Israel Insider
Israel Insider with Ashley Perry
Watch on YouTube
Description
How far will parties carry out the Trump-enforced Hamas-Israel ceasefire? What are the larger implications of this deal for Netanyahu’s government, for Hamas, and for Israel?
Ashley Perry is an advisor to the Middle East Forum’s Israel office. He served as adviser to Israel's minister of foreign affairs and deputy prime minister in 2009-15, and has also worked with Israel's Ministers of Intelligence, Agriculture and Rural Development, Energy, Water and Infrastructure, Defense, Tourism, Internal Security, and Immigrant Absorption and as an advisor to The Negev Forum. Originally from the U.K., he moved to Israel in 2001. He holds a B.A. from University College London and an M.A. from Reichman University (IDC Herzliya).
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 20, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:08 all right hello good afternoon and welcome to the Middle East forum's weekly podcast series Israel Insider my name is anaf Kalam and I will be moderating today's discussion we're pleased to be joined today by Ashley Perry adviser to the Middle East forum's Israel office who joins us each week to give us a brief overview of the top events currently going on in Israel Mr Perry will speak for 15 minutes followed by 15 minutes of Q&A from the audience and if you'd like to ask a question you can do so by using the Q&A box located at the bottom of your screen to type your question and with that I will turn the discussion over to Mr Perry thank you very much enough and good evening from Israel well it's been a week of very strong emotions contrasting emotions complexity relief concern worry um as I'm sure all of you know um about the three hostages that uh female hostages that were
1:11 released earlier in the week um it really was a day you could see there was almost no one in the streets when the exchange uh took place or when the Handover took place everyone really held their breath in this country from right to left whether you were supporter of the uh the the the deal or not not everybody uh really was just waiting um for these first three to come home and it was a extremely emotional day we're going to have another one on Sunday there's going to be four uh released female hostages um and as per last time there's a big debate who it will be who should it be who's going to be on the list who's going to be left behind who's going to be next um and that's really what you know everyone in Israel was talking about U they'll be released on Saturday there was some debate about that Hamas tried to play games as they did last time but it seems like everything's going ahead I think Hamas got the message that they cannot play games anymore um Israel prime minister
2:17 netan is really almost looking for an excuse to come down harder maybe even break the deal I don't think that will happen but I think Hamas know that uh this is not something that uh Netanyahu is coming to uh easily and we'll speak about that a little bit more um because at the end of the day we have 42 days well now we have less than 42 days but we have 42 days until the second and even third phase of this hostage deal this ceasefire and at the moment netan faces a major quandry he can take this to the very end and have all the hostages is living and dead and now they think there's 93 or 94 um uh come home but it will mean that there's no total Victory uh something that netan has been touting for well over a year uh the end of Hamas clearly if the hostage deal goes to its end it will not be the end of Hamas if anything
3:20 it will give them time to rearm uh reform uh we're already starting to see that on the ground they're trying to show that they're still very much in power if uh the 600 plus um um vehicles of uh humanitarian Aid comes in Hamas basically take most of it they make money of it this is how they get their power because they're the only organization which has any sort of money they have the food and basically they can uh replenish their numbers very very quickly and certainly uh hold on to power um but more importantly perhaps for those who believe that netanyahu's sole aim is to remain in power and there are a number of Israelis who believe that uh if netan does um go beyond the 42 days he loses his government almost certainly we saw this week with the signing or the agreement of the the deal uh itar Ben took his party out of the
4:22 government I think there's now 63 62 uh seats left in the government either way if Bal ofmri fulfills his promise that if uh the ceasefire goes on beyond the first stage uh and leaves the government then basically the government no longer has a majority and could be failed within days um so that is a major problem the other problem he has is if he breaks the ceasefire he loses chance of redeeming 60 plus hostages again many of them are no longer with us but many of them are uh and most importantly probably at this point he risk the eye of the new US president Donald Trump it's clear that Donald Trump wants this deal to come to the end he wants the hostages home he wants the ceasefire to hold and according to report tonight he's even going to sweeten the pot by um connecting uh the the uh the Fulfillment of the next phases of the ceasefire with
5:25 a possible normalization with Saudi Arabia this is the message that um the Middle East Envoy Steve witkoff who was very much instrumental in getting netan to the table and getting this deal over the line is bringing with him a message that uh the the dangling the carrot of Saudi normalization and according to hear his interview with Fox News all the countries of the region could follow obviously that's not true uh Iran is not going to follow in he mentioned by name Qatar um I don't think Qatar will be first second third uh necessarily in the normalization list but certainly that the the the added uh you know potential normalization of Saudi Arabia is something that's very much uh something that Netanyahu has sought it could be a way to explain away a ceasefire that this is much greater perhaps it can also be connected to Iran perhaps some sort of green light or at least an amber light we've talked about that in the
