Webinar or Talk
"Social Justice” and the Muslim Brotherhood – Illusion and Reality with Craig Considine
Watch on YouTube
Description
Craig Considine once believed the Muslim Brotherhood claim to advocate for “social justice,” so he defended and supported the Islamist organization. He then learned through bitter experience that the Brotherhood’s advocacy and activism for “justice” is but political theater and propaganda concealing a very different, dangerous, agenda. What is that agenda? How do Islamists use social justice activism to deceive well-meaning non-Muslims? What can Craig Considine’s journey into and away from the Muslim Brotherhood teach the rest of us?
Craig Considine, a sociologist, has written seven books in the field of Islamic studies, including The Humanity of Muhammad – A Christian View (Blue Dome Press 2020). His work has appeared in Newsweek, Foreign Policy, and other publications. He holds a B.A. from the American University, an MSc. from Royal Holloway, the University of London, and a Ph.D from Trinity College Dublin.
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 21, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:08 hello good afternoon and welcome to the Middle East forums weekly podcast series my name is anaf Kalam and I will be moderating today's discussion we are pleased to be joined by Dr Craig consedine author and sociologist who is joining us to discuss the topic of social justice and the Muslim now Dr kadine once believed the Muslim Brotherhood claim to advocate for social justice so he defended and supported the uh islamist organization he then learned through bitter experience that the brotherhood's advocacy and activism for justice is but political theater and propaganda concealing a very different dangerous agenda uh now I will turn the floor over to Dr Craig conine here um can we begin uh by having you tell us about your background and academic writings on Islam Muslims Muhammad and like sure thank you for having me uh
1:11 background grew up in Nita Massachusetts uh Irish Italian with a splash of English and Scottish also Catholic went to public school but also had my uh my fair share of Catholic indoctrination at St Sebastian's Church in NM when it came time to go to college I went to American University in Washington DC and I linked up with Dr Akbar Ahmed who was the former High Commissioner from the UK uh from Pakistan to the UK and Dr Ahmed introduced me to um Interfaith dialogue uh through the prism of international relations and this was 2003 2004 so the invasion of Afghanistan and Iraq had just happened happened and I became passionate about the Interfaith movement and I worked with him extensively on uh numerous projects uh after Au I went to Royal hallay University of London that's
2:15 where I did my masters and got a MSC in international relations and then I moved on to Trinity College Dublin uh Department of Sociology where I got my PhD terms of my books I've written eight books now my eighth is about to be published in a couple of months and they've largely focused on Islam in the west uh also Christian and Muslim relations and what I've been trying to do is to bridge the perceived Gap uh between these entities the the west and Islam through the prism of Christian and Muslim relations so this is where my efforts have uh been at over the last 15 years or so right thank you now uh in your pursuit of bridging that uh sort of interfaith Gap how is it that you found yourself working uh maybe not working but in contact and uh you know kind of
3:18 advancing the sort of agenda of islamist organizations like the Muslim Brotherhood and their and their various networks so it was it was never a conscious effort me I I I think I need to make that clear you know I I didn't necessarily know what I was completely mixed up in uh it it happened Without Really my uh my my conscious acknowledgment of it uh kind of naive in a way but it really kicked off when I moved to Houston in uh 2016 when I picked up a position at Rice University and at the time this was uh the 2016 election islamophobia was a hot button issue and I this was of concern to me I was com I thought I was combating it and slowly but surely uh various organizations reached out to me um and it's not just the Muslim
4:22 Brotherhood Affiliated uh organizations uh I've interacted with a plethora of organizations over the years and I was interested in the in especially car's uh civil rights Mantra if you want to call it that that's obviously what they pitch them themselves as and that was something I'm interested in and I'm obviously still interested in civil rights right I think this is where where in the United States uh this is a constitutional right uh but at the time I didn't NE necessarily know that there was a lot of political baggage behind it uh so that's how it's that's how it started all right well thank you now um this is an interesting topic for me personally as well so I come from a Muslim background and I an ex-muslim so I understand how a lot of uh a lot of these uh political ideas especially
