MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Webinar or Talk

Israel Votes: Election Night Special with Gregg Roman and Alex Selsky

Watch Israel Votes: Election Night Special with Gregg Roman and Alex Selsky on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

Minutes after polls closed in Israel's October 27, 2026 Knesset election, Middle East Forum Executive Director Gregg Roman and Alex Selsky, MEF's Director of Israel & East Mediterranean Affairs, went live to break down the first exit polls. Channel 12's initial exit poll gave Gadi Eisenkot's bloc 52 of the Knesset's 120 seats, Benjamin Netanyahu's bloc 50 and the Arab parties 18, nearly double their 2022 total. Likud placed first in all five exit polls, but no poll gave either bloc the 61 seats needed to form a government.

Selsky explains why the channels' exit polls differ, why neither bloc reaches 61 without the Arab parties, and how Israel's coalition process works, from party recommendations to the president to the deadlines for forming a government. Roman and Selsky also discuss whether party leaders will keep their pledges not to rely on Arab parties, the votes lost by parties that fell below the 3.25% electoral threshold, and why Selsky sees little difference on security and foreign policy whoever becomes prime minister.

In the Q&A, they answer viewer questions on bloc versus party seat counts, surplus-vote agreements, how parties are barred from running, whether Mansour Abbas will be the kingmaker, and why former senior police officer Yoav Segalovich is running second on the Ra'am list. Roman closes by stressing that these are initial results and that election night is only the end of the beginning, with coalition negotiations and the swearing-in of a new Knesset speaker still ahead.

Chapters
0:00 Preview
0:20 The first exit polls
1:48 Party-by-party results
4:40 Three early takeaways
7:37 Why the channels' polls differ
11:45 How a coalition gets formed
15:59 Will parties keep their promises?
20:04 Bloc seats vs. party seats
23:12 The Arab parties' new role
27:21 Latest numbers from five polls
29:09 The threshold and 'burned' votes
36:02 Surplus-vote agreements
38:20 Ra'am, Balad and the Supreme Court
40:44 Is Mansour Abbas the kingmaker?
42:57 A Jewish ex-police chief on Ra'am's list
45:28 Equal service and the draft law
50:11 How party leaders reacted
53:11 Closing

Subscribe to the Middle East Forum for expert analysis of the Middle East every week.

Transcript Automatic captions

Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 28, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.

0:00 And the biggest surprise of this election is the Arab parties have 18 Nobody gets 61 without the Arabs. This is only the end of the beginning. Good evening and good afternoon, good day to everyone who joins us today on the special Middle East Forum Israel elections webinar for October 27th, The initial exit polls are in and now we'd like to report at least the first results that are coming in from the polls that were taken by Israel's channel 12 and we'll also follow up with channel 14 13 the public broadcaster Khan Mi Voila and other Israeli sites in terms of who is expected to win these elections and in what places they were able to get in terms of looking at the

1:03 overall large picture The results are as follows. For the three blocks, that of the Shinui block or the change block led by Gotti Eisenkot, that of the current coalition led by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and that of the Arab parties split between three major parties across two blocks. As it stands right now, the Eisenote block came in with 52 seats out of 120. The Netanyahu block pulled at 50 seats out of 120. And the biggest surprise of this election is the Arab parties have 18 seats, almost doubling the amount that they had in the previous Knesset election which took place in 2022. In terms of the divide of what we're looking at for the parties of how they performed, Lily Cud is pulled at getting 24 seats being the largest party in this election. [clears throat] We also see that the Eisenote uh party,

2:07 Byak or Derk, excuse me, was polling at 22 seats. When we look at those who came in third place, Byakat led by Napali Bennett and Y laid is at 12. The joint Arab list at 11, Israel Betenu led by Avidor Lieberman at nine. A democrat team or the Democrats led by Yer Golan, the uh left-wing party is also at nine. With eight seats comes Arya Daris Shas the historical safari ultraorththodox party. [snorts] Raham the uh Islamist political party led by Mansour Abbas comes in at seven. And the Ashkenazi ultraorththodox party Yoda Torrah United Torah Judaism comes in with six seats.

3:00 In the last two parties which were able to maintain a uh presence in the Knesset, you have religious Zionism led by Betilos at six seats and Oats Mahi Odit led by Itamar Bengavir at six. Uh according to polls including the MEF poll of polls which has been tracking all these numbers for the past five weeks the two parties which did not pass the electoral threshold to get into the Knesset include Ofra Winter and Ysef Kad Israel or the people of Israel and Yawaz Hendel yam Zika the reser economic reform party did not get enough votes to pass the electoral threshold.

