MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Webinar or Talk

Islam and Academic Myths with Raymond Ibrahim

Watch Islam and Academic Myths with Raymond Ibrahim on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

Western academics routinely present Islam as an enlightened force for progress unfortunately stymied by Western bigotry and aggression. Where did this image come from and how did it become ensconced in universities? What truths and falsehoods does it contain? What implications does it have?

Transcript Automatic captions

Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 4, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.

0:00 um welcome everyone to the middle east forum's weekly webinar one of our weekly webinars my name is winfield myers i'm the director of campus watch and i'll be our host today our guest this afternoon is raymond ibrahim ray is the judith friedman rosen rosenfeld with the middle east forum and a shulman fellow at the david horowitz freedom center uh ray earned his ba and m.a in history at cal state fresno and studied toward a phd in medieval islamic history at the catholic university of he was born in the u.s to coptic immigrants from egypt uh which is why he knows a great deal about the middle east as you'll see and rey is the author of several books his most recent is sword and scimitar 14 centuries of war between islam and the west ray welcome great to have you here great to see you again great to be with you winfield thanks thank you good good to have you um our topic today is islam and the an academic myths that proliferate in university life about islam and um the middle east uh in general um

1:06 this could go in a lot of directions but but ready to start uh where do these come from what are the myths that we're going to discuss about islam in academia originate and then we'll get into some of the more important of those myths in your views yeah sure when what you said very complex and long and deep topic but to get to the heart of it and i think really before i can answer your question i have to lay a little groundwork which is the actual history especially of islam vis-a-vis the west which is um if you look at it again you look at the primary sources of chronicles european arab turkish it's one of hostility continuously sure there's you know little breaks and and whatnot not because there's a change in the mentality of you know being open-minded towards each other or any of that sort of thing but just because of the exigencies of reality in real politics and so forth um but it's continuous warfare from the seventh century on islam again most people don't realize uh most of the land that it's on was annexed conquered and absorbed from mostly christian nations so

2:09 all of north africa and the middle east from morocco on the west to iraq even syria of course egypt all that whole area later the turks enter into anatolia which is primarily greek also very christian it's the area where most of saint paul's letters for example go to those churches um and all the way into the balkans all that was violent spain as well the eighth century was conquered and so um you know and historians have done this they've actually gotten the numbers and you know graphed it basically three quarters of what was originally christian territory was conquered and absorbed by islam most of it permanently russia as well you know you hear of the mongol or tatar yoke and it comes it's usually depicted in a secular manner but that as well really fit into this whole islam christianity hostility paradigm especially later when the mongols convert in the 1300s and so forth the golden horde so really it's one of non-stop violence for well over a million from the seventh century from the death of muhammad the war begins two years later uh against the byzantine or eastern roman empire

3:11 and it goes on in various iterations you have the moors or the berbers in spain and then you have the arabs and then you get the the turks and you get you know very the celtics and the ottomans and it's very long and violent and now we come to our perception which is really the opposite um and that's what you're asking so how did we go from that being reality and to now we're really presented with something completely topsy-turvy and it goes back to the you know academics uh that's really where it today in our culture i think we're familiar with the concept of fake news whatever political spectrum you may be on i think it's obvious that there's a lot of exaggeration because the reality is um knowledge is power as that old axiom goes and whoever controls it has the power so it's clear that a lot of people in the media and so forth are manipulating and twisting stories around for their own agendas but that sort of thing goes way before especially in this field including amongst academics and uh it's in it the reason it works and this is a an interesting aspect that very few

4:15 people really mentioned is as you know when you with your undergraduate course in history and you're writing a master's thesis or dissertation phd and whatever the whole point is you always have to come up with something new it's you can't just rehash and summarize something that happened you have to give a new insight a new interpretation and so if the history of islam and the west or really islam and everyone and the rest is one of violence and you're a immediately that sets up the um situation for your dissertation to be the exact opposite because it won't do to just reiterate um so you mentioned for example my book sword and scimitar well that's just a summation and a reiteration of accurate history but if you're writing a dissertation or so forth you need to come up with a new clever thing so that going hand in hand with the political culture since the 60s and so forth of you know multiculturalism you know the boogeyman of racism and imperialism and of course orientalism and i think that's where we need to get to with edward saeed and so forth fused together 1978 book oriented right

