Webinar or Talk
"When Marx Meets Islam" with Craig Considine
Watch on YouTube
Description
In this episode of the Middle East Forum Podcast, host Lauri Regan speaks with Craig Considine, a senior lecturer in sociology at Rice University and a writing fellow at the Middle East Forum, about his new book, When Marx Meets Islam: Navigating Radical Ideologies in Defense of the West. Considine, for years one of the best-known Catholic voices defending Islam, explains how his experiences in the UAE, the backlash to his interfaith work, and the reaction to his condemnation of the October 7 attack led him to identify a "Red-Green alliance" between Marxists and Islamists.
He traces how the Frankfurt School recast Marx's class struggle as a binary of oppressed and oppressor rooted in identity politics, and why Marxists and Islamists, despite their differences, make common cause against the United States, Israel and the West. Drawing on the Bolshevik and Iranian revolutions, he argues the alliance is a tactical coalition that breaks apart after victory, and lays out his chessboard model: students and activists as pawns, professors as bishops, groups such as CAIR and Code Pink as knights, progressive politicians as rooks, and foreign patrons such as Qatar and China as kings and queens. He also describes the backlash he has faced at Rice.
In the Q&A, Considine draws on Karl Popper's paradox of tolerance to call for truth, moral clarity and accountability, including transparency about university funding and an end to diversity statements. He also discusses the riots in France, whether Abu Dhabi is now safer for Jews and conservatives than Paris or London, Qatar's funding of American universities and K-12 education, Black Lives Matter's influence on school curricula, and how the term Islamophobia is used to shut down criticism.
Chapters
0:00 Preview
0:21 Welcome and introduction
1:26 From interfaith voice to critic
6:41 Liberalism vs. leftism
7:57 The Frankfurt School and cultural Marxism
11:37 The unholy alliance's common cause
15:41 Will the alliance last?
17:37 The chessboard analogy
22:44 Under fire at Rice
26:34 Q&A: Popper and the paradox of tolerance
28:20 Truth, moral clarity and accountability
31:53 Europe, France and the Gulf
36:42 Are students arriving radicalized?
39:39 Islamophobia as a weapon
43:04 Closing
Subscribe to the Middle East Forum for new episodes and expert analysis every week.
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 20, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:00 If you can take down the United States, you can take down the West. So if you can take down the US, you can take down Israel. The Abraham Accords are like the kryptonite to the Red Green Alliance. Good afternoon and welcome to the Middle East Forums weekly podcast. I want to thank you all for joining and for your continued support of the critically important work that we do here, especially at these historic and dangerous times. I hope you all are sharing our work with friends, family, colleagues, and others in your networks.
0:36 This afternoon, I'm very pleased to be joined by Craig Considine, a senior lecturer in the department of sociology at Rice University, a writing fellow for MEF, an internationally recognized scholar on Islam, and author of numerous books, including his latest, which is the subject of today's discussion, When Marks Meets Islam: Navigating Radical Ideologies in the Defense of the West, a copy of which I have here. Craig's book is a critically important work helping to describe what he calls the soft war on Western civilization as he recognizes that the war on the west begins on college campuses where the intellectuals who brainwash the foot soldiers on their campuses are funded and organized by Islamist organizations with foreign funding and then they're sent off into the world to infiltrate our society and its institutions at large. Welcome Craig and thank you for joining us this Thank you Lori. Good to see you.
1:26 You too. Um, I I think a great place to begin, Craig, would be uh for you to explain to our audience a bit about your background and what compelled you to write this book. For almost 20 years, you were actually one of the best known Catholic voices defending Islam. And you even wrote a book entitled The Humanity of Muhammad and the people of the book. When did you first sense that something had shifted? As I know you also recognize that this didn't begin just on October 7th, 2023. And in this context, um, Greg, perhaps share your personal experience at the MEF conference in DC a year and a half ago, at which Yeron Lashinsky, um, who actually attended the conference and listened in on on your panel, and Sarah Mgrim were murdered outside of the Capital Jewish Museum just hours after you spoke.
