Webinar or Talk
Why and How the British Media Empowers Islamists with Hannah Baldock
Watch on YouTube
Description
Mainstream media in the UK treats the Muslim Council of Britain (MCB) - its equivalent of CAIR - as the representative voice of Muslims, despite MCB's lack of popular support and its ties to extremism and terror. The media thereby elevates this dangerous organization, while sidelining genuine moderates. Why does it do so? Which organizations should it turn to?
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved November 2, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:01 hello and welcome to the Middle East forum's weekly webinar series my name is Sam westro I Am the director of its islamist watch uh program I'm delighted to be joined today by Hannah balok a journalist and counter extremism researcher most recently with the london-based Henry Jackson Society uh she holds a ba in modern languages from Cambridge University and a post-graduate diploma in journalism from City University London and Hannah has written very interestingly in recent weeks on and and months on the promising development of new reformist strains within British Islam as well as the threat the problem posed by extent islamist forces which have been around for decades and continue to enjoy legitimacy and recognition from the media and from policy makers um we're here to discuss that question to discuss why the British media in particular continues to empower islamists and legitimize them as representative British Islam and to ask what the solution might be Hannah hi thank you so
1:05 much for for for joining us if I could start off um can you very briefly for a primarily American audience explain who are the people what are the groups that British media turn to when they want comment from British Muslims oh Hannah you're on mute I apologies yeah I mean since around about 1989 when at the time of the um Salon rash um islamist factions who had um that work of literature and had made their voices heard very loudly in the Public Square at that moment for the first time um mobilized and and formed to the core of what became the Muslim Council of Britain um we heard in 2014 in a review by the coalition government led by David Cameron of the Muslim Brotherhood UK activ that that um organization obviously a revolutionary
2:09 islamist um uh outfit had been instrumental in setting up the Muslim Council of Britain as well as um the largest Muslim student organization which is recognized to be FIS um and the Muslim Association in Britain also became another front for the Muslim Brotherhood in the UK and uh but it's the Muslim Council of Britain who have prevailed really as the go-to outfit the first ported call for the British media journalists um when issues concerning Islam and Muslims arise and um they have had they have been the best organized they are an umbrella Organization for well they claim to have 500 Affiliates um and an report in 2016 by The polic Exchange choosing our friends wisely describ them as an umbrella Organization for forist groups um but that Den that description hasn't really stuck to them they have
3:14 generally um well they have set themselves up as voice for British Muslims and um have crowded out um other voices um who would beg to differ from their um which is really rooted in sort of extreme Orthodox patriarchal politics of um South Asia primarily that's that's who um their Affiliates are seen to um I see and and I should just take this this moment to remind our audience that there'll be a moment for questions at the end so if you do have any during uh this session please use the Q&A box at the bottom of your screen answer your question and I'll and I'll I I'll get to it um why did the MCB become this leading voice though what what what led journalist to turn to the MCB that was on C of Britain instead of other groups maybe less radical ones um well they they um I think
4:19 initially they were well funded um they I mean to one of their found um founding trustees and who who confided in me that well he had parted ways with as in Council of Britain because he' found them to be sarian in the extreme he did say they had had a lot of uh help from uh rich spons in the Gulf to set up and they began to produce very um polished press releases and statements u in a very timely fashion and um I think initially hoped that they could act as a bul against uh they've always condemned um EXT islamist violence in the UK although they haven't done so um in outside they haven't condemned um similar um violence that you might see in Israel for example um but they have um they seen to be um you know they were seem to be people that
