Webinar or Talk
Turkey’s Occupation of Cyprus: 50 Years On with Michael Rubin, Mine Balman, and Marios Lyssiotis
Watch on YouTube
Description
July 20 marks the 50th anniversary of Turkey's invasion of Cyprus. Ankara initially justified it on the grounds of protecting the island’s Turkish minority and preventing its annexation by Greece. That justification, however, when the Greek junta fell ended less than a week later, Greece reverted to democracy and dropped all claims to Cyprus. Against this backdrop, Turkey invaded a second time, seizing in all nearly 40 percent of the island’s territory.
The status quo is increasingly untenable. Turkey created a puppet government, stations troops on the island, and transfers its own citizens to settle the occupied zone. Energy companies discover nearby gas deposits which Ankara claims for itself, even threatening to attack Americans workers. Hezbollah increasingly uses the occupied zone to plot attacks. Money laundering thrives and Iran increasingly sinks roots.
This special, hour-long podcast looks at Cyprus since July 20, 1974, issues arising from Europe’s oldest unresolved occupation, and future prospects.
Mine Balman worked in 2006-20 as first assistant to the Turkish Cypriot member of the Committee on Missing Persons in Cyprus. As a filmmaker, she has produced films and documentaries that contribute to peace-building, reconciliation, and conflict-resolution between Cypriot Greeks and Turks. She holds a BS from Essex University and a MS from the University of Surrey.
Marios Lyssiotis is a former Cypriot ambassador to the United States. He also served as ambassador to France, Austria and the Council of Europe. He holds a BA and an MA, both from the Institute d’Études Politiques, Grenoble, France.
Michael Rubin is director of policy analysis at the Middle East Forum and a past editor of the Middle East Quarterly. He also serves as a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute. Mr. Rubin has lived and traveled legendarily throughout the Middle East, including Yemen, Lebanon, Syria, Iraq, and Iran. He holds a BS in biology and history and an MA and PhD in history, all from Yale University.
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 21, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:12 hello my name is Michael rubben and I'm the director of policy analysis at the Middle East Forum we're going to do a longer podcast today than we normally do or webinar whatever you prefer to call it because we're approaching the 50th anniversary tomorrow of the Turkish invad of Cyprus and even though this may seem like a forgotten Conflict for many in Washington and elsewhere in the world it actively is heating up and the precedents that were created 50 years ago continue to have ramifications today I expect that you're going to see Cyprus much more in the news over the next year or two than we've seen over the past year or two I'm actually thrilled to have two really special guests and this is another reason why I'm thrilled to have a whole hour uh to do this we're joined by Marius Lotus who's the former US ambassador um the former cypriate Ambassador um to Washington DC where I
1:15 got to know him and also Mina Balman who's a very very well-known cypriate producer and filmmaker who is here to discuss turkey's occupation to Cyprus 50 years on um the ethnic Mosaic of Cypress is complex I'm going to leave it to our speakers uh to discuss that but um Mina can we start with you to talk maybe just for about three minutes instead of having a big 10 minute 10 minute 10 minute um sort of introduction and then we can actually do a couple rounds and ask questions of each other before turning to the general audience okay yes thank you very much for this opportunity um yeah unfortunately um tomorrow is the 50th Anniversary or um on 19 74 and um actually you introduced me um as the filmmaker but also I worked H for the commit on
2:18 missing persons for 15 years so um of course um the 50th Anniversary um is also a sad part of the um all the s aspect of the uh missing people issue because we still have a missing people that couldn't be found and returned to their families for proper burial I want to start with this um because it's it's it's important personally it's important for me as well um I want of course we have time limitations but I want to say that um the occupation uh the military occupation that happened in 74 um is seen differently on both sides so um Turkish cots are um seeing it in a different way and Greek cots are seeing in a different way um and course can I just um interject and I I I'm afraid I'm gonna do this
3:21 often just for the audience can you explain briefly how the two sides see it differently for people that might not be as as a tuned to events in Cyprus Yes actually um we we can say that um in mid 50s H I'm just briefly um giving the historical facts in mid-50s um some conflict uh based violence start initiated um which started um um some displacement so uh the first displacement for Greek CIO started in 19 and um 58 um from the mixed neighborhoods and then the same uh displacements happened for the turkey cypriots and in um actually cots in general uprooted from their homes unwillingly in 1958 63 64 74 um so some people H became refugees
