Israel Insider
Israel Insider with Ashley Perry
Watch on YouTube
Description
PM Bennett speaks of forming a second ‘National Camp’ to compete with Likud. How likely is that to succeed and what might it signify?
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 4, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:01 hey good afternoon and welcome to the middle east forums webinar and podcast series israel insider with ashley perry i'm stacy roman and i will be moderating this discussion today we are pleased to have mr ashley perry advisor to the middle east forum's israel office join us here each wednesday at 3 pm eastern for an update on all events going on in israel mr perry will be giving us a briefing on current israeli affairs for 15 minutes then open it up for questions should you wish to ask a question please use the q a box located at the bottom of your screen to type your question now with that i will turn the discussion over to mr ashley perry thank you very much stacey and good evening from israel we're going to focus much of tonight let's talk excuse me um on what was described as a media blitz by prime minister naftali bennett uh in the weekend's newspapers last weekend uh it's the first time uh since he took over the job around eight months ago that he's really devoted significant
1:04 um to the media to getting his messages across talking about his achievements talking about his challenges and he didn't just choose one or two or even just one uh he gave six major interviews um obviously here in israel the friday papers are the most significant the weekend papers uh for those who are more observant of the jewish sabbath you know the the actual prince publications are very important because you're not online or watching tv or listening to the radio whatever it is um so these are always the most sought uh papers of the week um and there's a lot uh to pass uh through in the many interviews a lot of them are the sort of expected stuff uh attacking netanyahu his predecessor uh for his what he calls a propaganda of um sending his uh msrs out to attack him etc etc um it's a lot of interesting stuff about uh his positions vis-a-vis iran um
2:09 palestinians coronavirus got a lot of play because that's a major issue and um there's a there's a lack of confidence let's say so in the lack of support and what this uh current government is doing on the omicron wave uh some uh i think this week uh per capita israel had one of the infection rates in the world even if they don't have very high you know sort of applicable uh death rates fatality rates although this week there's been around 50 deaths every day which is extremely high but uh on the whole not uh not in line with uh the actual infection rates and some say they were slow some say they were confusing orders this day one one message or one decision was made the next day something he got a lot of play on that a lot of pushback from some of the interviewers um the first thing i want to talk about is why why he decided to give them now i
3:11 think a big part of it's connected to the netanyahu penny bug and their so-called big bang that we've spoken about in the last few weeks it's now not happening it's been put on the back burner i think uh it won't be put back on the front burner as it were for a good few months if not half a year they still haven't decided on your attorney general it's been narrowed down to three but the discussions are going um there is uh an interim attorney general but they're not gonna make any major decisions and then when a new attorney general is appointed they're gonna need a lot of time to catch up uh to learn the case inside and out and obviously the netanyahu's lawyers will be looking and studying also the new attorney general to see what direction they're going in whether it's worth an outreach whether they could get a better deal which i doubt that they had possibly on the table with so uh to a certain extent israeli politics is back where it was a month ago before even this talk of a plea there's a lot of talk about the timing
4:14 of that did bennett know that the plea bargain was now taken on the table but did he do the media blitz thinking that p balkan could be on the table and this government may have had weeks if not only a few months to exist i i think it's a combination of things i think the netanyahu the suggestions or the possibility of netanyahu leaving politics for a while certainly played into that um i think the fact that his approval rating according to one poll at least were as low as four percent uh again it's not like in in the us where it's just sort of um you know do you like or not it's uh they put them up against various other figures in israel sometimes it'd be seven eight nine ten other figures so four percent it's not as it's low but it's not you know it's not a one-on-one race where the other person gets 96 or something like that or they disapprove the the disapproval was 96 it's not as simple as that but it's still very low uh and obviously the omicron and the economy and everything going on that
5:16 certainly didn't help but what was uh interesting about it was a number of things a number of things that was interesting uh many people focused on some comments that he made where again he tried to uh you know his right-wing positions he's stressing all his interviews i'm still a right-wing man i still believe in everything i believed in before i saw him against the palestinian states i would not meet with alba mars and i would not meet with anyone who was taking itf soldiers to the hague uh the icc um despite the fact that members of the cabinet are he said that there'll be no oslo process unlike in his predecessor's time alluding to netanyahu who had met with mahmoud abbas and other senior palestinian leaders had allowed a peace process a diplomatic process to happen various times during his tenure uh and he really tried to to push his right-wing credentials admitting that it's a difficult government to govern because there are different elements with people who disagree with him and you know they
