MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Israel Insider

Israel Insider with Ashley Perry

Watch Israel Insider with Ashley Perry on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

What is behind the recent spate of Palestinian terror attacks on Israelis? What is the debate about it and the likely government response? Is the Opposition cooperating with the government?

Transcript Automatic captions

Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 5, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.

0:00 and welcome to the middle east forums webinar and podcast series israel insider with ashley perry i'm stacy roman and i will be moderating this discussion today prayer please have mr ashley perry advisor to the middle east forum's israel office join us here each wednesday at 3 pm eastern to update us on all the events going on in israel mr pryor will be giving us a briefing on current israeli affairs for 15 minutes and open it up for questions should you wish to ask a question please use the q a box located at the bottom of your screen to type your question and now with no further ado i'll turn the discussion over to mr ashley perry thank you very much stay sane good night good evening from israel i should say um i've spoken about it a few times but you know i'm i'm asked uh usually by stacy to give a um a sort of a title a working title for this uh uh tonight's uh webinar on saturday night so again you know sometimes i write something because that's what's an you know maybe over the end of the

1:03 previous week thursday or friday don't forget in israel the weekend starts friday and saturday as opposed to in the u.s and uk and elsewhere saturday and sunday um and uh and so basically last week there was uh the latest uh attack a terrorist attack against an israeli jew by a palestinian arab uh israeli arabs but there was uh a spate of terrorist attacks uh what some defined as lone wolf meaning that you know many of these people did not belong necessarily to a terrorist organization even though sometimes groups like hamas take responsibility or they congratulate the people for for the attacks you you saw the attack which got a bit of news when it happened outside the old city when an ultra orthodox man was stabbed that was the previous saturday and then he was shot on the ground by israeli soldiers a lot

2:06 of people a lot of palestinians or activists spliced the video to make it look like just someone was sitting around and then they were shot when actually they tried to stab a few people uh with quite a nasty knife or a few days later we saw the latest attack in sheikh jarrah shimla and sadiq those of you who have been following the earlier in the year the hamas israel conflict earlier in the year was partially at least claimed to be about uh what's going to shake if you remember there's a there's a number of buildings in that area which were originally owned by jewish families and then when that area was taken over by jordan these houses where the jews had to flee or expelled but then handed over to some palestinian families who have been living there ever since and a number of years ago israeli

3:10 organizations who bought it off their family for which he owned it took the palestinian families to court and they wrote that they should hand it over and then there was an appeal so this process is winding its way through the supreme court and it caused quite an international outcry if you remember and hamas used it to garner support for what then became the latest uh conflict the flare-up uh the that particular neighborhood there's still a lot of tensions and there was a woman who was walking her children to when uh i believe a 14 or 15 year old uh walked behind her and took out a big kitchen knife and stabbed her in the thankfully the woman was um was not too seriously injured she didn't go to hospital the assailant fled to and apparently the school wouldn't give her up but the army had to go in and get uh get her out but uh that was just the latest i think there was five or six attacks the last couple of weeks

4:12 and a lot of people asking is this going to be something like uh what we had a few years ago when there was a lot of loan attacks and thankfully i have to say at least um there hasn't been an attack this week not a successful one at least uh all the time the israeli security officials police army um border patrols are stopping and preventing attacks that's not to say that there is there are no attacks and almost every day there's some sort of rock throwing or maybe petrol bomb throwing on some of the roads in judea and samaria but there hasn't been one of these uh star being attacks now uh for about a week uh so that was what sort of was was the title um of the webinar for this week but the question is what actually is going on in these areas and what we can see is that hamas is trying to gain a foothold in judea and sumers we know hamas control the gaza strip and fatah in theory at least control fatah is abu mao mahmud abbas the

