Webinar or Talk
"The Heist of Iran's Nuclear Archive and Its Continued Importance" with Tzvi Kahn
Watch on YouTube
Description
The half-ton of files cataloguing Iranian efforts to develop a nuclear weapon that Mossad removed from a Tehran warehouse in January 2018 continue to shape the discussion of Iran’s nuclear program. The covert archive contained much information that contradicts longstanding assumptions about Iran’s nuclear program by revealing additional nuclear facilities, equipment, and activities previously unknown to the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA). What is the impact of the archive? How does it affect the IAEA's ongoing investigations? What should U.S. policy be?
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 12, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:00 right hello and welcome to the Middle East farm speaker webinar series i'm stacy roman and i will be moderating this discussion today we're pleased to have sveet khan a research fellow at the foundation for the defense of democracies join us to discuss the heist of Iran's nuclear archive and its continued importance mr. Cahn will speak for 10 to 15 minutes and open it up for questions should you wish to ask a question please use the Q&A box located at the bottom of your screen we'll do our best to get to all questions but we have many participants on this webinar today so I apologize in advance to do not get yours with that I'll turn the discussion over to mr. Z Khan thank you very much Stacy and thank you to the Middle East forum for inviting me today it's good to be with you what I'd like to do over the next few minutes is talk about Iran's nuclear archive but it means its implications for the 2015 nuclear deal and other non-proliferation agreements and its implications for US policy towards Iran today earlier this month the Board of Governors of the
1:02 International Atomic Energy Agency IAEA which is the UN body tasked with monitoring Iran's nuclear program and verifying its key nuclear related commitments passed a resolution criticizing Iran for refusing to provide access to two suspicious sites one of them is near the city of ibadah and central Iran according to the IAEA the site may have it involved quote use and storage of nuclear material for outdoor conventional explosive testing may have taken place in 2003 and quote in relation to nuclear weapons development how did the IAEA learn of this site well Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu had publicly exposed the site last September and Israel found out about it from Iran's nuclear archive what's notable though is that this is only a tiny piece of the Iranian nuclear puzzle because the archive tells us a lot more about Iran's nuclear program than just this one site let me provide a little bit of background about the archive in January of 2018 Israel's Mossad intelligence agency conducted a
2:04 raid on a warehouse in Iran's capital city of Tehran removing about 55,000 paper files as well as 183 CDs with another 55,000 files on them all of which catalog Iran's efforts to develop a nuclear weapon Israeli officials estimate that the Jewish state sees only 20 to 50% of the archives total contents covert archive contained a wealth of new information that contradicts long-standing assumptions about Iran's nuclear weapons program specifically the archive identifies additional nuclear facilities equipment and activities previously unknown to the IAEA Israeli officials estimate that the for example it discusses a tunnel complex at the Parchin military complex known as the Shaheed Mirage Rd project likely intended for the fabrication of uranium based nuclear weapon components similarly the archive indicates that Iran conducted more high explosive tests at Parchin than earlier IAEA reports indicate the archive also expands on a
3:09 plan known as project Madan to construct an underground test site for nuclear weapons this reality points to flaws in past reporting on Iran's nuclear program in a December 2015 report the IAEA assessed that Iran's efforts to develop a bomb quote did not advance beyond feasibility and scientific studies and acquisition of certain relevant technical competencies and capabilities end quote similarly a 2007 US National Intelligence Estimate judged with high confidence that Iran halted its nuclear weapons program in 2003 if the archive shows that the nuclear weapons program continued Albia in a more circumscribed and diffused manner past 2003 likewise the archive indicates that Tehran as of 2003 had already designed a nuclear weapon and developed plans to produce five warheads in fact the archive includes the minutes of meetings of Iranian officials many still holding leadership positions today that discuss methods for concealing Iran's
4:12 nuclear activities the archive even contains so called deception folders according Iran's miss informations IAEA officials thereby ensuring their uniformity in each meeting with the why did US intelligence and IEA get it so wrong what happened well in August 2002 an Iranian opposition group exposed to clandestine sites in Iran a uranium enrichment plant and a heavy water production plan after the United States invaded in Iraq in 2003 Iran fear that it will become Washington's next target however rather than halt its nuclear program Iran devise a strategy aimed at preserving it while minimizing the risk of detection mm-hmm to that end Iran split its nuclear weapons project into covert and overt parts over parts located at research institutes and universities consisted of nuclear activities that Tehran could plausibly describe as non military in nature covert sites meanwhile would focus on research and development of weaponize
