MEF Menu
Middle East ForumDonateSupport MEF
Middle East ForumMEF Event Library

MEF Event Library

Webinar or Talk

War Against ISIS and the Future of Syria: A Conversation with Sinam Mohamad

Watch War Against ISIS and the Future of Syria: A Conversation with Sinam Mohamad on YouTubeWatch on YouTube

Description

Sinam Sherkany Mohamad is the chief of mission at the U.S. Mission of the Syrian Democratic Council.
Jonathan Spyer is the director of research at the Middle East Forum and the editor of Middle East Quarterly.

Transcript Automatic captions

Source: Automatic captions from YouTube, retrieved October 28, 2026. Automatic captions are machine generated and may misspell names and terms; check the video before quoting.

0:04 okay everyone will welcome to the uh first afternoon session of the Transformations 2023 conference and uh it's a very great pleasure for me I'm a Jonathan spire and I'm the uh uh the editor of Middle East quarterly currently and also the director of research at Middle East forum and it's a very great pleasure and uh honor for me to introduce the speaker for this session which is Mrs Cinema and sinam is the representative of the Syrian Democratic Council SDC Mission here in the USA and here in Washington DC just a brief introduction she's a a senior Diplomat of the autonomous administration of Northeast Syria and she serves on the SDC presidential Council and Mrs Muhammad has been a leading advocate for women's rights in Syria for more than two decades I first met her we were just recalling when she was running the European mission of SDC

1:07 a few years ago she's a graduate of the University of Aleppo I believe that she grew up in Aleppo and was born in Damascus so the way this is going to work is that I'm going to ask synonym a couple of questions and she's going to respond for as long as she wishes and uh and hopefully this will be a very informative for all of us so the first question synonym that I'd like to ask you is really quite a general one really how would you assess and see the current situation in Syria what should we be noticing or paying attention to with regard to developments in Syria at the present time you should be have the microphone on they should okay you should be audible yeah thank you so much uh good afternoon everyone thank you so much it's my it's my pleasure today to be here to talk about the most

2:13 important issue in our days in the Middle East the problem and the crisis of Syria I'm Sita Muhammad from the Northwest originally from Afrin the Kurdish small Kurdish City I was born in Damascus but I grew up in many Syrian cities I studied in the let me see the the Christian schools during my first I mean till the high I graduated from the University of Aleppo from English literature as you know now the problem or the crisis of Syria started in 2011.

3:05 when it started many of the Syrian people they were inspired that they will achieve something we will have our freedom democracy as all the people the Western Country and plurality Syria is like an uh you know multi we can say Nations and religions it is diverse in Syria we have you can see the Arabs Kurdish people we can see even the Aramaic dursis sunnis Christian Muslim and so on this diverse we see the domination of the past party which is very nationalistic very naturalistic and denying the other rights of the people

4:09 especially the Kurdish people which is the second let us say great minority in Kurdish people has about about more than 3 million people living in the north and Northwest East and Northwest of Syria so all the people you see that they they saw that we we can do something with the interfering of many Regional countries in the Syrian crisis turkey Iranian Russians you know all the interfere in the Syrian crisis started to have a very radical extremist group coming to and they were saying that we are rebellions and we have to build a new Syria which depends as a let us say Islamic State

5:13 which is not our goal our goal to have a pluralistic Syria Democratic Syria the unity through diversity which we have it but to have only the Islamic State so we are in this case we replace the Assad and we will have the others in the authoritarians to have the Islamic and which is not the the the dream of the Syria people they they want to so for that we can see in Syria it has been divided now if we look at the Syrian map you can see the red color which is now under the control of the Syrian you can see the yellow color which is under the control of the Syrian Democratic forces which I represent here the political wig

6:17 of it Northeast Syria and the Greek color which you can say it is under the control of turkey has been occupied by turkey and the people original people of this season has been displaced if we look at the northwest of it Afrin it is my home City hometown 2018 has been occupied by turkey 300 000 of the people of Africa Kurdish they be displaced and now they are living in the camp as well as my my family my family has been displaced now none of them can stay there because they will be killed or arrested so the people who is now governing the africity many multi military groups extremist islamist group

