MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Israel Insider

Israel Insider with Ashley Perry

Watch Israel Insider with Ashley Perry on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

Lebanon’s Hizballah is carrying out near-daily missile attacks against Israel. Yemen’s Houthis have launched missiles and drones at Israel, several of which the U.S. Navy shot down. How close are Israel and Iran to a regional war? How might a ground war in Gaza affect this prospect? What might be the American role?

Transcript Automatic captions

Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 26, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.

0:06 hello and welcome to the Middle East Forum speaker open our series and podcast Israel Insider with Ashley Perry I'm Stacy Roman and I will be moderating this discussion today we're pleased to have Mr Ashley Perry advised to the Middle East forum's Israel office join us here each Wednesday to update us on the latest events in Israel Mr per will be giving us a briefing on the current situation in Israel for 15 minutes followed by 15 minutes of Q&A from the audience should you wish to ask a question please use the Q&A box located at the bottom of your screen to type your question and with that I will turn the discussion over to Mr Ashley Perry thank you very much Stacy good evening from Israel um as those of you who have been following the Israel Insider for a while will know that um it been one second has been uh difficult to uh predict what the subject matter will be on any given week um when when I have to put up the title on Friday before and uh now it's

1:13 Wednesday and one can imagine during a war uh that becomes uh even worse one Stacy oh okay good um so tonight the big issue that arose was the Press conference given by prime minister uh Benjamin netan uh a lot of people think uh this is a when I say press conference it's it's more a statement um many people think it's a statement that should have been made a long time ago uh there were differences of opinion within his office uh whether he should take responsibility be accountable apologize perhaps like some of the uh heads of the security services Army and even his National Security advisor have done uh but tonight he went part of the way uh some people say he stopped short of taking responsibility um he said that there will be a lot of questions after the war

2:15 and everyone will have to answer for them including me which is definitely uh something that we haven't heard before but again some people felt it was still short of accepting responsibility um but what was also interesting is he laid out a new aim for the war up until now Benjamin Netanyahu has been really drumming the beat that the only goal of this war is to defeat annihilate exterminate get rid of whatever word he uses um in the Press statements or in his press conferences with the slew of foreign leaders who have come to Israel over the last week today he said alongside that to defeat Hamas um is to free the hostages um and it's interesting because that was put up for the first time um why he did that is probably because on that issue certainly there is movement we saw two uh hostages released last week we saw two hostages released this

3:17 week to El elderly women and apparently there are breakthroughs or at least movement uh on the release of further hostages there is talk that uh children under the age of 16 will be released others say women and children will be released soldiers will not um but what there appears to be is some good will at least on that issue at least from some parties and what's most important is the issue of Qatar suddenly in I mean not suddenly Qatar has been there for a while but uh certainly it's become front and center as one can imagine after the October 7th Massacre people were looking to see who is funding who is servicing who is behind Kamas and the most obvious one is Iran but Qatar also plays a role we know that for quite a many years Qatar has been funding Hamas has been bringing money cash in suitcases even into the strip and its role uh with Hamas and other terrorist organizations

4:20 that suddenly come under the microscope which has caused them quite a lot of conation because as we know Qatar in the world cup and by famous uh sporting teams around the world and they you know sort of full court press and trying to present themselves as a modern country as a country which really seeks uh to be a unifier which seeks to really be part of the West has come obviously Under Fire from various sources and once again what has obviously happened is Qatar is someone who can talk to both sides you know they they're someone who they're an organization which has been accused both of funding terrorist organizations but has a significant US base on his territory so you know it has played sort of both sides on this and it can play and it apparently is playing a role in the release of the hostages because it is talking to Hamas and is talking to Israel directly or indirectly depends who you speak to uh

5:22 there obviously are ties to the Qatari uh leadership here and we saw part of that in the last day with the fact that um foreign minister Ellie Cohen who was in New York at the United Nations for this debate on you know the war in the region he pointed an accusing finger at Qatar uh that enraged the qataris obviously that they sent a message to America that that is not acceptable when it is trying to play what it describes as a responsible role and we saw astonishingly uh sby Israel's National Security advisor basically obviously ordered from above to put out a statement that says the qataris are playing a responsible and constructive role in this one as one can imagine he was attacked by people in this government or stro being one of the minister orid tro and also people outside like former uh prime minister naftali Bennett Qatar is is not a country well-liked in Israel it's not a

