MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Media Interview

Michael Rubin on Ceasefire (C-SPAN): What Comes Next for Iran?

Watch Michael Rubin on Ceasefire (C-SPAN): What Comes Next for Iran? on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

Michael Rubin, director of policy analysis at Middle East Forum, joins Ceasefire alongside David Satterfield for a wide-ranging discussion with Dasha Burns on Iran, military pressure, regime stability, and what Washington may be underestimating.

Rubin argues that Iran’s ideological structure makes conventional dealmaking unreliable and warns that military gains do not resolve the harder question of political succession. Satterfield emphasizes that degrading nuclear and missile capabilities may be achievable, but shaping what follows inside Iran is far less predictable.

The conversation also examines Trump’s approach to Iran, comparisons to Iraq, regional reactions from Gulf states and Turkey, and whether diplomacy with Tehran had already reached its limits.

#MichaelRubin #Iran #CSPAN

Transcript Captions uploaded by MEF

Source: Captions uploaded by MEF from YouTube, retrieved October 15, 2026.

0:04 DASHA: WELCOME TO "CEASEFIRE" WHERE WE LOOK TO BRIDGE THE DIVIDE AND AMERICAN POLITICS. I AM DASHA BURNS AND TODAY I'M JOINED BY TWO GUESTS WITH EXTENSIVE FOREIGN POLICY ACROSS MULTIPLE PRESIDENTIAL ADMINISTRATIONS. MICHAEL RUBIN, ADVISOR FOR IRAN AND IRAQ UNDER THE GEORGE W. BUSH ADMINISTRATION AND AMBASSADOR DAVID SATTERFIELD, FORMER BIDEN MIDDLE EAST ENVOY AND FORMER AMBASSADOR TO TURKEY AND LEBANON IN BOTH DEMOCRATIC AND REPUBLICAN ADMINISTRATIONS.

0:40 I'M GLAD TO HAVE YOU THIS WEEK IN PARTICULAR. YOU BOTH HAVE POOR -- FOR A POLY EXPERTISE AND YOU HAVE ADVISED PRESIDENTS SPECIFICALLY ON THE MIDDLE EAST. I WANT TO START WITH YOUR EXPERIENCE AND HOW IT CREATES A LENS FOR YOU TO SAY -- TO SEE TODAY'S ACTIONS BY THIS ADMINISTRATION. DAVID: IN MY CAREER WITH THE GOVERNMENT AND THE FOREIGN SERVICE BEGAN WITH THE IRAN REVOLUTION AND THE HOSTAGE TAKING IN NOVEMBER, 1979. SINCE THEN, FOR ALMOST HALF A CENTURY, IRAN HAS BEEN A SOURCE OF INSTABILITY, THREAT, PRESUMED HEGEMONY OVER ITS ARAB NEIGHBORS AND OVER THE BROADER NON-ARAB REGION.

1:26 IT IS A THREAT THAT HAS PROJECTED TO THE FAR CORNERS OF THE WORLD THROUGH ITS PROXIES INTO LATIN AMERICA, EUROPE AND EVEN THE UNITED STATES. IT IS A THREAT WHICH TOOK ON A NEW DIMENSION SOME YEARS AGO WITH THE ACCELERATED PROGRESS BY IRAN TOWARDS AT LEAST THE CAPACITY TO HIGHLY ENRICHED URANIUM TO JUST SHORT OF NUCLEAR WEAPON GRADE. IT HAS ALSO BUILT DRAMATICALLY A BALLISTIC MISSILE FORCE CAPABLE OF AND DEMONSTRATED THROUGH USE OF THREATENING STATES FROM ISRAEL IN THE EASTERN MED THROUGH TO THE GREATER MIDDLE EAST IN ALL OF ITS DIMENSIONS.

2:05 IT IS A CHALLENGE THAT HAS BEEN DEALT WITH IN MANY DIFFERENT WAYS, DIPLOMATICALLY, KINETICALLY ON OCCASION BUT NEVER COMPREHENSIVELY. AND WE ADD TO THAT EXTERNAL CHALLENGE POSED BY THIS REGIME. WHAT THEY HAVE DONE TO THEIR OWN PEOPLE. IRAN HAS THIS CLERICAL REGIME HAS OVER A HALF-CENTURY DEPRIVED THE PEOPLE OF IRAN OF THE MOST BASIC SOURCES OF LIVELIHOOD. IT'S CORRUPTION, ITS GROTESQUE MANAGEMENT HAS LEFT IRANIANS IN A POSITION BEFORE THIS CAMPAIGN EVER STARTED, BEFORE LAST JUNE AND IT'S A TAX NOT IN A POSITION TO SERVE ITS OWN PEOPLE AND WHEN THE PEOPLE ROSE UP, THEY WERE MASSACRED THIS JANUARY.