5:16 ation activities aimed at preserving and advancing iran's expertise this effectively misled IAEA and US intelligence and what are the practical ramifications of August today well for starters torrents decision to preserve the archive is ink is inconsistent with its commitment under the 2015 nuclear deal formerly known as the joint comprehensive plan of action or jcpoa in the jcpoa Iran commits quote that under no circumstances will Iran ever seek develop or acquire any nuclear weapons end quote if Iran no longer seeks nuclear weapons though why would it preserve the archive moreover the archive refers to specific nuclear equipment whose use is prohibited by the jcpoa yet the current location of this equipment is unknown if Iran continues to use such equipment covertly today Iran would be in violation of the jcpoa it's not only the jcpoa that Iran is violating Iran's failure to declare the sites in the archive to the IAEA constitutes a
6:19 violation of the nuclear non-proliferation treaty for NPT which Iran ratified in 1970 under the NPT Iran is required to sign a comprehensive safeguards agreement or CSA with the IAEA which requires Iran to declare all nuclear sites in its territory Iran is also likely by a the Additional Protocol for AP and add-on agreement to the comprehensive safeguards agreement Iran signed in 2003 and that provides strength and tools for the IAEA to detect undeclared sites as a result IAEA cannot reach a credible broader conclusion that all nuclear material in Iran remains in peaceful activities in other words this means that Iran is violating not merely a it also means that Iran is challenging the cornerstone of the non-proliferation regime the NPT represents it means that even as Iran was negotiating the jcpoa between 2012 and 2015 it was actively concealing nuclear sites from the
7:21 international community it means that even as Iran was implementing the deal post 2016 it was actively deceiving the IAEA means that Iran's duplicity visa b the jcpoa is merely an attempt of the iceburg this reality has starving locations for the IAEA and the United States pursuant to the IAEA statute IAEA Board of Governors may refer any non-compliance with the Comprehensive safeguards agreement and the Additional Protocol to the UN Security Council of similarly parties to the jcpoa if faced with non-compliance by Iran may also refer your rods the UN Security Council to implement the jcpoa skee enforcement mechanism this enforcement mechanism is as follows if Iran violates the jcpoa the united states and unilaterally reimpose all sanctions enacted by the UN Security Council even without the support of other countries such as Russia and China such a step is known as a snapback mechanism the United States
8:24 retains the right to initiate a snapback even though the trump administration withdrew from the jcpoa in negative 2018 UN Security Council resolution 2231 which endorsed and codified the jcpoa defines the term participants state in the jcpoa to include the United States a State Department legal opinion released in December of 2019 maintains that the resolution does not envision a change this definition even if Washington abandons the jcpoa on the contrary the jcpoa was specifically designed to facilitate a snapback if one of its parties believes at any time that iran is engaging in significant non performance of the accords provisions I believe it's long past time for the UN Security Council to snapback sanctions on Iran for its long history of nuclear mendacity yeah in the IAEA Board of Governors resolution earlier this month which I reference at the start of this talk it refrained from referring Iran to the UN Security Council for refusing to provide
9:26 access to Avada and one other site as my colleagues Jacob Nagaland and restrict of the foundation for defense of democracies have read the resolution also contained no warning of future punishment the language in the resolution was also soft merely calling on Iran to cooperate with IAEA not requiring it the resolution also lacked stronger language describing Iran's violations and a potentially military nature of its activities what accounts with IAEA Board of Governors reticence most likely it is afraid of Torpedo in the jcpoa if the UN Security Council snaps back sanctions on Iran it was spelled a death note of the jcpoa yet I believe it's long past time that the international community recognize that the jcpoa is not the solution to the Iranian nuclear challenge if the jcpoa were so effective why did it fail to learn about the sites mentioned in the archive likewise the IAEA Board of Governors needs to recognize that Iran's violations of NPT comprehensive
10:29 safeguards agreement and the Additional Protocol are separate from its obligations under the jcpoa if the IAEA fails to uphold the decades-old agreement that lies at the heart of the non-proliferation regime why should any other rogue regime take the IAEA seriously that state is nothing less than integrity and credibility of IAEA accordingly I believe the United States long last invoked the jcpoa snapback mechanism in order to punish Iran for its nuclear violations only the Rhian position of strong sanctions will persuade Iran to halt its has its long-standing history of nuclear I'll stop there thank you very much and I look forward to your questions okay thank you so much so I guess the first question is wow that's a lot of information what can be done to get the international community's head out of the stand I guess you're just going over that but have these sites been like visited and seen that there is actually
11:34 a nuclear proliferation going on there well we haven't gotten access to the site and I think that's part of the problem I think what the United States needs to take lead on this and I think one of the best ways you can do that is finally invoking a snapback mechanism because that would put the international community to a real choice it'll basically say to them look you have these sites Iran isn't providing access to them so what are you going to do about it what does this say about the IAEA non-proliferation regime and I think if the United States were to do that at long last I think it would force the international community to act whether they want to or not because this is part of this is the cornerstone of nature of the non-proliferation regime why do you think there is such reluctance to pursue the snapback isn't in everyone's best interest well I think it's because it would rapido the jcpoa I mean I think the jcpoa for many people and particularly in Europe and Russia and China has become too big to fail it's basically for them it's the it's
