Webinar or Talk
When the Middle East Studies Association Votes BDS... with William Jacobson
Watch on YouTube
Description
Members of the Middle East Studies Association will soon have an opportunity to vote whether to make boycott, divestment, and sanction (BDS) of Israel MESA’s official policy. If MESA or its institutional and individual members carry out the boycott on campuses, they may run afoul of anti-discrimination and academic freedom protections. What are the implications of this step? How can students and faculty be protected from it?
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 5, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:00 good afternoon and welcome to the middle east forum's webinar series my name is winfield myers i'm the director of campus watch and i'll be our host today our guest today is william jacobson professor jacobson is clinical professor of law at cornell law school the founder of the legal insurrection website and president of the legal insurrection foundation he earned his ba from hamilton college and a jd from harvard law school professor jacobson welcome welcome to middle east forum's webinar we're very happy to have you today thank you for having me our topic today as most of you know is the middle east studies association's impending vote by its full membership on whether or not to make the boycott divestment and sanction or bds of israel its official policy uh its uh members attending its annual conference back last month voted 93 of the 444 who were there to pass this along to the full membership to be voted on
1:01 and professor jacobson is going to discuss today among other things the possible ramifications of this passage if it does pass the vote uh seems to be scheduled for sometime this month so we could only be a week or two away from this vote and when it occurs uh certainly the middle east forum and i'm sure legal insurrection will uh will broadcast it and uh and comment on it however it goes professor jacobson you had noted uh earlier in some of your writings that um if this passes from the full membership that uh to carry out a boycott against israeli academics they may run afoul in your words of anti-discrimination and academic freedom protections what are the implications of this how do you see this falling out should they vote yes which would not surprise many people i don't believe well i'm not going to go into too much background because i know our time is limited but the middle east studies association has passed a resolution and as is often the
2:04 case they got their people out to the business meeting so that is not necessarily a representative sample of the entire membership so there were 400 some odd people at the business meeting there were 2700 voting members and there have been instances in the past where a resolution makes its way out of the business meeting at a faculty or an association and does not pass the membership so it's not a given that it will pass but it probably will because unlike a lot of the other organizations like american historical modern language association there does not seem to be an internal opposition at mesa because everybody who would be has long left the organization because it's so skewed into israel so this is going to come up for a vote and i think mesa is very much aware that it could run into problems because they have worded the resolution very curiously okay the way they've worded it is that
3:08 be it resolved and i'm doing this from memory but i think accurately that the majority of the membership of mesa endorses the uh boycott call and the second operative is that the directors of mesa are directed to implement it consistent with local and federal and state laws and academic freedom so they know there's going to be a storm coming uh if this passes just like there was a storm several years ago it was december 2013 the american studies association passed the boycott resolution and that was a little stronger language than mesa used and there was a firestorm of controversy and there has not been a major academic group since december of 2013 that has passed it there have been some smaller ones but none of the major ones so this would be i consider a major one and 250 university presidents signed statements
4:11 opposing the asa boycott and it really they faced lawsuits and a lot of backlit flash how might it play out here well the first thing is that most university campuses i'll dare say every single one has anti-discrimination policies which are sometimes much broader than federal and state law they are expansively broad and i think you can make a very good argument that if the boycott is carried out on campus and i emphasize that is carried out i don't mean somebody having an opinion on it i don't mean somebody saying i support it but if it's actually implemented by mesa through its members on a campus it arguably is discrimination on the basis of national origin and it arguably is discrimination on the basis of religion because uh let's face it this is the one majority jewish state in the world okay um and and so those uh campus provisions could come into play i think they would come into play whether you know federal and
5:13 state protections come into play it would have to be very fact specific um if you were able to prove that you know an israeli was singled out for being an israeli or if you were able to prove that a jewish student who wanted to study in israel was singled out because of that and i think there have been instances and the sort of things where that come up is for example a professor is willing to write a recommendation for a student to attend the university of amman but not the university of tel aviv and that would be implementing a book that would be not only potentially violating the schools to anti-discrimination laws but academic freedom protections that apply to students and faculty so faculty where sometimes the line becomes blurry but the distinction i always draw is you're entitled to believe whatever you want to believe and frankly you're entitled to say just about anything you want to say but when you are on a campus you have to abide by the campuses rules and
