Webinar or Talk
Bankrupting Terrorists One Lawsuit at a Time with Nitsana Darshan-Leitner
Watch on YouTube
Description
Shurat HaDin (the Israel Law Center) confronts terrorists and their enablers where governments and intelligence agencies cannot: the civil court room. In less than two decades it has won more than US$2 billion in judgments from everyone from BDS bigots to state sponsors of terrorism. How does Shurat HaDin accomplish so much with limited resources, what are its goals, and what is its long-term impact?
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 9, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:00 Good afternoon and welcome to the Middle East Forum speaker webinar series and podcast. I'm Stacy Roman and I will be moderating this discussion today. Natsana Daran Lightner, founder and president of Sharat Hadin, joined me for a pre-recorded webinar to discuss bankrupting terrorists one lawsuit at a time. Miss Daran Lightner will speak for 15 minutes then address some questions. As this is a pre-recorded webinar, we unfortunately will not be taking any questions from the audience today. And with that I will play the discussion with Nitsana Darjan Lightner. Thank you Stacy and um hello everyone.
0:40 It's pleasure for me uh to be here with you today. Um a short introduction forin. It's a civil rights organization based in Israel that utilize a court system to go after the after Israel's enemies through the courts. And um we've been um doing this for 20 years now mainly finding terrorism but afterwards finding everybody who threatens the Jewish state and the answer is in the legal theater. I would like to focus today on um the recent threat against the state of Israel which is the international criminal court. We know that um since 2012, the Palestinian Authority uh threatened Israel that uh if uh Israel does not agree to their demands, they will go to the International Criminal Court and indict Israel for war crimes. Why 2012?
1:38 Because that year on September in the General Assembly, they were able to upgrade their status to an observer state. As such, they had the liberty to sign their own treaty and to ask the court to join as a state member. And they did. In 2015, they broke up relationship with Israel and they um signed the Rome treaty, went to the international court, asked to become a state member and they were So now for the past five years the international criminal court has been um doing a preliminary examination whether there are war crimes that Israel committed that they have the jurisdiction to um uh indict them for and the Palestinians brought before the court two allegations.
2:39 One is that the IDF soldiers are using excessive force against Israel in uh against the Palestinians in their different operations. And the other one is that Israel bidsman's in the West Bank and therefore violates international law. We in Shadin were involved from day one trying to obstruct any investigation and trying to tackle any intention of the court to go after Israel based on these allegations.
3:16 We know that Israel has an answer to the first one. Um you know the there is a principle in the court that uh if the investigated country runs investigation itself uh for the alleged crimes the court lacks jurisdiction because the court does not want to um be a supreme court on any country in the world. it just comes into to bridge gaps when there is nobody to investigate and nobody can bring to justice those war criminals. So we know that Israel has an answer for the first allegation um the idea of soldiers are not war Anything they do they do um with uh full moral values and if they do fail and if there is a sudden mistake of their side, Israel authorities will immediately
4:20 investigate them. They have strict rules. They have strict procedure. The military prosecutor will immediately investigate um and indict if he finds any crime. The court system will judge the soldier and if they find him guilty, they will put him in prison or will impose any punishment on him. And if the uh prosecutor will fail to do so by mistake or even intentionally, we have the Supreme Court. we have the Supreme Court that can go and um be um the one that will force the prosecutor to bring the soldier to justice.
5:08 In these instances, we don't need no court. We don't need an international criminal court. There are no crimes made and if they are made by mistake, they are fully investigated and brought to trial in Israel. The other allegation is a little bit harder because the Palestinians claim that Israel violates international law by building settlements in Judean, Samaria, in the West Bank. And this is an argument that the only answer to is that the territories are not occupied, something that the court will not accept and something that Israel will not Therefore, Israel has a big problems when they come to deal with the international criminal court.
6:00 What we did in Suratadin is trying to get into the case. Right in the beginning, we started filing criminal offenses against the leaders of the Palestinian Authority. We came and said, "It's not Israel to blame for war crimes. It's not the Israeli soldiers. It's not the Israeli military. It's those who commit crimes against humanity on a daily basis against the Israelis. The first antifada, the second antifada, even the last wave of terrorism where Palestinians just go and stab innocent Israelis. And it's all run, we believe, by the Palestinian Authority, by leaders of the Hamas organization. Those people should be indicted for war crimes. We brought war crimes complaints against Mahmud Abbas, um Mash, against all the leaders of the present and the teranization.
