MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Israel Insider

Israel Insider with Ashley Perry

Watch Israel Insider with Ashley Perry on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

What are the implications of Israel's ground operations in Gaza City?

Transcript Automatic captions

Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 16, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.

0:11 Okay. Hello. Good afternoon and welcome to the Middle East Forums weekly podcast series, Israel Insider. My name is Anaf Kalam and I will be moderating today's discussion. We are pleased to be joined today by Ashley Perry who is the adviser to the Middle East Forum's Israel office who joins us each week to give us a top overview of the current events going on in Israel. Uh Mr. Perry will speak for 15 minutes followed by a 15minute Q&A session. And if you'd like to ask a question, please feel free to use the Q&A box or the chat window. And with that, I will turn the discussion over to Mr. Ashley Perry.

0:48 Thank you very much, Ahnaf, and good evening from Israel. Um, tonight we're going to talk about uh the operation that started this week in earnest uh to conquer Gaza City um and all the uh potential uh ramifications of that. And really the question that needs asking uh or that's being asked in Israel and uh I I'll lay out the two various opinions on it is is conquering Gaza city going to be the tipping point uh the breaking point if you will uh to end this war to break Hamas to force them into a ceasefire on Israel's terms or not. Um and there are two larger large schools of thought uh with the security establishment, some in the political establishment will subscribe to one or the other. The first one is that this is the operation that will finally break Hamas's back. Um Gaza City uh at least parts of it are like

1:53 what Dia uh you know the suburb of Beirut uh that was uh stronghold is to Hamas. Um and really if you take that that's its last real stronghold from a strategic military um infrastructure point of view and also su symbolic Gaza city is obviously the capital of the Gaza Strip. It's the administrative capital. It's where Gaza set up Kamas have set up their administrative and military center since they brutally took over in 2007.

2:30 And if you uh take Gaza city, then pretty much Hamas uh are defeated largely as a body that rules has any administrative power really any military infrastructure. That's not to say there won't be fighters, there won't be pockets of resistance here, there uh and everywhere around the Gaza Strip, but as a a military infrastructure, it will be broken uh symbolically, psychologically. uh and this can be perhaps what will drive H kamas to the negotiating table and to agree to terms uh more generous to Israel. The other school of thought is that Hamas already understand that at some point it will leave Gaza city if it hasn't already started to do so. Some are worried that the 400,000 Gins who have left Gaza City, they may have kamas embedded in there. uh many have gone by car and haven't really been checked uh so um you know coherently perhaps even and some there is worry

3:34 among some that even some of the hostages have already been removed from uh Gaza city they will set up base in some of the refugee camps that they're allowed to uh uh create or some of the refugee camps in the center of the strip that have yet to be uh fully conquered and live to fight another day and Israel will basically fight pockets of resistance around Gaza that will slow it down in the hope um that Israel will do this for a number of months and still Hamas will be in pretty much uh a similar situation. Obviously if they do lose Gaza city then they will be in a worse position but if they are able to regroup elsewhere they won't be defeated and that's really the point at this point in time. Gaza knows it's not Hamas knows it's not going to win a military fight. Their their only hope at this point is to hold out long enough or to try and pressure Israel into a deal that are more in line with its thinking. Um either way, as we do know uh from

4:37 comments like those made by Wititov, even President Trump, and even uh strategic affairs minister Ron Derma, that pretty much this war will have to be done by the end of the calendar year. Um and this really is where everything is going. Um, originally the plan to take Gaza was supposed to take planning for a month and then the actual military operation for a month, but it's clear a that the military planning took longer, b that the residents are not leaving as quickly as Israel would have liked, and c the military offensive itself probably will take at least a few months if we're being generous. And even then, it may not conquer every single last millimeter of Gaza City. But both Israel and Hamas are very cognizant of this time scale.

