Webinar or Talk
The Islamist Threat in Britain with Wasiq Wasiq
Watch on YouTube
Description
Islamism threatens U.K. national security but British officials, from police to policymakers, tend to appease Islamists, shudderingly fearful of being called "Islamophobes." How have Islamists achieved this position of power? What can be done to reverse their success?
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 2, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:00 good afternoon and welcome to the middle east forums webinar and podcast series featuring box from middle east forums i'm dexter vanz island i'm the managing editor of focus on western italianism i will be moderating this discussion the format will be a 15 minute interview followed by 15 minutes of questions and answers from the audience should you wish to ask a question please use the q a button located at the bottom of your and type your question now i'm pleased to introduce our western guest today is a regularly contributed focus on western islamism an academic and a writer with expertise in anti-semitism islamism and jihadism worked as an associate research fellow for the henry jackson society and its center on radicalization and wasik's research focuses specifically on violent and non-violent islamists in the united kingdom the role the far left plays in providing cover for islamists
1:03 and the threat the far right poses to liberal democratic values you'll be speaking today about islamism in the united nations we'll seek i'll turn it over to you thank you thank you very much uh thank you to the team at middle east forum for holding this important webinar and thank you dexter for moderating it uh and i'll also like to take this opportunity to thank everyone for joining me today i hope you all come away with a better understanding of what islamism is and how it is a threat in britain so the first thing that i'd like to do is i'd like to first discuss the definition of islamism so what is islamism because once we know what islamism is and the parameters surrounding it we're better uh we will better understand how then it poses a threat to western liberal democracies like britain so islamism is essentially the political idea that the religion of islam has a role to play not just in the private sphere but also in the public in regards to the private that is of
2:08 course primarily concerned with muslims they are the people who practice the religion of islam whether it's through praying whether it's through giving to charity whether it's through collective but when we consider what is meant by the public sphere we're now examining what role islam plays with non-muslims and particularly in western liberal like britain a person who subscribes to the islamist idea of um of islam playing a public role is essentially an islamist and um they are the people who make a cons conscious decision of political affirmation to the political idea that the religion of islam should play a and a very vocal public role in in life now in terms of the islamists we need to understand that there is some diversity in there and that not all islamists are the same
3:11 they're not a homogenous bloc now damon perry from the policy exchange think tank a research fellow he posits that there are three types of islamists the first is the violent islamists the second are the non-violent islamists and then finally the third are the participationist islamists now the caveat here before i continue is that not all muslims are islamists but we can consider all islamists as muslims so let's have a look at each one of islamist types first and then we'll i'll advance the discussion a little further so in terms of the violent islamists these are the people that we can consider uh are the ones who want to achieve uh islam playing a role in public life but through the use of violence groups such as al-qaeda and isis are those sorts of islamists you find them mainly in majority muslim and in terms of how they want islam to
4:15 play a role in public life is very much at the extreme end what they want to do is or what what their aims are is to achieve a caliphate ruled under sharia the non-violent islamists however are slightly different um where they agree with the aims of the violent islamists they don't believe that uh violence is a way of achieving it necessarily or that they won't actually carry out that violence themselves so in terms of um the non-violent islamists they're very much similar to the quietest salafist salafist being the um the the strand of sunni islam the quietest being the ones who very feel like they can create that revolution within the muslim circles rather than expanding it out to to non-muslims and then our final islamists are the participationist islamists now before i give a definition of what they are um the remainder of the talk will
5:18 actually be looking at them because they are the islamists who really pose that threat um to western liberal democracies like britain so the participation in islamists are the ones that do believe in democracy and the rule of law so they're very much different to the violent and the non-violent who don't believe in man-made laws or kuffar which means non-believer laws or anything like but in terms of what they believe in democracy in the rule of law it's less so much on the agreement but rather on its usefulness and so what that means is that they're more interested in how to use democracy in the rule of law western rule of law to achieve their aims so they seek democracy in the rule of law as a way to achieve their aims and this is the main difference between them and the other two camps of islamists is that they do actually have belief in democracy in the rule of law but rather in terms of how to use it whereas the others completely outright reject it and would rather just have a
6:23 sharia law so now in terms of those aims let's look at that a little bit deeper so for islam to play a role in public life is broadly believe in the following and this is specifically in the west rather than in muslim majority countries so everything should be muslim focused and islam friendly and so what that means is that whether um you have policies or procedures or anything like that they should be focused on on on a muslim and they should be friendly to whatever people is in in regards to what islam is uh islam should not be critiqued or ridiculed so essentially what they believe in is blasphemy laws now obviously in the west we don't have blasphemy laws so they seek ways of trying to achieve that um in in terms of implementing it and protecting islam and so that goes back to being muslim-focused and islam friendly
