MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Israel Insider

Israel Insider with Ashley Perry

Watch Israel Insider with Ashley Perry on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

Netanyahu seems to be leaving the possibility of a negotiated agreement open as the IDF head into Gaza City. What is the strategy behind this? Could the war be approaching its end?

Ashley Perry is an advisor to the Middle East Forum’s Israel office. He served as adviser to Israel's minister of foreign affairs and deputy prime minister in 2009-15, and has also worked with Israel's Ministers of Intelligence, Agriculture and Rural Development, Energy, Water and Infrastructure, Defense, Tourism, Internal Security, and Immigrant Absorption and as an advisor to The Negev Forum. Originally from the U.K., he moved to Israel in 2001. He holds a B.A. from University College London and an M.A. from Reichman University (IDC Herzliya).

Transcript Automatic captions

Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 18, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.

0:02 Hello, good afternoon and welcome to the Middle East Forums weekly podcast series, Israel Insider. My name is Anafav Kalam and I will be moderating today's discussion. We are pleased to be joined today by Ashley Perry, who is the adviser to the Middle East forums Israel office who joins us each week to give us a brief overview of the top events currently going on in Israel. Mr. Perry will speak for 15 minutes followed by a 15minute Q&A session. And if you would like to ask a question, please feel free to use the Q&A box located at the bottom of your window. And with that, I will turn the discussion over to Mr. Ashley Thank you very much, and good evening from Israel. Um, well, it is clear uh more than ever today that the clock on Israel's war against Hamas is ticking.

0:54 the diplomatic clock, the thing that uh people were talking about from the beginning of the war uh has been running out for a while, but really the one that matters is the one that coming from the White House. And it's clear more than ever that while President Trump hasn't said to Prime Minister Netanyo to stop the war, it's clear that uh he now has limited patience. uh some of the comments that's been coming out from him. Even if you can see that sometimes President Trump speaks off the cuff, there's certainly been enough uh messages to show that there is limited patience. He does want this war over.

1:31 There's a lot of things going on that uh that necessitate the end of the war. And in the next I don't know at some point uh uh today there's going to be um a uh from what I understand President Trump is going to uh release the day after plan uh which again is another sign that uh they're already thinking about the end of the war. It's putting pressure uh both on kamas to show that there is going to be an alternative to kamas. We don't know yet what's in this plan, but also to put pressure on Israel to say, "Hurry up. There is a plan now. Do what you have to do, but do it quickly." Um, more and more people are saying that this war will be over by the end of the year. Obviously, not the Jewish uh new year because that starts in a few weeks, but by the end of the calendar year. Um, but what is also true is that there doesn't seem yet to be too much urgency on the ground. And what I mean by that is it's clear also that Prime Minister Netanyahu and other members of the

2:34 cabinet are losing patience with the IDF chief of staff Zamir. Uh this has been going on for a while. But basically for the last few weeks there has been this plan to conquer Gaza city. Um it was passed through the cabinet. The IDF uh basically brought out the um the actual operation itself and that was passed through. Everything is ready but it's going to take time. Some people say it will take more than 6 months. Some people would say it will take a year, perhaps even longer. But what is clear is Israel probably doesn't have that much time diplomatically, especially where the White House uh is concerned.

3:12 The conditions for even entering Gaza City on a concerted basis. Yes, there have been minor operations in and around Gaza City on the environs in Zetun, which is just south. um those have happened but the conditions for a mass entry into Gaza city which would be necessary for for Israel to conquer it have not been created. First of all the uh callup papers haven't officially been sent out through the tens of thousands of reserves that would be necessary for such uh an incursion. More importantly, arguably is that the 1 million roughly Gazan residents of Gaza City have not yet vacated their areas. We saw uh earlier in the war that the world challenged Israel that they couldn't go into Rafa because there's no way they could um displace the hundreds of thousands of gardens there at the time uh to be able to do their operation.

4:06 They were able to do it. they were able to move the population of Rafa elsewhere and then uh basically conquer the city and clear it mostly pretty much of Kamas. Here it's a very different situation. First of all, Gaza City is much larger. It's the capital city. It's an area that mostly hasn't been touched uh by the IDF throughout the war. Um but there are several other elements. And what we understand tonight is of the around a million Gazan residents of Gaza city, only around 5,000 have relocated. The IDF Arabic spokesman of who's become quite famous in the Arab world throughout the war uh has has said to the Gazen residents to please leave to go south. There's humanitarian aid, there's tents, there's everything else.

