Webinar or Talk
Turkey and Qatar Support Hamas: How to Respond? with Jordan Cope and Endy Zemenides
Watch on YouTube
Description
Turkey, a NATO ally, and Qatar, a major non-NATO ally, vocally and materially supports Hamas. What is the nature of these ties? What constraints do Doha and Ankara face? What should the U.S. government do in response?
Endy Zemenides is the executive director of the Hellenic American Leadership Council. He served as Senior Advisor for Illinois State Treasurer Alexi Giannoulias. He is as a nonresident fellow at the Chicago Council on Global Affairs. He holds a BA from DePaul University, an MA from the University of Essex (UK), and a JD from Georgetown University.
Jordan Cope is Qatari finance fellow at the Middle East Forum. He studies Qatar’s soft-power efforts via charity and media organizations. He has a BA and JD from the University of Texas at Austin.
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 26, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:06 hello everyone uh this is Cliff Smith I am the Washington Project Director of the Middle East Forum uh thanks for joining us for a special Roundtable discussion uh of what I have called in a recent article the problems of America's Frenemies in Hamas um basically uh cutter and Turkey um the issue is this on the horrific events of October 7th um have focused for understandable reasons on two main Bad actors Hamas and Gaza themselves and perhaps some of the traing areas um as well as Iran um which arms and supports Hamas in financial um ways in arms and other methods um and this is true um and it's very convenient to discuss it in these terms because there is very little support for Hamas or Iran um or the regime in America um and even in International Community in a larger sense Hezbollah or excuse me Hamas is um deemed a terrorist organization by many countries it is an internationally
1:08 isolated Iran is similarly isolated um and um somewhat cut off from other parts of the world um but things get more complicated once you get past this point uh because Iran is not the only major State sponsor of Hamas turkey and cter are both uh major supporters of Hamas they Harbor their lead ERS they hold political offices they have political offices in those countries and it is not too much to say that without the support of turkey and cutter it is highly unlikely Hamas would be the force it is today certainly not in its current form um and they thus both turkey and Kar are complicit in the events of October 7th and they've continued to defend Hamas even in the aftermath um indeed it was just this week president erdogan explicitly openly publicly said that Hamas was not not a terrorist group and basically defended them in their mission um what makes this uniquely difficult is they are both allies of the US turkey is a NATO Ally cutter is a major non-nato Ally that was a status recently given um
2:12 and this really creates a problem um here to discuss this with me today is em Indies EMES of the helenic American Leadership Council Jordan cope the Middle East forums cutter Finance fellow and also joining us is Jonathan Spire um an Israeli who is also the middle forums director of research so this will be a round table discussion for about 25 minutes and we'll take your questions um you can type your questions in the Q&A box we get to as many as feasible anyway in meantime thank you all gentlemen for being here and looking forward the rest it uh for starters um let's just start with Andy Andy what does turkey do to support Hamas and how does its support matter to this wider issue well let's and I want everybody to pay attention this week weekend because uh this actually this weekend is turkey Centennial and instead of celebrations of turkey Centennial they're going to host massive pramas rallies uh turkey has been described as hamas's second
3:17 largest base of operations after Gaza uh Istanbul is clearly hamas's funding uh Capital it's it Finance Capital according to shinb uh and when you think of all these Hamas operatives moving around so easily well how do they do that and and they're doing it with Turkish passports too um so the funding the training I I think when the history is written on on October 7th there's going to be proof of of Turkish at least knowledge if not involvement let's remember the Turkish foreign minister was the intelligence chief of turkey he helped Hamas grow in Turkey so they facilitate the movement of Hamas they facilitate hamas's purchase of rockets uh all this infrastructure all this Weaponry uh and that's that's something that everybody who keeps calling Gaza an
4:22 open air prison needs to answer for well if it's such an open air prison how did they get all this all these weapons in there turkey facilitates all of that and clearly it's giving Hamas its greatest moral support we're seeing I'm sure Jordan could talk about we're seeing tremendous pressure in Cutter reacting to this pressure turkeyy is getting the same pressure but instead of reacting and saying you know let's use our influence with Hamas they're saying Hamas is not a terrorist organization it's a mujahadin National Liberation group I'm quoting erdogan on on this so uh but I think the biggest problem is Turkey's um turkey is basically a terrorism financing operation for Hamas and uh keep in mind if anybody wants to discuss some of these things we can anybody can discuss it but we thought we'd start with one from each here um and that takes us to Jordan um Jordan cutter is probably the biggest bankroll of Hamas and it's the harbor of
