Israel Insider
Israel Insider with Naveh Dromi
Watch on YouTube
Description
Having apparently resolved its internal differences, Israel's incoming coalition seeks a showdown with the justice system. What are the issues and which side will likely prevail?
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 30, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:00 Good afternoon and welcome to the Middle East forums webinar and podcast series Israel Insider this week with Ned Dromy. I'm Stacy Roman and I will be moderating this discussion today. We're pleased to have Nvidi who oversees the day-to-day activities of the MEF's Israel Victory Project join us this week to update us on all the events going on in Israel. Nvid will be speaking for 15 minutes and open it up for questions. Should you wish to ask a question, please use the Q&A box located at the bottom of your screen to type your question. And with that, I'll turn the discussion over to Nvet Drum.
0:36 Hello everyone. Good afternoon. I replacing Ashley Perry that usually speaks at this webinar. I know that Ashley um was supposed to speak about the legal changes that might be in the next government. H I'll speak about this but I think that um the bigger thing today is that in a few hours from now or maybe even a few minutes Benjamin will call the president and we'll say to him um in Hebrew we call it I have managed which means that I have managed to establish a government. I have to say that it comes a bit longer.
1:28 It took a longer time than what people thought it will take. I remind you the were held in November 1st and you we are now at December December 21st which is almost two months. And people thought it will take shorter time because the government that is being established is um all the parties that were in the Netanyahu camp before they were all together in the opposition and now they are all together in the new coalition and the government which will be established and there is a very interesting situation here these days. It's like everyone knows that the government will be established but there are different difficulties as I said it took longer time. All the parties wanted to maximize their their success. They wanted to get more in the liquid itself. There were some
2:34 arguments between Tanyao advisors and some Knesset members and things weren't going easy for them and also in the opposition you can see you can see something very interesting the criticism of the camp of laid and benigans and liber and mi which are getting criticized from their vote. voters for not doing enough to fight the new laws that the new government want to promote and I'll explain and this is where the legal issues and other issues are coming into hand some of the main things that the new government promised to its voters is to have a reform when it comes to the legal issues from Netanyao camp of voters of Netanyahu Motric Itar Ben
3:41 and even the ultra orthodox parties. They voted because their leaders promised them a reform in the legal system in Israel. This is one of the main issues that um that is important to those voters and some of the things that those leaders want to achieve in order to promise in order to to fulfill what they promised to their voters is some things that the opposition is against and there are there is a big discussions in Israel about those things. Another issue that creating a discussion here or even a debate between the members is everything that um will go under Itar Ben which supposed to be the new minister of the interior of the interior security. He's replacing Omar Berv from the labor and what he is asking he wants
4:47 to have more power in his hands over the police. Today the minister of interior um doesn't have a lot of power over the police. H he can't tell them what to do. In many cases they are kind of a free and independent and he asked to have more power over them. So he can control some of the things that they do. To some people it sounds very reasonable and to others it sounds um dramatic because for them it seems that if he takes more control over the police then they think he'd somehow um that it's it's not how will I rephrase it? It's not how the situation and the relationship between the minister and the police should be.
5:46 And there is a big discussion because those who are prom saying how can the minister of defense can't control the army. Of course he does. He have connection with the chief of staff and they decide things together. And if the minister of defense wants something even if the chief of staff doesn't want it, he still has to do it. It's not the case between the minister of interior security and the chief of the police today. The chief of the police can decide that he does things his own way even if the minister doesn't accept it. So this is one of the big arguments and the legal system is also involved here because you can see that the legal advisor of the not all of them are working or loving this change that it want to do in the power that he has as minister of interior defense. So
6:51 when the coalition, the new coalition that is being built trying to promote the laws and the reforms and the changes that they want to do, they have problems not only with the opposition but also with some of the legal advisors who are against those steps. And now the question is if they will do it even if the legal advisors doesn't like it or if they will listen to the legal advisors. Of course um there are different I mean from outside the there are legal advisors that say that this is what it should do because the fact that he doesn't has any control over the police it's kind of grotesque.