6:16 regulations and that's particularly important if you have an administrative role and if the school has a policy against the boycott of israel you have to abide by that either that or get another job okay you have to abide by your employer's and and so that i think is really important to keep in mind it's the implementation of it that becomes important and we do know that that these things are actually implemented and so the distinction between speech and conduct becomes extremely extremely important the other thing i would say is as probably most people on this call you always hear bds say bds is supporters at least the ones who were on it say this is just a tactic bds is a tactic uh and they're right it is a ta and it took me a while to understand this they don't actually care if you study at tel aviv university they don't actually care if the dining hall
7:18 serves sauber hummus some of their useful fools who support them may care but the people behind it actually don't they use this as an opportunity to propagandize the campus against israel and if they can get a campus to spend two months or three months in a student council debating how bad israel is is it just bad or is it bad enough to boycott and they lose the vote they actually don't care for them it is a generational project it is not a project to pass a resolution a meaningless resolution of the student government um it is a generational project and i think the people opposing this and opportunities like mesa provide an opportunity to get campuses to affirm their support for academic involvement with israel we've already obtained we haven't gone public with it yet we will uh several statements from university presidents rejecting the boycott not promising to do anything about it but rejecting the boycott and
8:21 affirming their intention to interact with israel so i think use the op they use this as a tactic you can also regardless of whether it violates a particular rule um use this as a chance to educate people because again people on this call understand this is just a new variation on the anti-jewish boycott that started in the british mandate for palestine in the 1920s some people would say even earlier but you can see a clear continuation that this is just the repackaged anti-jewish boycott to speak to a social justice younger sort of western audience and and so i don't know that the answer to this ultimately is the law or anything like that but there are legal protections that people are entitled to enforce and i think mesa 100 reading their resolution they see this coming and they're going to say oh this is just a resolution expressing an promising to do anything
9:24 there i would note that there um this kind of activism and anti-israel activism on the part of me flows directly from the scholarship of its over many many decades now and one of the core elements of that scholarship regarding israel is the delegitimization of israel as a jewish so this is just you know politics by more political means if you will not not the scholar but it flows directly from what they have been uh teaching and writing for uh 30 years now and more it's so it's not a surprise to those of us who follow this organization a few years ago when it was brought up this kind of there was a there was actually a you know a debate and i think in 2014 at their annual meeting and um a few people got up and spoke against this kind of surprising who it was juan cole of university of michigan nathan brown of george washington a few you wouldn't necessarily expect this from because they're such bureau critics of israel but they spoke up against that at that point if they have spoken up
10:26 against it now i i haven't heard anything about i don't know whether they just have changed their minds or whether they're just so outgunned at this point they figure it's not worth the fight yeah i don't know you know i i'm not a mesa member i wasn't in at the business meeting i've only heard reports of it and apparently it was an extremely one-sided presentation there were no real opposition voices so and and that's the where the organization has gone yeah no it is it isn't well you mentioned um in some of your writing possible violation of title vi of the civil rights act of 1964 violating the civil rights of students of professors one of the consequences of that i know can be a threat to curtail federal funds to institutions that violate it um that's a draconian move it's hard to get anybody to do that in washington for for obvious political but is that a possible reaction to this let's say israeli scholars be banned not banned in
11:29 a physical sense perhaps but not recognized by or not invited to a particular campus or um should as you said students be denied the opportunity to study abroad in i know at the university of michigan there was a lecture a few years ago who infamously refused to write a letter of uh for a student wanting to study in israel and of course it exploded in his face as it should have um do you see that as a possible consequence it's unlikely to happen as you indicated but and it's particularly unlikely to happen with the current administration but maybe if there's another administration in the future i think the you know civil rights division of the department of education uh maybe even the justice department i don't know who has jurisdiction over something like that could certainly open an investigation and i think that that sort of systemic discrimination should at least be looked into and if nothing else that may elicit a