5:25 Hamas and other um radical islamist movements you want to explain how this works and why cutter is doing this of course cter Bank rolls Hamas perhaps it's the largest Finance here of Hamas today it might have even outpaced Iran so between 2012 and 2021 Qatar gave approximately 1.8 billion US dollars to Hamas and since 2021 it seems to have escalated its funding from what it previously was to approximately $360 million a year According to some estimates so Qatar like turkey not only offers Safe Haven to Hamas operatives in Turkey they've actually coordinated and planned attacks from there in previous years in Qatar the head of hamas's leadership Ismael Hanah has a safe haven where he operates there Qatar has acknowledged that Hamas has an office in Doha from which it operates and in previous years Hamas officials have hosted conferences in broad daylight in hotels such as the
6:27 chertin uh and the Four Seasons and so ultimately when it comes to qatar's relationship with Hamas it's one that is very fond of Hamas one that offers it safe haven uh and funding and allows it to continue its efforts Iran by contrast gives Hamas a100 million a year recent estimates as I've mentioned before estimate that qatar's financing actually outpaces that of Iran and yet Qatar remains a non-n major Ally of the United States while Iran remains a sanctioned State sponsor of terrorism so A lot's going on and it's not just through financing and through Safe Haven but through state sponsored media through which Qatar ultimately helps enable hamas's cause such as through its Al jazer station which has previously referred to hamas's dead as Martyrs uh including the former bomb maker for Hamas Yaya aash so Qatar remains front and center when it comes to support for Hamas not just sustaining M but for
7:30 garnering support for it worldwide yeah um John you want to discuss a little bit how this works in terms of Israeli diplomacy Israeli military operations and how this wider Dynamic affects Israel as it is now you know open war with Hamas yeah sure cliff and I think in this regard you know turkey and katar are two very different cases because you know first of all uh Israel has no formal and has has has had no formal diplomatic relations with Qatar there was a representative office uh opened uh During the period of the Oslo Peace process and then closed down at the start of the second intifada so relationship there is informal in its nature uh Qatar as Jordan pointed out was the major has been the major Financial supporter of the Hamas Enclave in Gaza pretty much from or from the moment of that enclave's Inception 2007 but it's interesting to note that that relationship moved on to a formal
8:34 and Israeli approved uh level after operation protective Edge in 2014 and essentially up to October 7th of this year uh K was providing around running a sum of $30 million uh per month to uh to Hamas Enclave Gaza with the approval of and indeed with the facilitation of uh the government of Israel this of course was all part of the uh now defunct but very significant Israeli strategy in those years in which it was thought that Hamas could be on some level tamed that Hamas ruling Gaza would continue and that Israel could find a way or another to work around that so to speak that's all over of course and to some degree I think it's uh correct to say that it was that policy that strategy at the highest level that kind of cleared the way for the complacency that then led to the blindness that then made October 7th uh possible so in that regard one would expect uh the Israeli attitude stand
9:37 towards Qatar to change now very rapidly however it appears to be the case that Qatar in the uh way that it kind of tends to be able to do has now kind of inserted itself once more into the issue of the Israeli 220 Israeli hostages held in Gaza and just a couple of days ago Israeli National Security advisor Saki hanegbi tweeted out a tweet only in English not in Hebrew praising Qatar for the positive role it was playing in the humanitarian issue of the hostages so Kat once more appears to be continuing to succeed in playing this double game someone has some analysts have likened it to a an arsonist who also tries to play the role of a firefighter like first of all sets fires and then comes along and says how can I help you in putting them out it appears in the evidence of recent days that role has not yet ceased to be and Israel appears to be willing ill advisedly in my personal in my opinion to be allowing that role to continue thus our regard to