5:15 palestinian president's party and they control ostensibly at least jude and samaria the west bank actually on the ground there are many areas where neither groups are necessarily in control it's the local authorities sometimes the sheriff's sometimes it's on clan rule but in the big cities what we have seen is hamas are trying to make a big play for taking control and fatah are trying to beat them back you know as much as they both are not big fans of israel to put it mildly they are not necessarily they're they're rivals they don't like each other they they're both trying to take power so we've seen fatah really try and uh clamp down on hamas what we have seen we haven't seen for quite a while uh is hamas openly parading through the streets with palestinians major cities with with not just their flags but also rifles and arms and weapons and this was more than a signal to israel this was a signal to fatah so perhaps that with the ongoing incitement the

6:18 terror payments um things like that is probably behind what's going on at the moment uh the you know the ground in jerusalem in certain areas at least it's a little bit tense even from earlier in the year and there are people who try to take advantage hamas are certainly uh interested in turning up the heat they've said that if their demands are not met uh on gaza then they you know that they will perhaps return to what they you know claim is the military option in other words firing at israeli population centers in the south and really stirring things up in jerusalem and the west bank at the moment it really isn't having too much of an effect on the israeli political scene what has uh had more of an effect this week which is uh has split uh the coalition as as we've spoken quite a lot about this coalition has strange ideological bedfellows so far they've been able to keep it under wraps they've been able to uh really ensure

7:22 that these ideological differences haven't come to the fore but one let's say relatively minor tweet this week certainly brought them to the front uh omar omar bar lev who is the internal security minister in charge of police and things like that i had a meeting with um a deputy secretary of state i believe and he quoted uh that during the meeting uh what was discussed one of the things that was discussed is what was described as settler violence um and for that comment he was praised by some of the more left-wing members of the government on the right in the amina party especially he was condemned especially as what i said before in the backdrop of the fact that there have numerous uh palestinian terrorist attacks in the last few weeks that the fact that uh you know there was a discussion with a senior foreign official especially from the american administration and they spent at least a certain amount of time on what was described as a settler

8:25 terrorism or settler attacks uh obviously outraged uh the right and that really did cause a bit of back and forth uh interestingly enough on that um when penny gans the the defense minister was in america uh to to talk about the iran nuclear negotiations and israel's point of view and reportedly according to certain media outlets what an israeli potential attack would look like and the fact that they are preparing for that at least preparing the strategy in case that was necessary were a lot of reports that said that during the meeting the secretary of state lincoln as much time on what israel would describe as an existential threat in other words the iranian nuclear weapons capability uh secretary of state lincoln and again i stress this is according to reports i wanted to spend as much time talking

9:28 about settlements in judea and samaria in other words the building of israeli homes over the green line was just as important to senior on some of the most senior members of the u.s administration as basically trying to coordinate what would be an existential threat to israel and as you can imagine even there were foreign uh ministry officials who also went on record and said there seems to be an obsession with settlements at the moment we want to talk about iran we want to talk about the fact that iran is maybe months away from nuclear threshold state being able to enrich uranium to 90 which is weapons-grade material which in theory should be a red line again like we discussed a couple of weeks ago it doesn't mean that necessarily that there's a missile ready the capability to attach it to a missile could take up to two years if not longer but the fact that they will have this great material means that that threshold is being met and that is a very dangerous moment so in israel the

10:32 defense security and political levels are very worried about this we saw that uh senior idf officials went off record uh with reporters in europe reporters in the u.s went to meet with uh all sorts of officials uh real a real uh full court press uh on this issue just to show really where israel is standing on this especially with the stored vienna uh nuclear weapons uh talks with iran but israel's really tried to show and it is extremely worried about the latest developments and the fact that again according to uh certain um leaks uh and officials who remained anonymous they said the americans are seem to be obsessed with bringing up settlements every time they want to talk about uh iran so that's obviously concern here in addition um what's also causing concern is reports are that uh israel purchased um uh refueling aircrafts that would be

