MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Israel Insider

Israel Insider with Ashley Perry

Watch Israel Insider with Ashley Perry on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

With the lists of the political parties now finalized and submitted, polls show Netanyahu having a harder time forming a coalition than his opponents. Could this election be Bibi's downfall?

Transcript Automatic captions

Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 10, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.

0:00 hello and welcome to the middle east forum's webinar series israel insider with ashley perry i'm stacy roman and i will be moderating this discussion today we're pleased to have mr ashley perry advisor to the middle east forum's israel office join us here each wednesday at 3 pm eastern to update us on all the events going on in israel mr prairie will be giving us a briefing on current israeli affairs for 15 minutes and open it up for questions should you wish to ask a question please use the q a box located at the bottom of your screen to type out your question now with no further ado i'll turn the discussion over to mr ashley perry thank you very much stacy and good as usual lots to talk about tonight is the last night or rather we're now into the last 24 hours uh before lists uh must be submitted to the knesset for the upcoming elections uh for those of you not so familiar with the israeli system israel has a proportional representation system where uh each party uh submits a list of candidates and depending on the

1:02 proportion of their votes receives that many seats for the knesset so if you receive 10 uh of the vote you receive 10 of the uh seats in the knesset which will represent 12 because there's 120 seats um what's most at this point is to see what parties are going to drop out what parties are going to merge and there's usually a level of interest this final day and this has certainly been no different um the most important thing to look out for at this point is the the threshold the electoral israel has an electoral threshold of i think it's 3.25 or something like that anyway uh a party uh the minimum party a minimum amount of seats that a party will receive is for if it gets under that it won't the threshold and those seats those votes rather will be uh what's termed in israel lost in other words they'll be thrown away um so this the the amount of

2:06 uh seats that are thrown away are the amount of votes that are thrown away is in the tens of thousands sometimes even in the hundreds of thousands and that can be crucial to uh exactly how the balance of the next knesset is going to be we've talked in the past how every seat matters uh really especially when we're talking about fine margins uh about whether a a potential prime minister can put together a a government of 61 which is the minimum they would need um and you know we really are looking at the polls we're looking at phone margins so anybody any uh party which is near the threshold there's a big question do they go through that and try and get above the threshold or do they drop out hoping or calling on someone else to take their for example there's a party for the pensioners party which wasn't a major uh party and probably wasn't polling even close to one percent but again there's probably thousands of votes and those thousands of votes can make the difference uh yeah mina for

3:09 example a few elections ago where i believe if i remember less than a thousand votes from uh a uh representation of knesset in the end they fell below it so those hundred and twenty thousand votes were then thrown away uh so the leader of the pensioners party basically dropped out and said i support uh yeah lapids uh yeshetid parties so now in theory his their supporters will now move to and could buttress another uh seat for them because obviously yeshetid are in no danger of falling below the threshold the most important tonight and we've only got 24 hours left but most of the party lists have come through most of the mergers or splits are now known uh and there's we can report that there's two major wins for netanyahu uh obviously netanyahu sees himself as the leader of the what's called the right wing block so for him anything which ensures that the right wing block maintains as many knesset seats is good and anything which loses

4:11 the left wing block seats possible seats uh is bad why because what happens when all those seats are all those votes are thrown away uh basically those seats don't appear on the knesset roster and then they get put up back into the mix so if one side for example loses 200 000 votes on lost lost votes then basically that obviously tilt things towards the other block what we can hear in the last couple of hours is netanyahu is once again uh midwifed uh the extreme right uh you know we know that uh smartrich left yamina left natalie bennett in the to form what uh what he called the the zionist religious party uh there was a big debate exactly who that would include uh habitude the jewish home of rafi peretz which basically uh almost uh went into dissolution was won by uh someone that uh was very much in netanyahu's camp

5:15 and she has been negotiating with betsal smatrick to join together uh they were very close to their threshold some polls had them over at four seats and some had them under what they managed to do and netanyahu again is seen as as he was in the past as seen very much as the person who made this deal they brought in itamar being career of ottoman ud the jewish strength party which is a far-right extreme far-right party which actually merged with another far-right party called noam and together they've now joined with betsalos matrice and fragid moshe now the theory is that they are expected to get let's take much closer to the four seats if those four seats occur then that's a big win for netanyahu and definitely this merger makes that more likely running together probably none of them would get in and there would be tens of thousands of uh seats wasted uh on the uh on on the right wing so that's definitely a win for netanyahu and netanyahu's even promised uh certain things like uh putting uh one

