Webinar or Talk
Daniel Haqiqatjou on Islamism vs. Liberalism
Watch on YouTube
Description
Daniel Haqiqatjou, one of America’s most vocal Islamist commentators, offers his views on the need to impose Islamic law universally and the clash between Islam and what he calls liberalism. A vehement critic of modernizing Islamists (such as CAIR and Omar) he has built an audience of hundreds of thousands of Western Muslims on social media and is on the frontlines of a powerful new ideological division. He will be in discussion with Sam Westrop.
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 3, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:00 Hello ladies and gentlemen. Um, welcome to the Middle East Forum's regular webinar series. Uh, I'm joined today by Daniel Hackatch, leading Muslim commentator whom we have written about critically in the past. Uh, this webinar, however, is not supposed to be contentious, but an honest and and frank interview, a unique chance to hear from Mr. Hacker Katu directly so that he might freely explain his views on our subject today, Islam versus liberalism. Now, Mr. Hakatu is the founder of Muslim Skeptic and the Alasna Institute. He reaches hundreds of thousands of subscribers and supporters across his various social media channels. Uh born in Houston, he studies physics, sorry, he studied physics and philosophy at Harvard before going on to do a philosophy and uh for his masters at Tufts. Now, Mr. Hackatchy will start with an introduction and then I'll ask a few questions. We'll also try to get to some questions from you, the audience.
0:55 Please use the Q&A box at the bottom of your screen to submit those questions. Uh, Mr. Hacku, over to you. Mr. Haku, you seem to be muted. Hello. Sorry. You hear me? We can hear you. Uh, there seems to be some problem with my video. Sorry about that. Let me see why it's not starting.
1:44 Hi. Hi. How's it going? Uh, but the volume Can you say something? Can you hear me now? Okay. Yes, I can I can hear you. Okay, that's okay. Go ahead. Okay, one second. Okay, thank you Sam for the invitation. Uh, just a little about myself. I'm the founder of Muslimskeepic.com. I was born and raised in the suburbs of Houston, Texas. I consider myself a Texan. Currently, I live with my wife and four children in a typical American suburb, just enjoying the warm weather with my family, grilling, going to the beach, teaching my boys how to play Meanwhile, Middle East Forum and Sam here have been writing article after article calling me a hardline Islamist.
2:40 So, what is it that makes me an Islamist? As far as I can tell, I'm called an Islamist because I'm a Muslim and I disagree with liberal secularism. So, let's talk about liberal secularism. When I talk about liberalism in my work, I'm referring to philosophical liberalism, which is a moral and technological project that aims to maximize individual freedom and equality. To be clear, when I say liberalism, I don't mean left-wing. When I refer to this philosophical liberalism, both the left and right-wing are committed to philosophical liberalism. Both the left and the right-wing are committed to maximizing freedom and equality. They just have different perspectives on how best to achieve that. And even Middle East forum as a conservative outlet is nonetheless philosophically liberal in this way. You are committed to spreading democratic values of freedom, women's equal rights, religious freedom, gay rights, etc. The problem with liberalism is that it
3:44 pursues maximizing freedom and equality at the expense of other important values like marriage, family, community, religious tradition, and so forth. The reality is that traditional institutions like marriage require some degree of lack of freedom and some degree of lack of equality. That is inevitable, but it's also intolerable to the liberal mind. A simple example is patriarchy. Patriarchy is a part of every traditional religion and culture. And the scientific consensus is that patriarchy is something biologically rooted in human psychology. But patriarchy entails a lack of equality between the genders. It also requires certain gender roles and those limit people's freedom of choice. And so liberalism seeks to destroy patriarchy, but that means destroying traditional life. Liberalism sees no problem with that. If maximizing freedom and equality means getting rid of traditional ways of life, so be it. But the problem is human
4:47 beings need patriarchy, otherwise marriages dissolve. There is no successful model of marriage that does not involve patriarchy and the inequality and lack of freedom that comes with it. All the modern liberal models of marriage have been a complete failure. The entire notion of the family unit has collapsed in our times. Why is that? It is because marriage and family require inequality. They require a lack of freedom and all of this is biologically based. Another example, religious practice also requires inequality. In all religions, for example, there are negative consequences for heresy or apostasy. But this conflicts with the liberal notion of religious freedom. So liberalism seeks to destroy this lack of freedom even though it means functionally destroying these religious traditions. So there are countless examples. So what does all of this have to do with Islam? Islam is the
5:51 last remaining major religion that is holding on to traditional values, traditional institutions of marriage, family, community, and religion. As such, it has been the target of unrelenting liberal attack for the past 250 years from colonialism until the neoc colonial war on terror being waged today. Liberal discourse liable lab labels any opposition to its project as extremism. This is not new. Liberal colonial powers shut down any opposition to their liberalizing project by labeling it radicalism. The same tact tactic has been accelerated with the current war on terror. Any Muslim who disagrees with the dictates of liberal secular modernity is branded an extremist. Who at the very least needs to be surveiled, whose travel should be restricted, who possibly needs to be detained, perhaps even tortured or extrajudicially assassinated.
