MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Israel Insider

Israel Insider with Ashley Perry

Watch Israel Insider with Ashley Perry on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

With less then three weeks until Israel's elections, this is the peak time for maneuverings and appeals from the many rival parties. What are the prominent issues and which are the key personalities? Is the outcome beginning to take shape?

Transcript Automatic captions

Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 10, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.

0:00 hello and welcome to the middle east forums webinar series israel insider with ashley perry i'm stacy roman and i will be moderating this discussion today we're pleased to have mr ashley perry advisor to the middle east forum's wizard office join us here each wednesday at 3 pm eastern to update us on all the events going on in israel mr perry will be giving us a briefing on current israeli affairs for 15 minutes and open it up for questions should you wish to ask a question please use the q a box located at the bottom of your screen to type out your question now with no further ado i'll turn the discussion over to mr ashley perry thank you very much stacey and good tonight we are now 20 days from the elections our fourth as we know in a year and a half um i thought tonight would really sort of focus uh um you know with such a small amount of time to go on um what are the issues what are the parties doing what are their tactics strategies in the days and weeks ahead the first thing

1:02 i'll say is that most people who have worked on campaigns who have studied the material the research over the years knows that most people make up their mind around two weeks from the elections that's something which uh those of us who've worked in the election campaign world know that's the key time really to make your case uh that's when the undecideds let's say uh you know start to drop off a little bit and people really make up their mind not to say that people don't make up their mind afterwards but there's a a huge number which are sort of that that's the sort of you know the date where many people's uh are solid uh after that there's a lot of work in trying to make sure that your people get up to vote because just people say that 20 25 will vote for you doesn't mean they will on election day and especially the polls that we see day after day in israel are not reflective of the fact that there is still up to now i think about 20 to 25 undecided and that's quite a high number especially at this stage and there's a lot of discussion about

2:05 where these people go but let's start tonight with the liquid uh prime minister benjamin launched tonight very late in the game officially at least um the li cut campaign now there's been a lot of talk about that in israel that many of the other parties have been spending hundreds of thousands of shekels on facebook ads social media posters around the country billboards uh it could happen they could have really really saved as much money as and we're really expecting a blitz uh starting today until the end of the campaign there's going to be a real real blitz of uh publicity advertising etc um speaking to some of the people in the know there does seem to be a lot of unease some characterize it as panic in the liquid because they really believed in this is suddenly prime minister netanyahu really believed that very successful uh coronavirus vaccine campaign program would really catapult him to the numbers that he

3:08 needs to form a government now we've spoken about the magic number being 61. at the moment netanyahu and his two or allies have no more than uh 43 44 between them that means he is far from that magic number of 61 even if naftali bennett the only other person on the map who said that he could sit with netanyahu joins there's still potentially three or four seats now that is significant and there is a lot of talk about the fact that behind the scenes um there's a certain amount of panic uh what we have seen in the last week is quite we see prime minister netanyahu going to the mainstream media the mainstream media which he uh you know disagrees with let's say characterizes his hostile uh today tonight in his launch of the campaign he basically went off to the media saying it's biased it's like an additional political party and it's against him and it's against the continuation of liquid war or he gave them quite a lot of time on at least the two major channels he had a half an hour interview

4:11 it was quite open they asked him anything and he and there's a debate where the house successfully was the usually extremely cool calm organized netanyahu at least on some of the interviews he did on tv and radio at some point at least he he lost uh his i don't know if he lost his temper but he certainly uh went off piece from the script a little bit uh it was one point he sort of you know made fun of uh some of his rivals he he made belittling comments about them and there are those who who see in this a certain element to panic from someone who's usually extremely composed um the liquid campaign is centered around two levels at this point one is that uh you know this government has been successful it's going to be the first country israel is going to be the first country to get out of coronavirus and we see from sunday pretty much everything's going to be open uh there's going to be opening wedding halls for i think up to 300 people uh you know cinemas sporting events the

5:16 education system by the way this is against the advice of the health ministry experts as we know prime minister netanyahu has been very beholden to their uh for pretty much moisture chronovirus and now exactly as you know i've talked about the two-week magic two-week number suddenly the whole uh of israel pretty much is going to be open um but there's a lot of questions and a lot of uh liquid people that i know are asking why people not voting letting you know considering the success he's having well there's a lot of reasons and it goes on to his second level of what their attack is their attack is that is either me by mr netanyahu or yellow pit of now in previous elections there's always been a party uh which has been pushing the liquid neck and neck sometimes one seat more one seat layers two seats voltage in the last elections which we know is benigns of uh blue and white these elections the closest party to the liquid which are polling 28 even 27 uh is yeshated which is probably no more than 19 so there's no