11:34 necessary for any sort of strike on iran and even though these have been purchased uh and israel wanted them uh obviously sent over and moved up as soon as possible now israel is being told that they won't be delivered until 2024. and again i stress the point that uh israel believes it's not just israel's other players around the world who believe that iran is weeks months away from that threshold status of 90 enriched uranium and now they're being told that a necessary piece of the puzzle to even have an option of a military strike on uh iran's nuclear uh weapons facilities could take up to more years so there's obviously a little bit of uh you know disgruntlement amongst uh israeli officials on that particular level finally just a little bit about israeli politics we're really back to the you know the sort of fun and games quote unquote uh the coalition of opposition it doesn't matter what issue comes up if

12:36 the opposition uh supporting the coalition will stand against it and vice versa some of the issues you would think would get more to support really uh just you know issues such as being able to supervise missile uh creating facilities to put extra safeguards the opposition voted against them likewise so it's really causing uh uh you know neither side to compromise you know usually in normal times you know there would certainly be times where uh opposition a coalition would vote against each other even if it's uh an issue of mutual concern but those only rare circumstances here it's rare extremely well that they will vote uh together on an issue and it came to such a point that uh and caused a lot of consonation this week that uh uh shirley pinto member of commissioner shirley pinto from the um uh you mean a party the first deaf uh mk uh gave birth uh last thursday and she was drafted in already today or yesterday to vote because

13:41 simply as we know there's a 61 59 and you had a couple of errant coalition members you had you had a cara who wasn't happy about the new green pass rules for those who are vaccinated being allowed into malls and those who are not vaccinated not being allowed intervals so he uh took some time off from the uh from the plenum and so that put it down to a bare minimum without uh pinto then uh it would have been 59.59 then when he returned you had taha of the iran party who's not happy about what's called the electricity bill that would provide the state provider of electricity would be also to unrecognize houses that's something very important to the arab community to ram so the fact that they kept on having people sit out meant that shirley pinto had to be drafted in because usually in these circumstances with someone ill someone can't make it to knit someone support they have an

14:44 offsetting tradition where someone from the other side of the opposition would sit out to ensure that the person could grieve if it was for a loved one get well if they're ill give birth you know get time off um but the opposition uh did not agree to give uh an offset for shirley pinto so she had to turn up and that as you can imagine cause a bit of a consonation she turned up with her baby uh in the knesset five days after uh you know she gave birth and there she voting uh benny gads and natalia bennett both of them who traveled abroad last week many councillors said to washington natalie bennett was the first prime minister to visit the uae on a state visit and both of them had to be brought in pretty much from the airport to the knesset plan and they had to sit in an isolated area and vote from the but that's what it takes these days really when they have such a slim and you have an opposition who's not

15:48 prepared to offset their mks then that's the situation we're in uh it's a very uh difficult situation at one point the coalition of the site was going to decide to put off any of his votes because it didn't have the number and that's when they decided to call in uh the new mother shirley pinto so politics has gone back to its uh you know combative self and i'm sure that's the way it's going to be for the coming days and weeks and with that happy to answer any questions about those issues or any other all right thank you so much the first question we have in is from jerry weiner uh are the attacks in uh mostly in judea and samaria or is it more widespread into israel and the west bank as well which would are the west bank uh it's the same it's the same area um i mean again you know if you ask people who live over the green line you know there's attacks almost every day there's rock throwing there's uh molotov cocktail launching of vehicles there's all sorts

16:51 of what some might argue minor attacks these go on multiple times a day but usually they don't make the media even in israel the star beings that that i was talking about those are mostly happening in jerusalem seems to be uh you know where where a lot of these places uh take place as they said uh the one on the shop art the sabbath with the ultra won the one that uh the video became famous that happened just outside the old city uh this stabbing of uh of her mother with her children happened in the sheikh jarrah shimon sadiq neighborhood which is just outside the old city in east jerusalem so mostly attacks at the moment the staffing attacks are taking place in jerusalem thank you david levine asks regarding the refueling planes is israel working with its new arab friends to arrange for refueling on the ground in the event of an israeli attack on iran