7:43 So as I see it I think that in the end of the day it bang will manage to do this change. he will be able to promote the reform that he wants to do. But then he will be under he will be in a problem because once he did this change everyone will look at him very closely to see if things if things are really getting changed and I think the main issue that will concern the people not matter if they are right or left Jews Arabs it's everything that consider the violence the the Arab society which is suffering from a very high violence between the crime organizations. Only yesterday 2 years old boy was killed. There was a big storm in Israel about it. Ministers, the chief of staff went there. There is a huge problem in this in Israel. And if
8:46 itar Benville manage to do these changes, he will have to give answers to everyone in Israel, not just the Arab Israeli society, but everyone. So it's a bit tricky the the reform that he wants to do in the opposition beside the things that they are trying to change with the coalition that is being built. Something interestingly yesterday when some of the voters wrote post and the articles saying that they are very disappointed from their leaders. Those who just who are still in their job. They are still ministers but their voters are are disappointed because they expected from them to be more to be more vocal and to stand more for the for the changes that they see from the upcoming coalition. And you can see that their leaders laid and Vladimir Bel from Yeshid mainly
9:51 I have to say mainly yes members are reacting to this criticism and saying that they they are against the reform they are against the changes and you can see that the voters of their camp are not satisfied with it. I'll give you an There was supposed to be a vote about Ben new reform and instead of fighting Ben and the law from the eyes of the of the pit voters instead of fighting these laws and the changes they want to do.
10:30 They got to an agreement between the new coalition and the new opposition that the votes about it new law will be on agreement hour of the day which will means that it will pass in the end of the day and their voters wanted to see a filibuster in the Knesset. They wanted them to stand there all night and read. So the vote over the laws will take time. they will postpone it. And from their point of view, it seems like the new opposition is giving up and is not fighting their fight. And it's interesting to see how from their eyes they're doing the completely different. There was a discussion in the this week about it vo which meas from Yeshid was there and other people from Yeshid and the Benigant party were there. They sat there for more over than
11:34 eight hours just to discuss uh this law. So just to give you an example of what's going on from h their eyes the members of the new opposition are there they are sitting they are fighting but their voters think it's not enough and in the teno camp they are trying to build the government for over almost almost two months now and in their eyes they are doing the best they are building the best right to win government that they could have think about but from their voters's eyes. It seems like it's taking too long. It's almost two months.
12:15 Therefore, it will be much shorter. It's not related, but something very interesting that happened today that might point out political things that can happen in the next months is that Benny Gand decided to not release a body of a Palestinian terrorist to a funeral in the PLO areas. a terror, a Palestinian terrorist named Abu Hamid died from cancer in an Israeli hospital.
12:48 He was sent to seven um world prison. I'm not sure I'm saying it right in English. And he died a few days ago in the prison. He killed about seven Israelis and was um part of other terror attacks and once he died the PLO said that they are waiting for his body to bury it and once the body if the body would gather then they would bury it with a lot of respect and will do a and the families of the victims in Israel wrote a letter to Benigant asking to not release the body unless Israel get something for it like the bodies of the soldiers on Shaul and Adar golden and today people were kind of surprised to see that Benigans decided not to release the body of the Palestinian and it's interesting because everyone
13:51 speaks about the possibility that in few months from now maybe a year Benigans will join Netanyahu government and the steps that he did today might approve it in one way or another because it's considered to be something that the government of Yapid wouldn't do for example. So this is something that we should look at not only in the eyes of the conflict between Israel and the Palestinians but also in the eyes about the political process because things are moving. People always keep saying that Netanyao is not completely satisi satisfied with the government that he has. people saying that he is the leftwing part of his government. So things are very interesting. It will be interesting to follow different events which are not I mean
14:55 from the outside doesn't look political but they are very political and this event with Benny guns and this terrorist body might be one of these events that we should learn from about the future. I hope it was interesting and that I was able to transfer some of the feelings and the events and the process that are going on in Israel these days. I'm happy to answer any question. All right, thank you so much. The first one is from Murray Feldman. Can Netanyahu control his religious allies or is it like 1933 Germany? Does Netanyahu have a the tiger by the tail, so to speak? Uh if the opposition brings down Netanyahu, the religious group will bring down the opposition.
