanyahu some sleepless nights i

25:17 i certainly don't think there's any closeness i'm sure netanyahu would love to bring him in to clip his wings a little bit uh but i don't think i think bennett has learned uh from his clashes with netanyahu in recent years where usually netanyahu was one and i think bennett if he does produce these sort of numbers in the next knesset elections will be a much harder person to bargain with and they say he may even demand a rotation of the prime ministership with him coming first as opposed to second like benigns so i i don't see them coming close at at this point uh on the country they are very much rivals at this point wonderful so well not wonderful um in our last few minutes here could you just give us a quick update on what's there with the coronavirus and the lockdown and all that well we are now uh certainly in i think it's now over a week of uh this severe lockdown let's say almost total

26:22 um the numbers are still growing we i believe yesterday for the first time our numbers per whatever it is 10 000 residents is is greater even in the united states for the amount of infections and even the numbers of people who are passing away who are seriously uh ill who are on ventilating machines is is growing exponentially um we won't know for at least another week what the effect of this lockdown will have um it's certainly very severe and there is talk that netanyahu wants to make it even more severe at the moment we're allowed to leave our houses uh up to one kilometer unless you're part of the exceptions uh but now netanyahu wants to limit it to 200 meters uh which will obviously be very severe uh there are some critics who say he's doing this just to get rid of demonstrations against him uh but you know in in recent days we've heard the health minister and others talk about this going way beyond the two weeks uh maybe even a month maybe even longer

27:25 netanyahu came out with a remarkable statement today which said that as opposed to the first after the first lockdown where everything pretty much within a couple of weeks he now says that the reopening and the return to nor normality could take six months if not a from the end of the lockdown so the idea that we will be with some sort of restrictive measures uh for up to another year is something i'm sure most israelis will not not want to hear at this point because people are struggling uh financially emotionally and there's a lot of anger at this point so the thought that we you know have to perhaps have some level of these restrictions for up to another something that will not go down with the uh israeli public uh but the question is how long are we going to be in these restrictive um measures you know there's over a million people out of work there's many many people who are going to be closing businesses in the coming weeks uh who you know will not be able to survive

28:27 even weeks little and months let alone up to a year so this is going to be a very very difficult time for netanyahu and this government because there's a lot of anger out there and it's growing day by day but the numbers are not coming down and it remains to be seen whether this lockdown will happen i mean it will eventually have its desired effect because that's the nature of the uh but how long will be in this and now people are already starting to talk about a third lockdown in january or it could be coupled with the flu uh that's that's the thing that they're worried about since the beginning but we have seen some places around the world in the southern hemisphere which already are leaving their winter flu rates are actually lower than usual because of the measures that we're taking against coronavirus so that remains to be seen what is clear is we're going to be going towards the end of the year into a lockdown or into very very severe restrictions and that is the key moment when netanyahu decides if this government should remain or not because as we know

29:28 uh this government was given a hundred days to try and pass a budget an extra 100 days and i think that runs out in the end of november or december and that's one of uh netanyahu's sort of get out of the coalition-free uh moments where he can leave without any guns uh taking six months in in the prime minister's uh office um so it's gonna be very hard for netanyahu to call elections while having the country under lockdown more than a million people unemployed businesses closing left right and center so this can be a very very um difficult decision especially as we talked about with naftali bennett uh growing in the polls and that's something you used to contend with as but the numbers are still not good um and the lockdown in israel seems to be it's going to be more than two weeks it's probably going to be more than a and for the foreseeable future israel will be locked in this sort of battle about uh exactly how to come out of this because learnt that the quicker you come out of

30:31 the quicker you can come back into it the second way and you certainly will not want a third wave no one wants a third wave um but it depends whether he can stand firm against all the sorts of outrage and all the sorts of clamour to open things up as we saw last time that would be the big uh key uh that we'll probably see in a few weeks we're still doing uh the jewish holidays we have the festival of sukkot coming up uh after it is when the lockdown official is supposed to end and i think a few days after that we'll see a lot of anger protest demonstration against these restrictions we'll see how much the government can hold out against understand well good luck um we have come to the close of our webinar thank you ashley again for joining us or yeah for updating us this week for our viewers please join us monday at 1pm eastern for our next webinar and thank you all for joining us i hope you have a wonderful day