Webinar or Talk
Are the Kurds on Their Own? with Mindy Belz
Watch on YouTube
Description
The Kurds are among the largest stateless people in the world, spread out primarily among Iran, Iraq, Syria and Turkey. Currently, they are central to the mass protests in Iran, under Iranian attack in Iraq, under Assad’s attack in Syria, and under Erdoğan’s repression in Türkiye. Where are these crises heading? What are U.S. relations with the Kurds in these four countries?
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 2, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:04 Cliff Smith here um welcome to the Middle East forums webinar and podcast Series today I am hosting a special guest Mindy bills uh Mindy work is with globetrot a Weekly Newsletter she writes devoted to news around the world um previously for several decades she was a senior editor at World magazine an Evangelical Christian outlet with focus on world affairs she has done on the ground reporting in Iraq Syria Sudan Israel and many other countries in the Middle East um she is also the author of a book called um they say we are infidels on the run from Isis with persecuted Christians in the Middle East um I have read Mindy's writing and occasionally shared tips and learned from her for many years welcome Mindy thank you for joining us thank you Cliff for having me um the thing we're going to talk about um along whatever else comes up is um one place in particular you have spent a lot of time in your running around the globe is the Kurdish regions of Iraq and Syria and you discuss
1:09 um a lot of that in your book um they say we are infidels which is largely born out of your experiences um mostly in Iraqi Kurdistan um you've been to the region many times and you've continued to write about it um so just in general terms let's start out um you want to discuss your experiences in the region how many times have you visited what are your impressions how they interact of their of that region how they interact their neighbors wherever you want to go with that well sure well I mean I think most of us can remember that when the United States went to war in Iraq um now almost 20 years ago um that the Kurds were our first and foremost Ally in in the the fight against the Saddam Hussein and um I actually went to Iraq for the first time a year before that war started and I went um through winning through the back door into Iraqi Kurdistan and and with the help of Kurdish groups
2:14 that were then headquartered in Damascus headquartered in Washington you know kind of living uh as they had to do under Saddam Hussein something of a of an exiled life um but but we've watched as this region and and the Kurdish people themselves have become a Powerhouse in the Middle East and and they have been throughout I would say you know and and let's just agree a very difficult region where almost all the territory is contested by Terror groups by the Iranian regime by corrupt um the Kurds have built themselves into sort of an economic and political Powerhouse and a force to be contended with and so I think what what is relevant right now and and you know one of the reasons I think it's important that we're having this conversation is that this um this incredible protest movement that we're seeing emerge in Iran it's now
3:17 entering its second month no one thought that you know friends and um supporters of an Iranian Kurdish who was killed in late September no one thought that this um well actually she was killed in in early September no one thought this movement would would grow as it has and that it would come to be focused in some ways on the Kurdish people who are spread from Iran through Iraq and into Syria so I think it just brings out a lot of the Dynamics that we've watched develop in this region and particularly draws attention again to the Kurdish people yeah you actually kind of preempted my next question there insofar as I was going to ask um it was the murder of Masha amini in Iran that set off these protests how much do you so you kind of alluded about how much of this is focused on the fact that she was Kurdish because then clearly the protests are far beyond just Iranian
4:19 Kurds how does the fact that she was Kurdish play into this in your view well a lot of the um I mean not all but a lot of the sort of fuel for the protest fire I would say has come from um Kurdish groups inside of Iran and um they have long been persecuted they have long been sort of on the outskirts of both the economic and the um political life of Iran but but you know keep in mind that everyone in Iran has suffered tremendously under um under the regime and under the sanctions that have come as a result of the regime's policies and so this this the way in which she was um by police forces and and killed and uh you know and then and then the Iranian government um kind of tossing that off and making excuses for what happened to her while she was in custody the fact that she was