6:26 past um to attack Iran when it's at it's weakest um but netan could then be voted out of office uh the very next day uh which is a problem that Netanyahu is known as the political magician in Israel and you never put it past him and you never bet against BBY as I like to say U but it certainly is going to be an extremely difficult um trick or uh uh you know event for net to try and get as much as he can while not annoying the new US president and uh keeping smotrich and his government intact uh we'll talk about some of the other problems he has because it's not just on the security front um what we also saw this week um is an operation in Janine which pretty much coincided with the ceasefire deal the ceasefire obviously is only in Gaza it's not it's not related to Judean Sam
7:29 area the West Bank and what Israel has done is really it's it's launched operation Iron Wall starting the Northern West Bank Northern uh Su Samaria in Janine which is probably the most problematic of all uh the Palestinian towns and they've gone into the refugee camp which is really a vipers Nest it's run largely by Islamic Jihad and let's not forget Islamic Jihad is a Shiite organization and it gets its funding and Direction straight from Iran Israel has gone there it's killed tens of terrorists it's arrested tens more interestingly enough it does seem that there is some coordination with the Palestinian Authority The palestin Authority police uh has waited outside of Janine and arrested some of those who tried to run away as the IDF uh came in another reason that's been suggested why Israel is doing uh this sort of cleanup now first of all it obviously can free up some of its troops on the northern border in in a in a few days in four days Israel has to be out of Lebanon
8:31 according to that particular ceasefire agreement but also they are starting to remove uh troops from some of the central locations in Gaza um so they do have troops uh available uh to go in and do this clean up but also let's not forget starting on Sunday uh there's going to be some very heavy Palestinian uh prisoners terrorists released in the in the in the deal from last week for the the three uh hostages the three female hostages uh most of the people released were uh women and children yes there was a leader of the pflp um but these are not necessarily some of the uh terrorists with mass blood on their hands that we are going to see uh this Sunday uh one of them is zubedi if we remember he was one of those who managed to escape prison and he has become quite a role model in Palestinian societ and they think and and and he is a Janine native and they think that Israel
9:34 is concerned that when he returns to Janine that will give quite a bit of a Tailwind for the terrorist organizations they'll celebrate it as a major victory and so one of the uh reasons for this operation Iron Wall beginning in ginine but certainly will not end there is to try and get ahead of the release of some of these big arch terrorists um and try disrupt uh and dismember some of the terrorist uh infrastructure here another possible reason for this is to appease his more right-wing elements as I talked before about balos mric but also uh some of the more right-wing elements in Le could there are a number of them who voted against the deal uh or at least abstained and they're not to be taken for granted either even though the majority could supported the deal certainly the minister iial level uh there are pockets of resistance uh who are not happy but obviously the one to watch is balos mric and that is a person
10:38 that netan really has to try and uh appease as much as possible we also saw uh the release of um some more extremist settlers who had been in administrative uh detention defense minister Yesa Katz said how can we let uh terrorist go and we can't let uh you know Jewish Israelis who have been suspected um of violence go as well so that's probably also another thing that smartr needed uh to try and say face because as as I said before Ben already made his move he handed in his resignation all the ministers I think there were three of them in total um in Otay udid party have handed in their resignation and they now go back to the back benches they are not even in the Coalition although they did vote with the Coalition today on a number of issues um another major event this week which is could also be uh associated with the Ben resignation and
11:40 smartr is the resignation of Herz Levy Israel's Chief of Staff now Herz Levy has become a bit of a lightning rod obviously as the chief of staff of the IDF it's clear that he Bears a large amount of responsibility for the failures uh on October uh 7th and perhaps even after although as some people have point out he also deserved some of the successes and achievements of the IDF since then but the fact is it was always going to happen um and now as we see that there is a ceasefire uh on two fronts and uh and it was felt that this was a good time this is something that the more right-wing elements of the government led by Ben and smartr have been calling for for quite a while they blame him uh this serves neton well because he as said he serves as a lightning rod and netan can make the case that you know the failures were the Army was the military was the security establishment the political level uh was not aware of what was going on and they