4:25 for three times um so of course these things were were happening in the in the past and um um when uh republico turkey as a garer state of Republic of Cyprus uh came to Ireland after the CP data happened in 15th of July um they giving that excuse as well um the they they want to to prevent the annexation of island with the Greece um so turkey cots uh thought that this will end the conflict intercommunal conflict um but actually of course now seeing from and evaluating the history from uh from this uh current day uh we we know that that's not the case um 1974 was an end to Greek cypriot so uh what what do I mean by that um it it means that greos um have missing people
5:31 they lost their houses uh they were unwillingly um they became stranger to their villages to the to their cities H they had economic difficulties and they had to start everything from the scratch um so it's the end of the happy beautiful days uh on the other hand from from uh today I could say that for turkey cots it's a start start o oh a new era um after the um 1974 and maybe initially turkey cots thought that um everything would be better because conflict would stop but actually um living under the um occupation living under invasion was um was not um so uh broad bright days for the Turkish cot uh the political pressures independency to Turkey um the cultural assimilation the
6:37 people who are the population who are carried from Turkey uh created lots of issues uh for the turkey cot and these were not handled properly we're going to come back to you Mina but just for the sake of clarity for our audience you come from the Turkish cypriate Community yes correct yeah okay let's turn the floor over to Mary um Ambassador leotus for a few minutes and then we can come back I'll talk a little bit about us policy and we can discuss the situation among ourselves before turning it over to the floor thank you thank you uh Michael and thanks for hosting me to this uh episode of the uh on this somber 50th anniversary of Turkish invasion in Cyprus if I may I have uh um I would Express a kind of disagreement if I may with what Nina is saying on certain issues ER not not
7:47 ER deny ER or to um make U kind of ER very different narrative um the background if we if we're going to speak about the relations between Turkish cypriots and Greek cots the background of these relations was a background of peaceful coexistence till late in the 50s when uh the colonial power uh tried to use or try to divide the communities and try also to introduce for the first time turkey as an actor in Cyprus a role that turkey itself through the Treaty of loan had had um itself uh
8:51 um refused I mean to to play so if uh I I would myself and the coup we all know and you said it yourself was just a pretext and Cyprus created a lot of precedents uh in this sense so yes ER perhaps members of each Community uh might uh interpret things uh differently the fact is that 1974 has been I think the uh most somber day in the history which is more than 10,000 years of the island of Cyprus for the first time turkey created a president ethnic cleansing ER it occupied one3 of the uh of the
9:56 uh an important part in July when the Constitutional order of the Republic was reestablished they launched a second invasion uh where they occupied almost one third of the country and they turned refugees ER the uh 30% almost of the Greek CPR population which was living so for the first time in the history of Cyprus the the the island its population is divided and uh not only that settlers were brought from Turkey ER even the cultural landscape was destroyed and turkey is building has been building uh in the occupied part of Cyprus a place in its image and that image might have changed sometimes it was the promise of a
11:02 socialist Paradise sometimes now that image is the image of of erdogan's so yes uh it's uh it's indeed ER the um devastating turning point for the history of Cyprus what what happened in 1974 not only for the humanitarian Mina talked about the about the uh Missing Persons but we also have had the enclaved people we also have the refuges there also have uh the thousands of people who uh were killed during the during The Invasion so uh as a as a ER president uh to which you referred we had the first is instance of ethnic
12:07 cleansing and we had also one of the first instances a friend of mine was telling me today if you ER if you change the geographic names ER in the narrative used at the time when turkey invaded Cyprus with other names it's the same the same narrative that Putin used when he Ukraine and this is another uh precedent which I believe we should have in mind thank you I'm actually going to um jump on to what Ambassador lotas said and I should also note Ambassador lotas has been an ambassador multiple times to multiple places and is currently the head of the um the president or the director of The Diplomatic Academy yes but that's on a voluntary basis I don't call them official position okay okay fair I'm a former Ambassador I'm a for