3:48 So again, what we see right now in terms of the expected results and I have to put a uh asterisk above this because I remember four years ago there was also the initial exit polls which gave a win to Benny G and we ended up waking up the next morning seeing that Benjamin Netanyahu was going to be able to put together a government. So this is just the initial results according to a survey uh led by one of the polling companies from channel 12. I'm sure we'll see different results from every uh channel that we go through and we'll be collecting those results. The results were just released 6 minutes ago. And there are even still people in line right now still at the polling uh stations trying to finish their vote. If they were in the line at the polling place at 10 p.m., they'll be allowed to stay there until they have the opportunity to vote. But we are in for a long night ahead of us here in Tel Aviv and in Jerusalem. And to tell us what this all means, I'm gonna ask our Israel director, Alex Selski, to give his input. Alex.

4:48 Hi, good evening from Jerusalem to everyone. Good evening, Greg. Well, very outstanding and very historic elections by the voting uh percentage. It is one of the highest or maybe the highest. We still don't know because people still vote because by Israel law if you enter the the voting station before 10 you can vote even after and there are many many lines in the voting stations all over the country. So we still don't know but we definitely understand that this might be at least the highest voting since at least 88. So uh few things.

5:28 First, as you Greg said, this is only poll and we cannot trust it as the results and you brought the example from the last elections that the exit poll was not precise and there are many others uh we could which we can bring but we just you know just one example we see many many differences between the results in different polls for example the a Victor Liberman's party in the poll exit poll of uh channel 12 is nine in channel 13 is seven another poll is six. We see differences in the ultra orthodox parties results but I think that we definitely can see two major or three maybe major things which I think we will find in the results which we already see. First, we don't see a win of a coalition or opposition, meaning nobody gets 61 without the Arabs, right? Second is a

6:33 big win for the Arabs parties. They grew up. We see in some polls 18, in some polls 17, but it's it's clear that they that that they rose. And the third thing that I think is already clear that we can see is that the parties the new parties the party of uh the the new ultra orthodox party of Mi Lightner the party of Yazendel and Iran and the party of the the brigadier general winter. These are three parties that were fighting and and made the most noise. Yes. And most troubles for the big parties. None of them apparently by all the polls didn't pass. So, uh we will definitely have to wait until the results, but I think these three major tendencies we can already see clearly.

7:38 So, Alex, can you I'm showing the results from five of Israel's news channels. Can you tell us what this means and why there might be um a little bit of a of a skew of the results. For instance, channel 14 right now is showing 30 results for the Leoot and only 19 for Gotti Eisenot's party. Is that attributed to their traditional support for the prime minister or do they have a different polling formula that they use? The same thing with I24. And if if you look actually at some of the results from the state news broadcaster and from uh channel 13 which is private, you see that the leak is the winner at least in terms of the most amount of votes in all five polls. What does this mean?

8:20 Well, definitely Greg, we can first of all see that, you know, the channels that are which audiences are more supportive of the coalition uh they show more better results for the coalition, right? the channel 14 and the channel I24 and the channels that are you know let's say more less supportive for the coalition or represent more the whole Israeli society or more supportive for the opposition show worse results for the coalition better results for opposition. Now you may say that you know that these c voting that these polling companies you know use different techniques or they maybe are biased or they measure measure you know people closer to the audience of their channel.

9:10 So definitely we see that this can be the uh the explanation for the gaps. But again you know this is a very you know exit polls or polls at large is very you know complex challenge. First of all, we know for example historically historically that voters of some of the let's say clear lie at the polls first of all because they cannot you know they don't want to explicitly show what they vote. You know, for example, you know, we we we we know about many right-wing voters who work, let's say, in finance or in high-tech where majority of the people around them are not, you know, traditional right-wing voters.

10:00 So, they, you know, they they don't say explicitly that they vote for. So, you're you're telling what you're telling me is is that when they answer a pollster's question for an exit poll, they're not going to tell the truth of who they voted for. This is one. And second, we know that liquid voras, for example, historically uh don't kind of, you know, don't say exactly uh on the voting stations at the exit polls in order to to to kind of give liability for a campaign that says, you know, we you know, what we say in Hebrew, the gal campaign, right? Like save us, save us.

10:36 We, you know, we need your help. So uh these can be definitely also some of the explanations and some of the explanation can be just you know the the different techniques and different audiences and different formats of polling. I think that one thing is clear though from the results and that is that there is no clear majority to put together a coalition without the support of one or both Arab parties uh come with the time when the president of the state of Israel has to pick a prime minister candidate to attempt to put together a coalition. So let's say the votes are in. They have to be certified by November 4th by next Wednesday. uh we'll see, you know, drips and drops of the actual results from all of the ballot boxes over the next 10 to 12 hours.