5:18 yes right so that book and that mentality and you know that book if you've read it briefly what it what it amounted to just very briefly so the book orientalism by edward saeed a palestinian academic who's a literary critic uh and he's not even a historian and so forth the whole point of the book was just to say that the what i told you right which is documented is a perception it's a false perception that was foisted by orientalists which are european academics who studied the orients the east islam and so forth in the 1800s and even before that 1700s and well into the 1900s people like bernard lewis were of course accused of being an orientalist and they are orientalists but in the good sense uh it's just it's just studying the east but of course that word now has a negative connotation which means you're not objective you're not really looking at the people and understanding all you do is you just you sit back and you from and you because you're the west uh have a superior outlook and you look at the east as barbaric and backwards

6:20 and primitive especially islam you're projecting your own views onto other the other right right and it has a psychoanalytical aspect which i think also kind of really lessens its uh credibility in my opinion so that thing that idea that paradigm which was really i guess ushered in by edward said and again i i would underscore it it only became important because the culture was receptive to that sort of thing at that time so the two went together so like i was saying we're living in a day and age where you know so western history is sort of has to be looked at as bad it's imperialistic it's racist it's xenophobic and you know everything and islam is the opposite for life for reasons i said including if you want to be a clever academic you have to come up with something new so what's better than to show how actually no islam was peaceful progressive in western europe and so forth were the negative ones and or the violent ones let me ask you what happened to the the old um the older schools of orientalists as you say who wore that badge

7:23 unashamedly no one no one told them there's anything wrong with doing it uh even the generation before lewis these guys who studied philology they studied languages they became expert in arabic hebrew aramaic all the various ancient languages of the middle east the whole orientalist impetus really shoved them aside didn't it i mean it gave a it gave a reason as you say new things uh are awarded in academy new ideas you're always looking for what's going to be the newest approach to any particular historical problem but what we've seen it seems to me over the last um say 20 30 years is almost a wholesale jettisoning of the um previous i hate to overuse the word overuse paradigm but the previous paradigm previously historiography of the middle east in which it's become now very combative uh always on the offensive there's a political edge to it now that was surely say when i was born

8:27 into the 60s and it really really changed that what what happened with that and and what do you see as the pr the primary problems what are the historiographical problems the problems are that the myths that we're discussing today that are emerging from academia what are the principal myths since we only sort of hit the high spots today um that you see coming out well one of the the aspects that you know i think it's again very subtle and i think this is what's going on is um you know we live in a culture where history isn't considered that important okay it's not i think it's very important i think you do too and i'm sure much of the audience agrees um and it is important i think a lot of islamists and and so forth to know that and i'll give you an example what's going on is um when 9 11 happens let's say okay and this is really when islam and radical islam you know makes a big splash in the in our era a lot of people the big question was what went wrong you know i think bernard lewis kind of you know rhetorically asked it and it that question presupposed the history and and that's the thing see and it because what went wrong means

9:30 something was right beforehand right and um so it presupposed that islam for you know the beginning of its all its history especially if you see the west was an okay for sure they had their conflicts but that's because of the crusaders and that's because of you know imperialistic western colonialist actions and so forth um now if if you if you change that first premise of history if you go with what i'm saying for example that actually no it was a it was a continuous um you know a continuum of warfare and violence mostly initiated by islam which was spreading into and absorbing and conquering the west and other lands uh that question what went wrong becomes a moot point superfluous because nothing went wrong this is we're actually seeing a continuum right um so i think there's this um an impetus to really guard the narrative the historical and i'll just give you a very obvious personal my own personal experience i've been invited and spoken in various places the greatest pushback i ever got was when i was talking about history and that was at the us army war college and they just invited me to talk about my book uh sword instruments or

10:31 what you mentioned which is history what i'm saying and that's the most time that care just went ballistic and attacked me and you would think big deal i'm just battles decisive battles and warfare and i think the point is they don't want because once you realize that islam was doing what it's been doing for over a millennium and in fact what we're seeing today is an identical duplication of that then you understand nothing went wrong there's nothing to fix there's nothing there's no you know so but as long as you believe that that history that the history is what the apologists and the edward said types want you to believe okay then you have to always look for something other than radical islam to explain what's going on and so it becomes colonialism it becomes israel and zionism it becomes you know western machinations whatever um anything and everything but islam because islam was fine historically so obviously it's something else and i think that's a very subtle um reason that a lot of the apologists work very hard to guard the historical term islamophobia

11:35 which is thrown around a great deal now there are centers devoted to what i would call the the propaganda of islamophobia at georgetown and in berkeley both out your way both dedicated to i would argue not so much furthering the debate about islam in any way or the near east but instead to shutting down critics of islamism of of the more radical strains or or critics of uh writing what we used to call straight history uh sort of political history intellectual history diplomatic history how do you explain this burst onto the scene over the last couple of decades or so of the term islam islamophobia which is now used everywhere in academia it's tied into intersectionality and it becomes part of the entire uh sort of leftist uh push to silence critics yeah and i think that's the main point you have to see it as part of a whole