12:33 more positive response in addressing it from the administrations because i mean that is the nuclear bomb for modern university systems because there probably isn't a one i mean there might be one hillsdale college but there aren't many that don't receive federal money that's right that's right and you've noted too um the institutional memberships of mesa that include i'm just looking at a list of columbia cornell your own university dartmouth duke unc florida state george washington harvard on and on indiana u uh big schools nyu all up and down the list are institutional members of misa and of course many other professors are institutional members you had noted that one consequence could be and maybe this would be easier to pull off i don't know uh the refusal or the denial of the payment of uh fees or funds to join it either institutionally or individually should this pass yeah i mean it's hard to understand how a university which is a policy of interaction with israel and policy of
13:37 protecting academic freedom not just of israelis remember this has to be framed the way it needs to be framed this is academic freedom for americans not just israelis okay if a student is deprived if researchers are deprived um this is actually a threat also to our health i mean think of how many medical innovations have come out of israeli institutes um and that cooperation so i i think that you know that has to be something that's taken into account that this is they need to the academic freedom of americans on their campus not just of israelis sure of course yeah they're they're um in the name of academic freedom uh in their words uh denying academic freedom they're saying that they're doing it for the academic freedom of uh palestinian scholars palestinian uh at various universities in the west bank and elsewhere and um and for i believe the language includes and for their israeli counterparts who are persecuted by the israeli government so for your own good we're going to prevent
14:40 you from um having academic freedom that you had i mean that is the unique feature of academic bds it may be the only which claims the academic freedom to deprive others of academic freedom i mean that is the whole point depriving others of academic freedom is the entire point of academic bds i mean there's a bigger point of delegitimizing israel but that is their methodology and so it's a very curious thing because the first thing they scream if anything is done to protect americans academic freedom or israelis is they you know well you're infringing our academic freedom and of course you'll get faculty members around the country to form groups and sign petitions and how bad this is they want the academic freedom to deprive others of academic freedom and i don't know of any other instance where that's the case and done unironically i would know um we've noted that governor de santos down
15:44 in florida has because florida state university is one of the institutional members has spoken out against this you you mentioned university presidents um do you see the possibility of um voters citizens of other states particularly for state public universities that are institutional members of misa to speak up against this to petition uh legislative uh the legislature the governors and others to um speak out and maybe take action against this uh should their institutional public universities in their states adopt this well you know i think that people tend to forget that the only voice that voices on campus include alumni parents and the general community they have a legitimate say and for the american studies association boycott people started reaching out to university presidents so i actually did it through my website and maybe we'll post that information again because we've emailed for comment so we can report on it every university
16:47 president who has an institutional membership and we've only heard back from a handful of them some are no comment and others are we stand by the prior statement we oppose the boycott of israel we have not heard back from florida state university surprisingly uh we have not heard back from the florida board of governors which governs their universities but these are all things people are entitled to get their voices heard you know there are petitions practically every week against israel circulated uh i don't know that we need a petition here but i think at some point you know we may publish the contact the public contact information for university officials particularly those who refuse to respond to us because i think the community is entitled to know any prospective student is entitled to know whether that student's going to be deprived of academic opportunities because mesa is operating on the campus that's right that's right and um i would suggest maybe a lot of
17:50 organizations to do that particularly at the state level donors uh donors i thought for many for decades and decades we all are alumni someplace and um you get these um multi-million dollar pr campaigns aimed at us every year telling us how wonderful things are on campus how nostalgic we were made to feel especially older we get and um so think back to your 20s when you were young and this is exactly the way things are and so give us ten thousand dollars and and things will be so that's a i've always thought that's a weak link to universities that's rarely exploited particularly public universities less so schools with multi-billion dollar endowments but your average public school simply doesn't have that kind of money at hand they can be squeezed through grassroots pressure through um organized resistance if you will to this kind of manipulation of as you say students and their own professors not just israelis