5:26 By the end of the year, we're already over halfway into September. So, we're talking about three and a half months. It will not be easy. And so, every day uh of resistance from kamas, every day that's being slowed by uh Israel works in their favor. Today, uh we heard senior IDF officials saying that they are going much slower than they wanted because of the hostages. There is there was a threat uh I think it was last week the kamas said that it's moving some of the hostages overground uh to into various areas of uh Gaza city to try and slow the presence or or styy the presence of Israeli soldiers and uh that uh has been admitted by some senior IDF officials and that is certainly not something that Prime Minister Netanyahu will want. Uh going back to those two schools of thoughts really the first one is that this is the operation um that will break Hamas, bring them back to the

6:28 table uh force them into a deal which is very suitable or at least meet I don't know if all of um Israel's goals but at least most of them uh that is something that Prime Minister NetO believes something that his right-hand man strategic affairs minister Ron Derma believes and various others. Um, there are people in the security and military establishment that believe the second that believe that this might not be the battle that ends the war that Hamas understand that they just have to hold out and live to fight another day and they're already starting if not their absolute retreat. Now they're starting to think about it and starting to prepare for it and even conquering Gaza City won't necessarily bring this war to an end. Um, as I said, Prime Minister NetO is banking on it. It's unsure what will happen if we do conquer Gaza and the war still going on. Kamas haven't come to the table because at the end of the day, this war will end with some

7:31 sort of agreement. It won't end with every single Hamas soldier terrorist being killed. It will end with some sort of agreement. Both sides clearly Prime Minister Netanyo and those around him in fact the whole you know the government itself major parts of it and kamas both want an end to this war but the difference is they both want it on their own conditions uh we know Israel's five conditions we've talked about them kamas basically have agreed that they will not be in power but they would they want some sort of technocratic government but if they are allowed to remain armed which is a key uh part of Israel's demands that the Gaza Strip be or Hamas be dearmed. Um, you know, regardless of who is officially in office, if Hamas still retains the ability to hold on to its weapons, then basically it will be in power, if not in name, at least really behind the scenes

8:34 until such time as they decide once again to retake power brutally militarily as they did in 2007. So that is why for Israel it's very important that there's some sort of demilitarization disarmament of Hamas and and the strip. But that's something that Hamas have said that they will never be prepared to do. And if you believe Hamas's Bellico statements they will never surrender. So again, we go back to that point where it's going to be very very hard to bridge the two sides to get together to a point which will be I wouldn't say satisfactory, but to a point where Israel can say that it's one and Hamas can at least walk away with some of its sort of uh pride intact. That's what people that's what the negotiators are hoping for. I don't know how you bridge those gaps. Uh, Israel is hoping by military power, by taking Gaza city with such force that it breaks Kamas's will to continue fighting. Um, tension between the military

9:38 establishment, the political establishment isn't just about the potential to end the war. It's also prioritizing the goals of the war. As we know for quite a while, there are many in the uh military establishment, including chief of staff uh El Zamir, uh that there is some sort of a deal on the table. Perhaps it's time to take it or at least uh improve or at least negotiate some sort of improvement. But at the end of the day, if we're going to go in, we h to Gaza City, we have to take into account uh the hostages. And apparently there was some tensions with uh meetings with the political establishment led by Prime Minister Netanyo who basically according to some in the the military establishment has decided that once and for all it's decided to prioritize defeating Kamas over um freeing rescuing uh the hostages and and uh according to various analysts and sources um uh the chief of staff basically called on the prime minister

10:40 to announce once and for all either to get rid of the goal of freeing the hostages or at least uh be open with the public that it's no longer the priority it used to be. Uh so there is certainly a continuation of these tensions between the military security establishment and uh the political establishment. Uh we had a lot of uh other discomfort within the uh uh the government. we're hearing uh not openly but behind the scenes um that this war especially now with this latest operation is taking its toll on Israel's diplomatic status. We know about these uh threats to um recognize a Palestinian state. We hear about these threats to uh push Israel out of sporting events, out of the Eurovvision Song Contest, out of sanctions by the EU uh and various other things, even calls uh from Spain, I think it was today, uh for Israel to be thrown out of the UN.

