Israel Insider
Israel Insider with Ashley Perry
Watch on YouTube
Description
The next, less intense and more focused stage of Israel’s ground campaign in Gaza looks set to begin even as Jerusalem acknowledges negotiations to release Israeli hostages. What implications do these developments have for Israel’s unity government?
Ashley Perry is an advisor to the Middle East Forum’s Israel office. He served as adviser to Israel's minister of foreign affairs and deputy prime minister in 2009-15, and has also worked with Israel's Ministers of Intelligence, Agriculture and Rural Development, Energy, Water and Infrastructure, Defense, Tourism, Internal Security, and Immigrant Absorption and as an advisor to The Negev Forum. Originally from the UK, he moved to Israel in 2001. He holds a BA from University College London and an MA from Reichman University (IDC Herzliya).
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 23, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:09 good afternoon and welcome to the Middle East forums webinar and podcast series Israel Insider with Ashley Perry I'm Stacy Roman and I will be moderating this discussion today we're pleased to have Mr Ashley Perry advisor to the Middle East forums Israel office join us each week to update us on the latest events in Israel Mr PR will be giving us a briefing on the current situation in Israel for 15 minutes followed by 15 minutes of Q&A from the audience should you wish to ask a question please use the Q&A box located at the bottom of your screen to type your question and with that I'll turn the discussion over to Mr Ashley Perry thank you very much Stacy and good evening from Israel and happy New Year to to everybody um the last week or so in Israel we we're coming up to 90 days tomorrow will be the 90th day of the war and it's clear that the signs are that um Israel is moving further and further south uh but what is also happening as it moves further south it doesn't need as many troops in the north of the uh Gaza Strip and over the last week or so
1:15 uh some of the um soldiers who are caught up in the reserves have been released um because uh as I said you know when when you're trying to take over as much territory as possible you need a very large fighting force but just to hold it or you know make sure that Hamas or militant groups terrorist groups do not return requires a much smaller force and there is talk uh in Israel that is moving to something what what is being described as phase three of the fighting which will be a lot more targeted uh with as I said a lot less forces um we're still not there yet it's clear that the fighting forces are moving further and further south um capturing as much territory as possible trying to squeeze the Hamas terrorist infrastructure as much as possible um according to Israeli sources um Israel has already killed over8 and a half thousand terrorists Hamas terrorists um during this war um so it is making uh
2:20 you know inroads into the uh not just into the uh bodies and soldiers of uh the Hamas terrorists but also the Hamas INF structure we know that uh um sino's headquarters have been taken and much of the underground tunnel infrastructure has already been taken and subsequently destroyed but there's clearly quite a lot uh to go but the war is certainly edging closer and closer to the third stage something which the Americans are very keen to start as soon as possible they don't like uh the death toll that is being reported by the Ministry of Health the Hamas controlled Ministry of Health which clearly if you look at the numbers is not telling the whole story and is probably exaggerating much of the numbers according to that same Hamas run Ministry of Health the majority of people have been killed are are women and children and that's clearly uh not the case but uh it is something which is causing um concern in America and Washington and many other places and
3:23 there is a lot more pressure on Israel to try and scale back some of its uh more aggressive mive movements that it's uh that it's basically done over the last few dozen uh days since the pretty much the early days of the war and again sort of more pinpointed attacks with the smaller forces in Gaza and try and let as many gazans back to their homes although um there you know a lot of the cities and towns and Villages um have destroyed not not full cities obviously but certain parts uh especially where Hamas were uh using and firing for them and had their headquarters so um Israel is uh looking to try and see how it can on the one hand appease this sentiment but on the other hand really try and go after Hamas as soon as possible obviously there's really only one place to to start um today which was which basically the the the major event of yesterday and the last week was the
4:26 assassination of s Al AI who was the number two in the military wing of Hamas what makes he's just below ish he is a Hamas terrorist leader who was there right from the beginning um and he has moved between Qatar turkey and Lebanon uh thinking that he was safe in the dhan neighborhood which is the neighborhood of beut which is pretty much controlled byah and the fact that he was killed in the bay neighborhood under the noses OFA is really a major achievement I I should say at this point that Israel has not taken responsibility like always there have been hints um mad director David B came out today and didn't accept responsibility but said uh you know sort of hinted very much towards it and uh obviously the working opinion in Hamas andah and others is that Israel was behind it but it is a