5:27 ideas that claim to promote an vate for things like social justice and uh um you know anti-islamophobia sorts of messages are very uh attractive now do you find this is a question from Sam westrop the islamist watch director here at MEF he asks did you find that Interfaith dialogue is exploited by islamist groups that is islamists using Interfaith bodies as a means to legitimize their claim to represent Western Muslims the same way they might by propagating these ideals of social justice I mean I think that's a fair point um I think it's part of a strategy to uh soften the playing field you know Interfaith is a very easy inroad you know I I can't imagine any sane person being anti- Interfaith given how diverse our country is but in my own personal experience if in working with various
6:31 networks that are linked to the Muslim Brotherhood and then obviously the entire kind of uh Network that is not really affiliated with it but that's there like I I found that the Interfaith card wasn't really sincere and that it was really about a political uh and yeah that's really what turned me off especially when I got uh deep into it and folks started trying to convert me you know like if this is I was always thinking like if this is about Interfaith then you should respect the fact that I'm Catholic that's how I was raised and I am you know uh speaking highly of Muhammad and writing books about muhammmad but if this is about interference faith and why are you trying to convert me so that was one of the kind of switches that went off uh in
7:36 my head that started making me think that the whole Interfaith thing was uh A sly political strategic maneuver and it honestly lowered my trust in the people that I was working with so that's interesting uh you as a Catholic uh to some extent were uh able to to kind of get embedded into some of these islamist groups and their activities um it's a little more understandable for somebody who grew up you know in Islam somebody who is a Muslim um but how uh can you speak more about how these islamist groups are able to recruit non-muslims and sort of fellow travelers to their islamist causes honestly it's mainly through Academia it's through a lot of the woke terminology you know critical race Theory decolonization social justice anti-racism I think a lot of it is happening uh in Academia and I'm afraid
8:41 that a lot of students around the country are not even really aware of exactly what they are supporting and why they're even supporting it I can say like I was never overtly recruited I never I never felt that but it was it was always subliminal it was always on these like left leaning liberal talking points uh which are you know kind of shallow in a way there's a lot of virtue signaling in this you know like who who couldn't be against social justice who shouldn't be against anti-racism of course we should be against these things but it's not as clearcut it's it's NE it's never that clearcut um so right and I I suspect that's a kind of by Design in a sense who wants who wants to be the guy as you said who wants to be the guy who is railing against Interfaith or against open dialogue between the faiths and uh as they would have you believe but realistically what they mean is the guy
9:44 railing against Interfaith might just have you know in your case qualms against what the Muslim Brotherhood and other islamists are trying to do now we have a question from the Middle East forum's president Daniel pipes here he says uh thank you Dr kadine for joining our podcast I have two questions first was there a specific event that changed your outlook and uh are there lessons that you can draw from your experience I wouldn't say Mr pipes that there was one specific event I think it was a multitude of events in 2018 I started traveling to UAE uh as part of the for for promoting peace and Muslim societies under Shake bin Baya this is part of the early uh efforts to normalize relations between the UAE and Israel and that's when I started getting backlash uh from individuals who are either directly linked to the Muslim
10:46 Brotherhood or their sympathizers and their allies and this obviously is rooted in a uh a deeper anti-israel anti-semitic uh ideology that we find Within the Muslim Brotherhood and then of course you know I traveled to the UAE for for years and uh I went to the O the the inauguration of the abrahamic family house uh which was which was Monumental one of the the great um professional experiences I've ever had and you know it's interesting too like hatam bazan I'm sure everyone knows who hatam bazan is he recently commented over social media on X that I started changing when I went to the UAE and he's actually right because I started listening really for the first time to Elder to Jewish elders and to Muslim Elders who were committed to a vision of the Middle East that was about
11:48 peace and that had a massive massive impact on me and I'll never forget it and then also in 2020 when I published my book under uh Blue Dome press the humanity Muhammad a Christian view it became quite popular and it got around into you know the public and into Political spheres and it was almost like it was too successful and they didn't like the fact that I was Bridging the Gap between Islam and the West this perceived Gap that we're talking about and they started pulling back uh or they started not not pulling back their support for me but also attacking me and real Qui just not to interrupt you uh when you say they you mean the islamists right you mean like the brother groups yes yeah but it's it's bigger than the islamists and in the Brotherhood too it's like as we were talking earlier like there there are so many uh organizations and and um uh sections of