6:18 they they have their meetings they have ideologies they have their their own narrative and but there's going to be no there's going to be no practical purpose he talked about the fact that he stopped he said no to us president biden on the u.s consulate issue in jerusalem uh he played this up he said i've i'm more right-wing i've been building more and now at the moment uh today uh because pretty much his last decision allowed the establishment at least post no problems or challenges to the establishment of a new uh outpost of vietnam which is a big bone of contention within the government that could also bring up some issues but what he did say which was interesting is that he is the head of a new national camp um national kirk in israel means the right-wing cab the left-wing is usually called the dovish camp or the police count the national camp usually signifies the right wing and what a lot of commentators we're trying to get out of that is that
7:22 there is talk the assessments claimed bennett is trying to uh put his yamina party with gideon tsar's new hope party and abigail lieberman's israel baitino party together to create a new uh right-wing party that could challenge that he could this is what a lot of people were talking about my particular view is it was something less than that i i don't believe that there will be this new party i think what he was trying to say is that there's a significant national cap within this alternative government um and that it's significant enough and it's leading the state i think his argument would be that he's allowed he's done a lot more right-wing things even than the previous so-called right-wing governments that's his argument um and while i'm sure that there have been talks have been certain people interested in putting together a larger party i don't believe it will happen for a number of factors
8:25 enough time bennett makes sense because he really hasn't made that many inroads since he's been prime minister uh to try and get boost his numbers uh his numbers when it comes down to how much percentage he would get in the next elections how many seats has not expanded he's pretty much lost most of his right-wing base his right-wing religious base he's brought in some more moderates moderate but he's probably lost his base so i think uh uh he understands that so maybe uh for him it makes sense even for gideon um who is polling numbers have really dropped in certain polls he's not even reaching the threshold which means if elections were held today he wouldn't necessarily even uh pass the threshold and and gain any connectivity uh for a victor liebman it makes less sense and uh and the reasons are multiple first of all avito liebmann as opposed to the other two have has a solid base let's say solid we're talking about five to six minimum of old
9:28 russian-speaking israelis they can count on his ensuring no matter what that he will look after that base and you know if he can get another seat or two that that's an added bonus um as i said has lost his base did on sal never really captured a base and whatever base he had seems to have deserted him perhaps returning that he could according to the um but also victor liebman has been burned by this sort of coming together of other parties uh there was a time it was i think if i'm not much mistaken where liquid and yeshua bettina ran together that was mostly on the vice of um american strategist arthur finkelstein who worked with both and lieberman and was trusted by both and he came up with these numbers together the parties would have 45 seats returning to the days where there'd be one supremely large party and that's what uh the two parties sort of ran on they believe that together they could become one larger party uh in the end they
10:31 actually uh slumped to a pretty amiga 31 and i certainly think that burnt of interleavement and it also sent a wider in israeli politics on the whole some of your parts you're never as strong together as the sum of your parts because again avito lieberman and naftali bennett may be close on diplomatic issues or political issues or security issues but on other issues for example religion and state which is a major issue at the they're much further apart you've got the hawkish members of yamina on religion and state issues where tishra betena is far more dovish on religious state issues what i mean by that is wants to reform things like cash would conversion uh the cocktail compromise uh things like that they're much closer to your shattered positions on those so i think it would be very unwieldy to have these uh parties together and again you know they can agree on certain things that disagree on other things
11:32 while they're separate parties but together it's far more difficult to formulate to common stance across the board so i don't see that happening i could be wrong but i just don't think it will happen because again you'd have to put the egos they're being burnt where where is their base because if you if for example victor lieberman comes in maybe some of the more traditionally based supporters of natalie bennett would then be turned off and move to another party and vice versa so again i just i just don't see that happening but i think what bennett was trying to say is that he is you know his government that he's leading has a significant right-wing camp in it and they are getting some things done obviously not everything and he underlined the fact that he's not able to achieve everything he's able to but i think that's more likely than anything else so i don't see necessarily the formation of a new party uh obviously there's a certain amount of time until elections someone never knows another very interesting element and