11:40 Now, that's not going to happen anytime soon, but the it's it's there are some voices in the government with with serious discomfort about the way that uh Israel's uh political diplomatic situation uh internationally is is going which kind of led to I would argue one of the most shocking statements in quite a while that was made by Prime Minister Netanyo. Prime Minister Net Netanyao again that everyone will concede whether you are a friend or foe that he is a great communicator. He understands very carefully what he's saying and everything uh that goes out is poured over. He mentioned this week during a speech that Israel has to start thinking of itself as something akin to ancient Athens and superpart which basically means a country to a certain extent isolated more um and basically has to rely on its own.

12:37 This caused great concernation uh around Israel especially in the markets which dropped which plummeted and we saw the next day Prime Minister Netanyahu had to do a lot of damage control. He either wasn't didn't fully understand the the nature of the way these comments would be taken um or he understood that perhaps it doesn't play as well into his base that he thought it would. Um and basically he walked back the comments. the original comments were about general isolation in Israel uh isolation uh around the world. Um and basically he tried to walk them back by saying well it's actually only a military armorament isolation. There are countries which will which are and in the future even more will not supply Israel with the necessary arms and military um wares to fight battles. So it has to have more of an independent and internal uh armament industry. That's something by the way which has been a great discussion for

13:39 decades in Israel whether Israel should move towards more independent and sovereign defense industry or it should still be reliant on others like the US, Germany and others. Um and NetO perhaps out of a need for damage control basically uh pushed towards that even though it's something which a lot of people in the defense establishment are realizing after two years of war and the threat of not supplying certain um hardware for Israel's uh army etc that perhaps Israel needs at this point to take it more seriously and to think how it can be less reliant on the international community. Either way, it is a comment which was jumped upon by all opponents of Netanyahu and even some friends of Netanyahu that Israel cannot afford to be a Sparta. Israel cannot uh afford to be completely isolated as it was as it as it seems to be moving towards. But it is an understanding even that Netanyahu understands that Israel's diplomatic situation is not good. Of

14:42 course, uh the prime minister tried to uh deflect and blame and he actually um uh specifically mentioned two countries. He said Qatar and China are really at the forefront of trying to delegitimize Israel, attack Israel uh around the world. He also talked about western countries and uh the fact that they seem to be moving against Israel almost purely for domestic reasons because of growing Islamist populations within them really trying to say you know it's nothing to do with anything we've done these are measures these are sentiments which would happen anyway and we just have to care about ourselves uh at this point finally the fallout from the uh now what seems almost uh uh likely to be the failed Qatar operation against the senior uh kamas abroad leadership. Um what we definitely have heard over the last few days is more and more discomfort not just from Israel's I would say if not necessarily enemies

15:47 opponents in in the in the region led by Qatar but even its friends in the region to a certain extent you know the Saudis Egyptians etc that uh Israel overreached here um there is this concept in the Middle East of the strong horse of backing the strong horse whoever shows that it's the strong horse in the region will be backed will be uh you know supported will will basically you know everyone wants to come in behind it but perhaps there is a feeling that Israel has become too much of a strong horse and perhaps needs to be knocked down a little bit and this is perhaps where some of even Israel's allies and potential allies in the region are today on the uh potential of restarting the negotiations uh Ron Durma uh reportedly is now in London tonight meeting with Witk off um the the US's negotiator um and apparently there are Qataris in town as we know President Trump is in London so that uh is perhaps why Witov is there and why Durham has gone to meet

16:50 with him but at this point it doesn't seem like negotiations can get back on track. The first thing that needs to be looked at and this is apparently what the goal of these meetings is, is not necessarily to get back towards negotiations is to bring Qatar back in. Uh there's a feeling in America that not only have Qatar got to be brought back in, but there needs to be some sort of gesture towards Qatar from Israel to make up for what they uh described as uh you know obscene heenous um you know attack on on Qatar's sovereignty and uh it seems like the Americans are bringing a message and others that Israel has to make um some sort of a gesture to Qatar at this point to even bring them back to the point where they want to be the negotiators even before we start talking about the restarting of negotiations with Kamas. So it seems that we're that's where we are at the moment. We'll have to see if Israel does do this gesture, if it agrees to it, because if

