Israel Insider
Israel Insider with Ashley Perry
Watch on YouTube
Description
The government appears to be teetering on the brink with seemingly opposite demands from all directions. How long can the coalition survive?
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 4, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:00 all right good afternoon and welcome to the middle east forums webinar and podcast series israel insider with ashley perry i'm stacy roman and i will be moderating this discussion today we are pleased to have mr ashley perry advisor to the middle east forum's israel office join us here each wednesday at 3 pm eastern to update us on all the events going on in israel mr perry will be giving us a briefing on current israeli affairs for 15 minutes then open it up for questions should you wish to ask a question please use the q a box located at the bottom of your screen to type your question now with no further ado i'll turn the discussion over to mr ashley perry thank you very much stacey and good evening from israel uh tonight for those who don't know is a solemn night in israel it's when israel commemorates the holocaust holocaust remembrance day which begins at eight o'clock israel uh with an official ceremony at yad vashem israel's official holocaust remembrance um where
1:04 usually you know the most senior dignitaries the president prime minister and other israeli leaders speak and tortures are lit in memory of the six million who are uh who were murdered but it's also usually a time where certain political messages are passed along you know there's there's always an opportunity for those sort of things uh when prime minister netanyahu was in office there was barely a holocaust remembrance day where he didn't use it as an opportunity to bring up iran and compare iran and the ayatollahs and their threats to wipe israel off the map comparing it with the nazi genocide of the jewish people and the fact that israel should not wait uh for someone to actually try and actualize uh their threats uh the one thing that you know jews say that we've learned from the holocaust is when someone tries to
2:05 murder us we should we should take them at their words uh tonight for the first time uh in 13 years we had someone uh speaking in the prime minister's uh speech at least and we had naftali bennett and he delivered a speech um which basically was you know a relatively powerful course to a certain extent about the importance of israel and if uh if israel had been there you know the holocaust wouldn't have happened and you know and but he went into anti-semitism he also went and talked about holocaust uh appropriation trivialization those who try and compare things to the holocaust we've seen quite a lot of that uh recently with kovid with what's going on in ukraine and other things going around the world uh the most interesting part let's say politically was towards the he spoke for a minute or two uh which i expected about unity uh interestingly he used the um the example
3:09 of the fact that during the famous or infamous uh warsaw ghetto uprising those few jews who were left in the warsaw ghetto before it was liquidated the final few people rounded up and said to auschwitz uh some of the jews got together to try and fight back they sparkled weapons in etc etc it was uh it's considered one of the more heroic of the holocaust and what natalie bennett touched on was the fact that there were two groups working not side by side but you know even against each other there was the left-wing socialist group and the right revisionist group and natalie bennett basically made the point that even in our darkest moment when the enemies were clear even then the right and the left did not come together and basically were fighting and squabbling and disagreeing and not speaking to each other not working together in the face of a mutual enemy now the reason he chose uh to bring up
4:12 this example was because especially over the last couple of weeks it's been a couple of weeks since we met because of the passover holiday um there's been a sort of up in the ante of hostility uh between the coalition and the opposition specifically between former prime minister netanyahu and his supporters and uh prime minister nathalie bennett uh this is definitely been taken up a notch ever since edith zillman the yamina former coalition uh whip uh left uh the and or left the government and decided to to go with the opposition with the promise of a position in the next government etc uh definitely there was a certain amount of momentum in your position so some of the abuse and attacks certainly uh traded in the last couple of weeks as a result of that we saw earlier in the week there was a report on a major israeli investigative news program which showed that uh
5:16 naftali bennett is prime minister and should be sitting or should be living in the house on balfour street in jerusalem as prime ministers uh do and even there's a law that the prime minister muslim jerusalem but because of a variety of factors some to do with his personal family he's got much younger kids than uh than any prime arguably ever or certainly a living so you know they don't want to upend their life as much as possible his is 16 years old and i think he has four children some of them are relatively but the other reason is the shoe beds the israel domestic security agency or intelligence agencies making amendments uh necessary security amendments to the prime minister's residence so at the moment it's unlivable uh that's the claim um but because of that they're still living in the house in manana there's been massive fortifications as you can imagine to make it secure