13:11 Ambassador yes good enough um I I just want to highlight a few issues um I'm not as expert on this as uh the Ambassador and Mina Balman are but um I I want to frame this a little bit in US context and why this actually still matters and Marius had said a little bit at the end the first thing I want to highlight just in the background is what we've heard a little bit from both parties that there really is a difference between Turkish cypriots and Turks themselves and that the settlers who are being put onto the island are culturally quite different from those who are native to the island and indeed if there were to be uh reconciliation it would be much easier reconcile uh those on Cyprus who happen to be of Greek origin and those on Cyprus who happen to be of Turkish origin versus the settlers that reti of
14:15 erdan uh and is now pouring onto and into the island uh it's it's a very different culture and I'm exaggerating a little bit it it's like the difference between um what might one experience in Saudi Arabia versus what one might ex um experience in Beirut in terms of Cosmopolitan nature of um society and so now when it comes to the invasion it's important to note there were actually two invasions the first Invasion took perhaps it was basically a beach head and it was meant to prevent um the island from from joining Greece but the Greek Juna collapsed and Greece has been a democracy ever since the ethnic cleansing of Cyprus actually occurred after the crisis had passed when turkey invaded against the backdrop of peace talks uh in Geneva and Turkish diplomats were there Americans were there the
15:19 Brits were there the Greeks were there um there were negotiations in good faith and it really is a primary example of how some countries look at diplomacy as a tool of of conflict resolution whereas other countries can look at diplomacy as an asymmetric Warfare strategy in order to cause opponents to let their guard down and in this case turkey invaded during the peace talks when the crisis had passed and occupied more than onethird of the island and ethnically cleansed it and it remains that way today now this is really precedent in two ways as Ambassador Lotus has said um you could you could um a as Ambassador L Lotus has said you can look at this in terms of what Russia did in Ukraine and actually Reb T erdogan the president of Turkey has said that it's a
16:25 shame that we didn't continue the occupation and completely overrun the island in 1974 because then it would have been a province of turkey today it kind of indicates his indic um where he's going but now what turkey is doing is turkey is saying that this F this fake government that they've established that is recognized by no one outside of turkey the so-called Turkish Republic of Northern Cypress should be recognized as an independent state and in many ways this is the same precedent if any country aeran Kazakhstan Pakistan recognizes the occupied Zone as an independent country and if the West accepts that in any way it's the same as recognizing the dunet People's Republic or the luhansk People's Republic that Russia has carved out of Ukraine what worries me is that there's actually two precedents going on because starting on June 15th turkey reinvaded
17:29 the north of Iraq and they have been systematically ethnically cleansing districts they have burned more than 250 um square miles of Farmland they have forced the evacuation of Seven Christian villages in numerous Kurdish Muslim Villages and what we see if we look at the cypriate precedent is you have this ethnic cleansing then you have the the import of settlers and a permanent change in the demography and then perhaps you have a pleite saying hey let's join the Turkish Homeland or and we've seen this also in Northern Syria where entire districts have been ethnically cleansed Kurdish graveyards have been destroyed turkey has opened up Turkish post offices they've opened up University campus branches for like University of gaziantep and so forth and really sought to incorporate Northern Syria into to Turkey itself the question is whether
18:33 that I mean that precedent if it isn't reversed we actually whether we're encouraging this but I actually have one question as I throw the floor back to you 50 years on the United Nations has really doesn't hasn't done anything even despite the recent aggression they've suffered and you have a lot of people who want to launder the aggression of the past to saying look this is just a fact of life now could I ask both Mina and Marius and excuse me for using your first names now could you each explain why a permanently divided Cyprus is unacceptable um Mina why don't we start you um yeah uh currently we don't have any political settlement so it's a conflict and the Frozen conflict cannot uh um be the solution therefore we need um we need a political
19:36 settlement um and we also uh need of course when I say political settlement um uh personally I don't um agree with the current position of um erdogan government and the turkey cot um elected um um authorities um two- State solution so when I say political settlement I um I'm um talking about a a model which is in favor of cots so um and it will be a sustainable one um yes if we have a a frozen conflict this means that um we can have conflict again um and we we could see that this could happen because in last a um in the uh mix village P um the turkey cot side immediately um entered the uh buffer zone um and this caused U some um
