Webinar or Talk
France and Islam: Is Something Changing? with Anne-Elisabeth Moutet
Watch on YouTube
Description
On Oct. 2, President Emmanuel Macron of France called Islam a religion in crisis and pledged to combat Islamism. In quick succession, jihadis attacked and murdered non-Muslim French citizens, to widespread alarm. Is France finally willing to combat Islamism? Will Macron succeed where other leaders failed? Can France provide leadership for the West?
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 11, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:00 and welcome to the Middle East Forum speaker webinar series. I'm Stacy Roman and I will be moderating this discussion today. We're pleased to have Ann Elizabeth Moute, columnist for London's Telegraph and a contributor to the BBC and New York Post join us to discuss France and Islam. Is something changing? Miss Mute will speak for 15 minutes and open it up and open up for questions. Should you wish to ask a question, please use the Q&A box located at the bottom of your screen to type out your question. And now with no further ado, I'll turn the discussion over to Ann Elizabeth Moute. Uh good afternoon. It's barely afternoon where you are and it's late afternoon where we are. Uh I was asked a series of questions essentially about France's fight against terrorism and about our president's commitment uh to fight against what he has called separatist Islamism uh leaving himself open to a great deal of criticism uh around um around the uh the Anglo the Anglosphere mostly uh all sorts of newspapers and columnists in in the New York Times, the
1:02 Washington Post, Politico, uh um the Financial Times and other uh prestige media have accused him of being uh islamophobic, racist, uh uh in need of an education, etc. And so the question is, does he mean it? How do the French take uh this lack of understanding of what he meant uh from supposedly our allies and um what will this change? So I think what you first need is a little bit of a reminder uh of what uh caused all this. Uh Fr first of all reminder that France is a country that has known terrorism for a very long time. We had terrorist attacks during the uh 60s uh as the end of the uh u Algerian war and afterwards caused uh bombings in Paris and other places from both uh the Algerian independentists and uh those people who represented the uh the French uh uh colon former colonists people who'd been there for two
2:05 centuries forced to come back. We then had terrorism in the 70s in the late 60s and in the 70s that was Palestinian uh uh mostly and then we started um getting also Iranian terrorism as soon as Ayatollah Kmeni came back from exile where he had been received by France that didn't help we also had terrorism from various leftist groups also at that time we started uh um knowing Libyan terrorism all of this was using proxy terrorism ists to make some points on the Middle East case. Uh in the 1990s, France was one of the main hintterlands of the uh civil war in Algeria. The civil war in Algeria lasted from 1992 to 2000 and it killed about a quarter million people. U people don't hear much about it. They ought to. uh the government which is by no means uh um entirely blameless decided to halt the elections before the Islamists uh uh uh were um party was scheduled to win it.
3:10 Uh and there was u push back horribly so with entire villages uh being slaughtered um with both parties not behaving terribly well. Uh and it left Algeria a bruised country with still the same government in place that has been put in place 40 years ago. A great deal of terrorism was waged uh on French soil including plane hijackings, deadly bombings in Paris, in one medical stations, another and then we got u more bombings after the uh u the 911 and the phenomenon that now you everyone unfortunately has become familiar with.
3:46 So uh the French um uh French justice and French defense forces are very much aware of the danger of terrorism. They're also very knowledgeable and it's knowledge we acquired in in blood. We paid for in blood. Um with a result that there is knowledge there's always been knowledge in France about who are who are the terrorists and how that happens and how uh there are ecosystems that have developed in some segments of of the the uh Salafist and Muslim Brotherhood leaning parts uh of of the Muslim minority in France. And that is by no means not at all the French uh Muslim community. The French Muslim community is about six or seven million people. Almost half of these people come from Barbber and Kabil backgrounds in Morocco and mostly in Algeria and and those were the people who are being slaughtered by the Islamists during the French Algeria the the Algerian civil war of 92. Um so they are people who absolutely want to integrate have