11:21 Probably the first clear picture of all the votes, not including those diplomats who voted overseas, members of the army who were in forward operating bases who have not been counting their votes yet, anything which may have came from prisons. And here's a little known fact. If you are in an Israeli prison, you still have the right to vote unlike the United States where you uh in most places lose the right to vote in democratic elections. And we get to November 4th. What happens next? Don't tell me about which party is most likely to be asked to form a coalition, but tell me about the technical process of how this ends up uh in terms of putting together a coalition of swearing in a speaker of the Knesset. What's next?

12:04 Yes. So let's really explain you know in a simple way how the Israeli democracy works. We you know Israel is a parliamentary democracy meaning that the the different parties has have to form a coalition which is a majority in the kesset. Now Israeli kesset Israeli parliament has 120 seats meaning that the minimum majority is 61. Even though you can manage what we call a narrow coalition which well first of all 61 definitely a narrow already but if let's say an Arab party or Arab parties don't support any of the block but at least you know they cannot vote with you but they don't vote against you so you may be less than 60 but still survive but I I don't think that this is possible for long run. So again theoretically a coalition must have 61

13:07 votes minimum. So meaning that now the negotiations start between different parties to form this coalition and always these can be surprises. You know, I just remind you that in for example, in um 2009, Natao invited then leftwing Labor Party head Bayud Barak to sit with him in a coalition and such examples can be brought and and and another example, you know, how in 21 Bennett who was, you know, a part of the right-wing Netanyahu block, you know, jumped to the other side and formed, you know, and added his then in the beginning seven mandates and then became six to the opposition that with his help formed the 61 and for that being you know being the game changer he received the role of the prime minister even

14:10 though being not the biggest party. So uh this negotiations start now the first the major thing is that the parties go to the uh president and they tell him who they recommend that will form this coalition. Now they can recommend even themselves and by the law by the way it can be any member of Knesset not necessarily a head of the party and definitely not ahead of the biggest party and we I brought few examples but we have many examples in the past even from the same elections in 2009 when not the biggest party formed the coalition then it was Netanyahu I just remind you with 27 s seats while TP li with Kadim party had one more 28 but he got majority of the parties recommending him meaning that agree with him to sit with him in a coalition and this process takes 40 days. If within the 40 days the

15:16 coalition was not formed and the member of Knesset that received the and the mandate from the uh president to form a coalition if he failed the president might might is he he h he can h give the authority give the right to form a coalition to another member of then he gets another I think it's two weeks and if that failed So we go to another elections and I want to remind you that Israel has the experience of having four elections in a row because there was no majority and with the numbers that we can see unfortunately this is an option.

15:59 Now, most of these parties, Lieberman, uh, Bennett, to a certain extent, certainly all of the right-wing parties or those identified in the current coalition with Netanyahu have made promises to their voters that they will not enter into a coalition or receive external support for a minority government from any Arab party. In fact, the slogan for the likud was oino philistine, either the right-wing or a state of Palestine. Uh, and we've heard similar statements from Lieberman, no less nuanced. Eisenote, again, a little bit squishy. Uh, Bennett saying he would do what he has to do to remove Netanyahu's prime minister. Are these parties going to go back on their promises to their voters because of the commitments that they made? Or or or do you think rather are they going to go back on their promises to their voters because of the reality of the election results? Or will they keep their promises prior to today's election?

17:02 Well, Greg, you know, let's look at the history and the history shows that everything is possible and that the promises before the elections and the reality, as you pointed very rightly, the reality can force parties to uh you know to uh to change their promises and we saw that many times. We saw that with Bennett. We saw that with uh you know others and uh but you know I want to to to to you know to take you maybe to a higher view and to say that you know I don't think though that there is really difference in policies toward for example you know you mentioned the Palestinian issue I don't think that whoever will be the prime minister and what the coalition whatever coalition will be I don't think that we will see really difference in security and foreign policies and you

18:05 know I just want to remind you that Bennett and Liberman were part for for many years of a very right block definitely in security policies and they will claim and rightly so in many issues that they are more right and Netanyahu in in policies toward the Palestinian authority. And if you really see you see that even in the opposition, majority of the leaders Eisen cut and definitely Benton definitely Lieberman and Laid as well are not so different from Natao and the leadership of the of his block toward the Palestinian issue.

