MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Webinar or Talk

"The Middle East's Media Wars" with Alberto Fernandez

Watch "The Middle East's Media Wars" with Alberto Fernandez on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

From providing Hezbollah with a platform to fueling the growth of al-Qaeda and ISIS, Middle Eastern news media has spread the message of jihadis since 9/11. The U.S. government pushed back in 2004 with the Alhurra network. Alberto Fernandez, the recent head of Alhurra’s holding company, witnessed first hand the great media battles. Have moderates begun winning the battle? What can Americans do to help?

Transcript Automatic captions

Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 12, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.

0:00 Right. Hello and welcome to the Middle East Forum speaker webinar series. I'm Stacy Roman and I will be moderating this discussion today. We're pleased to have Mr. Alberto Fernandez, vice president of the Middle East Media Research Institute, join us to discuss the Middle East media wars. Mr. Fernandez will speak for 10 to 15 minutes and open it up for questions. Should you wish to ask a question, please use the Q&A box located at the bottom of your screen. We will do our best to get to all questions, but we have many participants on this webinar. So, I apologize in advance if you do not get to yours today. And with that, I will turn the discussion over to Mr.

0:36 Alberto Fernandez. Oh, thank you very much. It's a real pleasure to be on here uh with you. I hope uh I can be concise, so there'll be plenty of time uh for questions. I usually have probably more than uh than 10 minutes worth of content to share. So I'm going to try to be as kind of you know scrunch it all in as much as I can. Usually when you're looking at media in the Middle East, you have the phenomenon of u the most significant phenomenon you can go on an hour of course is the proliferation of Arabic satellite channels which began in the 1990s uh on the entertainment side and on the on the uh information side the most of course the most famous one being Alazer in 1996 and uh we'll get to that but if you look at media in the region Today we look at media in the Arabic speaking world in the Middle East. It falls into several categories. The largest and the most significant category are media outlets connected to regimes uh to the

1:41 authoritarian regimes in the region. And these can be uh you know these can be entertainment channels, these can be uh private ostensively private or commercial channels or more often channels connected directly funded by regimes. I mean some of the most famous ones there of course are are things like Alabia funded by Saudis uh Sky News Arabia found funded by uh uh the United Arab Emirates and and of course Alazer funded by the uh the state of Qatar.

2:15 These are channels that uh generally by and large mimic the foreign policy goals and the foreign policy lines and red lines of the states that fund them. The the second largest category after regime media which I think is is very pertinent to our discussion are are religious or religiously oriented stations of which there are plethora in the region. Um these are overwhelmingly Islamic channels. Again, private, public, a mixture of the two. Uh I should mention that there are no public ones, but there are a handful of uh Christian channels in the region either associated with Christian minorities or places like Lebanon or broadcasting from Cyprus. But that's a very very small group. The large overwhelming number of channels of religious channels in the region are Islamically oriented channels and some of them are you know obviously concerned

3:18 with faith and with religion itself the religion itself but many of them are politically religious and they tend to be on obviously on the Islamist side uh they can be Salafi channels or they can be Islamist i.e the Muslim Brotherhood channels there. I think the interesting development has been over the last say six years is the development of over a dozen Islamist channels beaming from uh into the Arab world in Arabic. These are channels that are Muslim Brotherhood channels. uh very extreme content uh a lot of anti-semitic content a lot of anti-American anti-Israel anti-West anti-Christian content beaming to places like the Gulf and especially Egypt fact a lot of these people are Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood that moved after uh 2013 moved to the Gulf usually to Qatar then wound up in Turkey is a very

4:21 aggressive very aggressive very large footprint media operation. Um the sad thing of course is that this type of phenomenon that used to exist this type of Islamist media phenomenon used to exist very much funded by Gulf states and Gulf states with the exception of Qatar had stopped doing that. Saudi Arabia has stopped generally doing that. But a lot of my content has basically moved from the Gulf from funders in the Gulf world in the Gulf area to Turkey. Turkey is the new promoter you could say of Islamist media content in Arabic uh Sunni of course content uh in Arabic to the Arab world. There are there are Shia militias channels. There are you know Hezbollah has a channel from Lebanon.