6:51 All such actions by the liberal state are justified according to liberal logic because this Muslim has non-liberal beliefs and therefore poses a threat to the advancement of freedom, equality, and democracy. That's on the level of the individual. But the same logic applies to entire nations, which in the past has been enforced through colonialism, but now is enforced through international law and so-called nation building. The idea is if we invade Iraq and Afghanistan, force them to send their daughters to college to study feminism, and make sure they have elections every year, these Muslim countries will magically become bastions of liberal enlightenments like Sweden.
7:33 This is the hoax that neocons have pedled for the past 20 years of so-called Middle East intervention. Middle East Forum of course has played its part, portraying as an extremist threat any Muslim who expresses illiberal views. Muslims such as myself are depicted as extremist threats for what? For our belief in Islam, for advocating for traditional values, for condemning the generacy and the erosion of basic human institutions of marriage, family, belief in God, and are speaking out against the destruction of all traditional life by liberal secular forces. That's our great crime.
8:11 According to Middle East Forum, the funny thing is, according to the accelerating liberal project and its neverending pursuit of freedom, much of the Middle East Forum's conservative readership are increasingly considered extremists themselves. Don't believe that there are an infinite number of genders? You're an extremist. Don't believe that children should get sex change surgery? You're an extremist. You want to teach certain politically incorrect verses of the Bible or Talmud, you're an extremist. This tactic of crying extremist has been used for over two centuries to shut down Muslims. And the Middle East form has played its part in fanning those flames. The irony now is that the liberal project nowadays has accelerated to such an extent that conservatives themselves are being called extremists and are deplatformed and put on watch lists for not keeping up with the newest iterations of freedom and equality. In the f fantasy world of
9:14 Middle East Forum, the big existential threat to Americans are Muslims like me who are any day now going to ride in on camels to take over Washington DC and establish a Sharia state. But in the real world, Americans have long realized that the real threat is the fact that they can't get baby formula for their infants. The fact that they can't get married. The fact that their children have all become hardcore atheists. that their sons are degenerates and their daughters are prostituting themselves on Only Fans, that their lives have no meaning or purpose. Those are the dangers of liberalism that I warn about in my advocacy as a so-called hardline Islamist. Westerners are correct when they worry about their civilization being destroyed, but that is due to liberalism, not Islam. As a Muslim, I'm actually addressing the deep problems Americans are suffering from and offering solutions. Meanwhile, Middle East Forum distracts its readers with
10:16 this imaginary Islamist boogeyman. So, tell me, who is really the enemy of the West and its people? Okay, Daniel, thank you. Um you gave quite a broad definition of liberalism uh at the beginning pointing out that even the Middle East forum is included in this more philosophical uh definition of the term. You then did switch to uh defining it really as progressivism or at least it its excesses. Its most obvious examples you pointed to uh uh uh the gender obsession um uh uh certain views around atheism, religion, sexuality and so on. So, so is liberalism everything you say it is or are you specifically focused here on the left on the same progressivists that many conservatives non-Muslim conservatives worry about too?