18:49 And here, you know, I want to invite all our viewers to uh to visit our website of the Middle East forum and to read uh the new policy paper that we just issued written by the former security advisor to the prime minister and the head of the national security council, Mayor Ben Shabbat, who talks about it in terms of policies and he says that he definitely doesn't see that any political major player will agree to Palestinian state And I don't think that uh voters even of the Democrats will today after October 7th after October 7th Israeli society has changed. I don't see Israelis today agree to concessions agree to Palestinian state next to here you know next to me next to Jerusalem and and risk a possibility of another attack. So uh I just you know summarize things can definitely change in promises and blocks can be different from what we thought in

19:53 swing promises but I don't see real change in security policy not toward Iran not toward Hisbala and not toward Palestinian definitely not toward Gaza we had a question from one of our viewers Feldman who was asking can you explain on the one hand you're saying Eisen code has 52 kesset seats and the other hand you say his party has about 22. Can you elaborate on these two different numbers? So for what you'll see on your screen in my uh upper uh uh lefthand corner I think or maybe upper right hand corner I'm not sure where the poll is is the blocks that constitute the Israeli elector and their choosing one that led by the Netanyahu government that is Likood Otmayit Shas United Judaism and religious Zionism with Mosha Fagelan. uh at the end of our polling that we put together, which is a poll of polls, they were expected to obtain about 53 seats, uh eight short of that 61 they need to be able to put together

20:55 a government. The opposition block led by Gotti Eisenote, not um in so far as he's been the anointed head of the opposition block, but but just by the virtue of him having the most amount of seats in the polls up until today constitutes his party. Yes, the together party led by Napali Bennett, the Democrats led by Yeru Golan and Israel Betenu led by Avidor Lieberman. In the middle you have the third block that is the joint list of Khadash Talad to uh three Arab parties and a separate Arab party which did not run with the joint list Raham led by Mansour Abbas. So when we say Eisen Coat uh pulled 52 Knesset seats in the channel 12 poll, what we mean is that was his block that was obtaining those numbers uh not his individual party which was at 22. The same thing for Netanyahu came in at 50.

21:51 But again, we will get more results throughout the rest of the uh evening and we will publish the full results tomorrow 9:00 a.m. Eastern Standard Time with the Middle East insider that most of you should be subscribed to and uh we hope to be able to give you more analysis not just on what kind of government is coming down the pike, but what are the policies that these government may be considering. There's several options here, Alex. We have the Trump administration pushing for allegedly pushing for a unity government between Gotti Eisenot and Benjamin Netanyahu which may leave Smoorich and Ben Gavir out of the coalition mathematics. Um and together just with what they have between the 24 and 22 that still is 15 seats shy of being able to put or yeah let's do my math 15 seats shy of putting together a coalition. And would that mean that they would have to accept the Democrats? We're not Tally Bennett bite his tongue and say, you know what, I'll come in and help you or

22:53 will the ultraorththodox go with the guy? There's a lot of different variables at play right now. And we have to be able to understand this is the beginning of the formation of the next government. This is not a endstate period where the party with the most votes is necessarily going to be the party that puts together a coalition. Alex, in fact, if you paid attention to the chairman of the United List, the Arab party with the most votes according to these polls, he said he would recommend the top opposition party to be prime minister. And this is traditionally the Arab parties have not recommended an opposition politician to be prime minister. He said he will support whatever is necessary to get Benjamin Netanyahu out of office. What What does he mean by that? And what could that impact have on President Herzog's decision on who to appoint to try and put together a government and potentially be the next prime minister?

23:51 So first of all, Greg, you you mentioned very correctly everything is possible and in the p we just said that and everything is possible. We saw in the in in the past that you know parties that were taken for granted in one block were excluded and others included and whatever they said before the elections can be very very different after so many many different connections are possible and again as I said before in policies we really don't see change difference between you know definitely not Bennett and Natao right or Liberman Natao on external security issues on on definitely they have personal issues of trust between them and the issue of ultraorththodox but I think that Natao if he's able to form a coalition without the ultraorththodox and to pass the draft law he will be very happy to do that the problem is that he's he he he he trusts the ultraorthodox as better partners for him so it it's it's you know it it's hard to break this

24:56 connection And regarding the Arab part is very interesting things happen and very interesting new tendencies happened to Arab citizens of Israel. First of all, what we saw in the last few years is that more and more Arabs and Arab leaders and first and foremost Mansur Abbas and and and Ram party are integrating into the Israeli politics and are ready to participate and are ready to recommend on prime ministers and are ready to be part of coalitions and we saw that in the government and coalition between 21 and 22 with Napali Bennett and Laid as the prime ministers and Liberman sat with them but that was before October 7th and after October 7th Liberman said that you know no option sitting with the Arabs but now you you you mentioned correctly that even the joint list which is less integrating Arab party is speaking about