18:53 yeah and i think it's always very important to make distinctions between um the speech of people and uh the academic freedom so as long if i'm against you know trying to purge professors i mean god knows i've been trying to be purged many times i'm against that but that doesn't mean that a professor can actively discriminate in the conduct of running a course you know they can go off to a mesa meeting and say whatever they want to say but once they're conducting a course and once they're conducting school business with school funds they have to abide by school sure sure let me invite our audience to submit questions if you would like we haven't gotten any yet but one is from jay lewis uh he says are there competing academic organizations to misa and are they getting any traction uh there is one competing organization forgive me for not remember i i can tell you an association for the study of the middle east and africa i remember the
19:58 good for yes as mia don't ask me to repeat what it stands for as mia i think is an alternative it is more people will go there but there is a you know once you've accumulated an institutional presence it's hard for an upstart now they're not exactly an upstart but it's hard for a new organization to establish itself and but that would be good there was an attempt to create an alternative organization to the american studies association but it's a lot of work you need donors you need a staff you need a presence and you need somebody who's committed to it for four to six years maybe more you know to get it launched and so it's a it's a big undertaking and misa has a you know has been there for a while i forget when it was founded but it's been decades and you know it's going to be hard to displace them that's just the reality you can marginalize them okay there's no reason why an organization which endorses the boycott and has its directors have been instructed to
21:03 carry it out um should be able to use university funds for example or university sure sure again i'll repeat the name it's the association for the study of the middle east and africa um and i think it's doing quite well but as you say misa builds itself as the umbrella organization for the field it's been around since 1966 i believe it's it's difficult to replace a large uh once venerable scholarly organization no matter how how far they have fallen same is true for other scholarly organizations american historical association american political science association and so on um starting these is an arduous task if there are any donors who want to do that this is a worthy challenge i would suggest um jerry dences says is bds not blatantly anti-scholarly should this disqualify faculty as not scholarly uh well i think again bds is a very strange thing
22:06 because it's the academic study of depriving others of academic freedom so i i don't know i don't think you can with the broad brush say it's not scholarly i don't know what the repercussions of that would be but it is a political movement i mean that's what it is it's not a scholarly endeavor it's a political movement arguably a continuation of the anti-jewish boycotts but was birthed at and there's a lot of misinformation out but it was actually birthed at the 2001 durbin conference uh and then they created this superficial window dressing that it was actually a 2005 call from palestinian civil society but that's actually not true the entire formulation of the boycott was a durbin formulation in the declaration of the ngo forum at durban and it began to be carried out before 2005 so they were already boycotting israel under a bds style formula before the so-called uh palestinian call from civil society and
23:10 nobody ever seems to indicate who was that civil society well it was all the same groups that supported the boycott to begin with so uh yeah it's it's not a scholarly endeavor but i'm not sure you can declare the entire field as not worthy of being taught or spoken about on campus because of that it's a political movement sure sure julia lutch writes why does it seem so easy for groups hostile to to israel to get the funding and long-term backing they need yeah i mean you know follow the money follow the money you know there there seems they never seem to be at a loss for funds now a lot of these academic organizations don't necessarily get outside infusions of cash they get membership dues and those membership dues are almost always paid by universities most faculty i can't say all have certain expenses they are legitimately able to put through on the university or they might have a
24:15 budget for that you know i know we do at cornell we've got a certain research fund and as long as it's an appropriate thing you can use it for those purposes so the university ends up paying it so basically universities and not just the member universities but universities are funding these groups at least indirectly they also have sponsors they have publishing deals you can go to the museo website and look at who all their sponsors are and who they have agreements with so they don't necessarily receive a big check from a donor they don't need to they are pretty much self-funding sure sure um and stuart broad notes and i meant to mention this moment ago he's exactly right there's another fine organization uh scholars for peace in the middle east uh in addition to the association for the study of the middle east of africa um both somewhat alternatives again to founded as alternatives to meet forgiveness long uh politicization uh eric asks do you think care or other palestinian or