12:53 the wider Muslim American community that are buying into the ideology and they don't even know it that's what I think they don't even they don't even know it so there was there was a lot of different things also in 2021 like I started getting hacked on social media uh quite regularly uh to the point where the authorities had to get involved I can't share too many uh examples about this but uh I think this is largely due to the work that I was doing with the hiset movement the gulan movement which is obviously the arch nemesis of erdogan in Turkey which we all know has been promoting islamist and Brotherhood Antics for years now and then also getting push back from entities in Pakistan and the jamaat islami which we also know is part of the Brotherhood Network right so like there's a bunch of different elements that kind of came
13:55 together and created this perfect storm for me where I really had to think inward like what what is happening why is it happening and who is attacking me and I'm not an idiot and I figured out who was attacking me and that's why I I started saying there's no there's no chance I can support this that's uh that's so interesting but it's also so telling that uh it seems like the Crux of everybody uh sort of turning on you was you writing a book about Interfaith and Bridging the Gap between Islam and Christianity um we have a few questions coming in from some attendees here uh I'll start with this one from Ken Cohen what will be the most effective avenues for full court press education of misinformed students and others this year uh others I assume being the uh the fellow Travelers that you sort of mentioned who don't know what sort of service they're providing to the people uh whose goals advancing I must say Mr Cohen U I am
15:00 very concerned with uh this challenge um especially in Academia and I wish I had a uh clearcut easy uh digestible remedy for it but I'm I'm afraid I don't and I think Academia is so deeply embedded in far-left ideology especially Marxism um which is obviously I think if anyone knows what the islamist agenda and the Brotherhood is all about it it it banks on Marxist uh divide and conquer black and white type of ideology so it starts with Academia but not in the classroom I think it starts with the upper echelons of these institutions uh getting proper leadership and making sure that hiring practices don't contribute to Echo
16:04 Chambers and safe spaces uh we need to get back to getting critical thinking critical thinking into the classrooms and into Academia and then also and this is something I'm I'm I'm very concerned about and it's all part of the the the Marxist islamist kind of takeover of Academia we are you know I'm I'm a professor at at Rice there is so much sentiment within Academia at large rice does a lot of great things but there's also a lot of like we have teaching the youth to hate their country that's suicidal that's like civilizational suicide that's National Suicide this country obviously has a lot to work on every country does but it's still one of the best countries in the world if not the best country in the world so it does start in Academia but I'm not sure that uh there's an easy
17:10 remedy here and I'm very concerned also about the fall very concerned about the fall so uh inside of Academia can you uh speak a little bit about where you see the sources of some of uh some of these professors and academics who are misguiding these years you um do you uh do you have experience or any understanding that these professors are funded from foreign governments or from nonprofits or for groups like care well I think this is something that's been popping up uh post 7 October World about where money is coming from um in uh through the foreign realm to different universities in the US I know like China and katar are two of the funders um I don't know exactly where to pinpoint it you know and I'm not kind of throwing my colleagues under the bus and saying that they're all you know bot I
18:12 don't I don't think it's that but uh certainly the foreign money has a huge element to this I think anyone that would dismiss that is just being devoid of reality but I I think it's more of a a structural fundamental deeply ingrained issue within Western Academia that we've gone too far left we've gone too far left like in my classes like I promote Civic values and religious pluralism and and and and tolerance to a certain degree and it's oftentimes it's like I'm I'm speaking to a wall that they just don't even understand why these things are important you know freedom of speech freedom of religion freedom of conscience the right to own property the right to vote the right to assembly all of these things don't seem to matter uh to you know I'm not I'm not painting I'm not trying to paint a wide brush on all students but it is very real in Academia and that is very very
19:16 concerning to me uh it's all this super leftwing Marxist you know utopian ideal like let's just destroy everything and then voila we're going to have a a Eureka moment and everything is going to sort itself out I mean it it's honestly a little mad uh and it's and it's very difficult to operate in these spaces all right thank you um now we have another question here from Sam westrop uh he asks what hope is there in your opinion for anti-islamist Muslims to take back their communities from radical control and how can non-muslims government and others improve their chances another uh T tough question um and I hate to be a pessimist because I'm not really but I'm not sure that there is a ton of hope to be honest you know even in my own work um I've been working with the mdia Muslim Community for years