6:20 of the members of that party on a spot in his party listen that he could party unless he's done that again is that fair is that moral that's a whole question but it's legal and also promised all sorts of ministries if they do make it into the canoe set so that's something very much in netanyahu's interest on the other side something that he's been apparently working on for a while is the breakup of the joint list the joint list as we know uh our four arab parties which run because again uh separately they're all around the four mark three mark five mark some will get in some won't get in so a couple of elections ago actually a few elections ago now when they decided to raise their electoral threshold they decided to join together and it's always been an unhappy and uneasy alliance uh you know we have a nationalist palestinian nationalist party we have an islamist party we have a communist party so you can imagine that there's a lot of differences there and as we know netanyahu has very much been caught in mansur of us the leader of the islamist party

7:22 um in recent months and even courting arab vote what we now know is the islamist party will now run separately and that's going to be a big blow first of all it's unlikely iran will pass the electoral threshold so again on the left side this is the extreme it's a debate where you can count it on the left side because the arab list will not sit with any member of the government or with any type of government but it's definitely a big blow for the for the arab this which and now is now polling around and at the moment they can't strengthen the current kindness at 15 which was a remarkable achievement for that but a lot in that community have grown uh tired of the joint list they don't feel they represent them some say that they worry too much about the palestinian issue not about local and we saw tonight netanyahu has very much tried to create that wedge in the come out with a plan to spend 100 million shekels uh on basically building five police stations because um

8:26 for the our community crime violence is a massive issue since the beginning of last year almost 100 people have been killed in gang and criminal warfare and there was a shootout the other night excuse me there was a shootout the other night between police and gangs and a young arab medical student was killed and that really has created a massive movement in the arab society and there was even talk that that could bring ram back into the joint list but in the end it seems like it won't they haven't officially given their list but uh all indications are they will not uh join so that could really hamper the our community's representation kind of said and there is talk of liquid even gaining and netanyahu seems quite confident that he'll be able to get a couple of seats uh from the uh our community far more than he's ever expected before because of this outreach because of this work that he's been doing over the last couple of years

9:30 last couple of months i should say the wild card at this point really is what's going to happen with the left-wing parties uh labor have seen a bit of a renaissance resurgence under mikhaili they weren't expected to pass the threshold uh up until the time when she um the chairmanship and now they're very nicely over the threshold maybe uh five even i saw one polled seven or so um she is in a good place and she surpassed some of the other left-wing pretenders like uh officiella who left yesterday as we know he's polling well well down and not even i think the last poll that i saw not even one percent and one whole day who was supposed to lead this new party the israelis the and they were supposed to be the big uh shock the big party especially on the left uh to take

10:33 these elections and they never really hit with a bang at the beginning from from the beginning usually when you when you launch you get a bit of a boost i think the first poll showed them getting eight and then slowly it just went down now most polls don't show them going over the threshold uh and jorge has become more more desperate basically telling uh mikhaili or other left-wing parties there aren't that many others to choose please come and get me please come and rescue me uh mikhaili is now in a strong a couple of weeks ago probably labor would have jumped at the chance of joining hilda together but now mikhail has a strong so it's very possible that one chordae who was supposed to be the big wild horse of these elections or the big dark horse i should say uh is not going to even run um mikhail has put a deal on the table but it's uh it's not one that's uh particularly interesting from jorday it would put him uh as a backbencher at the best uh lowdown figure

11:34 and at the at the moment as we know one holiday is me of tel aviv so that could uh in the end beca stay as a far more uh enticing offer than just to be a backbench uh mk but it remains to be seen exactly what he will do and what his supporters would do could they return to labour bolster them uh mikhail's polls are looking good for her she believes that even more people will return to labor uh under her stewardship the other party that's very close to the is blue and white benny gans uh as we know he's really uh just lost so many of his uh mks he put out his list he only put out 10 people on his list which really shows this is a person who is the deputy you know the uh the alternate prime minister the defense and uh uh the leader of a party that not too long ago had uh had seats in the thirties uh so it's a great fall from grace a lot

