MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Webinar or Talk

Hussain Abdul-Hussain on Lebanon’s Road to Peace with Israel

Watch Hussain Abdul-Hussain on Lebanon’s Road to Peace with Israel on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

In this episode of the Middle East Forum Podcast, host Lauri Regan speaks with Hussain Abdul-Hussain, research fellow at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies and author of The Arab Case for Israel, about Lebanon, Hezbollah, Iran, and the case for Arab peace with Israel.

Drawing from current events and his book, Abdul-Hussain explains why Hezbollah’s refusal to disarm keeps Lebanon and Israel locked in conflict, how Iran uses its proxy network to pressure Israel and the United States, and why Washington should keep Lebanon policy focused on direct government-to-government negotiations.

The conversation also covers the future of Lebanon-Israel normalization, the limits of the old Palestinian veto over Arab-Israeli peace, and the economic and strategic benefits Arab states can gain from genuine relations with Israel.

Subscribe for more conversations with leading analysts on the Middle East.

Transcript Automatic captions

Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 14, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.

0:00 Good afternoon and welcome to the Middle East Forums weekly podcast. My name is Lori Rean and on behalf of MEF, I thank you all for joining today and for your continued support of the critically important work that we do. This afternoon, I'm pleased to be joined by Hussein Abdul Hussein, a research fellow at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies and the author of the book The Arab Case for Israel, whose work focuses on Arab affairs spanning Lebanon, Syria, Iraq, Saudi Arabia, Yemen, and Sudan. Today's podcast couldn't be more timelier as uh events in the Middle East once again heat up. We're going to spend the first part of the podcast hearing Hussein's insights on the everchanging events in Lebanon and the Iran war. And then we'll turn to the premise of Hussein's book on why immediate and unconditional peace with Israel is a pressing interest for all Arab nations. For those of you who attended MEF's annual policy conference in DC two weeks ago, you should have received a complimentary copy of the Arab case for Israel. And for those interested in reading this compelling and important work, you can order it on Amazon. Today's podcast is being recorded and will be available for future viewing. So, please do share the

1:02 link with those in your network who'll be interested in learning more on this important and timely topic. Welcome, Hussein, and thank you so much for joining us this afternoon. Um, thanks for having me on, Lori. Thank you. I know I'm sure you're very busy right now, and I appreciate you taking the time. Um, I did want to start by looking at the big picture and asking you to share with us what exactly is going on with the US broker ceasefire between Lebanon and Israel which Hezbollah rejected and especially in light of yesterday's escalations beginning with Hezbollah attacking Israel. Israel was retaliating with an assault on Hezbollah in Beirut and then Iran for the first time since April responding with its own ballistic missiles being laed at Israel. Um, first, Hussein, how can Lebanon and Israel have peace if Hezbollah refuses to stop attacking Israel? Um, and second, what's the purpose of Hezbollah's aggression? Is it to stop negotiations between Israel and Lebanon, or is it tied directly to Iran and being used as an excuse for Iran to stop negotiations with the US? Um, please share what you see as the significance also of Iran retaliating for an attack

2:05 on Hezbollah, which I believe is the first. So first of all we have to remember that uh the uh issue between Lebanon and Israel predates the uh creation of the Islamic Republic. Um starting in 1969, Palestinian organizations and militias in Lebanon started launching attacks on Israel. Israel retaliated and this back and forth continued or continues until today. So this is this goes a long time before there was even the Islamic Republic of Iran. Uh now what what you see happening is that um on November 27, uh after launched war on Israel in October 2023 um the two sides Lebanon and Israel uh signed the sessation of hostilities and that agreement said that uh Israel would stop the shooting uh would give back territory that it had taken during the war uh to Lebanon uh on the condition that Lebanon disarmsah of course in