5:29 major assassination it is one of the top levels probably for sure the highest level uh leader of Kamas that's been killed to date during this war and the fact that it took place uh under Nash's NOS is is really uh quite quite something um nasala came out tonight with one of his major speeches as usual it was well over an hour a lot of the usual uh propaganda that Israel is hiding or the thousands tens of thousands of casualties and and hundreds of thousands of Israelis have left Israel in the last um the last you know couple of months it's the beginning of the war and you know the Arab side is winning etc etc but interestingly enough what he did say is that sort of uh he will not be dragged hisbah will not be dragged into a war and and the question is why is Nala not really you know going full tilt on this because to uh you know at the end of the day nasrala as well as
6:33 being an Iranian uh proxy he is still a part of the Lebanese political infrastructure and he does have to care about Lebanese sentiment and Lebanese sentiment isn't as strong on a Palestinian leader as it is on what would be a Lebanese leader as we know Palestinians are considering are considered uh second class citizens in um in Lebanon in the refugee camps in Lebanon they have curfews they're not allowed to work in certain jobs they're not allowed to marry they're they're not well regarded they're not considered on the same level as uh Lebanon and also there's been a lot of threats some from NASA's allies and some from his opponents within Lebanese politics um basically not calling on Nala not to drag Lebanon into a war they they see very clearly what's going on in Gaza they understand Israel's power it's a superiority even though uh hisbah is a you know is a real threat it is a fully functioning army with major ballistic missile capability it's still really no
7:38 match for the IDF and and a lot in a lot of people in Lebanon are very worried about it so Nash has to take that into account so that's why his sort of you know Veiled Threat that um hisbah will respond but it will be at their time uh their watch and you know clearly anything that happens in the near future they'll they'll say that it's uh as a result of that assassination but the fact that he's not going gungho uh into some response shows that again as as we' spoken about in recent weeks there still has not been that final order from tan to go Full Tilt into war and is very cognizant not just of that but also of the Lebanese uh political uh and domestic uh feeling um another thing that happened today is South Africa uh applied uh or called for an investigation into genocide by the state of Israel this is a major diplomatic threat to Israel and Israel is considering its response it we
8:41 have to wait to see what uh exactly uh happens will there be an interim call uh for an investigation Israel is following this very carefully it's a long long report by South Africa mostly you know conjecture and attacks without really much um validity but they're the thing that they're most worried about in Israel is that there is an addendum or appendix or or what have you uh to the report which basically catalog some comments might made by Israeli politicians at the beginning and the duration of the war and again the overwhelming majority of these comments are by uh mid to lowlevel um politicians certainly not decision makers and really are not effective of where Israel has been uh fighting this war but as We Know in Israel every politician likes to get headlines every politician likes to you know sort of you know jump over the next one to see how more militant they can be and the South Africans have been quite clever and it's not just South Africa we
9:44 know very well that most of the information was provided by Foreign sources in the Arab and Muslim world but they've certainly been cataloging these uh these speeches and these comments and they're trying to use that uh to try and justify their case against Israel in that he on the hostage deal uh it's it's a very it's very unclear what is happening at this point uh according to Hamas publicly at least uh they are still sticking to the line that no hostage deal is even that there's no negotiations until the war has finished and Israel has uh Israel has withdrawn from the strip that's the official line but what clearly is happening is something else uh again nothing drastic is moving in a positive direction but the fact that there are negotiations the fact that the qataris are involved and most importantly from an Israeli point of view the kataris have not come out and condemned the assassination as of now at least of aurori U which leads suon Israel to optimism that uh
10:47 negotiations will not be styed by the assassination and in fact will still be uh ongoing there is a feeling in Israel that sinoa is starting to walk back this m maximalist demand and is prepared perhaps because of the assassination perhaps because Israel is pushing further into the South but there is some cause for optimism that talks could continue at some point soon again it's there are no great signs that negotiations are seriously happening um but the fact is that there have been proposals by the qataris and by Egypt um which were rejected by Hamas but clearly not completely because the negotiators are still in town uh and still trying to work out uh some deal on the domestic front there's been a real sort of earthquake um on the um judicial front with two major rulings that one would think perhaps in the middle of a war are either not necessary or could have
11:49 waited uh until after the war but I'll explain why they came about we talked a lot before the war about the reasonableness uh Clause that um that the government passed a basic law I should say the Coalition rather passed a basic law which would um uh deprive uh the Supreme Court of using the reasonableness Clause uh as opposed to an actual you know a contravention of a law uh in its ruling against appointments and laws themselves Etc up until now as we know basic laws were pretty much impregnable to uh Supreme court and um there was a feeling that this would really be you know unprecedented uh if they did strike down this uh this this uh you know change of the basic law um and so it was there was a ruling it was a 15 uh uh member bench if we remember uh the four Supreme Court