7:22 very nationalistic extremist Islamic group they are controlling by City occupying the people's Corrections they occupied my properties in Africa they occupied everything there I'm not able now I don't have anything after you know you your life you're building your life there and you have made a lot of issues there like factories business everything has why because I'm Kurdish I'm working here and advocated for democracy which they don't like it so now we have now 300 000 displays from the city of Africa demography changing has happened Afrin is a Kurdish City 98 percent were Kurds now we have 22 percent only Kurds so they are changing the demography of

8:27 Afrin as well they are changing the demography of all the green area which is you can see here so they built their own system building on I mean based on the extremism and this is what happened can I ask can I come in there and ask you a question uh sinam regarding this situation and where things may be heading as we're all following closely in the media the Assad regime is currently returning to the mainstream of acceptability first of all in the Arab world and very possibly also quite soon even regarding the International Community what does that mean for the Syrian Democratic Council and for the de facto Authority which you represent here which controls now roughly 30 percent of Syria as we can see on the map what does that mean for the future of your Authority yeah it is very important question actually the yellow area which we control now it's called the autonomous Administration area of North and East there is a government there

9:32 providing services for about more than 5 million people not only Kurds Arabs Syriac Christians Kurds Armenian turkmen all who is living in the North East Syria dialogue in the yellow area is governed now by the autonomous the autonomous advisation it is not only Kurdish people who is ruling there we have the plurality we have the diversity and we have the co-chair like we Christians Syriac Arab and kurd they are running this area together so we prefer to work together in the Northeast Syria as cured an Arab and Syria regression and so on either than to fight each other we have here multi-colors multi-religence multinations in the this area we build our system based on equal genders imagine we have the participation of the woman about 50

10:38 percent in all the institutions which is not there in any in other area in the green area the woman has been neglected because it is you know extremist they don't believe in women we have the freedom of religions the Christians the these Muslims Sunni whatever you have the freedom of religions whereas in the other region in the green area you have one religion one color Islamic finished has been persecuted and have been forced to be Muslim or to live and this is what happened so such a model in the Northeast Syria we want to be inspiring all the Syrian in all over Syria we worked through 13 years on this program I mean project now we see that the government Syrian with the normalizing with the Arab

11:44 countries going back to the Arab plagues you know for us we don't I mean see maybe we want to end the suffering of the Syria people Syrian people suffered a lot through 30 years ago economy is very bad all over the the Country economy is very bad the people in the control area of the Assad regime is suffering more and more unless this when the the earthquake happened that time you know started we can see that the prophecy of the earthquake started and the Arabs they realized that they have to do something to end the suffering of the Syrian people we want also to end the suffering of the Syrian people we fed up with the war we fed up with all these things but we want to build something which is a new not to come back as if nothing has happened no changes

12:48 if normalizing with the Assad regime is going on it's okay but let us have let us have some change let us have some democracy there let us have some inconstitution to change something to have the right of the in Constitution to have the right of the woman and the Kurdish people at the Celiac and the others this is what we need to see otherwise to have the normalization with the Assad government without changing so as if we are we did nothing 13 years million of the Syrian people refugees hundreds of this place inside this place hundred thousands and hundreds or so thousands be killed the country has been destroyed and we got nothing then we will go back to the first the point which is not acceptable so we need to see some changing during this normalization if normalization happening all the Arab countries they now they

13:51 accept it okay do it but don't accept as it is we have to make a changes and this is what we really need in the Northeast Syria I think I don't know if you I mean many but people knows we defeated the Islamic State Isis city was the capital city of the Islamic State imagine we defeated them our Syrian Democratic forces defeated Isis in the region how many people we have lost there you know 11 000 of our women and young men have been killed while fighting Isis do I fight Isis and I defeat Isis only before me defending my people no it's defending all of you the whole world I was fighting on behalf of all the world in my vision and then at the end I will got nothing

14:54 so we need this support from the U.S Administration and we got now they say we will not leave you we will stay there now we have about 900 troop U.S troops then they are still there and we I mean ask them to stay unless we get to a political solution for the ending the Syrian crisis we need that we are I mean ready to negotiate with the Syrian with regard to that as far as I'm aware there are negotiations taking place in Damascus between representatives of your Authority and the Assad regime what are the current state of those negotiations because as far as I have been aware at least the Assad regime has been completely inflexible in terms of granting any kind of promises of of autonomy and I guess the situation they're waiting for and I guess this is a second question in a way my sense at least is that the what they're waiting for is they're waiting for U.S withdrawal of those 900 troops and then they think that they will get the whole