2:10 So, let me begin with my undergraduate days. When I was at American University, I was a sophomore and I'm a post 911 uh, student, right? So I graduated from college in 2003. So 2004 I was taking a class called the world of Islam with ambassador Akbar Ahmed who's the former high uh high commissioner from the Pakist from Pakistan to the UK and I took a class there and it focused on interfaith dialogue and I thought Dr. Ahmed was offering the antidote to a lot of the hard war or the violence and the bombs and and this type of conflict that was uh rampaging across the world with the invasion of Afghanistan and Iraq. So I picked up on the interfaith angle and I rolled with that and I got to Rice in 2015 and in 2018 and this is where I started noticing some changes uh amongst Muslims uh around the world in regards to my work cuz I was in the UAE for the first time in 2018. The forum for
3:12 promoting peace in the in Muslim societies which is backed by the UAE government invited me to speak there. years later, I was at NYU Abu Dhabi giving a talk on Prophet Muhammad on one of my books and then I also went to the launch of the Abrahamic family house. So those moments in the UAE which preede October 7th started for me planting a seed in my mind that a lot of the interfaith work I was doing was not met on the opposite side with good intentions. So they like the fact that I'm speaking highly of Prophet Muhammad and I'm speaking highly of Islam in the Islamic tradition, but they didn't like the fact that I was in the UAE. So even prior to October 7th, this seed was there. And obviously we know UAE and Israel joined uh in tandem with the Abraham Accords. And I write in the book, the Abraham Accords are like the kryptonite to the red green alliance.
4:09 They absolutely hate it because it's all about the normalization of Israel and also about the integration of the Middle East. Now those trips again that kind of planted the seed. It also coincided with my books. So Lori, you you were mentioning the humanity of Muhammad and the peop and people of the book. Both of these books were talking about religious pluralism and the importance of bridge building. So I was doing my part with good intentions to try to bring peace, harmony and coexistence into the world. That was met by a lot of dissenters to my work with opposition. And the opposition came largely through the prism of my own identity. They didn't like the fact that an American, a white person, a Catholic was speaking highly of Muhammad and that my voice was actually getting out there and becoming popular in the Muslim world. So they started rejecting that, pushing back against that, not just publicly but also online. I was facing severe severe
5:13 attacks on my social media accounts. So I started learning here that the interfaith goodwill was being replaced by dogma, political dogma and identity politics that only certain people can talk about certain subjects and also with the political dogma there was a type of group think uh amongst the circles the Muslim circles that I was working with where they didn't like the fact that I was going against the grain which is actually looking at Isra as a democratic western country in the Middle East. Now, October 7th was just like the tipping point or the breaking point. I went out publicly for the first time on my social media and I said, "This is a terrorist attack. Hamas is a terrorist group." I was condemning the student protest, which I'm sure we're going to get into at a later point. Uh and that for me the backlash was so significant.