5:24 the government could work with and um people that had a um a large constituency of of supporters um and that they could uh help the government sort of deconstruct what the problem seem to be um the problems that were um inciting the the violence um that we've seen uh over the last several decades um from islamist extremist groups I see and I believe in your piece recently for focus on Western islamism you mentioned that the government at time times has acknowledged the islamist roots of the Muslim Council of Britain um and indeed that that it continues to present a problem when it comes to matters of extremism so if this is the case why does the media still turn to the Muslim Council of Britain with the knowledge that they are empowering an islamist group is there is there a willful disregard of the threat that isaz imposes I mean it is it's baffling
6:28 really I mean there particularly since um SJ Javid for example who's the Muslim uh who was Chancellor at the time he was um standing to be leader of the conservative party back in 2019 um he said I would be very suspicious of what the musl Council of Britain has to say you know we don't deal with them and we haven't since 2009 because of links that they've had to extremists you find me a group of Muslims who is represented by the MC said um and uh nevertheless I think um there's there's um I think the person who sounded up best for me was pragna Patel who runs an outf called Southall black sisters which defends minority women's rights uh she said um that it's possible to fight racism and fundamentalism at the same time get it uh she says there's there's um there's a the Muslim Council of Britain have
7:32 successfully um portray themselves as the Muslim Community as Community which is um the underdog it's constantly uh in danger of um experiencing a racist backlash and being tired with the same brush as extremists and Tra the prevent counter extremism strategy as uh and assault on civil liberties of the of of Muslims and and assault on their free speech so it's actually deflected and denied really that islamistic ideology even exists or is a problem and has conflated uh Islam and islamism and and to the point where I think editors and producers who who really should have done rearch um on this very pressing matter which is rocking the Western World um they hadn't been confident of their own convictions in in distinguishing Islam from islamism uh and um and they have they have been um there been a lot I think
8:39 they talk of um post Iraq post Afghanistan Invasion guilt that the um the the the the doubt that possibly extremism is a blowback from these foreign policy um M some would call them mistakes or um ill- fated excursions into the Middle East and and um I think they have um let be um let let the seeds of doubt be planted in their minds that um whether islamist islamist ideology is is to blame for um these these attacks and uh the motivations behind them interesting and is this a portion of the media perhaps more on one side of the spectrum or is this a problem across the board well it has become a a problem across the board because um I mean the the the the BBC for example which is obviously the UK's um Flagship media uh
9:45 out it's the most watched It's the most watched internationally um and it has on several occasions in recent years invited um Talking Heads onto onto the sofas of Morning Britain or um uh this morning that's on ITV but I mean it's example Boris Johnson got into some hot water when he wrote an opinion piece about the Burker ban in Denmark um he said he wouldn't he he wasn't in favor of one in the UK but he did he didn't think that um essentially his argument was he didn't think it was um really very appropriate or necessary to to wear ni on the streets of Britain and um the BBC invited um Sahar Ali should to debate this point um who was builded simply as a woman who's covered her face since she was 14 on one and she was build as Muslim Council of Britain on the other um Al jazer Arabic described her quite differently said that she was um an know islamist well a member of the Saudi
10:50 opposition follower of uh the preach Safar Al haali who's the author of a book most western civilization in which he refers to the West as the enemy supports terrorist acts regardless of the effects on communities believes Muslims have a religious duty to support jihadists um G Forks looked on her Twitter feed saw pictures of um um H lead in an op open top cavalcade um she was wishing them a mighty Victory and the Muslim Brotherhood salute they were making the Muslim Brotherhood salute so a producer had the British public was being she went on to for the Welsh Senate um on the back of the huge publicity she garnered from her appearances on on Good Morning Britain uh until she finally more anti antisemitic tweets were unveiled and she was suspended from um FL kimry nationalist party but all of this is is has and this has happened time and time again um where um the British public has been invited to
11:54 listen to uh representatives of the Muslim Council of Britain or political lobbying off menend um and without any knowledge of of who they're listening to or you know what what what their world view might be and essentially it's always been to portray any doubts about um Islamic practices or doctrines as as uh based on ignorance islamophobia and um Prejudice so it's there's been a very um it's it's it's become a very merky um um picture for the fal Republic trying to understand really what what's going on fascinating and is there a role played here by foreign islamist powers foreign islamist States um we've all seen how for instance the Qatari regime uses media in the west to great effect and I'm thinking of things like Al jazer and Middle East ey and so on um does this have an effect on the way British