5:14 There are lots of radical uh uh media outlets coming out of Iraq uh as well. But uh but the you know the the in terms of the footprint the largest one is all of that which is occurring from Turkey. There also Salafi channels extreme Salafi channels uh in places like Egypt and other places which are very extreme. They have they tend to be very small but kind of very extreme content preaching both anti-semitic and anti-Shia content you know mim mimicking the the split that exists between kind of Sunni extremists and Shia extremists. The third obviously uh uh category of channels that exist in the region are those funded by outside countries you know like the western countries the United States, the UK, France, Germany all have Arabic language channels.

6:07 Russia today has a very large and aggressive Arabic language presence as do the Iranians as well more than than a few. But obviously if you look in terms of impact the one that has had the most impact the most notorious and the most famous is Al Jazzer and Al Jazzer has a very colorful and interesting history and we can talk about it in in great length uh about that but it's very much the station that kind of captured the tempo and the the pulse of the region uh rising in the 1990s uh identifying itself with publicizing big events in the region. region which captured audience. Uh obviously the first one that comes to mind is a promotion or coverage of Osama bin Laden uh the Taliban and all of that related in the late 1990s and the uh as well kind of something that gave uh Alazer notoriety and moving from that to the Iraq war where Alazer was very much seen as a big critic of the United

7:11 States and a big supporter of uh insurgent movements and the narrative of insurgent movements against the United States as well. And an anniversary that we just had just a few days ago, the Tamuz war, the Hisba uh Israel war of 2006, Al Jazzer was a major pro promoter of kind of the Hisba line and the concept or the idea that Hezbollah was uh in this conflict with uh with Israel in 2006. move away, you move ahead a couple of years and you have the Gaza war, the uh operation castled award uh war which again Al Jazzer publicized as very much a a Hamas victory and in fact their their media campaign which was intensive and lengthy was built around the uh the the uh the motto Gaza triumphs uh but very much Hamas triumphs uh as they did. Obviously we can move

8:14 forward every major event that happened there was a kind of an alazer component whether the Arab Spring or the civil war in Syria u it's very much kind of captured that type had a very specific line not surprising very much mimicking that of the foreign policy of Kat there's very very close correlation 100% near 100% correlation between Alazer's editorial line and the editorial line or the foreign policy line of uh of uh uh the state of Qatar, the US government and this is something which I think is a huge problem generally with the exception of Alazer for a couple of years in the Bush administration when there was an Alazer monitoring group an inter agency monitoring group during the Bush administration rising out of concern about how they covered certain things in the region. I was on that monitor monitoring group for a while along with

9:18 other people from the State Department and from the White House and other organizations. Uh aside from that very brief attempt to kind of hold the official media outlet of a ostensibly friendly state uh to account. Generally we have a problem that occurs in that we have media that occurs in the region which is hostile to the United States. Some of that media is from uh governments or organizations which are hostile to the United States.

9:53 Terrorist groups like Hamas or Iran that that's obvious. But there's a huge amount of content that appears in media outlets that belong to or or are influenced or controlled by countries that are ostensibly allies of the United States. And I'm not talking here about uh you know an opposition or an independent media outlet which is criticizing the United States as you might see say in France or in Germany or in the UK. No, we're talking about media environments, places like Egypt or Jordan or the Gulf or Turkey, for example, where the power of the state of authoritarian regimes ostensibly allied or friendly to the United States preach and promote poison uh on a dayto-day basis. Some of this material is is uh obviously very anti-American, but there's also different different spins.

10:52 So there's a kind of anti- anti-Israel component, anti-wester, anti-Christian depending on the country and the place. But but it's pervasive. Now you might say, and this is the problem in government. Government people in government might say, well, what do we care of, say Jordan or or Egypt or uh what they're saying in their media? they're actually cooperating with us on the intelligence side or on the military security side. Well, the problem with that is that you have basically a disconnect having you may have a a security or a military relationship that works that that is mutually beneficial from both sides. But what is actually going on is this friendly state is using anti-Americanism as a kind of way to legitimize itself to its population and kind of make itself look good among populations that are are anti-American or anti-Western. So what these friendly

11:57 governments are doing basically is deepening the the sense of the masses in these countries against the United States. And worse than that, what happens is what they're doing is creating or feeding into a broader narrative that the real extremists use that the al-Qaeda and the ISISes of the world use as well. So you basically have a situation in the region where many of our friends uh unintentionally or intentionally and I would say intentionally because and these are countries where the security apparatus has a heavy hand in the media uh are in trying to protect themselves or immunize themselves from criticism are basically doing some of the spade work uh for our enemies and kind of poisoning the broader uh media environment against the United States and against our interests and this is extraordinarily dangerous and it's something that has been going

