MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Israel Insider

Israel Insider with Ashley Perry

Watch Israel Insider with Ashley Perry on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

The judicial reform debate continues, despite the Knesset summer recess, leading to increased security and financial problems. Who is to blame? Is compromise possible?

Transcript Automatic captions

Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 27, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.

0:07 and welcome to the Middle East forums webinar and podcast series Israel Insider with Ashley Perry I'm Stacy Roman and I will be moderating this discussion today we are pleased to have Ashley Perry advised advisor to the Middle East forums Israel office join us this week to update us on the top events going on in Israel Mr Perry will be giving us a briefing on current Israeli Affairs for 15 minutes and open it up for questions should you wish to ask a question please use the Q a box located at the bottom of the screen to type your question with that I'll turn the discussion over to Mr Ashley Perry thank you thank you very much Stacy and good evening from Israel um it's the middle of the summer as it is uh pretty much all over well the Northern Hemisphere let's say um and one would think especially with the heat wave that Israel has been experiencing the last few weeks um issues would sort of be on the back burner people are out vacationing or you know going on on holiday abroad in Israel even the netanyahuas have allowed

1:11 themselves to go on holiday I believe they're going uh next week but obviously even that is not without controversy they're going to a little town uh sort of holiday resorts in the north and there's already been a lot of controversy with the fact that there's going to be demonstrations outside there's been drones above and there's uh people who are basically reminding Netanyahu that they demand you know him to act against the judicial reform and all sorts of things and people who believe that he's a as the statement say a liar a cheater dictator all sorts of things and even from within the village itself there's a lot of controversy because one can imagine the security headache of having the Prime Minister uh visit so the security barriers everywhere and Farmers can't get to their fields etc etc so even for uh Netanyahu a holiday or vacation it's not without controversy but

2:13 um if he does go on holiday and it's already been put back a day or so uh he certainly uh you know uh needs one because uh again even in the midst and the depths of the summer Netanyahu is still dealing with some major major issues the knesset is is is off uh for the for the next couple of months you know the government is still working obviously the ministers are still working but a lot of them also on vacation holiday but uh uh what I've seen in the last week or so I don't think I've seen uh in long while and what I mean by that is he's really having to deal with issues far beyond his regular uh schedule um I'm a member of the government press office media list which basically whenever there's a statement by a minister or prime minister or president it goes up there and is translated to English and it's sent out and usually it's a reaction to an event or some speech that is given or some signing or something or an agreement or whatever it

3:16 but you know there's something big coming when it just says statement from the Prime Minister without saying at the event today of prime minister Netanyahu said when it just comes as a statement from the Prime Minister it's something he wants to get off his chest that something he wants to get out it's something he feels he needs to deal with and usually get one every so often I think there's been about four or five if not more over the last week because he's really had to deal with uh you know let's categorize them into three major issues the first one is the economy uh the second one is to do a security issue the idea of Readiness and the third one is let's say religious coercion stroke um conscription Bill and basically on all three issues really depending on where you've sit ideologically politically you'll see these things in drastically different ways and I'll go through each one and explain what the differences of opinions are let's start with the economy ever since uh this government started down the road of

4:19 judicial reform there's been warnings uh that the economy will be drastically hit should some of the reforms go through um especially in the high-tech industry one can imagine the high tech industry massively centered around Tel Aviv most of the again it's a bit of a generalization but it there is some truth to it that many people at the higher levels of the high tech industry from the left are people who didn't necessarily Vote for This government are from the Tel Aviv wider Tel Aviv area um there has been even protests specifically by high-tech people I think there was even a strike at one point if my memory serves me at one point there was a day where high tech people didn't go in or for a few hours but as it's a private uh sort of profession obviously they can't strike too much um but basically there's there's been warning of a brain drain or money going elsewhere people not wanting to invest in Israel with all the uncertainty with

5:21 all the demonstrations the accusations back and forth are that it's the reforms that is bringing uh the economy down and others say no it's actually the reaction to the performances the demonstrations which bring this uncertainty and a lot of people on both sides uh of the debate have been using international commentators International economic ratings uh institutions like fiction moodies Etc whenever they've mentioned anything about the uncertainty around the judicial reform one side has used that to say well look you know the international economic experts are saying that they you know you can't be touching this because it will hurt um the economy well this week one of the international credit ratings uh uh organizations left Israel with an A-Plus grading uh Netanyahu put out at least two press releases lauding that saying look this is the real truth Israel is not harmed by what is going on and the

