MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Israel Insider

Israel Insider with Ashley Perry

Watch Israel Insider with Ashley Perry on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

Israel is currently planning major ground operations in Gaza if Hamas does not agree to renewed negotiations in the coming weeks. What happens next?

Ashley Perry is an advisor to the Middle East Forum’s Israel office. He served as adviser to Israel's minister of foreign affairs and deputy prime minister in 2009-15, and has also worked with Israel's Ministers of Intelligence, Agriculture and Rural Development, Energy, Water and Infrastructure, Defense, Tourism, Internal Security, and Immigrant Absorption and as an advisor to The Negev Forum. Originally from the U.K., he moved to Israel in 2001. He holds a B.A. from University College London and an M.A. from Reichman University (IDC Herzliya).

Transcript Automatic captions

Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 20, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.

0:08 Oh, good afternoon and welcome to the Middle East Forums weekly podcast series, Israel Insider. My name is Anafav Kalam and I will be moderating today's discussion. We are pleased to be joined by Ashley Perry, adviser to the Middle East Forums Israel office, who joins us each week to give us a brief overview of the top events currently going on in Israel. Mr. Perry will speak for 15 minutes followed by a 15minute Q&A session from the audience. And if you'd like to ask a question, please feel free to use the Q&A box located at the bottom of your screen to type your question. And with that, I will turn the discussion over to Mr. Ashley Perry.

0:49 Thank you very much, Aknaf, and good evening from Israel. Um, it's been an interesting week. A lot of um events taking place uh overseas. Uh, as we know, uh, Prime Minister Netanyo spent the latter part of last week in Hungary in Budapest where he met a very warm welcome by the Prime Minister uh, Victor Orban. Um it was a sort of a softball event. Um Netinoa wanted to travel abroad not just to the US but probably somewhere else in the world knowing that his host would not exceed to the ICC warrant. And as expected uh the ICC did uh uh get in contact with the uh the Hungarian government asking them to arrest uh Netanyahu and pass him on. Not only did Victor Orban and the Hungarian government not exceeded that uh particular request, but in fact it withdrew from the ICC. This was

1:52 obviously very carefully choreographed from the beginning. It was a good look for Netanyao. Um he came out of it looking well. Um it could be that other countries will do the same. He did say Netanyahu did say um this will it's the first country to withdraw from the ICC since the arrest warrants were given but uh he in in his words not the last um controversially according to Simon Israel. Netanyahu then spent the weekend in Hungary for no particular reason. It was clear there was no more meetings.

2:28 You know the big meeting with Orban was already I think on Wednesday. Uh so there was no real need to stay, but there was a decision made that he would stay until Sunday and then travel back after the Sabbath. Obviously, Israeli prime ministers, unless there's a real need, do not travel on the Sabbath. Um so it could be that there was a meeting put on Friday, but certainly not one substantial enough to stay away from a country in the time of war and everything else that was going on. But what did happen is um uh during it's not clear exactly when but NetO uh was summoned let's say or invited uh to Washington DC uh during that trip to Hungary and uh he did travel in the end on Sunday straight to the US. Uh Netino was a little bit blindsided by this. Uh not the first or the last time he'll be blindsided in this particular episode. Um but there was a suspicion that uh he was being caught by President

3:30 Trump because Israel uh I think were if not the only country, one of the only countries that um with a threat of um the raising of tariffs uh by the US on countries around the world, Israel decided to remove all its tariffs on US imports to Israel. ahead of that thinking that there would be reciprocal um uh uh sort of exchange of zero tariffs. Um and Netino uh lorded the fact that he was the first leader to visit uh President Trump not just once but twice and the first one since the tariffs were raised. Um what he did find out that when he was on his way to Hungary is that the US obviously didn't do the reciprocal uh 0% tariffs and actually impose 70% 17% um on Israel. Uh but there was a feeling that he was being summoned to DC to negotiate and see if he could lower that somewhere close to uh zero. Um there was