6:26 country that is seen as having a respons role previously but it is clearly having a role in the hostage negotiations so Israel would like to uh calm the waters um and it really is quite an unprecedent to think for scena is really official to write something relatively positive actually more than relatively positive about the qataris um unfortunately you know with this going on we have had a return to politics Politics as Usual unfortunately in Israel that happens even during war what we have seen in the last few days is a return of many ministers who've been quiet because as one can imagine there's a lot of anger the country is still in shock what is it 19 days later uh 18 days after the 7th of October the country is still in shock the country is still angry uh and that's as I said part of what played into prime minister nany's live statement tonight um but I I think in the last few days there's been

7:30 a lot more attention on what are the ministers doing why are we spending all this money uh on all the budgets of these Ministries when we should be spending it on the war in the south on resettling those 120,000 plus Israelis who have been uh evacuated from the North and the South uh so there's been a lot of anger we've already seen one resignation the so-called hbra Minister public diplomacy Minister now we've seen a deputy minister in the prime minister's office office AI M who MOS who is a controversial figure anyway who has said that he will dedicate didn't say exactly how much or what but some of the money which he has been promised uh for the war effort and we've seen uh some other attempts like that we're also seeing other ministers trying to look relevant trying to uh you know saber rle at times or trying to uh look like they're playing roles behind the scenes and and do important things uh some of them attacking we've seen U NE bar cat's economy Ministry attacking BM Rich's

8:35 finance ministry finance ministry as one can imagine come under attack uh for what has been described as an underwhelming package of Aid to those most affected um and it's been seen as not even a plaster something less than a plaster for what is necessary uh at this uh point the blame game continues um and we're seeing differences of opinion uh between the upper echelons in the political and security levels and that also plays very much into netan statement tonight because he tried to play that everything is normal we are all on the same page when it's clear that that is not the case over the last week There's Been various leaking from the prime minister's office and his uh supporters uh against the upper echelons of the IDF uh and back and what are the what are the issues well as we know again 18 days later after the massacre the pogram on the 7th of October uh

9:39 Israeli soldiers were reservists were served with papers almost immediately uh to call for Duty and they did in massive 120% uh of who were called um but still nothing's happened they one expected a ground Invasion uh and it simply hasn't happened so on the one hand people are asking why haven't we done that and the IDF are saying well we were given the orders to call up everybody to get ourselves ready for a ground incursion but we haven't been given the green light uh the prime minister's uh people are explaining that why they such a rush to put our soldiers in in harm every day that we can bomb from the air without putting a single soldier into Gaza is is is is better the more we're able to prepare uh for the ground incursion the better it is uh and there's obviously been some very strong differences of opinion regardless of this So-Cal show of unity the fact that netan did not stand in front of the cameras alongside defense minister Galant alongside Benny

10:43 G Minister Benny Gans or the um the idea of Chief of Staff also says quite a lot what is really going on uh on the ground can be thought of in in in a few different ways first of all there there are rumors that uh the Americans have asked Israel to hold off on the ground Invasion that's one of the main re reasons they've done so various positions have been put out some have suggested that it's uh because they want to make sure that all of the American uh forces in the region are brought up to scratch and brought to the region to make sure that if it if this war does get out of hand if it does become more um America can defend its assets which has many of many bases throughout the region we've seen some attacked in Iraq uh in recent days others say that um uh the American advisers are coming across to advise is how best to deal with this

11:47 war how to defeat Hamas and there's been a lot of there's been a certain amount of focus at least behind the scenes on two options and they sort of descri have been described as the fuja and the mosul uh option uh you know sort of strategies um which the Americans involved with both uh in Iraq and if we look at both of them individually um they they they describe very different tactics in fua it was very much uh they tried to evacuate as many people as possible and then they basically bombed from the air until they were able to pretty much uh defeat uh the enemy uh within the the city in mosul they went to to Door uh really soldiers on the ground ground incursion they went door too and the Americans are very much pushing the fua model is more effective uh Israelis are certainly listening to this it seems from the moment because they are doing more more from the air we saw certain bombs being dropped today that we