6:21 one direct threat now it's very important for netanyahu especially in previous elections to show that there is a threat and that's why they need every single vote it's much harder to do it when your nearest rival is at least eight nine perhaps more seats behind you so it's very very hard also his main rivals at least to a certain extent are on the right wing and ideologically in line or even to the right of him so he can't call gideon a left-winger he can't good tony bennett to left-wing what he says is and there's a certain amount of credence to this that it's either me or because he's he argues if i don't continue as prime minister then the only other option is your lapid because he's the largest party in this block of uh parties which potentially will not sit with netanyahu so that that's what they're doing yeshua tit has been conspicuously silenced to a certain extent especially in the run-up to there's a lot of talk about the fact that yale appeared has not been doing a lot of interviews there's been a few tweets and he jokingly uh

7:23 said after netanyahu went on a 20-minute rant about lapid uh his uh the yellow kids uh twitter feed basically put out a post even my wife doesn't talk about me this much um but on the whole lapid is really trying to stay in the background it's to a certain extent a clever ploy but you would think especially with everything that's going on this week uh around the haridi community ultra orthodox community we know there's been some uh there's been a lot of criticism throughout this campaign and before about the ultra orthodox community what it's gaining momentum this week there was a ruling this week in the high court that reform and conservative conversions done in israel would be recognized unprecedented the high court ruled after 15 years of the government refusing and the connects are refusing to uh to create a law on this uh issue and the ultra-orthodox uh community their political parties came up very very strongly against this um the you know sort of moving

8:27 across as we say to the ultra orthodox especially the ashkenazi group uh party united judaism they're feeling a lot of flack from their people uh they're going down in the polls partly because despite what the non-ultra-orthodox community in israel are seeing and feeling the ultra-orthodox community feel very disappointed their leaders they feel that they are being bashed left right and center and they're not standing up for them uh we last week uh was the festival of purim and on sunday was what called shusham purim which means purim that was uh celebrated pretty much only in jerusalem and it's usually when people from around the country especially the ultra orthodox community come into the ultra parts of jerusalem and celebrate it with the big rabbis and the israeli government knowing that this could be a problem with coronavirus infection rates uh going up a little bit they basically canceled public transportation to jerusalem uh created crazy scenes of whole families walking

9:28 miles to get into jerusalem etc etc but they feel that they're being unfairly treated they're not getting what they believe is right that they're being targeted and remarkably in the middle or you know in in a pandemic the ultra-orthodox uh party and editorial judaism which is part of the government has just decided today that they are no longer going to be beholden to any government decisions they're not going to have any contact with the government not going to have any contact with the police are going to have any relationship with the media uh and basically because they're hearing from their people that they are losing popularity and so they feel that they have to show that they're strong uh the shas party another ultra party is basically doing what it usually does and reaching out to their more traditional minded safari voters uh to the lower socioeconomic voters their slogan is arya dairy a strong area dairy is the leader will strengthen the weaker part of society so

10:30 that's their traditional stance and uh we'll see if that works uh other parties um yamina yamin is really going strong as uh basically trying at least amongst all the other parties to a certain extent they're trying to really show that they have they put out an economic plan which has got a lot of people talking um but a lot of people are basically trying to nail down exactly where naftali bennett will be because he's the as we said he's the king maker he's the only one who said that i would either sit with uh phoebe or not sit with baby and he's trying to focus his supporters on or potential base or potential uh to those who really want to talk about the issues and for him it's how to get us out of coronavirus and the economy uh one of the reasons netanyahu hasn't been able to really make great hay from the crown of violence actually rolled out is the fact that there's still almost a million people unemployed 90 000 businesses have gone on during the last year