17:54 there was talk about that a long time ago even before relations that there'd be flyover rights there'd be assistance with refueling uh it's certainly not something which is going to be openly uh there is actually if anything the emiratis actually had a meeting with iranians this week so you know like like all things that you know trying to sit a little bit on both sides and try to calm things down discuss and um so it would be very unlikely you find to any of the arab leaders any of the gulf sunni leaders coming out openly and saying that it would give israel active assistance in any possible military strike so certainly if there was such assistance it would be clandestine be behind the scenes would be something that everyone would want to try and keep on the down low so it's certainly not something that's uh being made public at this point thank you and dr khan lichias uh regarding the government with mks voting more along the coalition

19:00 versus opposition how long will this government last if that continues is there any any threat of the government failing because of that um i said a few weeks ago now that the budget has passed that the biggest threat has really been taken off the table because there's only really a certain amount of ways that a government can fall a government can not pass a single law for another three four years and it could still survive that's not what can bring a government down uh not passing a budget in an appropriate amount of time like we said uh would would cause immediate uh elections a a non confidence vote uh could also bring down a government but a non-confidence vote requires a alternative government which means you need to have 61 seats with you at the moment the opposition at least uh the netanyahu led opposition is 53 seats because don't forget there's another six with the uh joint list who would not sit in a in the netanyahu government so at the moment

20:04 there are eight shy of being able to put together a government uh for no confidence vote until you have that you can't really put a proper no confidence uh vote through so that's not likely at this point um as i've mentioned before really the only party that could eventually at one point flip to the other side because of the numbers and because of the possible nature of coalition politics is uh many gans is uh blue and white it has he has eight seats uh prime former prime minister i should say benjamin netanyahu has been constantly uh talking up the chances of benny gans if he comes he'll be prime minister again uh that offer made the news this week there's a lot of disquiet within the of that because again you can see someone with a minority of seats a small number single sig of single figure seats uh becoming prime minister you know at the moment they keep on reminding the coalition that has been led by a prime minister with six seats well uh netanyahu was offering uh

21:07 someone to be a prime minister with eight seats so it's not that much different but they realize that's the only possible avenue to get to their 61 because some of those smaller right-wing parties uh do not have eight whether it's israel new hope none of those three are likely to move across but even if they did uh they would still be short and the other part is that the yashatir or labor are more to the left so it's unlikely that they would ever be offered such a proposition and they certainly wouldn't take it so really the only possible in that scenario is blue and white another way that a government can end is if they pass a law to disperse knesset that you only need 61 or you actually need a majority so it could be that some parties will abstain uh but again it would have to be a real there'd have to be a real breakdown in

22:09 the coalition and we're not there yet i talked a little bit about the elephants called the electricity law and it certainly was enough of a grievance for one of the mks to sit out on some of the bills today but the uh the leader of the right party monsoon bus went on the tv later on some of the tv shows and said while the electricity law is very important for us uh it doesn't deserve uh you know a stress on the coalition and not every single disagreement within the coalition is going to lead to a coalition crisis so certainly that calm tempers down a little bit um so at the moment uh the government is pretty stable even if there are disagreements even if there are ideological differences there's no real threat to it at this point things could change certainly but uh at the moment uh the the leaders of the parties seem to be working well together yes there are differences yes there are disagreements on twitter sometimes these battles like this week about uh ome bar live's tweet which i mentioned earlier that took

23:10 place on twitter this one attacked that one on twitter and the left attacked back the rides attacked back but that's pretty much where you know it remained it was more of a battle in the eyes of its ideological adherence but not necessarily enough to do any damage real damage to the coalition so at the moment the coalition's pretty stable will it live out its whole existence i wouldn't put too much money on it that remains to be seen but at the moment it's pretty stable thank you so much larry dunn asks when the security cabinet has to make a decision on whether to attack iran will they bring netanyahu into the decision making well there is a rule that the opposition leader does get a security briefing i believe it's monthly uh usually gets an update the atmosphere between the prime minister and the former prime minister at the moment is pretty bad uh i'm not sure exactly how much they're speaking so that remains to be seen but there's no there's no