12:34 it's significant is that uh one of the papers that he went to gave a very long a lengthy interview is israel young yes for those who aren't familiar is the largest uh has the largest circulation israel of any paper primarily because it's free it's given out on every street shops and restaurants or whatever so it has a very large circulation it was created by sheldon adelson and basically became what many uh claimed at least was a mouthpiece for netanyahu even gained the nickname bibiton playing on netanyahu's nickname and uh eton which is newspaper uh it's something obviously the paper itself rejected uh but interestingly shelton anderson passed away a number of months ago and uh his his widow miriam also has taken over uh at the paper and it seems like she's a lot more angry over netanyahu's attitude towards the paper and that's
13:39 what part of the uh criminal case is that uh he said that he would stop uh israeli on from having a fire jet edition which hurt its main rival your deals i'm not in the deal with your dior why not uh um to give more favorable coverage that's i think that's uh their case 2000 that's a large part of case 2000 and adolescents were certainly not happy about it at the time but a lot more information has come out during the court case and it said that miriam adolfson certainly feels a lot more bitter towards the whole experience than our late husband did what we saw this week was that the editor boss bismuth resigned or at the position or who knows was asked to leave the position uh bose b smith was very much in the netanyahu account was very much a loyalist to the netanyahu narrative and donald trump as well uh the fact that he's been uh replaced um has led to a lot of suggestions that the paper is going to start moving
14:41 towards nathalie bennett that apparently miriam had also a lot more sympathetic to uh bennett don't forget bennett was attacked many times in the past as all of latino's allies were and if bennett could become the benefactor of this new change in towards him from the larger circulation circulated paper in the country that could be highly significant there are those who say that it's happening and a lot of people point to the relatively sympathetic interview he received from yesterday whereas probably he wouldn't have received such a sympathetic one uh previously so there's a lot of a lot of talk about that and although it may seem relatively insignificant it can be possibly extremely significant i would like to hear any questions that you may have on any of these subjects or anything else that's happened this week okay thank you so much we have quite a
15:44 few questions coming in the first one from an anonymous attendee is what are the odds of an election being held in the near future and if so what party is likely to win well the first question i would say i think is unlikely one never knows um i think that now that abhijaimental has left the attorney general's office uh the plea bargain has certainly been put off for a number of months if not up to as i said half a year if even the person who comes in we don't know who that will be but it's suspected that netanyahu probably won't get as good deal as he would have under vanderbilt so perhaps the whole issue is off the table which means netanyahu remains as leader of the opposition for now uh which also means that this government still retains uh the significance of being that anti-sort of bb coalition some argue that the only glue of this coalition is the fact that um uh it's it's you know it doesn't trust
16:47 netanyahu on many different levels so i think at the moment i don't see elections happening uh in the immediate near future and as far as who's going to win well uh you know as we talked about before no one really wins that one party wins israeli because it's you know it's about their share of the knesset usually what happens is that who wins the election usually happens in negotiations after that the numbers are not drastically changing uh from portapol that it could has certainly gained a few of its seats perhaps as i said earlier the cost of um new hope on sales party but the numbers the overall mathematics hasn't changed what actually most polls have said that neither block will have a and the reason for that is because the united arab list will have uh six or seven seats maybe even eight so
17:50 neither neither side uh could form a government without them and they won't sit with either side it's one thing for mansoor abbas isram party who has for a while been you know reaching out or reached out to but no one will sit with um with the united arab so at the moment we could be if there were elections today and the results of the polls would be the actual results we could just be going for a subsequent uh number of elections after that thank you and eric asks is there any scenario where the religious movement will lose some of its power in israeli when it says religious movement i'm not clear exactly what it means but i'm going to assume the ultra orthodox it's it has lost power because it's in the opposition and uh everything that's happening now in religion and states uh certainly to its detriment you know it's had the monopoly over custod uh you
18:53 know kosher standards and restaurants and and hotels etc it's losing its monopoly on conversion so that the chief rabbinis is trying to fight that truth and now uh it's lost uh this week with a part passage of the first reading of the enlistment bill this is something which ostensibly uh if one remembers back to that after the first elections before merry go round of elections uh israel vito lehmann's party said that they wouldn't join a government that wouldn't pass past this law and this law would require a greater number of ultra orthodox to serve in the army or do national service and increase the numbers every year but uh so so if this law actually passed at the second time of counting at least it passed its first reading but obviously it's got a bit of a way to go but it's something which joel truth looks like he fought against truthfully behind closed doors it's not a great impediment for them you
