MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Webinar or Talk

Understanding Yemen's Civil War with Varsha Koduvayur

Watch Understanding Yemen's Civil War with Varsha Koduvayur on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

Yemen’s civil war, underway since 2014, involves a dizzying array of combatant groups backed by an almost as large number of foreign governments. What is at stake in this conflict, what is the record of America’s allies in it, and what policies should the Biden Administration pursue?

Transcript Automatic captions

Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 9, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.

0:00 all right good afternoon and welcome to the middle east forum speaker webinar series and podcast i'm stacy roman and i will be moderating this discussion today we're pleased to have varsha kudavar sorry a senior research analyst at the foundation for the defense of democracies join us to discuss understanding yemen's civil war ms kudavaier will speak for 15 minutes and open it up for questions should you wish to ask a question please use the q a box located at the bottom of your screen to type your question and with that i will turn the discussion over to miss starsha cudabear thank you so much for that introduction and thank you all for being with me today on this cloudy friday afternoon i'm delighted to be able to join the middle east forum and speak about the war in yemen which um as of march of this year is now in its sixth year with no resolution in sight but i'll start speaking about the nature of what led to the saudi-led and i'll wrap up by looking at where the war is now and what the biden administration's

1:02 policies are towards yemen and the houthis and the so saudi arabia intervened militarily to assist the government of yemeni president abraham in march 2015 after the houthi rebels took over the yemeni capital of sana the houthis had actually fought for years with hadi's predecessor ali abdullah who was forced to step down uh in 2011 after yemen's arab spring and hadi took but as the houthis consolidated their over the capital of sana in early 2015 hadi actually fled to adam in southern yemen and from there he went to to riyadh the reason that saudi arabia along with other gulf and middle eastern states gave for the intervention was to restore the um the government of hadi's government but saudi arabia has always seen yemen as a domestic problem and i think that's a point worth discussing and and shedding light upon

2:06 the two countries share a very long at parts they are porous found in king abdulaziz actually anecdotally is alleged to have said keep yemen weak when he was on his deathbed to his younger sons which shows the importance that yemen has to saudi policy making and thinking that avalaziz himself is said to have uttered those as amongst his last words saudi arabia has been concerned about the houthis developing into a permanent of iran on its southern border so morphing into a hezbollah in the gulf if you will that has been saudi arabia's key fear and many of the gulf states key fear from the start of this intervention and iran as we know has been aiding the houthis they have been there are reports of hezbollah fighters having been deployed to the houthis to assist them in training we know that caches of iranian arms shipments are periodically discovered um and sometimes internated sometimes

3:08 not most recently there was an interdiction of a cache of thousands of offensive assault weapons that was on its way to yemen so iran has really been able to bleed saudi arabia quite literally in both in terms of manpower and treasure with their low-grade investment in the houthis and by some accounts saudi arabia has been spending 200 million dollars a day on this war in yemen and of course we know that saudi arabia famously told the obama administration that the offensive would take about six weeks and six years later here we still are and the saudis are unable to extricate themselves from yemen but it's increasingly clear that they want to and that they're very eager to seek an off-ramp from this conflict which has done severe damage to saudi arabia's and definitely to saudi arabia's standing in washington especially on capitol hill the hattie government after six years of war still remains in exile is very weak

4:13 systemic endemic corruption and it's still a government from exile they're not able to really exert that much control saudi arabia's poor targeting practices have resulted in huge civilian i think amongst the more horrific instances where a wedding a funeral and a school in terms of what uh in terms of the um civilian casualties of his poor targeting record and as i mentioned earlier iran has been able to exploit all this as a low-cost way of threatening saudi arabia yemen has been completely broken the infrastructure is shattered there were cholera epidemics in the country even before the arrival of covet there was also famine excuse me in parts of the country the um and i do believe as most recently the world the u.n had said that yemen is on the cusp of another um so by some metrics by those metrics that i just gave out the war has not been a resounding success if we're going to assess