15:58 thing back uh 100 so maybe you can comment on and this is what we're afraid of yeah and you're afraid that the U.S one day they will decide to withdraw and what would happen to our lesion before we have any negotiation or agreement with the Syrian government Iranian militias they will be very happy to come Russian the same regime and turkey how many times turkey attack our Legion and occupied all the greed area turkey wanted to create a safe Zone all around along the border is it a safe Zone to displace the people the original people and replace them with the very Sunni radical group is it a safe Zone actually this green area under the control of turkey has became a safe haven for the former leader of Isis and Al-Qaeda in my city afried

17:01 the leader of al-Qaeda are very free working coming and going imagine so if we leave it like that turkey will control it and would be happy to take it Russia will be happy to see the government as well and Iranian which they are waiting so for that we ask it please we don't want you to stay forever in Syria we know that we are not asking you to stay forever but we ask you to stay there until we guarantee the negotiation with the Syria government and get something for our people rights this is what we need really it's very important now we are not against that Syrian government I mean Syrian to be ending the cities this crisis we are with that as long as we have a crisis in the region the whole Middle East will be endangered you know radical groups they are coming they are increasing they come everywhere

18:04 so everyone but they realize that it is a problem it is a dangerous to leave the the the issue like that say they have to find the solution so the the the radical groups they started to threaten the whole Regional the capital for instance they threatened the regional countries like Saudi Arabia Jordan Lebanon and so on so they realize that as well as long as the mess in Syria is there they will got a lot of problem so the Arab country started to you know fix it and they started to normalize with this Assyrian government so that they can you know solve the problem and do something so this is we are not against to solve the problem we are not against to end the crisis but it should not be on the expenses of our people that people who fought Isis and the people who sacrificed you know their lives in order to protect the other

19:07 as well as Isis is still there so I wanted to ask you exactly about that really sin on from what we hear and we don't hear a great deal in the media bless you but what we hear is that Isis is still operating that there are still operations and killings carried out by ISIS and of course you have the al-hal prison camp under the jurisdiction or Syrian Democratic Council yes whether if I'm not mistaken 10 000 prisoners of Isis many Isis prisoners many of whom are of course citizens of countries other than Syria so maybe you could tell us a little bit about the current state of affairs of operations against Isis and I think in particular people might be interested to hear also about the type and mode of cooperation between your forces and the U.S forces also present on the ground in that area yeah thank you for the questions really in in the region after defeating the Islamic State of Isis we still have Isis we end Isis military geographically that's okay but still

20:12 we have very important and dangerous issues the ideology of Isis still is and we have the sleeper cells of Isis who is activating and working and trying to re-emerge and gain organizing themselves again in the region we have 12 thousands Fighters dangerous fighters of the Isis in the presence database centers twelve thousands imagine these people if they escape what would happen who is guarding them our forces and I would like to thank the U.S also Army for their support for the training equipping this forces really we got some equipment training I mean from the the US Army but it is still not enough 12 000 in the present last January in the last year 2022 they tried to escape 200 of them they try to escape and we

21:18 get them back control them so if the 200 of the Isis leader they escape you will see them at the next day at the front the border of Mexico maybe coming here yeah who knows yeah so we have to be careful about that so who will guard them we are guarding when the riots happen in the present you know we we lost 124 from our forces in order to get them back in the present and they killed our people there just in a very cold you know blood so we are the the one that regarding these people as well as we have the El Campo a whole of the camp which holds about 54 thousands the families of Isis children women men in this al-holkat who is providing all these services for

22:21 our whole cab we are doing autonomous Administration our forces are guarding this last year in al-holkam a man who is giving like from the Kurdish red the Crescent providing health I mean help to al-holkam inside the whole he has been killed by a woman Camp so it's still dangerous so still there we have two very dangerous spots al-holka and the prisoners of Isis we have to solve this we ask it to have the repatriation for such people many of the countries they started to repatriate from the whole Camp women and children but none of country wants to get the fighters they say oh keep them there but it is not my responsibility alone to keep such a dangerous you know Fighters whereas it is the responsibility of all over the