26:03 a possibility of recommending on prime minister meaning that they also you know that toward integration to Israeli politics it means that it definitely can happen but again I want you to understand some math even if the one block has let's say 50 and the other has even the same let's say 50 okay let's speak you know just for for for for simplicity of the of the explanation and the Arabs have let's say 20 okay if They are not inside but they don't vote against you. They can help you to survive. So you may have an opposition surviving. It's very hard to maneuver but they might they may survive even less than 60 if Arabs they what we say in Hebrew you know they support from from outside meaning they don't what what you're talking about is say what you're talking about is a minority meaning that you have 50 seats. This is

27:05 what happened with Bennett last time. This is Mansor Boss and the Rahm party who contributed their five or six seats to support uh Bennett until Bennett's party itself broke apart and ended up becoming part of Leikud which was the way that Netanyahu was able to bring down the government. But there's um a few more updates that just came in that I want to share with our audience and I'm going to uh share the screen here with the uh the results. I'm hopefully everybody can see this. I know it's it's a screenshot, but this is what we were able to jury rigged within uh a few minutes. Some points from the uh different polls. Uh no poll gives either block 61 seats required to form a government. Luda's first in all five from 24 seats to 30 seats. Every final pre-election poll from Khan, that's channel 11, the state broadcaster, 12 and 13 had Eisenote first. So even with those news stations that don't support the prime minister, their polls show he

28:08 came in first place as it related to the results. Arab parties are at 1618, a record. Arab sector turnout was 64.3% in the late afternoon versus 39% at the same point last year that last time. That's a 25% increase in Arab sector participation in this election. Ala Israel and the reservist were below the threshold on all five. Uh channel 12 uh excuse me channel 11 con had them at 2.7% and 2.2%. Alex, we're going to get back to you really quickly after the the last point here on what the significance of 2.7 and 2.2% is versus the electoral threshold of 3 and a/4 points. And the channels and this is an important point to make here. All of the Israeli channels reporting on the election results will revise their exit polls later in the night as more samples come in. Channel 12's pollster said today to expect changes. Official results come on November 4th. Alex, how many votes does

29:11 it take for a party to be able to be uh uh passing the electoral threshold to get into the Knesset? And more importantly, if you have 2.7 for the uh reser and 2.4 four for over for winner. That's about five 5.1 uh points that some people say were sort of thrown to the trash bin. 5% of the electorate not having their decision were the people that they voted for getting into the Knesset. How does that work in terms of redistribution? That's kind of complicated coalition math right there or electoral math right there.

29:46 Right. So, let's answer to your first question. how many votes a party needs to get to the Knesset to pass the sharehold. So because of the very high you understand right because you know more people vote and the number of seats stay so the number of voters for one mandate is going up. So at the moment from what I see wait can you clarify what you mean by one mandate you mean by one seat right one yeah one seat exactly so at the moment it is 50 and something thousand for one seat which is about 20% higher than what was in 22 meaning that in order to pass the threshold of 325% right three and a quarter you need about 165,000 voters to uh to bring the party to to pass and to get into the Knesset which

30:51 gives them four seats right because three and and a quarter out of 100 means four seats out of 120 and I want to tell you that you know 2.7 and 2.4 4 you know it sounds very far but on the other hand we see some parties vary so significantly in different polls like again let's take a victor deliberum which in one poll is nine and in other poll is five so you know it's difference of four so I would not run and conclude that these who have 2.7 are definitely not passing I think we must wait and by the way the last votes of the soldiers can definitely bring a change because these are young people and we know that young people vote more to the right and by the way in these elections more than half a million of Israelis were added to those who had the right to vote. This is a huge number

31:55 out of you know 10 million of people. So I think that we might still see surprises but I think the major you know tendencies that we uh that we named we definitely can conclude that they that they are clear. So what we're basically seeing here is two 300,000 people that voted for those two parties 5% of the electorate they're not going to be able to have their decision uh reached here. maybe 250,000 depending on how we do the math and what the final turnout is. But more importantly, um there was discussions prior to the election that Overwinter, his party, which got 2.4% should drop out because he had said he may endorse Netanyahu to be prime minister. And my guess is or or or my educated guess is is that his voters would have maybe gone for Likood, would have maybe gone for religious Zionism, perhaps even Ben or Lieberman depending on uh how you look

32:59 at him and his and his base. And then Yas Hendel and his group may have gone for Bennett, may have gone for Eisenote perhaps, maybe even gone for Leikud. So their participation could have actually led us now to have a not a lame duck Knesset, but a Knesset that may not be able to put a government together. So if there is another election, you may be seeing a different version of this electoral math. And that's what happened in those four elections between 2019 and 2021. uh David Weiss, one of And by the way, if anyone has a question for us for either me or Alex or any MEF staff or fellow that if we can't answer it now, we can answer it later on, you can uh type it in the Q&A box that's at the bottom of your Zoom screen. Uh [snorts] David Weiss asks us there, is there any reasonably possible coalition of the right without Smitty and Bengavir? I'm going to just answer that and say um probably not unless Eisenote comes in and they rely on ultraorththodox party