4:52 But it's clear that they haven't yet, the overwhelming majority haven't yet um uh basically answered this. First of all, because there are Hamas threats. Hamas want as many people to remain in their houses as possible to make it more difficult to to get those headlines of uh civilians being killed, etc., etc. Um there's fear Hamas and others have put out that if you travel south, you will be killed, your family will go hungry. Um, but also there's the economic situation. Many people in Gaza are still living in their homes. Um, and to move south, uh, they've been told that you'll need a few thousand to buy a tent. And if you don't have a tent, you'll be sleeping out in the open. And people don't want to do that. So all of these conditions mean that as of now and already the plan to evacuate is already underway. only a tiny fraction have actually evacuated will make which will make it almost at this point impossible to do a full-scale operation uh for obvious reasons. So the clock is ticking

5:54 but there doesn't seem to be too much urgency. Perhaps it's a lack of planning. Perhaps they underestimated once again Hamas. Perhaps they misunderstood and they thought that this would be just like Rafa. But the end of the day we're almost in September. Uh we have only a few more months to the end of the year. Gaza city is not Rafa. It's not all these other place that Israel has conquered. This is the big one. This is the one that uh the Israeli public and the world have been told will end the war. That's Kamas's last hold out. But at this moment in time, uh already a few weeks in, uh we don't seem to be moving uh too uh far. Um on the diplomatic front, on the on the possible deal, uh again, things are not moving.

6:40 It's once again the blame game. A few weeks ago, the blame was all on Hamas. Hamas didn't respond to the Witito deal which Israel had agreed to. Now Hamas realizing perhaps that Israel had moved away from it have now accepted what some have characterized as 90% of the Witito deal or what Israel agreed to. Others have characterized it as 98%. Um and Qatar and Egypt are now turning their blame away from Kamas onto Israel at least publicly. and Israel uh they're still waiting for Israel to respond to Hamas's response to what Israel has already accepted. Uh apparently according to some of these interlocators um it's already been a few weeks and Israel has not responded yet. It's unclear exactly why Israel hasn't responded. U but what we have heard more and more from the higher echelons of the Israeli government is that they're no longer interested in a partial deal.

7:34 They want a full deal. all the hostages out, end of the war. But that would mean that Hamas would give up rule, they would surrender, they would give up their arms, and some would go into exile. Obviously, Hamas are not interested in this. Certainly not anything close to that at this point. Um the Trump administration seems to at this point have fallen in line with uh Netanyahu uh saying that at the moment the Witito deal, the phase deal, the temporary deal, whatever you want to call it, um is now no longer on on the table. And it that's another indication that uh the Trump administration and others just really want this war to end.

8:18 But they are at least at this point allowing Israel to try and force the end of it by military militarily conquering Gaza city, pushing Hamas to the negotiating table and trying to get something which will loosely resemble at least to some aspect uh of an Israel victory and a Hamas surrender. But it's clear the clock is ticking and it's clear that Israel doesn't have too much time and Kamas understands that and that's why it's diplomatically, militarily and on the civilian level on the ground they are trying to hold up Israel as long as possible because as long as Israel is not able to go into Gaza city in a concerted way and conquer it and maybe destroy some of the kamas remaining battalions there, uh then it just suits them uh very well. We did hear tonight um on American media Yil Lighter, ambassador of Israel to USA that Israel hasn't completely ruled out a uh a partial deal. Um I don't know if

9:21 he said that um off the cuff or there is a slight opening still for a temporary uh deal. That certainly hasn't come from the highest levels. But the fact that the ambassador of Israel said that perhaps could raise some hopes that a partial deal could still be on the table at some level from the uh Israeli uh side. Tonight, as I said, is an allimportant meeting in the White House with President Trump. There's been some interesting details of this so-called day after plan that's going to be released at some point, maybe the next few hours, maybe the next few days. Some interesting characters involved. Um, we know that former Prime Minister Tony Blair is central to this. We know he formerly had a role as the head of the quartet, which was one of those uh Urswell failed uh peace attempts going back a number of years. We know Jared Kushner is involved. And we also know that um uh Prime Minister Netanyahu's right-hand man, strategic affairs minister Ron Derma, is also in Washington in the White House uh