4:48 integrated pretty well and in general uh uh distrust the Islamists. In all this context where came the question of Shahi Abdul. Now you probably remember that Salman Rashi 30 years ago was accused of blasphemy and and insulting Islam with his f uh re magical realist novel uh the satanic verses. And at that time everybody supported him. Nobody said anything uh except that uh having one Müller in Tehran uh uh declare a fatwa condemning him to death uh for all good believers with anything else uh than uh uh madness and and criminal. Uh fast forward 30 years and um a number of um Islamist personalities have described the French Muslim cartoons as being the same thing as the satanic verses. You can decide that your taste leans more towards the beautiful English pros of Salman Rashi than uh the aggressive and funny cartoons of Shahi Abdul. But that is not the point. The point is that uh
5:53 the foreign elements who then have supporters in our countries and these supporters feel entitled to behead people and kill people just because they don't like something that has been drawn or written on paper. Uh and the French are very much behind this government. This government is embattled for other reasons. Mayor Mu is not terribly popular these days. People question his handling of COVID and other things. But on that specific instance, the French the French population is behind President M. President Mccon has actually been very careful when he made his speech on separatism about four weeks ago uh to separate uh the vast majority of Muslims than from those elements who do not want to live within French society. that live literally in kinds of enclaves uh in which uh uh the laws of the republic are defied. Uh the law of the land is defied and and the kind of talk and of actions including support logistic support logistical support to terrorist attacks is encouraged uh winked on encouraged and
6:57 sometimes actually practiced. uh this is what the speech meant and the speech said in effect uh we are going to be a lot more careful and we're not going to accept this. Uh now it is it wasn't Mau's position that the word Islamophobia is actually uh an extremely useful weapon in that you accuse people of of racism if you can have racism for a belief uh uh and call it Islamophobia and then you shut up any kind of criticism of that extremist aspect of Islam. Uh and that is uh what immediately was was put into gear. was put into gear by two uh leaders. The main one is Rasep Erdogan who is the um um Turkish president. Uh it's very important to see this. Turkey has ambitions. Turkey right now is waging or helping in seven different conflicts uh from Syria to places in Iraq to helping the Azeris against the Armenians uh in
8:01 Libya where Turkey is present has got boots on the ground and is effectively pushing one one of the two generals vying for power in Libya. Um and uh Turkey tried to push back against Greece, an age-old enemy, um and attacked Gree Greece boats uh ships and and Greece is a member of the European Union. Turkey isn't. Turkey is only a member of NATO. Uh and President M uh said that Greece and the European Union must be protected against attacks and that the French would send ships to help uh assist a nation uh being attacked.
8:39 that uh alarmed Adawan to the point when he decided that Matth would be his punching ball basically and uh he found in the republication of the Shali Hemdo caricaturures that provoked the killing in 2015 of uh uh uh eight cartoonists and editors at Shali. a good reason to uh attack France and say that uh insult Mau in in stupid uh schoolyard bullying words which are just words but then also encouraged the fact uh that people might be attacked if they either supported M or supported Mahon's attitude about having one nation under the broad umbrella of the legal law the law of the republic uh the caricatures had not republished by Shahi Abdu just for fun.
9:31 The the uh the court case against the the killers of what remained of the killers, the ones who hadn't been uh uh shot down by police while doing their killing um was reopened and uh the magazine decided that because this was a fight for freedom of expression uh because the first time that they published those caricaturures in 2006, they had been defended by all political leaders left and right of French major parties. Um it would be making a point that freedom of speech still existed today as it did uh 15 years ago. Um the reactions were not as good and the reactions were especially not good in in in in countries that are French allies.
10:13 Uh this is the entire context for the current situation in which France is being reviled by first of all by Turkey and Turkeykey's proxies. second by uh um Pakistan Pakistan the current Pakistan leader the prime minister Imran Khan a former uh English Pakistani playboy and very good cricketer um decided also to say that any Muslim uh who wanted to fight back in King's France was entitled which is also a call for murder but these people also uh have points they've paid for mosques they've subsidized some networks and therefore they have access to communities that are being separated from the rest of the national community in France. And this is how a French teacher Samuel Petti was beheaded because he was giving a civics lesson that was in the in the mandator by the the curriculum on on why caricaturures exist in the French cultural tradition and why uh uh anything that is written down is not something that entitles you to kill people uh to to simplify things.