2:49 SO WHAT WE ARE WATCHING IS THE RESPONSE TO FOUR DECADES PLUS OF DISASTROUS EXTERNAL AND INTERNAL POLICIES BY THIS CRIMINAL CORRUPT REGIME. DASHA: MICHAEL YOU HAVE ALSO SEEN SO MUCH DURING THE COURSE OF YOUR EXTENSIVE EXPERIENCE. HOW DOES THE PREVIOUS SERVICE INFORM HOW YOU VIEW THE CURRENT SITUATION? MICHAEL: I AGREE WITH WHAT DAVID HAS SAID. I USED TO LIVE IN THE ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF IRAN DOING MY DOCTORAL DISSERTATION OVER THERE DURING THE ROSS ON JOHNNY PERIOD.

3:28 IN GOVERNMENT AND OUT OF GOVERNMENT, WHAT I HAVE CONCLUDED IS THERE IS NO MAGIC FORMULA. OUR PREFECT -- POLITICAL DEBATE MIGHT HAVE THAT EACH SIDE HAS A MONOPOLY ON THE TRUTH BUT IN REALITY THE WORLD IS COMPLICATED. IF WE HAD A MAGIC SOLUTION, IT WOULD HAVE BEEN FOUND ALREADY. I AM REMINDED OF AN OLD SOVIET JOKE ABOUT THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE OPTIMIST AND THE PESSIMIST. THE RUSSIAN PESSIMIST SAYS THINGS HAVE NEVER BEEN SO BAD AND COULD NOT GET WORSE ON THE RUSSIAN OPTIMIST SAYS, NO, THEY CAN ALWAYS GET WORSE.

4:03 WE MIGHT NOW BE IN THAT SITUATION WHEN WE LOOK AT WHAT IS HAPPENING IN THE ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF IRAN ESPECIALLY IF OUR PLANNING MOVING FORWARD IS NOT UP TO SNUFF. DASHA: YOU WERE AN ADVISOR TO DONALD RUMSFELD DURING THE BUSH ADMINISTRATION. WHAT AMERICA WAS INVOLVED IN IN IRAN AND IRAQ, THE IRAQ AND AFGHANISTAN WARS ARE CONFLICTS THAT AMERICANS EQUATE TO FOREVER WARS. WHAT ARE LESSONS LEARNED FROM THAT ERA THAT CAN BE APPLIED TO TODAY?

4:35 MICHAEL: WHAT WE ENCAPSULATE AS THE IRAQ WAR WAS A SERIES OF SPECIFIC POLICY DECISIONS. NUMBER ONE WAS WHETHER OR NOT TO GO TO WAR. NUMBER TWO WAS WHETHER WE SHOULD TRY TO MAKE IRAQ INTO A DEMOCRACY OR SIMPLY REPLACE SADDAM HUSSEIN WITH ANOTHER DICTATOR. AND THE THIRD POLICY QUESTION WAS WHETHER WE SHOULD BE ENGAGED IN NATION BUILDING, IN DEVELOPMENT AND SO FORTH. DONALD TRUMP IT APPEARS HAS TAKEN A DIFFERENT APPROACH WHEN IT COMES TO IRAN.

5:09 MUCH MORE ATTUNED TO THE VENEZUELA MODEL. AS AN ANALYST WHEN I LOOK WHO OUR MOMS ARE KILLING I'M MORE INTERESTED IN WHO OUR BOMBS ARE NOT TARGETING. ARE THEY ON THE B LIST FOR ELIMINATION OR IS THIS A SIGN OF PEOPLE THAT HAVE A FREE PASS BECAUSE DONALD TRUMP WANTS TO NEGOTIATE WITH THEM. I'M ALSO WORRIED ABOUT SOMETHING THAT CAME OUT OF THE IRAQ WAR AND THE LIBYA WAR WHICH IS HOW DO YOU SECURE THE ARMS DEPOT? IN 2007 THE REVOLUTIONARY GUARD DECIDED THE BIGGEST DANGER TO THE REGIME WOULD BE THE IRANIAN PEOPLE SO THEY PUT ONE REVOLUTIONARY GUARD UNIT IN EACH PROVINCE.

5:48 32 PROVINCES. WE HAD PLANS TO SECURE EACH OF THOSE ARMS DEPOTS AND IF YOU ARE GOING TO DO THAT, CAN YOU DO THAT WITHOUT BOOTS ON THE GROUND? ONE FINAL QUICK POINT -- AND DAVID REMEMBERS THIS BUT IN 2003 DURING THE IRAQ WAR, THERE WAS A CLERIC WHO CAME BACK IN ORDER TO TAKE OVER THE SHRINE. HE WAS SET UPON BY THUGS AND HACKED TO DEATH. WHEN PEOPLE ARE TALKING ABOUT SOMEONE BEING APPOINTED, MAYBE THE FORMER CROWN PRINCE, IT IS ONE THING TO MAKE THAT APPOINTMENT AND ANOTHER THING TO KEEP THAT PERSON ALIVE WITHOUT BOOTS ON THE GROUND.