11:07 No, it's it's the same thing. You can't get, for example, thirdwave or fourthwave feminism without secondwave or firstwave feminism. You can't get the latest iterations of woke uh progressive liberal politics without classical liberalism, without John Stewart Mill, without uh Alexis Dtokavville, without all of these classical figures. It is one continuous project and it is a failure I think of certain modern figures within the you know alt-right or alt- light or republicanism or whatever you want to call it to not recognize that the source of these problems these societal problems have deep roots with the liberal secular project.
11:58 Okay. [clears throat] Okay. Um you mentioned that you advocate for traditional values in lie of this liberalism. Um does that mean an Islamic state? Uh you also mentioned apostasy so and atheism. So how would apostates and atheists fare under the vision of society that you prefer? Yeah. So I mean the issue of what is the ideal? So obviously I'm advocating for Islam as a solution and Islam is a complete way of life that touches on everything from individual decision making to um individual values but also family values marital values uh societal values economic law. All of these areas are covered under uh Sharia and Islamic law and including you know religious practices like uh worship, rituals and so forth. So all of this is covered under Islamic Sharia. And the ideal and and the solution that's being proposed
13:02 here is that this model uh preserves marriage, it preserves family, it preserves and and strengthens organic communities. um and belief in in God. These are inherent human values. They're biologically based. They're very important and all people value them and Islam is a system and the best system for preserving this because it comes from the creator of of human beings, God Almighty. And so ha preserving this kind of system or establishing Islam um yes it does mean a reduction in freedom and equality uh but this kind of reduction of freedom and and equality is necessary in order to preserve uh marriage, family, community, religious practice, belief in God. uh you cannot maintain belief in God if it's possible for um apostates or atheists to uh go around and insult God to criticize God
14:09 to criticize the entire notion of belief. Uh this is something that will destroy uh religious belief and fundamentally undermine it in society. So Islam among other religions including Christianity and Orthodox Judaism require understands that there needs to be um consequences and punishments or disincentives towards heresy towards apostasy in order to maintain the value the important value of belief in God. If you don't restrict people's freedom uh religious freedom in that way, then it leads to a much worse consequence uh in the loss of belief in God.
14:51 Okay. um Muslim critics of yours and you have quite a few uh from what I've read uh refer to you uh and some of your you know like-minded people who I think you've worked with or who have supported you as the a right which I understand is a play on the Arabic word for brother a um but also the alt-right that's popular term to describe a certain section of the conservative right do you do you recognize that term do you do you think there is something to be said for the fact uh that um a number of Muslim community leaders consider your rhetoric to be uh something in common with some of these alt-right figures we have today in American politics.
15:33 Yeah. So they will say that a lot of what I'm calling to or Muslim skeptic.com is calling to is uh Trumpian or is in line with someone like Jordan Peterson um and the right-wing. But like I said in the opening, I don't view um the rightwing as really an alternative to liberalism. And that includes much of the alt-right. I don't think that they are alternatives. They're just proposing different forms of uh liberalism. So certain things that Donald Trump would say or Jordan Peterson would say or some of these alt-right figures would say, I will actually acknowledge that I agree with certain things that they say, but I'll also uh acknowledge that a lot of what they say, perhaps most of what they say is also wrong. But I also acknowledge that with, you know, someone like Biden or Bernie Sanders or any politician on the left. So my position has always been that I'm I'm criticizing both the left and the right wing of
16:36 politics because they're different manifestations of the same uh underlying cancer. And you know, are there certain figures within the alt-right or even the farright that critique modernity? Yes. You know, there are certain figures like that, but I don't think that they're providing a good solution. And I don't think that they're people that I would ally myself with or align with because they're also many of them proposing ethnationalism, which as a Muslim I completely reject. And also, a lot of this alt-right wants to praise Western civilization. And if you ask them what's so great about western civilization, they'll talk about technocratic liberalism. They'll say that we have all this technology, we have all of this uh human rights and freedom and democracy, women's rights. So this is just liberalism. They're just championing liberalism. They're just reacting to some of the excesses of what where liberalism has taken the world today.