10:23 discussing uh these details. Whether he's part of the discussions or at least giving Israel's input into that day after plan, it's not clear uh yet, but I'm sure we'll hear more about that uh in the coming hours or at least the coming days. On the Iran uh front, things are getting very very problematic for Iran. uh today or tomorrow uh probably the E3 uh Germany, France and the UK are going to officially register with the uh UN what's called snapback sanctions. If we remember the JCPOA in 2015 uh as part of the deal uh the international community led by the UN would stop its sanctions crippling sanctions at the time uh on everything from the banking to the oil uh to all these very important issues uh industries for Iran um that they would uh be basically paused as long as Iran adhered to the JCPOA that 2015 Barack Obama broke a deal. Um the

11:29 Europeans are not happy about uh this the direction the Iranians are taking and as of tomorrow there's a very strong possibility they will start the process of what's uh being called the snapback uh sanctions. They will take around a month. There's a bureaucracy involved and there is still that window and that time for Iran to come back to the table. The Europeans have even stated that they hope the Iranians will come back to the negotiating table and negotiate or renegotiate some sort of deal before the snapback uh uh sanctions really take effect in around a month because they will be crippling to an Iranian economy already reeling. They have lack of electricity, lack of water. Uh the the local currency is just getting out of control. So this would be an extremely extremely difficult situation for the Iranian uh regime. Uh so we'll have to keep an eye on uh that one. Uh home in Israel, it's been quite a traumatic week. Started with the hostage families forum declaring a day of stoppages where they tried to shut the uh country down

12:33 as much as possible. Various industries went on strike. Uh there were demonstrations that closed down major arteries, highways, uh railway around the country. uh hundreds of thousands demonstrated around the country. Uh this isn't the first time, but it's clear that things are getting uh more popular from their point of view. More and more people are taking uh to the street and the activities that they're taking, not just in the public arena, but also against members of the government are certainly ratcheting it up. Uh one of the big issues uh in Israel again surrounds the whole enlistment issue. We've talked about that many times in recent weeks, the non-inlistment of the ultraorththodox community. Well, now the tempers have been raised uh once again because as tens of thousands of callup papers will be sent to the majority of the Israeli public or at least uh sectors from the majoritarian uh sector uh uh uh public in Israel to enlist, to go back to reserves, to fight in Gaza, to try and conquer Gaza city etc. But

13:38 there are tens of thousands of Israelis mostly from the ultraorththodox community who are looking to go on this pilgrimage which has become more and more popular over the last few years um to go to the grave of Rabi Nakman uh the breast of uh Rebi in Oman in the Ukraine. It's become a very popular pilgrimage and not only have uh are tens of thousands potentially going to Oman but now uh the ultraorththodox parties asked for the funding of these trips from the government. They've asked for 10 million uh shekels at least I believe it is and it's coming from various ministries. Let's not forget this is at a time of austerity where many ministries are being asked to cut back where soldiers don't have enough equipment where education systems don't have enough money etc etc but they seem to have found 10 million uh uh shekels specifically to allow tens of thousands of mostly ultra orthodox Israelis to go but the bigger outrage is at the moment

14:42 one of the um one of the uh areas of most of contention uh with the ultra Orthodox community are these sanctions on uh members of the ultraorththodox community who receive enlistment papers but do not enlist in the army. They are uh then considered awol and there are various measures taken against them. One of which they are not allowed to travel abroad. Um but uh uh Arya Derei the leader of the Shust party has asked has called for and apparently was even given a guarantee that none of these deserters they're they're considered official deserters will be arrested at the airport and they will be allowed to travel to Oman. So you can imagine uh the anger amongst all other uh sectors of Israeli society as their brothers, fathers, sons, uh friends are going off uh to war while tens of thousands are basically going off uh somewhere on a vacation at the expense uh of the government while the government decides to completely leave the law aside and

15:46 ensure that none of the people who are supposed to be arrested will do so. As one can imagine, this has really caused a lot of anger uh in Israeli society and this is what's been taking up a lot of media attention over the last few days. And with that, I'm happy to answer any questions on any of these issues. All right. Many thanks Ashley. I will begin with a question here from uh uh JL who asks is anyone taking these constantly changing deals promoted by the US seriously anymore? Every one of them has come to nothing.

16:26 Um yes they are taken very seriously because the US is really the power broker. Obviously there are other uh uh you know interlocators involved whether it's Qatar, Egypt or others but the US is certainly the the strong man in the room. Um and what they say certainly has value. They put pressure on some of the others to accept their principles. The Wititov uh deal was taken very seriously. It was debated by all sides. Um but it needs both sides to come to the table. One point Israel was there.