6:25 THIS IS WHY I AM A RUSSIAN OPTIMIST. DASHA: DAVID, THE ADMINISTRATION KEEPS MAKING THE POINT THAT THIS IS NOT IRAQ, THIS IS NOT A U.S. INTERVENTION IN THE MIDDLE EAST OF ADMINISTRATIONS PAST. HOW DIFFERENT DO YOU SEE WHAT TRUMP IS DOING NOW COMPARED TO WHAT WE HAVE SEEN BEFORE? DAVID: LET ME BUILD ON ALL OF THE POINTS THAT MICHAEL JUST MADE. THERE ARE TWO GOALS WHICH ARE NOT JUST IN THEORY BUT QUITE LIKELY ACHIEVABLE BY THE USE OF STANDOFF ATTACKS BY ISRAEL AND BY THE UNITED STATES.

7:06 ONE IS THE FURTHER DEMOLISH MEANT SETTING BACK OF ANY NUCLEAR ENRICHMENT PROGRAM AND ALL OF THE ANCILLARY RESEARCH THAT SOUNDS. WE KNOW WHERE THE FACILITIES ARE THEY ARE ACCESSIBLE. THEY HAVE BEEN STRUCK AND WILL UNDOUBTEDLY BE STRUCK FURTHER. IRAN'S ABILITY TO PROJECT HAFT, STRATEGIC HAFT THROUGH ITS BALLISTIC MISSILE PROGRAM IS ALSO A MAJOR TARGET.

7:37 BRAD COOPER, THE HEAD OF CENTCOM HAS SAID 86% OF THE CAPACITY TO LAUNCH MISSILES HAS BEEN ELIMINATED. DRONES REMAIN A CHALLENGE BUT THEY ARE ALSO BEING TARGETED. YOU CAN COME TO A POINT IN THE PREDICTABLE FUTURE WHEN IRAN WILL NOT POSSESS THESE RESOURCES IN ANY STRATEGIC SENSE. WHAT YOU CANNOT PREDICTABLY ACHIEVE IS A DIRECTED REGIME CHANGE THAT SOMEHOW ESTABLISHES A VERY DIFFERENT BUT STILL COHERENT, NOT CHAOTIC WITH ARMS RELEASED INTO MANY HANDS, IRAN.

8:13 THAT IS A MUCH MORE DIFFICULT CHALLENGE. NOW IF WE WERE TALKING JUST THREE OR FOUR HOURS PREVIOUSLY, I WOULD HAVE ARGUED TO YOU THAT DONALD TRUMP HAS LEFT HIMSELF AS ARTICULATED AND OFFRAMP ON THIS WHICH IS THE ABILITY AT SOME POINT IN THE COMING DAYS OR A FEW WEEKS TO SAY, LOOK AT WHAT I HAVE DONE. I HAVE DEVASTATED THE RESOURCES OF THE SECURITY STAGE. IT IS NOW UP TO THE IRANIAN PEOPLE TO MAKE THEIR CHOICES. BUT THE PRESIDENT IN MEDIA INTERVIEWS IN THE LAST FEW HOURS HAS SAID, I WILL HAVE A ROLE IN THE SELECTION OF THE NEXT SUPREME LEADER.

8:51 DASHA: DAVID, HE ACTUALLY SAID THAT TO ME. HE SAID HE WILL HAVE A MAJOR IMPACT HERE AND HE IS TALKING TO PEOPLE IN THE REGIME AND THE PEOPLE OF IRAN IN THE OPPOSITION AND THAT HE WANTS TO HAVE MAJOR INFLUENCE HERE. MICHAEL: I DON'T KNOW HOW THIS TRANSLATES INTO ACTUAL IMPACT BECAUSE RIGHT NOW I DON'T THINK ANY IRANIAN INTERLOCUTOR, FOR THEIR OWN SAKE IS PREPARED TO ENTER INTO DEALING WITH THE UNITED STATES.

9:24 THAT COULD CHANGE IN THE WEEK AHEAD AS THEIR CALCULATIONS AND WHAT SERVES THEIR INTEREST MOVES. BUT THIS IS NOT VENEZUELA. WHERE YOU CAN DECAPITATE A SINGLE INDIVIDUAL AND THEIR SPOUSE, REMOVE THEM FROM THE COUNTRY AND ACHIEVE VERY SPECIFIC ECONOMIC GOALS AND LEAVE THE REGIME IN TACT. IRAN IS MUCH, MUCH MORE COMPLEX AS MICHAEL FULLY UNDERSTANDS. DASHA: I SPOKE TO THE PRESIDENT FOR ABOUT 12 MINUTES AND WE COVERED IRAN AND A LOT MORE THAN THAT -- THAT I WANT TO ASK YOU MORE ABOUT BUT HE DID KEEP COMPARING IRAN TO VENEZUELA.