17:54 not, it seems like Qatar will not be pushing uh for negotiations to restart. And perhaps that leads us uh to a place where uh it'll be more more difficult even if Israel does put pressure on Hamas that some serious negotiations could take place. Uh but these things can change pretty quickly and it all depends on the pressure going back to my first points on the pressure that Israel is putting on Hamas in Gaza and uh depending on which school of thought that you subscribe to whether Gaza city is the da of kamas whether this is the final do or die kamas are coming to the fight and this is it for them or whether you subscribe to the fact uh to the uh to the uh idea that kamas are going to uh leave Gaza City, are going to try and fight another day, are going to try and hold off Israel as much as possible until 2026 when it seems like the Trump administration will lose patience and force Israel into some sort

18:56 of a deal. So, uh that's what where we appear to be as of now. And with that, I'm happy to answer any questions. Right. Thank you very much. I will uh begin with a question from Carrie Hillbrand who asks to what extent is Israel cooperating or aiding Gazin clans in addition to Abu Shabab as alternatives to Hamas? Are they having any success in pushing back Hamas and exerting a degree of control? I mean, they've been doing this for well over a year, trying to reach out to local clans or groups uh within Gaza.

19:36 They've had success in the in the southern Rafa area with the Al-Shabaab clan. Uh there is talk that they're having a certain amount of success in Gaza, but at the moment it doesn't seem um to be working to the point that Hamas are any way dissuaded from this. Hamas are very much still in power in areas of Gaza city. They are stopping and preventing a lot of those hundreds of thousands remaining in Gaza from leaving Gaza. They're still very much in control. So if there is a plan and I'm sure there is and I'm sure there are discussions with groups and clans that uh you know uh or opponents to uh to Hamas at this point in time it doesn't it's not having the greatest of success but perhaps it will grow as uh Israel encroaches more and more more territory.

20:27 Perhaps there are clans who are saying, "Well, you know, we want to hold on to a certain amount of territory and we're going to have to fight for this and we're going to have to fight kamas for this." So, at the moment, it's probably in its infancy in Gaza City, but uh perhaps as Israel takes more and more of the city militarily, perhaps that will All right, thank you. Um, next question comes from Eric Sulkov, who asks, "What does a win in Gaza City look like?" And do you think it will end the war?

21:00 Well, a way taking taking Gaza City is basically conquering it to the point where the IDF holds and occupies I wouldn't say every single corner, every single inch, but pretty much controls uh Gaza City. Again, this is not normative warfare. This is not the warfare for, you know, the last few hundred years. This is urban warfare against a terrorist entity, a guerilla uh movement even to a certain extent at this point. Some say that they're waiting for Israel, the IDF to go further further in and then they'll pop out from their tunnels, try and kidnap a soldier.

21:35 Apparently, that's something the IDF is extremely worried about tonight, that they could uh uh kidnap uh some soldiers uh as they move further and further into Gaza City. Um but I I don't know which school of thought I subscribed to. Um we have been told many times uh over the last two years that if this particular operation whether it was Rafa or others this will be the one that will end the war this is the final fight against Hamas. We have been told that before and each time it simply wasn't true. So I'm I'm a little bit skeptical personally about it. I hope it's true. I hope that um that really this does put as much pressure on kamas as possible and that they will I don't see any question of them surrendering in the old-fashioned uh sort of sense of the word but uh understanding that they are defeated in as much as they have to uh agree to a negotiated deal very much towards Israel's terms not necessarily every

22:38 single one but towards Israel's terms and I've talked previously about how some of the terms disarmament can be and and and uh sending some of the uh kamas leaders into exile, they could be symbolic. Uh Israel is not going to collect every single weapon from Kamas and certainly not every single weapon in in the Gaza Strip. So the idea of a completely de demilitarized Gaza Strip just simply isn't going to happen. Um so the question is exactly what that looks like and if it's something that kamas can live with maybe to fight another day maybe the leaders are understanding that this is it they defeated so at least they should leave with their lives perhaps to fight another day or perhaps just to live you know a life of luxury and dha like some of the kamas abroad leaders do. Um so we'll have to wait and see exactly uh what that looks like.