5:24 um arrested for not simply I mean it wasn't even that she wasn't wearing the hijab she her hair was showing you know um and so so all of it has provoked understandable outrage but it has also revealed sort of this the fact that the Iranian people have lived so much under the thumb of the regime in a way that we don't often appreciate because because they are Muslim people and so we don't appreciate um degree especially in the west the degree to which this Islamic extremist regime persecutes its own people persecutes Muslims as well as Christians and and other groups you think the the events in Iran are being viewed by the Kurds in Syria Iraq turkey so on well I I think that it has been like not on our radar at least in the media so much that um that Iran very quickly Unleashed a barrage of attacks
6:27 when when the protests deepened became very entrenched um somewhat I would say out of hand I mean if you look at the footage you can see that you have you have girls you have students you have now University uprisings that that are deepening the protest movement inside Iran as that happened I mean it became clear to the Iranian regime they were getting support from outside and they began um Kurdish areas in Syria and Iraq and in particular um and we got several reports I mean they've they and the Iran has now admitted they fired 73 surface-to-air uh no I'm sorry surface to surface missiles at Kurdish groups in inside Iraq so so in a sense widening the conflict through their own choice and and bringing all the Kurdish people into this protest um the the attacks in Iraq I mean what you have to understand it comes back to
7:30 how the Kurds have sort of become a force to be reckoned with across this and have become a Force for openness and democracy not perfectly not without corruption and problems um but have really become a Force for Freedom both inside a rock inside Northeast Syria and inside Northern Iran and so when Iran launched these 73 surface area service to surface missiles it's very ironic that there was there was sort of a Congress of medical people from throughout the region that was gathering outside of erbil in the town of Koya Koya is this you know University Town it's it's considered kind of a cultural center um it's a lovely lovely area of Iraqi Kurdistan I mean like a barrage dozens and dozens of missiles um were fired there in late September and I believe nine people were killed including a mother who is pregnant and and her baby was killed she baby was
8:33 delivered and and was also dead um so and people there were images of people this this Congress of medical people instead of meeting to discuss how to spread um Medical Care throughout the region they ended up being at the hospital next door taking care of the wounded and and you had hundreds of a rocky Kurds inside um and Iranian encouraged living inside Iraq who are having to take cover underneath rocks and and underground shelters in Iraq so all of that a picture of Iran sort of deciding to widen a conflict that it can't seem to bring under control itself in in its own country how so and you alluded to this um when you discussed um your time visiting Kurdistan in the early 90s you know after that the Kurdish Regional government in Iraq was formed and um it has you know some autonomy how has it reacted if at all to this
9:36 attack that is yeah I mean obviously they they've protested the the dropping missile I mean keep in mind that you know the last couple of years we've seen this region become um notable for garages of missiles if you remember after the United States killed General suleimani and in a in a strike in Baghdad that um Iran responded by attacking U.S Air Base and other Targets in Northern Iraq the same region and so I think the Kurdish government has tried to try to not escalate the conflict but is also protested I would just put it that and um um how does the only go to the next issue that might kind of boomerang back to this but uh turkey has of course also long had issues with its Kurdish um however since Northeast Syria has become governed by the Syrian Democratic
10:39 Council a semi-autonomous region kind of like Kurdish Regional government in Iraq during the Syrian Civil War um that's become a much bigger issue and turkey has made numerous excursions into Northeast Syria so it's no longer just domestic it's also International um and it's sort of an Open Secret in DC that the Turks have quite openly sought support for a full-out invasion of Northeast Syria creating what they call a buffer zone do you want to talk about how these things play out what are turkey's goals um how does the SDC respond to it you have any thoughts on these kinds of yeah it's um I mean these uh sort of low-level Wharf here I would call it have have been somewhat self-contained you've had um the situation for the Kurds in Syria that's somewhat different for the situation of the Kurds and Iraq and different from the Kurds in Iran what we're seeing right
11:43 now through the Iranian attacks on the Kurds as a whole is that that the conflict is being widened and and that is in the context of a region that both the United States and Russia have a strategic interest in and plain out on a geopolitical field that you know where we now are in quite a big war um with the threat of nuclear escalation in Ukraine I mean all of these things are related so the turkey moved into Northeast Syria at a time when the U.S and Russia were sort of contesting over how this war in Syria would be brought to a close and in fact it's been a standoff the war has not over and um and in Northeast Syria there is in particular again a kurdish-led very stable government with kurdish-led