12:53 bench and there was a ruling a very very close ruling 8 to7 in favor of striking it down now Not only was it unprecedented in the fact that this is the first time the Supreme Court has ruled that um a basic law can be analed but what was also interesting and I think this was even um I think there was to4 uh that basically well that a basic law can be struck down by the Supreme Court so what's interesting is that there were some who said that this particular uh law Amendment uh should not be strucked out in other words in opposition to the final ruling but did admit in their in their own personal rulings that it is the business of the Supreme Court it can look at basic laws and it can strike them down uh which certainly is perhaps even more worrying for the for this particular Coalition than the final ruling because what we see is the reason for the rulings basic now and and I'll I'll talk about the the second ruling in in a minute um the
13:56 reason is is because the Supreme uh Court president esut has just finished her tenure and according to the law you're allowed to give a ruling within three months of your of your uh retirement and that was in in the middle of January would have been the end of the three-month period after she resigned so it's clear that she wanted to get this decision out before she uh retired uh and there's another person also on the Supreme Court bench another Justice who's also retiring at the same time and and the two uh that are replacing are more from the conservative Wing so it would have tilted the balance at the moment it's more towards the progressive liberal side and it were tilted more towards the conservative side so there is a feeling that uh Supreme Court Justice president uh president esut really wanted to try and get ahead of the ruling ahead of um the change in the bench and get the rulings out the second one is uh to strike down the recusal law or not really to strike
14:59 down but basically the recusal law um deprived his hery general of recusing the Prime Minister because of a conflict of interest this is something which was much discussed over the last year before the war and the government the Coalition decided to create a law against it uh this was considered unfit it was considered a personal law in other words it was written specifically with one person in mind in other words prime minister Benjamin Neto um and it wasn't struck down necessarily the law but what the uh bench did decide and this was a smaller bench but again I think it was six to5 on 11 seat bench um that it can only come in um to law after the next elections during the next knesset in other words it shouldn't be used at this point uh with this particular uh Coalition so that was two really remarkable decisions not wholly unexpected but the fact that they took place uh within War um was something that obviously the uh Coalition jumped
16:03 on um there was um a a you know some commentary that said that the government could have extended the tenure or at least the uh the leaving uh that that three three-month period to another three months to make it a six-month period where uh retiring um Supreme Court Justices could have still uh given their their their ruling um that was not done um so the fact is that the decided to do this now before she ran out of time but it what it has done is it's really brought those divisions back into Focus uh as one could imagine the Coalition especially the could part and religious sinist party has come out against the decisions and the opposition has come out in support and and uh it's really bringing back to a certain extent those dividing lines that we saw before the war at really a time where there's great unity and there's a need for great unity in the middle of a war so uh it it'll be interesting to see how much
17:06 noise these make we're still in the reverberations of those uh decisions but we'll have to see how long uh that will continue finally um we've been hearing quite a lot how you know the calls for resignation of uh netan and and perhaps others in the senior political security and intelligence realms have been met with the uh retort that you don't change uh leadership in the middle of War well this week we actually did see a change of leadership we saw the rotation as we know under the rotation agreement foreign minister Ellie Cohen will then be replaced by Israel Kats Israel Katz has been foreign minister for about a 15 months in the past he's no stranger to the ministry but again this was a moment that was not unnoticed by those who were dismissed or yeah dismissed by those who basically said that you don't change leadership in law in in war and the fact that the foreign minister one of the most senior positions in the Israeli
18:09 government was switched because of political considerations as I said did not go unnoticed um and with that I'm happy to answer any questions all right well uh on that note thank you so much the the first question that came in before we even started this webinar from an any conditions short of a no confidence vote in the knesset that would enable Israel to go to elections uh short of the specified fixed mandated time that is some months if not years off yeah I mean you know the the other the other possibility is uh if a budget doesn't pass but the budget's been passed till the end of 2024 um even though there there are some amendments so it would have you know the government would only fall three months after that so we're talking about at the end of March 2025 so that's the other alternative at this point obviously if someone resigns and calls for early elections but that would necessitate um you know a law to pass um calling for elections which isn't likely to happen