6:12 It made me realize that everything I had previously gone through was part of the same thing I was going through at at the moment. So I kind of doubled down and just realize that I must be doing something right because if you're speaking the truth, people aren't going to like that. So the journey continues obviously uh here I am with MEF. Um so yeah. Yeah. Um, and we're happy to have you here at MEF, Craig. Very happy. Um, so in your book, and it begins with the preface, you um, distinguish between the terms liberal and leftist, liberalism and leftism. And you point out, uh, it's linked to Marxism. Um, and you address throughout the book and and you state at one point, quote, the rise of cultural Marxism in academia has had a profound impact on the intellectual landscape of Western universities. The new generation of Marxists, Marxists, focuses on wielding power within institutions rather than dismantling them from the outside. So Craig, can you elaborate on that and the way that you believe
7:15 classical liberalism became hijacked by the political ideology of the left or more precisely the Marxists? Yeah, so the preface of the book begins, so even before you get to the intro, it's demarcating the lines on these categories. What I mean by leftist and liberal. So a liberal in my understanding and I think in the traditional understanding is someone who is pro- enlightenment. And if you're pro- enlightenment, you're pro- individual. So that means you promote freedom of speech. You promote the civic orientations that come with a democratic society. You support capitalism. It's freedom and it's liberty. Now that got hijacked largely due to the Frankfurt school in the 1920s and the 1930s out of This group of Marxist scholars again 1920 1930 Germany uh were were looking at how they can transcend beyond the classic Marxist binary which is if you
8:19 understand Marx the oppressed and the oppressor or as Markx put it the boogeoisi verse the proletar proletariat. So the bourgeoisi being the people who owned land, the wealthy versus the proletariat basically being the workers. And in Germany and in the west, so it extends beyond just Germany. Even in western academic institutions, they were starting to realize that this binary of the workingclass struggle was not resonating with students. So they created a new binary. And that new binary of oppressed versus oppressor was largely rooted in what I mentioned uh in the previous qu question identity politics politics. So the oppressed were not the working class. The oppressed were the minority religions, the minority races. Uh it was also the third world. So they completely mashed it up and they made it about uh some type of culture and they made it about white
9:21 supremacy about Christian supremacy about uh western supremacy uh and this has carried over into the modern day. So the seed was planted in you 100 years ago that that's where we're at now. But if you look at western academia uh especially in the social sciences and and history and the humanities this is the prevalent ideology. This ideology as I argue in the book is the root cause really. Lori you mentioned it earlier it's all about the campuses. It starts with the students and it starts with uh the curriculum. Uh and and we're seeing this explode. It exploded after October 7th, but the seed was planted uh long ago and a lot of changes need to happen within academia and a lot of it happens not just with foreign funding but it happens inside the classroom and it happens with what the teachers are actually presenting to the students because this
10:24 binary this cultural Marxism especially for certain uh types of students who look like me or who have a similar faith than me, they have to reject uh their identity in order to be considered a a good citizen because if they don't, they're the oppressor. And that's toxic. You're raising an entire generation of young people uh in in these citadels that are supposed to be about enlightenment thinking and free thought and democracy and pride for your nation to hate their nation. And this has carried over into uh pre-occtober 7th, but especially post uh October 7th dynamics where the US again conflated in the red green alliance with whiteness, with Christianity, with Western power as without any regard for Hamas, for Hezbollah, for the IRGC. It's a massive blind spot. So the issue is primarily rooted in these institutions
11:28 which happily have gone through the ringer at least in the last couple years under the Trump administration. So we're I'm going to come back to campuses and and actually your chess analogy we're going to get to in a in a couple minutes. I wanted to talk about one of the premises of of your book is based on the unholy alliance which was the name of David Huroitz's seminal 2004 book to which you make reference um is the unholy alliance between leftists and Islamists with their extremist ideologies finding common cause. So my first question on this topic is what is the common cause as you refer to this as the most significant ideological threat of our time? Um, so I'm wondering if if if it's simply a shared hatred for the West and Judeo-Christian values, or is there more on a micro level? And given that Marxists are secular and Islamists want a religious order, which is very different with their views on women and gays, for instance, how do you explain their partnership in what you call this soft war on Western civilization? Uh, and I guess I can just add, do you think
12:31 that this alliance is going to survive or will the Islamists eventually discard the Marxists? It's a it's a very good question and I think what you mentioned Lori about whether it's just about a hatred of the west western civilization and Judeo-Christian values that's largely accurate. Uh and their actions their motivations and their strategies prove that. So it's not just me speaking theoretically or on top of some ivory tower. It's in their websites. It's in their declarations. It's in their manifestos. It's in their speeches. it's in their rallies. So, this is a a clear uh strategic motive for them. But more specifically, we have the USIsrael alliance that is in the crosshairs of the Red Green alliance. If you can take down the United States, you can take down the West. Uh you can take down Europe, you can take down Canada, you can take down Australia. And we're seeing horrific scenes out of France.
