MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Israel Insider

Israel Insider with Ashley Perry | April 23, 2025

Watch Israel Insider with Ashley Perry | April 23, 2025 on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

There are increasing differences between President Donald Trump and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Iran. Is Israel's window of opportunity to act against the Islamic Republic closing?

Ashley Perry is an advisor to the Middle East Forum’s Israel office. He served as adviser to Israel's minister of foreign affairs and deputy prime minister in 2009-15, and has also worked with Israel's Ministers of Intelligence, Agriculture and Rural Development, Energy, Water and Infrastructure, Defense, Tourism, Internal Security, and Immigrant Absorption and as an advisor to The Negev Forum. Originally from the U.K., he moved to Israel in 2001. He holds a B.A. from University College London and an M.A. from Reichman University (IDC Herzliya).

Transcript Automatic captions

Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 20, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.

0:08 Hello, good afternoon and welcome to the Middle East Forums weekly podcast series, Israel Insider. My name is Anafav Kalam and I will be moderating today's discussion. We are pleased to be joined today by Ashley Perry who is the adviser to the Middle East Forums Israel office who joins us each week to give us a brief overview of the top events currently going on in Israel. Mr. Perry will speak for 15 minutes followed by a 15minute Q&A session from the audience. And if you would like to ask a question, please feel free to use the Q&A box located at the bottom of your screen to type your question. And with that, I will turn the discussion over to Mr.

0:49 Ashley Perry. Thank you very much, Ahnaf. And good evening from Israel. Um, for those who don't know, tonight and tomorrow is Yong Hashawa, Israel's Holocaust Remembrance Day. So a lot of things shut down tonight and tomorrow. Places of leisure, uh even the major television channels are only showing Holocaust related uh programming. It's a day of greatity uh here in Israel. Um just wanted to recognize that at the beginning. Um but going on to sort of what's made the news in the last week.

1:29 um the most um arena let's say on a more sort of wider scale is the whole issue with Iran the negotiations uh the window of opportunity and I'd like to start there um Israel has felt or many in Israel has felt that there is no greater window of opportunity to attack Iran's nuclear weapons uh program than is currently There are four major reasons why. First of all, uh as we know over the last what is it 18 months, Israel's uh Iran, sorry, the Islamic Republic of Iran's ring of fire, so-called axes of resistance has pretty much crumbled or been destroyed. Talking about Hamas,ah, uh Assad, which was a very important aspect. Even if Assad and the old Syrian regime didn't necessarily fight Israel, it was certainly a conduit forbalah and a way for Iran to uh get

2:33 arms, money, funding, support, whatever it is to the Shiite proxies in Iraq. Uh and the Houthis who are taking uh quite a beating uh night after night by the US. um since o the second reason is since October 2024 when Israel struck um a lot of sites in Iran uh to do with Iran's ballistic missile program but most importantly took out a lot of the uh defenses around uh areas associated with Iran's nuclear weapons uh program uh specifically the S300's which was a a Russian made um or or developed uh defensive system that Iran got that for many years Israel was worried about but it managed to pretty much enter and leave Iran pretty much without any uh they were detected but they weren't no one was shot down and Israel showed Iran that it can attack anywhere um and

3:38 taking out pretty much uh its major defensive uh weapons and leaving it as some would naked uh if it or should need to return or want to return to attack. Uh another reason uh is that uh as I said Assad's gone and the Shiite proxies have been quelled to a certain extent. So Israel would have to a certain extent um a not a free run on Iran but certainly a freer. Um the third reason is that Iran hasn't been as weak economically in quite a long time. if ever. Um, their currency is just crashing by the day.

4:20 Economically, it's in real trouble and getting worse with the potential snapback uh sanctions in October. more and more sanctions being placed on Iran uh by the week uh by the u Trump administration and obviously we know internally there is a lot of anger against the regime because perhaps of the funding of its proxies because of the way they've run the country the the the you know the jack boot they've got uh on the heads of many Iranians the the protests uh because of the uh woman who was killed when she wasn't wearing her um it just shows a country really socially uh extremely weak at least in relation to the regime. But finally, perhaps arguably most importantly is you have one of the most Israel supportive um administrations in history. U but with that it's a double-edged sword and I'll explain why.