7:26 muslims must never be shown in a negative light is is another aim and so what they try to do is present an image that all muslims are peace loving um people and that you've got nothing to fear with them and of course we broadly agree with that because the majority of muslims are like that but what they want to do is they want to present all muslims like that where possible any kind of initiative that is presented should be sharia compliant what they're looking at here is things like islamic finance food things like that it should be sharia compliant and they should be able to practice the religion now of course in western liberal democracies there isn't really a case where they're not being allowed to do that but they will seek to present an image that that is the case they also look to set up parallel laws things like sharia courts to manage issues specifically for muslims what they're trying to do here um as
8:29 i've just stated is those parallel laws where they're the belief is that the laws currently the secular laws that we have in um britain are not fit for purpose in terms of dealing with um issues to do with muslims or issues to do with uh islam playing a role with for for muslim life and then finally the the last thing and this is something that they have been trying to uh islamists participationist islamists have been trying to do for a very long time is to be the gatekeepers between them uh between the government and the muslim community now the muslim community of course it should be stated as a diverse uh with lots of differing views uh on theology on on social aspects and on everything like that but what the islam's participationists want to do is to be the gatekeepers they want to be a the spokespeople for the muslim community between them and the the threat that then that comes from the participation
9:31 is in some ways more dangerous than the other two camps the violent and the non-violent islamists and in order to tackle that we do need some solid policy initiatives to deal with it but let's have a look at the the actual threat what are we talking about here so one of the threats and this is what um we don't have a lot of time so i won't go into all of the threats but i'll talk about one of the threats uh that participation is in this do pose and that's the threat to the use of language what participation is isn't this one to be able to do to do is to define who and what a muslim is now this may seem like an innocuous aim uh because you know if someone considers themselves a muslim that should be the end of the end of the matter but that's not necessarily the case and it's not actually an innocuous king a aim it's actually a very sinister one and we look in that we'll look at that now so one of the ways for the participants participation is islamists to do that is to seek to shape and
10:35 control the narrative in regards to muslims and in the use of the term and so what they want to do is they want to use islamophobia as a way to define who and what a muslim is currently uh within um the british we have a working definition of islamophobia now this was uh set up by the all-party parliamentary group on islamophobia and they uh currently define islamophobia as uh something that is rooted in racism and is a type of racism that targets expressions of muslimness or perceived and this definition has been adopted by i think nearly all political parties except the conservative party who are currently the ones who are in power they at the moment have not accepted this definition but let's have a look at this definition and uh critique it a little bit to understand
11:38 why this definition is problematic and how islamists participationists are using it to then define who and what a muslim is so the first thing to consider is that um it's not clear that islamists are behind the definition per se but it is clear that they are in support of it wholeheartedly now this definition is flawed because the first thing to consider is that it seeks to conflate religious identity with race on the one hand you can freely enter any faith and leave it but on the other hand you cannot do the same thing with race race is inherent to you whereas religion isn't you can meander between religions as much as you like but you cannot do the same thing with faith it also ignores sectarianism within muslim communities now if we go back to the definition of islamophobia this working definition of islamophobia it says that it's rooted in racism and it's a type of racism uh because through expressions of muslimness and perceived
12:41 muslimness but then when you've got two muslims who are let's say brown but come from one comes from the shia tradition of islam and the other one comes from the sunni tradition of islam and they both have bigoted views towards each other because of the type of muslim that they are then how would this definition work in terms of race you can't be necessarily racist to someone of the same race as and so in that respect the definition of islamophobia actually fails to consider sectarianism within muslim and then the most troubling aspect of this is that if it comes to a muslim carrying out a terrorist attack participationist islamists will look to use this definition to call it islamophobia if you focus on the religious identity of the perpetrator despite it being a motivating factor for why this person has taken out a terrorist attack so let's have a look at a case study in in terms of this
13:44 now we know that um the the definition is problematic uh when it comes to violent islamists we know they seek to implement aspects of sharia law in the west or want to gain concessions from the government by using so um by nearly every definition of terrorism the whole point is to gain concessions from the government um of the of today but to call anyone that focuses on the religious variable as islamophobic gives cover and exonerates the islamist terrorists from the act what it essentially does is it excuses the literal interpretation of islam as a defining variable for carrying out acts of violence in other words it makes the act islam friendly so the whole point here is that if someone carries out a terrorist attack in the name of what the islam's participationist will do is they'll try to remove that variable as a defining variable and so it's got nothing to do with islam because islam is a peaceful religion and
14:46 in fact actually you're being islamophobic this person acted separate to islam separate to muslims he's not even a royal muslim but this is not the case because if someone considers to be a muslim and considers themselves to follow the religion of islam then we should take them at their word let's look at how then this use of language becomes problematic so two years ago a police association made up of muslims were looking to drop the islamists and jihadis when describing terrorists who claim islam as their instead what they wanted to do is they wanted to uh provide alternative uh proposals for describing islamist terror for example faith faith claimed terrorism or terrorism abusing religious motivations or adherence of osama bin laden's ideology these are obviously problematic because it actually takes away the very variable that we should be focusing on which is that islam was one of the defining