9:59 AND HE WAS ALSO INCREDIBLY BULLISH ON THE COMBAT OPERATIONS IN IRAN SO FAR TELLING ME HE THINGS HE IS GOING TO ACHIEVE A BETTER RESULT THAN HE ANTICIPATED. ARE YOU AS BULLISH AS HE IS RIGHT NOW? DAVID: THE PRESIDENT HAS SAID HE IS AHEAD OF WHAT HE DETERMINED HAS SCHEDULED TO BE AND THAT IS BECAUSE NO ONE REALLY EXPECTED THE TARGETS TO BE TOGETHER ON THE FIRST DAY OF THE BOMBING CAMPAIGN. BUT AS AN ANALYST WHEN I LOOK AT THE WAY OUR GULF ARAB ALLIES INITIALLY SAT ON THE FENCE, THE WAY I INTERPRETED THAT IS WHEN YOU HAVE AHEARN -- A HORNETS NEST YOU HAVE TWO OPTIONS.

10:40 ONE IS LEAVE IT ALONE, THE OTHER IS TO GET RID OF IT BUT YOU DON'T WANT TO SIT UNDER IT LIGHTLY TAPPING IT WITH A STICK AND THEN WALK AWAY. THE RELUCTANCE OF OUR ARAB ALLIES TO GET INVOLVED I SAW AS A BAROMETER THAT THEY DID NOT THINK THAT DONALD TRUMP HAD FULLY DONE THE PLANNING TO BUILD THEIR OWN CONFIDENCE. THIS IS WHY I THINK IRAN MADE SUCH A HUGE MISTAKE BY STRIKING AT ALL OF THE ARAB ALLIES. AGAIN, I AGREE WITH DAVID ABOUT QATAR -- AND VENEZUELA BUT ONE OF THE INTERESTING SIDE NOTES INVOLVING THE MIDDLE EAST INVOLVING THE VENEZUELA SITUATION IS THAT DELCY RODRIGUEZ'S BROTHERS WERE NEGOTIATING WITH THE AMERICANS IN QATAR FOR A TIME BEFORE THE OPERATION INSIDE VENEZUELA.

11:26 I WONDER IF THERE HAS BEEN ANY OF THAT BACK CHANNEL. LAST TIME I WAS IN BAGHDAD I STAYED IN THE SAME PLACE AS THE SECRETARY OF THE SUPREME NATIONAL SECURITY COUNCIL. HE HAS SOMEONE WHOSE NAME HAS BEEN MENTIONED QUITE A BIT. USED TO BE IN THE REVOLUTIONARY GUARD AND THEN HE WAS AN ADVISOR TO THE SUPREME LEADER AND HIS DAUGHTER LIVES IN ATLANTA, GEORGIA. I WONDER IF THE SEEMING IMMUNIZATION HE HAS HAD OF ANY CONSEQUENCE IS AN INDICATION OF WHAT DONALD TRUMP IS THINKING MOVING FORWARD.

11:57 BUT DAVID HAS ALSO ARTICULATED THIS REGIME IS BRUTAL AND THE IRANIAN PUBLIC WILL NOT ACCEPT A REGIME QUISLING AFTER 40,000 PEOPLE HAVE BEEN MASSACRED IN THE STREETS. DASHA: SO WHAT DO YOU SEE AS THE NEXT VIABLE STEP IF THE PRESIDENT WANTS TO HAVE INFLUENCE OVER A REGIME CHANGE. HOW VIABLE IS THAT AND WHAT SHOULD THE WHITE HOUSE BE WARY OF RIGHT NOW? MICHAEL: MY CRITICISM OF DONALD TRUMP IS CONSISTENT ACROSS DIFFERENT AREAS. WHEN YOU ARE A REAL ESTATE DEVELOPER, EVERYTHING LOOKS LIKE A DEAL.

12:29 WHEN YOU'RE DEALING WITH THE ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF IRAN, THERE IS AN IDEOLOGY AT PLAY AND YOU CANNOT SIMPLY PROJECT OUR OWN UNDERSTANDING OF DEALMAKING ON PEOPLE WITH AN IDEOLOGY. YOU CAN GO TO THE REVELATION NORI GUARD DOUBLE WHEN YOU ARE EIGHT YEARS OLD BECAUSE THEY RUN THE EQUIVALENT OF PEOPLE BOY SCOUT PROGRAMS. THERE ARE CLUBS IN HIGH SCHOOL, IN UNIVERSITY. THEY RUN THEIR OWN UNIVERSITIES AND YOU CAN BE FULLY INDOCTRINATED. WHEN YOU'RE DEALING WITH PEOPLE THAT INDOCTRINATED SIMPLY WANTING TO BUILD BIG BUILDINGS OR HAVE A DEAL TO MAKE PEACE IS NOT GOING TO WORK.