4:36 a feeling within Netanyahu camp that perhaps he could even uh sort of uh uh you know show an impressive negotiating skills and come out of it and even show the world this is how you negotiate with Trump. Uh perhaps that was something that they could coordinate uh together. Uh unfortunately that is not how it worked out. Um, interestingly the press conference uh held between the two at first we were told there wouldn't be a press first we were told there was a press conference and then we were told it was canceled. In the end we got one of those sort of impromptu sort of informal sitdowns where the president likes to uh receive questions from the journalists. Um it is clear that this was not going to be a similar repeated event from the first time that the two of them sat uh down together after Netany visited DC a number of weeks ago. Uh the atmosphere was different. Bby was very restrained.

5:40 uh barely talking, allowing President Trump really to lead the way and sort of just uh having warm words whenever uh the conversation uh turned to him. What was clear and Israeli commentators were looking through Netanyo's um body language throughout is that the Israelis have been blindsided by a number of things. Uh first of all uh going back to tariffs, it is clear that uh Trump had no um uh decided not to remove the tariffs on Israel and when asked he said maybe we will maybe we won't. NetO did not come back with any sort of win or success or achievement on that. Um there was really no moving and the tariff uh continues even though President Trump over the last hour or whenever it was has decided to lower all uh all tariffs or at least freeze them for 90 days. Uh I I if I understand correctly there will

6:43 still be a 10% lower limit of tariffs during that time. But NetO did not get the win he wanted. He did not get to show the world the special treatment, the special relationship that he has with Donald Trump. And it just got worse on the issue of Iran, what the Israeli government had been hoping for. And certainly when Netino um got the invite to DC, he was hoping that as far as Iran, there would be some sort of timetable. He did understand that the president had been talking about the possibility of extending a hand towards negotiations. Iran had shown no interest. So there was a feeling that the Israelis could start to talk about a definitive timetable where some sort of decision possibly with military action uh could be uh sort of put in the diary as it were. What he did get uh is just before they faced the cameras, there was a 1-hour sitdown where uh some of these issues were brought up for the first time, not least the fact that the

7:45 Americans would be sitting uh in direct talks, as the Americans say it, the Iranians still claim that it's going to be indirect talks. This is will take place on Saturday. Um but the Americans and Donald Trump said to the cameras with the Israeli uh prime minister next to him that we are we will have direct uh talks with Iran. You could see Netanyahu's face. Uh by that time he had absorbed it and he understood how to keep as much of a poker face as possible. Certainly, it was a major uh problem, a major challenge and certainly not the win on Iran that Netanyo had been hoping for. The third uh problematic part that came out from that as far as Israel and Netanyo in particular was the issue of Turkey and um its president Erdogan. As we know, Erdogan had been taking far more bellose um stance towards Israel. Even recently on at the end of Ramadan calling for the

8:50 destruction of Israel, Netao was hoping not just to get uh the American president to restrain his Turkish counterpart, but certainly on the ground on a practical level. Uh the Turks are very keen on establishing certain military bases in Syria. That is something that Israel cannot tolerate. Um there were reports that Turkish commanders had been looking for uh specific bases around the country that they could set up shop similar to what the Russians had uh during the Assad uh regime. Um and Israel basically got ahead of them and bombed all of these three potential air strips and bases. Um but it's clear that this is this has the potential to be something very major. Um and uh Netanyahu was hoping to get some sort of assurances from Donald Trump.

