Webinar or Talk
"Dhimmitude: A Historical and Contemporary Perspective" with Bat Ye’or
Watch on YouTube
Description
In a world facing a resurgence of jihadist ideologies, the concept of dhimmitude—rooted in Sharia law and tied to historical jihad—casts a long shadow over modern societies. From blasphemy laws stifling free speech to the erosion of Judeo-Christian cultural identities, dhimmitude’s mechanisms are increasingly visible in the West. Unexpected alliances between jihadist movements, the anti-Christian Left, and antisemitic factions further complicate this global ideological war. How do these historical patterns shape today’s conflicts? What’s at stake for the future of Western civilization and global stability?
Bat Ye’or, originally born in Cairo, found asylum in London as a stateless refugee in 1957 and became British on marriage, settling in Switzerland. Since 1971 she has written a number of books and scores of articles on non-Muslims under Islam, adopting a biblical pen name, Bat Ye’or, or ‘Daughter of the Nile’. Her first essay, Les Juifs en Egypte (1971) was followed by a major study, The Dhimmi: Jews and Christians under Islam (English/1985). This is still an essential introduction to her second major work, The Decline of Eastern Christianity under Islam: From Jihad to Dhimmitude (English/1996) that confirmed her reputation as a pioneer thinker in this field. Then came Islam and Dhimmitude: Where Civilizations Collide (2002) which examined the trend toward dhimmitude in the 20th century and facilitated a serious assessment of the traditional ideology of Jihad. Her book, Eurabia: The Euro-Arab Axis (2005) provided an understanding of the gradual transformation of Europe into Eurabia, a cultural and political appendage of the Arab/Muslim world. Niall Ferguson praises: “No writer has done more than Bat Ye’or to draw attention to the menacing character of Islamic extremism.” She studied at University College London and the University of Geneva.
Bat Ye'or's books:
https://www.amazon.com/stores/Bat-YeOr/author/B000APQYP0?
Transcript Automatic captions
Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 19, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.
0:08 All right. Hello, good afternoon and welcome to the Middle East Forums weekly podcast series. My name is Anafav Kalam and I will be moderating today's Now in a world facing a resurgence of jihadist ideologies, the concept of dimitude, which is rooted in Sharia law and tied to historical jihad, casts a long shadow over modern societies. From blasphemy laws stifling free speech to the erosion of Judeo-Christian cultural identities, dimitude's mechanisms are increasingly becoming more and more visible across the west. Uh unexpected alliances between jihadist movements, the anti-Christian left and anti-semitic factions further complicate this global ideological war. How do these historical patterns shape today's conflicts? What is at stake for the future of Western civilization and global stability?
1:05 Joining us to discuss all of this is Batayor who has authored a number of books, articles and essays on this topic of dimitude over the last several decades. And we will begin today's episode with a brief lecture on the topic from Batyor followed by a audience Q&A section. And if you would like to ask a question, of course, you can use the Q&A box located at the bottom of your screen to type your question. And with that I will turn the discussion to Bat Yayor. Thanks for joining us.