20:21 since 2015 since I moved to Houston and when 7 October happened uh they I was surprised at the position that they took because they had been advocating for years for Interfaith dialogue and they also have a chapter in hia in Israel in Northern Israel and it was like to see them basically adopt the position of the islamist was shocking to me it literally shocked me and I was I was hurt and the connection with them was dropped off and I had hope for them I really did I I had hope for them uh because their values aligned with my values as a Christian but also my values as an American freedom of speech freedom of religion all the things that I mentioned in the question even the hiset movement the gulen movement they also stand by these similar principles through my experience
21:27 with them which has been extensive and they haven't been saying much of anything which is de facto nothing you're not supporting or doing anything so I honestly don't know where the American Muslim Community is going and I've told people uh even online like ahed rehab uh the the the president of the the care Chicago chapter he was uh crapping on me on on social media and I I I was like literally I'm afraid for y'all I don't know where y'all are going you're you're putting yourselves on an island and it's not a good Island you're putting all your eggs into one basket uh super leftwing and it's it's not it I don't think it's good and I think what we're seeing too if I can add a little uh political Dynamic here we're seeing the the far left politicians in the in the squad they're losing their elections they're not even getting to
22:29 the election they're losing their primaries so I think folks are losing touch in the American Muslim Community with just everyday kind of Americans you know the kind of neutral moderate uh they can maybe swing both both ways uh they're they're losing touch unfortunately all right well thank you now you mentioned earlier uh in this interview about your visit to the United Arab Emirates uh have a question here from Sarah forgive me if I butcher this muru uh who asks the United Arab Emirates condemns the Muslim Brotherhood as a terrorist organization why is it that the United States is not able to follow up with well uh because I think that the Muslim Brotherhood is uh deeply ingrained into the Democratic Party and I think there's a lot of evidence to
23:31 to show that um from the Grassroots level uh to uh Rashid to ilhan Omar uh to people around the Biden Administration or apparently Harris who is apparently running the country now uh well uh so I think that has a big that has a big part to do with it um I think the Republican party and this is one of the reasons why I'm actually moving towards the Republican party because they're very clear they're very clear on this issue that this movement this islamist movement whatever you want to call it is not good for this country it's not and their their rejection of the Abraham Accords to me is maddening because that is about peace and you cannot you know they try to politicize it they try to say it's about throwing the Palestinians under the us let me give you a a quick example the LA the second to last time I
24:34 was there I was giving a talk at New York University and I was getting a tour of KAS Al watan and I was walking around in the grand hall and there was a Jewish uh there was a Jewish couple there and this Jewish man came up to me he said can you take a picture of my wife and I and I said absolutely and I I didn't know he was Jewish at the time but when I got his phone I saw he Hebrew and I said oh are are you are you are you Jewish are you from Israel obviously probably and he's like this is amazing I never ever would have thought that we would be in the UAE we were in Abu Dhabi I never thought we would be in the in Abu Dhabi uh two years ago like how how are we so devoid of reality where something like the Abraham Accords isn't a good thing it just blows my mind it's so hyper polii right now that people are just not even understanding that peace is good peace is good and uh no you're I think you're totally right um the hyper
25:39 politicization and uh what you kind of mentioned earlier about some of the the supp if not all of the support for these islamist organizations being embedded inside of modern leftwing ideologies certainly the kind I teach on campuses um now now speaking of that uh you may or may not have seen recently some of the uh Buzz In The Press about the pick for the uh kamla Harris campaigns vice president Tim Walls awarding $100,000 uh to a islamist leader who among other things he did not condemn October 7th he has been on the record praising Hitler um Iman Assad Zaman is his name uh what what can you say about that what can you say about the of people to not separate these things and still just blindly kind of vote for their politics I mean honestly uh Mr walls he served uh though he's been lying about his