3:09 Lebanon including speaker who's uhah's ally and spokesperson who's in the state signed on this deal the ministers in the cabinet signed on this deal so everyone was under the impression that had agreed to disarming uh what happened was that never disarmed the Lebanese state never forced it to disarm and this forced Israel to continue policing to make sure that it is reconstitute itself, rearm itself and launch another war in the future. Now that's what exactly happened because on March 2 after the Iran war had broken to act to take revenge maybe for and it launched another war on Israel. Uh this time the Israelis responded and said we've been doing this for a long time promises to disarm nothing happens and then we go to another war. So Israel is saying now, listen, this time we will only stop shooting and pull out of Lebanon if the Lebanese government arms first. Nowaha doesn't like this. What wants to see is like what's happened in

4:12 the past that the shooting stops, Israel Lebanon pretends that it disarmed and then everything goes back to the way it was. Um now there's a wrinkle this time. However, seems to be on its last leg. It seems to be very weak. Uh, and Israel is not letting go. And this probably compelled the Iranians to uh, step in and try to defend their proxy because this is their most valuable asset outside of the Iranian borders. So, we saw that uh, Iran attacked Israel unprovoked uh, with at least 10 ballistic missiles. I'm I'm sorry. 23 ballistic missiles I'm told and and two came from Yemen. Um and Israel naturally was forced to defend itself, was forced to respond. And now we have this arrangement where Iran is demanding that for it to stop firing missiles on Israel, Israel must stop going afterah.

5:14 Now this is bad because this undermines the sovereignty of the state of Israel. No one can dictate how Israel can defend itself or how or against whom. Uh this same mistake was committed by Hassanah the chief the late chief of of who when the United States said okay now you are going to have a ceasefire with Israel insisted to tie his war to the Gaza war. He said we will not stop waring until Israel stops waring in Gaza. The Israelis said sorry Gaza is none of your business. This is our sovereignty. Now the same thing is happening. The Iranians are saying you stop in Lebanon and Israel saying sorry this is none of your business. This is between us and the Lebanese. The two governments are talking to arrange for Israel is going asah and Iran shouldn't be part of this.

6:01 So um that's a great segue to my next question because you said you know Israel is not going to be dictated what it can and can't do. So what are your thoughts, Hussein, on the Trump administration's efforts to broker this peace while simultaneously seemingly preventing Israel from using kinetic measures to preemptively go after Hezbollah and in particular, you know, drones and missiles. I mean, last week it was reported that Netanyahu had launched a strike on Beirut. Um, which had then been turned back when Trump called BB and was lambasting him for continuing the military confrontation.

6:34 Yesterday, the president told Fox News that he was unhappy with Israel's retaliatory strikes on Beirut, which were only in response to Hezbollah's attacks. Um, so, you know, I'm concerned that Trump is starting to sound more like his predecessors than the man who ordered Operation Midnight Hammer and Epic Fury on Iran. Do you believe that Trump is being played by the Iranians who insist that Lebanon must be part of this peace negotiation u to end the Iran war? because it's hard for me to believe that Trump and his adviserss are not aware of Iran's gain. What are your Okay, I think the basic problem here is that any foreign policy needs one foreign policy, one president. U we can't have one president and two foreign policies. And this is exactly the issue that we have here. President Trump brought the uh representatives of the governments of Lebanon and Israel into the White House, started direct talks for the first time in 30 years. No one but the Trump administration could do such a thing. And we said, "This is the official channel. These two governments

7:35 sort things out together, agree on how to disarm, start a ceasefire, withdraw, go all the way to peace." And this is great. Now at the same time there are other channels that appeared on the uh side of the Trump administration and all of a sudden we saw President Trump saying uh I spoke to we agreed on a ceasefire. Now, this in and by itself undermines the Trump policy of bringing the two governments together for direct talks because this opens a different channel and this givesah the leeway to decide for itself what it wants to do independent of the Lebanese government.

8:15 So the point here is that we can't be really talking to the government and asking it to disarmah and at the same time talk toah and force the Israelis to go into a ceasefire like like like wants it to be. So this is the issue we I mean this undermines our own policy. This undermines our own credibility. If you're the president of Lebanon and you're thinking, I have America's support to disarmah and then you open social media or, you know, and you see a statement coming out of the of the White House saying that, oh yeah, by the way, we're talking to what would you think?