19:55 know they fight a tooth and nail publicly and they claim it's a destruction of jewish learning in the state of israel but behind closed doors and i've spoken to a number of people involved with these parties they they're they're not afraid of the law they even sort of laugh a little bit i've even heard some members of knesset from the ultra author of the parties laugh that this is the great thing that they're going to do it's it's it's not significant enough for them but uh certainly and they don't like to be in your position they need to be in power they need to be closer to decision making for the budgets for their yeshua vods or whether it's for uh these decisions you know they want to fight every reform because they they they take a maximum position on issues of religion states so certainly it's hard to use them but as i said with the with the dynamics as they are in israeli politics the ultra orthodox are always an attractive partner for any block whether it's left to right because they don't have firm positions on certain key issues like the diplomatic or security
20:57 issues as long as they get there budgets they get control over certain ministries whether it's religious affairs or interior so they're suffering they want to be in the coalition but at the moment they're being kept up they're probably if if it will expand uh they're certainly uh one of the favorites to to join but there's still a lot of opposition from within the government from that happening thank you from london uh how much influence can netanyahu have in the near future in israeli politics massive influence you know uh even in opposition as i said so much pivots around him if this government as i said um if netanyahu were to take a plea bargain or to resign for public life or resign from the liquid it would be a massive it would be the big bang um so as long as he's there um the government stays for the time being
22:01 uh they will have internal elections in the liquid by the end of the year but at the moment he would be expected to win especially as uh his opposition is is not focused on one person it's unlikely that anyone will rally around one particular opponent there's lots of uh people who see themselves as as future heads of the liquid i think his position at the moment is safe um he doesn't have much say uh you know day-to-day governance obviously because he's in your position they make a lot of noise uh there's a lot of attacks on bennett and the that's rhetoric if they could you know stymie a vote here and build there then that's a win for them but at the end of the day it's about making noise from his side thank you and changing gears a little bit rabbi joel schwartzman asks most attention in american jewish in the american jewish community has been
23:03 focused on amnesty international's libelous report accusing israel of being an apartheid state is there similar outrage in israel apart from the comments coming from lapid i think amongst the average israeli no it's not it's not a big news item i certainly didn't read the news it's more in sort of you know from policy circles people who read the international media uh it's been known for a while in these sort of circles that there has there is a coordinated and concerted approach to try and frame israel as an apartheid state the case obviously can't be made and it hasn't been made but the terminology is there i i read the report before it was uh released and you know it was all over the titles all over the opening paragraphs but the case simply wasn't even made seriously um but it's part of the propaganda war uh against israel it's the attempt to delegitimize it or to make it the pariah state and you know they tried in the past to try and say
24:06 israel was nazis and they understood that didn't work because of obviously uh the historic connection with the holocaust uh but apartheid is is uh they've understood that it's a good frame of reference because uh a lot of the people that are are reading it especially the sort of so-called millennials a little bit older don't remember apartheid south africa they just know it's bad it's racist it's um so but it's a good framing from their point of view because it certainly frames israel as an evil state you know probably uniquely evil even though amnesty has called myanmar apartheid not sure they call them apartheid said some of their actions and policies they claim that's why they didn't single out israel it's clear from the fact the human rights watch used it amnesty uses it this anti-israel organization's bds movement uh has used it so it's clearly part of a concerted coordinated attempt to label israel but there was a lot of pushback uh coordinated to a certain extent from the jewish world the zionist world
25:10 and that's where it plays out it plays out in the sort of ideological sphere but in israel the average israeli is not concerned it's not involved uh doesn't really care about these sort of things it doesn't affect them on a day-to-day basis or even on a you know a wider basis but obviously in foreign foreign policy circles in the foreign ministry it is a concern because there is the fear that eventually could start catching on and you know sort of be equated as it was by some to the fa infamous i should say u.n resolution equating zionist with racism this is the sort of modern attempt to equate this role as an apartheid status to take a state that shouldn't uh it isn't just can't be justified was born in sin and should disappears as many would like it um so that's certainly a worry in foreign policy circles in israel but amongst the average israeli very very thank you robert lyric asks uh what do