6:27 international credit rating industry which are very sensitive to changes and uncertainty are basically giving Israel top marks obviously the uh The Wider picture of it it did mention the judicial reform it did mention the fact that it could impact on Israel's economy and Assessments in the future but um this particular one did you know give Israel a very high grade if you speak to people in that high-tech bubble if you speak to people in Tel Aviv they'll all tell you I had many conversations over the summer with with people from there and they also that they know people are leaving the country they know people who are taking their Investments elsewhere according to a an article that came out today 80 percent of high-tech companies newly registered high-tech companies in Israel are being registered in the US and not being and not in Israel now some say that that's because the US especially I think it's the state of Delaware or something like that are giving much better conditions and it's not really to do with the Israeli

7:28 economy it's just some states in the US are willing to give better conditions for new startups so again depending on where you've sit on it you see the situation is incredibly dire if you're against the judicial reform if you're against this government and this government is trying to to show now the situation isn't as bad as they make out in fact the some of the international commentators say Israel's doing very well and if there is a dip and clearly there is at least a certain amount of inflation you know the price of living cost of living keeps on going up they keep on raising the interest rates etc etc some of these are obviously connected to Global events but they would say that if there is a dip it's a short term that the long-term uh you know longevity of the Israeli economy is good Etc et cetera so again depending on where you sit depending how you look at that the idea uh has really come into the debate uh in a way probably at least in recent years

8:33 in an unprecedented way on an issue unrelated really to the idea of insecurity and that is the judicial reform and the fact that many reservists uh basically at first they just threatened uh and now it seems that they've followed through on it and are not turning up for their annual service Israelis up to a certain age had to do the annual service for a few weeks up to amount depending on what unit you are and at first there were all the signature uh signatures and all these petitions that were basically saying that um that we're not going to come and serve so they weren't really taken that seriously a lot of them were elderly and retirees etc etc but it is clear in recent weeks this has changed and there have been uh substantial uh lack of people coming forward again it's not the majority it's not even a pair reality but it does hurt certain units certain units especially to do with Israel's Readiness to deal with threats uh near and far and those are in the Air Force

9:38 where they say a significant number of their experience and high-level Pilots have not showed up for service and in the intelligence units now the regular sort of special units and the Armed Forces or the ground forces I should say have not been affected uh it is said because there are so many of them but there's also to a certain extent a little bit more of a tilt towards the right wing amongst some of those sort of services whereas the intelligence and the Air Force are more let's say tilted again it's I'm generalizing but there's more of a tilt to the left so those are the units they're going to be more and more harmed now the question is how far have we come uh is the IDF facing a a situation where they are not ready um for a washer to come a conflict a war even that attacks that is very much Up For Debate but it is clear that the IDF senior price are extremely concerned about this situation they spoke publicly semi-publicly they they spoke in the knesset and there's been as a result of that massive attacks from

10:43 um the right-wing members of the government they basically said that the idea shouldn't be involved they should be making these public statements they should be talking about this but it's clear that they believe that they're not being listened to and it got to a point on Sunday where Netanyahu shouted this is what was reported at the idea of chief of staff and the head of the Air Force saying you're making it look like the Army is running the country you know I can't have it like that I can't let it be seen by some really apparently shouted it obviously that was denied by netanyahua's office but many other people who were involved in the conversation claim that there it was extremely heated because the idea of wanted to give this message that's you know at the moment it hasn't impacted too much but it probably will in the autumn in the fall that's the message that's going around you can see sometimes by the people who are set up for the media how close they are to the IDF current uh Old-Timers without too many connections to the current IDF

11:48 senior echelons you can see who is saying what and what the messages are to see a little bit what the truth is and it does seem where a couple of months ago it was more threat than anything else it does seem to be really being the echelons in a major way at the moment and there is a concern that Israel will not have the full capacity to be able to fight on you know a major fund at this point the last major issue which is doing the rounds at the moment is the the issue of religious coercion now it should be said for those who don't know it's really that well that uh there's a time in the Summer where the issue the ultra Orthodox yeshivots are out for a break it's called Bennett's money where they get a month between uh Tisha ba'av and the first of all the month of Elo which is tonight so this is when the ultra-orthodoxy shoe won't go back but during those few weeks they're running the country any tourist spot to any uh sort of nature walk or any amusement