8:49 You know, I mean, you're going after and the president of the United States talking to it doesn't make sense. So, this is my issue. I don't think President Trump is being played but I think we have uh multiple opinions and President Trump I think must uh restrict everything about Lebanon to one channel and this better be the channel that goes through Secretary Rubio and all the diplomats the great diplomats that we have uh the two governments of Israel and Lebanon. This is the proper way to do it. It's not the proper way. It's wrong to go through back channels through the speaker B who's ally talk toah this is not the way to do it once you start doing the proper channel thing government to government then you will understand that Lebanon cannot be part of the discussion with Iran another thing that that will undermine our position when the nuclear ballistic and proxies now the minute you connect

9:52 Lebanon to Iran you concede this to the Iranians, it means you've conceded on the proxies in Lebanon and that Iran runs Lebanon and so you're automatically giving up on one of the three demands that you that because of them you went to war with the Iranians. So I'm what I'm trying to point out here is that even without comparing to what the previous administrations did on Iran, I think this administration is having an issue of staying coherent, staying on message, sticking with one channel, not multiple channels. If we do that, if we stick to one official channel, um I think that will help us a lot. That will help the Israelis, the Lebanese, and that'll put more pressure on the Do do you what do you think it mean that um Israel did retaliate directly on Iran? Um and Trump I I didn't see uh any negative response from from Trump with regard to that. Um do you think do you

10:55 have any thoughts on whether Trump actually supported Israel retaliating? whether that indicates that maybe Trump is getting to the point where where the US is ready to uh start a kinetic war again. Um does it have any any significance that Israel did that? And and also do you think that Trump is going to let Israel at this point continue to um go after Hezbollah at least um in the south and I I you know southern Beirut as well. Like I said, I think we in the United States and the Israelis should disconnect uh Iran from South Lebanon and Lebanon. It's it's in our interest and it's the interest of Lebanon and it's against the interest of Iran and we we we Israel will have to do what it has to do in Lebanon. This has been going on long before President Trump or any administration or or many of us were even alive. So this is Israel's northern border. It's not an intellectual exercise. Uh, you know, I mean, you and I sit here and talk about

11:59 missiles, but people in Israel have to run to shelters, and we're not running to shelters. So, it's really different if you're sitting there and if you're sitting here 6,000 miles away. So, we have to give the Israelis the space to do what they have to do to uh uh guarantee the security of their northern border to continue talking to the Lebanese government, which is a great thing. Now, on Iran, I think we should keep this separate. If there's no deal with Iran or if there's a deal with Iran, Lebanon should be should be a different thing. You know, we have a plan for Lebanon. The two governments of Israel and Lebanon have been talking.

12:35 They have a plan. They have pilot zone um you know disarmingah the Lebanese armed forces taking over with American support uh Israel conceding territory wherever the Lebanese government takes charge. So we have a plan and is trying to sabotage the plan and sometimes we let it do it. So we have a plan we have we need to follow the plan. Now this is independent of goes on in in Iran. Now, the way we deal with Iran, listen, the the Iranian attack yesterday on Israel was not part of any hormones or anything else. Israel was I'm sorry. Iran was taking the measurements of President Trump. Uh they shut down hormone straight and they got away with it.

13:19 They've been striking the UAE, Bahin, Kuwait, and they've been getting away with it. And yesterday they they thought, why not? Let's try Israel. Maybe, you know, we can get away with it. and and for a while they it's it looked like they were doing so because there were reports that President Trump had instructed Israel not to respond. Had Israel not responded, I think it would have been terribly bad because the Iranians would have even gone further. But since Israel has responded, I think now the Iranians will think, oh, okay, so maybe Israel is off limits. Maybe, you know, we try something else. So this was bound, the response was bound to happen and had Israel not responded, this would have been one of the worst foreign policy full pause that we as America would have committed over the past few years.