10:39 c a couple of words on Turkey just to introduce the point turkey of course has had formal and and once again now does have formal diplomatic relations with the state of Israel and these have had their ups and downs over the years we're just we've just prior to October 7th come out of a very long down period in which relations were basically to all intents and purposes cut after the uh mavi mamura incident the incident in which an NGO strongly linked to the Turkish government uh took part in the sending of a ship seeking to illegally enter Gaza Waters which was an apprehended by Israel with the loss of lives of some Turkish citizens just about a year ago just over a year ago full diplomatic relations were restored some people were talking about a new uh chapter in Israeli Turkish relations I was very skeptical about that as the Middle East Forum was and many others were because we aware of the fact that this is essentially an islamist government in uh turkey unlike regarding to Qatar there are kind of ideological links between the Turkish AE the ruling party and the Hamas organization they are branches from the same tree the tree
11:43 is that of the Muslim Brotherhood movement so turkey is an islamist government and it has offered very active backing short of arming Hamas but nevertheless doic siling an active Hamas office in Istanbul which as Andy pointed out has we uh there is proof to indicate taken PL in the active planning of terrorist operations including back in 2014 for example the kidnap and murder of three Israeli uh young uh men who were murdered and that was the trigger for operation protective Edge in 2014 so a very active uh uh link as we know Turkey the Turkish government operates also through NGS ihh the so-called humanitarian Wing but Sadat also uh the paramilitary organization and these organizations have much more direct links including you know practical active links to Hamas enabling the Turkish government to kind of play the role of saying well we're not taking part we're we're a legitimate government but these guys very strongly linked to Turkey are openly linked also to uh Hamas I think Andy pointed out the uh
12:46 statement made by president erdogan in recent days describing Hamas as a mujahadin group a Liberation group I think that speech is marks a new chapter in Israeli Turkish relations basically back to square one back to to where we were after 2010 in which absolutely predictably erogan when it suited him to do so refer reverted to islamist type reverted back to the islamist leader that he is and is now seeking to Fan the Flames of conflict between the Muslim the Islamic world and Israel so we're back very much to where we were prior to the so-called rosom brief rosom Israel and Turkey of a couple of years ago so those are just a couple of remarks on some remarks on on each of those relationships and I'm sure we can delve further into any of those elements as as the discussion I i' just like to highlight something that Jonathan reminds us all properly turkey and Hamas are offshoots of the same I mean aape in turkey and Hamas are offshoots of the same movement which is a Muslim Brotherhood erdogan
13:50 sees himself and I think the region very much sees him as the the top of the the pyramid in the Muslim Brotherhood and that also explains why turkey besides its bad relations with Israel had horrible relations over the last decade with Egypt uh cce's overthrow of morsey was taken personally by erdogan and even his moves for Rosman whether it's with Egypt or Israel or Greece uh right now we're we're born of economic dire necessity and uh because the US finally or at least some in the US started holding turkey accountable uh for example by holding off f-16s and other weapon sales that's not only because of the s400s it's not only because of Sweden's remember the the weapons holes were even before Sweden's uh accession uh it was it was a signal that Washington was getting fed up uh with turkey but erdogan has decided his
14:53 economic needs are are not as pressing is playing to the street uh the lesson in in a forum we did with with you in person in the Middle East Forum we said that the winners of turkey's election was turkey's nationalist movement uh it's a special it's it's much different than again on the weekend of turkey Centennial it's not it's not Kamal arat Turks nationalism it's a it's this new Blended Islam nationalism and that he decided with uh with municipal election coming back in Istanbul and Ana and we know how much erdogan prioritizes and want to get isul back that he's going all in on this Islam nationalist card uh and that's what that's what we're witnessing right now he's the leader of the Muslim Brotherhood movement uh in in 2023 I just wanted to note the irony that the country that Israel does not