16:58 Uh Hamas wasn't. And now Hamas are claiming that it's there and Israel isn't. Uh but still the deal probably uh at the end of the day the deal will be brokered whether it's officially brokered in Doha, Cairo or whatever it will be with an extremely strong presence uh and input from uh Washington DC. So it still matters uh where the US uh stands on this and what the UN US does on this. Uh so yes, I would say that these these things are taken seriously, but at the moment there doesn't seem to be a permanent deal because Israel's uh you know uh uh what what Israel would need is far far greater than anything that Hamas could agree to at this point. And that is why Netanyahu feels that more military pressure, especially conquering Gaza City, will um hopefully bring Kamas back to the table for some sort of a deal.

17:56 All right. Thank you. Um I'm going now to um not quite a question uh a remark and maybe you can offer your comments on it. Comes from Roshelle Mand who asks or states uh President Trump can solve this whole thing by talking tough with Qatar and make them order Hamas to release the hostages. Can you comment on that? That's a case that a lot of people be making. Uh it's certainly not one that the Israeli government is making publicly. One can make of that what they will. Uh but yes, Qatar and Turkey, don't let's not forget some of Hamas senior members are also in Turkey. And if more pressure was put on not just Qatar but also Erdogan, uh perhaps Hamas could um become more amunable uh to a deal. But at the end of the day probably uh the deal has to be accepted by kamas in the strip in the Gaza strip uh the political leadership whether it's in

18:58 Qatar or or Turkey has some influence u but it's been argued that it's relatively limited and it's really the power brokers the the leaders whoever they are today because Israel's taken out quite a lot of them over the last two years uh in the strip are the ones who have to make the deal. they have to agree to it. They're the ones who hold the hostages. They're the ones on the ground fighting. They're the ones who hold the territory. They're the ones who uh have to be disarmed. They're the ones who perhaps some of them have to go into exile. So, yes, I've no doubt that there could and should be more pressure on Qatar and Turkey and others. U but at the end of the day, uh really where it matters is pressure on Hamas in the Gaza Carrie Hillibbrand asks, "Is it conceivable that the plan to conquer Gaza City is largely a bluff on Prime Minister Netanyahu's part?" I don't think it's a bluff. Um, but I I've said this many times over the last

20:00 few weeks. I do believe that Netanyahu wants a deal. He would prefer not have to go into Gaza City. I think he's feeling the pressure, the international pressure. He's feeling pressure at home. As I said, there were around 400,000 uh demonstrators out this week. If you think about Israeli society or at least um you know, that's if you take out the ultra orthodox, perhaps even parts of the Arab, that's between 5 and 10% of all uh Israelis. Um the war has certainly become less popular um over the last few months. Um different people have different reasons. Some it's all about the hostages. Some uh feel that what's going on in Gaza is becoming too much. Some are just exhausted by it.

20:45 There's a number of reasons why more and more people are feeling that the uh war should be ended and that's certainly putting pressure. It's not necessarily within uh Netanyahu's party uh or in his government, but it certainly is start it it is starting to eb away even there. Um and as I said, you know, President Trump has made it clear that time is uh is running out. So Netanyahu is certainly not openly bluffing. I think he would prefer a deal with them rather than go into Gaza with the lives that would be lost on Israel's side. The uh the the public diplomacy wins for um for Hamas that you know they've ratcheted up over the last uh few weeks since the hunger and famine campaign uh began. and that would just uh get worse and worse. So, I think Netanyahu would prefer the war to end, but he cannot end it without at least meeting most of his criteria.

21:44 Whether they're symbolic or real, that's uh a debate to be had in the future, but it doesn't seem at this point in time that Hamas are there. Um I'd be surprised um if a deal would happen before Israel went in at all to Gaza uh city. I think they probably will have to go in and then I think Hamas will probably have to make an estimation of how things are going. Uh but at the moment, as I said, things are going well for them. Uh the vast majority of the Gazan population has not moved from Gaza City. They haven't seen that massive military buildup to show that any operation is really just, you know, uh happening in the next few days. Uh so there's really there's not that pressure yet. Um, but we'll have to wait and see.