5:21 when uh the Obama administration started negotiating with Iran with other countries obviously um the P5+1 uh there was um a way for NetO to try and sort of influence from the outside uh negotiations. He used the Republican party uh on the hill uh to attack Obama. We remember that he got that invitation to speak in the joint in the uh in Congress and he was able to get quite a lot of support across uh the US largely through uh his Republican allies. If he he has BB understands that he's restrained, he can't go against Trump.

6:05 First of all, because as we've seen, those who go publicly against Trump as BB did against Obama uh would obviously get received quite a backlash as Zalinski and some others have received. You do not go out publicly against uh President Trump, perhaps even privately, and there's no real plan B. He can't rally Republicans. He won't find much sympathy amongst Democrats. So really um there's a high level of constraint here. Um the only possible um tactic for for uh Netanyahu at this point is to try and influence uh pretty much from the outside. And we did see um some of this when uh Ron Durma, the strategic affairs uh minister who is pretty much the right hand of Netanyao and the Mossad uh head David Barer were dispatched to try and influence Whitkov who is the lead negotiator with Iran

7:09 ahead of the second round of negotiations. We know that the third round, I believe, will take place in Oman on Sunday. So far, the negotiations from both sid are sounding positive. We obviously don't know exactly what's going on, but both sides are talking positively uh about the negotiations themselves, even though the Iranians are obviously unhappy about the sanctions um that are being placed on them uh during these talks themselves. Um there is a major concern um in Israel about Wititov himself. Uh there seems to be some confusion exactly what he's doing, whether he knows uh the Iran nuclear file well enough. Let's put it on the table. The nuclear file is a very complicated issue. It's not just a simple military program. There are many different uh arenas and areas. uh if we go back to the JCPOA, it was a very very complicated agreement. Perhaps that's one of the uh the fallbacks of the agreement. Then Iran felt that it could

8:13 um bypass it because it was so detailed and so intricate uh you know enriching to this level but not at this amount and this that and the other and all this and um you know Wittov doesn't really have that background and there's a concern that no one really on his team has the requisite background and what we did see was a real sort of confusing fuddling of the issue uh by Witkoff where after there was a feeling that um that the US's position was that uh Iran wouldn't have a a nuclear program at all and the only option is really to not just restrain it but to completely uh uh dissolve it. Uh we did hear in an interview I can't remember who it was with some American um uh news channel where basically he said that uh Iran could enrich uranium I think it was to 3.75 which was the original limits in the JCPOA and let's not forget it was Trump himself who called it the worst

9:15 agreement in history and uh when he uh won the first elections he removed the US from the JCPO itself. So there were many uh in Israel at the highest levels who are ghass at that. Uh but it seems also in the US there were some who uh also had a major problem because we did see a more controlled press release put out the next day by Witkov saying absolutely Iran cannot have a nuclear weapons program. Uh obviously he didn't openly say he made a mistake but clearly walking back uh those remarks. what Israel is seeking and from what they're hearing from their American counterparts, it seems uh something where there's a lot of support is what's called the Libyan model. Let's not forget that Moar Gaddafi, who's obviously no longer with us after the fall of Saddam Hussein, he got very concerned that he was next in line. The West were going to attack him. So, he voluntarily gave up the nuclear his own uh nuclear weapons program. He allowed

10:18 some of it to be taken abroad and he destroyed and had other had the West destroy his nuclear weapons program. There was no containment. There was no limits. It was completely destroyed. That is what Israel would like to see. That's what the more hawkish elements in the Trump administration would like um to see. Um the Iranians have said it's a non-starter. They said that they have an absolute national right to a nuclear program. They claim that it's nothing to do with nuclear weapons. They claimed that there was a fatwa. I think it was who wrote a fatwa that it's against Islamic law to have nuclear weapons. We know that obviously that's not true. And now we see, you know, sort of on a daily event. Even the IAEA has basically said that there are so many elements of the Iranian program that are not conducive for a civilian nuclear program that you know that no one no one believes it. Um, but what is most uh worrying Israel is to put a time limit.