12:48 um broadly democratic military force that includes also Christian militias yazidi Warriors um you know and and some Arab Fighters as well turkey is using the context of of the the pkk group that has you know a terrorist past using the pretext of the pkk being part of this widely democratic uh group as for coming across the border trying to create this buffer zone and in fact they occupy a region you know at 30 and 40 miles somewhere inside the border um Syria and this is something that you know you have to say nato is just kind of I mean turkey is a member of NATO they have crossed a border into another country or occupying territory that's that's against the NATO Charter and NATO has just been sort of looking the other way since 2018 2019 when this began and now it has very strategic
13:54 ramifications because if Iran wants to continue to prosecute a tax on Kurds that is going to bring in these wider forces and you're going to have to either turkey and Iran conspire somehow to attack the Kurds which is a big problem for us in the west or they're going to be competing as they attack them and and you know for so long the United States was basically the patron of the Kurds and we all know that it was it was in some ways the sell-by date had passed on the U.S being at war in Iraq but the fact that we've had these these debates and you know troops have been pulled troops have been left in we we definitely have uh special forces in the region who are activated at times when we feel like our interests are um you've had you had U.S Special Forces very involved in a terror-led attack on uh prison in um Northeast Syria and these terror-led attacks are all you
15:00 know standing behind them is Turkey and um at some point this is going to blow up into a wider conflict again I think is is what we're looking at and why it's really important to pay attention to what happens to the Kurds that that you alluded to this but how does you know Donald Trump um quite famously pull the U.S troops out of parts of Northeast saharia um and that was very controversial even within his own Administration um do you want to speak to how that decision has shaped events in the last couple of years yeah and I think most dramatically because I I was I was there right in Syria right around the time that happened and then it came back again because because of the way the Turks had invaded Northeast Syria they forced thousands of people from their homes as a result of that and those those people continue to be living in displacement camps in Syria you know and and it was it was such a confusing and chaotic move
16:03 uh Trump on on a Sunday night communicate you know issued a statement from the White House saying that he was pulling back in order that turkey might move in and um and and we didn't end up pulling as many soldiers as he had first communicated and that I mean there was a point when I was there you could literally see the U.S forces crisscrossing the region in part because they didn't know where they were supposed to be ultimately it was a lot of pain and no gain what it did most dramatically is it it really kind of sealed the deal on trust between the Kurds and the United States and and between these governing authorities in Northern Iraq and Northeast Syria and across the region because the United States just it became so clear that the United States was treating this area as a football that they could toss whichever way they
17:06 wanted to and was very unclear itself about what the U.S role and what U.S presence was going to look like at this point I think that military commanders on the ground um with sent come have worked very hard to kind of restore some of the trust and to on a local kind of um very much under the radar way tried to shore up the U.S role in the region and try to support these military forces that we have been allied with now for two decades uh and that's worked to some degree but it but it's uh it's created a very much of an atmosphere of distrust of political um leaders in in the US and that you know let's be fair that began with Obama uh in in I mean that began with bush if we want to go back to some degree but it increased with Obama it multiplied exponentially under Trump and I don't know that Biden has even paid enough
18:09 attention to some of these things for it to change at the political level um I'm gonna ask another question or two and then we'll get to audience questions we already have quite a few up here but if you are um interested in asking questions please uh type it in the Q a box and we'll get to as many as possible um specifically since you've written about it um indigenous Christian populations of Iraq and Syria have generally found the most um regions of The Wider region to be kurdish-controlled areas of Iraq and Syria do you want to describe a little bit of the relationship between you know the majority Muslim Kurds and their Christian neighbors it's something you've obviously thought deeply about yeah and it's uh it's it's one of I would say um trying to think of a good a good way to kind of shorthand way to describe it there's definitely some friction there