15:49 factors of why they carried out the the this is obviously problematic so refusing to call these attacks islamists diverts attention away from islam and this would be wrong because the logic for these would-be senses the islamist participations is of course that islam is peaceful even if a minority of muslims are not but this is false logic islamists are by and large influenced by a narrow interpretation of islam such as salafism and it is these interpretations of islam as well as their political goals and other factors that motivate islam to carry out terrorist attacks to suggest that there is only one version of islam and that is is a peaceful one is actually a lie because there is no one single interpretation of islam the proposal also speaks to a big tree of low expectations when it comes to the general uh public in britain surely the general public are more than capable of differentiating between islamism and islam islamism being the political ideology whereas islam being the private faith that muslims practice
16:53 so we need to have more confidence that the two terms are seen as distinct and make those as clear as possible and in acts of terror where the two do overlap we need to find a way to stand up to this threat from the islamist participationist and not change that so to finally um conclude uh how do we then uh tackle this so did to defeat the islamists participationists who are the law-abiding ones who do use the law and the principles and values of liberal democracies we need to bring them back onto a level playing field if we want them to throw around accusations or if they want to throw around accusations of islamic phobia that we need to be confident in being able to challenge and scrutinize them and and their accusations and these should not be going unchallenged so we also need a firm commitment to free speech this is important for the general muslim population than it is for everyone else because islamists are seeking to define what
17:55 islam and muslims are limiting free allows them to continue this because as far as for some sunni extremists are concerned shia muslims are not muslims and so it needs to be up to every muslim to define who they are rather than allow someone else to to to do that when terrorist attacks involving muslims take place it must be described accurately otherwise we could be creating the wrong policies for the wrong issues and then finally the government needs to crack down on these islamist participationist organizations that seek to undermine counter-terrorism they should not be given a seat at the table until they are committed uh fully to british values such as free speech and the rule of law beyond just its utility so we know that the they see uh the rule of law and um and obviously um british values of free speech as a utility and it's useful but they don't really believe in it when it comes to
18:58 who muslims are or what islam is and so this is something that we need to but thank you very much i hope that's given you a uh an overview of islamist participationists and the threat that they pose to western liberal democracies in britain and i'll welcome your thank you so much wessie that was wonderful now one of the questions that popped into my head is is it what else can we do to somehow diminish the role of islamists and particularly the participationists that you spoke about what can we do to uh basically undermine their status as gatekeepers because that that seems to one of the big issues because government officials are always looking for somebody that will be able they can an interlocutor or an intermediary that they can talk to are there people in the muslim community that are out there that would be in a
20:00 position to replace the gatekeepers as they currently exist i think so i think that's a good question i um what what we don't want to do is we don't want to have any interlocutor between the muslim community and the the british government what we do have currently is we have mps we have members of parliament who are representative of their constituencies and we need to start understanding that muslims are part of society rather than separate to it and so once muslims more integrated in terms of using the political system as in their mps to get their views heard then there's no need for those gatekeepers to get through into polymer of course this is again the same thing with organizations so if organizations are seeking to um speak on behalf of a a membership or muslim membership then they need to be committed to british values of free speech british values or in terms of the rule
21:03 of law and things like that whether it's a misogyny whether some of the issues that we're the muslim community are facing currently they need to be firm against that to show that actually we're committed we're british muslims we don't have an issue living here we don't have an issue with the law here we don't want sharia here we have found a good medium here once we start having that the need for participation is starts to diminish okay now what would reform look like on the part of some of the the uh the muslim civil society organization suppose they wanted to basically send a message to the british public or the public's within western democracy to say look we're no longer interested in essentially using the tools of democracy's democracy to advance a religious authoritarianism what type of messages or signals would they have to send to their fellow muslims and to their fellow britons well i think um
22:04 if we look at a case study quite recently um only i think two months ago there was a film that was uh produced called the lady of heaven and it was it was done by a fringe group of shia muslims they produced and it was being shown across um across the country in cinemas what we found was a lot of um islamist extremists were protesting against it and some there was even a petition out there to to get the film banned and essentially what they were looking to do was to set up a de facto blasphemy law blasphemy through the back door essentially um however they didn't get as much support as they perhaps uh wanted especially if you look at um in 1989 when we had the salman rushdie affair when he produced the book the satanic verses we had fundamentalists running around screaming burning effigies whereas this time we didn't see as much support as we saw