14:09 I glad to hear you say that. I was um last night watching events and worried that Israel was not going to respond. So I think we're we're all in agreement on that point. Um, does does President Arun have I mean, it sounds like he has the will to clear out Hezbollah, but does he have the the ability does does Aun and and the LAF have the ability to really get rid of Hezbollah? So, look, I think the will is is a big deal and I think it could have been worse hadah had their guy in the presidential palace in Lebanon. the the president of Lebanon would have easily said dismissed us and said you have to stop shooting and this army is a domestic issue and we take care of it and this would have made our lives much harder and this would have forced Israel to do everything militarily now with there's a chance that we don't need to do everything militarily because the Lebanese government is parting ways withah and by the way is under an enormous campaign of slander frombah as licking the boots of the US

15:14 and Israel. You name it. And to give him credit where credit is due, he's been saying all all the right things. He went on on CNN two days ago and and said and told the Iranians, "This is our country. This is your country. You know, we take care of our own affairs." And all of this is great. Now, the question whether he can deliver on whatever they have promised. The short answer is no. It's an unfortunate no because we've seen that Last Wednesday, the two sides signed a joint agreement here at State Department. And the day after, Lebanon couldn't deliver. They couldn't stop.

15:50 So, Israel was forced to keep on fighting because, you know, the there's nothing that Lebanon can do to stopah. However, if if there's the political will, then this means that there are there's room that we, the United States, can help and support and teach the Lebanese how to do it. And with the Israeli air cover and with Israeli intel, I think we can do something. And I think the what what they have right now, the the pilot zone project that they have, this pilot zone is the Israelis are technically saying, let's take a specific area and let's agree on clearing it and then having the Lebanese army uh holding it and preventing from coming back. And this pilot zone, if it works in 1, 2, 3, four zones, then we keep on expanding these zones until we're we run out of territory and the Lebanese armed forces are in charge and can't come back. And I think this is a great idea and Sentcom should be in involved in the Lebanese armed force.

16:50 This takes time. It can't happen by just pressing a button. Uh but I'm hopeful. I mean, you know, I uh I hope uh that the plan that we have pans out and I hope that u the you know, whatever has in mind, the the ceasefire that they have that the back channel that they have through through President through Speaker Berry to President Trump, I hope that we get rid of all the side noise uh that's trying to obstruct this plan. Um so, one more question for you, Hussein, on this topic. I I saw an interesting um comment on X yesterday talking about the difference between Lebanon joining the Abraham Accords and the countries the the countries that already have signed on which are dictatorships there they're you know autocracies where there's a a king or somebody who who can sign on and tell the people this is what we're doing whether you like it or not. Lebanon's a different situation. um it you know it's not a dictatorship in that sense and it has different factions of different people with different views and backgrounds and cultures. So what are

17:51 your thoughts on Lebanon joining the Abraham Accords at some point in the Well, that's a great question. Let me start by saying that when you have an autocracy, you cannot assume the direction of the popular opinion. So if we have an autocracy, we can't just assume that no one wants peace with Israel. And therefore, if this autocrat has a peace treaty with Israel, it means that no one wants pe. If you have an autocracy, no one knows what public opinion is. And even if we know, there's no way to sway it in any direction because no one can really run a campaign for any topic. So there autocracy is because they they tend to assume that there's an autocracy, everyone is is opposed to Israel. That's not necessarily true. Now, on the case in the case of of Lebanon, as you said, Lori, it there's no autocracy. On on May 19, one of the most reliable uh pollsters in Lebanon called Information International owned by uh Lebanese who is anti-Israel and anti- peace survey

18:55 2,000 Lebanese uh people, which is a good sample. The methodology was was robust. And um in this uh survey, if you took the Shia out, the Shia are the ones who support and Shia are 27% of the Lebanese population. If you take the Shia out, 65% of the Lebanese said they wanted peace with Israel and they this is a huge number. Two in three Lebanese want peace with Israel. You know, this would be probably higher than some circles here in the US.