26:13 you think of israel participating with naval drills with the us oman bahrain saudi arabia for the first time as he understands it well it goes back you know there's there's been a lot of uh coordination uh there's there's not any uh open drills with with some of these countries uh but there's certainly a lot of below the surface uh coordination this week in it was considered quite historic but i guess today's you know with everything that's happened perhaps it's lost some of its resonance we had an israeli president the head of state of the states the jewish and democratic states fly over saudi arabian airspace openly and publicly that was considered very historic and certainly you know if someone would have said that a few years ago you would have said it's impossible especially not with movement on the diplomatic the palestinian issue but the fact is these things are happening today so um an open public uh military drills with some of these
27:18 we're not quite there yet but i i don't think uh i don't think we're a million miles away from maybe something more open there's there's a lot of talk and a lot of sort of bets on who would be the next country uh qatar came out i don't think qatar necessarily at the top of the list anyway but they came out and you know there's there's nothing doing for us because uh you know there's nothing doing on the palestinian uh from let's talk about indonesia perhaps there's talk about uh oman um oman obviously actually hosted prime minister former prime minister netanyahu so again we're talking about countries who are having more open steps towards israel uh so this is certainly positive positive thank you well we're on the military side of things here uh jacob hershman uh in the last few days bennett has been referring to a laser shield that should be implemented in the next 12 months or so is this real um from what i understand and i'm certainly not a military expert it is
28:20 real uh whether it's going to be implemented in the next 12 months there's a lot of people who say it will take a lot longer than that what he talked about is this sort of uh laser system that would surround israel that would be able to shoot down missiles and all uh all of its fronts uh what what's significant about this is because it would change the dynamic um the sort of missiles that are thrown into israel at the moment especially from gaza i said launch not are relatively cheap but israel's ein dome cost something like 50 000 uh a battery uh and obviously you know the idea is for hamas to exhaust israel financially or whatever it is and you know we get a lot of the funding from the us um but uh you know if we look at what he's been have on the northern front it has something like seven times the amount of rockets or precision longer um and quite simply it would be exorbitant to try and fight off
29:24 these sort of batteries also uh hamas found a ways round iron dome where they've fired dozens at a time uh sometimes you know very rudimentary uh rockets that i don't doesn't shoot down so this new system that uh bennett uh proudly touted apparently will be much cheaper cost a few dollars per laser as it were and the hamas rocket's getting more expensive than the first ones so it changed the dynamic there but a lot of military experts have said that he is being overly optimistic that they'll be ready in 12 months it only the system's been trying out and tried out on drones and other systems but uh to have it surrounding israel within 12 months again i'm not an expert i can't give anything behind the scenes on this but uh a lot of commentators coming out and said yes eventually we could have something like that in several years not the one to two year timeline that prime minister bennett talked about this week thank you so much and one last question
30:27 from carrie hillibrand uh recently israel announced the planned par procurement of several million no novavax coveted vaccines does this represent a no confidence in the israeli-developed pre-life vaccine that is approaching approval um to the best of my knowledge it's not that close to approval um we're talking about an old-school vaccine in israel actually they're trying to be a sort of hybrid between the new style vaccine and the old-style vaccine i don't think that we'll be able to develop it at the speed and the numbers of some of the more international brands there's been a lot of controversy surrounding that there's that the people behind the israeli vaccine have said that they were stymied after a great publicity under netanyahu then the money wasn't there and the assistance wasn't there as opposed to some of the other uh global brands that received assistance from uh from you know international governments um the fact that you know we've been using fisa all this time and we continue
31:30 to use fires of an even somewhat donor and some of this uh i i wouldn't say it doesn't show any confidence in israeli i'm better the fact is you know you need to take what's on the market now rather than wait you know who knows how long it will take and the efficacy and everything else if when it's released if we can see high efficacy if it's cheaper if it's you know whatever it is longer term you know that's that's the secret today it's not so much the efficacy it's whether it can last a long time because we've seen all the major uh rna vaccines are very effective but in the short term they're not lasting as long as everybody would hope so if the israeli one could show that it has high efficacy and longer term uh solutions and i'm sure the israeli government will will go with it but uh you know it seems like korean virus is here to stay so you know you have to you have to take whatever's out there because coronavirus is is with us yesterday today and tomorrow and unfortunately you can't wait for a few months time to see what may be so i think that's it's more about that
32:36 all right thank you so much well we've come to the close of our webinar and podcast ashley thank you so much for taking time to update us this week thank you and for our viewers and listeners please join us friday at 1 pm eastern for a webinar with dr walid ferris thank you all for joining us and i hope you have a wonderful day