12:38 of people are questioning why he should even be in the race and according to tonight he took to the airwaves he he went on the tv channels to basically say he's going to be around israeli politics for 10 years that remains to be seen that's in the hands of the voters but that's another party that's very close to the threshold but the numbers uh the recent polls that we've had are very interesting because on the right side or let's say the right-wing religious at the moment we have netanyahu's holding pretty consistently around 30. uh we see the two uh ultra-orthodox parties around eight so together that's uh 46. now where's the other 15 the other party who said that they would sit with netanyahu haven't brought it out is you mean naftali benedictiomina is around 10 to so he's still short so he basically the only way at this point and as he brings a surprise from across the aisle the only way netanyahu's path to a 61 is if he if patel smachrich

13:42 passes the electoral threshold with ben and hokkien moshe and entices uh bennett again that may not be enough but that's his real best chance to have a right-wing religious government on the other side we see um the the parties that the four parties seem to have some sort of unwritten alliance whether yesha did yamina uh of bennett again he could go either way uh kid onsar and evita leave and together they make about 50 according to the polls uh that could be bolstered with labour who again could poll around six or seven and blue and white which are polling possibly around four or even merits the the far-left party so it seems the anti-netanyahu bloc does a slight majority at this point uh never will like netanyahu he's as we said a wily fox he knows how to he's been around far longer than any of these people he knows how to win elections he knows how to make deals remarkable uh though it is

14:46 today he really succeeded on both wings at the same time as uh midwifing uh a kahanas party and extreme right anti-era party uh he's also making sure and our party basically doesn't go with the rest of its uh natural allies uh perhaps because he's promised them something so netanyahu is quite happy to work on both margins whatever uh suits him electorally and that's really where most of the sort of uh uh you know the talk has been today as i said there's another day uh to to uh add in the list the other the other talking point is netanyahu has four um reserve spots for him only two of them are realistic uh he's promised one of them will be an arab uh but so far the nazareth mayor and some others have turned it down will it be ali levy of the gesher party someone who was in yeshopateno and they moved all the way to the merits labour party now could she find herself in they could uh that's a possibility that's been

15:49 talked about but there's a lot of objection in the liquid because of her sitting five minutes ago with marines which is the extreme left-wing party um but uh netanyahu will be polling he'll be his people who are the best options for me what will serve my interests the most and it will be very interesting to see who uh who in the end gets these reserve spots so there's still a lot to come over the next 24 hours um but it's uh very interesting and i'm sure even after this conversation uh finishes there'll be more surprises but with that i'm happy to answer any questions thank you so much the first question is in israel's election process is there actually a day on which individuals votes are cast and if so are there pandemic precautions being taken such as voting by mail um at the moment uh well basically in in the israeli elections no one can vote outside of the borders of the state of israel except for diplomats and for example jewish agency officials

16:52 uh at the moment israel has no other alternative voting no postal ballots apart from those it the army uh people who are doing uh service whether it's uh you know their yearly cert their annual service or actually in service they vote separately um they don't go back to their towns and cities uh but everyone else has to vote within uh what is it something like a 12 14 14-hour window on a particular day there has been talk of what would happen if people in hospital hospitals usually ballots set up for them and there were some local municipal elections recently and even primaries and they did have some precautions taken some of them did it electronically and some in the municipal elections there were some ways you could do it by driving you don't actually get out of your car um but that remains to be seen we're supposed to get out of our lockdown next week

17:54 remains to be seen exactly there was supposed to be a government decision to extend it today the government did not meet because there was so much else going on but at the moment it's supposed to end on friday but i'm sure it'll be extended much longer uh so some of the english language israeli press is touting the arab especially significance this can i know you did discuss this already but can you comment on this either well it's very interesting because first of all if you look at the numbers you know arab uh arab society is over 20 of uh the total population but they've never seen those numbers i mean as i said in the last elections they got 15 votes which is the highest they've ever got but if you did you know you extrapolated these relative size they should be 20 25.