26:42 service let me say this bluntly as a white dude I feel like he's just trying to be the good white dude you know like a good white person just supports Muslims you know like that's an that's anti-racism you know that that is what uh makes America better and he doesn't even know who he's working with like I will say I was guilty of that being naive being a good person I like to think of myself as a good person like I'm trying to do good but I was duped and I think he was absolutely duped and he had no idea about the trail the obvious trail behind this Imam uh and then we we Splinter it down to ilhan Omar you know who who uh who met with erdogan you know and and and and some of her anti- blatant anti uh anti-American Jew hatred comments there's no place for that in this country there's no place so I think it's part of this woke ideology you know
27:47 it's like to to be a good person you just got to support every like every minority group or whatever you want to call it minority or or religion and like you just have to do it and if you don't do it you're racist and I've come to learn the hard way that that is a bunch of BS right it's uh it's through this sort of critical race critical uh identity lens of uh everything is seen through the lens of victim victimizer oppressed depressy it's it's Marxism I mean read Marx I mean he he laid it out oppressor versus the oppressed uh during your time while uh you were kind of uh I never know how to phrase this but let's just say in the service of some of these uh islamist groups did you see that sort of ideology explicitly manifest uh in groups like care or in other islamist groups or uh was it something kind of later on that started meshing itself with the current political climate yeah it it came it came later when I started getting
28:52 backlash and I think a lot of that had had to do with my work in the UAE when I started getting backlash I started investigating um who these groups were why they may not like me and then this kind of big Labyrinth just came in front of me and all these connections were just being uh uh showing themselves and they became very um uh apparent uh but you know a lot of my journey had to do with just being a product of Western Academia you know like a lot especially as a sociologist you know like I spent a lot of time in as a as a in the social sciences and a lot of the social sciences are are about this kind of you know anti-west you know the West is bad white people are bad Christians are bad nuclear families are bad I mean it's just it's it's kind of mad you know and like geez if maybe if I was a genius or something I would have been able to see through it but you know I was I was young um but um you know
29:58 thank God uh the light bulb went off and now it's like a it's almost like a different world honestly like once once I saw it was it was more about Marxism than anything once I saw Marxism and I saw How Deeply ingrained it was everywhere I mean it's a bit scary and it really transformed me and then I started realizing that the islamists are banking on uh marxists and their sympathizers to push all this stuff right thank you now um I see that we have reached uh the end of our time here uh I don't want to keep you any longer I don't know if you have any other obligations here but uh we have plenty of questions coming in let's do some more than I uh more than I have time to read them quickly enough in time but um if you have a few moments I'd love to continue for a moment please great well thank you um so uh internationally the Muslim Brotherhood seems to be in but it still feels like in the United
31:00 States that the Muslim Brotherhood Legacy groups exert the most influence as Muslim Community institutions and I think you kind of touched on this uh with our discussion on Academia and the left and all this woke stuff but um why do you think that is that uh they still have such prominence in the states I think a lot of it has to do with how deeply connected they are to the Democratic party uh and a lot of the talking points that you see from uh Democratic leaders uh from the very top are filtering down and and filtering up uh so I think that's a that's a huge huge part of it I'd also like to push back on this idea that the Muslim Brotherhood is declining internationally like I'm not sure that's I'm not sure that's true you know what we've seen over the last five to six years um especially since the sighting of the Abraham Accords as Qatar is an increasingly influential entity in international relations and
32:02 unfortunately they right smack in the middle of the issue in Israel um unfortunately uh and we've we've known that they are uh propping up uh Muslim Brotherhood related entities um in the United States and around the world uh Al jazer is obviously uh doing a great job of controlling the narrative especially among the youth uh in this country what we see in Bangladesh recently as well uh I mean no one's talking about that either uh the role that the Muslim Brotherhood played in uh the recent crisis uh in Bangladesh and obviously you know Hamas is doing its thing and like that that's obviously linked to the Muslim Brotherhood turkey is doing their thing Egypt is kind of wavering right now I'm not sure what Egypt is doing but I'm not sure that they're losing influence internationally I I really don't and I think in this country
33:05 they're flourishing and it's not just because of Muslims it's because of how well Muslims have spread propaganda and by by Muslims I mean these organizations uh and and in mosques and in their centers and in their organizations how they've successfully politicized everything and it's not even about Islam anymore it's not about spirituality it's not about you know connecting to God it's none of that it's all politics and they're all democrats for the most part which I think at this point in time is not a good thing it really isn't it is a uh interesting Dynamic that uh yes politically they seem to want to align themselves with Democrats when uh uh you you make this distinction of course that uh they're not all uh religious Muslims but uh conservative Islam is very different than what the Democratic party has to offer but seems to be a very convenient vehicle to get
