Israel Insider
Israel Insider with Ashley Perry
Watch on YouTube
Description
On the one-year anniversary of the most diverse coalition in Israel's history, what has it achieved and what are its chances for survival?
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 3, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:00 good afternoon and welcome to the middle east forums webinar and podcast series israel insider with ashley perry i'm stacy roman and i will be moderating this discussion today we're pleased to have mr ashley perry advisor to the middle east middle east forum's israel office join us here each wednesday at 3 p.m eastern to update us on all the events going on in israel mr perry will be giving us a briefing for 15 minutes then open it up for questions should you wish to ask a question please use the q a box located at the bottom of your screen to type your question now with no further ado i'll turn the discussion over to mr ashley perry thank you very much stacey and good evening from israel for some weeks now we've talked about the possible dissolution or breakup of this coalition the coalition that was uh exactly one year old now this uh remarkably wide and broad coalition for the first time involving an arab party involving parties from the far left to arguably the far right and many others uh in between um most parties that has
1:05 ever been in the government been caught by very many in the media commentators as the grand experiment the big experiment of israeli politics because as i said there's a lot of unique elements to it and it has survived a year much to the detriment of the opposition who believed that it would only last for months maybe six months but it has lasted a year but now the question is how much longer can it last and it now seems like at least as i've been predicting uh for the last few weeks that we're not talking anymore certainly not in years and probably not in many months uh maybe weeks possibly days um one of the leaders of uh in the put out a cryptic or not so cryptic tweet today says this coalition only has days left until the end of the week prepare for a surprise soon now last time
2:08 they were talking about surprises when he did silman of the yamina party left um you know an already very tenuous government of 61 then went down to 60 and it hasn't really been able to do too much in the committee has done quite a lot at the government level but uh where they don't need to you know to have a vote but in the knesset they haven't been able to achieve much this week uh really on the major issues the coalition really uh failed on monday which was a real sort of moment in israeli politics uh you had this law that has been passed every five years since 1967 since israel liberated the territories judea and samaria some called the west bank um there's been a law to ensure that israelis who live over the green line are under israeli civil and criminal uh um and every five years this law has been passed it's a consensus law from
3:10 the left to the right but he came up to vote on monday get on so the justice minister was pushing it and it should be a consensus issue it should get 90 to 100 you know votes for it as it you know has done many times in the past especially when the opposition is you know considers itself a right-wing religious uh that's where uh you know let's just say they get the largest percentages of their votes um they're obviously right-wing religio not necessarily religious because the majority of israelis here live over the green line contrary to popular belief are actually not um but there's is a very high percentage of religious voters uh a large percentage of ultra-orthodox voters and certainly a very high percentage of right-wing voters so this is really the face of those parties that sit in the opposition one would think that they would support it but not in this political climate they actually fought against it now what does that mean um it's not necessarily it depends
4:14 who you ask but it's not necessarily insignificant law if this law does not pass by july 1st all those israelis who live over the green line will no longer be under israeli law anymore what that means is that they won't have things like health care services they won't be under the criminal justice system of israel they'll be under the same civil um military administration as the palestinians there uh they won't be able to vote which is uh you would think would be the main reason why the right-wing religious bloc was supported and as avigdor lieberman the finance minister who lives in nokidim in the area over the green line said officially after july 1st he will not be able to serve as finance minister and bethel sumatras the leader of the religious zionist party would not be able to serve as a member of canesa now i haven't looked into the law myself but and it could be that it's a threat but i'm assumed that you wouldn't say it if there was no basis to it so
5:16 in theory at least we could be looking at in others at 22 23 days uh you know really for hundreds of thousands of israelis who live the green light their lives will change they won't uh be called up to serve in the army that could uh uh hurt israel's security they won't be able to seek health care as i said who knows that could harm people's health or worse they won't pay taxes uh they won't be under israel's civil jurisdiction the police the israeli police will have no authority over them i mean it could be a real mess and for what for for politic for politics basically you know that's what the coalition will have charged the opposition uh has argued that anything that brings down this what they claim is illegitimate or left-wing or islamist loving or friendly government is worth its well uh i'm not sure if they'll be uh saying that when there's more and more anger uh getting to july 1st because certainly there is a certain amount of anger if even if many people israelis who live over the green