13:34 I'm sure many of our audience members today have seen the the riots that are being uh framed by a large portion of the media as simply young uh disgruntled students uh who are upset that they don't have enough math teachers. Uh it's it's certainly uh much more than that. the the issues are are are deep here. Uh Lori and with with Horowitz, what I was trying to frame is that he was 2003 with the Iraq war and he was outlining the the protests, the anti-war protests that were actually happening. Uh I'm framing it as 20 years beyond. That book was published in 2004. So we're we're way beyond this. and the institutions, the organizations, the student groups that are behind the Red Green Alliance are much more entrenched within the institutions that we're that we're
14:36 seeing uh in academia. It's very difficult to be pro- American. I can say this even as a professor who loves my country. And then Israel on the other side of this is like the western outpost or the western colonial state uh somewhere in the Middle East. So if you can take down the US, you can take down Israel. So the Red Green Alliance has a shared strategic goal and I mentioned this in the book. It's a tactical coalition. A tactical coalition. At the micro level of things, we see the the red element of the alliance largely the students and the professors and academia providing the moral language. Right? So terms like settler colonialism, apartheid, genocide, imperialism, colonization, all of these words are music to the ears of the Islamist groups. So they're providing the food that the Islamist groups actually need to digest and they they they appreciate
15:40 that. Now in terms of whether this alliance will last, it hasn't lasted in previous generations. In the Bolevik Revolution, which preceded the Cold War, we saw the communists in power leading the revolution. And a lot of people don't really recognize that a a Muslim component was a big part of that Bolevik revolution. Not massive, but it was part of it. And because they were living in the Tsarist uh Russia at the time, they were marginalized as Muslims. And the Bolevik revolution was all about this oppressed oppressor. So if you're a Muslim, then you have to be oppressed.
16:20 So they got on board. and the Bolevik revolution happens and the Muslims get purged along with any anyone else that deviated from the party line as Orwell uh mentioned in uh his multiple books and I speak about Orwell Lori you know this cuz you read the book I speak about Orwell throughout the book. Now in 1979 we had the opposite happen with the Iranian revolution. it was the Islamic uh regime that got into power. But this time there was a significant red component to this. The red component was a huge part of that coalition that actually made the revolution successful.
16:59 What happens after the revolution succeeds? The red element gets pushed away and basically marginalized because the regime could wipe their hands and say the goal has been achieved. the Islamic system has been implemented. You're no longer useful. And that's why I use the chess analogy that a lot of these young people, especially these activists, are simply pawns. They're doing the dirty work for a lot of regimes that are authoritarian that do not have the best interests of the country that these students and activists are actually from.
17:37 Okay. So, so I'm going to have you walk us through the the chess analogy now and um the role that each of these components plays and and perhaps this is also a good opportunity maybe for you to share a couple of your personal experiences from your time at Rice, which has not been pleasant to say the least given the way your former allies uh came after you once you backed the Abraham Accords and Israel's right to defend itself. So, in particular, what role do faculty administrators play in this chess analogy? And is there any way to sort of knock them off the chessboard, so to speak? and I mean reduce their influence and power over the hearts and minds of future So I I wrote the book in the context of the soft war. But to allow uh readers to visualize this, I placed it in this chessboard analogy because if you're familiar with chess uh and I became familiar with chess by writing this book actually, you realize that there's strategy, there's there's moving parts. So throughout the book, you actually see all these different moving parts because it's not one part that wins the game. It's all the parts
18:40 coordinating together. So for our chess uh advocates here, you're going to be familiar with this terminology. The weakest or smallest piece on the chess board is a pawn. And I frame the pawns in the book largely as the students and the activists who are, as I mentioned earlier, they're doing the dirty work for the regimes and the organizations that have a nefarious agenda. Pawns are easily also disposable. If you're familiar with uh chess, you can get rid of them when they're no longer kind of useful. They're just kind of discarded uh away. The second level of the chess board are the bishops. The bishops as I frame it in the book are the academics.