19:13 and no confidence is certainly not going to happen at this particular Point although there are always murmurings that some liquid Rebels at least keeping it in their back pocket in case of emergency as it were um but yeah it's certainly not in the offing and there are very limited opportunities to call for elections especially now and and we did see this week uh Municipal elections were pushed back once again to the end of February I mean that's largely because a lot of people standing for elections are still in Gaza and in uh in the reserves um and it was felt that we couldn't uh hold Municipal elections during a war when so many people are still fighting again there was quite a lot of controversy in figh ing between the ultra Orthodox parties some other parties in the Coalition because as we know much smaller percentage of ultra Orthodox um Community are you know on the front lines and unable to uh campaign and vote Etc but that did get sorted out the will of the country
20:17 frankly one out on that and and the ultra Orthodox parties understood that um so the fact that Municipal elections have been put back uh there's very little justification at this point to go through general elections um especially when there seems to be very few tools um to do so thank you Adam Perry ask what is the genuine diplomatic benefit to South Africa for producing their report how will this impact overall African relationships with Israel well the on the second part it doesn't really impact the wi continent South Africa have for many years especially if we're talking about subsaharan Africa have really been an outlier of real anti-israel hostility I mean they've removed their Ambassador a long time ago um they basically you know call Israel a Nazi regime I think some of the comments that came out I mean the relationship has been very very bad for quite a while it doesn't necessarily affect um Israel's relationship with a
21:19 wider continent in fact when Israel tried to return to an observer status uh earlier in the year South Africa and some of the North African Arab countries came out very strongly against but they actually lost out because there were enough there was enough support around the rest of the continent uh for Israel and Israel has been making very strong inroads in in support in Africa and West Africa in uh in East Africa and even Central and Southern Parts but South Africa is a real outlier partly because of its history partly because of its um demographics it has a extreme ex um High Muslim population and in fact the one area if you look at the internal politics of South Africa I think it's the Western Cape which is the one area thec does not rule is actually the highest percentage of Muslim voters so it's very much pandering um to that for purely domestic uh uh reasons um but it certainly can be a bloody knows
22:22 diplomatically if they do get a ruling if for some reason at the end of this that Israel is charged accused of genocide won't necessarily have too much uh application under international law but it will certainly be just another um weapon that will be wielded by those who want to damage Israel's name to then be able to use this ruling as a previous icj ruling against Israel's anti-terrorism barrier was basically uh you know the icj ruled that it was uh it was unnecessary and it was uh I think they even called it an aparte uh uh uh barrier or whatever it is using the the language of Israel's enemies um it didn't have any bearing on the ground legally physically or anything but it is a ruling that is still used by um Israel's enemies around the world so if they were to successfully accuse Israel of genocide that would one can imagine the effect that would have on the discourse around Israel around the world absolutely thank you uh Brock kmar
23:27 asks which is Israel is real is it Ben gre's Israel with the idea of Gaza occupation and Exile of the gazans or idf's Israel which insists that Israel is conducting war against Hamas not the gazin can you comment on this dilemma please um did you say benur or Ben Ben the beginning Ben I think he meant I'm assuming he meant Ben yes yes that's right um at the end of the day uh the people who make the decisions in time of War at least is is the war cabinet and that's basically one that netan holds very very uh tightly Ben very much and balos smrc um his partner um have been you know very much sort of uh shouting from the outside they are part of the security cabinet but the major decisions are made in the in the war cabinet where they are not part of they're desperately trying to become part of it but netan will not let them in uh absolutely and so the decisions are made by netan in a
24:30 very small circle um of people around him um and it's that's the way that you know they're the ones who are really going to decide on the day after obviously n has to take into account Coalition interests personal interests um party interests you know there are there are a lot of people in Li could will be far closer to some of the suggestions of B vmrc than they will be of netan netan is certainly not a particular popular character in the LI good I mean his approval rating is Rock Bottom anywhere in the country um but uh you know the the idea the ideas that have been proposed by smotrich and Ben are not going to be voted on in the war cabinet are probably not even going to be discussed in any serious uh manner so it it it is going to be very much neto's decision of what happens to the Gaza Strip after the war there were supposed to be these discussions and there was supposed to be a meeting yesterday but the assassination really put pay to that so