20:44 violence to happen between the United Nations and the turkey cots so um things could um could uh happen in one minute um and violence violence could start so uh definitely the current Su situation is not um a sustainable one um and we also I think need this as cots because we have been suffering from the division we have been suffering from the um the things that were happening um after the division uh and we deserve a better future not only for ourselves but for the future Generations as well um and also we have trauma we have war war trauma that is transferred um through generations um and I think um healing could come after we have the H political settlement um because people need trust
21:49 building um people need reconciliation um people need their missing people to be found and to be buried properly with their cultural and religional um beliefs um so I think CIO deserve this um I want to stand on the humanitarian side of the thing um because as a mother too and um as a person who who didn't experience the um war and conflicts in the past um I believe that I I also carry the respons possibility of this H situation to be to be solved okay um Marius in addition to answering the question I have one other question for you to address yes can you address the failure of the US state department to call Cyprus occupied but those two questions first first first let me um let me uh agree
22:57 with uh with me that the situation in Cyprus is not viable I mean there is a status quo but this status quo is is not is dynamic it might change at any moment you know outside in kirenia now there are 50 vessels of the Turkish Fleet which came to celebrate the invasion a small a small in incident create and we have incidents a small incident might create might change dramatically the situation and I agree with Mina that cypriots deserve better than this we need to find a solution the we need to find a solution which will reunify our country which will reunify our people and which will put an end to the occupation of Cyprus there are and this is particularly important for the Greek
24:03 CIO we you know famagusta V why don't you explain it for the audience vosa is a ghost town 50,000 people were living there and 50 and this I mean it's it's a town in in the occupied part of Cyprus which the security Council considers under the direct control of the Turkish military and which is there it was the most important tourist Resort in Cyprus prior 1974 and it's now actually my wife is famagusta it's a ghost town where ER I mean in case of a settlement people could go rather more easily than anywhere else and uh and and uh and leave there so imagine these people from famagusta who can see the empty houses and the empty
25:07 buildings and so on from some distance away from the ringa Village and who cannot go these people are ready and willing to make and not only them they are ready and willing to make the necessary compromises in order to find the solution I believe it's also important and and and there again there is an issue that we lived before with the Turkish cots and there are there is inter I don't believe that the issue is bomal I don't believe that the issue is the relations between Greek cots and Turkish cots we meet each other and we are not in the 50s we are not in the 60s we are 2020 for so it's it's another era we need to find a solution which will heal and which will repair the losses we had all these year unlike unlike Mina I was 16 years old when I woke up on the 20th of July by
26:16 Civil um civil um how do we call it um by the alarms of the Civil protection Services as turkey started bombing Cyprus and uh I still have that sound I mean it's in a few in a few hours 8:20 tomorrow morning Cyprus time you will 520 sorry you you will hear it again so yes ER we need to find the solution the status quo is hurting both the Greek cots and the Turkish cypriots the status quo is dangerous as Mina said it it can change but we have to take into account something according to me it's turkey that has to uh that I mean the main obstacle to that as far as I my own assessment the the main obstacle to that
27:19 is turkey and uh the turkey c community itself I believe suffers from the policies erdogan is following in the occupied part of Cyprus they're becoming a minority compared to the settlers and they are being imposed a model of life which is alien to their own Traditions you know Cyprus is an island and islands are closed places people interact and they interacted there are problems but in the end they form a kind of community they understand each other they they that's not the case with SE now the the issue you raised about the US policy in cus it has a lot of a lot of aspects
28:24 they it's not only the US ER and and that's one of the problems of the issue you you see we speak about the parties but who are the parties in this case who is occupy we know we say who occupies in uh in Ukraine and who doesn't we don't say this in in the case of Cy and this has consequences because in the end you ask the communities to find Solutions where they are already willing and they want to find Solutions and they we discuss and so on but you just take out of the equation the country which is occupying Cyprus turkey and unless you do something on respect nothing will change so is it fair to summarize Marius that a solution would be much more possible if the Turkish troops went home of course and and a solution can only be
