MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Webinar or Talk

The Middle East after October 7th with Adi Schwartz

Watch The Middle East after October 7th with Adi Schwartz on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

The Hamas war with Israel will have a large and long-lasting impact on the whole region from Iran to Egypt. What are the repercussions on Israel and the Palestinians? On the jihadi movement? On great power involvement?

Adi Schwartz is a research fellow at the Misgav Institute and a postdoctoral fellow at Ben Gurion University of the Negev. Focusing on the Arab-Israeli conflict, he is co-author of "The War of Return: How Western Indulgence of the Palestinian Dream Has Obstructed the Path to Peace" (Macmillan, 2020), which was partially funded by the Middle East Forum Education Fund. Mr. Schwartz holds a BA from Tel Aviv University, and an MA and PhD in political science, both from Bar Ilan University.

Transcript Automatic captions

Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 26, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.

0:06 good after and welcome to the Middle East Forum speaker webinar series and podcast I'm Stacy Roman and I will be moderating this discussion today we're pleased to have Dr D Schwarz research fellow at The misgav Institute and post-doctoral fellow at the benorian University of the negtive join us to discuss the Middle East after October 7th Dr Schwarz will speak for 15 minutes followed by 15 minutes of Q&A from the audience should you wish to ask a question please use the Q&A box located at the bottom of your screen to type your question and with that I will turn the discussion over to Dr ad Schwarz thank you very much um for inviting me to speak this afternoon uh first um I'd like to say a few words about the meaning of the moment in history where we on um historians of the Middle East or of the Arab Israeli conflict tend to divide the history of conflict um into two separate periods until 1973 the Yum kipur war and after

1:11 1973 where until that war um Israel fought the War in 1948 the war of 1967 and the War of 1973 um and in each War there was an existential threat to the state of Israel so the threat and the position in which Israel found itself was that tanks and infantry invaded the state of Israel aircrafts tried to bomb Israeli cities and uh um the threat that Israelis and the state itself was in was a truly existential and um historians tend to say that after 1973 well all of these uh attempts failed the Arab states decided that it was somehow enough and that no major war uh occurred since 1973 indeed we saw Egypt moving to a different uh uh path of uh signing peace agreements

2:16 later Jordan and we haven't seen Syria embarking on a full war after the 1973 War so there was a feeling that existential threat real territorial of occupying really occupying and you know uh kicking all the Jews to the sea or murdering everybody and putting an end destroying the state of Israel is a threat that is already you know belonging to the history we still had the same intentions in some of these circles we had Terror uh following you know decades and and never stop stopping uh we found ourselves in a diplomatic battle we found ourselves in uh attempt at delegitimization ation apod height slur etc etc but the feeling was that 1973 Israel is no longer under existential territorial threat and I think that this is the big change that happened with October the 7th and as we seen uh some of our neighbors still

3:24 Harbor the same intentions that's not very surprising but they have the capability Unfortunately they succeeded in actually invading uh into the territory of the state of Israel occupying even for a few hours uh villages communities cities committing atrocities unbelievable unconceivable atrocities and I think that in this sense by the way we have now something like 200,000 refugees inside Israel this is something that did not happen certainly not since 1973 so in this sense Israel Isel went back to a period in its history where it's again in an existential threat uh again it comes from the south with Kamas it comes from the north with kesala we are very well aware of the situation in Judea and Samaria the West Bank and we you know uh um the hutis in Yemen are sending missiles long range missiles we know that uh uh uh Iranian Shiite mil are

4:30 coming towards the Golan height so again there's a sense and there's real sense and understanding that there is a territorial existential threat now how did this happen I think that what happened is a convergence of two um separate trajectory separate axis but they are converging right now one is the Palestinian axis of course what happened is that Hamas Palestinian terrorists invaded Israel but this access is also in Iranian axis so we have two a movement of two separate axis one is Shiite one is Sunni the outcome you know of murdering Jews for the families of course and for Israel does not really it doesn't matter but if you want to analyze the situation we have to be aware that we have two separate threats here one coming from the Palestinians and the second is coming from the Iranians of course hisbah and the htis and all the uh Shiite militias uh which are backed by Iran through from Syria