19:29 uh if you add the Shia because the Shia only eight or 10% said that they wanted peace the the percentage goes down to half like almost 50%. So you still have one in two who want peace with Israel. So the point here is that the Lebanese living if if if uh leave if we leave them to their own devices uh if you just give them a peace treaty like the one that Jordan or Egypt has with Israel. watch the Lebanese normalize on their own, you know, and that's that's a promise. I think, you know, if you give them a peace treaty, they'll do their magic. Uh that's that's my bet. So, and I see it, you know, and and this survey, the the last time such a survey was taken was August 2025. And if you if you look at the numbers, you will see that support for peace has doubled since since August 2025. And this tells you that when the government starts meeting with Israelis face to face and when when when they start holding direct talks, when the government starts saying pieces

20:32 in our interest, public opinion does change. You know, public opinion does follow the leadership and the elected president and the elected government. So, I'm not worried. You know, the obstacle to peace between Lebanon and Israel is not public opinion on either side. The obstacle is an armed non-state militia actor that pledges allegiance to Iran and that wants to to dominate to stay dominant of Lebanon regardless of you know public opinion or who wants peace and who doesn't want peace and and to my mind the minute we get rid of these arms disarmah I think the road to peace between Lebanon and Israel will be wide wide that I'm I'm glad to end that the first half of the um on that topic although we did spend a little bit more time given current events and I do want to take a couple minutes to talk about your book which um I have here I think it's a very important book the Arab case for Israel and I hope everybody can take a look at it and uh digest all the important things that you've covered in here but

21:34 um I want to just focus on a couple things for decades um specifically more recently under Democrat administrations of Obama and Biden there was this misguided belief that and this is as Morgan said in the forward for uh for your book. I'm going to quote Secretary of State John Kerry in December of 2016 um who who stated that there will be no advanced and separate peace with the Arab world without the Palestinian process and Palestinian peace. The two-state solution is the only way to achieve a just and lasting peace between Israelis and Palestinians. President Trump in his first term proved that to be a fallacy when he brokered the Abraham Accords. And um I mean in fact it's my understanding your colleague John Shantzer once said that the Saudis were on the 2-yard line right before um Trump did lose that election to Biden.

22:20 So you know my question to you is do Arab nations really care about the Palestinians and how much of an issue is this when it comes to peace among Israel and its and its Arab neighbors at large? Um I look I I think peace was unfolding. The the the problem here is that Palestinians want the world to stop until they get what whatever they want to get, which to my mind and as I explained in the book, Israel by by Palestine. They don't want a Palestine next to Israel. They don't want to live in Israel. They just want to replace all of Israel. So, they want to uh end Jewish sovereignty and and Jewish nation. So, this is the basic idea. and Palestinians want the world to stop. So if there are talks, say by the Scots and the Irish over something in in the UK, you will see a Palestinian flag and people shouting something in Tifada. So So this is how the Palestinians have designed their, you know, whatever they're doing, their activism all over

23:23 the decades. Now the Arabs have subscribed to this and the Arabs have said, "Okay, we will not normalize ties with Israel until there's a Palestinian state, until the Palestinians get what what they want." Now the issue here with with this kind of model is that okay if you want peace you want to talk to the other guys. The Saudis have been saying listen we will normalize ties but you give the Palestinians a state first. Well if you want to discuss this thing how about you come and discuss it with Israeli officials. How about a Saudi official you know meets an Israeli official somewhere here or in Geneva or anywhere and say okay let's try to sort this thing out. So the Arab proposal, the air what they call the air peace initiative is is not realistic because it stipulates that 5.9 million uh registered as refugees quote unquote with will have the right to go back not to Palestine to be created but to Israel itself. And this means you will have one

24:26 state that's pure Arab and the other state that's half Arab, half Jew. And and of course no one will will accept that in Israel. and rightly so. So the point here is that the the ideas that they had before the immers didn't make sense. And thankfully out of nowhere came President Trump and Jared Kushner and people like uh Morgan and Secretary Pompeo and everyone and they said no let's try to talk to the Arabs. Do you want peace? And then you know these the UAE and Bahin said yes it serves our interest. You know the Israel is a great and vibrant economy based in technology.