15:45 I'm not Can you repeat the question? Sure. Uh can Netanyahu control his religious allies? I think he does. I mean, I guess it's it's depend on the person you ask, but it seems like Natao was able to maintain some of the biggest jobs in the new government to his party to deod and and through the years Netanyahu was able to walk with the Orthodox with the Ultra Orthodox allies. So, I don't see any reason it won't work today.
16:24 Thank you. And uh we've been talking for a few weeks now about what you were speaking about with Gans and potentially joining Netanyahu. Uh Ashley was speculating that possibly he was holding out a minister position for Gance. Uh do you still see that as an option? No, I don't see it as an option. I think Benny Gans has wants to solve some things inside his party before it goes in. I'm not sure he would like to go in with his entire party to the new government. He might take some of his people and again it will take time because the voters of Netanyahu right now wouldn't like to see Benny Guns in the government. So Netanyahu will need to take some time before he he does something like this. And I have to say about uh the the the other question that sometimes the ultraorththodox are being are playing a game. Uh people think that they are very
17:31 and but they are very as I see it as a woman living in Israel I'm not getting afraid from some of the things that they are demanding because their demands doesn't affect me or my life and I think that I mean for example in the new agreements there are some issues which for me it's important like things that will make it easier for the ultra although to get involved in the general public which is good I don't want I would like to see more ultraorthod dogs in my area to see them involved in our community and not getting closer in their community so in this aspect I think the the agreements between the auto parties to the coalition are to the Israeli public.
18:30 Thank you. Different side of that, Carrie Hillbrand asks, why isn't there a serious backlash by IDF veterans, parents of drafties, bereaveve parents, etc. to the wholesale draft deferments and increasing benefits given to uh the yeshiva students because there is um if I understand correctly there is a question about why any military people former are not rejecting the benefits to the yeshiva because I'm not sure that the benefits of the Shiva students are so are So again it's dependent on point of view.
19:10 I'm not in a position where I think that the payment for the yeshiva students is threatening me. I don't think that involvement of yeshiva students in the IDF is the main problem. I think that we should be more concerned about them getting involved in the public and it will come not from the army but from going to the academia and going to work. This is the main issue and also you have to remember that there is a lot of criticism in Israel about the pension of military persons that they leave the army in a very very young age and get a very big pension. I'm sorry I'm moving because my little kid just woke up and she's joining me.
20:07 And uh so it's not so easy and you can find again secular like me that served in the IDF and think that the involvement of Khaled and the public it's a major challenge of Israel but it would come from the civil rights and not mainly from the IDF. Thank you so much. Uh Bar Barry Werner asks uh what we we've talked about this quite a few times, but uh given that Net and Yahoo is probably making that call this evening, uh what do you think the the reaction of the West will be to the new government?
20:50 I think the same reaction that was in the past for the same governments. And I think they might criticize it. I'm I'm not sure it's something that I I can be the person to answer it because I'm not a public relations or international expert. But I think that in the past to other Netanyahu governments there was a not a very good reaction. I don't see a reason why it will be different now.
21:30 Thank you. Uh is there any uh official opposition leader as of now? Uh it's an interesting question. Today I met two free two people from the Labor and and they don't I mean I can't answer this question because it won't be fair to anyone from their camp from Yid camp and Miki camp they saying that is not the leader of the camp but if you ask someone from Yeshid they will say is the leader of the camp for sure if there is leader of the camp it will be a lapided but the answers are different from different party to the other and obviously there is a lot of politics Benig Gans and laid are not best friends Liberman and Laid there was a black cat between them during the fight
22:33 with the committee of the teachers right before the elections Lieberman was a tougher than laid and there was argument between them. Miki and laid obviously are not friendly to each other because he blames her for the for losing the elections and she blames him. So it's very tricky like every in every camp but this is the situation. Thank you. Merad Ksari asks, "Is the ongoing protests in Iran helping Netanyahu's position visav the US, especially as there is a reluctance on the part of the Europeans to resume JCPOA talks?