11:16 Uh this is where we're at now. M sadly has taken in the fact that France is has been actually a battleground for at least two or three two or three decades. From the moment of 911, you can basically say that the the whole fight was being uh first waged by by lunaries on both sides. And then uh there was a a creeping influence of some of the worst elements of of Islamism, not Islam, but Islamism uh in in French Muslim communities. This I would say and we've just seen it recently was aided and abetted by uh the the the the you know what America has got to offer as sort of finest and most expensive educators education institutes of learning and and newspapers because it's become very fashionable to be quote unquote anti-colonialism. It's very fashionable to denounce uh supposed Islamophobia or racism in anywhere and France which has extremely different political traditions
12:20 uh and older political traditions than America and uh does not behave consider her citizens are each belonging to a specific community. We consider our citizens as all being French. Uh and we also consider that you uh there are things that you don't do in your own nation such as say that the law that the nation's laws do not apply to you that you're allowed to marry several women including minor women or women who don't want to marry you and stuff of that kind. Uh this is this is what we're basically waging war on. uh the current climate is become extremely strange to us because recently there have been a series of articles misrepresenting uh it were Emanuel Mron's speeches uh and to a large extent painting a target on if not the president who's well protected but French citizens in uh France and abroad uh for uh Islamophobia for uh intolerance for uh of course systemic racism because that's the new thing and
13:24 other things. Uh I now the question is will M hold fast? M was not really somebody who specialized in this in his studies. He knows lots about economics. Um he knows a great deal of things because he's a bright man. Uh Islamism was not a danger on his radar until facts and murders uh brought it to him. is he committed he started passing laws putting laws to parliament that uh uh give more means to uh anti-terrorists in France and also uh he started dissolving some associations that were very clearly uh uh um advocating murder and advocating uh uh illegal things and my hope is that and he's running for re-election the election is in uh two one and a half years time in in May of Uh he also he has massive support in this and no other thing and my hope is that at least his sense of self-preservation as a leader as a political leader will will help
14:26 something which I think from all accounts and from contacts I've heard is quite genuine. uh he is absolutely horrified that there is no way of of getting your point across to some people because they they they may understand what you want to say but they absolutely disapprove of your being able to say it and they say it with bombs. Uh so that's the situation as it is in France as I said we are talking here not about a country that's suddenly discovering all this. We have known terrorism for a long time. We have actually the expertise in France to know the networks. French whatever the French government was saying about other things in the United States. Uh the French always uh uh had extremely good working relationship on anti-terrorism uh and financing of terrorism all sorts of efforts with America and with other western nations.
15:11 So uh it's not as if Mron having discovered that this was a major issue uh was coming uh blind on this. He actually is well equipped. So I the answer to the question that had been asked in the beginning is I am cautiously hopeful that yes France means it this time and now I will welcome questions from anyone especially those who think I haven't made sense. All right, thank you so much. That was a great rundown of the history as well as what's going on today. Um do you have a sense of how or sorry does Macron believe he can isolate the Islamist ide ideology in the guise of a religion.
15:56 I think France is a country that always has had institutions to talk for uh religions. France is a country that is secular and and most other countries do not understand secularism. Lacete and of course Lacete has now been sort of made into one of those sort of uh uh uh uh dangerous words by people who would like to attack France and they say that it's racist. Uh but uh French secularism is only understandable if you know about the French Revolution and if you know uh that uh we had an established religion which was Catholicism. The king was anointed with the holy oils when he was being crowned at the cathedral of France and and it was the state religion. Uh it's a religion that for instance Volter fought against when a Protestant was executed for practicing Protestantism uh in the 1700s. Uh we we we fought our way towards freedom of religion. The French Revolution granted freedom of religion uh right at the beginning. It was not anti- uh sort of anti- relligion per se.
16:58 It was not against God per se. uh the there was a religion of the supreme being which was for a while enacted in France during the French revolution. Um and the point is that religious uh the the uh the France was divided in three orders. The nobility, the clergy and and the people. Uh when every French uh citizen no longer subjects were made equal, um the church was seen especially in the 19th century which was reacting against the revolution of Napoleon. Uh the the church was seen as the voice of reaction literally. So they were reacting against a movement that revolutionary movement. So there was a history where you had on one side the atheist Greek republic and on the other side uh uh uh the forces of religion uh and and of course they were monarchist because monarchy was was the monarch were the head the secular head of the church. And the result was uh uh eventually when that battle was waged, it was waged um in at the turn of the 1920th century in 1905. There was a law
18:03 that passed that enshrined uh the the uh uh the neutrality of the French state in in the modern version of lee secularism and what lee has become essentially and and lots of uh religious groups were expelled from the country for several decades and then they came back and it's now very much appeased with the Catholic Church. But what lacy means is every religion is protected. You're allowed to practice your religion. It is part of your personal freedom. It is private. It is not something that belongs to the state. The state has no opinion on religions. The state uh uh will protect the practice of religion. But what we guarantee for all citizens is the neutrality of the public space. And that means that civil servants are not supposed to advocate any kind of religion in any way. uh that children at school are not supposed to advocate religion or behave according to the pre precepts of any kind of religion at school when they're minors and they're entitled to the French cur national curriculum uh and and to be exposed to a
19:07 completely neutral education when they are university students where they are the reach majority uh if they're Muslim women they're allowed to wear the headscarf which they're not allowed to wear in high schools precisely because then it is their decision it's personal uh the school is supposed to create young French citizens and to uh make them I will say you know grand ground grandly commune in the ethos of the French state. So uh that's how it works and it is very much misunderstood in in in many ways. Uh and on this basis we I mean we had a some articles had to be pulled by places like the Financial Times or websites like Politico because they were riddled with inaccuracies and at one stage the you could see corrections every every half hour being added on the websites about what was in the pieces and eventually the pieces were pulled and then of course people said that Macon had threatened dangerously journalists and honestly I mean we you know we don't threaten dangerously journalists people who threaten dangerously journalists killed
20:09 uh and we've seen this happen. Uh but uh he had mentioned the fact that there were inaccuracies. Mak himself went on to Alazer which is to some extent the layer of the beast because it's the state channel of Qatar and Qatar unlike uh the Saudis. We've seen some of the errors of their ways. The Qataris fund terrorism in various places. Um and he spoke very convincingly in English with an Alazer interviewer to explain. I'm not sure that he got himself understood by everyone, but certainly his message went across and was aired by Alazer and he felt that it was something that you did and this is how he's been said to to threaten people. I I I don't know whether I should be answering questions that are actually on the Q&A uh on the Q&A list. Should we do that or Yeah, I'll be jumping.