17:39 And I think that they're not providing a solution. uh Islam is a solution. It's an it's a coherent cohesive system that has all of these benefits and all of these strengths. I think the alt-right some certain figures have recognized that and that's why you see some of them delving into Christianity or actually proposing or trying trying to rediscover or recapture some of the Christianity uh within their heritage. But as far as I'm concerned, it's very uh superficial Okay. And speaking of these this sort of ethnoism, you you interviewed recently Mark Collet, a self-described white nationalist frequently referred to as a neo-Nazi in British media. Um he seemed to I watched that that debate which is fascinating and he seemed to accept the idea of an Islamic Europe so long as it was white. Um that was certainly the implication of one of his sentences towards towards the end of that debate.
18:37 Um, so based on what you just said, do do and yes, they seem to currently be uh turning to Christianity, a lot of these figures on the so-called far right, but do you think there is potential for the the the far right or whatever you want to call them, uh, to regard Islam as a useful vehicle for their desires? Well, I I think I can ask Middle East form the same question. You know, I can ask because you have funding ties to people like Tommy Robinson and these right-wing affiliates in Europe and you know and Middle East form of course supports the ethnostate of Israel which includes many far-right elements. So you know a similar question can be asked of Middle East form. Do you consider the far right as a potential vehicle for your broader agenda? But, you know, the fact that I um you know, was in this debate with Mark Colette, he's a white nationalist. Uh yeah, we we did have common ground on certain things. But,
19:40 you know, let me ask you this, Sam. You know, do you agree that marriage and family are valuable institutions that should be preserved? Uh I'm a a forsaken atheist um with my own views that may not represent the forum. So, I'm going to keep my personal ideas out of this, but I would like to hear more from you. No. And like, do you think even as an atheist, do you think that marriage and and family are valuable? Of course. Of course I do. Okay. So, we have some common ground here, right? Does that make me a neocon or a sympa sympathetic to uh, you know, the Middle East form or does it make you an Islamist sympathizer just because you agree with me on the value of marriage and family? So, I think that question answers itself. But when it comes to Mark Klette, I don't want to like seem like I'm dodging the question, why did I engage with him? I'm willing to engage with people that are attacking Islam, whether they're Christians, whether they're from the far right, whether the far left, Hindutva, Middle East, form, whoever. I I'm open to talking with
20:43 people and I want to rebut their claims. Um, so that's that's just part of uh my advocacy and my work. But with Mark Colette, like did I agree with him on white nationalism or any kind of racism? No. I actually was giving arguments against that particular view. All I say is that in that conversation, we came to the common ground that marriage and certain traditional institutions, religious practices are valuable. And you know, I'll say it again. I agree with Mark Colette, the white nationalist, on those things. But when it comes to uh white nationalism, that is completely contrary to Islam. Any type of ethnationalism is contrary to Islam and we can't be allies on on that kind of basis. But if it's about traditional values and fighting and resisting liberalism in favor of a traditional way of life, then I see anyone as a potential ally, whether Christian, Jew, right-wing, left-wing, anyone, even you. Now, let me ask a few questions from the
21:46 audience and then I'll get back to just wrapping up with one or two questions of of my own. Um, uh, an anonymous questioner, so not sure who, uh, asks, uh, doesn't killing in the name of God for apostasy, for example, undermine belief in God and promote atheism? No. No, it doesn't. That's like saying, you know, does killing um murderers and killing people who commit uh heinous crimes and and punishing them, doesn't that promote uh murder? Doesn't that promote killing? No. Punishing criminals and those who violate norms and values uh in order to deter criminal behavior, to deter something that is disruptive, destabilizing. This is found in every religion and every legal system. Uh yeah, even within, look, I'm I'm in Texas, we still have the death penalty.