11:32 uh israeli school children have barely been back barely been in school for the last year uh and it's just from one shambles to another this week there was the whole issue of the airports on the open are they not open who can come home apparently israel is according to the media here the only country in the world where citizens not foreigners not permanent residents israeli citizens are simply not allowed to come into the country and people there was all these talks of people who needed you know surgeries people needed to come home they were you know living illegally in other countries because their visa ran out but they weren't able to come home uh and basically there's no plan for it and no understanding how to deal with the problem and then we saw the corona hotels and you saw all sorts of uh sort of fastest this week so that's maybe part of the reason um another party which is uh a lot of people been talking that they may be the surprise of these elections uh they really have haven't moved from their solid seven seats all throughout the elections

12:35 but a lot of people are saying that they are going to be the surprise and if they are it's one reason and one reason only because they have taken the hardest line against the ultra orthodox there is not a single event that happens in the ultra orthodox community that yeshua maitena and the victor eliminates leader haven't tried to you know jump on and say well this will not happen under the next government our sole aim is to make sure that the ultra orthodox parties are out of the next government you know so that's really uh those um some of the minor parties labor uh i try to go back to their sort of old-fashioned values left-wing socialism uh merits are are trying very hard to stay above the electoral threshold they're really reaching out especially to the arab um because they believe that that's where they can get the votes they're very angry labour party because as you can imagine the pool on the far left is very small and they believe that labour could as they gain the seed they could take

13:38 away merits see it and push them back under as we've said many many times any party which does not pass the threshold that at the moment is expected will really change the game and that's what a lot of parties are looking to do at the moment merits is really close to that line blue and white have moved up a little bit but there there's always a poll every now and again which shows them below the electoral threshold for the first time in any poll that i've seen ram which is the islamist party which was uh you know netanyahu was courting a while back uh for the first time past the electoral threshold but people don't expect it uh to do so on the day so there's really a lot to play for uh the numbers it remains to be seen whether there'll be a big surprise um i'm sure there'll be as we see with the liquid blitz media social media we will see some very strong messaging we'll see what israeli politic political commentators call the government uh move which is the sort of i guess they would call uh

14:41 in america the hell mary which is the last gas desperate attempt to try and get voters either by putting out a panic sometimes false um or basically really making appeal that you know the right wing rule is in is in and you have to come out and vote so we'll have to see but at the moment things haven't changed you know there's always a bit of movement but not necessarily enough at this point for netting out a former government and on the other side there could be a government but it would have to be as we've talked about a mishmash between the pretty much the right all the way to the far left would have to sit in a government with a lot of egos a lot of different ideologies with one thing in common to form a government to end for now at least the political career of uh benjamin netanyahu so it remains to be seen and with that i'm happy to answer any of your questions all right thank you so much so the first question and we have quite a few on the conversion case could

15:44 you comment on the implications of the israeli supreme court ruling this week recognizing the validity of conversions performed by conservative and reformed rabbis in israel right so first of all it should be understood that this there's there's various levels to this um first of all uh to make aliyah to um uh you know immigrate to israel uh you're supposed to do it under what's called the law of return which means that if you're a jew then you're allowed to come and live in israel now obviously there's always been a debate about what does it mean to be a jew and for the first few decades at the state there was very little debate and then there was a few cases so they decided to really detail it down and we could according to jewish law et cetera et cetera so they decided that anyone who has one jewish can make aliyah then they decided well obviously someone who converts can also make aliyah who do we recognize according to the state of israel anyone who converts from a recognized jewish

16:47 community can make aliyah that doesn't if it's reform conservative modern orthodox ultra-orthodox uh if they're from a uh recognized uh conversion then they can make aliyah and that that that's true and that's always been true and you know ironically enough while the ultra orthodox parties are slamming this arya dairy who's the interior minister is signing every day the ability for people who went through a form of conservative uh conversions to make aliyah so there's a certain amount of hypocrisy there's a certain amount of you know political campaigning here to be made of it what this decision did is for 15 years uh there were certain individuals who who tried to uh who tried to who converts it within israel because in israel we have around four hundred maybe even more now uh uh people who made aliyah but are not considered jewish uh they're jewish enough to make aliyah but not considered halachically jewish under under jewish law so they basically took the government to