6:18 um so you know these sort of sums were released to the the general public and some other sort of interesting tidbits about how much money they spend and it turns out they spend um trying to remember now something like twelve thousand shekels which is about four thousand dollars a month on takeaway they this is well within what they're allowed to spend you know they obviously have a budget uh usually you can have a chef which actually costs a lot more than that but they've decided to issue a chef and they basically used a lot of that banquet budget for takeaways uh those sort of um things all came out to the meeting as you can imagine your position had a field day with it uh bennett's camp uh created a graph showing that no matter how much he may or may not spend it is you know a fraction of what the netanyahu family spent you know points were made that netanyahu uh was taking state money for uh two of his private homes he has um at least two private
7:20 homes one in uh caesarea uh by the beach uh further north of jerusalem further north of tel aviv and another one not far from the official residence um on gaza street uh in jerusalem and a lot of work was done there and gardening and pool uh work on the pool and you know there was all these claims which actually came out that the netanyahu family not only had a chef but they were also ordering high-priced take uh ice cream for thousands of shekels and and all sorts of others so it was an interesting back and forth uh personally on twitter uh between whoever runs bennett's accountant whoever runs netanyahu's account obviously uh with the full approval of the principles but i think it's relatively unique that you have an open twitter feud at that by a sitting head of government and a former head of government but that's where we are at the moment this all came to a head in the last
8:22 couple of days with the revelation that the bennett family was sent in the mail a threatening letter with a bullet now um you know especially in israel there's a heightened sensitivity to these sort of things especially if we remember back to the assassination of vietnam in 1995 um so the idea of a prime minister being assassinated uh in office is certainly out of the realm of possibility uh not out of the realm of reality it is something which israel has experienced in the past so there's a heightened sensitivity to it the security detail around uh not just the prime minister uh but his family and other senior members of the government was heightened as a result there is a belief that there is a a possible threat and it just goes into some of the sort of threats and the language that's being used against specifically right-wing members of this government so um that's what's been uh going on on that uh there's been other political theater
9:26 uh earlier in the week there was the knesset showdown uh if we were talking about uh indeed silman who was the latest renegade myanmar member we have to go back to amihai shikhli who basically from the beginning as an elected member of the arena party decided not to go with the government and sat in protest with the opposition and basically voted against the government not just for the law uh the formation of the government and the the budget and all the important votes but pretty much every single vote has voted with the opposition all the way through uh it got to a point where basically amine decided to take the drastic step and this has only happened to other occasions uh in the knesset history as a party has decided to officially a member of his party as quitting the party uh pooresh has has left the party uh but it had to go through a vote in the knesset committee uh and as you can imagine it was a tremendous opportunity for the
10:28 media for the opposition to try and land some shots and those prepared speeches and there was lawyers and there was people shouting and calling each other traitor and all that sort of thing um as one can imagine you know everything kind of fell along uh coalition opposition lines seven out of 12 members of the committee uh i think even maybe even eight out of 13 or something like that they they had a very significant majority so there was very little doubt about the outcome although it is suggested that it will be appealed uh to the uh jerusalem district court um but basically the opposition decided not to even attend the vote so it uh went through uh you know unanimously indeed silman did turn up but she decided not to vote in the end but what really happened at this was basically it wasn't really about any height shooting obviously the event itself was uh but it was more as a show by the naftali bennett shaked the remaining yamina parties in the
11:30 coalition to send a message uh to idiot tillman that if you decide because obviously she quit uh without the knesset uh sitting so it's it's unsure exactly how she'll vote will she vote with the opposition will she vote possibly with the coalition on certain issues or she abstain all of these as you can imagine are very very important with that knesset sitting at 60 60 uh with no side having the majority is very crucial how she'll vote so most of this by the amina party was to send a message to it solomon that if you uh you know you better watch yourself or you could be treated exactly like uh shitley why is it important that um someone get this designation of being sort of quitting the party because this means that they will not be able to run in the next election uh with an existing party now there are there is talk of amikai shikhli uh starting his own party which should be legitimate uh to do and run with that but obviously that's certainly not a surefire way of getting