34:03 support or for some reason if you get a national unity government a center uh center right government or center right government where somehow uh Bennett and uh Lieberman agreed to join that coalition. Um Alex, any further thoughts on that? Yeah. So, first of all, I I just I didn't answer it, but but but you did about the voices that you know that actually gone. They actually, you know, how we say in Hebrew burned, right? those who voted for and for winter because definitely they they will not be given to any other party and that exactly was the reason why Netanyahu was pressing them so much to quit because even you know 2.7 it's a lot think of it it's it's it's three seats that that that definitely may you know solve the whole the whole dilemma. So this this you know almost five or maybe above if you take also

35:08 multi lighter maybe even six seats that were just you know burned this is one and and next time it definitely can be different and and the other thing about if a rightwing coalition can be formed again the question is what you call right if the if the criteria for right is those who can sit under Netanyahu so far if you believe to the prom promises of the opposition parties, you don't see a majority with Smrich in Benver and without Smrich in Benver. But if you measure the criteria of policies of right-wing, meaning the policies close to Netanyahu toward Lebanon and Iran and Palestinian issue. So you can count in almost everybody in the opposition, definitely Bennett and definitely Eisen and definitely Liberman. Will they sit with Natao? Let's see.

36:02 So, Alex, there's a uh unique feature of Israeli parliamentary elections, Knesset elections in Israeli democracy of something called surplus voter arrangements. This means that if there's a million people who vote and you have uh three parties running, one party gets 500,000, another party gets 450,000, the party with 50,000 that doesn't cross that threshold can assign their votes to another party. So Dan Angel asks, "Will voter sharing agreements be a factor in this election?" Apparently not. And I'll explain you why. Because usually the parties that sign these agreements are close So you will not find uh these agreements giving votes from one block to another.

36:55 So I don't see from those agreements that I saw and from the experience of these agreements I don't think that you know it might be redistributed within the block but not redistributed between the blocks and even by the way between the blocks you don't see the number. It's not that you have, you know, 60. By the way, channel 14 gave 60 to the coalition, but again, this is channel 14 who is the most supportive to the coalition. So, let's see, you know, in in a couple of weeks if they were serious or they were doing, you know, just propaganda. We'll know that soon.

37:34 But but but let's for a moment assume that they were right. If so and by these agreements you may have even one seat over going from one block to another from opposition to coalition. So they definitely can have the the majority and again as we explained before minority government is possible. It's just very hard to survive for the long run. But if you're very organized and if you know that you have only 60, but your opposition has 50 and the and the gap are Arabs who don't vote.

38:15 Okay. Don't vote for the opposition, you can survive longer. Yeah, Alex. Um, Barbie Ramboz asks, "Why was Mansurbas allowed to run as the head of Raham when he is under investigation for funding Hamas?" I haven't heard about that investigation, but um, happy to to hear more about that. What was the rationale given by the Supreme Court to rule in Abbas's favor when Netanyahu filed a petition to have Rah banned from the elections? Okay, let's let's just explain the the the mechanism of ruling out parties.

38:52 There is a committee and the committee is political combined by the representatives of the parties that run to the Knesset. They every elections they decide to rule out parties in the you know far right and far left and almost always or always you have the Arab parties part of them or all of them excluded and and and the far right excluded and then it goes to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court is very not in favor of excluding parties. Even though this time I want to remind you a a far left or I would even maybe say a far anti-Zionist Arab party ballad was was excluded by the committee and by the Supreme Court because their because their leader you know not only you know didn't speak against he actually spoke in favor of

39:56 the kamas attack of October. 7th and even the Supreme Court who who usually is much more liberal than this political committee said that you know it's impossible to see such a such a person such a politician in digness. So this is the mechanism. Now so what what happened though that chairman of their party actually stepped down and resigned. So that was sort of a preemptive move by the party to stay on the list. They got rid of one of their Yeah. because the because the Supreme Court they told him listen if you don't want us to to to write the decision which will be very bad for you you can resign and then preemptively you will just you know save your face for okay and he did it okay and I think rightly so because it was very very clear that they will run him out so let's uh let's let's let's move on to just a follow-up question on Abas months ago he said in the press that he would be the kingmaker regarding the Do you believe that Mansur Abbas is