13:06 ONE FINAL POINT, THE REASON DIPLOMACY WAS ALWAYS DOOMED -- IF YOU HAVE BEEN PRESIDENT AND THEN SUPREME LEADER, YOU HAVE ENCAPSULATED THE NUCLEAR PROGRAM. THE IRANIANS HAVE LOST UP TO $2 TRILLION IN SANCTIONS AND LOSS DEVELOPMENT. HOW WAS HE EVER GOING TO EXPLAIN TO HIS OWN PEOPLE THAT MADE THE SACRIFICE THAT THEIR SACRIFICE WAS WORTH IT IF HE SIGNED IT ALL THE WAY. THIS IS ONE OF THE REASONS WHY DIPLOMACY WAS HEDGING THE BRICK WALL. DASHA: PUTTING YOUR AMBASSADOR HAT BACK ON, THOSE COUNTRIES AND OTHERS ARE BEING DRAWN INTO THE CONFLICT.

13:43 NOT JUST IRAN BUT IT IS A REGIONAL CONFLICT. WHAT ARE YOUR CONCERNS AS THIS EXPANDS? DAVID: THEY ARE DIFFERENT. TURKEY, PRESIDENT ERDOGAN WILL BE VERY CAREFUL NOT TO BECOME DRAWN INTO THIS CONFLICT IN A WAY THAT EITHER ALIENATES DONALD TRUMP WHO IS A VITAL, PERSONAL CONNECTION, ALLY FOR PRESIDENT ERDOGAN AND ALSO PROMPT IRAN TO TARGET TURKIYE AS A HOSTILE SPEECH.

14:15 HE HAS BRIDGED THIS KIND OF ISSUE VERY ADROITLY WITH RUSSIA DURING THE COURSE OF THE UKRAINE CONFLICT IN WHICH HE HAS MAINTAINED A CRITICAL RELATIONSHIP WITH PUTIN WHILE CONTRIBUTING SIGNIFICANTLY TO THE ARMAMENT OF UKRAINE. LEBANON IS COMPLETELY DIFFERENT. BUT LOOK, LEBANON, AND HERE I GO TO MICHAEL'S POINT ABOUT IDEOLOGY TRIUMPHING OVER WHAT WE WOULD SAY IS RATIONAL JUDGMENT OR SELF-INTEREST. HEZBOLLAH HAD A CLEAR MESSAGE FROM THE ISRAELIS THAT THEY WERE NOT GOING TO STRIKE LEBANON.

14:50 UNLESS THEY WERE HIT BY HEZBOLLAH. VERY CLEAR. HEZBOLLAH SUICIDALLY LAUNCHED THREE MISSILES INTO THE GALILEE, TWO OF WHICH ENTERED EMPTY FIELDS AND THE THIRD WAS INTERCEPTED AND IN RESPONSE CAME THE CAMPAIGN THAT IS UNDERWAY AS WE SPEAK WITH THE LATEST ISRAELI DECLARATIONS CALLING FOR THE EVACUATIONS OF ALL OF LEBANON SOUTH OF LEAD COUNTY, FIVE HUNDRED THOUSAND PEOPLE AS WELL AS THE SO-CALLED SOUTHERN SUBURB OF BEIRUT CITY WHERE HEZBOLLAH'S HEADQUARTERS AND MANY ASSETS ARE LOCATED.

15:28 HEZBOLLAH BROUGHT THIS ON ITSELF. IS IT RATIONAL, SELF-INTERESTED? NO BUT IT IS THE PRODUCT OF IDEOLOGY, BOTH HEZBOLLAH'S AND IRAN'S. MICHAEL: COULD I ASK YOU A QUESTION ABOUT TURKEY BECAUSE WE ARE VIRTUALLY IN THE SAME ROOM? WHEN THE SUPREME LEADER WAS KILLED, ONLY TWO LEADERS WARNED HIM PUBLICLY, VLADIMIR PUTIN AND ERDOGAN. PRESIDENT ERDOGAN -- IS THIS SOMETHING SOMEONE HAS WHISPERED INTO DONALD TRUMP'S EAR SAYING MAYBE YOU SHOULD NOT TRUST THIS GUY AS MUCH OR WILL HE REMAIN THE PRESIDENT WHISPERER AND SEEMINGLY GET AWAY WITH EVERYTHING?