19:12 um but there also is a recognition that uh you know if if you are a Christian Living in Iran or in Iraq um Iraq is where I've spent the most time if you're a Christian Living in that region uh you have to choose patrons or protectors I would say from a lot of Bad actors and so are you going to choose a muzzle majority that often accommodates Terror groups that want to see you beheaded or are you going to be more comfortable with Kurds who have broadly and vocally supported Democratic Values uh even though some of those elements are extremist even though some of those elements are corrupt and have and have in some cases you know in localized cases I see this happening where you know these Christian communities that were all threatened and many of them emptied under Isis if you
20:16 remember starting back in 2014. 300 Iraqi Christians forced out of their homes forced out of Nineveh plain where did they find Refuge they found refuge in Iraqi Kurdistan and um and most of them are still there their churches are there their Church their their clergy has relocated um the you know until recently we saw a few churches reopen in mosul and and the the clergy is back there in mosul but for the most part they still live in Iraqi Kurdistan they simply can visit uh because security just has not returned to those regions so it's an uneasy uh truce an uneasy piece I guess I would say between those groups and and uh with the exception of a few Pockets you know the Kurds have been open to I visited churches in urbial the capital of Iraqi Kurdistan churches where 2 000 people might show up for a match the Chaldean Mass churches where
21:19 hundreds of people are forced to be uh you know with the doors open I mean I mean really kind of mega church type um events and and and this security for those will be the the Kurdish um uh peshmerga standing in the street corner directing traffic that kind of thing very different feel than you would get in other parts of a rock or other parts of Iran all right we'll get to audience questions uh we have quite a few we'll get to as many as we can um this is from um Rabbi Joel Schwartzman um who is arming the Kurds any of these countries are the Russians in the U.S not keeping turkey from invading and annexing large swaths of Northern Syria yeah I would say that there's a there's an uneasy jocking there the the United States is trying to I think continue to keep turkey in the native fold and so they don't want to just um jeopardize that by creating like an
22:23 open conflict that pits U.S forces uh a NATO partner against turkey directly so you see a lot of sort of proxy things and that gets to some of the other questions I see here where the United States is definitely supporting Kurdish forces and we had so much to do with the build up of Kurdish forces during the years of the Iraq War um but those those forces Now operate on their own to a large degree um they will still receive you know military aid and and other Aid that the United States provides to a lot of countries that are considered our allies um but but not to these forces are standing on their own and they operate on their own they train on their own they have their own commanding structure Northeast Syria is a little bit different where I think you you know those the ypg forces that are operating in Northeast Syria
23:26 have grown up as militias that were fighting Isis and there may be just second gen whereas in Iraq they're more third and fourth generation and and so they still operate very much more of a um that kind of structure and they do cooperate a lot with the U.S forces that are in the region but but U.S forces are keeping very much of a support role and managing this very delicate dicey situation where you have Russian forces that are still there and where you have Syrian forces that are I I mean if you go to comeishly in Northeast Syria there's there's a part of the city and I've stayed in a hotel not far away from there and it's very tense and you'll have uh you can see the Syrian checkpoint the uh ypg Kurdish checkpoint and then there are Russian forces and U.S forces right there in that mix too so it's it's a very tense place yeah you can imagine just by saying those few words there and about who's
24:29 stating where um next question is from Hal Tarr I'll paraphrase this a little basically he's asking turkey Sweden and Finland made promises some of which are not actually public from what I understand to Turkey um and turkey is concerned that Sweden and Finland are too close to the Kurds which is what they initially said they were and are still occasionally threatening to veto their NATO um how has that affected the Kurds as a foreign yeah I mean it's helpful to understand a little bit background there I think because of the way that the Kurds were persecuted under Saddam Hussein because of the way that they have been persecuted in Iran and the effects that we're seeing very directly of that right now um you have a Kurdish diaspora that extends across Europe into the United States you know we have a large Kurdish population in the U.S and and also in these Scandinavian