5:16 what the initial goals were restore the hattie government and instead what you have now is a deeply fractured yemen between the north and the south and you actually have the houthis now in control of more territory than they were in 2014-2015 when this conflict started but by other metrics you can say that the intervention has borne fruit and it has achieved some success for most among them the intervention has uh has led to the to the to exposing the cruelty of the houthis the houthis are not innocent in this fight they're complicit in a host of excuse me of atrocious activities they have used child soldiers they have used human shields they continue to steal aid from starving yemeni people and they continue to blockade and obfuscate attempts at negotiations at every possible term and they've also tortured activists and and women's rights activists and the list really does go on and on in terms of the houthis humanitarian it's also the war has also worked to

6:21 expose iran's meddling in the region and the extent to which iran's proxies are seeking to um to bleed the gulf states specifically around our tribal saudi arabia iran's um in iran's entrenchment of its support to the houthis has just been laid to light more and more as the war has gone on that brings me to talk briefly about where the war stands now six years into it most recently in march saudi arabia offered a very comprehensive ceasefire plan to the the plan envisioned reopening sanat allowing food and fuel imports through hudeida porch which the saudis have been blockading for a while and that would also include depositing tax revenues um from the port at the central the bank of the central excuse me the central bank branch in hodeidah and restarting political negotiations it is a significant and comprehensive offer but the houthis turned it down the houthis maintain that they want a separate sequencing than what the saudis

7:24 are offering so they maintain that they want saudi arabia to lift the blockade first on the port and the airport before the houthis take any reciprocal steps so this is not a new demand this has been something that houthis have demanded on and off throughout the conflict the houthis are also prioritizing their military offensive in mehreb and trying to hold on to their control in other parts of north yemen mary remains the last government stronghold in northern yemen the houthis even refer to this battle to take control of madrid in religious who the spokesman has called out of the gate to jerusalem for example so they're painting this battle with overt religious symbolism and symbolically it would be a blow if the houthis were to take matter because that as i mentioned is the last government stronghold in north yemen so the houthis seem to think that if they're able to seize control of this territory would significantly strengthen and embolden their hand going into future and as a result they're prioritizing continuing this conflict even though the humanitarian costs of that will be rather disastrous

8:26 rather than engage with negotiations and then that brings me to um one other thing i'll say about the houthis uh uh activities too as we've seen in the last two months they have dramatic drastically um increased the barrage of missiles that they're sending into saudi arabia as a way of further pressing their advantage and stoking their leverage the last point i'll talk about briefly is the biden administration's policy as i had so the trump administration designated the houthis in its in its final days the biden administration did revoke that designation of the houthis as a foreign terrorist organization and the revoking the designation does have valid grounds that designation does make it much for humanitarian groups to operate in the country and something like 80 percent of yemenis need food aid in order to to just live and survive and we look at those stats and we look at what this designation would do it would create a chilling effect on the ground

9:28 where a lot of aid agencies might just not even want to engage in the work for fear of running afoul of u.s entrance or u.s law so there are valid reasons for the administration to have decided to revoke that last minute designation on the but that did remove the us's source of leverage over the houthis and the de facto result is that u.s leverage on the houthis is very limited and the houthis are demonstrating that they're they're aware of this dynamic and they intend to exploit it for example just in recent weeks the houthis snubbed a meeting with the martin griffiths the un special envoy for yemen uh well while griffiths was in the region at the same time that tim lender king the us's special envoy for yemen was also in the region and another example of the houthis continuing to press their leverage and i'll end my overview of the conflict here is the houthis continued obstruction and obfuscation over the status of the fso of suffolk which is a ticking time bomb really in the middle of the red sea and the houthis are again using their access to that as leverage to get

10:32 what they want and and get the solution and the outcomes that they're leaning towards so i'll stop with my overview there and i look forward to welcoming all of your questions all right thank you so much we have a few questions questions coming in the first one is will last week's seizure of weapons in the gulf of aden have any real effect on the war in yemen i think it goes to show what i had mentioned earlier i i brought this up a recent cache had been um had been interdicted it goes to show that iran's support for the houthis continues i would say it even continues kind of brazenly here you have an administration that has made a good faith attempt to want to restore diplomacy with iran and it hasn't made any um it hasn't uh made um it hasn't it has very openly committed to wanting to return to some sort of nuclear deal with iran but having taken that iran is continuing to exploit all of its proxies in the region where it can to extract material costs on its enemies in the region