29:31 solution if Turkish troops leave and if cots and that's I mean that's the basis if cots are left alone to organize themselves and we know already how because Security Council resolutions have defined the aspects of the of the solution we know that it would be a federal solution bomal bonal with political equality as described by the relevant reports of the Secretary General and independent we want a normal we want to live in a normal country ER without the having foreign protectors and I believe that the membership of Cyprus in the European Union is already an important factor ER of which provides a feeling of security for both Greek cypriots and Turkish cots if the you
30:36 take out of the equation turkey I'm I I'm I'm very confident that ER we will find solutions to uh organize our poity in a way that respects uh the rights ER and also so meets the concerns of both communities for the Greek cypriots the major concern is security and security and the major threat is turkey and we are witnessing daily events where turkey is becoming more and more and aggressive and if I may just for the audience Marius in 2011 Egan BOS who is one of reab t erdogan's top foreign policy advisers actually suggested that if Americans were working offshore in Cyprus in the gas fields that turkey claimed because turkey claims part of um
31:41 northern cyprus's W the occupied zones waters on on behalf that that's what the Turkish navy is for that they would go after the Americans as well to me when it's shocking and I say this as in my hat as a panelist rather than a moderator um that we on one hand will describe turkey as a crucial NATO Ally and on the other hand one of Reb t erdogan's top advisors threatens to use the Turkish navy against American personnel and then is rewarded for that with the ambassadorship to the Czech Republic um I do want to just point out as a a point of fact that while we can look at turkey's motivations as irid dentist as religious the Imperial aspect of turkey's occupation has since evolved because of course as I just mentioned Cyprus has tremendous gas offshore and turkey is saying that Cyprus isn't allowed to develop its own Waters or portions of its own Waters
32:44 because turkey claims that on behalf of Turkish cypriots as their own in reality and I say this again as a panelist rather than a moderator when we give any legitimacy to the so-called Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus when we and the Europeans are guilty of this try to negotiate with them uh the United Nations is is guilty of this as well it's sort of the analogy I would make is like negotiating with the houthis or negotiating with heah but forgetting that Iran is the power behind both those groups we can try to negotiate with the occupied Zone in the north of Cypress but we need to recognize and this is what I'm deriving from your comments Ambassador that turkey is is behind that um and so how let let me ask you this uh I'm gonna I'll get back to you in a second Mina but I want to ask a historical question that came in on the Q&A function and I would urge anyone in the audience to to type in their questions
33:49 and I'll I'll pose them to to the panelists um could you could could you address Ambassador um how you how you consider the events of 1963 with the 13 points of leader madas the Greek kudeta on the 15th of July 1974 and of course the macaria speech to the United Nations who asked Turkish help just hours before the Turkish Invasion um why why did Cyprus or at least some aspects of Cyprus decide to commit suicide like this you you asked about 19 63 I'm passing on a question from the audience oh okay ER ER the Republic of Cyprus was three years old we had as somebody said ER one of the most complicated constitutions in the world so imagine a young Republic of three years old trying to overcome ER
34:56 all ER all these obstacles and at the same time having the uh interference of turkey ER within the functioning I mean for within the the political system of Cy you could not ER things were becoming dysfunctional so marcario wisely or unwisely one never knows he consulted with other people people and so on it's history that judges it thought it prudent good to H propose some Constitutional Amendments it was a proposal the response was Turkish aggression without even discussing or rejecting I mean his intention was not to change anything unilaterally he made a proposal and he made a proposal which he believed and if we we see it was not unfair to the turkey
36:04 cots marcario in 1974 didn't ask for the help of didn't ask for turkey to intervene to cyp you know to about okay Mina if if I could ask you a question last time I was in the region I heard that when people talk to school teachers for example today in Northern Cyprus that the school teachers are complaining that half their students now speak Arabic or Persian yeah um and that the teachers can't even communicate with them I've also heard rumors that the government in Northern Cyprus is in the occupied Zone um is talking with Russia about building a Russian Orthodox Church um and the Russian orth Ox Church in many ways it it it doesn't stand for um freedom of religion rather it stands for um a a political Alliance and perhaps