23:32 Thank you. Uh Schmill asks, "What comes next?" That is assuming the Israelis win militarily, what government will follow uh that will be at peace with Israel. Ah well those are two different things. Uh what comes next is very hard to understand because there are a lot of discussions on it and it's very unfair to say that the Israeli government haven't thought about the day after. They have they've been in discussions with various entities uh around the world whether it's the US or whether it's regional partners. It has certainly become more difficult as of late. Um but it it would need an end of war. It would need an end of Hamas. No Arab powers are going to send troops into a strip uh while Hamas are still there. They certainly don't want that. Um and there is a feeling that you know Israel, you broke it. You you smashed the place up.

24:28 you have to fix it yourself. So it's it's very hard uh to see what exactly the day after plan and to say that it will be peace with Israel. Again it all depends how that looks. Will it be a technocratic government? Will it be the personal authority something the Israeli government have been at pains to say that they do not accept? uh which makes it more difficult even though it's seen as understandable from an Israeli perspective with all the problems and challenges the PA itself have with corruption with its own uh hatred of Israel etc etc. Um, so it's it's really unclear what the day after will look like. And even, you know, even if we do have some sort of negotiated surrender, I again, I don't think we'll see something that looks like surrender in the classical sense, but something where Hamas will agree to terms that are amanable towards Israel. Um, it's hard to see that. So it's I would say even harder to see what will be the day after at this point at least. Maybe in the

25:32 next few weeks and few months we'll get a better idea but at this point in time it's very very hard to see what that could look like. All right. Thank you. Uh Mark Wiger would like to ask uh what does the polling in Israel say about where the people of Israel are on this operation? Like I think we've discussed this before, but uh as in all polling in Israel, it depends how the questions are asked, who's asking the questions. If you ask a you know a news channel which is very supportive, Netanyahu would be very supportive of the operation. If you um if if it's one of the uh media um that's antagonistic towards this government, then it will be the opposite way. I think it's relatively e evenly split and it all depends how the question is asked. If it's do you want to release the hostages, you'll get a very high uh percentage of those who do.

26:30 If you then ask do you should we um free the hostages which will mean an end of war, Hamas remaining in power, then it's a lot lower. Um there hasn't been too much explanation exactly how this operation will end the war. There is there are the slogans that this operation will end the war, but it's it hasn't really been explained. And let's not forget that there are tens of thousands of Israeli civilians who have been called up to the reserves who are now fighting. And again, even for them, it's not clear. They've heard this before, this is going to be the last time you're called up. They've been told on on a few occasions in the past because this is the operation that's going to end the war. And there was high levels of motivation. each time you uh state that again and again the motivation will uh will go down a little bit. Um it's it's very hard to know um what the support is for this operation.

27:23 Yes, that I would say if you just asked the simple question uh do you support the defeat of kamas large majority uh would come out in favor but what is the cost and exactly uh you know how are you going to do it and is this going to lead to the defeat of kamas? Do people believe that? These are all questions that at the moment play into all the different variables. So it's very very hard to uh to understand. But pretty much on all these issues, the country is largely split. If you're with this particular government, you're going to be more supportive. If you're against, then you're going to be less supportive.

27:58 And while the opposition parties appear to have a slight not just a slight a majority in polls. So the country probably will will is let's just say more antagonistic towards the government. Um there are elements who are voting or will say that they're voting for the opposition who are right-wing whether it's supporters of Bennett, supporters of Liberman or others. Um so it's it's it's very hard at the moment. It's very very complex and and really does change from day to day and changes on the variables and the way you answer it. So that's a very long- winded way of saying it's very difficult to tell what what the levels of support for this operation are. But I would say it's as as far as I can read, it's not necessarily straight down the middle, but not a million miles away All right, many thanks. We have uh unfortunately reached the end of our podcast. I want to thank you again for taking the time to update us this week.

28:56 Absolutely. Thank you. Of course. Now, for our viewers and listeners, please be on the lookout in your email inboxes for your uh weekly podcast offerings email over the weekend. As always, I thank you all for your viewership and your participation, and I hope you all have a wonderful day.