12:41 were not informed and it was it's basically they're the ones who have to take uh responsibility um the jury still out exactly how this will be seen but uh he is going to be in his position at least I believe for another month or so um there's already talks about who's going to be the ne next chief of staff and yes Kat's defense minister came out with three names none of them are unexpected um there was a feeling that perhaps it was time to clear out some of those older more experienced more obvious choices for someone a little bit younger a new generation that didn't think the same way as the those who failed on October 7th but in the end the three candidates are very much from uh the most obvious they're the most obvious candidates they're the very much from from the security establishment um we'll have to wait and see uh how that uh goes on another big threat to netan continues to be um the ultra Orthodox enlistment law uh this week uh it really came back
13:46 to the four uh it's clear that there is uh a push from the highest levels from Netanyahu himself certainly with with the prodding of the ultra Orthodox uh leaders of the parties in the government to try and get some sort of law across the line as we know it's been held up for various reasons one of them is the fact that the head of the uh defense and Foreign Affairs committee which is the committee that's supposed to debate the law in the knesset Run by juli edstein very much wants to find something closer to equality than uh the Israel cats principles if you like or law uh have stated Israel cats is very much trying to push something which really is very far from what most Israelis want it basically talks about a very very gradual uh increase in enlistment uh for Ultra Orthodox um population and only in seven years will it reached 50% of the potential of uh the ultra Orthodox uh
14:49 you know youth uh that is seen as a copout that is seen as kicking the can down the table even though publicly the ultra Orthodox leaders do not accept even that minimum uh uh numbers uh you know they they probably would kick and screen but they probably would uh accepted behind closed doors but that's clearly not enough for those like edstein and many others um let's not forget that uh this has to be passed pretty soon because while all of these Coalition uh issues and challenges are taking place the budget still has not been passed and the budget has to be passed for 2025 by the end of March by the end of three months from the beginning of the year if it doesn't the government immediately dissolves so there really is a strong clock on this and a lot of things are coming together uh for the next uh couple of months um as I said in in the next few days on the 26th the IDF is supposed to uh leave Lebanon uh we'll have to see what happen
15:54 is going to happen there there's been a lot of meetings um so we'll have to keep eye on that situation has the Lebanese Army uh done enough is hisbah uh completely away from the south of the country beyond the Lani River uh certainly it's taking a beating domestically politically um a new president a prime minister certainly not the ones that they wanted in Lebanon have been appointed in the last few days so it shows that kah's political power is waning at this point uh but it remains to be seen exactly how they uh react to it obviously last night we had a terror attack in Tel Aviv and unfortunately it's become a relatively regular um event these days uh but what made last night's attack uh particularly unique was it was um it was done by a us resident someone who holds a green card originally from Morocco came into the country uh was flagged by the immigration um people at the border at
16:57 the airport uh was handed over to the shinb but the shinb BET decided that he was no threat so there's quite a bit of Investigation into that why he was allowed into the country someone who then tried to murder Israelis thankfully no one was killed there were a few injured but certainly that's going to be a bit of a a topic between Israeli and American interlocutors as we remember Israel promised as part of the Visa waiver uh program which was passed recently that it would not make trouble for Americans coming into Israel especially those with a Muslim and Arab background um I don't know if that's relevant to the decision making at the border but it's something that certainly people are starting uh to bring up as a result of last night's attack uh and with that I'm happy to answer any questions all right well thank you very much Ashley uh lots to uh cover here uh I'll start with a question about a recent development uh it was revealed
17:59 recently that the three hostages that were released were being kept in onra camps do you suppose that this means that President Trump and the International Community will up the pressure on the United Nations well they already are one of the first um executive orders he signed on his first day there was a whole slew of them some of them uh were related to Israel one of them was they they're stopping all Aid um I think all un Aid programs or at least hating them suspending them until they could look into the properly let's not forget that Trump during his first tenure did stop funding for unrest so certainly they are worried and in fact uh he also returned sanctions on ICC um employees and from what I read today ICC are really in in are worried about this concerned about this some of the sanctions they could be arrested I believe uh some of them if they enter America I think at least some of the financial sanctions and the fact that they won't be funded um by the US and perhaps some of its allies as well um so