7:03 But we did not accept the jurisdiction of the court meaning we don't think that the Palestinian authority has a way to go into the court. They are not the state, not according to the international law. They don't have any right to step into the court the court here to investigate the situation. No doubt about that. The chief prosecutor Faru bin Suda has been saying since day one since 2012 that the Palestinians have a right. They can go into the court. She promised to be objective and to take it based on evidence basis. She wants to do it. The court wants to dive in. They want the courts want to take the situation against Israel to court but we don't think there is any jurisdiction and therefore in order to make sure that we don't seem like accepting the court jurisdiction we come and say the court can investigate those leaders of the Palestinian authority because they have
8:05 Jordanian citizenship and Jordan is a state member from day one. The court should investigate the Palestinian Israeli conflict, should investigate those who want and killed indeed Israeli innocent people but based on their Jordanian citizenship. And here we expand the period of the investigation. If the Palestinians asked the court to investigate from June 2014 from protective edge operation from a day after the kidnap and the murder of the three teenagers not to include this crime in the investigation of the court.
8:47 We come and want to open it since the beginning of the inifada since the inception of the court since 2002 because suicide bombing, drive by shooting, ambushes, uh throwing mol of cocktails, um shooting missiles towards Israeli population is crimes against humanity and they were done from 2002. Then when we do that the court might understand who are the world war We um now have to deal to deal with the other allegation which is the settlement issue. And this is a little bit harder as I said. Um the Palestinians say that Israel violates section 49 to the Geneva Uh the Geneva Convention was enacted in World War II after nazi Germany took over parts of Eastern Europe and made a massive population transfer into these
9:51 territories. So section 49 decides that no occupying country is allowed to do a population transfer to the territories that she occupied. The Palestinians say that Israel by building houses and encouraging Israelis to live in Judea and Samaria are violating section 49 because the territories are occupied. Israel, as you said, has a great defense. The territories are not Um, you know, to occupy a country or to occupy a land, you have to take it from someone who owns it. And nobody actually owns Judan Samaria, the West Bank. The last one to have any ownership rights on them were the Turks under the empire Otman Empire. And uh in 2017 in the World War I, Britain came, took over
10:55 this land. They took over Jordan, took over what's now is Israel, took over Egypt, Iraq, but they didn't have ownership rights. They only receive a mandate to administrate these and after 25 years the mandate ended concluded and now the British left and there are two parties that fighting over this piece of land the Arabs and the Jews. A war broke out. The independence war the 1948 war lasted a year and a half and ended with a ceasefire.
11:33 The ceasefire, the borders of this was drawn in a green ink and this is what is name come from the green line but it had no political meaning no political uh implications. But Jordan after two years after sorry a couple of months saw that there is a great piece of land attached to its border and decided to annex it. It even gave it a name the West Bank. But nobody recognizes annexation. No country in the world except for two Pakistan and England that had great relationship with King Abdullah. Even the Arab League was furious at Jordan for taking this unilateral act. They thought that this piece of land, the state of Israel or whatever is between the Jordan to the sea belongs to Syria, should be attached to Syria.
12:33 And in 1988, Jordan gave up its right for these territories. So in 1967, when Israel took over this piece of land, nobody owned it. The most we can say about this land is that it's disputed territories but they are not occupied. However, we know what the court's assumption is in regard with these territories. They consider them to be occupied. We know what's Europe's opinion is uh regarding these territories. Um, and who knows, even the Biden administration might change the recent decision of President Trump to and uh will go back to recognize them as Therefore, on this allegation, Israel will lose.
13:24 So we did in the we're realizing that Israel is not the only country in the world to be blamed for occupying that Turkey occupies northern Cyprus and uh Morocco occupies western Sahara and Russia occupies uh Georgia. So we went abroad to work and complain against Turkey for occupying northern Cyprus. And on 30page long brief we detailed what it what Turkey is doing in northern Cyprus, how they build universities, how they build hospitals, how they give tax incentives to their uh population to come and settle in northern Cyprus. Exactly what Israel is doing in the West Bank.