37:10 undercutting the traditional Greek Orthodox um Orthodoxy on the island could you address the recent influx of immigrants um both from a social level of non-turkish immigrants I should should say uh on the social level and then both if you and both you and the Ambassador could talk about some of the recent issues we've seen with regard or heard about with regard to the security aspects of this Hezbollah money laundering through land sales uh and other undesirable groups which seem to be using uh the north of Cyprus as a um back door into the European Union if they can get across into Cypress proper SOA yes um y um okay maybe I could um divide my answer into uh two parts because um uh one um aspect of the um problem is
38:17 that um there are tens of universities that were opened in the um in the uh areas um and uh I don't even know the number of the universities so uh universities um are used as one um let's say um step to bring uh people um and that's uh how um the population um is changing via uh the universities so we have let's say uh lots of um people coming from um Africa from the Middle East um who are studying at the University or let's say who are registered at the universities but they don't continue their studies and they are doing um other jobs um which we don't know if they're legal or illegal um so this is one aspect the
39:19 second one um is that uh we have um Russians H we have um people coming from ran um and um of course the problem that you mentioned about the the schools is a is a big problem because uh even in the public schools okay the private private schools they are giving English um education so um it's something that um that minimizes the language barrier but in the public schools where the education is p uh Turkish uh the the teachers cannot communicate with with the children um to to teach them um so yes um I as far as we know we don't know the population um at all but I could say that the the turkey cypriots are one of the minority groups now uh within the
40:22 within those um uh people different coming from different count countries uh and living uh living in the area okay and Ambassador could you address the security aspects of what we've seen with Hezbollah and so forth well I mean I would I I I would continue on on what Mina was saying uh that's an additional reason for having a a solution to the Cyprus problem uh and if I may say a good solution to this hpus problem a solution that addresses a certain concerns and I believe that kind of solution is also to the interest of the United States and of the European Union and to uh the uh the whole uh in the the whole region because um indeed you have a black a ho
41:27 there which you cannot control where you have various elements I mean we had recently even ER issues with um possible terrorist attacks where the people went from the occupied part of Cyprus and they tried to cross in order to hit Israeli interests and so on so you have you have a situation again it's in turkey's image I mean erdogan is hting Hamas erdogan says that uh he has an independent policy he has he he's both with Russian and he's also a NATO member and he claims that he so I believe that that this should be a wake up call for all those who are interested in the stability of the region in order to assist us to uh make efforts and
42:33 contribute towards solving the Cyprus problem in a way that guarantees that these things don't have don't don't continue to happen that is that turkey doesn't have a a Tage over Cyprus or cannot influence its policy uh VAV uh uh the region and and the the main issues which concern us I mean we will eliminate a threat to the peace security and stability of the region as well as a bonus to solving a longstanding problem and if I may just in intercede as a panelist now rather than a moderator um I want to highlight uh what both of you have said in terms of of um US policy one of the big lessons of the pre-september 11th error was that spaces are spaces in which money
43:39 laundering thrives and in which Terror terrorism thrives and terrorists can operate Cyprus is in many ways um an ungoverned space on the island of Cyprus can be more dangerous than what we've even seen in Afghanistan because of its proximity to Europe the Eastern Mediterranean used to be something which the United States sixth Fleet would sail through on its way to the fifth Fleet area of operations to the Middle East to the Persian Gulf and so forth now it very much is contested Waters another analogy I would make is in 1979 when we had the Islamic revolution in Iran even the Carter Administration recognized the danger which that posed of course they were holding American hostages but then again Hamas is holding American hostages right now as well and when Iran's government became islamist became fiercely anti-western fiercely
44:43 anti-American the United States doubled redoubled its diplomatic partnership with the gulf cooperation Council there is no way we were going to let the Islamic Republic of Iran get Beach heads on both sides of that important body of water of the Persian Gulf in many ways the difference between 1979 and turkey 2024 is not that there hasn't been an Islamic revolution according to turkey's own interior Ministry the murder rate of women inside turkey has increased 1, 1400% because of the impunity that religious conservatives feel under the erdogan government the issue is that we are calibrating our policy towards the wishful thinking that turkey remains what it was rather than what it has become and so addressing the Turkey um addressing the Cyprus issue in my mind is akin to us uh ensuring that