16:15 DAVID: HE SHOULD NOT BE SEPARATED FROM ERDOGAN. LOOK, THIS IS ERDOGAN IN HIS "I AM THE LEADER OF THE WORLD" MUSLIMS. THAT IS HIS PRESUMPTION OF AUTHORITY. HIS HOLY PRESUMPTION. THOSE KINDS OF REMARKS ARE NOT TAKEN ALL THAT SERIOUSLY. I DO NOT BELIEVE DONALD TRUMP REACTS TO THEM IN ANY MEANINGFUL, STRATEGIC FASHION.

16:50 HE IS STILL THE WHISPER. DASHA: LET'S TALK ABOUT THE JUSTIFICATION FOR THE ADMINISTRATION BECAUSE OFFICIALS BRIEFED MEMBERS OF CONGRESS ON COMBAT OPERATIONS AND EXPLAINED WHY THEY STRUCK IRAN PREEMPTIVELY. AND THEN COME AFTER AN INITIAL EXPLANATION PUBLICLY FROM MARCO RUBIO, HE THEN CLARIFIED THE FOLLOWING DAY. TAKE A LISTEN. >> THERE ABSOLUTELY WAS AN IMMINENT THREAT AND WE KNEW THAT IF IRAN WAS ATTACKED AND WE BELIEVE THEY WOULD'VE BEEN ATTACKED THEY WOULD IMMEDIATELY COME AFTER US.

17:29 WE WERE NOT GOING TO SIT THERE AND ABSORB A BLOW BEFORE WE RESPONDED. THE DEPARTMENT OF MORE ASSESS THAT IF WE WAITED FOR THEM TO HIT US FIRST AFTER THEY WERE ATTACKED BY SOMEONE ELSE, WE WAITED FOR THEM TO HIT US THAT WE WOULD SUFFER MORE CASUALTIES AND DEATHS. WE WENT PROACTIVELY IN A DEFENSIVE WAY TO PREVENT THEM FROM INFLICTING HIGHER DAMAGE. >> YESTERDAY YOU TOLD US ISRAEL WOULD STRIKE A RUN WHICH IS WHY WE NEEDED TO GET INVOLVED. TODAY THE PRESIDENT SAID -- I WAS ASKED VERY SPECIFICALLY -- SOMEONE ASKED ME DID WE GO IN BECAUSE OF ISRAEL.

18:19 I SAID, NO. THEY WILL NOT BE ALLOWED TO HIDE BEHIND THE ABILITY TO CONDUCT THE ATTACKS. DASHA: WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THESE RESPONSES FROM RUBIO AND WHAT WE HAVE HEARD OVERALL FROM THE ADMINISTRATION ABOUT THE JUSTIFICATION? MICHAEL: THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION FRANKLY -- THAT SAID, ONE ISSUE WE ARE NOT TALKING ABOUT BUT WHICH I THINK DETERMINED THE TIMING DOES SOME EXTENT, REMEMBER THAT IN APRIL AND OCTOBER OF 2024, ISRAEL ATTACKED IRAN AND TOOK OUT IRAN'S ANTI-AIR SYSTEM.

18:59 THE TIMING OF THE 12 DAY WAR IN JUNE, 2020 FIVE WAS DETERMINED BY IRAN RECONSTITUTING ITS AIR DEFENSE. WHEN WE TALK ABOUT DIPLOMACY AND ITS WINDOW, THE FACT THAT RUSSIANS WERE ANTIAIRCRAFT MISSILES TO IRAN AND THE CHINESE WERE TALKING ABOUT SHIPPING MISSILES, I THINK IT NARROWED THE WINDOW OF OPPORTUNITY. IT IS NOT ALL ABOUT ISRAEL AND THE UNITED STATES. WE ARE NOT THE ONLY PLAYERS IN THE SANDBOX. DASHA: DO YOU THINK ALL OTHER EFFORTS, DIPLOMATICALLY WERE EXHAUSTED HERE?

19:33 WHAT YOU MAKE OF THE ADMINISTRATION'S JUSTIFICATION? DAVID: I AGREE COMPLETELY WITH THE COMMENTS THAT MICHAEL MADE. THIS ADMINISTRATION HAS NOT EFFECTIVELY AND COHERENTLY AND BECAUSE INSTANTLY COMMUNICATED WHAT IS A GENUINE JUSTIFICATION FOR EFFORTS TO AT LEAST DRAMATICALLY MITIGATE THE THREAT FROM THE NUCLEAR ENRICHMENT PROGRAM AND THE MISSILES AND THE VERY REAL POTENTIAL -- IF NOT CERTAINTY -- THAT BOTH OF THOSE THREATS WOULD PROGRESSIVELY GROW WITH TIME WHETHER INDIGENOUS OR ASSISTED BY EXTERNAL ELEMENTS.