6:19 line may agree that this government should be replaced they certainly don't want to see all their rights being abrogated because of uh politics because obviously the vote itself won't mean the government has fallen gideon said as i said the justice minister who pushed this did say that this is a do or die legislation if the government is not able to pass this he'll have to consider other options uh and consider as a described at the beginning that this experiment quote unquote has failed uh interestingly enough i mean it did it did fail not only did he did sillman uh the renegade amina mk uh she actually didn't vote one way or another she left the plenum and didn't vote but uh uh two members of knesset and the coalition uh merits is awabi and um uh voted against it we've talked about those two as very as as potential renegades um we saw that zohabi left the coalition and then returned after having discussions with lapid she
7:22 claims that lapid the foreign minister or alternate prime minister who's very much involved in in many of the sort of coalition issues uh she claims that lapid allowed her to vote according to her conscience lepid's office denied this saying that it would be ridiculous if we allowed every mk to vote how they want that's just simply not the way coalitions work there has to be some level of coalition discipline or nothing ever gets done um but so far she has on all the major issues since she threatened and returned to coalition she has not voted uh with the coalition so that law did not pass uh it's going to be brought up again it can be brought up again it's not under because it's an emergency law it's not brought it's not under the same rules that usually if a law fails it's it can't be brought up for a number of months um because it's an emergency law it can be brought up as early as next week and gidon has decided to give it at least until next week to see uh if it can pass remains to be seen whether there's going
8:23 to be pressure on the opposition to either vote for or at least not vote against there's already certain leaders in judea and samaria who are basically saying you know let's put politics aside this is very important do not act against your own interests and your own ideologies so we'll see how how that goes but um gideon sahu said that this will be a test for him uh has said that he's prepared to give at least another week today uh there was even more you know one would call crazy scenes where uh opposition was actually the three laws to raise the minimum uh hourly payment uh actually by a third which is quite a lot and finance minister peter lehmann says it's too much it can hurt small businesses etc etc there were three almost identical uh brought through the knesset today uh two from the opposition one from a labor uh member of knesset who actually in the end decided not to attend hero vote
9:27 all of the three laws passed um with relatively low attendance but there was a big debate exactly how it be voted many on the left wanted to vote for it there was big arguments whether they would vote for the laws whether some others would vote against whether they would leave in the end it was agreed they would just not attend the vast majority i think there was only three or four coalition mk's including prime minister bennett who voted against and all all three laws passed but it show what it does show most importantly is the coalition is simply not working not only at this point are there individuals who can threaten the coalition we've also mikhail bhutan who we spoke about also in recent weeks has come back with his demands it shows that not just any average member of knesset can threaten this government the parties are simply not getting their people in order what manso abbas of the islamist iran party has said and as we know as we've
10:29 spoken about mansour is very keen on this government to continue he's been really a voice of reason he's tried to keep his people in in check so far uh this week he certainly failed uh he he has called for her name uh to resign his his position he says you should you know learn from this experience we haven't got there yet and also annam himself is a very popular figure and of a powerful figure within uh so it remains to be seen whether even has that but he's basically said he's challenged not just himself but all the coalition leaders by saying let's give it to the end of the month all of us are responsible for the members of knesset in our party we all have to make sure that we get our renegades in order and as i've said he has at least one if not uh two or maybe three um merits obviously have their problems yamina potentially there's been a lot of uh talk about nia could be the next member of yamina to to quit the coalition move across which