18:48 uh that's because a lot of arabs just refuse to vote on ideological grounds um sometimes they they feel they may not have anyone to vote for there's a lot of talk about whether some could vote for so-called quote-unquote zionist parties mainstream israeli parties evenly good um and there's been a lot of uh sort of news shows going into the arab especially in the north and asking people if they'll votefully could and they said why not you know they're doing more for us now than our arab lists have ever done before and what we see definitely is a certain level of uh let's say more confusion at least this is the way the media is portraying it obviously i have no uh a great knowledge not having trouble to any of these places recently um but it does seem that there is a possibility that uh some of the the the our votes will go for the more mainstream zionist parties this time um again according to polls the our joint list is down to 10 which is cutting its size uh by a third

19:52 which is quite big and they're certainly worried about it and they're fighting back uh the hourglass and they're trying to convince voters that they're the only ones who uh who have their interests at heart and they could are just playing you and that daniel's just playing games with you and trying to divide us this is the guy who's made a lot of attacks on the arab community this is what they're saying to their people how can you believe him now uh even avitor me came out with a quip when rahm when it was decided wrong will not uh run with the joint list he said well the strategic campaign manager of uh of the our community it seems uh netanyahu uh because he as i said he seemed to be very much behind this uh but it remains to be seen they could claimed to have done polling and uh say that they've got a few seats from the our community obviously we don't know that uh for sure but that's what they're claiming but uh only after the elections take place we'll know the truth thank you and can you please explain further the votes thrown away it sounds like some votes are being wasted

20:56 is this kind of like voting for a third party in the united states for the electoral college um no actually if in the american system or the british system the canadian system far more votes get thrown away in very few votes get thrown away because if you're in a constituency in these states in canada in britain you vote for the losing party your vote is then meaningless uh if you if you are in a blue state and you vote republican or vice versa your votes are basically wasted they're throwing away they have no meaning in israel the overwhelming majority of votes count because if you vote for one of the parties which is over the threshold which is the overwhelming your vote will count we don't have a first pass the post system in israel we have abortion representation which means that almost every vote counts but there's a small minority of votes uh who will vote for parties by the way there's another 10 15 parties that will never pass the threshold but these are small like the pirate party there's some sort of joke parties or some that are serious

21:59 you know like a bank against the bank a party against the banking system which always gets a few hundred maybe a few thousand but together yes they they number a couple of hundred thousand uh uh votes uh which are wasted but uh it's a very low number uh relative to the american system the british system the canadian australian system um but it be you know in in in in a in a system where every vote counts and that can be the difference between forming a government not forming government these folks are very important that's why netanyahu spent so much time trying to ensure the right mergers the right parties drop out the right parties come together etc etc thank you and what might the consequences be for israel if netanyahu loses the election vis-a-vis iran this would be iran not much vis-a-vis most israelis left right center uh have the same view on iran um you know if it's going to be git on tsar

23:03 yale appeared even betty gans obviously penny gats will not be the next prime minister but uh none of them have uh markedly different views they all are avidly against uh the jcpoa the iran nuclear agreement they're against iran having any particular path to nuclear weapons um so there'll be very little difference on that strategically definitely iran is very much the focus of netanyahu and has been for many years and he puts it as number one on his strategic threats list but i think that would probably be true of most other senior israeli politicians and certainly at the highest levels of the security sorry is there any likelihood that israel would attack iran's nuclear facilities in the next year depending on who else um i i mean i don't know i'm not privy to that sort of information but uh that would really be the last resort we did have uh energy minister uh uh

24:08 steinitz come out and said he doesn't any possibility the americans will never attack iran uh even though the americans have long said whether it's democrat or republicans that all uh everything remains all options remain on the table and israel certainly uh ensured that it has that option uh but whether it uses it will depend exactly what happens over the next few uh regarding the future of the jcpoa so one of our viewers writes i realize that's ours and the anti-bbq is there any chance that he in essence being a rightist that zara might swing and join a right-wing coalition under it depends who you ask um i think i said this a few a couple of months ago when he or maybe even less i was in the knesset announced a lot of what they thought about sars declaration that he will never sit with netanyahu and by the way interesting on a friday show of a talk show the uh presenters actually had

25:11 a piece of paper where they asked him to sign that he will never sit under a netanyahu government and basically said you know we're on tv now this is your word i want you to sign and he signed but as i said i've asked a lot of mks you know in the know in the system and there was not one of them who said that they didn't believe that sar could easily sit within a national uh led government um they don't think that he necessarily has the backbone to to tone down they don't think uh i mean i guess the bottom line is everything will depend on the numbers if sar has a path uh to get netanyahu out and this is true pretty much of everyone even by the way many members really could even now many members of the haredi parties even now even now i mean netanyahu is where he is and he is supported because he has the electoral strength at this point but if that should uh depart there is no there's very little love for