24:11 legal or constitutional need um to bring in the opposition leader but uh and and probably you want to if again this is a big because we're not there uh or even close to being there at this moment but if there would uh be military strike um i think you know you would assume you would want as few people as possible to know and again not not to make any aspersions on the former prime minister but in this political atmosphere some people could hear about it and want to make political um you know in the field of diplomacy or even security there has been things which should be very problematic that uh on you know that have been leaked let's say uh again i'm not saying that netanyahu would do such a thing but uh i think the atmosphere at the moment between the coalition opposition probably means that uh i doubt that anyone outside a very small circle uh would be aware of such plans

25:14 and necessarily be updated in real time to them andy pellick asks a report in today's jerusalem post is that israel will suspend natural gas development for a period of time to focus on renewables can you give us some insight into the politics causing this action yes this is a policy uh by uh minister of energy water natural infrastructure karen and hara very much put a focus on renewable energy has been really she she traveled to the cop conference and spoke about the need actually because she's in a wheelchair there was this whole thing i don't if you remember she wasn't able to get to give the speeches um but she's she's put a lot of focus and this government has put quite a lot of focus on renewables on moving to renewable energy and trying to do away with waste and and and all that sort of thing it did take a lot of people by surprise uh this decision but the government certainly is putting uh you know its money where its mouth is

26:16 um last week uh minister el harar was in the uae where she signed an agreement with jordan a a real historic and unique agreement where jordan would set up a massive solar field because what georgian has a lot of is territory uninhabited territory and israel has growing energy needs especially in electricity so they would then give us electricity and israel in turn which gives jordan what it needs which is available water is probably the most arid country in the world has the lowest amount of cubic meters of water per household in the world so it was quite an interesting deal it's quite a historic deal uh trying to move to you know certainly the the solar panel fields is an attempt to move as much as possible across to renewables uh and uh i think you know there's talking by 2050 whether majority visuals energy needs will be met by renewable so it's not a major surprise

27:20 uh but probably quite a lot of people especially in the opposition were quite surprised by this um but then there's the argument that the whole sort of gas exploration hasn't really trickled down to the israeli household level you know there was a promise of sovereign wealth funds there was promise of lower energy costs none of these things materialized so i think there'll be a certain amount of support for it but there will certainly be a stronger robust opposition i'm sure the the debate will all rage uh but certainly this government with um karinel gerard environment minister tamar zambok really stamping their putting their footprint the fingerprints whatever you want to call it on the israeli government policies and certainly there is a big push within the israeli government to move to uh renewable energy and this is probably one of the biggest manifestations of that policy uh joy wolf asked what is happening in the to the tourist industry is this pretty much the same as the first lockdown or or is this different

28:25 israel isn't in lockdown or anything close too uh but certainly foreign tourists are not allowed non-israelis are not allowed into israel without with a few exceptions first to be relative uh things like that uh yeah the tourism industry is in a lot of trouble um he was just starting to get back on its feet uh minister uh finance minister abito lima got into a bit of trouble this week because during a closed cabinet meeting was leaked that he said it's about time that uh some of the people in tourism industry wake up and understand that maybe they have to be retrained or look for other jobs he walked that comment back and he apologized for the phrasing of it but um it's certainly you know that the tourism industry those were demonstrations outside the knessets uh it's it's it's it's on its knees as you can imagine um anything to do with that and obviously there's a lot of industries which are affected by the tourism industry tourism industry you know is a significant industry in

29:28 israel and you can imagine especially in the christmas period with a lot of pilgrims a lot of christian visitors uh is really going to hurt uh israel even more so but the policy at this point is and they just extended it for at least another week is that no tourists can come in uh and at the moment also even leaving the country is difficult they just added the uk france spain the uae and a few other countries to the red list which means israelis alphabet of going to some of these other countries uh so definitely uh the tourism industry in israel like in many other places around the world is is certainly been brought to its knees uh during covert well thank you so much we've come to the close of our webinar and podcast ashley thank you again for taking time to update us this week for our viewers and listeners please join us friday at 1 pm eastern for a webinar on turkey's dangerous new exports regional instability and pan-islamist visions thank you all for joining us and i hope you have a great day