11:31 would uh you know then basically give 61 to the opposition which means that they would then have the numbers to pass a law to disperse the knesset or bahrain that he's in negotiations with the liquid but he is considering um different scenarios interestingly enough the one threat uh that the coalition is trying to press ahead uh with gideon sales law for as i said for judo and samaria next week is the threat of um just as they did previously to uh declare it silman a renegade official renegade uh mk are no longer part of yamina now that has been called the sort of nuclear uh uh uh you know decision um and it's even been compared to sort of mad mutually assured describe destruction if they declare her as um as a renegade mk then she can basically vote as she wants but she will not be
12:35 able to run in the next elections under an existing list but the idea is that they haven't so far is because they thought that maybe they could get her to vote on some issues particularly the budgets now a bitter liebmann finance minister said that he's put budget discussions uh he's frozen them at the request of uh prime minister bennett which shows that that sort of nuclear option is no longer really relevant and it's not a million miles away from declaring her also renegade mk but that basically puts her out and and shows that there's no reason particularly why they should rely on her anymore this uh this week she showed her colors even though every other important vote she abstained or didn't turn up uh on one of the more important pieces of legislation to try and get matanka hana as a minister of religious affairs we know he he quit to gain his place back in the knesset at the uh at the expense of an mk who they thought was tottering and maybe could go across the opposition well they have to pass
13:38 legislation to get him back in as minister at the moment he's deputy minister which doesn't require um legislation well if well that that law was put up to the knesset and it did not pass and idid silman remarkably voted out of all the laws she should uh vote against she voted against that one and got a lot of applause and applause uh from her sort of new pals uh in the opposition so it's uh the idea that this government can go on for a long time is probably most most players would look at it and say it's not going to last that much longer it could it struggle to the end of the month and then wait out the summer recess and then the jewish holidays etc it is possible but there's a lot of people are starting to look at that september date again for elections uh manso abbas has really laid down a marker by saying that uh you know he he wants to see in the next few weeks how it works out gideon saw me not even give it that long if the law for judo and falls again next week he may have then
14:43 make his own decision it could be near will have made his decision by then near orbach as we know in a electrocuted are very much coordinating their moves um so they really are and again you know we think about even the left-wing uh members of merits and and and uh and arm and it's all important who does decide to go first because if it's right-wing then the premiership uh reverts to yale appeared on the past the passage of the lord disposal of the knesset if it is left-wing members of the uh the knesset of israel or merits that ensure the falling of this government then naftali bennett will remain prime minister until the new one is appointed and as we saw uh during the last batch of elections that could be not just a few months it could even be a couple of years so even if this government is tottering even if it is seeing out its last few days last few weeks perhaps at best few months uh exactly how it falls is also
15:45 important and plays very much into the consideration of many of the parties and its leaders and with that i'm happy to answer any questions on this or any other issues all right thank you so much uh so on the last point you just made uh east simone's asked does the average voter think he is fairly representative well we you know i i think i think we've spoken about this in in the past and israel has a very highly or some might argue over representative system as opposed to the american the australian the canadian the british system which is first past the post when you vote in a particular constituency or area if you vote for the losing candidate your your votes get thrown away in israel maybe votes get thrown away unless you vote for a party it doesn't pass the threshold which is uh i think 3.25 or 75 i can't remember then your vote will count you will be represented and look you know in the knesset you
16:49 have uh representatives from the arab you know even within our society of the communists you have the nationalists you have the islamists then you have everything from the far left to the far right center parties religious parties ultra orthodox parties um and they're all represented so i would say that the over overwhelming majority of israeli voters do feel represented do they feel satisfied with israeli politics no i'm sure the majority of israeli israeli is not happy about the situation according to polls most would rather not go to new elections they would prefer either the current government to continue or perhaps go straight to an alternate government israelis are dissatisfied they're fed up with elections we've had what is it for in the last few years and according to the polls we could have um deadlock even if we did go for new elections which you know with