14:11 Now there are two complaints pending before the court. one against Israel for occupying the West Bank and one against Turkey for occupying northern Cyprus. We believe that the court will not indict Turkey for occupying northern Cyprus. Uh not Turkey is too dear to NATO, uh too dear to Europe. Uh nobody wants to deal with Erdogan. So the most the court can say about this dispute is that it's not under its jurisdiction. It's not for the court to get involved with. It's for the parties to resolve it against among each Having said that, the court will not be able to rule different when it comes to the Israeli Palestinian conflict. The court's hand will be tied.
15:06 What the court did after five years of the preliminary investigation is coming finally with a decision to investigate Israel. The chief prosecutor Faren Suda asked the preliminary judges chamber if there is jurisdiction because she doesn't want to go through this whole investigation and in the end will uh be found as lack of jurisdiction. The court came and authorized her to open investigation. Once again, the court said it doesn't matter actually if the Palestinian Authority is a state according to the international law. It's enough that they sign their own treaty.
15:46 They have a status of an observant state and they coin they join can join the the uh chief prosecutor just um two weeks ago allowed Israel to check again whether Israel wants to do this investigation by itself. If Israel wants to investigate her own crimes last um over the weekend, Israel came uh with a decision after many hearings in the government deciding not to collaborate with the court. Israel told the court very simply that they have no jurisdiction and they are not going to investigate any crimes. They are not going to collaborate with the court.
16:35 We can't leave this scene open. We can't leave it only in the hands of the Palestinian and therefore Shuratadin will enter the case, continue its fight, continue what we did so far. We are going to increase the volume of communications we are filing against the leaders of the Palestinian Authority and the Hamas organization. We are going to flood the court with evidence of the victims from the Israeli side. And as I said, we are not going to limit it to 2014 on, but we're going to open it from 2002.
17:13 And this will change the entire balance. will show the court who are the real war criminals will deter the Palestinian authority leaders that four so far think that they are immune because if you read the chief prosecutor decision very carefully she said she's going to investigate Israel to balance it she's going to investigate Hamas but she is not going to investigate the Palestinian Authority the Palestinian Authority that started the whole thing that pushed to move the court to investigate Israel is not something under the court's jurisdiction. She is not going to be We are going to change it. We are going to court and bringing many many indictments and communications based on the payto-slave policy of the policy We have precedences in the court itself that incitement to terrorism consider to
18:16 be a crimes against humanity. It's a crime that the court investigates. We saw it in Rwanda where the leaders over there incited to genocide through the radio just through the media. So if you incite to terrorism vocally and get charged with war crimes, if you pay for terrorism, you will be indicted for genocide. This is in order to deter the Palestinian authorities leader perhaps to lay back and not to push the court to go forward.
18:55 It's a real threat. We know that once the court will start its investigation, they will issue indictments. They will issue um arrest warrants against Israeli soldiers, against Israeli officers. They're not going to indict the state of Israel. They have only jurisdiction to indict personalities. They're going to go after individuals. They're going to go after Israeli officials. This arrange warrants will be honored by all states members of the court. We're talking about 128 that will have to honor these warrants.
19:36 Israeli soldiers will not be safe traveling around the world. Israel will be un under sanctions to collaborate with the court to indict those If the court will continue with this investigation, it will be a gamecher. Therefore, we have to fight it We will not let any go any day go without us inadin fighting back. We will not let a court in Europe to decide where Israelis can live, where Jews can settle, where the border of the Israeli state will uh go through. We'll have to find it because we are a sovereign state and we want to live safely in our borders and no international tribunals ever will determine the rights of the Jewish people to its own country.
20:46 this is what uh in recent days we are involved with. Obviously we continue our fights and struggles and lawsuits against terrorism against state sponsored terrorism terror organizations. Um, we continue our fights against the social media, Twitter, Google, Facebook for uh incitement of terrorism and for letting organizations use their platforms. We continue our fight against BDS, but I believe that the most dangerous step that is taken against Israel right now is the International Criminal Court and we will fight it. Thank you very All right, thank you so much. So the first question we have in is what current cases do you feel most hopeful about having an impact?