40:59 going to decide who the next prime minister of Israel is? Well, we just see the numbers at the moment. Mansurabaz gets by different polls between six and eight. So, as we speak, let's even take the joint list out. Okay? Take only Mansurabas. Let's say you have even not 55 in order to let him give you majority. Let's say that you have 52 and 53, okay? And he's seven, okay? And he doesn't give majority to anyone. As I explained before, he can provide a possibility for minority government to both of the blocks. So, he's definitely kingmaker. Now if the right wing head by Nata will do what they promised not to use him. Let's see if the opposition let's sorry if the mo majority of the opposition leaders will keep their promise not to use him. Let's see. But I just want to remind that Ger Golan spoke

42:02 explicitly that he think they have to use him and have to get his support because otherwise they will not have a a coalition and all the others and primarily Liberman said that you know it's unacceptable. Again, let's see. We know too many examples from the past when those, you know, things politicians said before the elections and things they did after were at minimum So, Samir, a good friend of MEF, asks, "It seems that none of the two blocks will reach the 61 seats, and both of them mentioned that they won't join Arabs, although they achieved a bigger number. Will we see both blocks contact parties in the other block to join them which might take weeks or will we see another election soon? And I I think a lot of the analysis that we gave this evening answers that question. But there there's another interesting factoid about the Ram party that uh many people on this call may or may not know. Uh

43:06 there is a Jew who is a Jewish Israeli former police uh deputy commissioner and member of Knesset who's sitting at number two on the ROM list even though it's an Islamist party. What is an Israeli Jew doing in an Islamist political party? Well, that's a very good question. So some say that this is an ideological move of Yav Sealovich you know to join the Ram party who is uh you know as I said tell us about Yav Sealovich a little bit who is he what's his background and why did he decide to do this right yavalovich was a a member of Nesset in laid yes there is a future party but he's a a former high senior officer from police.

43:54 He was head of the the the investigation unit that was, by the way, investigating even politicians. Okay. So, he's he's he's very serious. You're referring to Laav 443, the uh the the the equivalent of the Israeli FBI. This is the unit that he was in charge of. Correct. Right. Right. And now he joins Ram. So again uh the people in the opposition say primarily this is you know independent ideological move uh to you know join a party that is you know moving toward integration and this symbolizes the the cooperation between Jews and Arabs. And more cynical analysts primarily from the coalition say listen this is a technical maneuver to make Ram being cauter right to enter into the coalition or at least to

44:57 support from outside and if there is a need to provide a representative they may send Yavalovich and then you know a Jew sits in the coalition and even maybe in the government and not the Arabs And and some say also that you know he didn't you know he didn't have an opportunity to send the Knesset so he did this maneuver to stay at least this is an opportunist move to go to the Arabs everything is possible we'll see who was right in few weeks I'm going to I'm going to pose a question to you that may be a little bit controversial coming from me but I want to take a platform issue that Bennett uh Leed Lieberman Um to a certain extent there was also some talk about this from uh Smitrich and from Eisenote not Eisenote himself but some members of his list. They aim to have equality and what they call shivon bonetto or equality of the burden [clears throat] uh behind all Israeli

45:59 citizens. And there was this line from Lieberman's campaign a few years ago which was um meaning if if you don't serve you don't get the same rights that others get. uh meaning that if uh the ultraorththodox uh Arabs uh other individuals who might be so-called conscientious objectors don't do the army don't do a form of national service they should not be entitled to the same benefits that those who do do the army get so if you take that idea that there should be uh in the next coalition if the opposition is somehow able to put together a government, equality of the burden, equality of expectations for 18 and 19year-old Israelis, whether they're studying in a yeshiva or they're living in an Arab village, to do the army, to do the police, maybe to volunteer in a kindergarten or to pick up trash in public parks, whatever it ends up being.

47:02 Is there not an expectation that if they serve equally then there should be the same kind of expectation for members of the coalition to treat their representatives of who they vote for in minority parties to also have a certain amount of equality and political process. Does the expectation at the bottom sort of work its way to expectation at the top? Well, definitely and I'll tell you more. I think that all the players in the coalition if they can um pass the draft law and to uh force okay even force the ultraorththodox um population to go to the army I think they all the players in the coalition name Lud Bang and and Smriidge if they and they will support it.