1:39 Hello Has thank you to invite me to this um interesting discussion and lecture. Um the word dimitude desri describes the jeridical status of non-Muslim populations conquered by jihad. I will speak here only of Jews and Christians because they have the statute. This statute is enacted by the Sharia law. It establishes their political, economic, social and human conditions and their Islamic rule. A few words of jihad are necessary because jihad is linked to dimitude. The two institutions are correlated and the modality as the mor modality of the jihad uh battles and the prescriptions written into the pact of
2:42 submission of the vanquish population will be inscribed in the legal code of dimitude. So a few words of on jihad. Jihad is fundamentally different from western concept of war. It is not merely about territorial gain. Jihad is a is a theological war that seeks to impose Sharia law globally and suppress all non-Muslim religions. Jihad must continue until the law of Allah rules the whole humanity. Peace between ma Muslim and miscreants is unlawful only temporarily truth is allowed but only if it is in conformity with Sharia norms otherwise it is invalid. The miscreants embody the enemy of Allah because they rebel
3:49 against his will and refuse to become Muslim. They are um there are henceforth the answer the essence of evil and have no personal rights. They are like objectives animal and can be treated with the utmost cruelty and this is happened the seven October but it is normal in jihadist war. Historically, jihad has extended again uh has extended across three continents, Africa, Asia and deep into Europe and continue till today. The non-Muslim populations who survived jihadis conquest were allowed to live in their own country tolerated only under strict conditions. Security for their life,
4:54 their family, their good and religion was guarantee. They could also keep their own civil law. However, they had to accept discriminatory legal statute dictated by jihadist legal code and Islamic Jewish prudence both rooted in religious scriptures. It is this statute that I call dimitude. Dimitude therefore is a direct consequence of jihad and is tied to these two fundamental pillars of Islamic theology and civilization. Jihad and Sharia. Jihad, Sharia and Dimitude being fundamental component of Islamic civilization, religion and faith are thus extremely difficult to reform. As
6:00 jihad expanded, so did the number and diversity of the ind indigenous population subject to the laws of dimitude increase despite the different inre increed culture, language, behavior. They share the same reality. Submission to the same or more or less same. harsh Islamic legal frame frame uh legal framework. This is why we can speak of a civilization of dimitude spread across continent and lasting for centuries.
6:47 Today we are witnessing a powerful resurgence of jihad bolstered by unexpected alliance the anti-Christian left the excommunist factions neonazi and western western anti-ionist we are facing a relentless global ideological jihad war against Judaism and Christianity this jihad this movement is is spearheaded by fundamentalist group and but I I have to uh to underline and this is important that not all Muslims share their extremist views quite contrary often many Muslim government also actively oppose them but since The 1970s, jihad has taken on a new
7:50 dimension, one that involve mass Muslim immigration into western countries countries and is co closely tied to Palestinianism, a jihadist Nazi movement aiming at the eradication of Israel. This movement has collaborated ideologically and militarily with both Nazism and fascism from the 1920. The dimitude laws apply equally to Jews and Christian. Yet their effect on these two groups were not identical.
8:36 When the conquest began in the seventh century, Jews were still numerous in their country, Judea, Palestina, and throughout the diaspora, but they lack a central authority. In contrast, Christians represented powerful kingdoms with armies, bureaucracies, national languages, culture, and state While the Muslims were only minority mainly of Arab and late later Turkish military invading tribes but within two to three centuries the picture has totally reversed.
9:25 Christian majority became impoverished, marginalized minorities, stripped of their language, their legal power, their c cultural identity. Meanwhile, the Muslim uh rose to ruling position. Arabic replaced the ind indigenous language land later it was Turkish and Sharia replace the former Christian legal systems. I co the term dimitude to describe the mechanism that transform a judo Christian civilization strong civilization into an Islamic one. While studying these complex mechanisms I began noticing their introduction into Europe. I will just mention a few uh now first the
10:32 blasphemy law. I want first to point out that the Islamic concept of blasphemy is different from that notion in Judaism Christianity. Since the Rushi affair, the Islamic blasphemy law is now in entrenched in European societies. People accused of offending Islam are placed under police protection. Their professional, personal and family lives are destroyed. Blasphemy in Islam carry the penalty. then uh it is quite dangerous to uh to offend Islam. Uh and today self uh censor self self censorship dominates public discourse author journalists politicians and lecturers live in fear of offending
11:38 Islam. This fear and suppression of freedom of speech is a defining characteristic of dimitude. Then there is insecurity in the civilization of dimitude. Jews and Christian were forbidden from um bearing arms and from giving testimony in Sharia tribunals. They live in perpetual fear because they could never defend themsel if they were physic physically aggress um there were accused falsely accused uh of having done a crime because they would not never been able to uh to theirel by fighting the Muslim or because they would have been killed by law or to defend themsel in front of a tribunal because their testimony would