12:37 which is this idea of you know getting these name calling essentially and shutting up any kind of uh discussion and you see this especially today with the word racism which is just bandied about very loosely and you know which is unfortunate there is real racism in the world sure but when you use it for everything then it loses its opponents you know and so it's the same thing with islamophobia you know you instead of having a healthy debate um you just shut it down and you some islamophobic means it's the same thing as you know it's it's there's that whole group of words you know a racist and patriarchy and magically toxicity and you know um you know misogynist and you put islamophobic in there too so all of these i think are just ways when the opposition can't actually debate you and have an actual rational discussion and show how you're wrong because in the end objective truth wins out you just shut them down you silence them that's the whole idea which is amazing to see and it's sad to see academics championing this sort of thing because they're supposed to be the ones who believe in free thought and inquiry and sure something about the report rigorous debate right in search of the

13:39 truth yeah that's what it should be right and that's that's really the sad thing to see the academic world by and large not all of course it's you know it's it's spirit has more or less become you know all about censorship and shutting down and you know just following the official paradigms or you know the official presentation and it used to actually be more of a i don't use the word rebel but it was you know it goes against the the the grain you know against the stream um right and it because it's trying to think clearly and get objective truth and that's not where we're at and again i would i would emphasize it's not a it's not um an isolated case you're seeing it in so many different ways and by and large in the american culture today sure sure let me ask you another thing before we go to our audience some questions we're getting a few in and if you have questions please please stop them and we'll be eager to uh to answer why the obsession with the with israel palestine with bds that we're seeing now you know the middle east studies uh is voting as we speak and members have until march 22 to vote on the uh whether or not they will adopt bds

14:44 boycott sanctions divestment and sanction of israel as part of their platform to make it their official when i think of middle east studies if you have to put one topic at the top of the heap that receives more attention than anything else there's got to be israel it's got to be attacked in the whole why where did that come from why why well it comes it comes from the fact that it's muslims and arabs who are guiding this and obviously muslims and arabs hate and have animosity for israel because they see it as a great foe that supposedly took their land and the palestinians and so forth but it's unfortunate that you know non-muslims non-arabs regular academics and so forth follow follow this because if you want to be objective there's so many other you know things that you can talk about that are much much worse but one example that i focus on is the you know uh pandemic of christian persecution by muslim nations and um this is actually very appropriate to the topic of israel that you bring up because i just read a book uh written by um his name is mitri

15:49 and he's a palestinian and the book is called the politics of persecution and it purports to talk about persecution in the middle east of christians and really the book is focused on israel and it tries to demonize and present israel as the worst persecutor of christians and um that when persecution but when persecution happens from muslims which is way much larger in scope and much more dramatic in fact the the examples of israel are always the same two or three which have to do with some radical youth spitting at like a monk or something that's all they ever the persecution that christians experience in the islamic world is dramatically and exponentially worse that gets no mention so i mentioned that book as one example but others can look at that i mean most people don't even know that i just read a report something like 380 million christians around the world are being persecuted heavily 80 of it is in the islamic world you would think from people who you know present themselves as having a humanitarian inclination and that's why they're talking about palestinians that they might talk about that but they don't okay and and and the thing with

16:52 the palestinians that's a territorial secular dispute and yet they try to turn it into something more something of an existential nature which is actually what's happening to christians and other non-muslim minorities including shias and so forth amongst the sunni sure well let's take a few questions from the audience then uh ray um rochelle i can't quite read make out the last name says are muslims taught about the relationship between the quran and the bible and how much of it seems uh similar but reworded is there knowledge within yeah the schools of islam for an average person i'll talk about i mean scholars who wouldn't be more familiar with it of that question yeah well i mean the main thing i'd like to say about the quran and islam and um you know the bible and because we heard a lot of you know this ecumenical talk and pope francis and you know and kissing each other and uh the idea that's always presented to us is that because the quran and islam actually names and even venerates many

17:55 biblical figures abraham moses jesus everyone that that's a good thing the reality is it's actually a bad thing because what happens is it's an okay so for example uh the new testament or christians uh christians referred to they look to the hebrew scriptures the old testament as it's called but they don't change it it's the verbatim scriptures that the jews also rely on so nothing's changed in that sense okay now maybe interpretations change but the actual text has not changed so abraham is who abraham was and what he said is what he said in moses and so forth what muslims do though and what islam does is it takes the names and it uses the you know their the antiquity and the prestige of those names and the authority but then it completely recasts it in a way that justifies and gives credibility to islam and denigrates christianity and judaism so for example abraham in the in the islamic tradition ibrahim my name's sake um so in the bible he just he leaves you