20:57 I'm going to go around this because at some stage I will stop. But you know uh Ken Miller says do I have adi any advice of your president to be so that the United States can avoid making the same mistakes that France has made in regards to Islam and immigrants entering the United States? I think actually this doesn't make much sense because you America doesn't have the same structure of immigration as France has. Immigration comes from places that have a common history with you or are on the other side from a border to you. uh it's pretty it's pretty difficult to get to America on a small boat from say Afghanistan or other places. It's relatively easy to go from those places to Turkey or to Lebanon and then get to Greece which is absolutely next door and then walk. So uh the structure and our history especially for France we had colonies in Africa for a long time and therefore we have normally so and many of them have made massive contributions to the nation. uh you know the uh first black academician France was a man who also became president of the Republic of
21:58 Sineagal Leopango. Uh uh we have other well-known writers, doctors, etc. who come from Muslim immigration. Uh that is uh uh that's not really that's not really um a problem. Uh so uh on on that question uh and I've just seen it disappear. I don't know where whether those questions disappear when they're answered. Yes, they do. Um the uh I don't think I don't think you can uh sort of you don't have the same problems in terms of Islam. I think there are things about Islam that America should be careful of and that's basically who finances the mosques, who sends money, especially foreign countries. And I think it's much too easy, especially through proxies in America. And I expect actually the department of the treasury who are no spring checkers actually have a fair idea of how the money gets in and I think uh you know yes people should be allowed to practice Islam. America is a bit different from other countries but
22:59 certainly you should be watching schools and watch whether schools are teaching dangerous things and that is where you defer from our schools. We really have a national curriculum and a very top down administr administered country and I think there are people who are allowed to homeschool their kids if they want their kids not to learn about evolution in America and you know that's the way you guys do it. Uh the kids who don't believe in evolution do not go out with machetes and I would say that the kids who learn things about radical Islam do not go out thank god with machetes either. But uh that's something that the French can do and that you can't do. you can't teach not you can't you know refuse to teach your kids evolution in France and many of you will say that's not freedom and I'll live with that uh but in terms of you know follow the money follow the funders of people who are in Congress pushing some bills follow the lobbyists and and that will defank some of the unpleasant things so that's one question I'm I'm these things are sort of behaving in the in the in the sort of chat window in a strange way um and a number of us attendees says uh the concept of Lacy has taken the
24:03 proportions of a state religion. Is it realistic? Uh oh god. H well well convert or die. Well that was in the middle ages people. You know we've all changed actually. Uh I would like you to ask to think you know about uh dentists and plumbing in the middle ages and realize that many things in life changed over 800 years. And so I will please stop talking about crusaders. It's exhausting. uh but uh lacet is not a state religion. Lacete however is an constitutive tenate of the French outlook on life and we're entitled to our you know constitutive uh tenants on life. This is our freedom. That's our culture you know by I believe in multiculturalism and I would like every culture to be respected including the French one. Uh that's to me that's point uh French Muslim M is not going to change French Muslim hearts and minds.