26:12 netanyahu on the political map left to right religious or secular uh so you know the the four leaders i talked about before um yeah it appeared to get on sir after there's something unofficial going on between those four and if they get the numbers uh it would be you know very much in each of their interest to get rid of netanyahu uh the sort of you know these elections are not really about right or left the palestinian issue is not really the front of center security issues not front and center diplomatic issues not front and center so even these ideas of right and left you know what divides many of these parties is even far less than uh than in normal times you know of coronavirus because the economy so uh sal would quite happily sit with yeah and appear to he may disagree fundamentally with on the palestinian issue and avitor lehman could sit quite comfortably with uh nathalie bennett who may uh disagree on religion and state issues but the

27:15 four of them could certainly work together in a government to deal with many of the pressing issues of the and along those lines what is the chance that these anti-netanyahu parties would be able to agree to form a coalition again it's all about the numbers if they have the numbers then i'm sure they would do it um at the moment according to the polls that's the only that's the that's the most uh uh outcome it would be difficult because they would need to be supported by at least labor perhaps blue and white and maybe even merits and uh merits and yamina and merits and yes robertaina would certainly be a hard uh but again they may put their ideological differences apart uh just to get rid of netanyahu and then sort of uh try and maybe it would be a short-term government to go for a new election so maybe they'd find some way to work together on as i said some of these other issues uh but everything depends on the numbers but at this point this so-called anti-netanyahu camp

28:19 could certainly reach 61 according to most recent polls what impact is the way israel is dealing with the coronavirus having on these if any i mean according to netanyahu himself that his success will be governed or failure will be governed by that will be governed by the queen of ice and he's right um he's doing very well on the vaccine program israel still needs very much uh well over a third now have received the first vaccine around a over a fifth and received the second vaccine but now the numbers are trailing off we're probably the only country in the world now where the vaccine centers are becoming empty we have more vaccines than people who want to be vaccinated they have lowered the number the age to anyone can get it now over the age of 16. that was a decision made a few hours ago so anyone over the age of 16 can go and get a vaccine but the fact is that there seems to be a lowering of interest in the vaccine which is quite remarkable

29:23 when the whole world is fighting over so that's putting a little bit of a dent in the enthusiasm uh on the economy uh you know tens of thousands are losing their jobs um you know the longer the lockdown the more businesses will close the more self-employed people will lose their their livelihood etc etc so these are things that certainly will worry netanyahu but what he's hoping for is that there'll be enough reduction in the numbers thanks to lockdown and the vaccination program that that he'll be able to go uh and open up the economy open up life uh as he calls it uh to some semblance of normalcy enough ahead of the elections where there'll be an optimism around and obviously optimism uh in in a country is very good for the incumbent so that's what he's very much playing for uh and again we'll see because the numbers are not coming down the number of infections

30:25 the number of ill people the number of people who are dying despite the fact that israel is leading in the vaccine program largely because of the variance the mutations the british the south african et cetera that's what people are blaming it on uh but netanyahu certainly has a lot to gain by making sure that things do open up and we'll have to see as we talked a little bit last week the ultra-orthodox issue is becoming a massive issue um and they are netanyahu's closest ally some people are saying that the ultra orthodox could lose this elections for netanyahu at the moment we're not seeing that uh necessarily in the polls um but a lot could still happen with a couple of months uh to go um but there's there's still there's still very much uh a lot of time between now and the election so if netanyahu can manage to israel out of lockdown you know the vaccination numbers where he wants them to be uh and he's able to open up businesses

31:27 he's over to open up malls he's able to you know people are able to fly open the airports sporting events cultural events if all of these things and then obviously the education system which is absolutely if all of these things are relatively back to normal either day of the elections or even a couple of day weeks before the elections numbers will probably uh get into the mid 30s i would say he he suggested they could even get into the low 40s i don't think they'll get that but even if they go up a few seats and take away from yamina and get on tsa that could definitely tilt uh things very much uh in his direction so that remains to be seen and uh we'll see in the weeks ahead all right well thank you so much we've come to the close of our webinar ashley thank you again for taking time to update us this week uh for our viewers please join us friday at 1 pm eastern for a webinar with eric gordon kershaw discussing obama 2.0 or biden 1.0 in the middle east thank you all for

32:30 joining us and i hope you have a great