23:09 here and so what what that actually demonstrates is that there's a quiet revolution taking place so either we're we're looking at muslims who either they do not care about blasphemy any more or the islamists are just not uh able to recruit them and i think it's a it's a combination of both and i think we need to continue to empower british muslim communities uh in in regards to that they don't want to be dragged into issues that have no real life impact on them in a in a country in a nation where they pretty much get to say what they want and so that's the sort of messaging that i think we need to start getting through and um and start promoting now how many supporters you have there's a question in the queue that says what is the state of muslim reformism in the uk are you a lone voice or do you have colleagues muslim colleagues and friends who share your views and are committed to opposing islamism how strong is the
24:11 constituency i guess well as i said i think the in terms of that quiet revolution is taking place and there is a lot of support because um when when we look at for example prevent prevent is a government initiative to tackle extremism and terrorism and this came following the seven seven uh london bombings where 52 people were killed as a result of homegrown terrorist islamist and prevent has been um has been an image has been portrayed of prevent that is islamophobic it's um targeting muslim communities and everything like that but then recently in polling by crest advisory research uh think tank they found that actually when uh prevent was um explained to muslims that more people more muslims were more in favor of prevent than uh the general population so what we do see is that there is
25:13 support there for for reform-minded muslims um who are not necessarily looking to reform islam but looking to reform themselves as muslims and to find their their own identity here in in britain against the backdrop of islamists constantly saying that it's islamophobic here and you know you're not wanted here and we need to change things and and and everything like that so there is support there it's now about actually getting them to be more part of um british society and being able to use their mps and you know use the civil service use their councils and things like that participate in society in the same way non-muslims do because we are part of a british society we're not apart from it and so we need to continue that and and the support is there is then now about getting that support and being a bit more vocal against that islamist participation is threat okay now there's a question in the queue
26:16 that says which categories would you put each of the following groups into and one i think it's muslim public affairs council in the uk men five pillars in and i maybe it's unfair to i don't want to ambush you i promise you i wouldn't ambush you that's going to be a difficult question or if that's going to put you on the spot but can you because you talked about three categories can you give some names without getting in too much trouble um i probably won't give names but there is research out there that um i think we can uh perhaps publish um with the middle east forum that uh actually names some organizations who fall into the categories of um of being islamist participationists i would consider most um organizations that a lot of your viewers have heard of who would fall into the category of um islamist participation is the fact that they're still able to operate um the fact that they have legitimate companies running and you know that they're using um the machinery that we have here to to obviously
27:20 undermine the efforts so but there there are other um prescribed organizations like al-mahdirun who would have fallen into the non-violent um category so they they agree with jihad for example jihad being the the um the use of violence a holy war so to speak um but the the difference between them and the violent is that they won't carry out they just support it although that's not to say some of the supporters didn't go to um to syria to join um is islamic state so so there are um a number of if you consider any of these organizations to be islamists they're probably going to be the participationist ones now one of the questions that i have is is that it seems as if islamism and i don't want to overstate the case is having a difficult time in the middle east which is one of the regions where it originated so my question is why is it that we see
28:21 uh so many institutions in the west still promoting this agenda when the people who live in the region where it started uh some of them seem to want to kind of get away from it well absolutely i think when we start looking at the middle east especially in egypt for example uh tunisia some some of these places where they've already had the islamist project take place and it's failed spectacularly and quite embarrassingly it just doesn't work there is an idea that here in the west that it can work and there's a especially for the islamist participationists what they're obviously looking to do is to find that happy medium between the two so they want things to be muslim focused and islam friendly and they want to achieve that by being able to define who and what muslims are and so for a lot of um islamist participation is here they're looking to it as a way to save themselves from a threat that
29:26 doesn't exist against them because free speech is not a threat to them um liberal democracy is not a threat to them but they're looking at islam as the solution for everything and most muslims do look at islam as a solution for everything but it's not necessarily a solution for everything because that's we don't you don't go to the quran or you don't go to an imam to seek a medical solution you go to a doctor and so in the same way that's what we need to be doing over here and we we need to tackle that idea that islam can solve all the problems actually it can't it's a personal faith and that's that's something that that we need to promote more uh rather than it being something that's uh public and should be able to control and shape how um society is run and one last question it's just uh which is like when's your book coming out or where can we find some more of your work okay i mean because this has been
30:28 astounding it's been it's been enlightening and it's actually given me a lot of hope so so talk to us about where people can find your stuff thank you yeah so um currently i write a lot for focus on western islamism so please obviously go go there to to read some of my stuff there's some great work coming out on there i write for a number of other publications as well on the threat of islamists and also how the far left to give cover to them and so you can find a lot of my stuff on my twitter so my twitter is uh was iq uk and also my website will seek dot co dot uk um and you can find all of my stuff on there a book is uh coming soon so uh keep your eyes out for that that's good to hear and so we've come to the close of our webinar and i want to thank you wasseek again for joining us and for our viewers and listeners be on the lookout for our weekly webinar offerings that's going to be sent out this weekend thank you all for attending and have a wonderful day thank you so much