15:55 have formal ties to was funding Hamas with the de facto support of the Israeli government while the one that it did have diplomatic relationship was doing things without side of its uh its uh relationship which is just uh strange but uh anyway um yeah there's much more to cover and we only have so much time um let me ask one other question that sort of begs to be answered and anybody can jump in here but um as we already mentioned the other big state sponsor of terrorism or of Hamas in particular is Iran um do you want to discuss turkey and Cutter's relationship with Iran and what that means anybody yeah we can do yeah go ahead please I think i' would like to discuss I think something that Jonathan mentioned as well about the turkey and Qatar relationship before I begin about that of Iran because it does appear turkey and Qatar do act in concert at times the Qatari State Affiliated e charity actually gave millions of dollars to the Turkish Islam islamist organization that Jonathan referred to earlier ihh and so not just that but
16:59 through media often times the media agenda talking points overlap between Qatar state sponsored Al jazer and turkey state sponsored trt World both frequently at least over time have aused both Israel and India in one way or another or of at least platform stories accusing those countries of settler colonialism of genocide and AP partide and so at the end of the day both of them do act in concert and even at the Doha Forum in 20 22 the opening moderator was actually a moderator from trt World in Qatar who introduced the Amir it a very interesting Dynamic now going to the relations between these two countries and Iran Qatar during the Arab Spring ultimately was a friend of Iran's um Landing its planes after it got boycotted effectively by the G by much of the GCC in Egypt qara actually would land its planes and use Iranian airspace so there was a relationship throughout
18:01 much of this time and it was one that was hotly contested by much of the rest of GCC so there's always been that interesting Dynamic Iran obviously has a very different ideology at hand compared to Turkey and compared to Qatar turkey and Qatar support islamist movements and are generally grounded in ideology that is ultimately that ultimately comes from the Muslim Brotherhood Iran instead of supporting Sunni islamism support Shia islamism and revolutionaries throughout much of the middle throughout much of the Middle East both of them have advanced Pro capacities but they do find that some overlapping interest when it comes to some causes they agree with which is the destruction of Israel and support and asence for Hamas Iran differs and goes on its own way when it comes to sponsoring hasbalah and so when it comes to understanding these relationships it's important to understand that turkey and Qatar generally have not supported isolationism uh when Qatar was boycotted
19:04 Qatar had ties with Iran and turkey spoke out against Qatar being isolated and boycotted by the CET that Saudi the UAE in Egypt so I think that's just an interesting Dynamic to understand they don't always overlap turkey and Qatar often times have a more similar ideology and agenda but they do find some common ground with Iran when it comes to ultimately promoting Israel's two points if I may on on Qatar and Iran firstly we should remember obviously qatar's geographical position very very close by Iran and its sharing of the massive uh natural gas field the north Dome South pass field so qat probably any uh government running Qatar would seek to not get too much on the wrong side of Iran for simple geopolitical reasons and Qatar this Qatari monarchy certainly uh lives up to that um a second point is with which Jordan made mentioned with to the issue of Sunni versus Shia political Islam uh traveling through hisb control South Lebanon in 2007 a year after the Israel Hezbollah
20:07 War I was struck by the amount I expected to find and did find Billboards announcing the role of the Islamic Republic of Iran in rebuilding hisb controlled South Lebanon I was struck by the presence of a number of Bill massive Billboards announcing reconstruction projects financed by Qatar with a picture of the the beaming em hammad ofq at that time qat is also involved in a relationship with hisbah we know about the the relief and reconstruction element of that Benjamin weal also of MEF and myself have done some reporting over the last year or so trying to look into indications that elements in qat once again not necessarily the official state but uh elements leading up to members of the Qatar royal family also have a more direct relationship with hisb up to and including the financing of arms purchase is by hisb as well so qat also has a deeply murky and deeply negative role less of which is yet known about more of which needs to be researched with regard to practical
21:09 assistance to Lebanese hisbah as well Lebanese hisbah of course being a direct franchise of the Islamic revolutionary guards Corp of of Iran and I think yeah I think it's also I want to add something that the guys did not the overall Regional Dynamic Jordan talk about cutter in Iran during the boycott let's remember cutter and turkey turkey troops uh to Cutter to defend and and turkey keeps cashing in on that chip especially in its when it really needed money a lot of money came back for cutter to help from cutter to help erdogan in his reelection and credit swaps and the rest but uh because let's remember what was attacked on October 7th it wasn't only only Hamas and it wasn't only Israel being attacked by Hamas uh for all of those disingenuously calling for a ceasefire and for peace right now they conveniently neglect to mention that for a decade Israel was in