21:38 So I believe our case against banks um created a huge impact and still are. Banks are very afraid to support terrorism, to uh open bank account to designated terror organizations or to uh work in environments or areas that are um full with terrorists and uh we can see that there are no banking system in South Lebanon or in Gaza which affect the terror organizations that war them.
22:13 but also the case against the Palestinian Authority. Um, we just recently won uh an enormous decision in the district court of Israel uh finding the Palestinian Authority responsible for 15 uh acts of terrorism, terror attacks that were um taking place during the second inif and we are able to uh put a lean to assert a lean uh in the this case for uh on half a billion checkles that belong to the Palestinian Authority that creates a huge impact. The Palestinian Authority understands that the little support they give the uh terrorists before they do the attacks, um the safe haven that provide them even after they attack or perhaps the weapon that provide them with before they attack or even the incitement to go and kill Israelis and up in the end of the day with hundreds of millions of dollars
23:21 in damages against them. These are tremendous impacting cases against Speaking of financing, can you describe the role Qatar plays in financing terrorism and what efforts are being made to address this through the legal So Qatar I would call it the ATM of the terrorism. There is no ter organization in the world that Qatar is the is not funding. Uh beginning from the Palestinian organization, Hamas, Islamic Jihad, uh continuing with ISIS, Boku Haram, every terror organization on earth, if they pledge to the Qatari government and to the Qatari uh kingdom, they um they get paid. They can get Israel allows Qatar to um formally fund Hamas. Every month there is a messenger
24:28 coming at Benon airport with a suitcase full of $10 million in cash to give it to uh the Hamas organization in Gaza. They claim it's designated only to salaries of the employees in Gaza. uh but nobody can really supervise it and make sure that this money is not going uh partially to the hands of the terrorists. So we are in a very difficult situation where we find Israel on one hand fight Hamas and um destroy tunnels that Hamas builds on the other hand fund Hamas and perhaps even contribute to the tunnels that Hamas builds. We in didn't understand that um in addition to this formal path there are informal ways that Hamas funds terrorism and that Qatar funds Hamas and um this money is going to uh
25:32 organizations to charities to fund to foundations in Gaza. We have an intention to stop this by filing a major lawsuit against the Qatari charities and against the banks in Qatar and in Europe that allow this transfer of money to get to the hands of the organizations. Hopefully hopefully we'll be successful in this lawsuit as well as we have been in previous cases against banks. Thank you. Has anyone been persecuted for threatening you or your employees for their work against terrorists?
26:12 Um, well, I'm happy to say that uh so far nobody threatened us uh to the extent that they have to be prosecuted. We um indeed receive some you know hate emails or uh or phone calls in Arabic and such. Um but uh it did not come up to um to to to a life threat or thank God to our safety. Um I always believe that uh in Israel there are highest rank officials that uh the terrorists can threaten before they get to me before they climb you know to my office 13 floors and find me somewhere. Um we are cautious in uh in what we do but um we'll continue uh doing what we do because somebody has to
27:17 do it. Well, thank you for that. What has involvement from the US government been like? Have they ever played a role? And if so, can you talk about the different levels of support from Bush through So you know um the uh US administration has been involved uh usually not so much supported or cast although they have there are some exceptions. I can tell you a couple of examples. Um in the beginning we won a lawsuit against the Palestinian authority uh for over $160 Um and the council approached the state department and told them that uh that uh they had to get involved in order to cancel this judgment or to stop the proceeding to enforce this judgment because uh we put leans on all their assets in the United States. We uh got restraining orders against them all transaction they did in the United
28:20 States. all their bank accounts uh their office the salaries are paid to employees. So they approached uh Condisa Rice under the Bush administration and ask her to uh to bring a halt to this and Condisa Rice said that she cannot get involved. It's a civil case. It's between terror victims to the one that cla they claim was the aggressor in the case and she recommend the Palestinian authority to settle this case out of court. So for the first time after many years of litigation, the parallel authorities lawyers approached us to settle this case out of court and that was a beginning of many cases to settle after that.
29:17 On the other hand, um Obama's administration got involved in a another case that we had against the Palestinian Authority. That was a case that we filed in 2004 and um after 11 years went to trial. Uh it was a case that was filed on behalf of 10 families that lost their loved ones in uh uh terror attacks during the second where they all done all the terrorists belong to the Palestinian Authority.