17:51 all the issues that israel is facing with the rising uh cost of living with defensive challenges on on all borders and iran diplomatic issues uh issues of you know the cost of land and property there are so many issues which israelis just want want to resolve and a non-functioning knesset and non-functioning government constant elections are certainly not going to give them that thank you uh michael marcus asked her comments i always thought that the opposition in the parliamentary system was actually called the loyal opposition which infers that while they may have differing positions from the government on many issues the bottom line is they should operate in the best interests of the country rather than having to bring down the government as its prime motivating force can you please comment well i i mean i personally would agree with that you know and opposition you know that there's the opposition the the opposition in israel's line is that our
18:53 sole responsibility is to oppose everything the government does even if we agree with it 100 percent our role is to uh fell this government to make sure it does not continue and to give us a chance to return to power now i agree personally with the person who wrote that that's not necessarily the wrong opposition you're an elected official you make uh you make a vow an oath to serve the public you do not make a vow or oath to serve opposing everything the government does i agree that there are some things which should be above that especially when there are boilerplate issues something like that the judeo and samara and by the way i am hearing a certain amount of dissatisfaction from residents of judea and samaria and i if this does fall and july 1st comes round and suddenly some of these rights are abrogated i think the right-wing religious parties may start to suffer may start to feel okay you know we agree with bringing down the government but we
19:56 don't agree with abrogating our rights with turning against us we're standing against the settlements so i think if it is actualized and i don't really see how good on sales law bringing the law next week is going to change anything if this is allowed to uh expire this law and things on the ground actually do change um then i think there may be a certain uh number of people who may turn against uh the opposition who are who are uh for this but israeli politics as you know all those who who hear this weekly briefing uh one no has become extremely divisive uh where all parts of the knesset are voting against their ideology against what they stand for in the name of coalitional opposition discipline um there's always a certain amount of opposition coalition discipline it happens every single commissar every parliament around the world but the point where we've got to today in israel is is really an extreme
20:59 example of that and it's certainly not helpful because if the government were to become the opposition the opposition were to become the government uh perhaps the exact reverse would happen and again we would just have an opposition standing against the government and government standing against the opposition with very little work bipartisan here we don't really just have two parties you can't quote bipartisan multi-parties and whatever you want to call it uh but we wouldn't have much cooperation across the r which is absolutely necessary in in any absolutely so going back to that martin sternberg asks uh for clarification will jews living over the green line lose their israeli citizenship if the law extension doesn't pass well first of all it's not just jews there are non-jews who live over the green island any israeli it's it's not about your religion it's not about your people it's about your nationality your citizenship if you're an israeli citizen you live over the green line because israel hasn't it's a very matter because there are no other
22:02 examples around the world but israel as we know has never uh you know portioned sovereignty but they have allowed it their citizens to live over the green line and to do that they had to create a framework to make sure that they were under israeli law even if they lived outside of the sovereign state of israel no israeli will lose their citizenship if an israeli wants to go and live in america or brazil or india if it is they'll still have their citizenship but they will not be under the laws of the state of israel they won't have to pay taxes they won't have to serve in the army they won't be able to run for office for example uh so maybe a victor liebmann's threat perhaps is true if he'll live outside the boundaries of the state of israel according to the laws of the state of israel you cannot vote israel doesn't have overseas voting you have to physically be in israel at the time of voting to vote uh even if you're on holiday uh it's a diplomats there's an exception for diplomats but
23:04 so israelis who live over the green line effectively will live outside the boundaries do live outside of the boundaries of the state of israel so they will not be able to vote they will not be able to hold office so it could be quite a major have a major impact on hundreds of thousands of israelis but none of them will lose their citizenship thank you for that clarification uh carrie hillebrand asks uh you did mention that obviously some of the settlers are quite upset about this but why isn't there a serious backlash among settlers beyond the green line against likud and netanyahu in particular for torpedoing the renewal of the law it's an interesting one when the law a few weeks ago of contin before for paying for studies of those in combat units as we talked about that there was a major backlash major uh public relations and pressure groups and ngos really came out and forced the opposition to ensure that the law was