12:32 into the connection running within he could which is probably the most likely uh is a sure way of getting back into the can i said that at the moment as long as the jerusalem district court does not strike down this decision he will not be able to run with liquids in the next elections and there's various other sanctions as well it obviously hurts you i mean every time they decide to uh force a member out because then they get less campaign funding before the next elections but this was all about uh uh uh it did so man rather than america uh furthermore what's going to be very interesting in the days or week and a bit ahead until the opening of the summer session of the knesset is exactly what is happening in the coalition the latest party to threaten and even has gone a little bit further than just threatened have basically suspended uh their role in the government is the iran party the islamist arab party uh which basically ever since
13:33 the riots on the temple mount and what they claim is the excessive reaction by the israeli police and security forces they have decided to suspend all cooperation with the government um i mean that's some have suggested especially the opponents of the arab uh society that this is an empty threat at this point because there's no knesset and there's nothing really going on for them to suspend their involvement with would be interesting to see come may 8th whether this continues what is happening within the party is it's evenly split it's a four member party two of the members including the leader manso abbas who's really his reputation and cooperation with israeli government with with the right left and center in israel and taking this unique position of being part of an israeli coalition once wants to remain in the government but there is another faction who basically wants to leave it's led by uh vanayam who is
14:36 a former mayor of safranin and it is said that he probably will go back to municipal politics and run for that position again next year so this could be a part of his saber rattling he said at the moment i do not feel beholden i'm not sure if i'm gonna return to the coalition it's gonna take a lot he's taken a far more he's leading the more hard uh hardline position within iran so we'll be very interested to see who uh wins out on that particular thing because there are only days now uh something like 10 or 11 days until the knesset uh returns and without uh this government's days are numbered even more uh than they were before finally uh on the diplomatic front it's interesting to note that uh natalie bennett and president uh biden spoke and it's uh it emerges that president biden is coming in the next few months to visit israel this will certainly bolster naftali bennett's some have said that ever since indeed
15:40 someone left uh his diplomatic position has been weakened and he's been more ignored and put on the sidelines by the international community so the fact that president biden has declared that he would like to come to israel and apparently things are moving on that front uh shows that there is uh still especially by you know the leader of the us is a significant gesture um that they they still have some confidence in this particular government and they're certainly not uh it would be much easier to ignore and not put out a statement about it but the fact that there's an official statement that president biden will come to it over the next few months only a little bit of momentum back to naphtali bennett certainly after a difficult few weeks so with that i'm happy to answer any questions on these or any other issues all right thank you so much first question we have is from j.r pride do you think this is the most unstable government in israel's recent memory and do you think another
16:42 election is in the near future i'll start with the last thing yes i do believe that first of all we know that by next march this government unless there's again events like it did someone returning she said she's not going to return maybe someone from the opposition another possibility by the way um that could turn it back to 61 59 is if amikai shikley decides one way to get out of this punishment that he can't run in the next elections with an established party is if he quits the connection but if he quits the connection the next person in the amina comes in and the next person neomina will be far more beholden to naftali bennett and will give back that 61.59 so the opposition will be putting a lot of pressure to ensure that if [ __ ] he does not resign or if he does it'll be maybe at a point where the government is already on its way down perhaps um but barring any of these really
17:45 i would say unlikely uh scenarios this days are numbered because when everyone knows that it has a sell-by date uh as it were then every party within it will try and uh you know sort of shuttle for position try and make issues that they think will speak to their base uh maybe even leave the government according to what they see is uh that will play best to their supporters so you know we already seen this happen as i said rahm already doing that we saw merits do that before we saw other members of yamina do it so everyone's got to think about their political future and when you know this government almost certainly will not last beyond next march uh every um member of knesset that alone party leader is starting to think how am i going into the next elections what achievements have i got to show what what are my issues um so so i think these are uh reasons why i don't think it's you know it's it's going to even reach march