12:44 not be accepted. And this was the case of BB Assa BB for instance in in not long ago. So um uh jihadist um uh the west in the modern west now insecurity arises from terrorism and we cannot know there is a difference between terrorism and the jihadist tactic because a jihadist tactic has a aim. It has um it wants to um to impose on the a miscrean state. It want to impose Sharia laws. So um now there is a terrorist there is insecurity in e in Europe and we know that the jihad this warfare includes killing and we have
13:50 suddenly killing at random uh satic fire and hostage taking among other crimes all justifies by religious law of war against miscreants. I don't want to say that this jihad this war are done uh by uh in in Europe um um by all Muslims but unfortunately we have such crimes done by Muslims also against other Muslims. So the law the um the um um the laws which um normal laws democratic laws that respect the the security of everyone whatever religion are not respected now or always in Europe. Now we have also the destruction
14:56 of the religious site and attacks on synagogue and church are common in the civilization of dimitude reflecting the deep rooted disrespect for non-Muslim worship and now in Europe unfortunately synagogue and um churches have to be um have to be protected. There is also the refusal to accept non-Muslim authority. Sharia consider obedience to non-Muslim ruler as submission to infidelity which is uh forbidden in in Islam. Therefore, there is a often uh concerted effort to undermine the legitimacy of non-Muslim governance and the cultural norm. This discrepancy between two system of law based on
16:00 contradictory concept of justice and peace appear also in the international uh forums of the UN. um because um where um 56 Muslim uh countries are voting and they vote according to uh the norms of jihad and Sharia. Then we have um the principle of gender inequality and the fact that the Muslim declaration on human rights must be always in conformity with Sharia norms and this this belief this um uh this feelings are increasing increasingly being intro introduced pushed into western contrasting sharply with secular western
17:05 values. But I repeat, it is not all Muslims and all Muslim immigrants who are uh imposing uh this uh situation of con of confusion and um also of social interest. In conclusion, I will mention the collapse of the educational system. Islamic and western view of history are incompatible. For example, it is increasingly difficult to teach the Holocaust in school. In the wa in the west his Hitler and the Nazi regime are condemned for their atrocities because of the second world war. Seion people died. But in the Musl Muslim world, Hitler is seen as a hero and Nazi ideology was shared and supported
18:14 um and by propaganda. The so-called new anti-semitism we we see today is not new at all. It is a continuation of all dimitude and jihadist hatred uh toward Jews which has merged with Nazi ideology and terminology. It is Nazi Islamism. In walkism, the hatred against the white westerner which embodies the essence of evil make me think of the hatred against the miscreant and his jaha culture that has to be eliminated. It is important to teach in schools the history of jihad and dimitude. Jihad is a major page of human history. It is a force that has changed the face of continent that does have suppressed many people and cultures. The
19:22 same with the civilization of dimitude which has affected millions of people on continents and continues till today. It is important today to know well these notions because they are very pregnant in our own time. History is not only western history. We have to know the history the Islamic history Islamic of other continent in Asia and other places. And we have to know what motivated has motivated jihad. So we shall be better prepared to challenge it in order to keep our values, identities and able to make peace with uh with the Muslim people if uh we succeed in have jihad abolished
20:29 uh in the uh UN um in the UN uh United Nation uh forum either condemned or um or uh suppressed. Well, Manny, thanks for your lecture. That was very insightful and very eye openening. Something uh a topic that we also don't talk very much about here on this podcast. So, uh we appreciate you sharing your insights. Now, uh, I'll begin with a question here. In your concluding remarks, you mentioned long-standing collaboration between Nazism and fascism, and you mentioned uh, collaboration with Hitler and the Nazis, and uh, I don't want to deviate too far from the topic at hand, but one thing that has been of interest to me and I don't think is discussed very frequently. Can you speak about the relationship between Hitler and the Grand Muy of Jerusalem and how did that play out for Muslims and non-Muslims in
21:34 Europe during that time? Um between Hitler and Amal Husini. That's right. Yes. Um well uh the the the relations were very good. First of all, Hitler has a great admiration and also the top leaders surrounding him in Nazism. He had a great admiration for Islam and there were also um Muslim military formations um included in the Vermark and also in the SS. And he always complimented them and they had a special fa uh favorish uh treatment by the by him and by the the Nazi the Nazi hierarchy military hierarchy and government. So the the
22:38 relations were very good and uh also um Hitler regret that his uh Christianity that Europe was Christianed. He he he regrets that the Islamic army had been had been vanquished by Christianity. And so um now uh the um the MUI thought that u he will do the same as uh as Hitler the the extermination policy of the Jews in the Muslim countries. He was all prepared for that and the Jews from the Arab countries knew that because the MUI was speaking or uh from Bari or other other um stations. He was speaking to the Arab to the Arab and Muslim world. There was a strong strong implication the MUI was
23:44 not the only one to collaborate with the Muslim with the Nazi system. There were many other MUI and other Muslim leaders from uh the Muslim world from um the whole Muslim world. They were represented in the in in the in the third ray rush. The third rush was enormous. It covered most of the countries of Europe.