25:33 is going to be put off uh for at least in a couple of days thank you so an anonymous attende ask is the risk of escalation with Hezbollah rising in recent events uh it has seemed that Iran's proxies aside from Hamas itself have been deterred from escalating the conflict but is that the cont is that containment shifting in any important way now um it's still there currently uh the assassination I mean it's still the early hours after the assassination so you know things could change basically the the uh the equation has been that while there is this sort of contained uh I wouldn't say War but sort of battle between hisbah and Israel on the northern border um hasn't really come into a Philly fledged War because that there didn't seem to be an interest from either party to do so but what is coming into sharp focus is that the tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands of Israelis who have been removed by their own government from the northern border
26:34 will will not go back unless hisbah have been completely deterred now there's a lot of talk in Israel and around the International Community about resolution uh un res security security Council resolution 1701 which was passed at the end of the second Lebanon war in 2006 um and basically what that says is that there should be no armed militias in other words kah south of the Lani river which is a river demarcating the sort of South uh of Lebanon uh but a lot of Israelis are coming to the conclusion that even if some diplomatic solution uh did work out Amos poin who is the uh us Envoy uh who's Landing in Lebanon tomorrow to discuss these issues even if one what even if a diplomatic solution succeeded and hisbah in some way looked like they were removing themselves what would be and the war you know the war would finish in Gaza and the war would finish in in in the north what would be uh stopping hisbah one month two months
27:37 six months later from just simply traveling south under the guise of civilians which is what they've done before going back to their underground bunkers and what have you so there are lot of people in Israel who say that hisbah at one point have to be taken on militarily there's no other way around it and this is as good as a time as any to do so because it just won't have the leverage or the ability to strike uh in any meaningful way uh you know further down the line thank you Eric sov asked when we look at the major goals of Israel one eliminating Hamas leadership to making Hamas unable to attack Israel uh three making sure Hamas can not regain power and of course uh returning the hostages where do you think Israel is in achieving these goals well certainly uh hamas's missile capabilities weakening I mean from the fact you know from the early days of the war where they were shooting multiple times you know across the country every day to once or twice a week sometimes less sometimes more uh
28:42 part of it is because they're just shooting off Rockets um before Israel conquers that particular territory um um but also because their missile ability is weakening a lot of its missile abilities especially the longer range ones were in the north which would make sense because it's obviously closer to Israel's Center so it's clearly defeating hamas's ability to strike at Israel from a rocket point of view and the um you know it its military command hamas's military command has been severely disrupted as I said Israel has conquered much of its headquarters and it uh you know military infrastructure so it's suddenly on the way to defeating Hamas whether it can completely defeat Hamas whether it will completely defeat hamash to the last man whether it will be able to take out people like y sin and Muhammad diff and some of the other leaders uh that remains to be seen um you know depending who you speak to some are confident that they will be uh you
29:45 know targeted now there's even talk and netan apparently behind closed doors even admitted in a meeting that was supposed to be offord with the hostages Forum that they could could be some talk of allowing the senior Kamas leaders to leave if the hostages were released uh it's the first time that that was admitted that there was even thoughts in that direction uh so that is certainly you know that was something pounced on by the media and many of the government's opponents um but certainly the one that's sort of holding firm at this point and doesn't seem to be too much movement is the hostages um and uh but that that is is a you know that that's that's that's a more difficult one to approach because you need a lot of things some say that you you know you need to take your foot off the gas militarily some say you need to push Full Tilt on that to put pressure you know Sina only made the first deal because he felt the Israeli boot on his neck that's what a lot of people are saying and he just simply doesn't feel that at the moment because
30:48 Israel is allowing as much humanitarian Aid in almost as was during that deal so there's no real uh leverage with uh with sin who seems to be the person pulling the strings so um that that doesn't seem to be there seems to be as I said some optimism within hisel but doesn't seem to be moving you know particularly uh in a speedy fashion but the other the other goals are on their way uh but it you know sometimes the most difficult part of Wars are the final moments and we're we're far from the final moments but certainly on the ground uh the battle is going you know in Israel's favor and it is moving further and further south so it remains to be seen to what point Israel you know goes and and at what point it feels that it's done enough achieved enough and then moves on to the phase absolutely thank you so much so we've come to the close of our webinar and podcast Ashley thank you again for taking time to update us this week for our viewers and listeners please note
31:50 there will be no webinar this Friday January 5th thank you all for joining us and I hope you have a wonderful