19:02 yes so there's quite a lot to get through with those early executive orders um but it's clear it's been clear since the beginning that Hamas have used unra you know I'm not going to get into how much unra knows it's clear that many of them did it's clear that some of the unra employees have be were involved in the terrorist attacks on October 7th and Beyond uh we know that um some of the hostages were held by unra officials and we know now that some of the hostages were held in unra bases or camps um again they will probably deny that they knew anything about it um but there needs to be a follow investigation but at the moment the UN Secretary General doesn't seem to be at all interested in in in in taking part in any sort of Investigation like that right thank you now uh what effect will the resignation of benir and Hali uh have on the security cabinet and uh Israel's ongoing multi-front
20:06 War well the multi I'll start with the end the multif front War now is pretty much only a couple of fronts uh hisbah you know there's a ceasefire there there's a ceasefire in Gaza again it could be only temporary there's a very good chance that it will only be temporary and they could go back uh to war the htis have basically said that while there's a ceas f in Gaza it will respect it uh Iran is certainly not looking for any trouble at this point they know how bad the situation is even if they're trying to put on a brave public face um at the moment there is Terrorism uh coming from Jude and Samaria and apparently from outside of the country as well or even inside the country um so we are in a bit of a rest bite how long that lasts is anybody's guess so that's probably why her L decided to resign now uh Ben is you know adamantly against the the hostage deal um so that was always going to happen he said from the beginning he will resign he wanted to try and embarrass smotrich
21:09 um smotrich was in a bit of a difficult situation and the negotiations between him and Neto went on for a couple of days um obviously what was promised or not has not been revealed smartr claims that he was promised that there will be a resumption of war and if there isn't he will resign and that uh he's got at least what is it now 35 days or something like that still in the government um until uh he has to make a decision about that right thank you now Eric sov like to ask Hamas looked like they are quite firmly in power did Israel misjudge the Hamas casualty numbers it depends what you call power as I said um the International Community some argue Israel itself did not do enough to ensure that Hamas lost its grip how Hamas maintained its grip throughout the war and certainly now uh during the ceasefire is it will uh maintain control over food over aid over
22:13 pretty much everything they are still the only governing um uh body uh around and let's not forget when you have money uh if you lose 20,000 terrorists you have enough money to replenish them pretty quickly you give 17 18 year old guns you give them a few hundred dollars whatever it is a month I mean you knowas have billions um and suddenly you've got 20,000 new soldiers there are those in the security establishment who claim that Hamas kept one or two brigades uh completely away from the battle to ensure that this the day after this during the sea SP they have uh the Personnel to take back the streets uh and M main control um so that's what some some of what we're seeing it's clear that it will be very difficult for them to be completely 100% in control throughout the Gaza Strip but at the moment basically the ceasefire allows them to remain in control to what level we don't know U but they're the only
23:18 governing uh Power left and as I said last week if this ceasefire deal comes to the end uh this is the end of the war Hamas will remain the only governing uh party now they have asked the PA to come in to govern while they maintain military or security control um but that's really the PA know exactly what that is that's window dressing and that's just to entice the International Community to give the billions that would be necessary uh to rebuild Gaza and we know where that money would go it would go straight back to Hamas to rebuild replenish rearm you know recreate create some of their tunnels etc etc so the PA at the moment are not interested in being that fig Leaf uh so Hamas really is the only game in town when the money comes in it's going to go pretty much at least certain percentage of it straight back into hamas's Pockets right thank you David LaVine would like to ask do you have any
24:21 comment on the quote unquote gift bags that Hamas the three women as they left Gaza as part of their propaganda they're very good at propaganda they put out these nice videos clever videos um but it's clear that they lost control of that particular Handover because what they did at first for those who watched it and all of Israel was watching every single moment that was being released by Al jazer Hamas propaganda whatever it is so we saw they tried to create a clearing they put a desk down they put chairs down they wanted this to be a little bit more controlled a little bit more showy to show that they're in control to to show that they're their prisoners but now they're releasing them but then when um I wouldn't say thousands because if you zoomed out from the particular scenes there weren't actually that many people there but it was enough to cause the Hamas um uh militants their problem as I said it could be that these are these fresh recruits who don't really know what they're doing and they don't have that