12:48 haven't seen up until now uh I don't know if you they could be described as bunker Busters but certainly far more heavy far more deadly uh to those who may be or most certainly are hiding in underground bunkers which is where the Hamas leadership remain um so that could be another reason to try and do as much as they can from the air before they need either a full ground incursion or maybe something less uh with some special forces but that's certainly uh what what is being discussed uh but there certainly appears to be very different uh differences of opinion within the upper uh and security echelons regionally uh things are actually getting very interesting first of all we've seen in the last couple of days something relatively extraordinary usually in these kind of situations you would expect the the higher the Palestinian um uh fatality rate the more anger there'd be from the region and we certainly see that with uh those like

13:50 president erdogan who put out statements that Hamas is not a terrorist organization it's freedom fighter and it's a genocide Etc and we've heard heard that from a few leaders but we've also heard from the likes of Bahrain which have come out with relatively positive statements the saying we should not let this ruin the economic uh agreements that we've been signing and the Abraham the spirit of the Abraham Accords etc etc and we also heard the Saudi foreign minister come out in the last 24 hours and say that we still hope for peace let not let this situation destroy uh chances for peace and as soon as this is over we should resume uh those calls uh which is quite remarkable at this stage because you know one can imagine they're feeding quite a lot of heat from um the region but also they're obviously uh hearing a lot from the Americans and and as we've explained in recent weeks before the war how important the Saudi Israel normalization is it sounds crazy at this point to be talking about the Saudi

14:52 Israel normalization and I did say uh last week that I believe that that is a major factor how why and when this uh this massacre took place and this war was forced on Israel but it seems like that dream has not dissipated at this moment at least and we're as I said we're over two weeks into the war um so that's certainly positive on the less positive we see more and more how Iran is moving its pieces throughout the region into place we see more more uh attempts from their allies in Yemen the houis to attack Israel to attack American interests as I said before we see um uh forces in Iraq led by Iran uh attacking American forces we see some of the groups trying to push their way towards the Jordanian border and uh at the moment they're not being allowed in but maybe they'll be able to find another way we've seen other uh terrorist Iranian proxies on the Syrian borders and we've had some rocket attacks from Syria over the last week

15:56 and obviously we have hisbah on the northern border put out a show today where they hadan sit down with leading members of Hamas andah with Hamas and Islamic Jihad to try and show this Unity how they're working together but clearly at the moment hisbah while they have certainly been poking Israel once again and further and further in Israel have been responding indeed it's still not uh have not come to the decision yet of whether it's going to come in full again as I said last week there is that feeling that they would wait until Israel got bogged down in Gaz at the moment it has even entered Gaza at least not from the ground so perhaps that's the reason why they haven't upped the scale of their incursions and their attempts uh to uh join uh this war at this point um so I'm happy to answer any questions on anything I've mentioned thus far thank you so much uh so alakan asked uh did nine months of anti-government

17:01 protests in Israel EMB embolden um they said it did and and and I talked about this last week and I said that hisbah certainly who Hassan N is a great student of Israeli politics and Society he obviously follows it or these people around him to and give him information because he mentioned it quite a lot during his um speeches uh in the lead up to the war how he saw Israel as weak a society which is cleaved in uh and you know hinted that now is the time to strike uh I'm sure Hamas were reading a similar situation whether they believed that that was part of the reason to attack now because quite simply the country is more unified than I can certainly ever remember um so it was a great misunderstanding on on both of their parts if that was part of their calculation um but uh it could well have been and we did hear that rhetoric from Israel's

18:05 enemies in the region that they did see Israel is weakened because of the um because of the uh difference of opinion on uh judicial reform but that's part of a a a vibrant robust democracy something which they're obviously you know blissfully ignorant of it certainly appears so uh Carrie hbr asks is there any indication when iron beam will be deployed on the Gaz up front um I did see reports I did see people reporting that it's only being used again I'm I'm not an expert in that particular Arena but I certainly saw reports of it being already used this week but could just be iome and someone mislabeling it I I I don't really know enough about that particular subject sorry no problem just curious if that was well known knowledge there or not all right uh so an anonymous attendee asks what do you think of the General Secretary of the UN victim blaming Israel for the death of those who died