19:24 These are the professors. These are your uh these professionals who are using highly sophisticated theoretical language that is morphed in a way and biased towards the west especially as I mentioned earlier social sciences, humanities and history. So you have the student or the activist the actual body the impressionable mind and then you have the professor who's saying this is the reality. So the indoctrination comes through the bishops. Next tier up are the knights. So now we're out of the five pieces the knights are kind of in the middle. The knights as I frame it and the larger sophomore uh that the red green alliance is imposing upon the west are the organizations largely the civil society organizations uh these entities so in this context care the council on American Islamic relations you have ISNA you have Jewish voice for peace you have code pink you
20:28 have the people's forum they're not just providing cover for the the pawns and the the bishops, but they're also engaging in political advocacy at the highest levels of government. They're also fundraising. They're lobbying. They're going out into the public. They're going into mosques. They're going into churches. So, they're in civil society. They're covering that realm. The next element of the chessboard are the rooks. The rooks are the politicians. And in the book, because it's Red Green Alliance, it's largely focusing on progressive politicians. Back to our earlier point, not your moderate Democrat per se, but your progressive woke politicians. So, I isolate Mamani, AOC, Rashida Tale.
21:17 Unfortunately, Elsa uh has emerged, but that was before the book was actually written. But these politicians, these rooks turn the campus slogan or the syllabus or the mission statement of the organizations into actual policy. And that's where it becomes quite dangerous because policy is the law of the land. And then finally, we have the kings and the queens of the chessboard. These are the foreign patrons. So you have Qatar. Qatar has a huge section in this book with not only its uh financial funding to American universities but also its diplomatic work trying to provide cover for Hamas and supporting Hamas and hosting Hamas. We also have Al Jazer Alazer is a huge player. China is providing uh support whether financial or media related to Roy Neville Singum who is behind the people's forum. People's Forum is a communist, not a socialist group, not
22:20 just a Marxist group. It's an open communist group uh working on the streets of of this country uh to cause mayhem. The type of mayhem that we're actually seeing uh unfold in in France today. I also look at Hamas. Uh Hamas is a is a huge player of this. Turkey is involved uh as well. Now, at Rice, I'm a bishop. Uh, I do not indoctrinate my students. I tell them on the first day of class that I'm here to teach you how to think, not what to think, which is not the norm at universities in general, uh, across the West. My issues largely stem from October 7th, especially when the height of the protests on campus happened in March and April of 2024.
23:16 And I put out a video, Lori, of my of these student protests, largely calling them pawns, doing the the the dirty work of the authoritarian regimes and the terrorist groups uh around the world. And this was met with all sorts of backlash primarily from my department. And I'll I'll spare the details. Uh I also witnessed my Wikipedia page, not my Wikipedia page, the Wikipedia page under my name online. As you know with Wikipedia, I don't own it. I I can't edit it. Uh that was butchered and and slandered by someone who was a student in my own department.
24:00 Um, I've been attacked several times by SJP online via their social media account, uh, calling me a Zionist. Uh, in in this context, that is a uh, declaration because for a lot of students, uh, a lot of the pawns, this is equivalent to Nazi. And if you can decry someone as a Nazi and frame them as a Nazi, uh, you can do whatever to them because these are the worst people on earth. The last incident I had came right after I returned from Israel. I was on a JNF Jewish National Fund faculty fellowship.
24:40 And when I was there, I was sharing all this amazing stuff I was doing there, meeting people, Palestinians, Muslims, Christians. We went all across the country. And I got back to an anonymous complaint filed by an anonymous student uh that I was homophobic, which is a a clear lie and a blatant attempt to just make my life more miserable. And I've had to go through the legal process at Rice uh to deal with a lot of these and the support has not been great. The last question uh I think I addressed it Lori. What role do faculty and administrators play in this um two primary roles with faculty? They're providing the justification for the protests for the harassment of Jewish students for the public declarations that they hate the United States. The administrators protect largely not professors like me, but they're
25:43 protecting professors that tow the administrative line, which is rooted in the cultural Marxism. It's rooted in the identity politics. And if you fray too far from that, if you start targeting certain religions as potentially problematic, then you're ruffling too many feathers and they don't like that. So, it's an uphill battle. I'm not the only professor in this country that's actually going through this. There are many and actually my next book it's called the end of inquiry and I'm working with another professor who also got cancelled on how the pursuit of inquiry or knowledge has been replaced by this hierarchy of identities and this idea that everything needs to be kumbaya and you can't criticize anyone or any group or any religion. So that's the next book.