17:50 court and the hype the supreme court kept on putting it off and saying please government and parliament can i said please make a ruling on this and there were various committees that netanyahu and others set up and they were basically ignored uh to the point where the supreme court said we gave you 15 years to make a decision on this so we're going to decide and we recognize we have no reason not to recognize reform and conservative uh conversions from within israel and so as one can imagine the ultra orthodox parties jumped on this but very little was said about the fact that for 15 years they ignored the situation hoping it would just go away as you can for prime minister netanyahu it's a very difficult issue on the one hand he needs his ultra-orthodox part of partners on the other hand he also has to play nice because the vast majority of american jury is an unorthodox and he can't come out against these communities so he's in a bit of a bind he didn't react at all to this decision so that's really what's remarkably which i didn't mention the

18:55 day after there was a conference to talk about this issue and an ultra-orthodox uh uh party member yakov pinterest uh was asked what about the conversions that are done in the army because these people who make aliyah but are not considered have the possibility under a certain program during their military training to also undergo a conversion interestingly enough this is done under the uh under the chief rabbinate of the army which is under the auspices of the chief rabbinate which is under haredi auspices and amazingly enough united torah judaism mk said well as far as i'm concerned these people are which is a remarkably antagonistic and provocative word he was slammed for it he apologized for that but he said he stands by his uh designation and as you can imagine that gave a lot of momentum for this anti-clarity feeling which is just uh towards the election so it's it's extended this uh sort of focus on the uh the hawaii community and its

19:59 extremism within its ranks and as you can imagine it gave a bit of a boost for people like lieberman even some within uh yeshetid and others and there was pretty much wall-to-wall condemnation for what pindra said uh even from the far-right you know sort of uh modern orthodox community there was also condemnation but it's just another example of how one of the issues in these elections is really what do we do with the ultra orthodox parties so real quick uh can you just remind our viewers what the electoral threshold currently is basically it's i think it's 3.25 uh it's four seats you either get four seats or you don't or it's that's a minimum uh if you if you only get three seats you're basically your your votes don't get counted and uh goes back into the system and uh when the full amount is counted so basically the minimum amount of parties is for that minimum amount of seats for parties for i should

21:03 thank you uh because of so many elections in the past few years is there any strong movement to change the voting structure in israel such as fewer parties longer period between elections maximum term for prime minister and our viewer does admit this is doubtful um but it's still like that question answer um remarkably not enough to my mind at least this is something i've been talking about for a long time that we're moving towards political paralysis and we're certainly there um very little is taught about this um a new hope under gidon has said that we need term also he's talking about a 60-60 bicameral parliament where 60 seats are in the current proportion 60 will be by a regional voting uh there are so and also there are some who are talking about fixed terms uh israel baitino have long espoused the presidential system similar in many ways to the american system with

22:05 fixed terms and also limits uh terms and more powers you know as i said something more towards the presidential system um but yeshua did to the best of my knowledge however again most of the parties are now saying there should be term limits but um but very few are talking about changing the system uh even though it's it's clear that it desperately needs it quite simply uh whoever becomes the next prime minister has to rely on at least one or two parties which are close to the threshold who will obviously not agree to change it so they will then fall under the threshold the next time it comes around so it's always a problem if we could get some of the larger parties together uh to agree on this but at the moment none of the larger parties will sit with each other so it's not likely to happen at this point but it's something that's to my mind at least desperately needed uh in the years ahead so with all the the smaller parties with similar ideological

23:07 ideologies uh would they ever consider i mean it's unclear exactly who because the smaller parties if we're talking about the religious zionist list of patel smart rich blue and white you've got three very different parties there with very different ideologies uh the only example of uh successful joining is with the arab joint arab list we saw in the last elections where they reached 15 together one of the major components around as we talked about the islamist party has dropped out and now they're polling around nine also because we did talk about them when i ran down but there's also a large discontent in the arab public uh with them as well so they're down to nine um but still if they ran or separately there's four parties sometimes even five uh it's unlikely any maybe one would uh go over the threshold so they decided to run together but there's they sometimes talk of other parties joining

24:08 uh and we've certainly seen that in the past but usually what we know is that the sum of its parts is usually not so sometimes it's just not worth it so that's why uh there haven't been so many partnerships at this point and it's too late anyway for parties to join that that already passed a few weeks understood and i know we've touched on this past few weeks but do you feel like the arab vote will impact the election i mean of course yeah we're talking about uh 22 to the public not all arabs vote for our geological reasons uh but it'll be very interesting to see it and we'll only know this after the elections exactly how many voted and where they voted you know there's a lot of talk about some maybe even uh voting for right-wing parties like they could i talked last time that according to liquid's internal polls that they've received at least one mandate from the republic which i'm sure is relatively um so it remains to be seen as i said merits is very much building on getting