22:33 But perhaps part of this is to give some space for diplomacy. But I don't think it's a bluff. But I do certainly uh think that Netanyo uh let's just say he would prefer a deal over having to enter and conquer Gaza City. Right. Thank you. Um, now going to another question from the audience from an anonymous attendee who asks, "Why has Gaza City been left untouched as a strategic matter?" Well, there are a number of reasons.

23:06 First of all, because when you have a population, the whole Gaza Strip of 2 million and around 1 million of them in Gaza City, uh, one can imagine that it's going to be the toughest place to conquer. It's the last uh part of it's it's got the last real battalions and real Hamas sort of uh you know headquarters, but a major reason is is because there's a feeling that a lot of hostages are being held there. Um there has been a lot of talk this week that the Israeli army hasn't gone into certain areas of the strip specifically because they know from intelligent sources that that is where the hostage is being held. We are now, I think I heard earlier, one year since six Israeli hostages were killed uh as the IDF got closer to where they were the famous um murder of H Goldberg Poland and five others. Um and that that's weighed very heavily on Israeli society and the IDF. Uh so there's there's a number of reasons why uh Israel hasn't gone into uh Gaza City. Um and the

24:10 hostages uh is certainly one of them. And as I said, the fact that it's taking this long to come up with a plan uh to try and move the civilian population, it's it's the biggest city. Uh so it's obviously going to be the hardest uh to conquer. So that that's probably the reason why they left it to to last. Right. Thank you. Now, um, going to a question from John Walsteader, who asks, "How long can the 20 hostages possibly still stay alive under the appalling conditions of their captivity?" I mean, it's an impossible question to answer. My my feeling would be it wouldn't be in Kamas's interest for to let them die because just on a purely, you know, calculating point of view, they're worth more uh to Hamas alive than dead. First of all, because obviously they, you know, it it resonates more with the Israeli public.

25:08 Uh and they know that Israel will pay more in whatever it is um for live ones. Uh but also Israel can more easily rescue dead hostages because you can't, you know, to put it oddly, you can't murder a dead hostage. You know, if the Israeli the as is done as has done quite a few times even in recent months, uh when Israel goes on a rescue operation for a dead body, it's not like Hamas can kill them while they run away. Um, but I think the main reason is is it's just yes, it I'm not ruling it out. And even President Trump keeps on talking about less than 20, which has shocked a lot of people in Israel because we've always been told that there are 20 live hostages. And President Trump on at least two occasions has spoke of less than 20. So it could be that some have died or maybe some were always dead and they just were defined as alive or allowed to be defined as alive because again that strengthens Hamas's hand. Um but I don't think they'll keep them in appalling conditions. I don't think

26:11 they'll let them die uh if possible because again just purely from a calculating point of view they're worth more to Hamas alive than dead. Thank you. Now, uh, uh, segue to another question, if bit of a morbid one. Um, what is happening to the bodies of the dead hostages, and how is Hamas holding it's a difficult question. We can only go by what we've known before. Sometimes they're stored in hospitals. Uh, sometimes they're buried. Sometimes they're held uh in tunnels. Um, you know, that's just going by uh previous experience. It is a very morbid thing. I can I don't want to distress some of the viewers here, but there's some really disturbing stories um which uh you know has come out, some of them openly, some of them less so of uh body parts that were rescued individually um over the last uh two years. Um but

27:15 they they're they're holding on to them. They know where they are. Um and they'll just you know that that's unfortunately that's also part of the deal that's being spoken about. They're talking about 10 the partial deal at least I should say at this point the 10 live hostages and 20 although I did see the number 18. I'm not quite sure why because it's to my understanding it's supposed to be half uh 20 uh dead bodies as the first part in this uh partial deal if it ever should happen. Uh so they clearly have the bodies. They know where they are. We've seen it before when they what when they need to hand them back for as part of a deal. Uh they know where they are and they do hand them back again. We we remember that terrible story of Shiri BBas uh when they gave the body of someone else that wasn't Sheri Bbbass. But very quickly within 24 hours they gave back Sherei Bbas's body. So it's clear that they knew what was going on and they just wanted to torment the Israeli public one more time.

28:16 All right, many thanks, Ashley. Uh, we are unfortunately out of time for this week's podcast. I want to thank you again for taking the time to update us this week. Absolutely. Thank you. Of course. And for our viewers and listeners, please be on the lookout in your email inboxes over the weekend for our forthcoming podcast offerings email. Uh, as always, I thank you all again for joining us, for your viewership, and for your participation. And I hope you all have a wonderful day. Thanks.