5:34 Iraq and and of course they're attacking also American bases now of course the task of Israel is to make sure that nothing can happen again said this could not happen again and the question of course is how do you do that and um I think that Israel should address two separate issues one is the intentions and the second is the means one is the motivation what our adversaries want to do that's the first question and the second question is what are the means or can they execute their intentions now um to the motivation of the Palestinians I'm following the Palestinian society and especially its relationship with Israel its attitudes towards the Jewish State what has been called the peace process now I can certainly say that in Brackets and unfortunately um there is no difference or I I would say that the Palestinian

6:37 Society is United perhaps on one and only thing and that is that the state of Israel should not exist and for this matter it really doesn't matter if you are a Hamas person or a fat person or an independent person whatever that means there is no difference in the perspective towards the existence of a Jewish sovereign state in the sense that we know today state of Israel with its government and army etc etc um there's a very um unanimous one-sided simplistic narrative one view in the Palestinian society and I urge anyone who you know thinks otherwise to bring me that Palestinian who would say otherwise um The Narrative goes like that they are the complete victims um their lands were stolen by the Jews in 1948 the Jews had no excuse to do that and that narrative remains from 1948 um you know many things changed in

7:39 the world from 1948 technology economy many things changed but the mindset of the Palestinians did not change um for the people who like history among our audience I urge you to read uh texts from the 40s and the 50s by Palestinians you would would be amazed how similar they are to what they say today now again Hamas and fat might diverge or might have different opinions or or you know Visions regarding the regime that they would like to create in this area of course Hamas is a branch of Muslim Brotherhood they have a more radical Muslim or Islamic vision and fat not so much so they have differences between them I'm not saying that they don't have differences but regarding the Jews the position of the Jews at best the Jews should simply be a minority under Muslim rule meaning no state of Israel no nation state for the Jews and of course at the maximum as we have just

8:43 seen murdering butchering raping you know committing any kind of atrocity that um uh you know human mind or even unhuman mind can can create so this is challenge uh Israel faces and and I think the entire Middle East Le in the entire world faces millions of people who are brought up and taught from day one that they are the complete victims and that their Injustice is so difficult is so harsh that almost anything is possible uh to address that Injustice I just want to bring you back to Munich in 1972 in Munich 1972 11 athletes uh uh were killed by uh PLO right that's fat and um they were their bodies were mutilated in atrocities that are similar to what happened here of course what happened here is 100 times worse because the number of the casualties is much bigger but the pattern is again the same and I have yet

9:48 to come across a Palestinian political figure politician novelist author and not even in Gaza Street some sometimes people say well you know they live under dictatorship so they can't really Express themselves Hamas is stifling their freedom of speech um by the way even in Nazi Germany you had the dissidents I don't see any dissidents even now I don't see dissidents and you see Palestinians in the Aspira were certainly free to raise their their their voices in in in the United States in Europe and what I see is exactly the opposite I see that they embrace the cause of Kamas they see them as libera so we're dealing here with an entire concept with the entire narrative National narrative who rejects the notion of the state of Israel now some people say that what we have to do with the Palestinians is similar to what the Allies had to do with Germany and Japan so you have to destroy them first of all

10:52 physically and then you have to somehow uh um Den naify Palestinian Society or deradicalize Palestinian Society so on the one hand I'm 100% I agree with that there will be no chance of any peaceful coexistence as long as the Palestinians are brought up with this um you know maximalist vision and intransigent Vision towards the Jews but I must admit that I'm not that optimistic and I'll explain why because the German societ you could Den naify German society and something could have remained of course we know that even in Nazi Germany many Nazis remained in the apparatus and the dentification wasn't really a complete work but you did have some politicians you did did have some Mayors from before the period of the Nazi regime Germany was somewhat functioning democracy in the 20s in the 30s you could find people like Conrad Adenauer and you know was

11:57 elected Chancellor because he was not a Nazi sympathizer unfortunately I think that you will not find today anyone in Palestinian Society who is not committed totally to the idea of destroying Israel so I think that our task is much more difficult with all the of course comparisons in history are very difficult but um I think that we have a very very tough work to do and this is a a job which Israel would not be could not be able will not be able to do alone it has to be a regional and an international uh attempt to deradicalize the Palestinian society that is for the medium and for the longer range I think that in the shorter term Israel must take some very concrete steps because as I said before there are intentions this is the motivation this is the spirit of the Palestinian Nation it will take time to change it but in the meantime we have to take away the means all the means that the