18:58 know the land of ur and that's it and he goes he goes west um in islam he tells his people and this is in the quran quran 64 ibrahim says we hate you and we will forever hate you until you become muslims essentially now until this day muslims use that verse of abraham ibrahim to basically say we are obligated to hate muslim uh to hate jews and christians okay so it's an appropriation and uh same thing with jesus uh isa okay he's taken and what jesus is gonna do when he comes back he's gonna destroy all the crosses because he was never crucified and he's angry at christians for saying that he was and he was resurrected he's going to kill all the pigs and he's going to become a good muslim and or he is a good muslim so my point is that sort of thing far from creating commonality actually i think creates obstacles it's like if someone were to tell you you know you have a grandfather that you love and venerate and then someone comes and says hey that's my grandfather too and guess what everything you know about him is wrong you have to listen to what i have to say about him so i don't think that really helps sure sure um

20:02 len levin or levin asks why don't western christians stand up for their co-religionists in the arab that's a good question um i would say a lot of it you know a lot of it is sectarian in the sense that you know the christian world is split up into all these different sects and the western world is more mostly protestant um the christians of the middle east are mostly orthodox um so to a lot of protestants they don't even acknowledge that they're christians to start with um you know uh that's so that's just one reason i don't think that's a major reason i think another one has to do with ignorance because the media like i said you know the persecution of christians around the world is a real thing something like 6 000 were killed last year for their faith butchered but the media doesn't cover it and i remember that when 21 coptic christians or 20 cops and one gonaian uh were beheaded by isis in libya in 2014 or 15 for their faith and it was carved off uh someone did some number crunching and it turned out that the media covered at the same time a gorilla in some american zoo

21:06 was killed yeah right yeah so and that's why you remember it because that was covered six times more and i remember the cut the juxtaposition yeah yeah right so um i think a lot of it has to do with ignorance because the media obviously is not doing its job because this because anything that shows an islam in a negative light just throws a wrench into the history is just so poorly taught including american history people don't know they don't know history much an anonymous attendee asks are most of these western academics simply anti-christian and anti-jewish because they 100 believe the muslim side of any disputes and arguments obviously or they you know why do why why would a westerner whether jewish or christian um be so susceptible to this uh yeah i do know because they're anti-christian or anti-semitic because it's more innocent than that for them i think so but i do think there's a uh there's a sort of synergism between it's it's strange because you find an alliance it's been called what you know the red green alliance and so forth between the left and uh you know

22:08 especially and the more hardcore the left goes the more it's embedded with islamist types which is ironic because the left is really antithetical to islam in many social mores and so forth you know think about you know sexual freedom in the minds of the left compared to the much more traditional form so but that you often find them and i do believe when you see that it is because the left have an animosity for jews and christians basically the west's background you know judeo-christian tradition um a hatred for it i think and um so it's almost like the enemy of my enemies my friend okay so the islamists are are exotic and foreign and i'm not worried about them but i in in allying with them i can actually you know have some sort of um support against what i really don't like in my society which is this sort of judeo-christian uh ethical someone asks uh or the middle anonymous attendee again are the middle eastern christians afraid to show positive support for israel which is this person's perception

23:11 yeah well it's a matter of um israel in the islamic world and especially in the middle east as you know is is you know the arch enemy it's the great foe and if you're a christian you're already a second class minority who's you know oscar sized and disenfranchised so the best thing you want to do is try to assimilate uh with the host nation with muslim with the muslims in general and this is why for a lot of arab christians in the 20th century early and late night in the late 19th century were very pro-arab nationalism uh because that was one way for them to be part of the group you know instead of being christians so i do believe and i actually i know this for a fact speaking to a lot of christians who live there that they have to maintain this sort of you know we have to be on the same page with our muslim neighbors when it comes to israel we can't be like oh and you see this because many of them when they come here it changes and that whole thing drops um you know and there's actually been some progress because i know in egypt for a long time with the coptic pope shenuda um he actually had a ban to visiting israel