11:19 The Iranians are very good at procrastinating at moving negotiations on and on and on. They know that the longer it goes on, the more they'll be able to hide their nuclear program, as they're doing now, deeper and deeper underground, spread it further around the nation. uh perhaps restore some sort of defense uh mechanisms, shields, uh missile programs, whatever it is. Uh and the longer goes on and maybe even they could delay it to a point where we get closer to the American midterms where obviously the Trump administration will be more distracted and if they lose that then perhaps they uh then then there's a problem uh you know with Congress and they won't have um the control that they do at the moment. What what Israel is saying really behind the scenes to the Americans is it's not against an agreement, but it does believe that agreement should only come after military action, not before. There is no real agreement that Iran are going to agree to which really stops uh permanently Iran's nuclear program. And

12:23 there is also a concern in in Israel as there is in other parts of the world that a military uh action itself will not completely destroy uh Iran's nuclear program. Um but perhaps a combination of the two. The disagreement they have with the Americans at the moment is you don't negotiate before military uh action. you first used military action and then you take out the only real leverage they have. Iran's only real leverage for speaking to the international community is the fact that they are close to nuclear weapons. In fact, there is a great worry that at this point Iran is doing something which they didn't do a number of years ago and really racing to try and get a relatively in in you know relative terms a small rudimentary nuclear weapon something along the lines of the North Korea model. North Korea became a nuclear power nation because they basically built a relatively rudimentary nuclear weapon. Um, and they tested it and from that moment on they

13:25 became a nuclear uh state. If Iran does that, you know, it changes everything and there is a feeling where they could do that perhaps in weeks and not the more sophisticated program that they were originally going for. not to say that they would stop their more sophisticated program, but just to run ahead to create something and then they have even greater um uh leverage. So that is also a great concern in Israel. On Gaza, there still doesn't seem to be a decision on a wider attack uh that's been brewing uh for a number of weeks now. hasn't been that massive call up of hundreds of thousands of Israeli reserves that would uh be necessary for any sort of attack on Gaza. The reserves themselves probably wouldn't go into Gaza, at least the majority of them.

14:11 They would go and protect other areas in Israel or in Judea and Samaria, the West Bank, or perhaps on the northern border because the the reserves on the whole, you know, are people who have jobs, who have families, you know, they're not the young recruits. they've been uh in the reserves perhaps for 300 plus days over the last year. So there's a feeling that they want to you know not put them on the front lines but they would need them for where the recruits would uh leave where as I said whether it's in Judea Samaria the north or the south or wherever it is. Um there seems to be also a disagreement at this point about what's going to happen with the humanitarian aid for many days if not weeks. The Israeli government has said that there will be no humanitarian aid until there's an agreement. Um but there seems to be a lot of pressure to put humanitarian back in. They there was quite a lot of humanitarian aid that came in before uh the breaking of the ceasefire. So there's no real concern about a famine at the moment, but the longer it goes on, not to say that there

15:14 will be a famine, but certainly there will be more problems. The whole issue of humanitarian aid um during the fighting is it basically replenishes Hamas's um cash reserves because as we know they steal humanitarian uh aid, they sell it, they they basically control life in the Gaza Strip as a result of it. Uh interestingly uh today there was uh a cabinet meeting about this and the government floated the idea of the IDF controlling humanitarian aid. the IDF chief of staff, the new chief of staff, Netanyahu's own choice, uh Zamir basically said, "We will not do that. I will not ask the IDF to do that." One can understand why. And uh Smatri, Pat Batalich, the finance minister and also minister in the defense ministry shot back and said, "You will do as you're told. We're the ones who direct policy.

16:07 You're the ones who enact it." So the tensions are there even when Netino gets his choice in the security apparatus. Um and these tensions are really really uh racking up at the moment due to the uh real uh uh sort of um major event of the week which was Ronin Bar the current Shinbet leader uh uh sent an affidavit to the Supreme Court in Israel. Supreme Court at the moment is deciding what to do about this crisis between bar and nine. Netanyao fired one bar uh and uh some NOS's took the government to court and said he has no right to fire one bar at least not without a whole process due process and he can't do so u because of political reasons there have to be professional reasons. um Roninbar the really the the the the last minute uh sent this affidavit along with a secret

17:10 annex where he showed proof for what he said and really it was a a major major event in Israel because he accused the prime minister of basically trying to use the Shimet for political reasons whether it's to postpone his testimony in his criminal trials criminal trials or act against uh anti-government protesters or some other things that he accused and he also said that uh bar's firing was only a result of uh the shimet being asked to look into uh what's being called kataggate that people very close to neto were paid by kataggate perhaps proxies um and this is an an ongoing investigation and that was according to bar and his supporters that was the moment when decided to fire him and that is is extremely problematic by himself. He said he probably will resign in the middle of May. But at the moment it the Supreme Court now doesn't just have to

18:12 rule on a procedural issue. Does the government have the right to fire uh the Shimbet? Does it have to go through a certain procedure? Does he he have to annunciate exactly what the issues are, whether it's political or or whatever? But now um with with these accusations the Supreme Court now has to look into is Bar correct is Netanyahu correct? Obviously the government will have a right of response and they'll have to try and paint a picture of what they believe is happening and what they can do about it. Uh this could really create a constitutional crisis because if they decide that the government does not have the right to fire bar, I don't necessarily see that happening u but the government will ignore that. um bar himself as I said is on his way out.