23:19 I don't know. I regarding the Iran, I am just hearing what you are hearing. I I don't know if the I'm sure that Israel is in looking at a protest and seeking ways to use it, but I'm not sure how and what if they're planning to do Um I had a chance to talk with Yakov which was the head of the Malal the center for national security and he said that it's not a secret. He also talked about it in the news. He said that he thinks that this government will try to will try to be more aggressive about Iran. I don't know what it means.
24:13 If it means acting militarily or maybe international arenas, I don't know. I'm not sure I'm the person to to talk about Thank you. Uh so Jack Wasserman asked, "What will happen to or with Shakad?" I don't know. I heard this week that she enlisted to the Likood and to be someone that can vote in the Likood and to choose people. Maybe it means that she inspired to gain back her political career in the future in the liquid.
24:56 Thank you. And Barack Corkm uh expands upon our earlier question about Gansce. Uh do you think that Gance can uh balance the far-right effect on the Netanyahu government and would he be a defense minister and if yes what would Ben Gre and Matri do then I don't think Gans will be defense minister as it seems for today you have Galant is going to be the defense minister as I said before I don't think Gans if he will join it won't be now because the voters of the camp of Netanyahu be prop wouldn't like it and I think Netanyahu even if he wants to balance the government at least in the beginning he will try to satisfy his voters and maybe then invite guns for the It would be interesting to see if it happens and how if guns goes along with
25:59 all his party or not but again it's something that I don't see it happening in the near future. Maybe in a few months a year I don't know it very much depend on how this government will work together and I don't know how they will work together so I can't really tell. Thank you so much. One last question on uh Gance there. Uh do you think that he didn't release the body because uh he couldn't ex uh secure an exchange like you mentioned?
26:34 Maybe maybe they couldn't secure an exchange because the body of the prisoner will go to the PLO and the bodies of the soldiers are in a Gaza in the hands of Hamas. So maybe it's related. I don't know. In the eyes of the families of the victims, it doesn't matter because in their eyes, what matter is that the bodies won't be released and that the Palestinians won't So that was the main concern for these families. Um I'm not sure what was really God's um concerns or what he thought about.
27:20 Absolutely. Thank you. And Marie Felman. Uh so we had the recent article about Israel needing to take over the Temple Mount. Uh do you agree? And what are your thoughts on that that article that came out? I think the Temple Mount is a symbol to Israel sovereignty. Um it's interesting because I just saw message of Jordan saying that it expect the new government to keep the status quo in Temple Mount. I don't think Israel will do something extreme about Temple Mount. It didn't do before under Netanyao governments or other any government. But I think Temple Mount is definitely a symbol for Israel's sovereignty.
28:12 Absolutely. Uh and before we go, you uh we started off this webinar talking about the the laws that the new coalition is trying to get passed. Uh as of now, where do they stand and what are those laws specifically? The laws as I said are the law that giving it Benville more power over the police. Uh it's a law that will enable modric to be minister of finance but also have control over the kat and a law that will enable derry area for the head of chass to be minister.
28:58 I think I think I mentioned all the laws which are under discussion or debate. I think. Yeah. Okay, great. Yes, we we've heard those. I was just making sure we haven't missed any uh new ones coming out. All right. Well, thank you so much. We've come to the close of our webinar and podcast. Nea, thank you so much for taking time to update us tonight. Thank you for having me. Of course, for our viewers and listeners, please join us Friday at 1 p.m. Eastern with Emanuel Atangi discussing Iranian operations in Latin America. Thank you all for joining us and I hope you have a wonderful day.