12:52 park will be just absolutely full of Orthodox and what has been seen the last couple of weeks it's not to say we haven't seen it previously maybe there's more of a noise this year because of everything else that's happening but we've seen a lot more cases of women who have not been able to get on buses or women have been sent to the back of buses or women have been told or men have been told that these are Ultra Orthodox only seems to happen quite a lot in our studs where there's been a major influx of ultra-orthodox specifically there there was also a story on the news about United Airlines was asked to move see it's it's unclear except what happened she claims it's because she was a woman whereas the the haridi man involved said had nothing to do with I said next to uh women all the time I just wanted my son and their friend to sit together so I calmly asked her so there's a bit of a debate about that but it shows that there's a major major sensitivity uh at this time partly another major issue which is the haridi conscription idea of conscription pill

13:55 now six years ago the uh the high court the Supreme Court asked the government to deal with this issue because the idea that it just sort of is left where a certain sector of the population just simply doesn't show up for service and is not being asked to show up for service is considered difficult um for six years they kept on asking for more more delay to deal with this issue and it's clear that with a strong Ultra Orthodox station in a pretty conservative government uh that they want say that this is really something that we want to deal with and that is Major um uh sort of propulsions from the ultra Orthodox Community why they support and want to in some ways other some of the bigger supporters of judicial reform because they believe that uh um if they manage to uh pass an override law or whatever it is then they will be able to pass laws which have uh been

14:58 struck down in the past by the Supreme Court as unequitable and reasonable perhaps or or any other reasons um so the this is coming up there's a debate now within the Coalition should we move ahead with the reform uh should we put it off for six months should we put off for a year that's a discussion between Netanyahu and Justice Minister Levine but the ultra Orthodox have threatened not to support any more uh bills until the idea of conscription law that I idea of conscription which means that they will finally put into law uh what has always been sort of practice where the uh Ultra Orthodox do not serve in the Army and that is considered uh a red line for many in Israel that you're actually putting into law and unequal and uneven uh demand um from the country's citizens where some people have to serve their country uh and serve in the Army others will simply not uh so that is a major major issue coming up two more issues before we go to some questions uh Hezbollah the

16:03 friction in the north is is heating up a lot of people I've talked about maybe there'll be some sort of conflict collaboration in in the north um during the summer as we've seen previously Wars conflicts tend to happen in the summer in Israel with either girls or Lebanon and we saw the director general of Hezbollah uh give a very bellicose uh Speech as he always does on the anniversary of the Lebanon second Lebanon war which they claimed that they won um and basically interestingly he did um to the issue of whether the idea is ready he said that the IDF is in a worse State than this ever been and interesting enough he also talked about the ultra Orthodox conscription or he said if that passes then Israel is over the IDF is in real trouble interestingly uh you know taking a position against Netanyahu on that showing once again that naturale particular really does follow what's going on uh in Israel

17:07 um so we'll see what happens but definitely physical I seemed to be um you know poking the eye of Israel this government Netanyahu and he'll continue to do so partly for internal um but also perhaps they want to get into some sort of uh fight um defense minister your Gallant spoke earlier the week that if if Hezbollah does try anything he will send Lebanon back to the Stone Age this is the kind of rhetoric we've heard in the past and we heard uh nasarana say exactly the same thing about Israel you know it won't just be us sent back to the Stone Age he threatened finally um back to judicial reform it doesn't leave the headlines even even in the summer uh when it is not being dealt with in the knesset uh interestingly enough the Attorney General uh who is herself the subject of a lot of uh attacks from this government uh and some of the reform bills that have been suggested would clip her wings or take away part of her position some are

18:10 according to fire her she is basically um she has a few different positions one of them is supposed to defend the government the Supreme Court um on certain issues but there there is the right of the Attorney General if they feel that they cannot defend the government from a certain issue they can recluse themselves and then the government can take a private attorney to represent them and that's what's happening the reasonableness um hearings which are upcoming in September the Attorney General said that she cannot defend the government and has given mission for the government for justice Minister Levin specifically to bring in a private attorney so uh this is interesting because it already shows at least part of the legal system is already basically saying that there could be a major problem with it and one has to remember on this point that it was passed as a basic law and the Supreme Court gave it gave basic laws quasi-constitutional power which means and and they have never ever struck down