19:08 on the 7th of October well that was that was a statement made by the Secretary General where he basically you know gave all the usual sort of lines about you know expressing you know outrage over what happened to Israel and then in the next sentence basically said well it didn't happen in a vacuum it's because of Israel's oppression of the Palestinian for what did he say 60 years 50 years 70 years I can't remember and as one can imagine that was met with a lot of anger and Aston astonishment you know we're used to the un uh beating up on Israel but for the Secretary General to basically victim blame Israel and say that it's their fault uh was you know received a massive backlash not just from Israel but from others and we can see how much he felt it because he put out a statement uh secretary General gueras today saying my statement was taken out of context and I can't believe the way it was understood I do not uh blame Israel for what happened but I also you know basically always

20:12 equivocating always sort of trying to clarify his remarks clearly outrageous remarks to victim blame Israel for what happened on on October 7th um again just like the media was caught out and a lot of people are more so inspect about the media after what happened with the um Hospital uh the AL Hospital the Baptist Hospital in Gaza that they claimed was shot at by Israelis and hundreds of Palestinians were killed clearly now we know that's not true M that was the moment where people understood that the media parts of the media had got the story wrong had got something wrong were too quick to judge and we're quick too quick to take hamas's word and now everybody is a lot more circumspect and you can even see it in it in a certain amount of reporting perhaps this is the moment where people understand that the UN has a systemic bias uh and blind spot towards Israel perhaps even in the Jewish people um so perhaps again that not that any of these things are good

21:16 but perhaps something uh comes out of it that people will be more wary and more and will understand that there is this systemic bias and things are said about Israel and the Jewish people which clearly have never said about any other country I can't think of if any of the uh you know those who are watching this can point me in the direction to see where someone blames a massacre on the country that it happened in the citizens to which it happened I I would be I would be amazed but I I don't ever remember seeing such a statement if anyone does please copy me as well on that um on on that note so we we're talking about the misinformation and the air strikes as well uh is there any real calculation this is horrible to say it so coldly but uh you know any civilian death is obviously a tragedy but do we have any real count on how many people have died in in Gaza so far well no it's impossible for anyone really to report the only numbers that

22:18 are put out there is from the Hamas run Ministry of Health and we saw uh that you know Hamas put out outrageous numbers that are clearly not true and we've seen all these reports of you know uh Hamas you know padding the numbers in various events and also you know they they they try and Pad the scene sometimes to make sure that the image is out there someone sent me earlier that three different scenes had the same little girl um you know who who had been uh injured in three different bombings you know in in a series of days clearly you know that was part of the prop that is part of the propaganda so it's very very hard in the F of what Israel certainly there's no way for Israel to know there's no way for the International Community to know there's no way for the international media to know the only numbers that have being put out there uh are the Hamas numbers and obviously they want to P it as much as possible so there's no way that I could certainly uh give any numbers at this

23:20 point thank you for that uh Carrie hillbrand asked macron uh raised the possibility of a multilateral force is this considered a serious proposal will any countries be moving forward on this well he actually walk that state well at least his office W that state on back yes he did talk about that but then it was more sort of you know we have your back but from far back uh sort of that that's the the the walk back on that original statement clearly there's not going to be multinational forces fighting for Israel perhaps there'll be more um support in the region just like the Americans have I believe there are some British warships in the in the region perhaps to mostly I would say to make sure that it doesn't get out of hand regionally because as as I've said to you um that there is a scenario where this does become a wider Regional War even though Israel is already you know being attacked from at least five fronts I believe um but the um I I don't see any any scenario where there's