9:46 Well, when it came uh publicly in front of the cameras, not only did Trump not castigate Erdogan in any way, he basically spoke very warmly about him. He's a good guy. We can trust him. He's very clever. He took over Syria. What a great thing he did. Uh again, um he he did suggest that Americans could mediate and he said in in so many ways in very Trumpian language that uh if anything the Israelis had to be reasonable about this uh which was certainly not music to Netanyo's uh ears. Um and uh the latest on that issue between Turkey and Israel is there are the beginning of talks this was confirmed by the Turkish foreign minister uh to create some sort of deconliction uh line because obviously Turkey sits between Israel uh Syria sits between Turkey and Israel. Israel's basic aims in Turkey today to make sure

10:48 that a lot of the hardware of the Assad regime does not fall into the hands of the new government and to make sure that there are no forces that enter Syria that can be a risk for the future and there is a a major worry about Turkey in the future. There are some um former security uh officials who have even gone as far as to say Turkey represents an even possibly bigger threat to Israel than Iran. So it is something very worrying for Israel and it's clear that NetO did not get what he wanted on that issue either. What we do know is that this meeting did not go as planned. NetO did not walk away from any achievements.

11:31 If anything, he got himself uh a certain amount of warnings on Iran, on Turkey, and at the moment, the tariffs are are staying. Um, as opposed to last time, we didn't get all these congratulatory messages on social media and all these uh talking heads for NetO and the Li could talking about what a great meeting, talking about the great chemistry between Trump and Netanyo, how he's on board with everything that Israel wants to do. The fact that we didn't hear any of this just goes to show how uh very few people took this meeting in a particularly uh positive uh way. Um as far as the uh possible negotiations with Kamas go, there are very low level negotiations. Egypt came up with a proposal, some sort of compromise uh between Israel and Kamas.

12:27 At the moment, that's all it is. Israel claimed that it didn't receive the offer and then uh accepted that it did but then basically said it's a non-starter because once again even when there is flexibility on many of the issues how many hostages to be released how many days of ceasefire humanitarian aid etc etc Hamas still demand that part of the ceasefire would be to negotiate towards an end of the war which would mean in Kamas's eyes uh that Israel would leave the Gaza Strip Hamas would return to power and that is considered unacceptable to Israel. Israel is going further and further into Gaza is creating more and more buffer zones. At the moment there is little to no fighting. There has been some rockets launched at Israel uh from Hamas uh from Gaza um this week. But at the moment the IDF isn't really fighting too much. It is taking over more territory. that it seems that Hamas as a fighting force has decided to stay underground largely uh hoping to wait Israel out. Israel is in

13:33 a bit of a quandry. It wants to uh especially the the chief of staff wants to take a far more robust um approach, wants to really uh bring in tens of thousands uh or more forces into Gaza and really uh sort of take on Hamas uh from different parts of the strip at once. At the moment, we haven't seen that massive call up of reserves that would be would necessitate that would be necessary for uh such moves. Um but it could just be a matter of time. I'm sure this was something that was discussed in the White House as well. But at the moment, we don't see any signs of anything more than just holding more and more uh territory. As I said, the negotiations don't seem to be going anywhere. Hamas understand that this is probably the last time they'll get to negotiate. if they do release more and more hostages. Uh so for them they really have to stand their ground. But Israel also is standing uh its ground.

14:30 Um on Lebanon there's now more and more talk about disarmament as opposed to just keeping uh Lebanon away from the border. Uh there more excuse me more and more um according for disarmament. It was the American mediator Orteus who came to the region uh this week and certainly the the buzzwords at the moment are disarmament. It is something even uh an anonymous official was quoted as saying that we are ready for a certain amount of disarmament. It if that's true then it really does show what a bad statebah are in. Uh, Israel did get some intel this week that it that have been using the ceasefire to try and develop more and more weapons. They have a Israel found a weapons factory in the Dhaka which is the stronghold just outside the capital Beirut. Um, and uh it's certainly uh taking steps to uh try and push back even more. It'll be

15:36 interesting to see if there can be an agreement. Um, on the one side, Hezbollah disarms, on the other side, Israel removes itself from the five points along the border. Finally, a little bit of uh internal domestic politics. As we know, the Knesset uh is on a break and it will be for a few weeks because of the Passover holiday which begins on Sunday. Um but there's no real let up or pressure on Netanyahu especially from the ultra orthodox. haven't heard too much over the last few months from the Sphadic ultra orthodox party Shust and its leader Arya Derry that relative silence was broken um where Arya Derry basically said if there is no agreement on the idea of enlistment law in other words the non-inlistment of the ultraorththodox public by the start of the summer session then they will not feel themselves bound by coalition discipline and in fact they believe that they could vote against or at least not vote for.