13:01 Palestinians currently have which they use to harm Jews to kill Jews Israel must take away all these means what does it mean it means demilitarizing the entire area as they say between the river and the Sea so the state of Israel the Gaza Strip and Judea and Samaria the West Bank should be demilitarized there should be no um weapons I mean heavy weapons no Hamas no Hamas in the Gaza Street no Hamas in the West Bank no Palestinian Authority in the sense that they cannot have uh heavy Armory or automatic G Guns nothing like that if they want you know uh pistols or something like police force to uh catch thieves or to disperse uh demonstrations that's okay but nothing that can be a danger to the state of Israel so I think Israel's uh um challenge or Israel uh one of its tasks after it finishes the war in Gaza would be to demilitarize the

14:05 entire area between the river and the Sea only uh official organs of the state of Israel meaning the IDF the police etc etc only they can carry heavy guns this is something that uh um we we have seen the price of mistakes in this sense uh Palestinian uh um uh the Palestinians both in the West Bank as we have seen have shown tremendous support to what happened on October the 7th not only from simple people in the street but all the way up we have seen ministers in the Palestinian Authority that so-called moderate pa pa and it's only a question of time or a question of the means uh or the ability that they would do the same uh from Jude and Samaria that is the reason why Israel must take steps right now or as we end the war in Gaza to demilitarize the entire area now of

15:07 course this war or a peaceful Middle East would not be achieved until the other axis is addressed as well and the other axis of course is the Iranian axis Hezbollah uh you know Iranian and Shiite backed militias in Syria and Iraq what happening in Yemen and the of course uh Iran itself I was of the opinion much before October 7th that Iran should not be um you know let uh conduct this proxy war imagine the position of of the Ayatollah in Iran they had their proxies they sent um sometimes missiles sometimes terrorist sometimes all kinds of skirmishes and they were not hit they were not harmed in Iran this is the you know this is a dream coming true for someone like Iran you have your puppets you have your proxies whenever you want you push a button and they harm the Americans they harm the

16:09 Saudis they harm the Israelis and no one reacts against Iran this should have uh you know been stopped much before October 7th and I think that there will be no solution to this uh um period of insecurity in our region before uh Iran itself is addressed and uh being responsible for everything which is happening in the area so I think I I uh I should stop here and perhaps uh have your questions um uh time for questions wonderful thank you so much we have quite a few questions coming in the first one is from David Edmund asking how does Israel the Us and other countries together develop a strategy to end Iran's State sponsorship of Terror and can it happen under the current well there are a few questions here first of all the question of ability and capability and then the will and then the politics of the United States so we have a few a few elements um for the

17:14 question if can they do it of course uh there's always only the question of will with all due respect to Iran that's a a powerful Regional um you know power nothing to be you know you don't have to estimate them but uh with the right combination of very strong economic leverage um cyber means all kinds of technological advantages that the West has and of course some very credible military uh threat uh Iran would not be the first you know to cave in the history of Rogue countries is full of of such attempts and such cases of of you know winning winning that's it that you need the will you need to first of all have the will to win now the question regarding the will of the of the American Administration we all know that there are very serious questions I think that when we say American Administration it's

18:16 not you know there are certain um you have the White House you have Department of State you have people in the Congress in the Senate Republicans Democrats so it's a question of who exactly do you um I am under the impression that right now there's a reluctancy from the American Administration from day one um there's a attempt to contain um the conflict to say okay now we're taking care of Hamas you know Hamas is our problem when we take care of Hamas uh okay we'll do some kind of a political solution etc etc trying to you know uh make it very simplistic um I I'm not of that opinion I think that's naive uh and I think not only that the Iranian issue will not be soed but even the Palestinian access will not be saved Hamas um did not arrive at the Gaza STP from the Moon Hamas is a very very

19:21 Palestinian represent I I hear people from day one I heard President Biden which by the way Israel is really you know grateful and thankful for everything and really he was uh very emotional in some of his remarks and and that was really great but I think that some of the things that he's saying are simply not true he's saying stuff like Kamas does not represent the people the Palestinians I'm sorry but they do represent the Palestinian people and you know a few days until or before October 7th if you would conduct elections I I I even think that even if today you conduct elections in the West Bank or or you know you will find more than 50% voting for uh Hamas you know for the last 20 years we have seen where Hamas took the Gaza street right Hamas took the Gaza Strip to Poverty to isolation to everything and still Palestinians from Jude and Samaria were looking they