11:32 so in terms of is it going to have an impact on the war in yemen absolutely i would say that this is just going to continue and as long as houthi excuse me iranian support to the houthis continues because houthis will have some sort of a lifeline that they can rely upon to continue extracting concessions of their own thank you my apologies that was from bob and sue raydes and the follow-up questions to that is what percentage of weapons smuggled into yemen does this seizure represent and is there any estimated dollar value on this i do not know the statistics to that off the top of my head i'm sorry but happy to look into that at a later date prom and from david levine uh why isn't the danger on international shipping to the houthis takeover in the red sea entrance with the pro-iranian houthis on one side and the somali pilot pirates on the how does international shipping how is international shipping not threatened well international shipping is threatened and that's exactly why um president obama six years ago did

12:35 engage u.s assistance and enlist u.s assistance in this war the babylonian street is one of the world's three major maritime choke points i think the other two if i'm right are suitable moves and the streets of malacca so this is a key um a key lane to maritime security and i would take a step back from just looking at it from the from the the view of yemen and the houthis and say this is this is why the middle matters still i think we sort of have this debate in washington of uh maybe we are you know the middle east area is over it's time to pivot to i hate using that phrase from asia but it's time to look at other threats great part competition is coming but the middle east is going to be a place where great power competition out and it does host this very vital shipping lane and something like two-thirds of seaborn oil traffic does go through this lane this is why countering iran in the region needs to remain a super high the houthis are able to use their strategic position iran is able to then exploit the houthis and then create these security risks

13:39 that threaten global shipping global trade thank you so this question is from arnold uh on that topic geo politically speaking how do you think that do you think that whoever controls yemen also can control shipping traffic in the red sea and is this iron's objective that is a very interesting question i'm not too certain about the control element of it i think it's um i don't think any let me put it this even with looking at great great power competitions excuse me for example i i don't think any country out there would prefer any other entity to be controlling these shipping lanes so i kind of see that as a different question i think even with this um the return of grave power competition between u.s russia and china it's all because um everybody wants to maintain their access to these strategic choke points so ultimately what is iran's end goal

14:41 with yemen iraq seeks to bleed its enemies that's pretty much what it is it's doing the tactic throughout you've seen how they've cultivated and fostered a network of iraqi militias you've seen how they've entrenched hezbollah to be a permanent or semi-permanent feature in the landscape of lebanese politics and that's exactly what they're seeking to do with the houthis in yemen also i think there's an argument to be made that the houthis are independent of iran they are not as co-opted into iran's vision into iran's structure as i think maybe even some iranian officials would like to think it is um i think there's an element of the houthis look um sort of mutually cooperating and co-opting iran and vice but the houthis represent a low-cost way as i said earlier of iran to be able to bleed saudi arabia and its enemies if that figure of 200 million dollars a day that saudi arabia is spending is um is to be extrapolated for the entire course of the war and we know that iran's investment isn't all that much i don't have dollar limits but you can imagine that they are you know they're just sending advisors

15:42 on the ground they're helping them build missile technology and they're not investing in an entire military and entire nation's military into this conflict the way saudi arabia is so iran's end goal in the region is to be able to use all of these um proxies to their for their revisionist goal thank you from len levin is the conflict in yemen a major result of a religious dispute between shia and sunni religious groups that is a really interesting question i would say less so the houthis of course are very problematic very scary some of the when they take over territory they have imposed draconian uh wahabi style laws um and uh and uh public codes there governing things like how women can dress i mean in some places they even i remember a story i can't remember the province that this happened in but but when they took over the houthis tried to block access to birth control for women so they definitely come at

16:45 this with this sort of extremist totalitarian religious but that's what the houthis are bringing to their to the conflict and if we look at the houthis um motto if you will it's like death to curse israel death to the jews victory to islam missing a couple other freezes but i've said enough for you to get the gist i think that's where the houthis come from i'm not so certain that the rest of yemeni society would fall into that sunni versus shia battle but of course if you look at it from the geopolitical perspective when you take a step back then but there's the argument people have made it that it's you know iran and the shias versus saudi arabia and the sunni-led bloc so i mean that's that's a dynamic that is interesting to consider for sure thank you from raymond stock a very interesting presentation thank you uh what is the situation with the sunni islamist groups such as the muslim brotherhood and is in al qaeda in yemen