18:58 That could prevent a lot of things. But now the Supreme Court has ammunition to really do something that could as I said lead us towards this sort of crisis perhaps take away control from firing uh senior security figures u because of uh bar's revelations. Um it's it's going to be very interesting and also extremely explosive. On the issue of divisiveness, as I said at the beginning, tonight and tomorrow is Israel's Holocaust Remembrance Day. It's interesting to hear the two speeches by the two leaders of Israel. We had President Herzog who gave the speech at Yadbashem as traditional uh where he spent most of his speech. The main theme was to end divisions. He said, "We are too divided, especially in this war, and that is the worst thing that can happen at this point, and we have to stop this divisiveness." Netanyao used his speech at Yadvashm shortly afterwards basically to tout his policies to show that he is

20:04 the one who's preventing the next Holocaust, that Hamas are the Nazis, and he's the one who said that he's going to fight to the end, even though many told him he couldn't. So we sort of even in a solemn day like this unfortunately politics are still there and we can still see the lines of uh communication by uh Israel's leadership but it's clear from uh some of the things that are going on domestically. Uh Israel is really as divided as it was before October the 7th. And with that I'm happy to answer any questions.

20:41 Thank you very much Ashley. Um now I will begin with a question here from Robert Laric who asks what do you think of the Iranian Russian security treaty and is this a concern of the US president or for Europe and what is Turkeykey's response to this? Well Russia has its own issues as we know it's fighting Ukraine. It's really it's taken a massive blow. Uh as we know from the beginning Putin thought that this would be a relatively short war. It hasn't been. It's cost Russia a lot diplomatically, economically, and militarily. Um, I don't envision a situation where Russia will actively become involved. Can and will it assist with uh munitions just as the West is doing in Ukraine? Absolutely. But just as the West is doing in Ukraine, it stop it will probably stop short of any um military involvement. Um, so it's it's not it's a concern because as I

21:44 said before, Russia did supply Iran with the S300's and it's got a more technologically advanced system now which could uh assist the Iranians. Probably not as much as the Iranians would like because they believed in the S300's and then Israel showed that, you know, that belief wasn't really warranted. Um but um then I don't think there's too much worry or concern that the Russians will become involved in the actual fighting. Anything's possible, but they're too distracted. They've been weakened themselves. Um you know, one can imagine if that happened, perhaps it would up the stakes. Perhaps the Americans would become even more involved. Um so it's it's more on paper.

22:28 It's more of a show. It's more of a diplomatic move. I don't think um the Russians will be actually involved uh on the ground. Um as far as Turkey to do with Iran, is is that the What will Turkey do? Uh what is uh what is Turkey uh I guess what is uh what do they think of this? What might their response be? all their their arrival of Iran in the sort of Islamic arena on the one hand, but they're also on the same side to a certain extent as far as Israel. Um, and Turkey wouldn't come to uh Iran's rescue. Let's not forget also commenting on the first piece that there was before the war uh an understanding or agreement between Iran and Saudi Arabia which is pretty historic and we don't know exactly what was in that agreement what the promises are. We think at least that there was a promise from Iran not to attack Saudi Arabia, not to use its proxies to attack Saudi

23:30 Arabia since that agreement. We didn't see for example the Houthis attack Saudi Arabia as we saw a number of years ago. Um and uh so there is I wouldn't say there's a warming they they don't like each other Saudi Arabia and Iran and Saudi Arabia would not come uh to their assistance. Um but certainly there seems to be an understanding not to openly each other at this point. So again would Saudi Arabia be involved in some sort of military attack? No. Uh but would they allow the airspace to be used? That's a debate. Uh that would be you know sort of I don't even know if um practically or strategically you need it. But there are other countries which also uh might be pressured by Saudi Arabia as the lead of the Sunni uh Muslim world uh not to allow Israel or even the Americans to use their airspace uh for an attack. But uh I don't think there is any country that would put his armed forces um to defend Iran. Yes, we would