18:47 um is it the it's certainly one of the uh the least stable governments if you look at the makeup it's there's more parties in this government than in any time in israel's history and especially with such diverse figures as as i've said many times before i think if you lift it up to the leaders the leaders will find a way to patch it up and work together there is going to be a meeting i believe on sunday of all the party leaders to try and work together but again because it's especially now in 60 60 any single member of knesset can bring down this government can stop uh votes happening it's it's not necessarily in the leader's hands anymore because each of them could have a renegade or even just someone who decides that they want to be in another party or they can name for themselves or maybe they've got uh aspirations uh elsewhere like i said uh with a member of connect who they say has aspirations to return uh to be may of suffering so there's so many permutations there which
19:49 certainly make it extremely unstable but they did manage to stabilize a little bit after this and stop the momentum of the opposition after um after the latest yamina mk left uh did so and so you know it could last through the summer session that'll be very very key because obviously after that you then get a nice big recess and then you have the jewish holidays and then already we're starting to get to the end of the year so i think in the next couple of months once the commencement returns will really be crucial for the longevity of this thank you and i know we have a entire webinar coming up on the temple mount but anonymous attendee asked will israel seek control of the temple mount to the jordanians as per mr blinken's well first of all you know it's a very complicated question israel has official sovereignty it's within the borders what israel considers under its sovereignty most of the rest of the world do not consider that the u.s did
20:52 recognize israel's sovereignty under the trump administration the ban administration has kept to that um but ever since 1967 israel did hand off the day-to-day running of the temple except for security issues to the jordanian established and funded wife which are the islamic religious authorities so i don't think anything's going to change there jordan still has is a major player um i didn't hear of any suggestion that things will change everyone keeps on talking about the status quo so i can't imagine the status quo will change i can't imagine that israel will give up or seed any less control and i can't uh see the jordanians seating any of their less control so i think at the end of all this unfortunately this is probably going to become an annual happening now because of what happened last year i think there'll be certain understandings at the moment they're trying to reach understandings with some arab leaders to try and calm the situation the israeli security forces is working day and night to try and take uh
21:56 you know take out uh either arrest or otherwise some terrorists and some organizations which are trying to take advantage of this and um but israel is trying to ride out the ramadan period which also as as we saw uh included pesach and now it's including holocaust remembrance day and next week will have um israel's independence day and and within that also you have i think per day which is what uh the palestinians refer to and they celebrate or commemorate every year with riots so it's a tense time all round but i think everyone's trying to get through but i can't imagine after the dust has settled that there will be any major changes to the status quo thank you len levin asks has it been a plus or a minus to israeli jews and to the israeli arabs for the iran party to be a part of the coalition government well that's a very difficult question to
22:57 answer because it depends where you sit on the political map it's only historic it's certainly unprecedented it certainly shatters glass ceilings if you will which means that uh potentially we could see this a lot more uh manso abbas uh it certainly remains committed to the government as i said he has pressure uh and there are many who feel that they should have quit the government even a week ago um the religious council talked about quitting the government so because right it's a religious party we should remember and it does have like some of the jewish religious parties it does have a religious council which advises and it advises advise them to leave there is a you know the whole issue around what happened on the temple mount is is very important for many in the arab street so they're very angry to see you know don't forget the images they see it's not always the truth and certainly taken out of context when they see israeli uh police and security forces what they claim attacking uh muslims who are on the temple mount
24:00 obviously uh they most of them if you have seen before we're writing and creating trouble and throwing uh stones and molotov cocktails from the mosques uh sometimes onto the western water down onto the western wall uh plaza where jews are praying uh but it's created we shouldn't underestimate the anchor of these images that they've been seeing on the arab streets there's a lot of pressure on iran to leave um they have got some i would say at this point minor um it'd be interesting to see at the moment polls have shown around not growing but not decreasing i mean this is i haven't seen a poll since everything that went off on the temple mount but uh up until now i think there is a still sizable chunk of arab society that does want to be more involved that does want to see their representation in the decision-making process in the government rather than just sitting in the opposition as the joint arab list does and will continue to do basically just complaining so i think the jury is out on that and it depends where you sit on the map but i