22:15 several peace processes several uh I focus on the Eastern Mediterranean if somebody told you Jonathan you may be able to comment MOS if somebody told you 20 years ago there would be such a tight trilateral between Greece Cyprus and Israel you would have called B if somebody told you there would be something called the East Med gas Forum in Egypt with Egyptians Israelis jordanians Greeks cprs Italians French Americans and Palestinians making joint decisions you would have called BS if somebody told you the Abraham or NE the Abraham Accords a negative form the imch the India Middle East European economic Corridor starting in New passing through Israel ending up in Greece all of this was a road towards peace which should also which should lead to the question who is really serious about peace uh even when we're talking about Israel and the Palestinians and I think uh we should all review everybody should
23:19 review what yasar arat said no to and Camp David in in 2000 but the attack was on this what turkey car and Iran have in common in all the institutions that I just mentioned all the peace building initiatives they were on the outside looking in they don't want that to happen Iran doesn't want anything to happen in the greater Middle East without it having a say same with cutter turkey doesn't want anything happening in the caucuses in the in the Eastern Mediterranean or the Middle East without it having a say they attacked that that era of collaboration and cooperation as much as they as they attacked Israel they want the wider Regional War they do they want it because they don't want the next step in in in neev or Abraham Accords and that's why it's imperative that uh I will tell you one it's hard to Envision how we have a meeting anytime soon of the abrahamic
24:23 cords let's be honest about that but you know what we could have we could have the three plus one we could have Greece Cyprus Israel plus blinkin Anthony blinkin has not yet had a minister level three plus one Mike Pompeo did right those are three democracies there are three democracies that have all affirmed and supported Israel's rights to defend itself and uh I think we need to start uh showing the contrast between the democracies and non-democracies in the uh we're about to get to questions we got a couple in the in the box if anybody wants to go more please we'll get to them very shortly uh we'll ask one more question before we get to those though um the us as we pointed out has a close relationship with turkey and cter um what can the US be doing to get turkey and cter to change direction are there diplomatic fallouts of that so on and so forth who would be anybody want to speak to that well the f-16s the issue of the f-16s uh should
25:28 include what turkeyy doing in the Middle East it should not be tied we should not give away that defense relationship cheaply uh We've lowered the bar to hey even if you discuss Sweden's membership in in the parliament maybe we give you the f-16s Sweden can and should be integrated in NATO no matter what turkey does turkey should realize that it's privileged place in the US uh in military procurement system is dependent on it being a real Ally uh and it will not be compartmentalized I also think there should be hearings the discussion about turkey's ties with hamash should be very open uh today as we actually right be an hour before we spoke I think treasury sanctioned uh Turkish uh Turkish officials and others I think Jordan can speak to that in in detail uh there should be no quarter for Hamas no matter where it is Turkish Bank should have to face potential exclusion from the Swift system if they're banking Hamas and and
26:32 then finally because Senator Rick Scott brought it up yesterday and it's hard to do but he says turkey's NATO membership should be reconsidered we can't kick out turkey from NATO because turkey has a veto on its own expulsion but we can do is ask for hearings to talk about where turkey and others like Hungary for example fall short of the expectations and the obligations of a NATO member and maybe other hearings like at the Helsinki commission Chris Smith has been great in in doing these type of of hearings to say if Turkey was a candidate country today would it be eligible for NATO spoiler alert the answer is no but we should have this openly I would I'd like to add just a couple of things literally two senten with regard to Q here uh look it's important to really stress the following the we've been discussing the katari relationship to Hamas but it's important to to bear in mind this relationship is part of a much more larger pattern of Ki behavior of D of support for