20:11 IT IS A COMMUNICATIONS PROBLEM OF A FUNDAMENTAL LEVEL. BUT, THE SUBSTANCE OF THE THREAT IS NOT SOMETHING I BELIEVE IS CHALLENGED AND I DON'T BELIEVE THERE WAS ANY DIPLOMATIC RESOLUTION POSSIBLE. INDEED, I THINK THE IRANIAN REGIME PROBABLY PREFERRED THAT THIS CAMPAIGN COME. THEY BELIEVE THEY WILL SURVIVED IT MUCH AS HAMAS WAS ALWAYS CONVINCED IT WOULD SURVIVE THE ISRAELI CAMPAIGN IN GAZA AND THEY WOULD EMERGE WITH A DIFFERENT SET OF OPTIONS BEFORE THEM THEN THEY POSSESSED BEFOREHAND.

20:45 MICHAEL: I THINK IT IS IMPORTANT TO DIFFERENTIATE BETWEEN THE AMERICAN THREAT PERCEPTION AND THE ISRAELI THREAT PERCEPTION. WHEN IT COMES TO AMERICA, OFTENTIMES CRITICS OF THIS ACTION NOW WILL SAY, LOOK, EVEN IF IRAN WENT NUCLEAR, THEY ARE NOT SUICIDAL. BUT FROM AN ISRAELI PRECEPTORSHIP, THAT WAS A STRAWMAN IDEA. IT WAS THAT THEY WERE TERMINALLY ILL. DASHA: LET ME PLAY FOR YOU BOTH A SOUNDBITE FROM DEMOCRATIC SENATOR MARK WARNER AFTER BEING BRIEFED BY SECRETARY RUBIO THIS WEEK AND IT TOUCHES ON WHAT YOU JUST MENTIONED HERE.

21:24 >> THERE WAS NO IMMINENT THREAT TO THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA. BY THE AMERICANS. -- BY THE IRANIANS. THERE WAS A THREAT TO ISRAEL. AND IF WE EQUATE A THREAT TO ISRAEL AS THE EQUIVALENT OF AN IMMINENT THREAT TO THE UNITED STATES, THEN WE ARE DASHA: IN UNCHARTERED TERRITORY. AND THEN THE PRESIDENT WAS ASKED ABOUT THIS AND ASKED IF PRIME MINISTER NETANYAHU FORCED HIS HAND ON IRAN.

21:59 >> DID ISRAEL FORCE YOUR HAND TO LAUNCH THESE STRIKES AGAINST IRAN? DID NETANYAHU PULL THE UNITED STATES INTO THIS WORK? >> WE WERE HAVING NEGOTIATIONS WITH THESE LUNATICS. AND IT WAS MY OPINION THAT THEY WERE GOING TO ATTACK FIRST. DASHA: WHOSE HAND WAS FORCED HERE IF ANYONE'S? MICHAEL: I DON'T THINK ANYONE'S HAND WAS FORCED. THE IRANIANS HAVE AGENCY. IF IRAN DEVELOPED NUCLEAR WEAPONS, THEY WOULD BE IN THE COMMAND AND CONTROL AND CUSTODY OF THE MOST IDEOLOGICALLY PURE ELEMENTS OF THE REVOLUTIONARY GUARD.

22:39 THE PROTESTS HAVE BEEN -- HOW DO YOU THEN STOP THE REGIME IN THE LAST 24 HOURS OF ITS LIFE FROM LAUNCHING THESE NUCLEAR WEAPONS? WHEN WE LOOK AT WHAT HAPPENED IN 2024 WITH THE ATTACKS ON ISRAEL, A LOT OF PEOPLE SAY ISRAELI AIR DEFENSES WERE GOOD AND THEY SHOT DOWN ALL BUT SEVEN OF 300 MISSILES AND DRONES. IF ANY OF THE SEVEN HAT THAT HAD GOTTEN THROUGH HAD WARHEADS, IT WOULD BE A DIFFERENT STORY. AND WHAT ALWAYS STRUCK ME AS AN ANALYST AS WELL IS WHILE IRAN SAID THEY NEEDED ENRICHMENT FOR THEIR OWN NUCLEAR POWER STATION AT BUSHEHR, IT HAS BEEN REALLY -- REFUELED EIGHT TIMES AND EACH TIME BY THE RUSSIANS.

23:24 THE IRANIANS HAVE NEVER USED ANY OF THEIR OWN ENRICHED URANIUM TO REFUEL THEIR OWN CIVILIAN PROGRAM. DASHA: CAN YOU EXPLAIN ISRAEL'S ROLE IN WORKING WITH THE UNITED STATES EITHER PUSHING FOR ACTION OR WORKING WITH THE UNITED STATES? HOW DOES NETANYAHU'S DESIRE TO SEE THIS REGIME IN IRAN TOPPLED PLAY INTO WHAT WE ARE SEEING IN THE UNITED STATES TODAY? MICHAEL: LET'S WALK THE CLOCK BACK TO SEPTEMBER, 2024 WHEN THE PAGERS WENT OFF IN LEBANON.