12:59 on for years and continues to this day. I notice I'm at 13 minutes so I'm going to stop there. There's a lot more I could say but uh I wanted to keep uh be respectful of the time that we have. Of course. Thank you so much for that. We have quite a few questions coming in already. Uh the first one is what are the common themes of the Islamist networks in terms of content? Is there a Well, there is a pattern, but there are many patterns. Obviously, the the big one is that the solution to the region's problems are to be found in kind of the Islamist narrative, the Islamist political agenda. That's obviously I mean it's it's about power. It's about a a mode of governance uh and government that these are groups. These are revolutionary groups that want to be in power. That's the big picture. But within that subtext, of course, there are uh uh uh anti-American, anti-semitic, anti-western, uh uh you know, conspiracy theory, uh

14:07 anti-gay, anti- you can go on and on and on, but these are subjects of a broader one, which basically says those guys, meaning the regimes in power, are the tools of the Jews or the tools of the Americans or controlled by the gays or controlled by the Christians or controlled by whatever. And we're we're the true believers. We're the ones that have to be followed, not those guys who are corrupt and contaminated and evil in the pocket of the bad guys. Pick pick your pick your category in that long list of of of uh descriptions that I that I mentioned.

14:51 Thank you. How much real influence does Al Al Jazzer have with young people and Uh well, it's interesting you mentioned the word progressives. Uh first of all, of course, I mean, I think many of you may know this. There's a huge difference between Alazer in Arabic and Alazer in English. Alazer in English is a kind of progressive, you know, left-wing, whatever you want to call it, kind of station. In Arabic, it's different. In Arabic, it is mostly an Islamist station with a kind of pan-Arab Arabism subtext very much mirroring the ruler uh Khalifa, the Amir of Qatar at the time, who was inspired by both kind of the left and by political Islam. But the people who founded Alazer were Islamists. uh largely connected with the Muslim Brotherhood, often connected with Hamas and that's been the entire subtext

15:54 of Alazir in Arabic. So Alazer in Arabic is so Islamist that a few years ago the Qataris established another network uh to basically uh uh uh service the progressive or leftwing Arab audience. And so the Qataris have Al Jazzer, which is the big dog, the big thing that they have. And then they have an outfit Alabia or Arab Jade uh out of London which is a kind of a secular left-wing progressive outlet uh connected to a former member of the Israeli Knesset uh turned Arab nationalist a guy named Azi Bashara a Palestinian or Israeli Arab Christian who now has Qatari citizenship. So Al Jazzer basically has two irons in their fire. They have the big Islamist fi iron in the fire which is alazer and then more recently in the last few years they kind of decided to

16:56 hedged their bets. They created this kind of progressive uh uh option also paid for by Qatar from Thank you. You mentioned the shortlived monitoring group. What is preventing the west from saying enough is enough? I I think it's just uh the attention span is uh you know how much attention are you going to devote uh in the west to this who actually does it? Who in government in our government you know uh or or in other governments does it? Who has as we used to say in the state department who has the pen? Who has the power to convene? Is it the state department? Is it the intelligence community? Is it the white house? Where does the center of mass lie uh of people who care about this and even more importantly care about this that have the knowledge to contribute something to the debate because you don't want to just be complaining to people you know your stuff is bad or your stuff is evil

17:58 or whatever and actually you don't know what you're talking about which uh is I think a problem that happens with government you want to confront these states you want to criticize them you want to do it intelligently like you know what is actually happening It's a great point. Um, how should a more effective Egyptian counter reaction look against the Turkish Islamist media wave absent a strong civil society? This is a problem. I think this is a problem with media outlets uh throughout the region, right? It's the eternal temptation is control and u uh you know uh uh conviction or or or credibility. Uh regimes always tend to this by the way this is not just unique to the Arab world. We do this in the west as well. You know uh the more something has credibility the more real it is. You kind of have to let it be organic and let it be honest and uh governments even western governments

19:03 but especially authoritarian Middle Eastern governments want to control things you know. So for example, if you want to criticize Turkey and the Turkish regime, it would seem that the most logical way to do it is from a kind of reformist, liberal, secularist, uh point of view. But if you're an authoritarian Arab regime uh that's kind of thuggish uh that also throws those types of people in prison, it's difficult for you to have credibility when you're criticizing Erdogan. If you're kind of doing things more or less the same, but from your angle. Uh so this is the problem that all these governments face. The more credible is, the more critical it's going to be.