12:57 journalism covers uh uh uh Islam and islamism in the west um well I think I think um I think journalists often find that they um that there were there were several journalists who were very diligently covering um islamist groups and their activities one of whom was Andrew Gilligan he then went on to become transport um Minister uh in a conservative government but um uh there have been others um um who have uh made made documentaries um Andrew nor has has done quite a bit for the Sunday Times and I know a lot various of them have had to have experienced um uh they've been sued and they have been uh uh the the criticisms they've made have been um hotly contested um I think some of the
13:59 the group The some of the islamist lead groups in the UK have been using um very expensive lawyers like Carter BR who charge ,000 pounds an hour um to bring liable suits well it's now seen as really using law to sort of Silence criticism and there's been speculation as to who you know who might be who might have the Deep Pockets to help them pay for these um uh these very sort of defensive Li actions sometimes preemptive liable actions and um I mean I think that there has been I think you yourselves at folks on Western islamism have have uncovered a lot as as regards um uh support from Qatar for example for um some islamist groups in the UK and I think they have also some islamist groups have contributed to um ipso Guidance the guidance of the UK press regulator on reported on Islam and Muslims they've contributed to the
15:01 definition of islamophobia which uh was widely adopted 2019 um despite the opposition of counterterrorist experts um women's groups minority rights groups who said it um failed to distinguish between uh criticism of Islam and anti-muslim hatred and um so there's been a lot of smoke and mirrors and uh I think um the the best the best the best indicator of of um of how for Gulf Gulf States may be supporting these groups is just how deep their pockets are how many people they employ how slick the the um media campaigns are which which continue to be quite Relentless um and the counter extremism the counter prevent campaigns the islamophobia awareness month every every year which is which obviously they they have every right to raise issues over genuine uh
16:04 discrimination Prejudice intolerance but um it's the it's the con it's the the refusal to ever look inwards and um discuss the the possibilities of um um reform that might be needed within the Muslim Community and that's where these new uh groups which are coming onto the scene like the Oxford Institute for British Islam could be so very valuable to the National debate okay and and then just lastly before I head to some audience questions uh could you tell us about this new group then uh the the oi and and what its mission is and uh why you hope it will replace groups like The MCB as the go-to voice for for British media and policy makers yeah so I think basically that the groups like The MCB and their political Ling off men and um um the groups that really garnered the media attention have and try to dominate the discourse are predominantly sort of Sunni islamist um groups and um part of the criticism of the
17:10 islamophobia definition was that it didn't address any inter sectarian hostility which which has been seen very recently for example in the um the the attack on the free speech of a sh um Muslim um film producer and writer who who saw their film banned from Cinemas um due to some mob demonstrations um and um the IBI has set itself out to be pluralist um it it was founded by Dr taji he's a South African born um Muslim he doesn't describe himself as any one sect or another his MOS he's got a mosque in K the open mosque and another in Oxford which welcomes um people from all denominations all faiths and none and um he's tried to create um he says they're passionately pluralistic they want to um just create an open Forum um the debate what they're very
18:14 determined um about is to counter um divisive and uh interpretations of Islam they reject well they they are sort of a kurran centc as they call it outfit where they're happy to debate um verses of the Quran which are areum have been deemed to be controversial that they reject had the Sharia and the fats which they say are man-made um basically they reject they think that they're man-made um parts of Islamic Doctrine which are created by male clergy and designed to perpetuate their power power over um women and the and um the predominant position in in um in within you know Islamic countries and um so they want to just create a modern Progressive forward-looking um open and pluralistic um British Islam as they call it um