24:35 see the Houthis. Yes, we perhaps see the Iraqi um uh Shiite groups. Yes, perhaps. Yes, perhaps no. Um but I don't think there would be an army or air force or anything like that of another country that would actually come to Iran's aid. Right. Thank you. Now, uh, turning to a more recent development here, Mahmud Abbas, uh, said just earlier, quote, uh, that, uh, he's calling for, uh, quote, the Sons of Dogs in Hamas to turn over the hostages. Uh, of course, meanwhile, he's uh, as far as I understand, he has not seized uh, his pay for slave program. What do you make of his Well, first of all, and Kamas, there's no love lost. uh you know if if if Israel was to defeat and destroy Hamas there would be few greater fans outside of Israel than Mahmud Abbas. Um he has had to take this difficult position. He hates Hamas but he also has to show that

25:38 he's not Israel's lap dog or even a fan of Israel. So yes the pay for slay it's been moved. It's been officially taken out of uh social services and put somewhere else but it hasn't really stopped. And as we know from the beginning um Fatak's uh clerics you know incited in the days after October 7th Cornier you know glorious days and all that sort of thing. So Israel doesn't see at least this this government doesn't see too much difference between Fatak and Kamas. But it's clear that Fat fed up um that they see that there are cracks within support of Kamas. They perhaps believe in these demonstrations in Gaza from anti-Hamas uh gazins. Uh perhaps they think that's an opportunity to rally some support towards them. Uh so to use this colorful language that he did against Hamas is relatively rare.

26:30 But again, alongside calling to give up the hostages, he also said, you know, by keeping the hostages, you're just giving Israel legitimacy to continue killing our people. we need to give uh them back the hostages and then uh end the war and create allow us to govern. Um so again we just see that there are some internal Palestinian uh aspects involved here. Uh not necessarily anything for Israel to get too excited about. There's pretty much consensus in this current government and even some in the opposition that the PA Fatak Mahmud Abbas can also not play a role in the future of Gaza. There are many around the world who believe that that's just untenable because you have to have some uh power. You have to have some governing uh governance uh and the only other body able to do that is the PA. Uh but Netanyahu stated on many occasions that's simply a non-starter for him.

27:29 All right. Thank you. Now, um, Eric Sulov asks, "What can you tell us about the security leaks of Israeli plans to bomb Iran? And will those leaks hurt future Israeli plans?" There is a debate with all these things. Who who leaked it? Was it the Americans? Was it the Israelis? Was it to send a message? Was it to show Israeli public that Israel had planned to do it and they were just prevented from doing it? So when uh you know the longer they put it off so Netanyahu can say well I wanted to but I was prevented. Is it the Americans to try and dissuade the Israelis? It's it's sort of unclear exactly some of the details, not the the the nitty-gritty details, but some of the overall details of what Israel will do or at least what Israel would not do. At one point there was even talk of landing some forces, but then that was nixed um for more aerial attacks. Um but I I can't imagine there are too many surprises there for

28:32 the Iranians on what an attack would look like. U but it's certainly worrying that these sort of things do take place. the leak is is probably harmful not just for what it might show but also the fact that the worst thing that can happen and something that President Trump tried to deal with tonight is that if there's any daylight between Israel and the US there seems to be and um uh President Trump was very quick tonight to basically said on all the issues tariffs Gaza Iran the uh the US and Israel stand on the same side they want the same things Um so that's really helpful towards Israel to show its enemies that you know they are together, they are united, there is no daylight. Yes, there may be differences on tactics. It's clear Israel doesn't uh see too much good coming out of negotiations, but uh you know it's it's something that they're going to have to stomach at the moment and relay their concerns uh as privately as possible.

29:33 Um, but uh these sort of leaks certainly don't help the relationship. Well, thank you very much, Ashley. I am afraid we are all out of time for this week's podcast. I want to thank you again for taking the time to update us this week. Absolutely. Thank you. Of course. Now, for our viewers and listeners, please join us on Friday, 11:30 a.m. Eastern time for our second uh in our series of our Middle East Forum roundt discussions. Uh this week's panel will feature Lori Rean as well as the Middle East Forum's Jonathan Spire, Clifford May from the Foundation for the Defense of Democracies, and Michael Doran from the Hudson Institute. Uh, as always, we thank you all again for joining us and for your participation.

30:25 And I hope you all have a wonderful day.