27:36 destabilizing movements and individuals across the region going back to the doicy of khed shik Muhammad you know the architect of the 911 attacks and going back to and taking in the relationship to Afghan Taliban right at the time domicil of Afghan Taliban right at the time when they were engaged in Insurgency not against Israel but against the United States of America in Afghanistan so this ER approach goes is is Broad and deep of qat and I would say it's a strategic interest of the United States simply to challenge this to say it is not acceptable for a so-called non-nato Ally which also is of course the host of the largest US Airbase in the region alade to be also the mo one of the most active supporter of Terror terrorist and destabilizing movements across the Islamic Middle East and Qatar needs the American relationship Qatar needs alud Qatar needs American protection so the Americans the United States has a very very strong hand to play once it begins to I guess kind of switch the disc so to speak and understand that this relationship that kata's this uh strategy K has been
28:39 pursuing is absolutely unacceptable and absolutely destabilizing I think the first thing is to understand and Israel needs to as well to understand the nature of that approach and then you know uh possible counter measures in a sense line up themselves because Kat is dependent in many ways on the relationship with the United States I would just like to add I guess a little bit onto that the United States does wage a lot of influence over Qatar if we remember what happened to Qatar during the era of the boycott is very much isolated and it wasn't the only period that Qatar faced isolation in the Persian and Arabian Gulf if we remember the coup in 1995 when air hammed B Khalifa a aani assumed the throne Qatar was very much isolated back then as well and it's very much probably on the internal conscience of Kari Le ERS ship that they do fear isolationism and so over time they've used effectively soft power efforts to prop up the means of influence that they have both in the region and Beyond and they've also helped Forge ties with the United States
29:41 through contributions to American universities five billion dollars of such effectively since the 1980s allowing Al udade base to be there um through billions of dollars of weapon sale trades with the United States over the years the US needs to ultimately let Qatar realize that it cannot continue to to finance terrorism and islamist insurrections as it did throughout the Arab Spring Qatar needs to be reigned in and the US needs to realize that ultimately it needs to stop empowering Qatar by giving it opportunity time and time again to intervene in these mediation rules that time and time again have come back to bite America uh in the back whether it be through helping restore the Taliban to rule in Afghanistan whether it be just about a month ago when Qatar helped promote a captive exchange between the United States and Iran that would have ultimately channeled $6 billion dollar towards Iran geopolitical expert Richard Goldberg ultimately noted at the time that this would create a precedent for
30:43 more American hostages in the future and here we are now after the Hamas Massacre on October 7th with Americans in Hamas captivity and so Qatar should not be able to dictate to America what its terms are and right now it should not be able to dictate to India effectively some uh many of you may have been aware of the eight former naval officers in India that have just been sentenced to death by Qatar supposedly for spying on Israel the charges seem rather spous to some um and it's definitely one of concern but Qatar continues to wage much influence for the tiny country that it is and one that unstable uh unstable insurrections and one that promotes an islamist agenda what America ultimately needs to do is to reign in on the weapon cells it needs to threaten Qatar to ultimately realize that if it does not stop its terrorism financing it will end up on our state sponsored designated uh our designated terrorist list as a state sponsor of terrorism um we need to be aware of all of cter soft power um uh plays that It ultimately tries to pursue whether it be
31:49 through Sports through sport sponsorships whether it be through the media through American universities through military uh trade um through its Airlines Qatar Airways which remains one of the world's most premier Airlines we need to be more conscious about this and turkey has learned from coutur I believe over time to a degree uh about katar soft power efforts uh and hence we see Turkish Airlines uh over time having assumed a more present role um in in social media and in advertising and so I think these are just some things to consider but America also needs to realize that its military bases in Turkey and katar definitely endanger American interests because it forges our dependency upon these two countries that haven't proven true allies to United States let's get to some of the questions now um I uh David Levine asks it's well known that Hamas leaders have found Safe Haven and cutter um and turkey I would like to add um what is the likelihood that th if things