19:14 a basic law so this would be unprecedented but certainly the signs are not good for the government uh it's going to be a full bench but it is going to be without the uh the Attorney General defending the government on this so I have to wait till September to see how this plays out and with that I'm happy to answer any questions all right thank you so much so uh Going Back to Basics here Don Sable asks uh what exactly was the original knesset override of the Supreme Court legislation that was being discussed uh what became of it how has it changed and um you did mention this already but is the issue something the Coalition has publicly put on hold for now um yeah I mean the override was probably considered the most extreme parts of the judicial reform which basically gave the government the ability of the knesset uh the ability to override um a situation where the Supreme Court has shut down a particular law uh it's basically given itself the right to then

20:17 ignore that and obviously that would be controversial because it basically completely nullifies the Supreme Court again depending how strong it was if it was on all issues or certain issues and importantly what majority you need the original override Bill uh basically had a majority 61. there are those who say you know if you could make it up to 80 which means you always have to bring in at least some of the opposition then that would be fairer but it does seem that that's off the table for the moment Netanyahu when he talks about all the different stages at the moment now that the reason on business law has passed the only one that he said is still really on the table is to change uh the makeup of the committee for the judicial the judicial selection committee to make it more weighted towards the the you know the the uh democratically elected representatives as opposed to the judicial system itself which at this point which had this moment has the

21:20 majority to basically uh assign itself like-minded people um that's the only one that he's really really uh talking about the override is very important for the Orthodox we spoke about that a little bit earlier because if the Supreme Court does strike down for example their idea of conscription law they want the ability to basically override that decision and that's why that particular law is very important uh for them but at the moment because it's the most extreme version probably it's the one that rankles the most uh by opposition because it basically would neuter the Supreme Court in a way that all the other parts wouldn't do to that that same extent so I doubt that there'll be an override pause and it certainly won't be as Extreme as the original tabled version which basically gives this government an opportunity to do it anytime they want if it just has a 61 majority contained within the bill thank you very much for that uh so going

22:23 back to your comments on the the issues with the buses and the airplane uh how Terror Taurus uh do you think women's rights are being eroded in Israel and if so does this affect your attitude about the defense of Israel and if so how well now officially women's rights are not being eroded netanyahua came out again in one of these statements uh saying that absolutely he rejects this he said that there is no place for that and there's no legal basis for that so officially it's absolutely forbidden to do so but it's clear that there are certain lines uh bus lines I should say uh which do this in practice are they allowed to it's not clear like you know I watch something on the news just before and you know if it's a private pass employed by the ultra Orthodox community and that is something which they themselves have um which is not for the general public I I don't know the law but maybe that is more of a less of a problem legally than

23:28 a public uh Agate bus again is the national bus service um that basically doesn't allow uh women on or won't allow women on with uh you know what they consider immortalous clothing or will make women sit at the back again it's a relatively minor phenomenon but it's the kind of thing that makes a lot of headlines and a lot of noise uh obviously legally you know the status of women has not been eroded um legally but the ultra-orthodox are certainly uh becoming more prominent in certain areas they're asking for more separate beaches there was a hold of debate a week or so ago because the it's an environment I mean so one of the ministers in Israel I think she's the environment Minister basically asked for certain Springs you know a lot of people in Israel like to visit Springs in the summer you know small sort of uh offsprings sort of rivers or whatever um and there there was talk of also having separate hours for men and women

24:32 at some of these Springs um which has never been there and and legal again the Attorney General had to get involved and she said there's no legislation to support that if you legislate that's another issue but of course she was attacked for the fact that she uh wouldn't allow it so at the moment there is not going to be that and I doubt that there is the real stomach in this government to to fight over something as relatively minor as that but the issue does keep raising yourself at the moment there's nothing official there's no law being passed or anything like that but there are certain areas certainly where the ultra-orthodox community are prominent where they themselves will sort of insist on Separation on the buses and if someone not from that Community wants to get on a bus sometimes they've been harassed but it's at the personal level so the communal level it's not at the national level so the women's rights are not being eroded but certainly um there seem to be again especially at this time of year ultra-orthodox are out and about a lot more uh there's always always these stories uh perhaps they're