25:04 i think most israelis you know when you take them aside i think the majority of israelis will say that they think that this is this is an important experiment and hopefully it has broken some of those glass ceilings understood thank you uh carrie hillebrand asks has the war in ukraine impacted the israel russia d conflict arrangements in syria not yet that's what i would say at the moment but israel is moving far more robustly towards a western position it did attend or it is attempting a group a conference around i think 14 nations which is deciding how to aid most countries will only do defensively um ukraine and uh israel is attempting that which i don't think a few weeks ago would have is taking a far more robust position and it's certainly annoying the russians the russians are very unhappy and they put their own ease to israel they've cited against israel
26:07 on this whole issue of what's been happening in the temple mount came up very unequivocally not to say in the past they haven't but certainly they're displaying their uh their disagreement with israel's position themselves closer to the americans and the europeans on ukraine with um with more harsh rhetoric against each other and i think the idea of israel now playing a mediating role in trying to you know try to duck between the the droplets as it were is no longer really uh you know it doesn't really uh stand up too much but you know still uh they're gonna try as much as possible because of all the reasons i've explained in the russia is still a very important player in the region and especially for israel what's going on in syria and even on iran so israel can't be seen to take too harsh a position against russia quite simply because it's security and safety of citizens are at stake and we saw even i think it was last night or night before that israel continues to launch strikes against
27:10 uh hezbollah against iranian uh interest in syria and israel needs to be able to continue that and russia simply allows it at this point whether that will continue remains to be seen and also will be sort of tested how far the comes from israel and exactly what israel supplies ukraine at the end of the day thank you so much um david levine asks it appears that turkey has been making a number of conciliatory gestures towards israel in the last few weeks can you comment on this yeah i mean we talked about this a few weeks ago but uh yeah i mean it's it seems that erdogan president erdogan does want to turn over new leaf it's not because he said become a zionist there's there's inherent interests the turkish economy is flailing uh it's basically outside america's sort of allies at this point in the region they witness israel's coming closer to the uae to bahrain to other major players in
28:14 the region even egypt which turkey wants also to make nice with him so they understand but they also have to make nice to israel so they have taken some conciliatory steps we saw president herzog in ankara a few weeks ago and conversations between prime minister bennett and president erdogan and uh so for the moment that it's in total it certainly is in turkey's interest to um to turn over this new leaf to reset uh turkish israel relations and i think that will continue in the near future but um you know even even by the way i should say even now with everything that's gone on the temple mount in the past we saw very harsh uh statements from turkey we did see criticism that's normal and expected but certainly not using the rhetoric that we've seen in the past thank you sorry this is the question i had met uh steven orlow asks does israel's participation in the 40 nation
29:16 conference in germany indicate a change in position regarding the supply of weapons to the ukraine i think what i understand is israel is possibly going to supply things like helmets of flapjackets and things like that which are defensive in nature i do not see any situation where israel will provide offensive weapons and by the way that's the position pretty much of every nation in the world power just a few uh germany changed his position on that uh poland and even the us to a certain extent but other a few countries any country that's going to supply any sort of military equipment to ukraine is going to be defensive in nature and israel i think will again really with that balancing act in mind supply uh some sort of equipment but it'll be defensive in nature because of what what i just spoke about a minute ago because of that typewriter that it needs to maintain uh with russia but certainly over the last couple of weeks
30:19 israel has come far more towards the western or let's say the nato position uh far more critical of russia and far more ready to assist ukraine again mostly defensively but that's pretty much what most countries involved are also doing all right well thank you so much we've come to the close for our webinar and podcast ashley thank you again for taking time to update us this week thank you and for our viewers and listeners please join us friday at 1 pm eastern for a webinar with naveed mohibi thank you all for joining us and i hope you have a wonderful day