25:01 The UAE is is, you know, is always looking for a good deal, looking to boost its economy away from oil income and bingo, you know, you have we had a peace deal. Same applied to the Bahinis. The Moroccans are thinking, you know, we're thinking along similar lines. So anytime anyone of these states think of their national interest and of their econ economic interest, they will go for peace. And this is the basic argument in my book when I try to show that the more normal the relations are between the Arab country and Israel, the more dividends both sides will get in terms of economy, the worse the uh the relationships. Like for example, Jordan and Egypt, they have peace. They call it cold peace with Israel because there's no peopleto-people normalization. So they're doing okay, but not as good as as the Abraham Accords countries. But then when you compare Egypt and Jordan to Lebanon and Syria, you would think, well, you know, Jordan and Egypt are doing great. Even with their cold peace, they're doing great compared to the states that that are still at war with Israel. So, you can establish a trend.

26:03 And and thankfully, like I said, thankfully that someone in Washington thought, okay, why wait for whatever proposal that the Arab League has? Why not come up with our own ideas? And it worked. And I I think this is the right idea and this is what we should expand with other countries. So, um, we just have a couple minutes. I'm going to ask you just to follow up a little bit on the assumption that, um, that if they pri if the Arab world were to prioritize its economic and and living standards, um, it would realize that peace with Israel is is um, in its best interest.

26:38 But there's also another side of that which is the animist towards Israel. um the belief that Israel is um colonizing stolen land. Um you know, you talked a couple minutes ago about this and the fact that the Arabs really want didn't want to make peace with an Israel or the Palestinians. They they wanted no Israel. So, how do you reconcile I this animist towards Israel, which probably also helps allow some of these leaders to remain in power? um it's an concept um you know against Israel and the Jews in the region with the notion that they the Arabs will prioritize what's in their best interest. Can you reconcile those two?

27:24 Well, I think I think you should be able to unfortunately a country like Saudi Arabia that was really really close to normalization with Israel. Um, you know, NBS had a ambitious plan, vision 2030, modernize the economy away from oil econom oil rent just like the UAE had done before him. And for some reason, this didn't work out. It just it tanked. anything. The first thing he did was that he uh gave up on normalization, distant himself from Israel uh and and resorted to the populist pitch of you know look at the Jews, look at Israel, look at and and this is unfortunate and I think many of these countries do the same. I think the Turks under did a similar thing. Turkey used to have one of the strongest ties with with the with Israel and and then when the economy started suffering being the populist the Islamist populist that he is with the Muslim Brotherhood he started uh steering things with with Israel and you know there's tension now

28:26 and relations are not at their best and I would say this applies to almost everyone in the region whenever things go back go bad for them they instigate against Israel can we convince convince these people that listen when things go bad bad it's in your interest to really make peace you know this the dividends of peace in terms of economy are much better than really just sitting back and and instigating your population against Israel and the Jews it's it's not an easy thing to do and you know this thing the animus against the Jews is really ancient and if you don't find it with with the Arab nationalists who imported it from Nazi in fascism, Nazi Germany and the fascism of of Europe. Uh you will find it with the Muslim Brotherhood and the Islamist organizations that imported from 1400 years back from you know old legends and tales about the time of prophet Muhammad. So this requires some leadership. This requires some heavy lifting. Leaders might not be

29:29 popular when they call on their population to follow them and trust them in normalizing ties. But this is what true leadership must be. You know, this is what they should do uh to uh to lead their populations into better economics and a higher standard of living. Thank you so much, Hussein. And thank you to everybody in the audience for joining. Please do um order Hussein's book, The Arab Case for Israel on Amazon. It's terrific read. Uh you'll learn a lot. And uh I hope you all can join us on Wednesday for Israel Insider with Ashley Perry at 3 p.m. And uh Hussein, thank you again for taking the time. I'm sure you're going to be we're going to be seeing a lot of you in the in the media over the coming days. So we appreciate it.

30:11 Thank you. Good afternoon.