19:20 which is um aligned with what a lot you know is what the the Muslim Reform movement is a global Coalition of of Muslim reformers in fact one of their Founders Usama Hassan is also um a visiting fellow with the oi and um they want to also just I think um create a Port of Call for British Muslims who are C caught between um who are experiencing cognitive dissonance between their British identity and um you know which is pro pro secular democracy and obviously Pro individual freedoms and their Muslim identity which um they've been told in in many mosques you know is is at odds with um those values and um I think I think it's caused a lot of uh um it's caused a lot of um heartache and identity crisis for for many young Western Muslims and and and uh the iibi aims to theologically empower as it says young Western Muslims to um reinterpret
20:24 their faith in a way that's just more conducive with with living in the western world and in an open and free society and and obviously a pluralistic society that's it now um we've had a couple of questions about uh a new government in in in Britain and with the death of the queen uh I imagine uh Liz truss the new prime minister will have her attention like the rest of the country firmly focused elsewh for the next few weeks if not months however Bill bagot asks what changes will there be under trust when it when it relates to to islamism and in fact another questioner Richard kenfeld particularly asked does truss have any influence on the BBC can we at least have the BBC take a more reasonable line when it comes to the question of islamism so yes so I suppose two questions really one what are your hopes for the trust government on the question of islamism more broadly and two what about the BBC is a time uh uh uh that as a taxpayer fund of service that the
21:26 government imposed some sort of uh uh uh stricter rules on how BBC covers Islam islamism um Liz trust um I'm not sure what her um views on islamism are I know she was preoccupied with Ukraine I think is um foreign secretary I haven't heard her speak um specifically about islamism but um I would hope she would do more than Boris Johnson's government has done um on it it's um interestingly I mean Michael Gove who who was a member of Boris Johnson government had written a book on islamism well Celsius 77 he'd written after the the um 77 attack so it was surprising that he was um wasn't very proactive on on this issue um and um I think obviously was because it did such a a thorny issue there's a political and cultural trap in truthfully identifying the problems especially as they they
22:27 they V in constituencies um grow get larger Muslim Community but um we'll have to just watch the space with LZ Char I mean she's obviously going to have a lot of domestic um um very pressing domestic issues with cost of living crisis and um um and in and um you know energy policy and and um support for Ukraine I think um unless there's any fresh um Terror attacks or ities and and we then that that'll be when we find out but um with the BBC they have appointed a new director General Tim Davey um who was um I think appointed under the Boris Johnson government the BBC had kind of a lot of heat for um seeing um alleged leftwing bias um some of the some of the reporters they'd had who were particularly guilty of those types of lapses of editorial
23:30 impartiality like Emily matless of newsight have gone but again they do need to I mean they had um rashan s of of Five Pillars um on on newsight BBC's newsight recently who um debating you know the the Alle Lady Of Heaven this film that um the son islans had Wanted band and she introduced his website as just um a website popular with um Sun Muslims and whereas you know if you look on sarak Khan's sarak Khan who was the commissioner for countering extremism you know has repeatedly identified Five Pillars as as a supportive of of key tenet of islamist ideology including physical Jihad you know a caliphate um um you know death penalties for after States and so for and and they shouldn't be they need to to start identifying islamist as such and not just um and and also identifying islamist ideology as as
24:34 an ideology you know hostile to secularism um democracy Western social freedoms these are not it's just they do need to get a grip on this kind of cultural relativism where everybody's worldview is um um is is equally valid um in in terms of where this country is heading or should be wants to be heading but um uh I I I think um there's a learning cve for not just the BBC but all of the media about islamism as an ideology it needs to become as well understood as you know communism C capitalism and all of the other you know as it as a as a sort of ideology cooked up in the 20th century it's not a sacred um you know spiritual um project that we we can't discuss it is a it's a 20th century political idea ideology which needs to be deconstructed and debated um as rigor rigorously as possible um along with any other belief