16:36 Now, that is an annoyance to Netanyahu, especially if he has a legislative um agenda coming up, but it's not a threat to the government. Derry doesn't say he'll leave the government. Doesn't say he'll vote against certainly not a vote of no confidence. So, it's pressure. Derry because he pretty much took a backseat to Gold Canop and others over the last few weeks probably feels the pressure uh from some in his community. Uh this was probably a way to say look we're acting as well. We're acting with a certain amount of balance and moderation but for us it is still an issue and we still have to act according to our interest. As I said it won't bother Netany too much because there's no real threat to his coalition. uh the budget has been passed uh it would only be a vote of no confidence which means that some in this coalition would have to cross the aisle and vote in favor of a vote of no confidence uh which is not a threat. No one is saying that. So

17:39 Netino's tenure is not really in threat but it could certainly uh spoil any particular plans uh that Netino has uh in the upcoming session. Um, and with that, I'm happy to, uh, answer any All right. Thank you very much, Ashley. Uh, I will begin with a question here from Rabbi Joel Schwarzman, who asks, uh, Lieutenant General Gadi Eisenot wrote a lengthy document about Israel's strategy. Obviously, on October 7th, Israel's military strategy failed for the southern communities. To your knowledge, who if anyone is working on a new military strategy for Israel today?

18:22 What elements have changed and what may have been added? That's a very wise question with certainly not a lot of elements. Um on a strategic level, yes, there's been many discussions since then. Obviously they were led by previous um IDF uh uh chief of staff Herz Levy now by Aal Zamir who comes in with a very different approach both because of his background as a tank commander and because he comes from a more let's say hawkish uh background. Um you know he he likes to fight very much on the front foot. Um for many years the chief of staff was largely defensive and that's perhaps what led to October 7th uh not you know not not leaving at the political level which obviously plays a major role uh in this but um there there are many discussions you know the the threats have changed is not the threat that it was not to say it can't be again in the future but at this point in timebah are

19:26 not uh the threat that it was uh in Uh it's certainly a better move if Israel could have decided whether to have had Bashar al-Assad or to have um the current rulers in Syria. Probably would have uh plumped for that just because Assad, you know, was basically allowing his country to be a conduit between Iran uh and many other factors which were very problematic on the Iranian side. Are in major trouble. they cannot bring in money. They're supposed to be paying rent for those people in the south of the country um who are displaced. They're supposed to be paying for their hospitals and all their schools and everything else and they simply can't bring the money in as easily as they could before. Um so that was a major blow and that certainly got to be taken into it. As I said, the big worry for many on the northern or north eastern uh border of Israel is now Turkey. There is a concern that Turkey

20:29 could become the de facto rulers militarily at least uh in in Syria and Turkey is a very technologically advanced army. Let's not forget Turkey is part of NATO and that presents its own complications. Um so that's something certainly to be uh looked over. As far as Iran um you know there is there's been a lot of training going on for there. There is this feeling that there is a window of opportunity. I've talked about that quite a number of times uh in recent weeks and months. Um but it could be the political and diplomatic uh clock does not align necessarily to that. And with this announcement by President Trump that there will be direct negotiations or direct talks or whatever it is certainly pushes everything back because the Iranians know above anything else how to play for time. Uh there is a certain amount of concern that the American side will be led by Steve Witkov who while he was credited with the first uh ceasefire and the release of uh hostages in in in