25:35 more prominent this year perhaps there's more this year it's hard to tell because obviously there's no statistics but they seem to be getting more prominence in uh in the media certainly thank you very much Larry Greenberg asked since the reform issue has flared up has Aliyah been um from what I have been reading not necessarily they've gone down earlier numbers have gone down a little bit to pre-covered levels uh during covert they went up uh perhaps because Israel it was thought that Israel was doing very well with covid and uh and things like that uh so Alia numbers did go up during covid and now I think they've pretty much gone down to pre-covered levels so it hasn't really been affects too much uh By the judicial reform uh as far as I can tell and also as far as tourism incoming tourism again I haven't seen statistics obviously the government want to play up if there is as far as I can see being around the country over the last week there's a lot of tourists in

26:38 the country um so I don't know if there are people who are not coming to Israel because of the judicial reform uh as far as I know the numbers haven't been largely affected by judicial reform but perhaps we'll have to see next year because you know people don't decide to make Alia from one day to the next usually they make it half a year a year in advance so perhaps we'll see in the coming years whether there is an effect uh by the judicial reform yeah absolutely good point uh Stephen uh although the reasonableness legislation was passed as a basic law uh what occurs if the Supreme Court rejects it as it seems the AG has suggested they should well he hasn't said that they should he just she just said um that she cannot defend it she hasn't said that it shouldn't pass she just will has said that she will not defended um basically the answer is it'll be a constitutional crisis and people are

27:40 talking about this at the moment for example the National Security manage uh Minister uh is at odds with the police uh commissioner because the police commissioner said that he would obey the law if the Supreme Court strikes it down then simply it won't exist anymore whereas the national security minister part of this present government said well you should support the government's position on this uh it will be unprecedented to have such a situation uh we don't know exactly what's going to happen Netanyahu keeps his answer to that is we are nation of laws we have to be upheld but you could argue both sides again depending where you come down if you're a proponent of judicial reform you say well the government passed a law and it's a basic law which has never been touched so that's the will of the majority uh Representatives democratically elected representatives in the knesset whereas the opponents would say yes but it's it's it's a law which is undemocratic and if the Supreme Court which has the right to strike down

28:45 um then the government should accept that so it'll be unprecedented it will be very problematic if it is struck down uh unless of course immediately it is dropped down the government accept that decision which at the moment certainly there'll be certain members of the government who will have a problem with but the tone will be set by the Prime Minister uh so I guess um hopefully prime minister Netanyahu will have a position either way and will lead with that and whatever he says hopefully you know the government will fall in line and hopefully there will be no constitutional crisis but there is great potential for that uh at the end of this uh hearing but again that's that's next month so we'll have to see what happens with that thank you and our last minute here Doris rosstrausas uh could you please comment on the light rail running on Shabbat what the moment it's not running I'm sure that uh uh that's the decision was made by this government it just opened today officially there was a whole big uh

29:47 opening ceremony obviously Israel being Israel there was there was uh problems even at the opening but it is a major achievement of the like Railway in the whole Tel Aviv region it's not just in the city of Tel Aviv it's for sure mercion is so many of the uh the areas around so it is a big achievement but it is being clouded by the fellow it's not going to run on Shabbat as a result the mayor of Tel Aviv uh boycotted the event uh for D don't forget there's Municipal elections in a few months so it certainly plays into his base which is largely secular left wing uh to not turn up to this event and to take a stand on it but again it also goes into that whole sort of debate religious coercions it should Israel's a Jewish State have laws like this at the moment public transport in most places there isn't public transport in most uh places there are in some like about but at the moment the decision is not to have the like Railway largely because we have a more conservative more

30:49 religious uh government obviously if if we have the previous government and it opened then they almost certainly would have allowed it to be on Shabbat maybe in the future it will be again but at the moment it's it's not on Shabbat um so have to have to wait and see on that but uh it's that's that's what they're basically starting uh with it being a six day service all right thank you so much so we've come to the close of our webinar and podcasts Ashley thank you for taking time to update us this week for our viewers and listeners please join us Friday at 1pm Eastern for webinar with Greg Roman just on defining U.S policy towards the Azerbaijan Armenian conflict thank you all for joining us and I hope you have a wonderful day