29:54 They were employees of the Palestinian Authority and the Palestinary. The um personator argument when the uh trial started was that uh indeed these terrorists were its employees but they were wrong employees. They did the attacks after work hours. They weren't authorized to kill Jews. It was it wasn't their policy to uh kill that when the trial started, they found it hard to explain the jury if they were rogue employees, how do you keep paying their salary until today? These terrorists who now are prisoners in the Israeli jail continues to receive a salary every month. They uh promoted in rank every three years. The pulerary pays tip to
30:58 the families of the suicide bombers. They call streets and town squares on the names of the terrorists. This is not how you treat wrong employees. This is not the new policy against killing Jews. So when the trial ended and the jury came back, there was no wonder that they found the Palestinator responsible for all this terror attacks and gave us a judgment for $655 million. The Palistor was very upset. They hired a new lawyer from uh New York to file an appeal. And uh in the United States, in order to file an appeal, you have to pass the bond for the entire amount of the judgment. The Palestinian Authority claimed that they don't have $655 million to post as a bond. They approached the State Department for help and the State Department under Obama's administration helped.
31:56 they um entered an letter of interest to the court saying that the Palestinian Authority is an asset of the United States in the Middle East. They don't want it to go bankrupt and they as the court to be considerate and the court was instead of $655 million the court imposed only $10 million bond. So now the person was free to argue its appeal and they did not argue against the verdict of the jury or the evidence brought before them or the testimonies of the experts or of the witnesses.
32:38 They argued one technical allegation personal jurisdiction. They came and said the Palestinian Authority is not present in the United States. They don't run business in the United States. They don't have representation in the United States. Therefore, there is no personal And the court had a dilemma because on one hand um we filed this case based on the anti-terrorism act which is a law that allows American citizen that were killed or injured in terror of terror attacks abroad to bring their case in the United It's an exoratorial jurisdiction law. on the other hand the American Constitution the requirement for due process but having before them the letter that of the state department saying that in other words whatever you impose a policy to pay they don't have the money to pay
33:43 the court of appeal went and vacated the we went to the Supreme Court and the Supreme Court knowing that there is a new pharaoh that didn't know Joseph Now it's under Trump administration as the state department if they have a different opinion if the law indeed is but the state department under Trump came and say the law is not constitutional that you cannot bring this sort of cases against the Palestinian authority in the United States. There is no personal and the court did not give us a read.
34:25 now we have a final judgment against us. We went to Congress and said there is a problem. There is a problem because we filed these cases and litigated for 11 years based on the law that you legislated which was a very well-intended law. But now the Supreme Court found it unconstitutional. So you have to fix the problem. And the way to fix the problem is to legislate a law to reinstate personal jurisdiction. You have to come and say that the Palestinian authority if they want to continue to receive aid from the United States government have to agree to personal jurisdiction when it comes to terror victims litigation.
35:11 And I'm happy to say that the Congress passed the law. Uh, President Trump signed up of the law and now the Palestinian Authority has to consider whether they want to continue receiving aid from United States government. We are back in the game due to this change of the law. Wonderful. Our last question here is where can our viewers follow your work? Um well we have a website uh israel.org or if you Google shuratadin it will immediately come up on the website you will get all the updates about our work.
35:54 Um please join our email list. The uh we send a newsletter every week uh updating our uh members and supporters about the work about decision that we receive about cases that we file about any development that has to do with our work. And uh you can follow up on Facebook, you can follow up in Twitter, on YouTube, uh on Instagram, all the social media. And uh thank you really for this question because uh I would like everyone to know what we do to understand that there is a fight for civilians, for regular people, for professionals, for laymen, for everyone to help the state of Israel.
36:44 Private people build the state of Israel. Private people have to keep it safe. This is our job and this is a privilege for the entire Jewish community to come and join us with this. All right. Well, thank you so much. We've reached the close of our webinar. Thank you again for taking time to speak with us today. Thank you very much, Stacy. right, we've come to the close of our webinars. For viewers and listeners, please join us tomorrow, Tuesday, at 3 p.m. Eastern for an update with Ashley Perry. Please note the date change.
37:23 Thank you all for joining us, and I hope you have a wonderful day.