21:32 the more recent um deal uh there is a feeling that he didn't get a lot of the other negotiations and messed up on some of the others. So the fact that he's leading the American side is is is is of um and uh that really you know Israel cannot go it alone and while there are negotiations and the prospect of some sort of negotiated deal um the Americans probably won't give a green light to Israel and as I said the Iranians are really expert in just pushing the clock further and further and further back um so basically there it's it's it's a moving target things are changing in this region so quickly the Houthis are also not the force that they were even a few months ago because of the you know the the daily attacks from the Americans. They they have tried to launch rockets missiles ballistic missiles at Israel. Some of them have not reached their target. Some fell short in Saudi Arabia but all of them that reached the uh you know Israel or

22:37 on their way to Israel were shot down. So they haven't really been able to do too much to target Israel during this time. Uh the threats are not there. also even in the in in in the the the seas which they basically been uh you know sort of uh bullying for for a number of years now uh they're not able to do as much the American force there is hurting the Houthis um so the it's very difficult to create some sort of strategic plan because the region is changing so quickly um and a lot depends on the diplomatic level on the political level will Israel have enough time? Will they be given enough time domestically, internationally to finish the job against Hamas? Will there be another uh hostage deal? Uh certainly Israel wants to give it time to be a hostage deal.

23:28 But it's clear that if that doesn't happen and if Al Zamir is allowed to go through with his plans, uh it will certainly be a far more brutal assault on Gaza than we saw previously. Uh quicker. Uh there was a lot of criticism that Herzi took too long or the political level took too long, whatever it is. But now there's a feeling that you have a new sheriff in town and he wants to do things uh very differently. Um so he'll have a very different plan and of course all of these things are constantly being looked at and you know edited and uh reassessed all the time.

24:07 Um but it's clear that Israel uh needs to take a different approach since October 7th. Has to be more on the front foot, not just wait for things to happen, not just believe that uh uh certain things are taking place just because they want to believe it as the government and the security forces in Israel believed pre October 7th. So yes, that's a very long winded way of saying that um there there are strategic plans. uh they are constantly being uh reassessed but it's clear things have changed to a certain extent.

24:40 Unfortunately, we've always also got to remember that as much as there were resignations at the highest level of some of the security agencies, 90% of the system remains in place and that was the same system that simply missed uh everything leading up to October 7th. Right. Thank you very much. Now, uh there was a report in the Jerusalem Post from earlier today, uh where it notes that about 75% of Hamas's tunnels in Gaza are still intact, including a significant number of those used to smuggle uh goods between Egypt and Gaza.

25:20 Now, you mentioned that while Israel is occupying uh parts of the Gaza, there hasn't been a lot of fighting in the attempts to uh get rid of these tunnels. How does that affect uh the the goal of keeping these hostages alive while doing that? Right. Well, that's an important point. We know that all of the hostages are being held in these tunnels. So, Israel is very circumspect because a lot of these tunnels are interlin. So even if you take out a tunnel, not necessarily that is in the immediate vicinity of the hostages themselves, it could affect um it could affect them physically. Um so Israel's being very careful, but largely it's just a matter of time and opportunity. It's very hard.

26:07 It's not so easy like blowing up a house or something like that um to blow up a tunnel. Even if you blow up a certain section that can relatively be uh easily rebuilt. Let's not forget, you know, the the the figures at the beginning of the war, everyone was saying that the the the amount of tunnel is larger than the London underground system, which goes across the whole metropolitan area of you know, one of the largest cities in the western world. Um so we're talking about a massive system and it's very hard to get to all of that. You know, 25% is not a small number. It sounds in percentage terms it's a small number but in actual terms it's a very large number. Uh there were many figures who said that it would take if not many many months certainly years to completely demolish the whole system. Um and yeah it seems that it is taking a long time and when you factor into the hostages into that it's it's not amazingly surprising that the number is as small as that. Um again I think without the