23:25 the countries so am I what should I do the place is still under threat so this is the issue with for that we say the presence of the United States the U.S Army in the region is very essential now unless we solve such all this problem now here and I will just say something in a whole camp we have about 25 thousands children who has been raised by their radical mom in a whole cab they became more dangerous than their Fighters so if they stayed like that since 2019 we have it so imagine how many years now the child who has been that time 12 years old now he has been a man so after still many years if we don't solve this problem we will have a new generation of Isis coming out from an Old Camp again so what would happen so we I think for that it is very

24:29 essential the U.S army stayed there unless we solve such a problem and whole Camp prisoners and have a negotiation with the Syrian government to reach a at least to get something we are not against to have the stability in the region we want it we want the stability but how can you get the stability if you have always the threat of Isis in the presence are there how do you get the stability if you are always you are having the uh the Turkish shedding dual region and your people either sharing with the artillery sharing or by drone attack so how can we have the stability if you don't have stability in the Northeast Syria I don't think we will have stability in all over the region I think there's some there's a point here which is worth stressing the cinema you made it but just to really stress the issue that there is quite an astonishing cynicism I think of some Western governments specifically in Europe

25:31 regarding the repatriation of their citizens they take advantage of the fact that Syrian Democratic council is not of course recognized as a state or quasi-state authority which means like the SDC can't insist your citizens came here to fight as islamist volunteers now take them back again because SEC doesn't have that status these countries are able to say our citizens are now your problem and as a result you're having to look after these guys in alcohol it's a completely ridiculous and very cynical situation we're a little bit short of time we're unfortunately only have a short session so I wanted to ask you also if I may to talk a little bit about the internal Arrangements of SDC you mentioned it but for example the role of of women which is quite unique in terms of your area compared to others can you tell us a little bit about the internal Administration in STC how that works and how it differs from both Assad regime area and the islamist areas controlled by the Turks thank you so much for that uh you know as you mentioned before as

26:35 the autonomous Administration it is not a state it is not recognized so however when we asked even the humanitarian assistant to come to the region through the United Nation they will not handed it to us directly so they will give it to the Syrian government and Syria government should bring it to our region and we we don't get you know we get just a small maybe sometimes very less from that so we have BC I mean we are besieged now in the the area which is in the yellow color it's about a third of Syrian so we have from the the turkey SBC we don't have any border from the Syrian government also same sometimes we have I mean sometimes open sometimes not according to the the political issues we have some coordination with the Syrian government it is a condolation only and even the Kurdistan region also from

27:39 the Kurdistan region we have some boarding now it has been closed Ali Arabia has been closed so we need that border to have some humanitarian assistance to the people as we have a hundred thousand of displaced people in the Northeast Syria yeah so the system which is going on the administration of the Northeast Syria which is in the yellow area now I can't talk about it at the administration of Northeast Syria we have like a multi as I said mentioned religions and Nations and so on so we have there the each institutions you can see Arab Kern Syria each of them they are working together we have the system of co-chair so we have the coaching like being the Kurdish woman with the Arab guy or the city equipment with the Arab Kurds and so on so in each institution we have all these diverse in the institution this is very important for us we believe in this

28:44 diversity we believe in plurality this is what we want to so to see in the future of Syria as well as I mentioned for the role of the woman which is very now we have like a social contract we can call it social contact all the people more than five five billion people they come together they agree to this social conflict which we say that we have for instance official languages the Kurdish language the Arab language the Celiac language language it is the first time in the history of Syria that you can find the Aramaic language the people in the school they can study in their language the other the Kurdish they can study in their language the Arab they can study in their language whereas in the all the other part of Syria you can't find that

29:48 in the control area of the regime only we have the Arab country Arab language which I like it but as I'm that Arabic I have to learn also my mother language so it is that time it is not allowed in the green area controlled by turkey we have turkification Turkish language Arabic language only so imagine so this is the difference when you deny the rights of the others and you don't accept only you accept your own either religion or language which is not acceptable we are now on 25th first century where we have the Democracy we see the people in in America how do they live they don't have you know any problems so why should we shouldn't we have the same thing we need that it is enough we as a curse I know I remember when I was kid I was not allowed to speak in Kurdish language never