22:46 People who commit heinous crimes um are punished with the death penalty, even capital punishment. That is not that it's kind of a superficial argument to say that, oh well, Texas is not in favor of preserving life because they have capital punishment. That doesn't make sense. They are deterring future murders, future crimes. Now on the issue of apostasy, I think I explained it uh very briefly. I can go into more depth, but on my uh channel and Muslimskeepic.com, we have a lot of uh information on this uh apostasy rule within Islamic law. And I believe it's completely rationally justified and even an atheist um can understand uh that it has a kind of rationalistic basis. Even at the end of the day, if you don't agree with that and you believe in complete religious freedom, uh you can still appreciate that there is a basis for it. For someone who wants to preserve belief in God, who wants to preserve traditional uh religious institutions, it does have a a rational
23:50 basis and I'm perfectly happy to defend that. And then just to be explicit and and this wasn't um in our list of questions or in more from the audience so feel free to ignore. You would expand then the death penalty to apostasy if if if you were seeking a a more idealistic Yes, I would um I would criminalize blasphemy. So I go further not just apostasy but even blasphemy. I would um completely uh criminalize uh insulting for example Jesus Christ uh insulting the Virgin Mary, insulting uh the Hebrew Bible, uh insulting you know any of these uh what are called Abrahamic values and and prophets and figures. uh this is blasphemy in Islam and it and it should be completely illegal and the fact that it is allowed to run rampant within the west is the cause of a you
24:54 know rising atheism and the extinction of of these religions like those things are very tied and when I have conversations with Christians uh conservative Christians or even liberal Christians atheists they always bring up this apostasy point and I try to get them to understand that things are connected they're allow allowing just complete blasphemy to run rampant uh apostasy to run rampant where someone apostatizes and then goes on a campaign to undermine religion. This is something that's very dangerous uh to belief in God. And in so far as you value belief in God, you have to deter it. And this is why it's something that is found in all religions including Christianity, including Judaism. uh they punished heretics, they punished uh apostates at different times in history. Those are uh traditional practices and it has a rational basis. Liberalism says no, the most important thing is freedom.
25:51 Everyone should have the freedom of choice of individual choice no matter what. Even if it means that no one on earth believes in God anymore and there's no such thing as religion, then doesn't matter as long as people have freedom of choice. I find that to be extremism. I find that to be very uh unhinged but it comes from this classical liberal understanding of freedom of speech which which comes from deists and atheists who had no commitment to Christianity uh or any kind of tradition. Now, a significant portion of of of your time is spent discussing Muslim community figures who and and this is my inference, so please correct me if my interpretation is wrong, who you believe have embraced progressivism so tightly that they've radicalized their own children into believing some of its its core tenants. So you focused on groups like care, clerics such as Omar Sulaman, politicians such as Ilan Omar, people who have uh rather permissive rhetoric on subjects such as homosexuality uh and other uh progressivist uh causes.