12:38 the cornerstone of the entire non-proliferation regime for them it's basically says that if you if if this is what's not if if you don't have this agreement and Iran is definitely going to get a nuclear weapon it's gonna destabilize the region but I think that's not true and I think what's I think what's that the jcpoa has actually inflamed the region because what it's done is it's basically allowed Iran to conceal these sites it's allowed Iran to to pursue its nuclear ambitions overtly while simultaneously providing Iran with tens of millions of dollars of sanctions relief which it's used to expand its regional ambitions and its support regime throughout the region so so that's not a particularly fair trade and I think the international community has been in denial about this far too long and I think that if we were to vote the snapback mechanism it would basically call out they're bluffing would call out the fact that the jcpoa has not been working and i think the international community is just loath to admit that because it goes against what they've been believing and advocating
13:40 for all these years how accurate are these files today do you think since they were already several years old when they were taken by Mossad well I think they're very awkward this has been a this has been confirmed by IAEA and taught by US and British intelligence excuse me there's no reason to doubt their authenticity Iran these are in Farsi language documents that that has been group that has been very reviewed by US intelligence that has been reviewed by my colleagues at the Institute for Science and International Security and what they've seen is that this referred they refer to sites and to and to facilities that have been long known to the international community and to the IAEA so I don't think there's any real doubt about this at this point these are authentic files and I think that we have to long-last recognize that so that we could get to the bottom of Iran's nuclear program so you mentioned that the US would be the most likely choice to lead the way on this but can you
14:44 speculate on how a change in the office in November would have any effect on this that's a great question um it's likely to have a big effect because President as Vice President Biden has pledged to reach in for the jcpoa the weather will actually act on this pledge I think is actually an open question because if because what happened problem with the jcpoa is that's key terms begin to expire in 2023 so it by a 10 but so by the time President by a president biden would reach the end of his first term the jcpoa would already begin to be expiring so as a result he has to have a plan he has to have a post jcpoa plan and i think that already in here for that he needs to have leverage on iran he needs to have leverage so that he could actually lady Ron who force Iran to negotiate a new add-on agreement so if he were to return to the jcpoa he would lose a lot of that leverage so I think we'll see what happens whether or not President bite of a President Biden will actually do that but I think he's gonna have a
15:49 very difficult choice to make because if he doesn't go back because if he chooses to go back to the jcpoa he's on a time limit in that time he's on a ticking clock and that clock is going to expire by the end of his first term thank you can you comment on the explosion of the Iranian test site that was reported this past week by satellite imagery well we don't know that's a great question I think time will tell at this point there have been earlier and there been earlier there been some reports that this was commandeered by Israeli intelligence as part of an effort to undo its nuclear it's a sabotage US missile program but I think at this point there's still too many unknowns to really comment on that so I wish I could provide more information I think time will tell and we'll have we'll get to the bottom of it eventually choose to disclose this intelligence instead of keeping the Iranians unaware that the Israelis knew well I think that's a good that's a great question I think what likely is they want IAEA to act on it they want an international
16:51 community to act if they could keep there's not much there's not much used to having this information if we don't do anything I don't think just holding it Kirtley necessarily accomplish much they need IAEA to inspect these sites and I think part of it I think in doing so it can and I think in doing so it can allow the high eh inspector and if Iran refuses to comply with the IAEA then it could go then Iran then then international community could bring Iran to the UN Security Council countermeasures and the u.s. can invoke the snapback mechanism to reimpose sanctions on Iran so I think it's necessary for us to expose this side before us to expose the archive because if we didn't because by doing so it allows us to impose real penalties on Iran and expose the fact that Iran has been blind in fact that the jcpoa has not been working all this time so what is the status of nuclear programs of Saudi Arabia and Egypt and Turkey which were initiated when details of the jpoa leaked out five years ago well those site knows program those
17:57 programs are still I think in their budding stage I think at a certain point that you know they're not going to be announcing it publicly these programs if they're these are programs obviously that they don't want necessarily they don't want the international community to be to get onto it so quickly so I think right now there's still however likely in their early stages I don't think at this point that they're at the verge of going nuclear or anything like that they want to I think they're right right now they're hedging their bets and they're holding on to see what happens with Iran's nuclear program and to see if the United States and Israel are going to enforce the red lines on Iran and actually let Iran get a nuclear weapon I think if Iran goes nuclear or if they continue to expand its nuclear activities without getting some without stopping then it's very likely that Iran that Saudi Arabia and other countries are going to expand their nuclear programs and see events as a necessary counterweight to do wrong given the dispersal of Iran's testing and