26:34 Well, we'll have to have you back for that, but there's a lot of questions in the queue right now and um we're going to try to get to as many of them as possible. I hope you're okay to stay a little bit longer, Craig. Um uh I So, someone actually mentioned Carl Pauper, coincidentally. I don't know if they've read your book, but you did um refer to philosopher Carl Puper's argument from his book, The Open Society and Its Enemies, that unlimited tolerance can ultimately empower the intolerant and lead to the destruction of a tolerant society. So maybe this with in response to the person mentioning Popper, you could uh tell us what you think some thoughts are on on how to defeat this evil partnership. And in in that context, someone had um actually also asked about whether uh there's any corrective action that can possibly be taken uh on universities. So maybe try to bring everything full Sure. So yes, the book ends on Carl uh theory on how a tolerant society, if it's too tolerant of intolerant groups
27:39 or intolerant ideas, it allows those ideas in groups to get oxygen. And if you give too much ox too much oxygen, you give too much life. And if they get too much power, what they end up doing is swallowing and eating alive the tolerant society. And the endgame is that the intolerant groups end up conquering the tolerant society. This is what we see happening here. Now, Hopper wrote this book decades ago in the last century, but it's still highly revalent.
28:13 Uh yeah. So, how do we how do we grapple with this? Uh three main things here. Um the truth matters more than anything. The the the truth following paper trails this is extremely important. So let's take El for uh instance. All of this well doumented um and well reported to be fair uh links that he has with the Muslim Brotherhood. We have his public statements following the Arab Spring in Egypt in 2011 where he signed on board with Morsey's vision for a new Egypt.
28:54 That is truth. That's a it's like a primary source. It's a primary document. Or let's look at the truth behind care being a front group and founded by the Muslim Brotherhood. So there are some things that just need to be treated as black and white. I'm not a fan of binaries, but there aren't multiple truths. The truth is the is the truth. It's not some cultural Marxist postmodern world where Lori, your truth and my truth or someone else's truth is the truth based on experience or ideology or perspective. The truth is the truth. The second thing is moral clarity. to enact or or or to defend our society as popper would, we have to have moral clarity. We have to look at a group like Hamas, we have to look at a group like SJP, which targets Jewish students, targets the state of Israel, targets the United States, targets the West as immoral.
29:58 That's it. Immoral. Uh, and you have to understand why they're immoral. You have to dig into the to the history. You know, people are saying, "Oh, well, Hamas is a legitimate resistance group. You know, the the Red Green Alliance likes to manipulate language. They like to turn things on their head as as Orwell warned, and they're and they're framing these type of things as as resistance. But if you know the truth behind October 7th, you'll have moral clarity on who the good guys are and who the bad guys are. Lastly, we need accountability to enact Popper's strategy to defend a tolerant society.