25:13 a certain amount of our votes but mostly other parties perhaps labor will also get a certain amount but most of the other parties outside of the jewish community we talked about that last week uh he'll be interested to see if they do but none of the other parties are doing uh in terms of outreach to my knowledge significant outreach i should say to the arab public again beyond the jews community of your rights might sar come back to likud for the good of the nation i think definitely saul will eventually make his way back to liquid but until uh leaves that's not likely especially now um it's you know the the big debate is will keep to his word because as i said and netanyahu even spoke about this at the moment the numbers show that even with bennett he does not have the most obvious partner for such a uh with liquid with bennett with the uh

26:16 ultra orthodox partisan with smart rich would be gideon as we've talked about previously most of the people on the list are previously liquid or have definitely seen themselves in that ideological space so it made the most sense for them to go back uh for them to sit in that government gideon sahaja said he will not sit under again speaking to a lot of people within the knesset within the system a lot of are skeptical about that but he's been pretty strong on it uh so it really that would be the big test because um i'm sure netanyahu as the great strategist that he is is already trying to see where he can take maybe even two or three uh if that's all he needs uh from some other list because that's what he was able to do last time he was able to take the labour party you know break it in into the blue and white party he was definitely able to you know rip into and you had even the derek harris party of uh hauser and hender which he was able to bring to his government again

27:18 these are all people who said that they will not sit in the netanyahu government so there's a lot of skepticism within israel about making such promises because we've seen this before but at the moment i don't see sarah returning to it could but i think the day after netanyahu there will be a lot of people who return so that it could in one way or another so currently what are the routes that netanyahu could take to get the 61 seats pretty much as i said you know again if if bennett uh does decide to go with uh netanyahu and he hasn't brought that out uh then at the moment according to polls again these are just polls he'll still need some now where could he get them from we've seen netanyahu you know really reach across the aisle he's taken people from the far left in the past into his government as long as he'll get that 61.

28:13 so pretty much he would look at anyone from the labour party onwards and there you've got the labour you know again we saw last time two out of the three or three out of the four labour party members basically went with the netanyahu again even though they said they wouldn't in fact uh i mean parrots the previous leader of the party shaved off his moustache so we could read his lips that he will not join the netanyahu's government and there he was without a mistake in it government so you know there's you can understand why there's a certain amount of skepticism in israel but i don't think anyone yeshua did uh israel has shown that they're pretty um so really the only possibility that netting if if i was in the 10 yard strategy meetings the only ones that you could see is within uh uh new hope in kid and sal's party and there's a lot of people he's worked um and there's a lot of things that he could potentially offer just to manage to get over that i'm sure

29:16 this is something that they're thinking about now they're not necessarily waiting till after the elections thank you and if you don't mind if we could go back real quick to the case um if they receive full citizenship does this mean there have been rabbis have to approve their marriage to another israeli jew to take place within israel that's that's another um i i i sort of touched on it before but in israel uh there's there's two layers to it those who are able to make aliyah and there are those who are considered jewish for the unfortunately we have a situation where there's as i said four hundred thousand half a million people who are not considered who are not muslims they're not uh christians that say they're not jews they're people considered of no religion and they really have no way of marrying uh there was a law a few years ago yeshua bethany put through uh where basically says someone of no religion can marry someone of no

30:18 as you can imagine that's very limiting marriages that take place abroad are recognized in israel regardless of who they're between but in israel you have to get mad through one of the religious structures so a muslim commanding muslim a christian cabaret but the rabbi will not uh recognize who got married who got converted through perhaps reform or has only one who is a jewish father or a jewish so that's a very different level this ruling wasn't about that this ruling was the status to be able to make aliyah because a convert can make aliyah if they're from a recognized community outside of israel but if they're inside uh then they can be considered due to due to stay in israel and get that status within that let's say the secular authorities if they now according to high courts if they converted through a former conservative which certainly wasn't the case uh up until recently all right well thank you so much we've come to the close of our webinar ashley thank you again for taking time down

31:20 with us this week uh for our viewers please join us on friday at 1 pm eastern for a webinar with ali al yami discussing mbs back down backs down uh cut our surprising victory in the gcc thank you all for joining us and i hope you have a great day