17:48 and what is their relationship with the various factions within the country yeah that's a really good question the houthis do have some links the yemeni government has some links with the muslim brotherhood and in the earlier stages of the war this was um the conflict was allowing al-qaeda and the arabian peninsula to thrive they established the emirate that is one aspect where the u.s continues to maintain a presence so even after uh by the administration's announcement that the us is ending offensive offensive support to the war in yemen which i think is kind of broadly defined um they are not pulling back from counterterrorism and counterintelligence so i think that's i bring that point up to say that the um any in any vacuum there's the ability terrorist groups to resurge to re-emerge and to thrive so i think there's a good awareness on all sides that there's almost two parallel battles in yemen one's obviously what's going on the houthis saudi arabia and iran but then the other is the implications that

18:51 this could have on um for other extremist groups in the and it makes it a very complicated situation when you are trying to fight two battles at the same time interested thank you so from robert slater if yemen were a true democracy would the houthis be in control that is an interesting question i'm not i'm not certain i don't think we've ever seen yemen be a true democracy so um part of it is just not having a precedent to go off of i don't think that i mean the houthis are not great people like i i want to go back to their war crimes they are not good to their fellow um their fellow yemenis i don't think that there's a lot of of um a love harbored amongst yemenis and certainly when you look at when you look at yemen and some you look at how this used to be two countries it reunited in the 90s those divisions didn't went away it didn't go away it's a very um tribalistic society still i think that there's a lot of um a lot of different factors on the ground i'm not an

19:52 expert of yemen itself it is a fascinating country i could spend all day looking at yemeni society politics tribal power power arrangements and all of that i look at the war more from the geopolitical perspective so i would say that it's a very interesting question and certainly of a hypothetical to think about thank you again from arnold do you see a danger of iron extending its influence from the persian gulf to the red sea and through syria and lebanon so as to surround saudi arabia israel and jordan that's exactly what it's trying to do right i mean we talked about the shia crescent that iran had been building through the word um through syria and lebanon and then the houthis are also another opportunistic way for them to extend their influence to the other side it is all about again their preventious goals and it is all about their hegemonic ambitions in the region and all of these different um all of these different like syria and lebanon and yemen they're all pressure points

20:55 that iran can leverage they are all um uh they can tap into disaffected segments of society and in all of these countries in order to um better extend their leverage and encircle saudi arabia so do you think that the u.s should be helping out saudi arabia or hindering them a bit in the fight of the houthis well i think that depends on so we got to take a step back and look at what is the goal here there is no military solution so whatever u.s assistance is given it will not help to create a military solution that's what the houthis think can happen they think that they can win the war on military terms but that is just not possible and it's something that analysts have been saying since the war began is that there is no military solution to this i think that the best role forward for the us is to maintain both the carrot and a stick approach at the moment i do believe we have surrendered all of our sticks again valid reason to delist the houthis from

21:58 humanitarian perspectives but the de facto result is that we don't have a whole lot of leverage that we can use against the houthis as a result and it's a very difficult tricky situation for our policymakers to be in right now but i think the u.s has done a good job definitely continuing support with it was the uae that was mostly leading a lot of the counterterrorism operations the u.s is doing the job of continuing and maintaining support for that um the us has has tried to help saudi targeting where it can so it has logistical and training courses to get saudi capacity further up and so i think the u.s has has played the best role that it can thus far again the question is just what other sticks can we can we put into our arsenal to try to get um more of a political solution try to get more momentum behind a political solution because we really are at an inflection point right now we have been since covent started saudi arabia is to wind down this war it's eager to seek

23:01 an off-ramp it knows that it has just um it wants to staunch the bleeding basically both in terms of what it's doing to its international reputation but also the fleecing it's getting in us domestic politics with the growing cadre of voices um that insistent that relations be broken with saudi arabia that haven't been said man become persona non grata et cetera so they are eager to repair the damage at the same time they have very real and valid security concerns in yemen with the houthis that i think sometimes other sides of u.s policymakers do not fully um discuss in the public sphere and then you've got um you've got the us's own interests too to go back to the shipping question that somebody had asked earlier and this is a key part of the world to key corridor for global trade so you've got all of these different dynamics in the mix and i think it's been um the us has done a good job of giving support to its allies but also continuing to demand better prosecution of the war from saudi arabia and giving its assistance where