24:07 passed that's a real consensus issue um i think the reason there hasn't been a major backlash maybe there will be ahead of next week but we haven't really seen is because um many of the leaders or many of the people the residents who live over the green line vote for these parties and would vote for them again and want to see them back in government and they have been persuaded at this point that the it's for the greater good it may involve some short-term pain they've been uh sort of persuaded that this isn't a big deal because no one feels it at the moment life goes on until july 1st and then it remains to be seen what happens that's what that's why i say possibly it's the actualization of the law expiring and everything that goes along with that that may ensure that there is that backlash um but up until then uh many have been persuaded by netanyahu or smartridge the leader of two of the larger parties in the
25:11 whose voter base is right-wing and that uh the greater good is to top all this government they've been persuaded that this government is dangerous that it has an islamist party uh you know we we know that the coalition's argument is that it's netanyahu that started negotiating with ron long before anyone in the current coalition did but that's the argument that constantly gets made and that's the the argument that is bought by a lot of people so that there has been a certain backlash there has been letters written by certain municipal leaders but many of those are identified with parties in the the head of the yeshua council the the sort of ngo which brings together all the different municipalities over the green line uh it was a member of uh gideon saul's new hope party so that he could dismiss that as you know political partisanship when when he led a letter calling on the opposition to vote for the party so that wasn't taken us seriously but uh we'll see what happens next week i don't think that there'll suddenly be a lot more pressure because
26:13 as i said most people do not feel it well no one feels it yet and it could be it will take the law to expire for people to feel it for there to be some groundswell of pressure on your position to support the law thank you and eric follows up on that why wasn't this law permanent instead of every five years and who will the public blame if the jews over the great israelis over the green line lose their rights um i don't think it can i i don't know the exact uh legislation but i think because it's an emergency law it has to be um re-legislated every five years like all emergency legislation it can't be permanent um it has to be re-legislated every five years but as i said it's never become an issue before it always had massive support it was not even close in the past but uh we live as i said before we live in a very divisive political time so that's why um that's why it's
27:14 you know being held hostage to that i can't remember the second part of the why has there been no pressure i think i think i dealt with that in the question who will the public blame if they lose their rights it all depends who gives the best pr who is able to convince the public at the certainly i think the majority of people of israelis deliver the green line are not blaming the opposition at this point um certainly they haven't done themselves any favors in those waivers those who could decide between a benefit and a smart rich or a sar and a netanyahu there are those who say there are some laws some issues which should be above and i've certainly heard a lot of that but again there isn't that groundswell of blame at the moment but that could change as i said july 1st thank you and michael marcus actually has an
28:16 interesting clarification on this if the law doesn't pass does that mean that those living over the green line are disenfranchised or on election day can they travel back into israel proper to well they have nowhere to vote you have to be registered somewhere um you can't just turn up at any ballot office and vote you you you vote in the again you know i i don't think it will come to that i'm sure that uh it's just in no one's interest come election day that hundreds of thousands of israelis won't be able to vote so i'm sure no matter what the it will be it'll be resolved by uh by election day it could be that uh they'll but maybe at the same time it's passing the dispersal of knesset they'll agree they'll have some compromise towards the past this at the same time i can't imagine we get to a situation where hundreds of thousands of israelis are disenfranchised especially when uh the opposition which can make this law next week or any any day after that um you know would allow so many of its own
29:22 voters to potentially not be able to vote but practically speaking you have to turn up for the ballot that you're a ballot box uh that you're registered to and it's usually local to your place so i you know there's no way currently to resolve that fair point thank you so much all right so we have come to the close for our webinar and podcast ashley thank you again for taking time to update us this for our viewers and listeners please note that we will not be hosting a webinar on friday thank you all for joining us and i hope you have a wonderful day