27:11 hostage issue they would be able to do a lot more but again because of time because of everything else and don't forget that's manpower as well and that's manpower taken away from other military actions. So it's unsurprising it's not uh it's it's it's around that uh that number and uh just to demolish it possibly could take the years that some commentators suggested. Right. Thank you. Now, Steven Miller would like to ask, you mentioned that President Trump gave Netanyahu a warning on Iran. Do we know exactly what that was? As I said, there wasn't a specific warning. What it was was basically we're trying to negotiate. That is where we are at the moment which clearly is not where Netanyahu wants the American administration to be which is putting maximum pressure and with not just a threat a theoretical threat but a timetable an actual timetable because as we know these kind of military actions

28:15 if there is ever going to be a military action takes time to arrange to practice to look into all the intelligence to figure out exactly what needs to be done. It's not something even if there was a green light tomorrow, it could take weeks if not months for all the different elements uh to be in place. And every day of negotiations that turns into a week of negotiations that turned into month we saw in the leadup I don't know if you know many people remember but to get to the final signing of the JCPOA took years. The Iranians knew very well how to put everything off. Um and a lot of the administration, the current US administration has no real experience in negotiating with Iran and they really are arguably some of the best negotiators in the world. You know, there is that sort of stereotype of the Persian bazaar, but to a certain extent it's true. The the Iranians have thousands of years of expertise in negotiating and they do it very very well. Um, so there's certainly a certain

29:19 amount of pessimism in Israel about this. So it wasn't necessarily a warning from uh President Trump, but it was at this point in time diplomacy is taking precedence and we're going to give it a chance and uh that's where we are at the moment and that's certainly not what Netanyahu would have wanted to hear. All right. Thank you very much. I think we have maybe time for one more here. uh the Trump administration and Steve Witkoff had have been uh pretty lax when it comes to the issue of Qatar. Now if the allegations that are being investigated in the Qatarate scandal uh actually are proven and come to light, do you think that this might change the Trump administration's tune and force them to be a little tougher on Qatar?

30:05 I don't think it's really related. I mean, first of all, we know that some of the allegations are true because everyone's admitted it that at least Feldstein, one of the uh one of the former now former uh close advisers to Netanyao was accepting money through a third party from Qatar. Now the question is who else was? Um the allegations are that even closer advisers to Netanyao were accepting um money and acting for Qatar when they were pretending to act on behalf of the prime minister's office. That's one of the harshest allegations that they basically gave the um the press communicates talking points etc etc when the media professionals thought that they were getting that from the prime minister's office when in fact it was going through Kadda. Um I don't think that will necessarily have uh a bearing on what's going on in the US.

31:00 The US has its own issues. Um there are quite a number of people in and around the administration who also have a a history with Qatar one way or another. Let's not forget it's got the largest base uh in the region and Qatar know very very well how to play that. Um so we don't see any pressure on Qatar at this moment from the US administration and also from the Israeli um administration. We heard Netanyahu come out during the the sort of height of Qatar Gates, I think it was last week, basically calling Qatar a complex country, denying that it was seen as an enemy country and calling it complex, which is certainly not what one would expect to say of a country which harbors, hosts, funds, and supports a terrorist organization which seeks the destruction of your state and was behind October 7th massacre. So it's clear that it is a major issue on both sides. Um at the moment Netanyahu is happy for that to be off the headlines for the moment.

32:02 Um but certainly we haven't heard the last of it. But I'm not sure that there is too much of a connection between what's going on in Israel and what that could mean for America's relationship with Qatar moving forward. All right. Well, thank you very much, Ashley. Uh we have reached the end of our podcast for the week. I want to thank you again for taking the time to give us an update this week. Thank you. Of course. Now, for our viewers and listeners, please be on the lookout in your email inboxes for our weekly podcast offerings email for the uh for the following week. As always, I thank you all again for your participation and for your viewership, and I hope you all have a wonderful day. Thanks.