25:37 system and they need to just uh sort of start um to stand well basically realize that the Muslim Council of Britain um with its line of Nar narratives of grievance and victimhood and islamophobia um they need to just take it with a pinch of salt and then and carry on to debate the issues um because really you know when when we're having MPS um sort of butchered in their constituency surgeries as the David Amos was last year we need to stop [ __ ] footing around the issues as as Dr T Hari the IBI would say um because it's reached a point where El Mania of um the oi she's a visiting fellow of the oi who wrote The Perils of nonviolent islamism she talks about the huge pink elephant in the room um of of the ideology which which um everybody knows is there but isn't discussing and um I think well
26:42 hopefully you know gradually as the Muslim reformers and including the Muslim Reform movement who've done some great work in America and I think um are listen to by many um interested parties over here if we can help them gain some more attraction um and counter the islamist marriage narratives um you know more and more editors and producers will hopefully cut on um so um I think we've got time for one more question although I'll combine several quite a few have asked about well this is very interesting about the situation in the UK is this the same in Mainland Europe um one one question to ask particularly about the group cage which is now focusing heavily on uh France and uh uh being active there so your your expertise is obiously the UK but do you consider the UK to be and it's the media's relationship with islamism in the UK do you consider that to be the UK to be particularly worse off or is this a problem Across the Western World at the moment no well it seems to me that um you know Emanuel maon has has grasped
27:46 the nle somewhat in in France um and uh last year I think after the stabbing of the Samuel PTI um the school teacher in the street um after he taught a lesson on blasphemy which by the way happened you know was something similar happened in Batley and Yorkshire and the teacher is still in hiding who tried to teach a similar lesson on Free Speech using um cartoons the prophet I think um um I think no I think it seems that France has been quite proactive um it's tried to get um imams to sign a declaration of um adherence to the values of the Republic um you know Free Speech tolerance of minorities and and um um women's equality and so forth I think it's actually basing a a a scheme to license imams only if they will declare an oath of allegiance to the B of the Republic it's closed down quite a lot of
28:48 um mosques which were um found to have hosted islamist speakers and um I think it is now de a raft of laws to try and tackle the problem I think um Germany's is doing um quite a bit and Belgium I think really the UK's been sitting on its hands rather with um in terms of doing any taking any concrete measures um to there have been several mosques who've where um there have been several documentaries undercover mosque was made in 2008 or um by BR braen was under undercover reporters who who went and um filmed some of the sort of hate preaching that was going on in mosqu but um one of the preachers in that film is still preaching at that mosque um the result of that was that channel four were sued by West mis's Police for sort of inciting racial hatred in a court case which they
29:50 lost so um it's um it's no it's it's been um surprising how little um I mean the government the last the government was considering Banning groups like hipsa um but it hasn't done there I think they are banned in some European countries I think their argument was that um it's better to defeat uh extremist groups like this by um debating them but then as as sarak Khan the counter extremism commissioner pointed out unfortunately nobody has they've they've had a pretty um long free run at um with their narrative and very few people have counted it uh those who have like herself have been smeared as islamophobes or part of the neocar or Zionist conspiracy um to do down Muslims and so it's it's wonderful that um the obibi and and other organizations British Muslims for secular democracy was another one um who tried to stand up
30:53 and counter um islamist ideology which which is not suppor by the majority of British Muslims and and as successive Studies have shown um just they have had loud voices they've had um lots of funding but they haven't got um majority support from the Bri community and and that's what needs to be um you know consistently repeated aired understood well H I feel we've we've come to the end of our time here so thank you so much for for coming on and explaining just uh A Whole New World of islamism to our audience uh for those who want to to read Hannah's recent piece it's said focus on Western islamism uh which is at islamism do newws uh Hannah thank you very much for your time uh I hope we'll be able to work together in the future and um uh for everyone else uh MEF runs a regular webinar Series so if you haven't already signed up on our mailing list to be alerted to Future webinars please do so at Emy forum.org thank you very much and have a wonderful weekend thank you bye
31:57 bye thank you bye