45:46 we had proper deterrence and containment back in 1979 when Iran was lashing out for ideological reasons so so that's my two sense there if I may Michael yeah say something on this issue I mean as you know I was Ambassador ER to the United States I was uh one of the um my first experiences was to witness a the failure of the United States to optimize the value of Cyprus and uh for with the US ER because they uh and we can see even now this value with what's going on in the neighborhood they failed to optimize ER this value they even imposed an arms embar on
46:49 Cyprus making it and um at the same time they were not doing what they I mean ER they were not exercising the necessary shall I say pressure influence of turkey on Turkey in order to bring about a solution which would have solve the other issue you are mentioning before the issue of the black box ER in the occupied part of Cyprus where money trafficking uh whatever go on so erdogan turkey has changed there's no way of going back to what turkey was in 1976 77 or even earlier T the US policy has to take this
47:55 into account there's no way of going back there's no way of going back I I agree with you and just on back of the napkin calculation using demographic statistics I believe 35 million Turks or so have gone through the Turkish education system in the two decades of Reb tab erdogan uh and gone through the university system and so forth and so while there might be wishful thinking in Washington that we can go back to the status quo anti once re T erdogan dies Society is fundament CH one Speaking of society changing there are a few other questions from the audience but I want to ask one more and instead of during doing formal closing statements anything you want to say that you haven't said yes just tie it into your answer so that we can end this uh in 10 minutes at 2 o'clock but looking to the Future it's one I mean what drives me nuts in Washington and an academic Community is the wishful thinking we need to do something about this we need a plan without ever Ann what that is if we were
48:59 to reverse the occation look I proposed that we shouldn't a we shouldn't be giving turkey f-16s but if we do give turkey f-16s we should calibrate it to the withdrawal of Turkish forces from Cyprus um but putting that aside when it comes to the settlers in Cyprus does the cypriate government do the people both Society Civil Society Mina in the northern area and the formal recognized government of Cyprus in the kosia Ambassador do they have a mechanism to determine 50 years on who is a legitimate cypriate versus who is a settler Mina why don't I address that to you first and then we'll go to Marius and then I'll uh go through the last questions that we have from the um actually I don't know the answer all this question I I don't even know the population uh and I don't know how many
50:04 PE people uh brought from um Turkey um 1974 um but this is an area that I I researched a lot um um I just don't know the official numbers I could say that it's a really complex situation so uh what they did is uh basically they brought uh people they brought Villages let's say a village that has 500 people 200 people um um so they brought the whole village and uh um put them into a Greek cypriot Village that is empty um after the population exchange um so um yes uh they brought people in waves so uh the first wave 75 and uh then after uh 7 79 81 and uh after 81 it was an ongoing situation
51:08 because uh people started coming individually as well um and of course the mixed marriages um started um and let's say who are the legal um settlers that could be considered as as cot this is a complex situation for the sake of time let me if you I'll it thing H because Generations are passing and there are uh PE there are children of the settlers who speak um Turkish in cypriot dialect U and you can't really differentiate if they're cypriot or coming from turkey and they're in favorable reunification and they're active in Civil Society for reunification so this issue a really is a really complex situation Ambassador can the number can the people actually determined well I mean now it's difficult H but I mean if if you're saying we don't know how many how how
52:15 many settlers there are and I think that minina described the situation more or less the way things were done but in case of a solution we will be in a position to determine well for example if I may press you just as someone who knows knows the government my understanding is if someone wants to apply even from the occupied zone for a republic of Cyprus passport there are ways of determining whether they qualify we we we we know that's what that's why I said I I what I refer to in the beginning we don't know the numbers okay we don't know the numbers exactly and so on so the there are estimates but we know who the citizens of the Republic of Cyprus are we know the turkey secos and as you said they can apply for passports and the vast majority of them has passports of the of the Republic of