19:00 development projects just a military action against Iran still is military action against Tehran is still feasible that's a good question short answer is no I don't have access to Israeli intelligence into US intelligence I don't know exactly whether or not what degree they have the abilities to to attack Iran's nuclear facilities I do think though that's - I'd be very surprised if they don't have a counter plan if they don't have a plan they need they need they have that I mean this is an existential situation for Israel it's obviously a mere existential for the United States as well if you're after onward to attack the US city such as Washington DC or New York so I think they obviously I would be very shocked they don't have a plan and I think that they would have to that over time they would have to pre prepare for this and and time will tell alright so many questions coming in this is a very interesting topic for sure
20:05 does Russia give its full support to Iran's nuclear program or do they want it to be limited well I think they want it to be limited but at the same time they're not as concerned about it as the United States or Israel is and I think that's part of the problem right now Russia is vociferous ly opposing the renewal of the arms embargo on Iran which is right now pending before the UN Security Council they've long provide assistance to Iran's nuclear program I think they're in a bit of denial about Iran's intentions and I think part of the problem is that they want to for them this isn't just about Iran's nuclear program it's also about great power competition with the United States and for them Iran is partially an ally they want you they want they want Iran they wanted sell arms to Iran they want to basically show that they're a regional power broker in the region and so I think they are in effect supporting Iran's nuclear program although I don't think they're necessarily too boozed
21:09 about going nuclear but for them this is about much more than in the Iranian nuclear program it's about regional power projection projection and countering the United States and that's why I think it's very it's very so you're eventually mentioning the redline earlier but now in this current situation what do you think the pathway to escalation would be what would be the trigger for the Israeli and/or US kinetic action it's a very good question short answer is we don't know I think Israel and United States are watching this very closely I think what's likely I think would likely be a very key trigger who's as it's great as it is Iran's breakout time breakout time refers to the amount of time that Iran needs to develop enough uranium highly enriched uranium for one nuclear weapon so if Iran were to reach the lope right now its breakouts fine according to the Institute for Science and International Security is about three months as that breakout time Iran is I think the United States and Israel are likely going to wake up and say hey
22:10 might have to act so if that breakout time goes continues to go down then I think the odds the chances for us military or Israeli military escalation or going to dramatically increase so the NRC thinks boiling water nuclear reactors are more dangerous than traditional nuclear reactors what do you think I learned if the reactors I don't know the answer to that who are the ones who originally allowed such a poor agreement to be offered and accepted and to whose benefit did this well this was a prop this was a project of the Obama administration in the international community the p5 plus one that's Russia Russia China Europe Britain Germany and France so this was a lot this was a long-standing project the Obama administration it was basically planned for years actually and I think I think the Obama administration hoped that this
23:15 nuclear core that this nuclear deal would defang Iran's nuclear ambitions and at the same time as they repeatedly said it would they hope that it would meteor onto Madhuri I think that was a key plan of the hope was that if this nuclear deal were signed that Iran and it would lead to further cooperation between Iran and the international community so if so if so right now I think that was the plan it has not come true mud it has Iran is not moderated and I think that was hope but it has not come to pass jumping back a little bit you explained what President Biden might do but what if it's President Trump what do you see happening well I think President Trump is very eager for a new nuclear deal with Iran I think that's part of that's the premise of his strategy and I think the maximum pressure campaign is going to continue under President Trump if you were
24:17 reelected if Iran continues to pursue its nuclear ambitions and if the breakout time continues Oh down then I think Iran is likely then then the United States is gonna have a choice about whether or not to engage in military action but for now I think President Trump is certainly not going to engage any military action before an election and I think right now he's his mind is elsewhere and and I think that right and I think he's going to have to anything he's gonna have to make a decision if you were to win reelection and the break-up time goes down about what he's going to do thank you so much unfortunately we have run out of time but if you could please explain to us where we could find some more information on this go to WWF GD org that's the website at the foundation for defensive democracies where I work wonderful thank you so much for for giving us all out terrifying but
25:21 wonderful information we really do appreciate your taking time out of your day for that for our viewers please join us Wednesday at 3 p.m. Eastern for Ashley Perry's weekly Israel insider update and thank you all for joining us again and I hope you have a wonderful day thank you very much