20:23 were living much better lives life is much better in ramala than in Gaza life is much better in Bethlehem than in kanun and when they were asked who do you prefer they said they prefer Kamas so how can you say that Hamas does not represent the Palestinian people so I think there's a lot of work to be done in terms of really understanding uh the true problems of course there also politics if someone doesn't want to engage in a full out war or really you know taking care of the entire problem then perhaps he's saying that even though he doesn't really believe that but that's you know that's a question for uh that's a question um for the president himself to answer thank you uh Daniel pipes writes uh thank you so much Dr Schwarz for joining us uh can you please go into detail about your plan for the Authority that's a very good question and I think there are no good solutions for the Palestinian Authority as I said

21:26 before the pal inan Authority um is not a solution cannot take part in the solution and I said it very clearly uh there is no difference the vision of the PLO is that or the PA which is you know the PLO is the most important force behind it is to destroy the state of Israel now how can you ever have a peaceful or some kind of an agreement or some kind of a future when that is the that is the vision so of course the the PA cannot take any part in a constructive Vision on the other hand we have the short term and the middle term whereas Israel does not want to take care of the lives of the Palestinians we're talking about education which is by the way a huge thing because how they educate their children is is a subject in itself is part of what we're saying but Israel used in a sense the PA for all those matters there was some kind of a

22:31 cooperation I I agree that this is a moment in time that the role of the PA should be reconsidered now one thing which I I I didn't emphasize enough and I think this is the moment to say there would be uh very big importance to how this war ends so some of the things that we're saying now might change with the Dynamics of the war the war it's itself is an event which can have some repercussion so perhaps the war ends with a you know very big victory to Israel and Hamas is really you know you have all the heads of Hamas killed and you have their capitulation or Surrender whatever and you have all the hostages free that's one scenario you have different scenarios I think that it's a little bit too early to say exactly how the Gaza Strip should be uh run uh and again how the West Bank should be run but even if the PA remains as it is to the question I think all heavy weapons should be

23:35 taken away that should be a u you know a demand an Israeli demand that's it you don't have any you cannot have the means to kill Israelis um as to the you know more uh um medium and long term I think we have to reconsider to think how we go forward but at the minimum right right now we have to minimize the risks and that means taking away all the weapons all the serious weapons that's that's uh that's the start thank you uh Eric asks uh so with the world it's geopolitical uh pressure on Israel from from outside uh to not let this war go on for many months how can Israel demilitarize the the South where most of gaza's populations have gone and how can Israel avoid the world from stopping the war so I think there are two separate issues here one has to be the 100%

24:41 resilience of Israelis and when I say Israel is I mean from the prime minister to the last Soldier and to the last citizen that we have to conduct this war we have to wage this war and we have to win this war okay that is that's a must now there's a question of tactics how do you what exactly do you do every day in order to you know be able to execute your plans now I think that this is this is the challenge um if you ask me I'm against any kind of humanitarian pauses I think that Israel is going far above and beyond everything that it should have done I think this is you know we have been more than one month calling for Palestinian citizens civilians whatever that means because we don't really know what non-combatant or civilian means in in in in you know Palestinian context we have seen very clearly in October 7 that some of the infiltrators were civil civilians they were citizens you I saw someone running

25:43 with you know an old man running with uh was you know with he he could barely walk and it was important enough for him to go into a kibuts kidnap rape so so is that a civilian okay so Israel called on the Civ more than a one month and that's not you know that's not coming from Moscow to Siberia that's going from Gaza to kanun that's that's a few hours by walking okay that's perhaps one hour so I think we have done far and above whatever we have we had to do but I understand that in order to perhaps somehow plate or pacify or or you know uh um uh have the Good Will of of of um governments in the west especially the American government there are some stamps being taken that I don't think should have been taken but you know you do them I think this is exactly the way forward each day you have to tactically decide so the purpose must be 100% War but in the