25:23 experience so it's clear that it was getting out of control and they had to dispense with this whole sort of ceremony and they rushed them from the Kamas um pickup trucks to um to the Red Cross they did give them these bags it's another part of their sickness that they have to sort of show how how how how great they are and how they were their guests and they made them sign their certificates of release and they gave them pictures from their um captivity and everything but it's part of hamas's show for the outside world we are we treat our prisoners well I mean it's clear that they were treated probably relatively well in the last couple of weeks there was uh there there's been a lot of talk that they were given vitamins they were given much better food they were treated well in the last couple of weeks we don't know exactly yet what they went through we know uh what some of the previous release hostages went through and they were only there for 50 days and it was traumatic enough Israel being a a small Society where everyone knows everyone they try
26:27 not to release and the and the journalists and the media are very cautious about releasing some of the details U but is Israelis tend to know what happened to these hostages and I'm sure we will hear despite the smiles despite the gratitude for coming home that they experien unspeakable Horrors and sadly we'll probably hear more about those uh in the weeks and months to come so sending them off with these packages these goodbye presence is just part of the psychological Terror on the one hand and also to to show the outside outside world that they're good people at the end of the day and unfortunately some people do lap that up all right thank you very much now uh Barack cormas would like to ask can you comment on Turkish Israeli relations regarding the Kurdish issue do you think Israel or turkey would like to pick a fight against the other over the Kurds I don't think so I think both want what they want Israel is not um as motivated on this issue let's put it
27:29 that way as turkey for turkey they see it as a real I wouldn't say existential issue but certainly an an extremely strategic um issue because as we know the Kurdish separatist elements within turkey there their concern is that they will join up with uh Syrian Kurds perhaps Iraqi kurs and create this Kurdistan and they will do anything to quell it um and the fact that they basically the the new government in Syria basically their p uh the other way around um they basically feel that they can put the pressure on on the new Syrian government to deal with the Kurds and in fact that they threaten the Kurds today if you don't lay down your arms um we will do it by force Israel is not going to go to war for the Kurds and let's not forget the Kurds are armed by the US the US have a have a greater interest here Israel is just trying to defend itself um but the CDs are not a bur burning issue
28:31 we Israel does feel a certain friendship uh you know fraternal friendship towards the Kurds um but it it's not going to go to war for them uh turkey could and certainly elements within the Syrian government with their threats they could as well but Israel is not going to get probably involved certainly not openly in in such a battle all right thank you I think we have time for maybe one more here now uh in exchange for the hostages in Gaza the uh Israel agreed to release hundreds of terrorists including Mass murderers is there a concern that this is just a rerun of the events that led up to October 7th yeah yeah it it absolutely is and and that's why I said about the conflicting emotions because on the one hand every Israeli is just delighted to see the three young women who came home and then on the other hand you see the price that is being paid and we we we read the names and you know many of us I know uh a couple of people whose family
29:35 members were killed by people who will now be released and walk in the streets you know it's very difficult people remember it you know I I I'm I'm was good friends with Ari fold uh who was stabbed while he went he was going shopping not not too far from where I live and his murderer is going to be released in this deal his his name was on the list um so there is a lot of conflict ing emotions and people understand the major price that they have to pay for this that's the big debate it's an impossible deal it's the devil's deal it's Israel wants its people home and the hostages just because we're such a small country because put such a value of Life family uh and all that we we're prepared to pay a very very high price so Israelis are going into this open eyed some are against the deal some before the deal but most understand that this is not a good deal it's just if you want to get the hostages out in total it's probably the only deal and on the other hand you
30:39 can say well yes we've seen this before but the people who may die in the future are nameless and faceless the people who could be released and lives will be saved we know their names we know their pictures they're everywhere in Israel so it is it's it's it's it's a very painful and very difficult time in Israel as I said it's that's why I started it uh this this conversation tonight is contrasting emotions the the the high the Euphoria everywhere sporting events entertainment events on the streets everybody's talking about everyone's so excited everyone feels that one of their own relatives was released and then you see the pictures and you see the names of those who will be released and you can't but think back to the shal deal with sin's release Etc but it's the deal all right well thank you very much Ashley we have unfortunately reached the end of this week's podcast I want to thank you again for taking the time to update us thank you of course now for our viewers and listeners please join us this Friday at 1 pm eastern time for a podcast with John Spencer as always we
31:45 thank you again for joining us and for your participation and I hope you all have a wonderful day