25:18 muslim organizations are behind this and how can we fight this well behind it i'm not sure if that's the right term but there definitely is a lot of crossover so we've written a lot about um connector groups so american muslims for palestine is one of these connector groups that connects various anti-israel groups where everybody gets their funding i don't know but you cannot view the bds groups in isolation they're not in isolation they're part of a greater ecosystem that seems to have a lot of money um and one of their targets is and this is just the way they do it sure sure i can tell you a lot of professors who are members and even past presidents of misa like john esposito for example at georgetown has have spoken they care banquets um more than once the the connection uh may or may not be formal i don't know about that it probably is in time so yes there are some and i could name some
26:21 names on that too you have formal connections funding is a different question as you say that's not exactly the same thing as being associated with care in some ways but the associations and the friendliness is certainly there a few years ago misa also had a table at their annual conference from the international institute of islamic thought which undoubtedly has islamist and funding and so thereby legitimizing trying to legitimize them failing ultimately of course to do that too stephen orlow says how does one organize a campaign against me so revisiting something we discussed earlier misa anti-be and anti-bds efforts is there access to their membership list the last with the final question i can say no i don't think there's access to the membership list that i know of um but their institutional members are right listed right online website and you certainly could reach out and i always say people please be polite okay but you can reach out expressing concern um that whether university funds are
27:23 going to be used to support this boycott effort i mean i think that's appropriate and uh those universities are listed there they are directly paying dues to misa and they are probably in a perhaps a less direct way supporting it and i think if that's what they want to do they should announce it okay they should take a position on it and if their position is they support the boycott of israel we'll deal with that and they'll deal with that but if their position is against it then they've got to address why they're a member of an organization which has endorsed it and it's not just endorsed it but vowed dire instructed their board of directors to carry it out sure sure uh robert larrick asks how do these academics feel about the hezbollah rejectionist terrorists take over and so uh and uh the destruction of lebanon the old paris of the middle east now in ruins let me just know quickly i would say a lot of the professors that we follow uh daily
28:25 um one of one of the hallmarks of their scholarship such as it is and they're teaching is that many of them ignore the systemic problems in the middle east uh whether it's terrorism or the mistreatment of women or the uh iranian hegemony throughout the region through hezbollah and other organizations um not a lot of attention paid to that but uh do you have a comment on that also yeah i mean i think this is something that i encounter often that people can't understand why they these people are the way they are okay and well don't they want to be balanced don't they want to be you know take oil and the answer is no they don't want to be balanced that's not what this is about this is not a scholarly endeavor this is not a seeking of the truth i mean this is just war against israel by another means and the there are honest ones who will admit that but most of the people who participate in the us and western europe are really you know i think the term the soviets used to use as useful idiots i
29:27 mean they they believe the propaganda angle they believe they're doing something for social justice they don't really care what hezbollah is doing in lebanon they just want to rid the world of the zionist entity that's right that's right you know we've talked a little about the islamist connections let me tell you something you go to any university who's going to be front and center it's far left wing juice anti-zionist jews okay they are the the driving force behind this in you know the university setting and the second an issue is raised that this is discriminatory against israelis or against you know jews who's gonna if you follow as we've done for many years the campus boycotts at student councils who is always the first speaker in front in favor of the resolution someone from the local chapter of jewish voice for okay they do that deliberately they use those people as a shield against correct accusations of
30:30 anti-semitism so you know i don't we don't focus really i mean i think the ties to islamist organizations that's all interesting but on practical terms in the united states the driving force are anti-zionist left-wing jews we're coming to the end of the of the if people want to learn more about you and about your organization tell us where they can find you sure um well the main website is legal insurrection dot com legal insurrection foundation which is a 501c3 is our operating entity and it has its own website and we have recently launched recently as in early last year a secondary website called criticalrace.org where we track all that's going on on the campuses about critical race theory and its offshoots or you can google me and you'll find some very interesting indeed and a lot of your writing your prolific writer well thank you very much
31:32 we really appreciate this it's been most informative um i think our audience has benefited from it i hope so and um i would ask the audience to please be on the lookout for future emails including one this weekend announcing our future webinars uh so again we've been with the professor william jacobson of cornell and uh legal interaction we again thank you so much this is this has been an excellent session we appreciate it very our audience thank you very much and um have a wonderful weekend