24:18 It was not only Germany. So we have this this Nazi this Islamic penetration and influence on the whole superficy of the Nazi uh the third Raj and this has continue after the second world war the after the peace I did don't want if you want me to continue because the Muslim world invited the uh the criminal the Nazi criminals they may be there was a there was a collaboration militarily also and Muslim countries Egypt, Iraq, Syria invite the Nazi criminals to come to their country after the second world war. So the Nazi influence continue and it continued parti particularly with the Palestinians because they formed them they formed the the the Arafat and the
25:24 terrorists of Arafat. He Arafat was in Egypt. He was an Egyptian. He was in Egypt living in Egypt and there were the Nazi imig criminals there. under NASA and they contribute to uh to form uh the the Arab terrorist to form them militarily to attack uh to attack Well, thank you. Now, um we'll see some of those uh hopefully uh in the rest of these questions how some of those historical uh items contribute to modern society in the west. Now, how has it been possible for many Muslim communities who themselves began in a position as a minority group in countries where they settled in the west? How is it that they were able to grow so rapidly that they are now able
26:27 to exert their influence and demands over their non-Muslim neighbors in a a salient way? You are speaking of now. Yes. Yes. Well, this is what I have explained in my book Arabia. There were there were there were welcome. they were privileged. So there is a by the government they wanted this immigration for se several reasons. First of all, the Muslim world. First of all, they knew all these country, the Europe, the European Union. First of all, the European community, the nine countries of the European community which have start the a a policy of of um immigration in their um in Europe. This
27:31 this policy it was not a simple policy. It was linked with a lot of of um um alliance with the Muslim world because the Muslim world was very rich. First of all, there was a strong contact with this uh this between Europe and the Arab countries because Europe many countries of Europe have been colonist colon col col colonial power. Then there was the this the uh then the the colonialism end but they kept good relations with their former colonies and they want to keep a good relations with the those countries. It was normal. So uh because first of all the Mediterranean is not so so big and um so they want to keep because they want to keep they knew that they
28:36 had it was econom economy economically good also for them. And um then so there was um there was a a a whole The pact for instance the pact of Barcelona which is you can found it. It is it is known it is it was signed between Europe and the Arab countries the Muslim countries um in 1994 but before the back of Barcelona there was a a lot of um of um arrangements and networks on uh and cultural political everything uh to organize also the immigration and have uh the immigration happy immigration well settled in Europe. But um and then
29:45 um then um if you ask me how this situation happened, it is because the Muslim population was the the immigration population population was It is too long to explain but if you read my book you will see uh how it was done but as my say I must say that because I've have written Arabia and um Europe and the coming caliphate which I explain how it happened all this I have I had to be put under police protection and all my writing were refused. I could not publish anything nor in newspaper. I could never I could not speak in public. All my all my
30:51 appointmentments were uh nified. uh and I was treated like a paria in uh even if my name appear appeared in a book the book could be refused or if it appeared in another in an article written by some someone else the article could be refused. my name was uh polluting any any book and any uh writing piece.
31:30 So this uh for years well that is uh that is outrageous and tragic. Um now we're uh reaching the end here. I uh I hope you might have time for maybe one more question then we can uh wrap up. But uh on that note there, why do you think it is that some western countries push back harder against blasphemy blasphemy laws and they seem to defend freedom of speech more adamantly than other countries in the West who seem to prefer to appease the demands of Muslim communities and oftentimes will capitulate to them.