26:55 Um, do you believe uh these Muslim leaders that you you focus on have genuinely embraced progressivism or these leftwing ideals or do you think this is a a tactic a facade something with which they hope to advance their own ideas uh eventually? In other words, is it a vehicle for their own designs? I mean to be honest, you know, if we if we read Middle East forum, um you guys complain a lot about figures like Ilhan Omar or Omar Salman, other liberalized Muslims who have embraced uh progressivism and they don't, you know, acknowledge certain illiberal aspects of the faith such as, you know, the the penalty for apostasy and so forth. But honestly, you know, it's this ironfisted suppression of illiberal beliefs that pushes many Muslims and other religions, Christians and Jews, uh, Hindus, even Buddhists, to liberalize their traditional religious teachings and become progressives. So, Middle East Forum wants to attack and has attacked
27:57 these liberal Muslims for being dishonest about Islam. But you're also the ones who are constantly attacking any Muslim with illiberal beliefs as an extremist threat or potential terrorist who should be surveiled or put in prison or deported. So there's a kind of hypocrisy I think in in that uh kind of approach. But to answer your question, you know, do I think that Ilhan Omar or Rashid Tale are these kinds of sleeper agents who are just pretending to be progressive so that they can rise the ranks of American power until one day they're going to drop the facade and they're going to make the entire US a hardcore Sharia state? You know, no, I I don't think that that's what's happening at all, you know. I think that they're actually someone like Ilhan Omar is progressive. I'd like to see where Ilhan Omar has ever uh suggested or Rashida Tib ever suggested any kind of uh allegiance or affiliation with Islamic politics. I think she would be repulsed
29:00 by that. She is definitely someone who would hate me or hates me. And I mean the question is kind of non-gerine because we've already had a Muslim president, right? Barack Hussein. So, [gasps] so he's already infiltrated. We've already infiltrated the highest ranks of the nation. Okay. Okay. Point point taken. But then take someone like someone like Omar Sullean uh who was a you know a very devoted uh a prominent man of God, a cleric, an imam. He you I think forced him to apologize publicly for he took part in some anti- um immigration [clears throat] policy protest against the Trump administration and took part in some I think you described it as a as a pagan ritual. So what about him? Does he genuinely believe in some of these progressivist ideas or or is is is it for him is it a facade?
29:53 I really don't know. I I don't know what he actually believes. Um and I make this this is a point when criticizing certain figures. I'll say that look I don't know what is in their heart. Um clearly someone like Omar Salman who's being attacked constantly uh as being this kind of you know terror insider or an extremist. So over the years some people uh just because of the constant pressure they may buckle under the pressure and they start you know not expressing their actual views or maybe they become genuine progressives. uh and it's not just Omar Salman it's many Christian pastors Christianity itself any Christian uh followers of Middle East forum will recognize that within the Christian church or within the synagogues you find this liberalizing progressive streak and it's unfortunate but the the problem the cause of it we have to look at the roots it's this liberalism it's any attack on any
30:58 expression that uh contradicts liberalism that's the the source of it. So Omar yeah I I criticize him. I think that you know the best interpretation is that he thinks look we are being very practical right now as a Muslim community. We want to uh survive because there's all of this kind of force or all kind of pressure on the Muslim community. We're just trying to keep our heads above water and sometimes you have to compromise in order to do that. We have to find allies within the uh anywhere we can find them and we have to be pragmatic. I think that's his mentality in the in the best interpretation of it. But it and but it's not for this purpose of being a sleeper cell and wanting to take over America. I think he really uh feels like he is a proud liberal American or a proud Democrat or whatever. I think that's actually how he what he thinks of it. But he's but uh I think he's just mistaken. I think that he's just made the wrong calculation and he's he's compromising Islam in a way that's going
32:02 to lead to the eraser of Islam for the next generation of American Muslims. That's my critique. All right. Now, we've got a little over time, but if we're all right with you, Daniel, I'll just have two more questions if you don't mind staying. Sure, of course. uh, let me take one from the audience and I'll ask my own. Uh, uh, one again an anonymous questioner says, uh, what are your views on capitalism? uh it has its roots in the very classical liberalism you condemn. Uh I the the implicit follow-on question I guess being what would an economic system look like in the society you would prefer?