25:32 countries that took them in starting in the 90s and Contin with the first Gulf War and continuing on through and so it is it is the basis of that that has made these countries um very open to their Kurdish populations and somewhat protective of them turkey under President erdogan is simply using that as a way to kind of blackmail them this is how the erdogan regime operates and so um they kind of are asking Finland and Sweden to to do their dirty work for them as a as a way of um of of Co-op you know as a way of of saying we'll check off the boxes for you to join NATO if you do this dirty work for us regarding the Kurds and again it's an uneasy negotiation but I mean to my knowledge they have not stepped in and stopped it because they've been warned not to do that um but but I think that there there is continuing to be this jockeying for
26:35 power and for concessions from Finland and and Sweden and I think what we want to watch for this is going to happen when it comes to Ukraine as well what we want to watch for just kind of the the ways around the edges that we see the curds are being co-opted because people have had to make side deals to accommodate turkey to accommodate the negotiations with Moscow that kind of thing that's what we want to watch for these and it's not only the Kurds it's other minority groups who can suffer because they simply they don't have their own country they don't have their own Representatives at the UN level and things like that and so and and so they're constantly going to be on their heels a little bit apart from support from Western Nations I'm gonna get one or two more here before we have to go uh Larry Greenberg says an Assyrian friend in the U.S tells me that even in autonomous Iraqi Kurdistan even in erbil Assyrians are persecuted property confiscated Etc do
27:39 you want to speak to how that kind of thing plays out started to say earlier and I just were going in too many directions one of the things I've noticed you see it a lot in Northeast Syria because because the Kurds were the ones who sort of stood up these ypg forces they successfully fought back Isis from towns that had large Kurdish populations but also historically were Christian after they helped to defeat Isis this would be in 2015-2017-2018 time period they began using Kurdish names for these towns and and CR and they had historic Christian towns in Issa would be one um but other areas are much smaller this is this is a rural society that is still very agrarian a lot of ways and I began
28:42 noticing as I was traveling across the region that I would use the Assyria the ancient Assyrian names for a town and someone would correct me with a Kurdish name and it's become very much of a political battle fought at the local level and I think this is a very difficult question I think if Western Powers Western groups if you saw Western Aid in this region like we've seen in Northern Iraq if you saw uh the United States being a good supportive actor of democracy in these regions that we would be able to bring these groups to the table and say look you know an ancient historic town that has had a name for a Christian name for not even centuries but for Millennia ought to be able to keep that name in other words they seem like third and fourth tier problems that ought to be able to be negotiated I believe with
29:46 with some outside help and and that simply hasn't happened because you've had so many other major things happening in this region that the United States and others are just like we don't care what you call the town we just want to be sure that Isis isn't controlling it and and that's long-term that's not a good solution long term that is going to lead to and it is leading to increasing conflicts among Assyrian groups the ancient Christian groups of the region and the Kurdish groups uh my own one maybe two more um several people have asked what is the relationship between the different Kurdish groups you've mentioned and Israel and uh how they interact in some of this yeah big question how are you that would be interesting yeah I I might just kind of Punt and say it's uneasy um you know I mean it's interesting because the kurts in Israel if you think about it have a lot in common um the Kurds have for centuries uh called for their own nation and they and
30:48 that's never you know they will often be called one of the largest people groups with the out of country in the world um and and that reminds you of the history of Israel uh but I also I think that they are they have been at loggerheads too because the Kurds are historically a Muslim group and um and that has put them at odds with some of the interests of Israel that's uh very much of a summary statement but kind of how I would put that okay uh I would love to ask more questions and there's a whole bunch more to answer but unfortunately we are out of time uh really appreciate talking to you about this and everybody else please join us next week for more webinars and podcast series and uh thanks for being here thanks Mindy thank you cliff foreign