26:47 meantime that's the that's the situation we're in you know Israel is the size of Belgium Ireland Denmark Portugal when we're not the United States we're not Russia we're not China we're not a superpower so there are limits and there are limitations of how we can conduct a war everything is known we know that the world is biased of course the United Nations is biased against us we know that there are Muslim communities in Europe and the United States which are against us everything is known but this is the situation where we're in and we have to win thank you uh so JL is asking about what about the surrounding mus Muslim countries like Egypt Jordan Etc is there any evidence that the citizens of those countries are more open to the existence of Israel or do they feel the same way as the Palestinians and on that note can you comment a little bit on the uh the Arab Summit that took place yes well unfortunately the the short answer would be no but I would make a a longer answer um you have to

27:52 differentiate between public opinion and and the people which I think are very very anti-israeli very even anti-semitic you have to bear in mind Cairo today is the number one exporter of anti-Semitic literature stuff that you can't find anywhere on Earth all the writings of Adolf Hitler all the protocols of the Elders of science are sold in Cairo like you know people believe it they are really really you know hardcore anti-semites I'm I'm not saying it very lightly but this is the situation and you have seen that of course they have their other problems Egypt is a is a poor country on the verge of you know bankruptcy Etc but if you think that the ordinary people in the Middle East most of them I'm talking about Egypt and Jordan which we have peace treaties with if you think that they're more open to the idea of a Jewish State I don't think so I'm sorry to say that this is not the case you have to differentiate the

28:55 leaders the leaders are much have to be much more pragmatic and as we know aissi just came after the Egyptian president just came after the Muslim Brotherhood he's very well aware of the potential of these uh of these people he was Waging War in the Sin with them he had the cooperation of Israel the same goes to the hashemite kingdom to the King of Jordan um his father had to fight Palestinian terrorists for years and he had to expel them so he's very cognizant of that his grandfather or his great-grandfather was murdered was assassinated by Palestinians so he knows in his family that Palestinian terrorists are something that are not easy to to deal with but so they would like Israel to you know eliminate Hamas but they have an inner problem because people see oh Israelis are you know killing bombing Palestinians so if Israel could have done it in one week or two week they would be very satisfied they want Israel to you know dismantle

29:59 and kill Hamas nobody likes Hamas here I mean Qatar likes them turkey likes them but not not Egypt and not Jordan and the last word to the to the uh uh Arab Summit or even the Muslim Summit so I think it was a classic case of of Arab uh um not only hypocrisy but also disagreement There is almost nobody there likes anybody you can see Iran shaking hands with Saudi Arabia which is ridiculous we know that Iran is responsible for killing Saudis not very not you know recently you saw um you know Syrian president Assad lecturing us about human rights right so you had really stuff which is which is uh unimaginable uh indeed there were reports in the Israeli media which I I can't verify I didn't see the the text themselves but that some of the Arab countries including UAE but the Abram Accords uh the the members of the the Abram Accords managed to block some of the harsher uh um resolutions against

31:04 Israel and this is something which I see in a very positive way it means that there are buds very small buds perhaps again in the UAE perhaps in Saudi Arabia in the more modern younger generation of leaders in the Middle East which understand that the future is much more aligned with the interests of Israel United States in the west rather than people who butcher you know kill ma rape people so I think that after we finish this war with Hamas um we could have a reemergence of that Trend towards the Abram Accords but first I think that we have to to finish the war with Kamas right well thank you on that note H can you tell our viewers where we can find some more of your work so um just to use either Google or I'm on social media Facebook just as you see my name uh you can find a book that I coauthored with anat Vil and it was

32:06 with the generous support of the Middle East Forum uh you can Google it up it's called The War of return and it was published in 2020 and unfortunately nothing changed and if you really want to understand uh the ethos of the Palestinian what has to be done we have a chapter in the end with recommendations what actually should be done then you're more than welcome you can find it uh an electronic version or uh hard copies whatever you want and feel free of course to write me comments or um ask me questions wonderful thank you so much unfortunately we had a lot of un uh answered questions I apologize to our viewers who submitted them uh they were all fantastic all right so we have come to the close of our webinar thank you again Dr Schwarz for joining us today thank you for having me of course for our viewers please join us Wednesday at 3m. Eastern for webinar with Ashley Perry thank you all for joining us and I hope you have a wonderful