30:37 Accountability. We need financial accountability. This starts with universities. They need to be more transparent with where their funding is actually coming from. We need more transparency and accountability with hiring practices in academia. So this idea of diversity statements, I didn't bring this up earlier, but a lot of universities right now have these diversity statements where you have to basically pledge allegiance to the woke agenda in a certain university. This is the exact opposite of enlightenment principles and the true authentic engagement of inquiry. These things should be scrap uh scrapped. A lot of universities have scrapped them, but accountability and transparency keeps an eye on these universities and an eye on these departments to make sure they're not replicating what happened in the Frankfurt school. So I'm semi optimistic um even with the the the the downfall of the red green alliance like we have the the USIsrael alliance is still holding
31:41 strong but that also means that the red green alliance will persist uh in the future. So we're kind of it feels like we're in the trenches of this war at the Um, so a number of people, including someone who emailed a question in a little earlier today, um, are are asking about what's happening in Europe. It's it's France, it's it's the UK. Um, one one person asked if, um, the Europe is basically a dwindling market and shouldn't the the US turn towards um, the Middle East, North Africa, Southeast Asia? And uh the person that sent in a question earlier in the day was wondering really as as people are are leaving or fleeing these Western European countries, some are moving to the UAE and other Gulf nations. Um and would it be a stretch to say that the survival of some aspects of Western civilization lie in some of these Gulf countries and Israel due to its mix of normalization through the development of the and implementation of the Abraham
32:43 Accords and demographic shifts? I've been very concerned with what I'm seeing out of France and also Milan. Uh I think it it can easily spread uh through other parts of Europe, through London, through Berlin. Now, the book actually makes many references to the European context. But here's my important point with this book. The book is largely focused on the American context. But the structure of the book, the framework of the book, the chessboard analogy can be repeated in any other western country. What I outline in this book is not unique to the United States. The structure, the brainwashed students, the indoctrinating professors, the civil society organizations, the progressive or woke politicians, and the international patrons. You can find that in any western country from Australia to Canada to Germany to Greece. It's all there. So I encourage future authors to actually
33:46 use the structure that I've laid out and apply it to uh to France to to Spain. And we've seen it. I mean look at Australia, look at Canada, look at Spain. Uh it's the same operation. It's the same strategy. And this is why the book actually frames the main threat as an ideological threat and not a threat based based in a specific nation because the strategy that is being used by the Red Green Alliance is transnational. So it transcends nations. It's global and it's international. Now, I would say this with the the scenes that we're seeing in in in Paris and other major French cities, it's been well documented by journalists that this Red Green Alliance, again, certainly not a bunch of disgruntled students. Uh that's certainly not the case, though some might be. They are targeting Jewish businesses. They had a map of Jewish businesses. Generally speaking, in in some circumstance uh circumstances, they knew exactly where the Jewish businesses
34:50 were. They knew which ones to take down, which ones to loot, and which ones to essentially uh destroy. Now, if you're a Jewish person in France, or even a conservative person in France, someone who loves their country, uh who's not Islamophobic, but who also doesn't welcome Islamist groups in the MB, what do you do? I mean, this is maybe not even a soft war. Even these scenes coming out of France, they're challenging me. Is soft war too soft of a word to actually explain what is happening? The other thing I want to raise, as someone who's been to Abu Dhabi many times, is Abu Dhabi safer for Jews, for conservatives um than Paris or London? I mean, we've seen this, Lori. We've seen the UAE is banning or has banned their college uh college students from attending certain universities in the UK because they know that the bishops in those universities are going to take those young
35:55 potentially naive minds and and warp them. And the UAE knows that there are civil society organizations in London that will also come onto campus and try to get people into into their sphere. So the I think the the the fault lines and the battleground of of the west in general are are shifting where you have the geographic west if we can call it that England, France, Germany seem to be crumbling and seem to be taking o uh been taken over by this red green alliance. And then you have countries like the UAE while authoritarian in many ways at least they're allowing for people to live in peace. So it's quite interesting from a political science Yeah, I'm I'm sure. Um I somebody is actually asking whether it's the case that students are entering college um predisposed to this cultural Marxism rationalization of Muslim terror and anti-semitism. Are you seeing that?
36:56 100%. Um, and and this is kind of outside of the boundaries of the book, but I do mention when I talk about Qatar's funding to American universities in this country. By the way, for our listeners, Qatar is the number one funer of American universities uh across this country. It's in the billions uh and it has been for the last uh uh 20 years. But we also have evidence and receipts. The book is all about the receipts, right? So, it's it's hard to knock the Qatar is also investing a lot of money into K through 12 education in the United States. This is well documented.