30:51 even if I am in the school I was in the high school if my colleague is occurred if I want to speak with her Kurdish in the break time I will be my name will be taken to the the manager there or they will be put my name in the you know they say why are you speaking I will be punished imagine so and nobody can speak the Kurdish language we only speak it in in our at maybe if they they could prevent at home maybe they can also do it but even though we continued learning our language we never I mean just say okay I forgot no it's my oh my mother tongue my grandmother I know her she doesn't even speak Arabic she doesn't how can I ask you know her to speak Arabic or where she doesn't so this is the the issue we have to accept it whether you like it or not we have to accept it

31:53 whether you like it or not there in Syria we have the Kurdish people you have to accept this fact reality if we want always to close our eyes on the reality doesn't mean that it is not exist it is there so if you want to solve it put your hand there point at it solve it and we will be happy to live together so you're not looking for Kurdish separate states no we in our region our project it is not separate it is not dividing Syria and we need to live as a Kurdish people inside Syrian territories but in a very democratic system which I have my rights as occurred my language my political rights my culture you know this is very important you know this year in 21st of March every year the Kurdish people they have their National

32:55 like naurus I think if you know about it now rules it is the the new year for the Kurdish people and the person and all these people we celebrated every year you know so before it was so difficult to celebrate it in the region now in our region people they are celebrating in our rules they see the Christian Assyrian they are celebrating their own also Nationals days it is very important so we have the the cultures and the diversity which give us a very beautiful in the region which is under the control of the turkey in Africa in my city after the earthquake there are families of Kurdish people in the in the city of genderis if you hear about it which is very influenced by the the earthquake they lost their houses they built a tent in the tent they make like a fire you know it is a symbol of the long rules

33:57 they lit a small fire the military groups very islamists extremist groups they come to them this family and killed four of them four of them have been killed because they are celebrating down roads they are not celebrating just they are letting the fire so imagine this is what's going on in the other in the under the control of turkey how could you accept it if you don't accept to lead a small fire as a I mean I am celebrating how do you accept me as a nation have you accept me to speak in my so with for that we said four people from one family all Brothers being killed it is a genocide well as at the same time same time I was invited to the White House to celebrate it the naurus with the President Biden in the White House so this is the difference

34:59 so what do you need to see such democracy means to defend my right as I defend you right we don't want to see more General side no never again finished it is done the the the century that we have to kill each other like tribal you know thousand years ago finished it's done now so never again for killing the people never again to have just one only one party political party one religion one language that's done we have to accept each other Syria is a diverse all the region in the Middle East it is diverse we have many nations we have Arabs in Syria we use I I remember there you know many years ago we used to have in Aleppo city which I I mean was was there I I know that I have you know Kurdish Armenian they were there they came they

36:03 were survivors from the usual side of turkey that time Armenian and Syria and even Jewish we have Jewish Aleppo City so they were a part of these people of this nation of this Earth Earth this land why do you deny them so all the the reason it has been diverse like Jewish Arab kurd the Syria Christians all together we should accept each other as long as you are denied me the war will go will continue and so it is up to us either to fight each other to the end of the our life or to live together coexistent to live together in peace for us for our children and for the Next Generation coming this is what we need actually this is our choice but the other choice will be different that is up to them that time we have to resist together this is what can I see

37:07 we had only a short time for the conversation I wanted in closing before thanking you just to to make one additional Point looking at the map as which you can all see there to your rights you can see also there's a strategic element to all this the Syrian Democratic Council simply by being located where it is located is playing in fact a vital role which is that it is blocking the advance of hostile forces to whom we don't even need to mention the name getting from east to west it's not a solid wall because right in the South you have the elbow Kamal border crossing controlled by the regime and the priority militias but nevertheless it is a very significant barrier and it is for that reason that both Israel and Jordan among other reasons are so Keen that the Syrian Democratic Council and the authority should continue to survive and to flourish so for that reason as well as for all the other reasons that you have outlined so well sinum we saw certainly wish for continued success for

38:10 that on until we apparently have another 10 minutes so whilst I'm delivering my ringing closing remarks no no you're stuck with us for another 10 minutes perhaps we could then take some some questions uh yeah I'm not sure if we have the system for that for flashcards or so or if somebody wishes somebody to put their hands up and perhaps I can bring them in so you uh yeah but can we take someone from from the audience also perhaps yeah so at the front go ahead uh part of the country and are you not being a recognized country in the international stage are you able to yeah thank you yes and the Northeast Syria it's actually the the region which agricultural region I can see the basket food of all over Syria comes from this