53:19 Cyprus or identity cards and so on so yes we will be in a position uh to to determine who are the legal citizens of the Republic of Cyprus we know who the Turkish cypriots are and if you mudis mandis if you apply the legislation you can even solve a lot of issues I mean issues of if you if you apply current laws issues of te marri to a Turk either settler or from turkey and so on it uh it um determining the legal population will be an issue which is solvable okay um just very quick answers because we only have four minutes left I'm looking at the audience questions um why has the European Union um and also the human rights non-governmental organizations Been So Silent on Cypress occupation just very briefly do you have
54:23 any thoughts on that I I if I have to say something I mean the European Union has not been uh that necessarily that silent they could be more vocal and it depends on when we're speaking ER there was at the time a universal condemnation in 1974 because we are also commemorating a universal condemnation of turkey its activities mostly verbal ER there was also there were Al remarks like the ones of Henry kinger what does it matter to the United States if Turkey gets one3 of the island of Cyprus ER we are trying to uh involve as much as possible the European Union in the efforts to solve the Cyprus problem first of all because it's normal we are members of the European Union and the European Union has a stake uh in that
55:28 and they can contribute positively this ER and uh it's even even uh sometimes it's a great ER achievement if we manag to have somebody from the European Union ER for example in the past during the talks in order to give advice and so on for on the solution but not I mean that that's why for example we never had a European Envoy of the Secretary General yeah to the talks I mean it's because turkey refuses to do this even though it's legitimate for the European Union and it's in their own interest and it's in our own interest I mean uh they fail because as you very well know the European Union is not I mean uh it's member states member states have different policies member states have different aspirations different
56:32 relations with turkey and so on so it's always very complicated to get er to to to I mean to get something but on the basic issues for example now for example when we're discussing about the basis of the talks the European Union is very is very clear on the issue okay we only have about a minute left and so I do want to just highlight what you said I mean even before Ukraine this is not only one of the longest running occupations it's the longest running occupation um and of a US partner of a pro-western country that has contributed disproportionately punched far above its weight and unfortunately my own personal observation sometimes we expect small democracies to make concessions simply because it's easier to pressure them than it is to get dictatorships to change their positions um I do just want to highlight some other questions
57:36 although I don't think we'll have time to answer them we had an anonymous attendee who asked well isn't this analogous to what happened with Czechoslovakia in the 1930s uh with regard to the appeasement policy although while I worry about how turkey might look at it in such way and of course if you appease here could turkey repeat this we talked about that earlier in in in other countries we talked about this earlier in the panel um but as you say Ambassador the Europeans are seeming to be holding much more firm even though of course they could hold firmer I certainly would wish that we wouldn't have direct flights from Europe into the occupied Zone in a way that rewards the occupation government with Revenue um and then there is another question and I'll end here how do you assess the role of the organization of Turk States for turkey's attempts to normalize the Turkish occupation of Northern Cyprus um how perspective do you assess the strategy unfortunately seems the strategy has
58:39 been working um in my opinion we could be a little bit more proactive rather than reactive in recognizing that turkey has a strategy um that is undermining the liberal International order um but with that you know the occupation is now at 50 our time is now up but I want to just say that perhaps in conclusion what we are not going to see is the status quo anti- continu whereas perhaps for decades the west and Europe um more generally were willing to allow the northern cypriate issue to Fester now we see interplay in motion with turkey and Turkish revanchism with Hamas with Hezbollah and so forth and it behooves the United States and the European Union I'll say in conclusion to actually have a proactive strategy not to allow this sort of aggression to pay off in a way
59:41 which will undermine our own Security in the future with that I very much want to thank Mina I want to thank Marius off camera I want to thank Daniel pipes the founder of the Middle East Forum as well as Greg ran the the um the present director as well as um anaf kham who has been coordinating all the AV behind the scenes and with that I wish you a good night and everyone in the United States a good afternoon thank you good night and good afternoon to you and to mina bye thank you thank you bye