34:07 their uh to get their ideas across now on that note um I wouldn't put you into this group but um would you say that there are non-muslim islamists in other words people who Advance the uh goals and Ambitions of islamist groups while uh while not being Muslim themselves absolutely um and as a college professor and someone who follows Academia very closely uh knowing what groups like um the Muslim Brotherhood care um SJP Muslim American society isna um they're all pushing left-wing talking points decolonization critical race Theory social justice all this stuff and this is what the the youth um a big chunk of the youth in this country like this is what they think is right and if you're not if you're not for it then
35:12 racist or somehow you're like not with program and to be a a white person uh pushing these things in the classroom you get a lot of you get a lot of push back a lot of push back and like here we are like I'm at a point now where pushing Civic values Civic values basic American values and I'm all for D I'm all for diversity but like people need to buy in people need to buy in and realize how good they have it in this country you know my next book that's coming out Beyond dialogue building bonds with Christians and Muslims I look at all the the the horrific incidences throughout history and in the modern world uh Christians are a massively persec uh persecuted group in the in the in the world look at Nigeria look at Pakistan even countries like Saudi Arabia and when you bring this up to the youth and to and students it's like they're like there's no way because
36:14 they're Christian and they probably think Christian is white because they're American and they've been programmed to think this way so we there's a lot of work to be done um I think it's it's multifaceted a lot of it does start with education but a lot of it starts with our political leaders and I'm afraid the Democratic party not to say that the Republican party is perfect either but the Democratic party has I think lost plot now uh when you have these discussions in your classes even just uh the very basic barebone Civic discussions not pertaining to Islam or islamism or faith or theology uh are your students generally receptive do they push back or they uh how do how do they feel about that yeah it depends I mean there's a lot of brilliant students at Rice who I think uh get the importance of these these constitutional rights and values and they understand the importance of freedom of speech um they understand the values
37:19 that are deeply ingrained in the society but even with the issue of freedom of speech you know like even saying something like I'm for controll migration or I I want to be uh I want to vote accordingly so we can uh defend the borders like that is that is seen that is perceived by a lot of people as like racist right or even on my social media lately I've been pushing back against the Muslim Brotherhood and a lot of Muslim Students who have been in my classes and a lot of Muslims the Jonathan Browns and the Nathan leans of the world are now saying racist because I'm calling out um a a movement and an ideology that anyone with a sane mind would understand is not good for this country it's not good for this country because it's it's fundamentally opposing basic values that were entrenched in the 18th century so it's
38:23 it's a it's a tough it's a tough navigation um you know a lot of the times I just feel like I'm talking to the wall unfortunately now when you can get some of these uh younger students to uh you know understand the importance of uh western civilization and the American uh the American political system and the freedoms and the Constitution that we all enjoy uh from there to be able to get them to understand why those things are important and need to be defended against the threats they face uh that's got to be a challenge considering that the other side the the so to speak the woke side has kind of said that these things are all bad and that uh that uh who cares if let's say the islamists have their way and their uh these beloved freedoms and values we express are in danger uh how do you navigate that I mean I tried to emphasize individualism as much as possible you know I think a lot of this
39:25 identity politics stuff is forcing young people and everyone really into tribes into communitarianism so if you look a certain way or if you believe a certain way you have to think a certain way which is really the antithesis of uh what the American Experience is is really all about or experiment if I should say that so I'm trying to teach um you know and this is this goes back to the Marxism thing I was talking about we have to start molding shaping teaching individuals to think independently to think critically and not to be enslaved by identity politics this is I think this is one of the greatest challenges that we have uh because what what we're seeing in America it's like it's like white vers everything that's not white and even Jews are now being thrown into the white