24:03 it can where we really hit a wall is with the houthis because we we don't have leverage over them to get them to do something to get them to come to the table but it's been clear since april 2020 when saudi arabia began implementing these unilateral ceasefires that the houthis rejected quite literally shot up um that the us and saudi arabia are more probably more aligned now than they have been at previous stages of the war in terms of seeking a diplomatic fantastic thank you is yeah uh this is from jr pride uh is yemen still divided north and south and how does this influence the yes it is but i would say it's more of maybe a societal or a de facto division and certainly you had um a few earlier into the war you had these stc southern transitional council also known as the hit of movement they were very aligned with the uae i um i'm not aware of what the stc uh there was a riyadh agreement i remember from a couple of years ago maybe a year ago

25:05 where essentially saudi arabia sought to smooth some tensions between its domestic partners so the southerners and then other factions of its allies in yemen like i said i do not follow um the granular level of the war because that is that that is i think that is a career in and of itself yemen is an absolutely fascinating fascinating place but what i think is quite obvious is it's going to be pretty hard to stitch the country back together after six years of war that has destroyed infrastructure facilities families and it has just really broken what was a state with limited state capacity so it's going to be quite hard to to stitch it back together in some sort of cohesive comprehensive way thank you and this next question involves uh does israel have a reason to be more favorable to either side in the dispute in yemen and does russia have any influence on or concern about the conflict in yemen as regards israel we are seeing an

26:09 interesting time in the middle east with the rise of the abrahamic courts i certainly think saudi arabia supports the abraham accords otherwise bahrain would not have normalized but he intends to be the gcc state that serves as the bell weather for um for for the region so i do think that there's tacit and implicit saudi support for israel definitely growing by the day even in public salman has made statements where he has not shied away from embracing uh israel's role in the region as an economic powerhouse and from looking at how saudi arabia could tap into the the startup nation model for its own economic diversification goals so i think there's definitely that angle i am less certain about although of course i think with the return of great par competition that's why all of these states and these avenues are so important for us to continue being engaged in great part competition isn't going to play out in the east or else it's going to play out everywhere it's going to play out in all of our theaters and it's going to play out in the middle east which is really really really important for a

27:11 host of energy and commercial reasons so um russia has significant interest in libya it's got significant interests in it's creating a pipeline um so it's creating a um a transit network of pipelines um throughout like turkey uh that is just seeking to entrench its status as a gas exporter and a gas supplier so it's not a question we can side step and it just again to go back to what i had said earlier this is why us engagement in the region is so important and has to continue so six years later is there anything that can be done to end this i think it just depends on it comes down to the houthis truly i there was a time previously where i don't think you saw this level of willingness to engage from saudi arabia and then that has completely shifted they're so eager to tamp the war down that is a big shift in the dynamics of the conflict

28:13 but an equally bigger shift is also the houthis um desire now to lock in military gains i mean they think that they have nothing to lose they don't see any sources of leverage piled against them and if they were to capture adam that would be they look at mata sort of as like their crown jewel that would to them they think it would change the nature of the math and and just give them a really good upper hand going into negotiations so it comes back to what are our sources of leverage and at this point i'm i'm not so sure i'm interested thank you so much in our last minute here can you tell us where we can find some more of your work yeah sure so you can feel free to visit the fdd website um but you'll find all of my work there i'm also on twitter it's just at first name last name and i sometimes uh tweet about yemen increasingly more so now but like i said i i cover the gulf states specifically so all six of the gulf cooperation council

29:16 so my view of the war in yemen is just influenced by my tiny perch of gulf geopolitics and saudi but uh yemen is i think i also know we're just saying that yemen is a beautiful country it's such a historic country and um i i fear losing it for a generation or more if we're not able to if we're not able to stop the war in its tracks it's already gone on for for six extremely long years okay well thank you so much it comes with the clothes for our webinar i thank you again varsha for taking time to speak with us today my pleasure thank you all for having me and thank you for joining me today thank you for our viewers and listeners please be on the lookout for our weekly webinars offering email coming out over the weekend thank you all for joining us and i hope you have a great day thank you