37:39 Uh you can simply look it up. Uh I've noticed the shift among Rice students since the Black Lives Matter movement uh which was 2020. If you dig into Black Lives Matter, and this is again, it's not a conspiracy. It's all backed by the public statements that the founders of Black Lives Matter have made themselves. So, it's not me making things up. They are Marxists. They are communists. And a lot of the agenda and strategy that was pushed out of the Black Lives Matter movement was framed in this context. And we know so many teachers were I don't know if they were trying to be uh saviors or trying to be like moral grandstanders but you had these teachers who were like you know we need we need to we need to be good people uh we need to teach about uh this other side. We need to look at what Black Lives Matter say is saying in and their leaders and integrate it into curriculum without knowing that Black Lives Matter was founded as a Marxist organization uh to
38:42 begin with and a communist organization. Uh so an anti-semitic organization, I'll just 100%. And Black Lives Matter, I talk about this in the book. uh a lot of their leaders at the highest level they were invited over uh to the Middle East to Gaza to the West Bank uh on some it's basically a propaganda tour uh to put it bluntly uh to see the so-called apartheid and then they come back to the United States they're activists they're leaders and then they start creating curriculum and they create the new generation of activists and and student um so it's deeply rooted. Honestly, I you know, I don't want to give blunt advice to parents, but I think if you can, private school is probably going to be better than public school at this Um I I I'm I'm glad that that you said that. I would tend to agree with you also homeschooling perhaps.
39:38 Yeah. Seriously. No. So, so we do have a lot of questions left, but we're running out of time. I somebody's asking about the use of the word Islamophobia as maybe perhaps being used as a product or developed as a product of this alliance and I know that words you know you you do make a lot of references to Orwell in the book and words are important. So can you maybe touch on Islamophobia as a concept of and use in this alliance? Yes. Uh this is extremely important and I've had my own evolution on this issue. So the term Islamophobia is rooted in this grander narrative strategy that the Red Green Alliance is using. So it's all about lexicon and it's all about censoring criticism and ideas that challenge the racial religious hierarchy that we're seeing. So because cultural Marxism has framed the West and the US as white, as Christian, as superior, if you're any of the if you're not any of those things, you're ranked lower down the totem pole. So with Muslims, if
40:42 you're if they're framed at the bottom of the totem pole, they they have to be protected. You cannot criticize them. And if you criticize their religion, you're criticizing them. two totally separate things. So I can what I should be able to do is criticize a Muslim person based on their character, their conduct, their value system. If they're a good person, I can say, "Well, you're a good person." But I should also be able to criticize your faith, criticize your founding, criticize your Quran. I expect the same thing from my faith.
41:14 This is what open inquiry is all about. But now I'm I'm being accused as being Islamophobic because I'm pushing back against Hamas and this is a form of selfcensorship. This is what Orwell is actually talking about. So any type of is is deemed to be part of a larger racist agenda and racist structure that we have in the United States, which is wrong. Flat out wrong. It's getting back to the truth and the moral clarity that I talked about and Lori the book and you know this I differentiate between Islamist and Islam. There's a huge distinction there. So I should be able to criticize someone who is using Islam as a political agenda just as I would be able to use a Christian using Christianity as a political agenda. But the rules are different. There's two standards. It's a double standard and care weaponizes this term Islamophobia
42:16 to shut down any type of criticism or push back against what people are doing. Last point, even AOC AOC was interviewed yesterday, I believe, about Alied and the journalist was saying, "Well, you know, this guy's got a lot of Muslim Brotherhood baggage. The receipts are there. It shows it. His mother, his sister, him, the links are there." But AOC said that this is part of a racist agenda that is part of Islamophobia, which is just intellectually lazy and it's anti-enlightenment, which I talk about in the book.
42:53 Yeah, I think we're hearing the same arguments over Ilan Omar's the investigation into her and it's just it's a term that's being thrown out probably as often as calling Jews Nazis pretty much. Unfortunately, we're we've run out of time. There's still a number of questions in the queue. So Craig, with your next book, we're definitely going to have to have you back. Um, please everybody follow Craig's work and uh he's I think his the book is very important to read. Please everybody do read it. It's in the background there, but I'm going to share it here as well. And uh again Craig, thank you very much. Thank you Lori. It was a pleasure.