24:13 but that's been dropped so the new the new pope um and has shown much more leniency towards that which is actually an impressive step in the context of what's going on but i think it also has to do with egypt's uh politics overall with cc and so forth so yeah it's just that's that's real that's real politics sort of thing where uh and most of the christians in the middle don't even know anything about what's going on but hey it's the enemy and uh that's what everyone says so who are we to come on their side when we're already you know on a thin line sure sure uh hal asks or says there was a long pause between islam's conquering christian lands and the current islamic violence how can you see this as one continuous process no there's been there's been aberrations and so of course the colonial era you can say is an aberration and that went on from really starting in 1800s i mean look from the very first attack in the west is in the seventh seventh century and one of the biggest battle for example that really opened the floodgates is the battle of the armor in year 636 okay now go more than 1000 years here in 1683 and

25:16 now you have the largest islamic attack on europe which is the siege of vienna okay that's now now we're in 1683. but then you have a you know then the ottoman empire starts waning and then you have the barbary pirates in america's first war in 1800 and again in 1815 is with muslims first war is a nation after its independence with muslims who are saying the same thing and you know thomas jefferson writes that famous letter where he quotes the ambassador barbary saying we are attacking your sailors because you're infidels in our book or quran says to do so and so forth um so but from 1800 to now of course the islamic world wanes and you know the symbolic date really i think 1799 with napoleon entering egypt and so you definitely get a whole what and that's actually often called for example the golden age for the christian minorities of the middle age the colonial era because that actually helped create an even playing field and religion was pushed aside and that's what nationalism like i was saying but now we're seeing a return very much and so isis in in fact most people don't know this the very words it uses in the formulations are are words that were used from over a thousand years ago the

26:19 battle of the armor that i just mentioned in 636 when isis which they've done comes up and says we've tasted american blood and find none better that's a verbatim quote from khalid bin al-walid the sword of islam at that battle talking to the romans or the the eastern romans the byzantines um so yes to me it's definitely a continuum but of course there's aberrations and hiccups even if they took one or two centuries robert larrick asks do conservative muslims hate liberal muslims and more who want that is the more secular muslims who uh advocate for human or women's rights and the like right well i mean within islam not just sunni shia but between secular more secularized more westernized if you will and uh and more traditional yeah sure but you know i would i would shy away from using those words conservative liberals because i don't i don't i don't think they apply do we see this within the academy does this ever show up in in university life as well oh you mean conservative and liberal yeah i'm throwing that in to uh

27:24 yeah it's it's it's it's the same you know all these different iterations whether it's the islam or in the academic world you see the same thing but in the islamic world um to me just it's it's plain and simple and and when you use these terms and the dichotomy of liberal conservatives it just doesn't really work in my mind with the islam uh you know the balloon because islam is very black and white you know you have laws rules which is in sharia which really don't have in let's say christianity especially not in western modern day christianity you know hard set black and white you have to do this right so it's it's to me it's not a question of to be liberated so for example in islam um you can have you you can beat your wife it's in the crown you can have four uh am i a liberal to say no i don't want to do that or am i actually contradicting what islam teaches and that's that's more the debate that goes on and so the so-called conservatives will say what i just said which is whatever you're talking about that means that's just western stuff but our book our holy quran so forth and our sharia says x y and z and that so it really

28:26 comes down to that exactly let the professors that we critique at campus watch that you've written about and read um generally in my impression are not practicing muslims some of them are obviously but a lot of them are quite yet they are virulently anti-israel many of them are anti-semitic what explains that i don't mean just those who are even most even even those of uh whatever the background english background or you know if they're jewish or whatever they happen to be um what explains that in academia that they're so inimical to the west um to uh the traditional study of western history as you outlined it earlier or to the study of islam to get back to our original point um as let's say it should be studied and as some like you and others still still in fact write about it i'll just say because i know how time's very limited it's uh at root it's in

29:29 interact it's irrational okay there's so it can't be explained in a rational logical sense i think it's ultimately an irrational hatred and an irrational animosity i think a lot of it it really has to do with a sort of rejection of those people rejecting their heritage their roots you know which which includes israel in that sense because it's part of the you know the biblical tradition and so forth um i think that's at root but ultimately to me it's very irrational because it and again you know when you see these hardcore leftists who are so pro whatever homosexual rights and you know the people who believe in this you know there's no gender you find them going hand in hand with radical muslims who are the same people who would behead them in an art be um and so it's at root very irrational and the the linchpin that holds all these diverse groups together is i think hatred for the what we would call the western tradition sure well unfortunately we're out of time because this is this is a discussion that we could carry on for a long time and it would be fascinating to do that but um our guest has been raven ibrahim um right thank you so much for for

30:34 speaking with us today we really appreciate it's great to talk to you and um for the rest of our audience please remember that to watch for an mef email that will appear over the weekend with additional webinars so thanks thanks again to ray thank you to our audience and good afternoon everyone