40:28 category which I think is is questionable to begin with the uh the white colonizer category of all things too you know like I'm Irish and Italian when when students are like you're white uh like you're you're guilty of of colonization I'm like my God you have no clue what you're talking about you know like especially in Ireland like I I've done my ancestral genealogical history I'm I'm a pseudo scholar on Irish history and and to accuse me of being guilty like I'm I'm somehow responsible uh for white supremacy in America is absolutely ridiculous but that's but that's where we're at you know and if I said this often times I can't say this in class I cannot say this in class because it would it would create a uh it would create a massive ruffle and like this is also part of the issue just the freedom of speech like just being able to think critically like I'm I'm I'm not a a enslave to my
41:32 identity politics you know I am me I have my own lived experience I was raised a certain way I know what my history is I have values I have principles these are the things that should uh I should be judged upon not uh my ethnicity or my race how uh how far we've Fallen now um I I don't want to keep you too long here so I've got a a couple more um I wanted to ask Will other islamist groups fully replace the Brotherhood in the west as Muslim reader as Muslim leaders modern salafis certainly seem to be gaining ground as do various South Asian Sunni islamists uh what are your predictions about the future of islamism in the west and in the United States well I think the sufy crowd uh they need to be more organized I don't think they have the structure that the Muslim Brotherhood has the likes of care the MSA masas isna nna all this stuff um so they're fully
42:40 entrenched I don't see an upset happening anytime soon of uh some of these you know Underdog islamist movements coming out of nowhere I think a lot of those are more localized uh I think I think their numbers are are smaller um but I don't see it happening anytime soon to be honest and I think again the political inroads that the most of Brotherhood has made with the Democratic party is massive absolutely massive and it's happening at the very very top right thank you now uh I suppose I will close with this question um now through your journey kind of uh being not recruited but uh kind of put in the service of uh groups like the Muslim Brotherhood and uh other islamist organizations and your subsequent disavow and moving away from them what are some of the lessons that you could draw from your experience that uh the rest of us can maybe learn from
43:44 you very good question and I hate to be a pessimist but be skeptical understand that groups entities have political objectives so encouraging people to think about the potential political implications of their allyship right their their social justice efforts uh it was mentioned in the description of this event you know like all Is Not What It Seems and like that is that is true so do your homework uh be cautious interact with people though engage you know I'm not I'm not telling anyone to be timid uh and and to be reserved you know go out there it's America you have the you have the opportunity to do that thank God so go out there uh do your thing but also do
44:49 your homework and and doing your homework make sure you're not just reading from one political tribe make sure to read across the aisle read everything not just fox or CNN read both uh and and and do your homework and then you can make a um a sound decision and then also and this is going back to my previous point about just being an uh uh don't feel like you need to be inherently attached to any group Because of Who You Are or what you believe in be yourself that's most important well thank you that is very Sound Advice uh I wish uh myself and people uh when I was in college took that to heart but uh at at any rate we thank you Dr consedine for joining us this has been a fantastic discussion we have more questions than I am even able
45:53 to scroll through and read I wish we could get to all of them um but for our viewers and audience is there somewhere where they can go where they can follow more of your work yeah I'm on uh pretty much all the social media except for Tik Tok refuse to get on Tik Tok for obvious reasons um but um I'm working on a book um about to sign a contract um hopefully in the next few days but it's going to look at the intersection uh and the relationship between Marxism and islamism in the United States um it's been written about before like David Horowitz has written about it asro nanii just wrote about it this Unholy Alliance but I'm going to write about it from a sociological perspective and also include some of my own personal experiences so I'd encourage folks to be on the lookout for that I'll be sharing more information about it but I appreciate everyone being there and if anyone who is listening if you have more questions you can email me all right great thank you we will uh
46:55 we'll be on the lookout for that upcoming book uh if you are watching this uh on the future recording on our YouTube page I will be sure to link Dr kadan's social media account to the video description here and for all of you watching uh please be on the lookout for our Israel Insider podcast this Wednesday at 3M with Ashley Perry and as always I thank you all again for joining us and for your participation and I hope you all have a wonderful day thank you