47:59 I think that even possible that the may reach out to Smriidge and invite him to sit with them and abandon Bangir and Likood and the ultra orthodox parties and by some of the polls they may even reach majority you know to pass the 61 and invite him to sit with them and erh and uh pass the draft law and I think this is possible and more than that I just want to remind you that yesterday uh number two in Smrich's list the head of Zut identity party Mosha Fagen said that we might to the president on Eisenot to be the prime minister. Now ideologically I even think that Benvir can reach can be part of such a coalition together with the opposition and Smrich I didn't don't I just don't think that

49:02 Yer Golan will sit with him and Eisenkot will want to sit with him but I think that it logically in terms of their approach to the draft law that you just elaborated on I think they definitely can sit together. So if many possibilities are there on the table uh if only people you know just leave the by coating one of of of the other. Uh so and again I'm claiming and and you know I'm not the first and not the last to claim that that you know 80% of the Israelis agree on 80% of the issues. So there are no really really big differences. So if you take the ultra orthodox parties out, all the others leave Arabs out. Okay, all the Zionist parties will definitely go on draft law.

49:57 So a coalition without ultra orthodox parties based on security, common security policies and draft law is possible. Let's see that they can talk together and sit together. So we have uh some comments now from the uh parties based on the preliminary results that came in this evening. First GI Eisenote he says if these are the results it is a total vote of no confidence in the government and a victory for the statist Zionist majority. He says he will form a Zionist conscription government as soon as possible. Golan of the Democrats, a historic opportunity. Now it's our turn.

50:44 Gonar of the Likud, the celebrations on the left are premature. And Netanyahu, uh, making a statement prior to the closing of the polls, he says, um, I'm warning you of a Mansor bus government. Uh, four years of consistently broken promises. It was the response from the person he was speaking to. So, uh, we now also have some of the official counts coming in at the, uh, Israel votes 26, which I will, uh, share with everyone in the chat. If you guys want to maybe turn on your Google Translate and get the, uh, the live results that are coming in, you can see that at votes26.com.

51:31 And uh based off of these results, um there really is just a a smidgen of results that have come in. So it's not really even worth mentioning in terms of of the numbers cuz it's going to change every minute from now until tomorrow morning, even through November 3rd, uh when some of the the votes may be challenged. But um Alex, it seems like the opposition sees this as a historic win for them. And I think just looking at that statement from Golan and from Eisenote, uh, they think that they have the opportunity here to replace Benjamin Netanyahu. Your, uh, closing thoughts before we end this broadcast.

52:09 I just want to repeat I whatever I just said, everything is possible. Great. Because if you listen to the words carefully, I think says Zionist Zionist coalition, right? Or Zionist minority. And again, if they take the opposition Zionist party and invite the non ultra orthodox parties from the without liken will they be able to swallow the the the you know the the the bad blood between them let's see things happened in the past and again I claim that The really differences, ideological differences are much much smaller. So everything is possible and can be a prime minister if Ben and Smidge or maybe only Smothidge join him. If that can happen, we must Thank you, Alex Selki, director of

53:13 Israel and Eastern Mediterranean Affairs for the Middle East Forum for joining us this evening, this afternoon, this day for our special Israel votes election results webinar. Uh, a few closing thoughts for myself as executive director of MEF. Number one, one thing is certain this evening. Benjamin Netanyahu has lost the ability to form a coalition with himself as prime minister for uh the foreseeable future. Unless a major earthquake or split in the opposition parties takes place, this may be the end of BB Netanyahu as prime minister of Israel if we are to believe the results of the polls that have come in. The second we've already seen the malleability and the going back on the statements made by political parties Eisenote Bennett um even Golan to a certain extent in terms of their willingness to do something to put together a uh temporary coalition to see

54:17 Netanyahu remove this prime minister. And the third thing is is is that this is only the end of the beginning. There will be a major process in coalition negotiations in forming a coalition and putting together a government. There will be a new Knesset speaker who will be sworn in even prior to there being a new government being put together. The Knesset Israel's legislature can start their job even without there being a government being there in place. They'll still have the caretaker government of Benjamin Netanyahu until they're able to select a new prime minister. And we will have much more news, analysis, and all of the developments as it relates to Israel's elections in the weeks, days, weeks, and and months ahead. We also are pivoting to another election that we are covering, which is the midterm elections for the US House of Representatives, for the Senate, and for gubernatorial races taking across the United States. Uh we will have another written analysis of

55:19 that come next Tuesday after midterm day depending on the results of what happens. You may get a notice for us for another broadcast like this. But we are preparing as MEF our policy agenda for the 120th Congress coming up between 2027 and 2028. So we're not just covering Israel, we're covering the US. We're covering every Western liberal democracy where Middle East policy matters. and I invite you to tune into that. Beyond that, I encourage all of you to support the Middle East forum at meforum.org as we get ready for our endofear campaign. You'll be receiving letters from us with our work for the past year and what we plan for 2027.

55:57 Thank you, Alex. Thanks to all of our viewers for joining us this evening. Have a great rest of your day. [music]