32:52 escalate in Gaza Israel could actually attempt to assassinate Hamas leadership and cutter or turkey I will just say one thing um um that has not gotten enough attention that shows how incestuous some of this is ishma Hanah the one of the the heads of Hamas um as everybody knows has um has been residing in cter haam haa his son was a resident in Turkey until he met his demise in Gaza um in recent weeks after the fighting started so he went back and forth between the two just to say that but anyhow yes I was a wrath of God like um event um on these countries what How likely is this and what uh what would the Fallout be yeah I would assume that this is quite possible I mean I think it's even likely that uh you know the the Israeli capacities that have been on display famously in So-Cal operation WTH of God but also in in other contexts as well including with regard to Hamas in the past famously the uh attempted
33:55 assassination of or the assassination rather of Muhammad M of Hamas in Dubai just around a decade ago so you know this is one of the tools in Israel's Arsenal and uh that's been you know used already in the past also with regard to Hamas also in different sites in the world and I assume it's very possible or even probable or even likely that that will be one of the things Israel will be operating U during this war and also uh subsequent to it we know also that Israeli uh intelligence is is act both in Q and indeed in turkey and I think it's very very possible that actions of this kind will be taken I think it's uh you know the fact that when when defense minister yov Gallant describes the Hamas leadership as Dead Men Walking then I think we should not assume that's a purely a metaphorical turn of phrase and this I think is quite likely in the period we're now seeing opening up I like to add sorry just I would like to add one thing and that is if there's any lesson potentially from from America America's efforts to try to hunt down
34:58 holl Shake Muhammad and Qatar in the past it's it's been reported by some that the Qatari officials ultimately tipped off bed shik Muhammad and allowed his Escape I mean whether that actually happened or not it's up to it's up to dispute but it's something to consider for Israel if it is to go in um and how much it can rely on the American qari relationship to ultimately reel in these people but forgive me for interrupting B um Eric can you please talk about Cutter's relationship with American universities yes um the Qatar Foundation has ultimately been at the far Forefront for the qari state for financing educational efforts throughout much of the world excuse me not throughout much of the world throughout the United States and so Qatar is effectively dollars um to us universities since the 1980 some of the biggest beneficiaries have been Georgetown Texas A&M um Northwestern I believe actually has a partnership with
36:00 the AL jazer Network the same News Network that once hosted a birthday party celebration for hasbalah terrorist Samir kunar and so in regards to universities Qatari influence has definitely been expanded through money um Qatar has helped establish Education City in Doha which now houses branches of many American of several uh American universities I believe North Western Texas A&M uh I think Cornell has a medical school there um Virginia Commonwealth University and so there's there's quite a few universities that have received significant funding and even the Amir himself actually happened to speak at Georgetown during the midst of the Arab Spring and so it definitely seems that there is interest in having some influence in these universities it has allowed the Amir to at least speak to one of them in the past face Toof face with students and to convey The qari Narrative at a time it was very pivotal and so it remained suspect I
37:03 guess the depths of qari financing today because it is it has been a bit serious and uh suspect and a bit secretive in the past and the question is how much more will be revealed in the future um there's a related question that I will actually answer Jeff Bing ban asks does pramas prot terrorism bias shown in recently in our yeares anything to do with Kari Aid um I'll answer that because I've actually been looking at this a little bit the the short version is we don't know um I don't think um the longer version is however um due to some of the factors Jordan's talking about it's it's a good question I mean you have seen um for example a professor at um northwestern's Cuttery campus which you mentioned um openly float conspiracy theories that no women and children really died in hamas's attack which is just absurd um can had NPR canel a nationwide program due to his comments on that um and given that right now technically universities are supposed to