24:24 International forces coming to fight against Hamas for is of the only multinational forces that could come in at some point is some sort of peacekeeping tried that before usually fails um but clearly uh the French authorities understand that the president misspoke because they already W back that statement understood thank you uh so you did touch on this earlier but B asked do you think turkey Israeli Repro will has ended for the moment yeah uh I do think so I think the statement that came out has been attacked by all quarters uh in Israel I mean it was uh it was pretty bad at the beginning of the war there was the statement was bad but it wasn't you know too bad let's say you know the we understand the way these things go and we sort of expect certain levels from certain countries and we understand that there are certain things that certain countries can say and the original Turkish one was bad but again

25:26 it wasn't AB absolutely awful the statement made by president erdogan was considered in Israel to be a whole another level not to refer to Hamas as a terrorist organization to call it a freedom fighting organization uh justifies it in some way and certainly that was seen with uh extreme disgust uh within Israel and uh at the moment yeah uh you know that there's there's no chance of the rment moving up a level uh I think think even though Adan says that he regrets shaking nany's hands don't forget this only happened a few weeks ago um so you know it's Eran has made a decision decision quite clearly at this point that for him trying to be seen as the leader of the Muslim world trying to whip up or at least be on the side of the extremist seem to be more important than this rment with a regional uh you know power uh so it's clear what's happening at the moment but again who knows what will

26:29 happen in the year we've seen Turkish Israel relations go up and down so you know it's you can never say relations are over but certainly the rep parment we saw over the last year is is certainly going to be frozen if not walked back quite a lot here in the in the coming days and weeks thank you an anonymous attendee asks how long economically can Israel keep 300,000 reservists called up well Israel has a pretty robust economy um it's it's not just the actual cost on paper it's also the human cost one can imagine 300,000 people outside the workforce is having a major effect on the education system on Transportation sanitation uh you know Israeli soldiers literally come from every Walk of Life from every level a socioeconomic strata um so it is having a major effect it is costing the country also a lot of money because you the country has to pay for

27:32 someone when they're in the reserves um they have to you know offset what they could be losing from their work and also don't forget they have to also they're they're paying a lot of money to move 120,000 people into hotels Benny Gant today apparently told uh representatives of those who had have been internally uh displaced that this will probably be at least three months in hotels uh and you probably won't be able to return to your homes for at least a year that's what he reportedly told them so there are mounting costs even bombing uh you know sorties cost money Iron Dome costs a lot of money you know Wars are not cheap so it certainly is damaging for the economy and we saw that with one of the major credit rating um organization I think it was Moody that came out and said that it's uh its credit rating is unchanged but the forecast is certainly less than positive one can imagine after everything that's happened in the world Corona and then the Ukraine crisis and now Israel at War

28:36 for the foreseeable future is certainly uh you know going to be seen negatively e in economic terms but Israel is at the moment you know it it is able to deal with it how much longer for how many months or or longer uh certainly uh will be difficult to tell but certainly keeping 300,000 people uh you know uh near not just in the southern Border in the northern border and other places because you know we we we are stretched as I said we are fighting on many different fronts or potentially fighting on many different fronts so it's not just on the southern border but you know the claim is that they are training they are getting better at what they have to do they're getting more detailed information so again the the positive side is that apparently they'll be better prepared when they do actually go in but certainly it is economically a a very great strain uh on the on the economy absolutely uh Robert laric asks are countries including the UN SEC

29:38 Security Council pushing back enough on hamas's use of Civilian shields uh as what's causing the humanitarian crisis well for something to be addressed by the security Council someone has to bring it up uh the problem on the Security Council is you have certain countries like China like Russia which are more war on the side of Iran its proxies whether they areah Hamas so they will veto anything like that and then you have America who will veto any attacks on Israel so at the moment the the Security Council is probably not the place to deal with any of these complaints um because of that that nature because of the bad relations between America and Russia uh very specifically um so the security Council probably even you know countries will still bring these things to the security Council but whether they target one side or another at this point it's unlikely that anything significant will pass through understood thank you all right

30:41 so we've come to the close of our webinar in podcast Ashley thank you for taking time to update us this week thank you for our viewers and listeners please join us Friday at 1M Eastern for a webinar with Andy zimes and Jordan cope discussing turkey supports Hamas how to respond thank you all for joining us and I hope you have a wonderful