19:52 the more it's going to say, well, this is bad and it's that's bad, too. Governments don't usually want that. They just want a monochrome criticism of, you know, our enemies are bad and our friends are good. And you can do some of that, but uh it hurts your credibility. Thank you. Do you think there is a correlation between Alazer and the radical Islamist groups? Well, there is but of course uh what is it? Uh uh you know correlation does not prove causality right. Uh obviously Islamism and Salifism in the Arab world uh precedes Al Jazzer uh for many many you know decades or many many years. Uh so these are movements that are independent of long before Alazer. What Al Jazer did was to mainstream the discourse to take the discourse from a a discourse that was already

20:55 occurring in society but not on television. It was occurring offscreen. It was occurring within the society about uh politics about Islamist politics. Alazer brought it front and center and made it credible and made it respectable. I mean, I'll give you an example. The last time I one of the last times I was on Al Jazzer, I was on Al Jazzer as on one of their debate shows, which is one of their u their premium things. I think this is about five years ago or six years ago. It was about uh uh the Syrian regime and you know who's responsible for Assad. And basically the idea was that we're the Americans are it's our fault, right? Because it's always America's fault. Well, okay, I agreed to do it. that went on. The guy who was debating against me in Arabic was an Iraqi, a former communist living in Sweden who had weeks before sworn

22:03 allegiance on Al Jazzer to ISIS. That's who Al Jazer picked to debate me. Uh, you know, that tells I mean it, you know, it kind of tells you all you need to know, right? They did not regard a guy who had sworn allegiance to ISIS as beyond the pale. I actually laughed at him. I said, "You're pro-ISIS and yet you pay taxes to the king of Sweden, but actually should I should not have had to debate someone with that kind of background." So that's what Alazer did did. It kind of accelerated and mainstreamed radical discourses which already existed and still exist but made them more kind of upfront and personal.

22:50 Great. So along those lines we have a question that came in. I have friends who think that Alazer in English is an excellent news source. How can I counter I think Alazer in English is a legitimate news source. It's it's like I said it's left of center but it's it it's within the realm of what is generally I mean sometimes you know on the opinion it can go one way or another but but it's it's within the mainstream of what western media is and it is a western media outlet but the big impact of alazir is not in English it's in Arabic Does the growing Israeli ties with moderate Sunni states such as the UAE exert a moderate influence on the local media in these countries? If not, why not? It does. It does. You've seen uh the kind of uh moderation in the Saudi UAE media outlets, a kind of broadening

23:56 of perspectives uh that wasn't there before. uh on on the on the dislazer uses that closeness or that growing closeness that exists between say Saudi Arabia and the UAE as a way of attacking Saudi Arabia and the UAE of saying see they're with the Zionists they're with the enemy and they'll have on some Palestinian extremists talking about that and so so yeah it has moderated or has brought I should say more than moderated kind of brought in the perspective of media in those countries which is a very good thing. It's also been used as a tool against them not just by Alazer but by uh radical outlets throughout the Thank you so much. And our last question is can you comment on the role of newspapers in the region real quick?

24:51 uh you know like the west there are newspapers in the region obviously but it is they're they're heavily declining the same things that we see happening in the west are happening in the region I think more important than newspapers of course and more important than than kind of television is the future of the region in terms of media is social media and uh parts of the media parts of the region say the Gulf states for example are among the most connected society ies in the world. I mean the percentage of Saudis or Emiratis who use Twitter who use Facebook is higher than even in the US. So so rather than tell rather than newspapers the big challenge to broadcast media in the region is the growth of social media and the social media platforms.

25:43 Thank you. Very interesting. And real quick, can you just let us know where we can find some more of your work? Uh I am on Twitter. Uh I'm at uh Alberto F55 I think because there are many Alberto uh on Twitter. Obviously I also write at Memory and I write in other places as well. Uh if you want a good piece on US broadcasting in Arabic, there's a piece I wrote for Providence magazine uh back in February of this year which has information on that as well. Wonderful.

26:18 Well, thank you so much. Unfortunately, we've come to the close of our webinar. Thank you again, Mr. Fernandez, for speaking with us today. Thank you. Please be on the Please join us Wednesday at 3 PM Eastern for Ashley Perry's Israel Insider Update. Uh, thank you all for joining us and I hope you have a wonderful day.