24:06 THE EXTRAORDINARY OFFENSE THAT FOLLOWED -- THE EXTRAORDINARY EVENTS THAT FOLLOWED, THE LITERAL THE COMPETITION OF HEZBOLLAH'S LEADERSHIP, THE EXTRAORDINARY RAPID, IN 11 DAYS, OVERTHROW OF THE ASSAD REGIME AFTER 50 PLUS YEARS OF POWER, ALL OF THIS TRANSFORMED THE REGION AND WHAT MICHAEL REFERRED TO, THE ISRAELI STRIKES THAT SHOWED IRAN WAS NAKED TO ITS ENEMIES WITH NO ABILITY TO CONTROL ITS OWN AIRSPACE. ALL OF THIS HAS SHIFTED THE STRATEGIC BALANCE IN THE MIDDLE EAST AND THE THREAT PICTURE VERY DRAMATICALLY AWAY FROM THE CHALLENGES ISRAEL HAS HISTORICALLY FACED TO A MUCH BETTER POSITION.

24:50 BUT IRAN REMAINED. AND I ARE GREAT, WHETHER IRAN PURSUES A NUCLEAR WEAPON OR NOT, THE THREAT THAT IT COULD, THAT IT POSSESSED THE HIGHLY ENRICHED URANIUM, 60% PLUS, WHICH HAS NO PURPOSE OTHER THAN TO BE FULLY ENRICHED TO BOMB FISSILE MATERIAL, ALL OF THIS POSED A MAJOR CHALLENGE. NOT JUST TO ISRAEL BUT TO EVERY GULF STATE.

25:20 AND YOU SAW HEDGING BEHAVIORS BEGINNING. I HAVE TO DRAW ATTENTION TO THAT. THE SAUDI'S IN THE LAST YEAR TOOK A SERIES OF STEPS, YOU CAN CALL THEM DE-RISKING, HEDGING, WHICH INDICATED A CERTAIN LACK OF CONFIDENCE IN THE U.S. ABILITY TO COME TO THEIR AID AND A GREATER RECOGNITION OF THE THREAT IRAN POSED. THEY MADE A SEPARATE PEACE WITH THE HOUTHIS. AND HE WAS MAKING STEPS TO RECONCILE WITH IRAN.

25:56 I BELIEVE IRAN'S OWN MISJUDGMENT, ALTHOUGH I UNDERSTAND IT STRATEGICALLY, OF ATTACKING THE GULF STATES HAS CHANGED ALL OF THAT. BUT THERE WERE LINES OF ACTION UNDERWAY WHICH WERE NOT IN THE FAVOR OF THE U.S. OR ISRAEL BUT WERE IN FAVOR OF IRAN. I WANT TO MAKE A COMMENT HERE THAT GOES BEYOND THE ISSUE OF ISRAEL'S ROLE IN ALL THIS AND I WILL GO TO SENATOR WARNER'S COMMENTS. I REGRET PROFOUNDLY THE INTRODUCTION, ALBEIT OBLIQUELY, OF ISRAEL HAS SUCKERED US INTO THIS CAMPAIGN.

26:33 AND WHAT IS A THREAT TO ISRAEL IS NOT A THREAT TO THE UNITED STATES. IF THERE IS A SEA CHANGE IN THINKING, IT IS A SENATOR EXPRESSING EXACTLY THAT THOUGHT. IT IS ONE I FIND DEEPLY REGRETTABLE AND IT STARTS ONE DOWN A SLOPE THE END OF WHICH WE ALL UNDERSTAND IS NOT DESIRABLE AT ALL FOR THE UNITED STATES. DASHA: WE HAVE ABOUT 30 SECONDS AND I WILL ASK A SIMPLE QUESTION.

27:05 HOW WOULD YOU DEFINE THE TRUMP FOREIGN POLICY DOCTRINE? DAVID: WHAT CAN PRODUCE ACQUISITIONS OR DECLARED VICTORIES FOR DONALD TRUMP? DASHA: THANK YOU, SIR. MICHAEL: I WOULD SAY DONALD TRUMP DOES NOT WANT TO BE A LAME DUCK PRESIDENT. HE WILL DO WHAT HE THINKS IS RIGHT REGARDLESS OF WHAT PROCEDURE IS AN PRESIDENT MAY HOLD. DASHA: GENTLEMEN, THANK YOU SO MUCH.

27:36 WE APPRECIATE YOUR EXPERTISE. FORMER PENTAGON OFFICIAL