24:56 However, m not mak, I mean most French Muslims actually believe in le. Uh my very nice hardworking Moroccan grosser whom I could point to you if this were a laptop in the street has all five kids of his in a Catholic school because it's a good school and the state school next to him was not very good and uh he can live with that. He does the Ramadan. He's a devout Muslim. He has no problems with it. uh the we live in a different we have we live in a different environment. Uh everybody knows that uh uh the relig uh god I mean yeah well I know I can see why that question is being asked by somebody who wishes to remain anonymous very bravely. I bet you have a pseudonym on Twitter as well. um Republican values uh not Republican party republic and the values of a republic or you know the values that we believe in and I'm really sorry that offends your feeling. I think I'll stop answering this one. Uh why haven't President Muan French citizens
25:58 acknowledge the fact that Islam is a political ideology and not a religion? You know it you can have a political ideology and be a religion at the same time. and considering you know take various dominations of Protestants take the Orthodox and the Catholics and everything lots of different things in Christianity as well and I understand that if you've got two three Jew two Jews together you've got three opinions and I you know you should hear I mean I bet you've heard conservative rabbis being sort of uh uh talking about the religious rabbis and the reverse so conceptions about religion is are very complicated and I'm not going to go into this parts of Islam. Islam is a way of life and and a law. Uh Jewish law was a law at one stage and and then we we went touring for a long time. Uh but still uh Islam is not just a political ideology and not a religion. Some of Islam, a great deal of Islam is a religion. Some Islam is a political ideology and it lives with the state. and some Islam um
27:04 some Islam is is nothing but but uh it's up to them. I don't think we can say blanket. And I'm going to finish on this one too because there are more. Okay. Isn't there a legislation that prevents abusing religions like the anti-semitism religion? Oh god. Anti-usemitism is not abusing religion. Kyrie, I really appreciate your signing your name. Uh that's really nice. Uh so we can talk in good faith. Um uh anti-semitism is abusing Jews and defaming Jews and saying that they are bad people and it's I think legislation for that is excellent. I think there should be legislation actually there is legislation thank god uh on you know abusing Muslims who are persons. Uh if you want to say that you think Judaism is a stupid religion you are absolutely free to do it. You can say that Catholicism is stupid and the French philosophers did it. And uh if people want to say look I think the tenants of Islams are stupid. It's not people it is an idea. If you want to say Muslims are stupid that should be actionable. Well
28:06 actionable is not really an insult. If you say that Muslims should be exterminated uh you yourself should be put to rest in a place with a roof over your head for a long time. Uh and that's all I'm going to say on this one. How do other EU countries feel about Macau's comments regarding extremist Islam? Well, you know Europe is one continent. passing our borders because of Shenhen is extremely easy. Therefore, most European countries have seen the effects of truly extremist Islam and therefore there's a great deal of understanding on all sides. We actually had uh uh um messages from President M over Samuel Betty's beheading. We've had messages in various cases. Uh there's a great deal of collaboration through Interipole on terror fight against terrorism. So most EU countries understand and of course EU countries in Eastern Europe feel very strongly about this and support MO. Is there any truth to reports of so-called no-go areas in France Muslim and place where police can't or will not go? Ah that's an interesting question and uh when I lived in New York which was uh 30
29:11 years ago uh there were definitely areas in the Bronx and in the South Bronx and in Central Park at night where it was a no-go area if you knew what was good for you. Uh admittedly the police could go there. The police didn't always like to go there but the police could go there. Uh we've got those now and I think we have not learned the lessons of New York. I'm I'm not sure I have any feelings about Woody Giuliani as a lawyer, but as a mayor, he was a bloody good mayor and I used to live in New York at that time. Uh that's all I can say about this. And before him, you had Ed Cot who was wonderful. And and there was an effort in changing policing in New York that made it possible for there not to be nogo zones. And a great deal of the no-go zones in France have got less to do with Islam and a great deal to do with uh complete chaos and and and uh a problem with rule of law. If you send enough police in those places, yes, they can go in. If you send two cops, things may happen to them like stuff being thrown at them from the windows.
30:12 It is not pleasing. It is not exactly no go, but it is something that as a French voter, I would like my country to work on. Uh and you know, when when when I was growing up in New York, uh the uh I also we also wanted something to be done at the time. So let's just hope are the children grandchildren of the webinar though. Unfortunately we reached the time limit well if you guys want more answers uh I leave it to Stacy to see whether we can talk about this. Uh let me just have a look on all of this. If I think there's a conclusion in two minutes uh does France support uh all well all I can say is uh we need allies in this. America should understand that there are many ways of being free democratic countries and uh do not listen to people who want to
31:14 divide us. Do not listen to people who say, "Look at them. They're hateful." Do not think that the American way is 100% the best way. Uh uh nothing is 100% the best way because we're not angels. Uh so help us, think of us, support us, read French books because, you know, French literature because it's good. Goodbye. Wonderful. Thank you so much. I'm sorry that we had to come to the close of our webinar. There were so many great Thank you. Thank you again, Mrs. smooth with us today. Uh for our viewers, please be on the lookout for our weekly webinar offerings email coming out over the weekend. Thank you all for joining us and I hope you have a wonderful day.
31:53 Thanks again. Bye.