38:07 disclose how much money they get from foreign universities but it is basically unenforceable um as the law is currently written and even when they're supposed to disclose they're supposed to disclose very little um basically just we got the money you don't have to say who got it you don't have to say what it's for what conditions are on it things of that nature totally totally not something the is law requires uh a bill by an amazing coincidence just got introduced in Congress in recent weeks that would increase the fines for not disclosing the amount of money and require disclosure of um of what the money is for and what it does and who controls it so hopefully um that will continue on um but yeah that's on that and we have a several questions about Cliff that's something we all have to prioritize it's cutter it's confucious institutes uh by China we can look at a lot of Turkish institutes which were
39:11 established by the way when turkey was an ally but you see when erdogan purged everybody he got rid of uh moderate secularists we we see how erdogan has shifted the funding of turkey for Stuff America's adversary uh are are trying to conduct a hybrid war and they're using our universities uh this is not conspiratorial it's it's there it's it's out in the open and frankly Sun Sunshine is the best disinfectant so that legislation is a must if Congress can agree on one thing it's got to be this we got to know who's spending money uh especially when we see what our students have become it's one thing to say yes I'm Pro Palestinian that's one thing to say Hamas was justified to attack to when we see Jewish students barricaded at Cooper's Union I I mean this is this is outrageous and it it's just too coincidental that it's happening in conjunction with these these huge spend
40:14 by America's adversaries yeah there is several questions concerning um turkey and NATO and people asking can turkey be removed from NATO the answer is no not really um there's theoretical ways but in all practical purposes no um however that sort of leads to a question um internally in NATO is there anything that can be done you know I mean Andy mentioned um Congressional hearings and such um but internally is there anything in NATO that can be done to minimize the benefit they get out of it and to keep their influence at a minimum well absolutely first of all you can isolate them even within NATO you can do exercises out of its area that turkey is not part of uh and if you really want to antagonize them really include uh Greece in areas outside of the aian in the Eastern Mediterranean you can show less
41:18 Reliance uh this is for and this is something very important for the United States you really need to start Rel lying less and drawing down at in Cher link uh you have to develop uh multiple uh Alternatives you know Stephen cook wrote a report years ago for Council of forign relations called neither friend nor fo and he said you can split up what you wanted in Cher for and use uh Romania and Greece and Cyprus and Jordan uh so any anything that that let you uh keep them out of being a necessary player uh but there are fundamental parts of NATO you can't even you can't even meet have the North Atlantic Council meet uh unless everybody's on the same page so you may have to do some kind of ad hoc uh coalitions um especially when it comes to Sweden but
42:23 you can't isolate them and the number one part is make make sure they they know that they will not be armed uh let's take the f-16s for example right we need to get the United Kingdom on the same side that if we're not giving them f-16s there's a reason so don't go and give them typhoons right we need to get NATO all on the same page Germany has to understand that no you know don't give them don't give them submarines unless they really start acting uh like it's not Russia that has made turkey problematic it's our own allies and and our own government here in Washington DC they've been so obsessed with don't lose turkey that they're letting turkey play both sides against the middle so make this s Washington Brussels Berlin London have played the carrot card only and I have no problem with offering the carrots but make the sticks clear it should not be carrots only uh any of last thoughts before we
43:25 wrap the all right well just to say I mean I guess just a one liner on regarding Israel just to reiterate what I said before that you know for Israel and also for the United States there needs to be a paradigmatic shift here once the once it is understood that the countries we've been discussing are de facto State supporters of terrorism whether defined or not as such you know much of the policy stuff we then discussed in detail kind of falls into place by itself but it's that paradigmatic shift that so urgently I think needs to take place very much so in Israel as well as in the States and if I may just add one quick sentence on that I do think in Israel in the last week in the UN at least through gilad Eran the ambassador to the UN we have seen to some degree a definite shift on Israeli opinion towards Qatar realizing the danger that it poses and so I I definitely agree though with Jonathan's comments uh there needs to be a parad paradigmatic shift and it needs to happen
44:28 now all right well thank you very much everyone really appreciate it come back next week for more webinars on Middle East topics and thanks for all my guests for coming I'll see you