39:13 region Northeast Syria as well as the gas and oil yes but most of the oil fields in the Northeast Syria has been destroyed by ISIS when they control it we got now many of the oil fields we started to restore it and rebuild it and get use of it otherwise how can the autonomous administration pay their salaries for all the people there we use it for local news we don't export but local use that means some Traders I will be just very open some Traders they come and take the the room and oil and take it some of them they take it to the regime control area Syrian government there they will be they have the uh the refinery and they do it and some of them they take it to the control area by the Syrian the green area under the corner of turkey they will take it also

40:16 so we see that this oil it's not for the only the people of the Northeast Syria it is for the all Syrian people this is what we believe but now as we as you say it is a very good card for us to negotiate with the Syrian government about that and this is what we need to do actually so but still we have I mean for exporting and for manufacturing all the oil fields it's very difficult because you know there is a sanction the U.S sanction on the Syria and the oil our region has been accepted from the sanction unless oil oil is not accepted so we are not able to export it or to do it only to use it for the local use for the other people to manage it yeah okay Ron yeah right yesterday yeah you have have the mic go ahead thank you so my I have two questions my first is we've heard that

41:19 Isis was destroyed eliminated a few years ago and now it's back so was it actually destroyed in your opinion and and if it was destroyed how did it reconstitute itself that's my my first question I'll just let you ask that answer that so how do the Isis reconstitute itself you mean after being destroyed as it was in 2019. yeah it is very important question really um you know what we destroyed as I mentioned we defeat Isis military and geographically that's right but I mentioned the ideology of Isis which is the most dangerous no it is still there among some people yes but Isis is starting to realize that they should reorganize themselves again they are getting use of the economic crisis which we have in our region in all over Syria

42:22 so this economic crisis which make many of the young people lost their you know work and you know job and so on they don't have anything to live on so the Isis sleeper cells they start to they start to recruit young people in order to you know just these people maybe they they don't even believe in it but they want to work to get some money to live on so they start to recruit the young people and so that the Isis now again reorganizing themselves this is one the other one reason some Isis coming from the Iraqi border which is another issue we face so this is very important also for us to have to control it Iraqi board that is a long border the other one some of them they come from the turkey border so they are sending to us you know to to

43:27 us turkey in order to weaken the autonomous Administration there so that they they say oh it is a Kurdish Administration so they have to destroy it which is not true of course so in this way Isis is starting to reorganize themselves even there is a recent happen Isis woman in not inside the Lord Camp outside in the in the place which is the resort and all these places started to recruit some again I mean according to their ideology so the women they know that the woman she can recruit her children also so in this way they are starting many I mean things they are doing today to reorganize themselves again we have time I think for one last question so yeah we have the mark please you haven't mentioned the Russians what now is the role of the Russians yes Russians are there exists in Syria many years ago and still they have in in

44:30 our region also we have Russia imagine this small area which is the yellow area we have Russian forces Syrian forces government American forces and even maybe some Iranian militias and our but who is administrating all the region we are administrating none of them Russia is there in 2019 if you remember when President Trump tried I mean wanted to withdraw from the region and that time turkey come and occupied this in between the the two the the yellow I mean Russia so he occupied this area which is in the middle of the yellow area in 2019.

45:21 that time we we asked the the American please do something not to allow turkey to control all the region we couldn't hear I mean that time unfortunately so the the Russian came to us and say okay I can come to the region because they were threatening to to occupy kubani that time so we say okay come and stay here so that the the turkey will not allow I mean will not allow turkey to come in so for that the Russian they are there that time to prevent turkey to have the any I mean occupation so there is an agreement turkey Russian agreement and U.S Russia turkey agreement both of them they say we can make ceasefire so that turkey will not allow to occupy more region Still Still Russia are there still are there their forces but we are the one that controlling everything we have a strategic till now a good relationship

46:24 with the American News U.S there there not only troops even the U.S official like diplomatic diplomacy people they are in the region and what we need even if the U.S the withdraw front region we hope that we still continue have a strategy relationship with the United States this is what we like and we hope that we can do it and that's probably a good note on which to conclude so once again thank you very much thank you for taking the time thank you so much