32:14 Well, because first of all the po Muslim population is very big. Secondly, secondly, it is very affirmative and also because it has uh it can do it can uh uh do crimes and therefore and the western government don't know how to answer to that and secondly there are afraid of terrorist of reprisal terrorist reprisals and they don't want that and also they are afraid to see their relationship with the Muslim countries to deteriorate and they want this relationship. They want absolutely to have good relationships with the Muslim world. This is why they have done all that. In the views of some, not all
33:19 but in the views of some uh Europe should be and anyway this was the demand of the Arab side during negotiation or uh dialogue what I call the politic of dialogue and so on. uh they wanted uh uh Europe to um take its distance from America from the USA. So this was the demand of the they wanted a a more free Europe not always submitted according to them to the US.
33:57 But you know the politics of it of Europe is very complex but because there are different parties they're not so not all all opinions are the Secondly, uh um this policy of which I am speaking to you was done through uh a body which is the the the um uh comm uh uh com the European Union European community which has several bodies. It has its parliament.
34:40 It's um uh European Council and European Parliament but these are the main one but there are a lot lot of others commissions which are doing which are running this policy with the Muslim um people the Muslim state and the the European people didn't know all that they didn't realize what was going on that in fact they were giving to the European Union they were giving a lot of their power the sovereign sovereign powers they they didn't realize that so now there is a lot of problem in Europe because they want to change policy but they they cannot because they are tied to the policy decided the uh the um immigration policy decided by the
35:44 European Commission and the European Union. So it looks like they are themselves prisoners of what they have done or their government have done without them knowing it. So it is complicated but um I don't know what will be done. The problem also about having a policy that uh uh that uh is against Muslim is not right because we have a lot of Muslims who are encouraging us on the contrary to be stronger against the the the fundamentalist one, the radical ones, the Muslim themselves. there are threatened and there are uh advising us to be strong against them. And the problem is that they came to Europe to
36:47 protect themselves from the from the the Sharia governments in their own countries. And now now as in Europe we cannot protect them either because they are um they reject Islam or there are they are converted or for all other uh that make them uh have make them chose Europe and living within the democratic laws of Europe. So it is a complex situation and I don't know how do our government will respond to that.
37:31 uh how Europe can respond to that because we have a democratic laws we cannot act um uh too strongly harshly I don't know and uh the European uh nations have also their political orientation which to my view extremely anti- Zionist anti-Israel very much linked to the to the terrorist uh to the ter terrorist movement like Hamas even help helping me know with the uh with the UN um organization.
38:19 So with the UNRA and so on so and also with on Lebanon with the Hezbollah with the UN uh the UN organization troops there which didn't stop the Hezbollah while they were ready while they should have done it. So there are a lot of things to say on that. But how to change now when you have millions and millions uh of immigrants in Europe uh who have a different culture, different uh way of thinking about gender, about uh what is uh the miscreant laws they don't want to they don't want to assimilate to accept those Um this is for this generation and the
39:29 next generation a great problem to solve. Maybe people says a a Christian uh Maronite friend told me the future of Europe is Lebanon. So I hope it won't be but we are taking this way. Well uh it's uh it is hard to be optimistic. Uh to me it kind of seems like the damage has already been done but uh Lebanon is a good uh a good end goal to hope for given the circumstances. Now, we have unfortunately run out of time for today's podcast, but Byor, I want to thank you again for taking the time to give us your insights today and to join us, especially given the time difference. I understand it's quite late where you are. So, thank you for that.
40:24 Thanks so much. Thank you. Thank you very much. Thank you. Of course. Now uh for our viewers and listeners, Batyor has authored a number of books on this subject and if you are watching this on YouTube, I will be sure to put the links to those books in the video description and would encourage you to check them out, purchase them and read them if you'd like to learn more. As always, we thank you again for your viewership, for your participation, and I hope you have a wonderful day. Thanks. Thanks. Thanks.