32:36 I think in in certain respects uh is if you look at Islamic law, it uh seems to have certain aspects of free market uh enterprise and and maybe more of a seeming policy in terms of allowing uh trade and having not very many restrictions, very low taxing or even no taxes. uh but it the the one the big problem or for Islam with capitalism is what's called ribba or user and this is something that arguably capitalism cannot exist without this concept of usery or this practice of uh user and userious loans and um capital funding and so forth. So this is actually the um problem or I think the main conflict between capitalism and Islam and traditional religion also Christianity has been c in certain sects
33:41 of Christianity very against user same with Judaism. Uh I think these religions have recognized um because as a Muslim we believe that all these religions Christianity and Judaism in particular have been uh have their own texts and their revelation from God and God has identified and and has told humanity that this is a practice that is destructive. It is evil and it will lead to all kinds of pain and suffering which it does that we see you know throughout history and in the world today and that's why they've banned it. Um but as far as free market and being able to conduct your business uh without the force of the states to limit uh certain practices then that that is found in Okay. And and last question from me. Um over the past decade a lot of clerics who would have once openly described themselves as salafi are no longer doing so. Um publicly sometimes rejecting the term. I'm particularly thinking of people like Yasia Kadati. Um uh on this
34:44 point um I wonder what do you think of yourself as? Do you embrace a particular movement or sect? And just to to accompany that um I noticed you work quite closely with clerics from the Deabandi movement these days which is the South FAR South Asian uh uh Islamic movement set up in the 19th century uh whose offshoots of course include the Taliban. um uh what do you identify as and do you think deabandism offers a more authentic vision of Islam? Yeah, I I would say that it's interesting that to ask a question about sect. Uh I'm not going to try to judge your intention with the question, but um this kind of questioning about Salafi versus traditionalism versus Diego Bendy just as an intellectual history of it, it's coming straight from Rand the Rand playbook and Cheryl Bernard. Uh so what the RAND strategy has been uh and this is the strategy that a lot of a lot of
35:47 think tanks and policy strategists have taken is that we want to get traditionalist Muslims on one side and we want to split them up strategically from Salafies on the other side and we don't want them to unite together under the banner of conservative Sunni Islamic teachings. We want them to be fighting each other. And ideally, we want one side, the the traditionalists to ally with the reformers like Muslim reformers or Muslim secularists who are backed by the west and who support uh western uh policy points. But as far as Muslim skeptic is concerned, we we acknowledge that there are important differences between Salafis, the Obendies, traditional etc. But the similarities are much much deeper and the only people who really want to split these groups up are people like Rand or Middle East Forum or different brands of neocons. So um you know this is this is our perspective on on Muslim skeptic.com.
36:49 We're not trying to say there are no differences between the two uh strains, but they're Sunni. They're Sunni Orthodox and they care about preodern expressions and teachings of Islam as it's been practiced for 1400 years. And that's what unites me and other Sunnis, Orthodox, conservative Sunnis. The history of this term Salafi actually it's it's really interesting because it's seems to be more recent maybe the last 1015 years that the word Salafi has been showing up amongst neocons and there the term used to be terrorist or terrorist sympathizer or Islamist then it became Wahhabi then it become Salafi so basically it's come to mean anyone who is an conservative orthodox Sunni Muslim is being labeled as a Salafi or anyone who think who teaches or believes that Quran and Hadith are important.
37:45 This is a Salafi Wahhabi Islam Islamist. So, but I I consider myself a Sunni, an orthodox conservative Sunni. And you know, if if that's your definition of what a Salafi is, then yeah, I'm a Do you mind if I ask Do you mind if I ask which which Madhab which school of Jewish prudence of? I've studied the hami school of I've also studied the hannfi school of uh those are the medabs but that's yeah those are the things I've studied interesting um we've gone very much over time uh Mr. Hakatu, thank you so much uh for your answers for your uh conversation today.
38:24 Yeah. So Sam, any possibility of a Uh we'll get back to you on that one. Can we extend the conversation? Can we because I thought this was a productive conversation. I think you agree like this was an enjoyable for me and I think we can engage in good faith and have more productive exchanges. But I want to hear your reaction because you asked questions. I didn't really hear your response. I think your audience as well would love to see what Sam Wester thinks about what this Islamist extremist has has just said. It'd be great to get your perspective or anyone else at Middle East Forum.
39:01 Well, thank you for the invitation. We'll certainly [clears throat] uh discuss it. Um Mr. Hacketry, thank you very much for your time. to our audience. Um this is a regular series uh that MEF runs webinars throughout the year with various guests um including today [laughter] someone we wouldn't usually have. Uh you can sign up uh for our newsletters to uh uh join us on future webinars at meforum.org. Thank you very much for your time and uh have a wonderful weekend. You as well. Thank you.